Economical Comparison among Rechargeable Batteries for Integrating Renewable Energy into Electrical Grids.
- 4. 4745678
!#$%''%(()'*$)+,'()$%-./.0!1#*')'%'%
-/20!1$)+3$%+,'()$%/4$5$6#%$%7'%$18889:#
$)-;/80 '$%'7($'##$=8;=?#':)@$61A*
7($%BC)'*+A%7(!/?#'3''$'('%($$))*'D('
E%%$A#$'/?#'9F'7',4$5$6#%$$7%'$%'#'%(()*,
')'*3''$',7''$)'''3*(;0*=8;G1.0*=8=H1$;;0
*=8I8J'K$%L'F')(7'3$77'-JKL!4$5$6#%$1=8;H/
?$)*'$)*')'*3''$%'D(''''$%'(;.818889:#*
=8I8M#'','1;G1.889:#%'D('''%(()'*''$)'''3*=8I8/
?#''%$(%%)*%$))%'F'$)%'F'$)5'%,9:+)$%%,$7%/N
=+9:%)$()$%#$%%$'=8;I/OPQPRSTUPVXTYVZY[USZY]^_`%
33'%$7('%$#$%#'%')$3'%'%'F'%,$7$)3
N%$)$M#'3F'7',4$5$6#%$$7%#$;/.9: ('3''$))
7',7)'$('()$*=8I8/
@#'$(()$,''$)'''3*''%#'''3*%$3'%*%'7%B''$)'
''3*%'%$''7'%'%$$$%'#',)$,')'*
%(()*#''3')*'3$'')'3%#%3''3*%$3'
%*%'7%%#$%'#$3'$)'$''%M#'''$)'''3*%'%#$F''
,'''a%'''('3#',)$3')'*'7$a%(()*
$)$'/b,%'#''$'7$*#'''3*%$3'7'$%'%'%'#$3'$)'
')'#'7$)$''%1%#$%#*')'$$+7('%%M#'F'1
'#$3'$)'$''%$'%$))'$7',)'D)'7$'#$#*')'
,$)'%$+7('%%%/
AF'$)'#$3'$)'$''%#$F',,''%$%,$*%+(',7$'
$$a('$)%$,'*%%'%%,$$%,))%/
-;!?#'%('=.*'$%,)#7+$''%-def%!1)'$+$$''%-dNf%!1
$ F$$7 'D+,) $''% -gE@f%!$'1'/3/1;1I8a6:#h=.+*'$
-JiLG88a6:#1'F'*/=*'$%!1'/3/1JiL2I;+Ijklmhno+*'$-JiL;=8a6:#1
'F'*I/=+H/;*'$%!1$'/3/1pqrstnojklmhno+*'$-JiL;1888a6:#1u'F'*=2
*'$%v$w/1@x/1y#$3x/1w':/1=8;8!1'%('F')*-NCKLez!/
-=!?#'%'$''%#$F'%'$)'%$,'*%%'%1'/3/1def%%',)$77$)'
')')*'%)%1dNf%%'D)'$$$33'%%F'%),$1$gE@f%
%')'#$))*DF$$7$$33'%%F'%),$/?#'','1#''F')(7'
,%$,'-+,)$77$)'$+D!$''%$$)),'*)'%%$)/
N{'%'#$3'$)'$''%#$%'+,)$77$)'$'+$%'')')*'
%)%%'$,,)$77$)'3$')')*'%)%$'(','$)'
7F'$#3$,'%'$''%#$%'#''D'%%''3*('*
('()$%-'%('$))*'7'(',7%)$$,$7%!%#)'
- 6. 4745678
!#$%%'()*)!+,-./0!112
'*3!4#56785',-.0!%9'*!):
1!;)'')';2;=?@A;BCD(E FGHI!+*!)'J
?@KLBD(E ;1!CG!/ +#MMN,@OP/;'!,-.0!!
)!2')!2!2;2;QOQ#RN44+S(.1O%!;T3/
+3UDD('V3D2)D22'))D9*)/1)0) 2!';
?@G;HBBD(E FGHI!+?@K;BBBD(E ;1!KB!/
7');*3I9'$%%0!13!2!)
