SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1
Y O U T H F U L C I T I E S
A F F O R D A B I L I T Y R E P O R T 2 0 1 5
2 3
WHY AFFORDABILITY? - 3
INTRODUCTION - 4
OVERALL CITIES SCORE - 6
CITIES AS AFFORDABLE PLACES - 7
WHY WE’RE DIFFERENT - 8
YOUTH AFFORDABILITY SERIES - 9
COST OF A FAST FOOD MEAL - 10
MINIMUM WAGE - 11
COST OF 12 EGGS - 12
COST OF A TUBE OF TOOTHPASTE - 13
COST OF A GYM MEMBERSHIP - 14
STANDING RATE FOR A TAXI - 15
COST OF A MOVIE TICKET - 16
COST OF RENTAL HOUSING - 17
FINAL DATA - 18
PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS - 22
ABOUT YOUTHFULCITIES - 23
C O N T E N T S
3
W H Y
A F F O R D A B I L I T Y ?
C I T I E S A R E O U R C O L L E C T I V E F U T U R E
Today’s young people are at the centre of building
Welcome to YouthfulCities. We are a global social
enterprise that illuminates and decodes the power
of urban youth. We’re a two-year old social startup
with big ambitions – to lead cities around the world
towards youthfulness. Our goal is to be the catalyst
for boosting prosperity and happiness for all citizens
of the world’s 100 biggest cities by 2025. It may be
bold, but we’re ready for the challenge. Over the last
three years we have been working with thousands of
youth in the world’s largest cities to uncover the best
places to live, work and play.
Civic leaders, policy makers, and municipal
strategists in cities around the world are beginning to
recognize youth as their city’s greatest assets. Youth
are now widely recognized to be the world’s largest
untapped resource — and the secret sauce to driving
a city’s competitive edge, stimulating development,
and finding new solutions to pressing urban problems.
The rich and comprehensive reservoir of youth-centric
knowledge we have helped gather is empowering
and engaging civic leaders to build better, connected,
dynamic, open, fun, curious, and inventive cities.
The YouthfulCities Index is a first-of-its-kind statistical
ranking of the world’s top cities from a youth
perspective. And Affordability is a critical issue. 	
Young people from around the world have told us
that affordability is among their top urban priorities.
Results from our Urban Attitudes Survey of 10,000+
global youth show it to be more important than
having access to education, having a great film/
music culture, and even having access to healthcare.
Keeping all the above in mind, we want to answer
the following:
I N W H I C H C I T Y D O A L L T H E A S P E C T S
O F A F F O R D A B I L I T Y F R O M A Y O U T H
P E R S P E C T I V E B E S T A L I G N ?
Read further and find out!
3
4 5
This year Sydney has been
awarded the title of Most
Affordable City for Youth.
And like Paris last year,
Sydney is the city in this year’s
YouthfulCities Index with the
highest local minimum wage.
Most of the cities in the top five show up there because
of their relatively high minimum wages. Sydney is top
in both cases, Montreal has the 5th highest minimum,
San Francisco 4th and Berlin 3rd. Detroit’s high finish
in affordability is driven less by its minimum wage and
more-so by its affordable housing stock.
