โดย นายสมยศ คำสิทธิ์ นักวิเคราะห์นโยบายและแผน

1. •d
~1UVl'cl~
'~ l.J'VI O~®b.Ci'/1 ~Q~ m1l'1.:iLa~lJrn-stlnF1·rn.:il'ia.:iriu
t'lJ'UtJFl'S'S1'11~111 L'!J(Jl~a(Jl fl'Vll.J. momoo
~ i;_,mf111 l!:lcrcr~
L~cN in.ijCllJLL'U1Yl"l.:Jn"l'i~vivi1.:iuJ'S:::mru-s1v~1vtl-s~'11ll.:iuh~inru vuit l!icrbo 'S1fJfl1'1L~tJ~~,,,'4tJvi'1u
L~'U'lVl-1'4Ja 1Vlfoai!.J'1'4'U~'UeJ~91J'lJ1L~nL~n '11fJ fl1'j L~J~Vl,,,'!1'U~1,,,~UG'li!'U'1'4Jtl1Vl1'SL'17lJ (tJ)J)
ft1"1 i'J~'UV~91JtJ1L~m~n LLfl:::11fJ n17L~J~VIVl'4tJ"',,,,i'uG'li!J'1'4J81"11'Sfl~111tJ ~1'Hi°tJ~'UVn91JtJ1
.. .II• "' ..., trl ..,
L'HJ'U ~11'i1"11fl1'1'1'1·rJV1 'flfl~l'H1Vl
... ... ... ... 1 . ..I ..I ., "'
m.:Jt1I Vlti1'1Bn'S:::'Vl'i'N11'11~ 'VIE.I m'UVlqvi Vl >J'Yl o~o~.l!:>/1 <to~!> t'l-11JVl m<t' fl'ifl!)1FllJ l!>ctct~
~'1~a'1lJ1~1tl LL'U1'Vl1.:JJ'S:::lJ1rufl1'S'S1EJ'S'ULL'1t~Vlvi1'1.JU')tlJ1ru'S1EJ~1tl"SB.:Jfu., ~1'U1'U (9) 'qVl
m11~n<J:::vtn.:i11vr1vi1Vl CJ 't~'llnimmu1V11.:i n1 -s~vivh.:iuJ"S:::111ru'S1v~1EJtl-s:::~1i1
'1uJ1:::mru YUL ~crbo ·ua_,CJ-:if-1mtlnF1"StNa1ul'ia.:iriu 1Vlt1"S1t1m"S L~uciVIV1'4uvi'11tJn1,,,ui;if(JlQJ'S:::a'1f1
~tN~mtlnA'Hl1~1J~e:i.:i~u1~i'ututJ.:iutJcs::::1J1ru w.Pl. l9ct<t'ci J1l'S1E.Jm'S ~.:i'S"llJCll'S1flfl1'SL~tJ~~·vn~tJ
'1'1,,,foai!ua'4Ul:JUV~VlltJ1L~m~fl Flru:::m-s11rn-sm1m:::11t1ei1mv1~LLfia.:if1mtlflf1w.:ia1ul'ia.:ifiu1~ih.1~
tum'Su<J:::iqu Fl~.:i~ l!:l~cr~ LdEJ1uvl a:: 11u1A1l !:Jeter~ L~u'llau1iXn1vruV1'S1vm'Svi''1mh1LllUL~tJ~VlV1'4tJ
vi'11ti~a .:i f'1mtJ nf1•rn .:i a1 tJ'ia .:i au~eH~V1vi1.LJaut:y rQ'~/LYlfl!Ut:y rQ'~.:i.J J 'S:::lJ1 W'11 EJ~1 t.JU'S~~1U
.1 .. .,~..,., .. ~
lJ v'I:::111ru w.fl!. ~crbo 'l1tlft:::LE>t.JVllil1'-l-1lJ~"1'ilYltl1'1Cl.:J JtJ
n-slJa.:i L'1~1.1m'ltJflf'rrn.:il'iti.:i ~tJ~'11"Sru1LLa1 Li1tJ11 LvJa1~m'l~~vi1.:iuth~mru'S1EJ~1EJ
t1·n:~1tJ.:iutJ-s:::1l1ru vu11. l!:>cr-oo '1JCJ.:JEJ'1FlmtlflA'Sv~a1tJl'ia.:inuLtl'U1t1~·rnm11lLivuiaEJ Qfllllu.:i LLa~ii