'')'O33!;** * *3!*2!
'*3!1))W*!'!%'!*%!!!'
2!%3
XY[]^_`_abcdef_ghidifjdkdfaghjd^`adlelc_fkdlemndnio_aad`bdi
XYpqgr_iibiadlstuwxyyz{||}~u€‚‚ƒ„…
†'+†/21)'!*!)'!*21)I'))
3)$%%)'!))%)22%3%1)20!:
!!;*$%%0!321)'!*!)')%2
*23!*!+I!'!20)/0!+†D-‡G 0!/)()
*23!*!0!+†D-‡G0!/8%!!*!;W'9'
'3ˆ3!0)*%W'!!'!20)0!W'!*!
+*%)I0!'2!I)('!)/%!2'!22'3!3!!
!%)2!)!I'!'%)%!:!!;%W'!!'!20)
0! 0'%)‰-(-;#33@;-!N@;GBAB:
-W(S;4??;8%(%%(ˆ;#0ˆ;GBAG:S7;8%(*S;?((
ˆ;‡2Š.;GBAK‹
,‡‡.31)'!*!)'!*31 )I'))
3)$%%)'!))%)22%3%1)20!
8%!!*!;*!)'!)2''))9'
N1%2 †D,‡‡. 0!'!2)'3!!*'
+?@KBBD(E /;!)W†D,‡‡.0!!*'%)0'%
!)!%)2!*W'!!*‰T!T;GBBB:Q2-
,!@‡;GBBK:O(%!R;-%!(*.;,!?;8%!%(,;
O%.;GBBH:Š%Š8;ˆ%TM;E%.-;4Š;?@Œ;†P5;GBBL:
Š%Š8;ˆ%TM;E%.-;Š2Š†;?@Œ;†P5;GBBL:--;
ˆ%TM;Š%Š8;E2P4;4S8;-8;†2†Š;GBBC:4?I.;
S*S;ŠRIE;GBAK‹
.1!;')2;)I†D,‡‡.0!;!')0
- 8. 4745678
!!#!$%$#'('$))$*+,$!-.'/*,012$,34*
5346)(7)(#8349)(:534;(:!34:=:!;34?@A!:3B34
;#C-)!534D))$+9349)(:5342$,34;$)-)%%!A34D))+E3F34*534
:=:!;34?GHI(!)(:#)!$)$)($:7(%C%C4#
#7(:%%!(:##$!J(!(()!!)(:!$CK::!(
!$+#3A#$%!?L!$)$+J(K:M*(NNO !( $P
/;QRRM-F#S?LJ!.C!()$T(!)$!$U/;GRM-F#4V7!?R
!03W!#!C$!4#(!$:$:$X(C!()3Y%!$)C(#
!(:#%!($+#:#!(:$:#(:$!+(:4#(!)($:C$:C
)!((3
[[]^_`b^c^bdefghijklmjnnopq
Br2A.8(0:B;5Y.8(0!$CC!())%%)(:.J0Y'ss*(NNO.T0
:!$!7(3;(:t(:( %!$)C(C!()$!!#!)!(4
(7!$:.Y'0#:$!:)!:(7$t(:3Y(7!$:.Y'0
())$!)!()$))!%($!.Br'0#:%%) #(#!
!!:(: #$!(C#:!(4::$! )$:!)(#:!(I(:
:!:$!M%%)($:)#!$# $!%($:M$!%($:$($:(:
)!$)$)($:$:$Y'!@(:$!!-(:(#!#(#!
!!:%%)(: #$!(C4:)#C()!($:$C!():#!
)$:!)(#:!(3Y%!$)C(##:!:($C)$+!#:
#$$!(.$MQ$!(+(#t(::$0(:#(%$:!