For more on how we integrated minimum wage
into our calculations check out our “Problems and
Solutions” on page 20.
The YouthfulCities Affordability Index draws attention
to the important role that minimum wage plays in
cities’ affordability and appeal to youth. Given this,
when thinking about the future of cities, mayors, policy
makers and employers should have a focus on high
minimum wage at the top of their urban to-do lists.
Read on to see visuals for select indicators. The
overall results for all cities are included at the end
of this report in the appendix.
2. Montreal
3. Detroit
4. San Francisco
5. Berlin
6. Tokyo
7. Boston
8. Osaka
9. Paris
10. Los Angeles
T H E M O S T
A F F O R D A B L E C I T Y F O R
Y O U N G P E O P L E I S . . .
SYDNEY
766
Special Thanks To
EXPATISTAN
WWW.EXPATISTAN.COM
The collaborative, crowd-sourced international cost
of living index - We’d like to thank Expatistan for
providing us full and open access to cost of
living data in all our cities.
O V E R A L L A F F O R D A B I L I T Y I N D E X R A N K I N G
1.	Sydney
1118.97
2.	 Montreal1082.84
3.	 Detroit
1074.59
4.	 San Francisco
1068.75
5.	 Berlin
1067.44
6.	 Tokyo
1065.09
7.	 Boston
1063.35
8.	 Osaka
1062/27
9.	 Paris
1060.60
10.	 Los Angeles
1057.79
11.	 Washington
1055.87
12.	 Dallas
1054.08
13.	 Toronto
1053.72
14.	 Miami
1051.99
15.	 Vancouver
1050.12
16.	 Chicago
1046.10
17.	 New York City
1042.52
18.	 Tel Aviv
1039.32
19.	 Tehran
1035.90
20.	 Seoul
1035.08
21.	 Amsterdam
1029.64
22.	 Madrid
1011.51
23.	 London
1010.32
24.	 Quito
1001.85
25.	 Rome
996.84
26.	 Hong Kong
995.19
27.	 Dubai
992.91
28.	 Shanghai
987.10
29.	 Lima
986.66
30.	 Singapore
986.57
31.	 Cairo
984.49
32.	 Jakarta
975.90
33.	 Warsaw
975.32
34.	 Buenos Aires
973.52
35.	 Casablanca
961.38
36.	 Bangkok
960.38
37.	 Manila
958.55
38.	 Istanbul
956.92
39.	 New Delhi
952.24
40.	 Santiago
944.33
41.	 Bogota
938.54
42.	 Durban
922.44
43.	 Karachi
915.97
44.	 Nairobi
908.72
45.	 Johannesburg
900.43
46.	 Sao Paulo
900.33
47.	 Rio de Janeiro
898.66
48.	 Moscow
881.42
49.	 Lagos
877.87
50.	 Beirut
859.84
51.	 Mexico City
840.92
52.	 Mumbai
837.21
53.	 Dar Es Salaam
569.85
54.	 Accra
453.85
55.	 Caracas
319.73
*Each city is scored out of a possible 1181.3
points. We've included each city's total score.
ASIA/AUSTRALIA
U S A / C A N A D A
L AT I N A M E R I C A
A F R I C A
M I D D L E E A S T
E U R O P E
C I T I E S A S
A F F O R D A B L E P L A C E S
O U R C O L L E C T I V E C H A L L E N G E I S
T O M A K E C I T I E S M O R E A F F O R D A B L E
F O R Y O U T H .
The YouthfulCities Affordability Index takes 55 of
the world’s biggest cities and compares the cost of
everyday items like food, housing and public transit.
The index also covers some basic entertainment costs,
like the cost of a movie ticket, since letting loose on a
budget is key to making a city an exhilarating, liveable
and youthful place. Finally, in each city it looks at the
base wage that young people make at entry-level jobs
and the base tax rate for everyday goods.
W E P O S E T H I S T O
C I T Y G O V E R N M E N T S :
You rely on the brains and brawn of young people.
