SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 30
Taxonomy
           Folksonomy
           Plutonomy

 Seth Maislin — Potomac Indexing, LLC

SSP 30th Annual Meeting — Boston, Mass.
         Thursday, May 29, 2008
I Hear
  I See
I Learn

Audio
Video
Disco
A Whole Lotta Otomy
               • Taxonomy
               • Folksonomy
               • Plutonomy
Taxonomy. 1) Hierarchy




  FACET
  Subject            FACET
                     Process              FACET
                                          Person




            FACET
            Status             FACET
                               Location            FACET
                                                   File Type
Taxonomy. 2) Language
methanol                 submarine sandwich
methyl alcohol           bomber
methylated spirits       Cuban sandwich
meths                    grinder
wood alcohol             hero
                         hero sandwich
                         hoagie
                         hoagy
Chef Chow’s Restaurant   Italian sandwich
Chef Chou’s Restaurant   poor boy
Chef Chow’s Restaurant   sub
Chef Chows Restaurant    submarine
                         torpedo
                         wedge
                         zip
Taxonomy. 3) Relationships




       Hierarchical cross-facet relationship
          Exclusive (parent-child) relationship
           Items requiring relationship
              Component disambiguation
Trying to Imagine Taxonomy…

             bomber                                  dried
  poor boy                                               rolled
                                         spoon boil
               hoagie                           boil
                                           roasted
                                               pan-fried
                             sugar   dried
  grinder                                         knead rolled
                                                boil
                   raisins                      boil spoon
                                               pan-fried
     candy canes
                   vanilla                        kneadroasted
the metaphor
FACET: Functionality




Work Space

Storage Space

Sitting Space
FACET: Ease of Use




Easy to Reach

Hard to Reach

Impossible to Reach
FACET: People




Food Preparation, Complex

Food Preparation, Simple

Table Setting

No One (e.g., decoration)
LANGUAGE: “spoon”
Similar locations
                                                RELATIONSHIPS




                Components of same application

     Similar function



Similar temperatures


                                 Similar size
taxonomy
an understanding of concepts within a domain,
     including relevant terminology,
     relationships between concepts,
     and types of relationships
Navel Gazing
Facets   Values (controlled vocabulary)
Price/Book Type


Book Type Facet

                             Relationship
                           Between Books




                    Book Subject Facet
2   3
                                       8
                   4                            9
 1
                              7



                              4
                                       10
                   2    3              3
                                            11
                              2
               6
               1
 1
       5                                            6
                                       5



                                  4
Where is the trash can?
      are the spoons?
             water pitcher?       12

                                            5
Creation and Governance
taxonomist




             22
taxonomy is a team effort

        knowing stuff is not your job
taxonomy is freudian

    just pretend you don’t know anything
folksonomy is easier

    the surest sign of wisdom is saying nothing
These folks know what they’re doing.
Imagine this kitchen in a college fraternity house…




                                       empty pizza boxes




           cups


       bottle openers


      plastic cutlery
Taxonomy vs. Folksonomy
Advantages to taxonomy:
• Governance processes
• Strongly influenced by practical application

Advantages to folksonomy:
• Requires almost none of your resources
• Fun, social, organic, interesting
Plutonomy
the study of the production
  and distribution of wealth
whoever controls the
most information wins
         taxonomists rule



            Seth Maislin
       Potomac Indexing, LLC
         seth@maislin.com

More Related Content

More from Society for Scholarly Publishing

04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadowsSociety for Scholarly Publishing
 
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterickSociety for Scholarly Publishing
 

More from Society for Scholarly Publishing (20)

10052016 ssp seminar2_newsham
10052016 ssp seminar2_newsham10052016 ssp seminar2_newsham
10052016 ssp seminar2_newsham
 
10052016 ssp seminar2_rivera
10052016 ssp seminar2_rivera10052016 ssp seminar2_rivera
10052016 ssp seminar2_rivera
 
10052016 ssp seminar2_pesanelli
10052016 ssp seminar2_pesanelli10052016 ssp seminar2_pesanelli
10052016 ssp seminar2_pesanelli
 
10052016 ssp seminar2_harley
10052016 ssp seminar2_harley10052016 ssp seminar2_harley
10052016 ssp seminar2_harley
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_myers
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_myers10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_myers
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_myers
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_demers
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_demers10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_demers
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_demers
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_cochran
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_cochran10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_cochran
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_cochran
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_stanley
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_stanley10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_stanley
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_stanley
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_ranganathan
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_ranganathan10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_ranganathan
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_ranganathan
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_odike
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_odike10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_odike
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_odike
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_cochran
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_cochran10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_cochran
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_cochran
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_walker
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_walker10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_walker
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_walker
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_ivins
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_ivins10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_ivins
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_ivins
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_holland
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_holland10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_holland
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_holland
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_stanley
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_stanley10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_stanley
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_stanley
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_keane
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_keane10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_keane
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_keane
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_ivins
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_ivins10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_ivins
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_ivins
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_asadilari
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_asadilari10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_asadilari
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_asadilari
 
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows
 
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick
 

397 seth maislinpresentation