$!7(Y'$!#:(7)!$3
Yu/2N*B*B8D,./;Y0#!:)!%%)(:#%!$$%$.J0Y'ss
*5:N?.T0:!$!7(#+(!!%$!uu3A34;#(,34A(:;34
'#:,3O34F,3634:O$)t831?vH3O$+7!4*5:N?$!)%(
.JLCY#M0#:*(NNO.?v?CY#M03B7:#$#*5:N?+X%$
CJ%!$ #%!$#:*(NNO4#!()($*5:N?(())
%!$)C(I%!$)4*5:N?+(# $%:#=(QT(!w(!$#
C)(J7):$C::#:#($)($:$C::($:(:$
)!$)$)($:(#!)!!$C::$X((:$()(t
$%:3A#$%(::!)(:#$(:!3
A# $%!?L ! $# #)%($!J#)! ( $
/;LGRM-F#S?LJ!./;QM-F#47!Q3R!03
[xyzlo{q{ko{|}n{|~jpz}|€
A)2CC!(t)()$$C%!($: C$:7!($%$$:7:($:)
!( :!:)7)$%$:3Y#$+:(:A)24!:)7)$%
- 10. 4745678
!#$%'()*+,,-.)'!#/$!#.
01'$)*+,,-21'$)*+3),45$#6/)1#.#
$!) $)1)$)#0#!7$)2#''21)'7
'$6#$%2)')8#7#!.''59
:;=@ABCDEFE=EGHIEGJK;LCHGMN;HHOJCMPQRSEFE=HKLF;LTA
U../ V.#$
WXYZ[]^_`a.5
b)#$
0cde*8f!5
V
0.5
g#77#.2
$6.9
V!7$) 2hi j h94 g#77#
V'' kilih 4 i94m9 n$6
o)'7
'$6#$%
pl4r 2 s4k9 n$6
+8#7#
!.''
2 ijm h94 d#'!t
g#$%'
()*+,,-
uikk umk s4k9
-#/$v
!#.
rmk i i9k
QAwx=FyI;LIz{|OGOH};IILF~=GKJMI€LGEI
‚)%ƒ$.'1#$/7)/$„!)7/#7)'!b)$
U VV… 0b$U50†‡8!)59…$7/' %! ! #7)$)'
#$%'()*+,,-2!ˆ‰Š‹Œ#$%()*+,,-.'$
)$)'!7/#7)$)$$)#$#.$#$)#$).7!
'$!#$%'()*+,,-9
n!8.!)$#$t$!//$)t)()%!8t$%!05!
7$/!$#$t.$)$#$())$'.#1$/#'/$$)!)ƒ)'
045()%!8t$%!//$$'$)$!()2)'0i5!7$/!$#$t.$)$#
$+,,-$+0,-54 0''$7 $+,,-5 .#1$/#
'/$$)!)ƒ9‚tt'.8#92!$##$%)tt.Ž05
#)t#$)t)t#$) $)'1.!$t!!))$$‡)#$'2
057/#$)$#')$'))$7#.!$t!$
!#$'2)'05$7)t/##. $))'1$'1$#7#7)
%!)!)$$!/$$‡) )$'!6/''$#$)*'/$$) )
//()')'$7$)89g92…!1)…9+92+#$)‘9d92’$#$)e9
’92V$)t9f924m“89g92+#$)‘9d92f)'$39e92…!1)…9+92
V$)t9f92’$#$)e9’924m”9
n!7$!)%.#$%7#$0cdei*8f!%!$)
- 12. 4745678
!#$$%'()(*#+,-./0123!#$$$%45'6)
5 78'*9 5' : 3)9 3 ;*
,-.===0123*8*#*'3'55+!#$?5*'@*'3
,-.AA=AA01233*78'*93'3*;'*'()*(
B'0C*DDE#6%!3(5#**63)*B'0C*DDE#63'
#''*;(*'38F3F5(%E)9;'*'(*
')6*;8;'(3'@*53+3;83@6'B''(
65*'@8*(8**'3'*G5'(+B')3*1@)3588
+86;*'@'3B''(678(*;893(5#**6
3#6%!3*#658H9')3'3*18+%@%=;;*
5(3#6'3*@395;*'@6('*63'3)*(
B'0C*DDE#6%!3)*B'0C*DDE*;*#(5*'@38*(
)3'3*'5'3*')*'(+)*''(**65886*'(
*5365*'%
IJLMNOPQRSMN
$'3*88';*;8*'3#''(5(;'@''7*