You need to ensure that young talent, creativity
and energy is nurtured, in order to foster the
social, cultural and economic capital of this crucial
demographic and your city as a whole. We dare you
to guarantee that you will be a place young people
can afford to live today and tomorrow. 		
W E P O S E T H I S C H A L L E N G E
T O C O M PA N I E S :
Your bottom lines rely on young people. We want
to afford your products or services. But you often
price yourself out of the market. Take a cue from
the growing contingent of companies working with
municipalities to promote affordability, as well
as those promoting the sharing economy. These
businesses are working towards cities as more
affordable places and are encouraging all of us to
capitalize on our underused assets, which in turn
push affordability.
98
Y O U T H F U L C I T I E S
A F F O R D A B I L I T Y S E R I E S
2 0 1 5
W H Y W E ’ R E
D I F F E R E N T
Our Index is different in that we place a strong
emphasis on base wages. Too often, discussions about
affordability focus solely on the cost of everyday items,
products and services, usually normalized to U.S.
dollars, and indexed against a baseline city. We think
these fail to take into account the varying levels of
income present in each city. Our Affordability Index is
unique in the way we measure costs as relative to one
hour of minimum wage labour in each of our cities.
Looking at the results, you’ll see that Sydney takes the
top spot, followed by Montreal, Detroit, San Francisco
and Berlin. These aren’t all cities that normally place
at the top of similar lists. What’s happening in these
cities, however, is that minimum wage has come to
be framed as a key policy area not only for young
people, but for the growing overall demographic that
relies on minimum wage jobs. In these places a fair
wage has become a key concern for policy makers
too, as they’ve begun to wake up to the reality that
youth are highly mobile and likely to leave town if a
city isn’t doing enough to protect their pocketbook.
Since youth rely on entry level jobs when they enter
the workforce, we feel tying costs to an hour of
minimum wage labour is the best way to measure a
city’s affordability from a youth perspective. And the
fact that it’s within the legislative reach of many of
the municipalities in our Index to increase wages only
adds to the impact of this factor. Measuring it this way,
we look at affordability from both a cost perspective,
as well as from an entry- level income perspective. Both
sides of the coin, we feel, are necessary to accurately
state how reasonably priced life in any given city is.
10 11
11. Chicago
12. Osaka
13. Montreal
14. New York City
15. Washington
16. Miami
17. Boston
18. Dallas
19. Amsterdam
20. London
21. Hong Kong
22. Seoul
23. Rome
24. Madrid
25. Singapore
26. Shanghai
27. Tel Aviv
28. Warsaw
29. Karachi
30. Quito
31. Santiago
32. Istanbul
33. Jakarta
34. Manila
35. Buenos Aires
36. Durban
37. Lima
38. Dubai
39. Johannesburg
40. Bangkok
41. Rio De Janeiro
42. Bogota
43. Sao Paulo
44. Casablanca
45. Cairo
46. Moscow
47. Beirut
48. New Delhi