U"S~i;vi5m'Vi ~~'llvinimJLLt11vi1.:im'l~V1vi1.:iuJ':i~lJ1ru'l1t1~1EJ 'lh~'11i'.l.:iutJ'S~>.nru 'YUi. lm:tbo 'lEl~i'u
L~J~~vi~uvi'11ti '11Eln1')L~tJ~~Yi1tJ~1'1~u~i!.J"11'4'U~tJ6~llllU1L~nL~n '11e.in1'lL~JQ~Yi11mhwsuai!u~'4tJ
ti1m'lL'1~11 ('Ul.J) ri1wfo~ua~91J'J1L~m~fl LL'1~'S1EJnTH~tJQV1Yi'4tJri1vifoai!u'111JuT·n'lmn.:i1tJ ~hvifo
~tJ~~91JJ1L~flL~fl tviEJ'llti1~~.:ivi1~LL~~1~ti.:il"1mt!flf'l'lu.:iri1u'1a.:i ~uvti'.if!JtJ~~91JU1L~nL~flt'U~~nvi~ciLllu
tl- -...0. .cit .1 Ill.I _..,. 0 ti d ' ...
U.'J1Vl1'1 !)Ulil 'l1tl'1tLCJtJ;llil1lJLLJ1Yl1lJ'S~lJ1Wn1'S'l1tl'l.JLL'1~'1VlV11.:J'U 'S~lJ1W., Yl'1-l'-11Vl1fJ
~.:iLivumL~tl1tl'lV1~v1'lru1~1LiJum'Sllie:i1tl
. ' "" "{tJ1t1.Utii'in1 ..i '!lU~f'l~11)
~(l~c:iBJ~ iru11l'n 'tlrn'l wiu .
ClGll~fl'il-!'1ILft'l>Jn1'itlnA'StWr1CJ.:inu
na.:iri.:JL'1;>JLL'1~iYlltJ1fl1':i~Vlfl1.')Plfl4cl1~B.:JntJ
flcl>J11tJ'1.:JL'1~>Jfl1)~Vln1'lrin4cJ1tliil.11t1LL'1~fl!JSnilJ'U1L~nL~n•• ... I
LYl'l. o - ~~a:'.® .,. ~ol!:le>-r;n ~ti ctol!:>-Ci'.'.GJ'o
LV1'j'11'l o - l!:>l!Ja:'.m - ~ol!:>l!;,-m ~tl Ci'.'.mrj
•

2. l1ll'1vl 1
LL'U1'Yl1·nh::inam1n1ufou11::i"'ri1o111.1hz:ina.111u~hu1i1-1i'1.1L~'Ufl"""~"~1ll
L1'U~"""'4Jfl1llfoflU1Jfl'4J~JV~91JJ1L~nLan L1J~fl11'4Jfl1lli'UflU1Jfl'4Jtl1llTHfl;i.i (till) ri1'Mfo~t1V~91Jtl1LflnLan
LLfl::L1J~fl11'4Jfl1lli'UflU1Jfl'4Jt11111'jnfl1./11J fl1llfo~JV~91JJ1LflnLan
tl1::.i°1U./11Jh::i.i1tu 'l'UI. lr!cl'.bo
nt1./lfl./ILfl;iJLLfl::~RJtJ1m1;i'fln11f1n-~1~t1./li'iu n1i.id./1Lfl;i.ini1tlnfl1t1.:i~t1.:ii'iu
" V'9 ,J - ti " ..: o .,I ..I v .,I :I
UJ1JV11VllJollat1n'illt1./1Lfl'illn1'i nfl'itloll'Yltlolltltl "1t1V1fjfl 'YI i.JV1 oc:;:•b.cC/1 si~ovl fl./11JV1 111 t1./l111flll lr!~~c;<
- 'i1E.ln1'iLLfl::llilnLntu'1m1;i'flfl11L1J~fl11'4J,t11tl 'i1E.ln11L1J~fl11'4Jfl1llfoflu1Jfl'4J~JV~91Jtl1LflnLan L1J~"""'4Jfl1'Mi'uflU1Jfl'4J
t111111Lfl;i.i Cui.i> ri1'Mi'u~ua~RJt11Lflman LLfl::L1u~"""'4"ri1'Mfofluufl'4ut111111nf11.:i1u ri1""fo~uv~RJu1Lflman t1tj1::w·h.:ini1vhmru1