'';;#3@##**'@*'@')#'@6*'*
@*(%!)68'6(98(''7*G55#*)*'(5(
'( '6T(% U) *( B'0C*DDE #6 * 9*#
VWXYZ[[]^_`ab6+;*c(*#d,-./e012396
6%E8*3#653f40C*DDE'(f40Cg'D
hihjkhlkmhoWXYbp[]^_`ab6+,-.=012396=%e6%!3')6
(98('@6@(9*78'*95*'@'@6
@ 3' '9'*' #*H *3*5;*' #* +q$r
,-.s=]^_`ab6+,-.t012396s%6:(*(#*+qfr
,-.e=u=s]^_`ab6+,-.012396=%/%6:9'(*5; (7
)#*+?vUrw,-.uA]^_`ab6+,-.0123x96e6:
'('*1;36(*(+C*gE#*,-.A/e0123`A6+,-.=0123
96=%e6%
f')6(G55#6(98;')*B'0C*DDE#6*
78( 53';*5*'%@%3*'**
,-.AA=AA0123%$*6(8'('353163'@*
588*'@B')3*1@)3*%%3;83@6'B''(6
9*58*(8**'3'*G5'(B')3*1@)3588+86;
*'@'3B''(6#65*'@*;*(86;*T*'%
- 14. 4745678
!#$%$!'(#!)*!%*+!%%!$%$!,-+./0)%
2#%!%$!-+./0)%'*+#!%$!34#+#4*4(5
#+6)#+78,
9 !#$%$!'(#!)%*+!%%!$%$!,-+./0)%
:;?@@ABCDEFFADCE@GHE@;ID;@JEBK;KA@LHMNOPOQRQ
STUV WXYT[U]^_T
`abcd a^_T a^_T^UUeUeSTUVfXYT
`abcd
WUgghXi`_^^UY[jfUklmnlmnofVkpqord pqomshXi sqmm pqom
tUV_^jg pqmmsTUV_^jg oqmm uqmm
vwxYXg]T_X^`yzd mq{{sr oqsu sq|m
}^w[X~eU`pm€rd sq{ps mqmu mqso
‚UgjT_^jU^T`[XgƒjfƒgjV_eUd`um€rd oqp„s mqsp mqps
W]U^TfXggUfTX mqmmsfXggUfTX |oqmm mqmm
bU[jjTX`WUgjepyms…mqoy†‡V†Tˆ_fd mq|usYˆUUT suoqmm syyqyo
}^YX]fU`}^bwl‰xowd mqlls oqls sqmu
}^Y]ŠjfUTUjTVU^TjU^T lyqyms mqms mqou
‹_YX]fU`‹_bwld lq„ys „q{m p„qml
tXTjg omyqlm
`abc€Œˆd smoq„
gjhX]^_TfXYT`abc€ˆd ˆX]Y^UUeUe gjhXfXYT`abcd
z_i_^UgUfTXgƒTU {qmm mqym lqmm
bUTT_^`luY]hYTjTUYd {qmm mqym lqmm
^XeUUgUfTXeU[XY_TX^ {qmm mqym lqmm
^XeU_^YUŽeƒ_^`sd {qmm mqym lqmm
^XeUY]ŠjfUTUjTVU^T {qmm mqym lqmm
^XeU_^YUŽeƒ_^`od {qmm mqym lqmm
WjTˆXeUYUTT_^`luY]hYTjTUYd {qmm mqym lqmm
WjTˆXeUUgUfTXeU[XY_T_X^ {qmm mqym lqmm
WjTˆXeU_^YUŽeƒ_^ {qmm mqym lqmm
WjTˆXeUj^^Ujg_^ {qmm sqmm {qmm
WUggjYYUVhgƒ {qmm mqym lqmm
tXTjg uqmm l{qmm
abc€Œˆ olqmm
STUV WXYT[U]^_T
`abcd a^_T a^_T^UUeUeSTUVfXYT
`abcd
WUgghXi`_^^UY[jfUklmnlmnofVkpqord pqomshXi sqmm pqom
tUV_^jg pqmmsTUV_^jg oqmm uqmm
vwxYXg]T_X^`yzd mq{{sr oqsu sq|m
}^w[X~eU`pm€rd sq{ps mqmu mqso
‚UgjT_^jU^T`[XgƒjfƒgjV_eUd`um€rd oqp„s mqsp mqps
W]U^TfXggUfTX`t‚†x†mumd spmqmmsfXggUfTX |oqmmss|umqmm