49. Nairobi
50. Mumbai
51. Mexico City
52. Lagos
53. Dar Es Salaam
54. Accra
55. Caracas
11. New York City
12. Osaka
13. Chicago
14. Washington
15. Detroit
16. Miami
17. Boston
18. Rome
19. London
20. Dallas
21. Tel Aviv
22. Madrid
23. Seoul
24. Singapore
25. Hong Kong
26. Buenos Aires
27. Shanghai
28. Warsaw
29. Santiago
30. Istanbul
31. Rio De Janeiro
32. Sao Paulo
33. Tehran
34. Quito
35. Bogota
36. Dubai
37. Casablanca
38. Jakarta
39. Lima
40. Beirut
41. Durban
42. Johannesburg
43. Manila
44. Bangkok
45. Moscow
46. Cairo
47. Nairobi
48. Lagos
49. New Delhi
50. Mexico City
51. Caracas
52. Karachi
53. Mumbai
54. Accra
55. Dar Es Salaam
12 13
11. Karachi
12. Los Angeles
13. Paris
14. Vancouver
15. New York City
16. Washington
17. Boston
18. Madrid
19. San Francisco
20. Berlin
21. Lima
22. Tel Aviv
23. London
24. Rome
25. Singapore
26. Seoul
27. Rio De Janeiro
28. Shanghai
29. Buenos Aires
30. Quito
31. Hong Kong
32. Casablanca
33. Warsaw
34. Istanbul
35. Sao Paulo
36. Manila
37. Santiago
38. Bogota
39. Jakarta
40. Dubai
41. Durban
42. New Delhi
43. Moscow
44. Tehran
45. Cairo
46. Bangkok
47. Johannesburg
48. Mumbai
49. Nairobi
50. Beirut
51. Lagos
52. Mexico City
53. Dar Es Salaam
54. Accra
55. Caracas
11. New York City
12. London
13. Miami
14. Rome
15. San Francisco
16. Amsterdam
17. Madrid
18. Washington
19. Boston
20. Tokyo
21. Vancouver
22. Seoul
23. Rio De Janeiro
24. Singapore
25. Sao Paulo
26. Hong Kong
27. Tel Aviv
28. Warsaw
29. Durban
30. Bogota
31. Johannesburg
32. Shanghai
33. Buenos Aires
34. Jakarta
35. Quito
36. Santiago
37. Istanbul
38. Casablanca
39. Cairo
40. Karachi
41. New Delhi
42. Manila
43. Bangkok
44. Nairobi
45. Lima
46. Dubai
47. Moscow
48. Beirut
49. Tehran
50. Mumbai
51. Mexico City
52. Lagos
53. Dar Es Salaam
54. Caracas
55. Accra
14 15
11. Los Angeles
12. Boston
13. Paris
14. Rome
15. Chicago
16. New York City
17. London
18. Osaka
19. Tokyo
20. Washington
21. Tel Aviv
22. Madrid
23. Seoul
24. Hong Kong
25. Warsaw
26. Shanghai
27. Santiago
28. Singapore
29. Karachi
30. Johannesburg
31. Rio De Janeiro
32. Buenos Aires
33. Durban
34. Jakarta
35. Quito
36. Bogota
37. Istanbul
38. Tehran
39. Sao Paulo
40. Casablanca
41. Lima
42. Manila
43. New Delhi
44. Dubai
45. Bangkok
46. Beirut
47. Cairo
48. Nairobi
49. Mumbai
50. Mexico City
51. Moscow
52. Lagos
53. Dar Es Salaam
54. Accra
55. Caracas
11. Karachi
12. New York City
13. Dallas
14. Detroit
15. Vancouver
16. Los Angeles
17. San Francisco
18. Boston
19. Montreal
20. Miami
21. Chicago
22. Washington
23. Amsterdam
24. Berlin
25. Madrid
26. Toronto
27. Jakarta
28. London
29. Rome
30. Tel Aviv
31. Dubai
32. Cairo
33. Seoul
34. Hong Kong
35. Buenos Aires
36. Istanbul
37. Singapore
38. New Delhi
39. Shanghai
40. Sao Paulo
41. Tokyo
42. Osaka
43. Mumbai
44. Bangkok
45. Warsaw
46. Rio De Janeiro
47. Bogota
48. Mexico City
49. Johannesburg
50. Lima
51. Nairobi
52. Dar Es Salaam
53. Lagos
54. Accra
55. Caracas
1716
11. Rome
12. Chicago
13. Dallas
14. Los Angeles
15. Boston
16. Washington
17. Amsterdam
18. New York City
19. Tel Aviv
20. Madrid
21. Seoul
22. Tokyo
23. Osaka
24. Singapore
25. London
26. Quito