~1.:i 'l'l.rn. .:iuth::i.i1ru11v~1vt11::i1tl.:iuth::i.i1tu'l'l.f'I. lricrbo tfofu hit1.:ifln1tlnfl'it1./ld1t1~t1.:icit1 cvliif'luv~91JJ1Lflmantu~fo)fl)
"
Lfl;E.liJn1'j;i"'ri1.:iut11::i.i1ru11v~1vtl1::i1tl.:iut11::i.i1tu VI.fl. lricl'.bo 'jtJ./lfoL1J~fl11'4J,t1ti 'i1E.ln11L1J~fl11'4Jfl1lli'UflU1Jfl'4J~'UV~91Jtl1LflnLfln
L1J~fl11'4tlfl1llfoflU1Jfl'4Jt111111Lfl;i.i (Jll) fl1'Mi°1J~JV~91JJ1L~man LLfl::L1J~fl11'4Jfl1llfoflu1Jfl'4Jtl1111'infl1./11J fl1llfo~JV~91JJ1LflnLfln
tlflvflfltltlollfl1iJ'i1EJfl::LDE.lfl fi.:id
....Lflman
ilfon1'iL~v'IJfi1fl!lJUl'l'Jlll1l!iJ1lll'i!1'1J~1tiL~E.11rlJYOJn-111J~Wtltl~ vtll'l.
- mll-Uv l!i.<i>.m ;i'V1'1'i'iBlll'i1flJn:: <i>,ooo J1l'lllitJL~tlJ
n!J'Mi.i1v/1::Liivu/Vlu./lf!t1tl.:imv
iln"tttu::11t1.:i.:iut11::i.i1ru
llll1flL1tJLfivtJ
-..llll1flLollJLfltltl

3. 'MUl~ 2
OQ'1.UJ1V/1::LijVJ/'lllU~ih1fi'~011/
ti'n1:1cu::~imJ.h::imu
UJ1flfl1flilJLL'Vl'IJ
'Vl111flfl1flilJLL'Vl'IJ

4. 'llu1vl 3
.,j 11't>iJilL~'Uflfl'11'4'U~"ltJ n~"11111t1/1::Lut1u/ln!~ilmt~011/
" 11tl011
ii'n'l:lru::'!rn~~utJ1::111ru
o .m.m mru~utl~IJllu1L~nL~n~ti~fi'n'iJnmt1~a1u.,;t1~ciu~i;i~~Ltl~ - l-Hi~l'U'l1lJ"lflfl1tffltitl
'11~tifom'iri1EJLtlU111'iii'il'il1nn'ilJn1'i~9lJU1~11'UU, l'ltl'U. (L~n m 'U1tJ) tJ'i::LJ1Vl'i1El'hEJL~EJ1L~tl~tltJ
.. J .,j .. ua 1'11'itln'ilJn1'if'11i'IU1 ~ UtJtJ VI c;i '11'itl I!> 111lJ'l1U~ tln'i::Vl'i1~lJl11ll VIEJ n1'iJ~Wi·mim'ilfl1~m'ii'IUJi'l'4U
~ lJVI o~~m.cd1 l!i'*i il~i'u~ l!im lJn'i1fllJ l!ict:ct:Ci'. f'i11i'ii1EJn1'itJ~'l11'ii'lmu~m~11
- 16m'i 1fui;it1ulu01'iLUnin
1-1ana~L'IJ1uqJiiL~u~1n1iu1fl1'i
'llt>~l'lo1u~n1:111i.1u~Uiii;i111l1tl'~~t>
1 ' .,j .,j
n'i::Vl'i1~lJ'l11ll Viti 111UVl'1ll VI lJVI
o~~m.l!i/1 m~m~ il~i'u~ mo
ijfl'U1EJ'U l!ict:crl!i
o.m.l!i n'iruf!!utl~9lJu1L~nL~n~ti~Rn'itlnmti~li1u.,;ti~fiu l~e
1 'l~ u
- 'Hf!~ 'U'HlJ"lftfl1 'UfltltlUil::"li'lfl
fo01'iri1EJfau111'iii'il'il1nn'ilJn1'if'11i'IU1 ~Juuu~ m m11i.1tl'~ati (tl~Rn'itlnfl'it>~li1u.,;tl~auLJu
n'i::Vl'i1~lJ'l11111VIEJ ~ lJVI o~~m.cd1 l!ilrib il~i'u~ l!im lJn'i1fllJ l!ict'.ct'.Ci'.