bU[jjTX`WUgjepyms…mqoy†‡V†Tˆ_fd mq|usYˆUUT suoqmm syyqyo
}^YX]fU`}^bwl‰xowd mqlls oqls sqmu
}^Y]ŠjfUTUjTVU^TjU^T lyqyms mqms mqou
‹_YX]fU`‹_bwld lq„ys „q{m p„qml
tXTjg sosuyqlm
`abc€Œˆd um{oq„
- 18. 4745678
!#$%' ()*$+ #,-./*0 1#$.#.$+ 2 3)#$.*'
$$-/0445556#.6784.%+4-)%.#$.*/4$2529#$%4*4::;:
*6$,
*.$ =$.*/8-,*$37,,?=3@.* AB/$*':C/
D**.8/+E-$'D-.':F6
G.H6'!)C6'I*7C6'H6'/.7*9H+%.1*7+J$7(*$J+/$,9
.* !,/K/ *!5K$$+* 1#$.#)%2L+(-#.$'
MNOPQSTUVTPQWXVTWYTPPQYTWZNT[PQPTP]^MMVVZ_`abcb^dYSeMSY[Y'
.06f4D3311(6:6FFgh:'(.*'i#:g2;':6
i.*/.i6'D--6'*i$.*166':6'VjPkQNlPmYSjSTUnNjYUenkSkP
oPkkPQd';?h@'Dhh2Dg6
i.+B.A6'LJ6J6'!))$/)6'* D%6'::6D*.#K8.9
3** 3)/I.*#1#$/.*D.*1#$+$'VjPkQNlPmYdkQX'
g?@'h:2h:h6
AE6'!),.A6'J6'* p7$C6H6':;6D3+/.#i#*./,9
J)--//.* 9I.*# *.$/()/ %+ H.7 199.#.*#+ 9$
1#$-/.$.*5.$.*(*9.*=*-/'VZnVjPkQNlPmYdkQXoPkkPQd'
:?:@'f26
G.*G6':6J=.qI*#/'rNsQTSjN[MNOPQnNsQPd'gg'::2:6
t*7i6*=$56p6':;68-,*$98*##7%=.4iH
*=.4I*%$$./'uTkPQTSkYNTSjrNsQTSjN[vXUQNWPTVTPQWX':g'w;;2w;w6
x5)(6'i),.H6'=J6'!))5=6'* x*)H6':6'rNsQTSjN[
MNOPQnNsQPd':':f2:fF6
C)*C6!6')G636')H6i6'L.C6'J.6y6'* Iz6K6':w6
(72./#7##$./$.#/9*.#4B.*#%$$+5.$-+,+7
#$+$'rNsQTSjN[MNOPQnNsQPd'f';h2;w6
C)*C6!6')G636')H6i6'C*7C6I6'J.6y6'* Iz6K6':w6
1#$#,.#-9,*#* ,-7+8)$.*9**/.BI*p/
*,$.9=.qI*%$$./'VjPkQNlYmYS^kS'';w;:2;w;w6
ii6')G636'C)*C6!6'*7z6L6'L.A6!6'i!6'* I*7I6C6':g6
1#$#,.#-9,*#9I*p**-$//*,$./9=.4I*
/#*+%$$./'rNsQTSjN[MNOPQnNsQPd'hf';f2F6
LJ62H6'A., A6'* C.(626':;63+?#+,.2#2#+.##.@t
1#$+$/9=.2I*J#*+K$$./'{sjjPkYTN[|NQPSTZlPmYSj
nNYPkX';F?;@'hh2hg6
x$C6'=+#i6'3.8.#E6'A.*i6'J$.*7$6'* K*}J6':6I.*#
,-7+.*B.*#q*.#95//./$%$$./*.,-#$*-9,*#'
rNsQTSjN[MNOPQnNsQPd'fw':;F2:;F6
- 20. 4745678
!#$%'()*''+,*--'.(/0+1#2+''*33)*''*,*
4562(*78*9#:; '+3%0*70=0.+?*
2++%.2.7@=2*'?'+,@*==.=07A.2B.2'@$7+C.7*'*'.D*00
EFGHIJKFMNFOPHQFGHRPS:;;T@UV
WW#$.1.*#X$1Y51Z*7Y+'A[:T,2$*3
*=%%0.2*]+==32*3*2.0+^20.*072*D+BB6*(_:EFGHIJKFM
NFOPHQFGHRPST;`:a:::b::U
Z*4cX$.X66'=+!#[+'.=+ [d+45:;5..