27. Hong Kong
28. Buenos Aires
29. Warsaw
30. Jakarta
31. Bogota
32. Santiago
33. Istanbul
34. Durban
35. Manila
36. Lima
37. Rio De Janeiro
38. Sao Paulo
39. Shanghai
40. Casablanca
41. Bangkok
42. Johannesburg
43. Karachi
44. Cairo
45. Dubai
46. Nairobi
47. New Delhi
48. Beirut
49. Mexico City
50. Mumbai
51. Moscow
52. Lagos
53. Dar Es Salaam
54. Accra
55. Caracas
11. Tehran
12. Amsterdam
13. Madrid
14. Los Angeles
15. Paris
16. Rome
17. Washington
18. Tel Aviv
19. Tokyo
20. Boston
21. San Francisco
22. Seoul
23. New York City
24. Buenos Aires
25. London
26. Warsaw
27. Quito
28. Istanbul
29. Santiago
30. Cairo
31. Karachi
32. Shanghai
33. Lima
34. Casablanca
35. Durban
36. New Delhi
37. Sao Paulo
38. Johannesburg
39. Bogota
40. Singapore
41. Manila
42. Rio De Janeiro
43. Bangkok
44. Jakarta
45. Beirut
46. Hong Kong
47. Dubai
48. Nairobi
49. Mumbai
50. Mexico City
51. Moscow
52. Lagos
53. Dar Es Salaam
54. Caracas
55. Accra
19
City
Minimum wage
(USD 2014)
Consumption
tax rate
GINI Coefficient†
Cost of rental
housing*
Cost of one prepaid
cellular minute*
Cost of 12 eggs*
Cost of monthly
transit pass
Price per square
meter to buy an
apartment*
Cost of a tube of
toothpaste*
Standing rate
for a taxi*
Cost of a
movie ticket*
Cost of a fast
food meal*
Cost of 1 month of
gym membership
in business district*
Cost of 1 pair of
sport shoes (Nike,
Adidas, or similar)*
Accra 453.85 0.37 15% 0.43 10805.24 0.48 10.94 131.05 4392.79 30.89 19.77 26.00 26.42 382.78 388.17
Amsterdam 1029.64 9.28 21% 0.34 255.68 0.05 0.37 12.88 739.88 0.34 0.40 1.51 1.01 5.80 12.80
Bangkok 960.38 1.22 7% 0.40 1046.91 0.17 2.05 26.72 3059.59 1.95 0.94 4.85 3.96 73.81 83.89
Beirut 859.84 1.40 10% 0.86 1159.45 0.23 2.95 59.32 2.88 2.46 0.00 7.16 6.41 74.32 83.75
Berlin 1067.44 11.29 19% 0.28 131.15 0.01 0.46 9.35 414.99 0.15 0.40 0.94 0.77 3.97 11.41
Bogota 938.54 1.72 16% 0.54 988.55 0.08 1.39 27.79 1203.10 0.80 1.05 3.14 4.03 35.53 51.89
Boston 1063.35 8.00 6% 0.48 379.75 0.07 0.42 3.25 369.43 0.38 0.33 1.49 0.90 8.40 10.68
Buenos Aires 973.52 3.44 21% 0.37 476.72 0.15 0.91 9.52 185.66 1.01 0.64 2.91 3.09 31.89 69.40
Cairo 984.49 0.91 10% 0.31 698.70 0.08 2.03 20.63 939.96 1.49 0.56 5.69 5.83 79.75 113.46
Caracas 319.73 0.53 12% 0.39 9361.79 0.69 34.27 18.69 581.49 29.33 24.92 28.04 85.67 1345.87 1370.64
Casablanca 961.38 1.47 13% 0.41 794.71 0.22 0.98 15.52 1604.59 1.41 0.14 4.73 4.17 50.41 56.08
Chicago 1046.10 8.25 9% 0.47 241.89 0.12 0.29 10.91 396.96 0.22 0.39 1.43 0.81 10.43 10.80
Dallas 1054.08 7.25 8.25% 0.46 212.70 0.08 0.31 5.52 277.14 0.29 0.31 1.44 0.92 5.46 11.87
Dar Es Salaam 569.85 0.26 18% 0.39 8732.45 1.03 8.31 128.22 798.08 6.85 6.92 23.08 18.46 334.94 497.69
Detroit 1074.59 8.15 6% 0.47 191.66 0.02 0.27 5.77 102.53 0.24 0.31 1.18 0.76 4.11 9.60
Dubai 992.91 1.56 0% 0.30 1590.69 0.13 1.60 38.40 3294.28 2.25 0.52 6.38 3.82 66.95 78.76
Durban 922.44 1.38 14% 0.72 813.62 0.15 1.61 18.24 658.15 0.78 0.00 3.93 3.49 32.28 52.76
Hong Kong 995.19 3.87 0% 0.54 1388.59 0.06 0.95 19.32 6754.32 0.75 0.63 2.81 1.16 18.74 24.35
Istanbul 956.92 2.47 18% 0.40 541.33 0.10 1.18 32.17 1225.95 1.33 0.68 3.34 2.84 36.72 35.92