I e - ... z .. U II
'11J'lEJm LUUn1'i'illl'!ltll1'itl'illl'il1~
111lJ'i::LUt1tJ~i'l~'llt>~t>~fln'iJnflw~
li1u.,;t1~fiuli.1nuf'11i'lui'101u)
b.l!i n'iruri1'11tJll'i1EJn1'iLUUflJlOJorlLfl~tl~L<iU~9lJU1n1'iL~n l ~el , u '
- 'HPH 'U'l111"lflfl1fl"{11N'1
l1~t>~tin1'iL~EJun1'ii'lt>u~iji'ni;ru::LJuflJi'ru'1 m11l1tl'~atim::m1~
11'111lllVIEJ ~ lJVI o~~m.l!i/1 ~om il~i'u~ mm ijU1fllJ l!ict'.ct'.m
frl. 'Vj'Un1'iAn'1:11ih"Hi'Jfli~~LLilL~n ~JOi11~ - 11tl'ii1tl'11111Jti~n~'U
- '1lll'l'i'if'i11i'i'ilJLUEJlJn1'i~n1:11 ~111~ m Bll'i1fltJil:: mo,ooo tJ1VI
~~Lllul tJm11uuVin'IJtillnil~m 111-i111ijt1V11~i'lf1n1'i'i::l111~
n'ilJli~Li'l~lJn1'itJnfl'itl~.,;t>~fiuntJlJl111VIEJ1am11U~~ll
- ~lli'l'i'if'i11i'i'i11LilEJ1101'i~n1:11 i.1an~ll'i~n1:11f'11i'lll'iururtii;i
~. fl1PltltJLLVl'UyjLfl'l:l'i1ti Lfiti'Ul-H'LLOL~1'11U1~~tJfi~~1'U'Utl~ '1111"lf1Ll'UL;jtl'U
ti~fimtJnfl'iti~ri"l'U~t>~ciul u~u~'1~'111fl'll1vLLfl'U111fllfi ('1~'111"t1::i11
Ufl'11U 'U11G"l1i1 LLil::fl~'Ui11l'U IC ti°1LJ1tl lfi'LLri tl.'il::'U:: tl.LVJyj1
ti.u1V11 ui1::m:u16tit1) (Lovn::f'1utl~9llu1L~m~n~t1~fi'munfl'it>~li1u.,;t1~ciu.mru~i;i~~Ltl~ '11~tii'tJm'iri1EJLtlUJ11'iii'il'il10n'ilJn1'i~9lJU1~lJ'UtJ,
d 4 ~ ..
i'IU'U. (Llln m 'U1tJ) l1'itln'ilJn1'if'11i'IU1 ~tlUtJtJ VI (j) mt> I!>
(mrihJuwtl'n~1u~1~'Ut>~ tiJVJ.) m11i.1tl'~atim::V1'i1~11mi;i1VJEJ
~ lJVI o~~m.cd1 l!ilrib il~i'u~ l!:ic;i lJn'i1fllJ l!ict'.ct'.Ci'.