A.2.0$7.%=.+=@,.0=D*003?+%*2@@@77.0@?
22'.eIPHfgheIijHFIkPIlJKQRjPIRPmm@:;
Z*4c6'=+!#5*007+?( X$.X6d+45[+'.=+[
:; [0*..0$nc*%,++?o.2#3++7=3+3
.=2$*.ob.X''=pqQprrKjPstJlPHjJKSuIlPHMJRPS`::a
T;m@T;m
vwwxyz{|
X+=03:U*=
@d/8^~€‚ƒ„…†‡ˆ‰@*`Š#B5$V:*=a
Š#B5$*==%.d.cZ_;@D*=7d/8=`+2*?.7=.%.'*d/8=?++??@.7
=+'*3+,==0% *0$003^BB,,,*'.D*D*2+%B02a$22''.?+?d.cZ_;
2*0$+7.=*D+0n22'=2+=3+7.0+V:*=*==%.nU22'=3
*
`$003^BB,,,'.?3+;@.?+2+%B=%.0$@@?.7=@*?0@@*=@n@22'=@'.?3+;@D*00
.=@0*.@V@320@2*3*2.0B
$003^BB?3+0.%D2$.*2B=''.@'*7=B70*.':VVn:Vn:‹@n@X2'=@$@
d.?Z_;@X''@c+@8*23@Z+,@#33'@#+'*@!$0%'
$003^BB'*D2+AB3+720B'*D@n@'.?3+;@D*00BaŒ0$22''.?+?*3$.0+
$*72*D+*+7.=*0%+=022'=2+=3+7.0+:m*=Œ=+%,
*+7%*0.*'==2$*=*+@=.'.2+B2*D+2+%3+=.0=2*D=7?+=*'
0$+=*722'=#$+022'@'.?d/8==2$*=*3'*2%0D*00?+0$::
X$‹+'0%*D**.'*D'*0*2$*32+=0Š#;;B5$Œ$+,=2$
.7+?d.8=d/8=,.0$*d.`6.(X+a_:@D*=72*0$+72*D=7+'?+
*0%+=0nn*=`:22'=a
@d8^Š#mn@TnVƒ„…†‡ˆ‰@*`Š#:B5$n:@;*=a
$22''.?+?d8.=*D+0U@U22'=*0*730$+?7.=2$*+?U`
$003^BB=*+9*+B:BVBnB'*7@*2.7@.=@0$@2$*3=0@D*00@2+7.0.+=@*33'B
$003^BB,,,%3+,2+%B'.?$0%a
@‹[c8^Ž‘’ˆ‰ƒ„…†‡ˆ‰@*`Š#B5$“:m*=a
- 22. 4745678
!#$%#'()')($$(*+,-+,,.,/
,1#23456789:;=.,!?@?#?$'()'A567/B;8C!:.!?'D
E()+#?#))-?#?$'()')-567/B;?%(!($$#-)-/8
(!($'()')%# ):.!?'F?'()'-)?!+#%,$(#(,C#($,*'
6)(!($,$#-1#23'8'*(?'?+?!-)'?$$$()#( ?%'8?!+
?C?#$?+$??(?()'G)FC8'*(;#%)-1#23'(?+*'%)$!-)H
!?' IJIKLMNN @O?F?'?;# 3?C! J%*'!8 P??D #' ?C?#$?+$ ?
567.8;=.,!? @567/8;8 C! / !?'D
@FFF;#()Q$#'#?($$#%R$D1)?$)F ?'',$)?%# )-
?(#C?#?$'8$)!# ,%#'#)?$(*()$$()((?#)C
(!($$#-+*?(()?!##(?'#()'