Jakarta 975.70 1.47 10% 0.38 1086.30 0.17 1.39 20.86 2426.15 1.10 0.48 2.98 2.92 35.11 60.86
Johannesburg 900.43 1.38 14% 0.60 968.12 0.11 2.18 58.96 940.22 0.90 2.44 4.89 3.91 29.12 62.63
Karachi 915.97 0.52 23% 0.30 730.26 0.37 0.37 28.80 1942.41 1.49 0.29 5.10 2.24 27.85 17.70
Lagos 877.87 0.71 5% 0.49 3139.65 0.24 3.20 2.22 641.20 4.11 10.65 13.31 12.91 172.02 93.33
Lima 986.66 1.47 5% 0.45 777.22 0.12 0.50 7.42 1505.65 2.20 3.84 4.13 3.58 52.39 69.87
London 1010.32 7.85 20% 0.34 487.20 0.03 0.57 20.81 1942.30 0.32 0.48 2.30 1.09 11.19 12.86
Los Angeles 1057.79 9.00 9% 0.49 266.13 0.07 0.37 4.78 520.49 0.21 0.32 1.45 0.75 6.00 9.14
Madrid 1011.51 6.24 21% 0.33 264.71 0.06 0.42 11.44 764.46 0.34 0.43 1.85 1.49 14.12 15.06
18
*Raw data supplied by expatistan.com
† GINI coefficient is a standard economic measure of income inequality.
Its range is between 0 (per fect equality) and 1 (total inequality).
F I N A L
D ATA
All cost values below refer to the number of hours of work at the city’s
minimum wage that it takes to purchase the given item.
20
City
Minimum wage
(USD 2014)
Consumption
tax rate
GINI Coefficient†
Cost of rental
housing*
Cost of one prepaid
cellular minute*
Cost of 12 eggs*
Cost of monthly
transit pass
Price per square
meter to buy an
apartment*
Cost of a tube of
toothpaste*
Standing rate
for a taxi*
Cost of a
movie ticket*
Cost of a fast
food meal*
Cost of 1 month of
gym membership
in business district*
Cost of 1 pair of
sport shoes (Nike,
Adidas, or similar)*
Manila 958.55 1.29 12% 0.43 1036.81 0.13 1.34 44.01 3013.48 1.87 0.06 4.07 2.96 56.24 68.61
Mexico City 840.92 0.57 16% 0.48 2649.71 0.29 3.71 6.99 451.28 3.67 1.20 9.00 9.73 141.97 150.87
Miami 1051.99 8.05 7% 0.50 251.79 0.11 0.34 4.76 367.00 0.32 0.37 1.41 0.88 5.38 10.60
Montreal 1082.84 10.05 10% 0.36 161.43 0.05 0.35 44.69 177.33 0.18 0.33 1.16 0.83 5.18 11.02
Moscow 881.42 1.21 18% 0.52 2678.37 0.04 1.86 43.74 16617.03 2.31 0.18 9.39 6.36 161.73 120.39
Mumbai 837.21 0.43 12.36% 0.34 2330.67 0.04 2.34 56.62 1547.11 2.85 0.84 9.34 8.72 134.02 123.78
Nairobi 908.72 0.90 15% 0.34 1659.47 0.06 2.71 12.41 5013.44 2.17 3.93 6.93 7.64 92.29 60.62
New Delhi 952.24 0.62 13% 0.34 837.73 0.03 1.72 13.31 1171.96 1.58 0.69 6.98 6.68 60.96 115.72
New York City 1043.52 8.75 8.88% 0.51 461.67 0.05 0.40 9.53 692.97 0.31 0.29 1.57 0.86 10.68 9.15
Osaka 1062.27 8.39 8% 0.42 226.57 0.05 0.31 6.84 989.77 0.30 0.83 2.09 0.82 11.43 8.45
Paris 1060.60 12.52 20% 0.32 276.48 0.03 0.39 8.67 610.33 0.27 0.21 1.05 0.78 8.60 10.54
Quito 1001.85 2.13 12% 0.42 516.43 0.07 0.93 34.31 2253.05 1.15 0.16 2.35 2.48 35.42 52.56
Rio De Janeiro 898.66 2.31 19% 0.52 1040.81 0.34 0.89 5.83 1568.14 0.63 0.96 4.34 4.00 31.42 72.45
Rome 996.84 7.97 22% 0.49 284.64 0.02 0.60 7.24 827.99 0.33 0.50 1.41 1.22 9.44 14.47
San Francisco 1068.75 11.05 8.50% 0.48 386.90 0.05 0.43 26.92 886.50 0.33 0.32 1.17 0.64 5.58 7.73
Santiago 944.33 2.53 19% 0.49 559.91 0.13 1.36 37.10 1885.77 1.17 0.20 3.24 2.69 24.18 27.58
Sao Paulo 900.33 2.31 18.50% 0.56 857.97 0.27 1.27 11.16 2355.25 0.70 0.82 4.60 4.04 44.69 61.08