- ~Vli'l'i'iBll'i1flUil:: l!i,ct'.oo tJ1Vl~tlL~tlU
lo L~U'!fl'll'4Uft1'11i''l.Jf1U'l.Jf1'4Utl1'1111Lf1~11 (Ull) "' " "' d d lll ~.,, d d ..I i.J- 'ilVli'l'i'i 1'11'itJLVlnLilntl1~ l!J-cr Uf!!UEJW9lJU1LVlnLilnVI tl VI. ii'n'l:lru::~utJ1::111ru
a ... ,... • "1'111tJ~Utlyj'1J'U1LflnLiln ,)i;i~~Ltl~ LLil::i'uri1EJLtlU ,j1tJ1tJ l!:>bo i'u - ~~LU~tJ~1LtiU~1U l1111Vlf'i1lltl'l.JLLVlJ
- W'!Jti11i1,j1J1UL~n ru 1u~ mo ijou1EJu l!icrcr~. . 1il'lt>EJ Uil::li'IV) 'i1EJn1'if'i1li'IV)
- 1i.1w'il1'iru1~~~tJJ'i::111ru'it1~folmi'm1flui1:: lrl.mlrl u1V1~t11u tJ'i::L11Vlf'i1tl1'111'iLi'l~lJ (UlJ)
- tlUVI. LUU'l1U1EJ'1Vl~tl~Vl~1~
Wurif!!uV~JllU1L~nL~nm11111'iii'il
ri1EJ1t1u~tJJ'i::111ru
- Bll'i1'1lll'l'i'iflUil:: lri.mlrl tJ1VI
bJ1'li'i1fl1ni11~l u m'i'1vitt1'1vi~1~
tl1'111'iLi'l~lJ (tJlJ) LUULVlEJ~'i1fl1
'1vil'l'i'im11l1anLnru'1m11M1
fl1111llnil~nua1tl'n~utl'i::111ru

5. 'MU1~ 4
.I oVtl1Ji1Ll'IJ'lfl11fU~1tl n!J'>11l1v/'muvu1M'1'~i'lvtl~0111
VI 11Vn11
am;ru::'!JtJ~~Jtl1::1J1CU
Ill Ll'IJi!fl'llltj'IJri1'111i'Jfltl'Jf!j'IJtl1111 .... "' .... " G Ul ,ft.I G d ..I tJ- 'il~an 1muL~mcinv1q l!i-.t: u~'IJEJ1~'1J1L~milnVI v VI.
ni11~1u ri1'>1i'uf!!uv~vuu1L~m~n ~~~~L"il~Lrn::fori1EJLv'IJ ,j1'1J1'1J l!i<i'.<f l'IJ
- 1'tfilvi,ici,j1u1uL~n ru i'u~ <ilo ijQ'IJ1EJ'IJ l!i<t:<t:~
- 1"1~'il1'iru1~~~Jtl'i::J.J1ru'rn~folu~gi'i1ifvil:: l!io J1Vl~"ilfl'IJ~"ill'IJ
•. n"ll'!!ud~vuu1L~m~nluil~nfl vtlVI. - ,f~tU~Jfi1LU1N1I ltil'Ulft1"ilJU'VlI
t'lif!tJV U.il::ffl'! 11Vn11fl1t'lifltJV
t11::L11V111v.i1vLriv1L~v~nun11
t1~~11-u011;l'WL;i1ini:tru::11v~1v
11J1fl~'IJ"l "LR1~n11fl'1'Ufltj'IJ
fi1l'li.i1vf!tl'Jfltj'IJfl"1'1JflO'l:t1"
-15m'i ~'IJgv'IJ1un1'iLunin~'1n.,~
L~'IJLiJ1uqJiiL~'Ui:J1nG'U1fl1'il 'U'U11J
'!lv~a~1uPln'l:l1l-.1t1Bu1igi1J.JllU~~"il
1 ' .J
n'i::'l'i1~1J111~ VIEJ ~1'UVl'1~
~ lJVI o~~m.l!i/1 <il~<il~ Ml'U~
(i)°;) ijQ'U1EJ'U l!i<t'.<fl!i
.... , " d, "" """ I 1ID. n1tu'!!'IJVVltu'U1LflmilnVl'iJmv "il'IJ'il1n01J.Jm1fl1f!u1
- mru~1~/l1a1'i~ lJ"ilJB1'U1'il1"1 vtlYI. ~~~"il/~~'11~"il111'i Wt1~u;1,iuLiiv1nu~ud~1a1u11iinLiin
mrni'u luil~nfl vtlVI. fl1J.Joliv .,
- mru~1~/l1a1'i~ 'WJ.JvJB1'U1'il1"1 vtlYI. ~~~"il~~'11~"il1111'i i~~ut11::J.J1culu1J.J1flfi1t'liflvv
nci1~1u t11::L11V111v.i1mriv1L~tl~
nun11tl~~11'!1011vl'UiLoV1
~ ' .I
i1n,;ru::11v;i1t11J.J1fltl'IJ"l
- Lfl'i~01,auua"luri1W~1v
auua"luamuPln'l:l1