Seoul 1035.08 4.46 10% 0.31 439.32 0.06 0.79 11.77 3356.80 0.61 0.61 1.88 1.17 16.77 21.79
Shanghai 987.10 2.75 11.60% 0.37 763.10 0.09 0.90 23.99 4868.49 1.00 0.76 4.69 1.82 21.20 46.55
Singapore 986.57 4.00 7% 0.48 1001.63 0.10 0.62 8.09 672.77 0.65 0.68 2.18 1.49 26.03 30.40
Sydney 1118.97 16.28 10% 0.33 186.72 0.04 0.33 0.00 1167.43 0.24 0.21 1.11 0.51 3.77 7.78
Tehran 1035.90 2.24 4% 0.38 0.03 0.11 1.98 5.54 1205.00 2.63 0.00 1.34 0.00 43.93 125.38
Tel Aviv 1039.32 6.41 13% 0.37 329.38 0.03 0.56 8.38 811.57 0.77 0.50 73.80 1.84 13.26 20.72
Tokyo 1065.09 9.10 8% 0.42 369.40 0.05 0.31 12.00 637.27 0.39 0.82 72.89 0.72 11.44 8.38
Toronto 1053.72 9.95 13% 0.42 228.29 0.05 0.36 10.09 766.27 0.24 0.44 74.71 0.80 5.56 11.56
Vancouver 1050.12 9.95 12% 0.48 233.69 0.03 0.39 8.76 1196.62 0.41 0.31 74.96 0.80 5.42 11.68
Warsaw 975.32 2.66 23% 0.33 509.32 0.03 1.06 21.42 691.50 0.77 0.95 70.26 2.06 20.98 32.38
Washington 1055.87 8.25 5.75% 0.44 326.25 0.11 0.41 73.37 84.07 0.36 0.39 74.35 0.86 12.45 8.75
21
F I N A L
D ATA ( C O N T )
All cost values below refer to the number of hours of work at the city’s
minimum wage that it takes to purchase the given item.
*Raw data supplied by expatistan.com
† GINI coefficient is a standard economic measure of income inequality.
Its range is between 0 (per fect equality) and 1 (total inequality).
22 23
Y O U T H F U L C I T I E S
YouthfulCities is leading a unique urban regeneration.
We are building a global network of 15 - to 29-year-olds who dive
deep into youth-driven urban knowledge to create far-reaching inventive
solutions from youth outward. And, we are illuminating youthful stories
around the world. This leads to the 100 biggest cities and their almost
one billion inhabitants becoming more connected, dynamic, open, fun,
curious, and inventive – In other words, more youthful cities.
It’s a bold direction for a social enterprise that’s only two years old.
But we’re not shy about it.
W H AT I S S U E S
D I D W E R U N I N T O ?
Problem:
Some cities, for example Mumbai, have more than
1000 minimum wages.
Solution:
We take the average amount across all the given
minimum wages in a city.
Problem:
Not all cities have an agreed upon minimum wage.
Solution:
For cities without a legislated minimum we take the
base wage at a typical entry-level job, for example
a fast food restaurant.
Problem:
The cost of an everyday item like subway fare is
relative to the local currency value.
Solution:
All cost amounts were translated from local currencies
into U.S. dollars at the average price between January
2013 and January 2014.
Problem:
Costs are relative to the local average income level.
Solution:
Since robust data for average youth income at the
city level doesn’t exist, we use minimum wage as our
baseline income level.
While constructing this and other YouthfulCities Indexes we’ve run into logistical problems. Some are problems
inherent to comparing the cost of items between cities, others are specific to establishing minimum wage values
for all cities. Here we explain the key hurdles.
For more information, contact our Research Director: matthew@youthfulcities.com

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Iran tests new missiles – Liberty Champion
Iran tests new missiles – Liberty ChampionIran tests new missiles – Liberty Champion
Iran tests new missiles – Liberty ChampionErica Tomlin
 
New microsoft power point presentation
New microsoft power point presentationNew microsoft power point presentation
New microsoft power point presentation
JASMINENGUYENKHOA
 
Viejas locas 2
Viejas locas 2Viejas locas 2
Viejas locas 2victornob
 
El maíz de sndra
El maíz de sndraEl maíz de sndra
El maíz de sndrapreciosa5
 
EnsayoDelitosInformaticos
EnsayoDelitosInformaticosEnsayoDelitosInformaticos
EnsayoDelitosInformaticosenlacesred
 
DIE MARKTMEINUNG AUS STUTTGART: Aktienmärkte tendieren seitwärts
DIE MARKTMEINUNG AUS STUTTGART: Aktienmärkte tendieren seitwärtsDIE MARKTMEINUNG AUS STUTTGART: Aktienmärkte tendieren seitwärts
DIE MARKTMEINUNG AUS STUTTGART: Aktienmärkte tendieren seitwärts
Ellwanger & Geiger Privatbankiers
 

Viewers also liked (12)

Iran tests new missiles – Liberty Champion
Iran tests new missiles – Liberty ChampionIran tests new missiles – Liberty Champion
Iran tests new missiles – Liberty Champion
 
Resume
ResumeResume
Resume
 
New microsoft power point presentation
New microsoft power point presentationNew microsoft power point presentation
New microsoft power point presentation
 
Teatre
TeatreTeatre
Teatre
 
SanthoshMGowtham-updated
SanthoshMGowtham-updatedSanthoshMGowtham-updated
SanthoshMGowtham-updated
 
Cvo
CvoCvo
Cvo
 
Viejas locas 2
Viejas locas 2Viejas locas 2
Viejas locas 2
 
Ecología
EcologíaEcología
Ecología
 
El maíz de sndra
El maíz de sndraEl maíz de sndra
El maíz de sndra
 
Pro Med
Pro MedPro Med
Pro Med
 
EnsayoDelitosInformaticos
EnsayoDelitosInformaticosEnsayoDelitosInformaticos
EnsayoDelitosInformaticos
 
DIE MARKTMEINUNG AUS STUTTGART: Aktienmärkte tendieren seitwärts
DIE MARKTMEINUNG AUS STUTTGART: Aktienmärkte tendieren seitwärtsDIE MARKTMEINUNG AUS STUTTGART: Aktienmärkte tendieren seitwärts
DIE MARKTMEINUNG AUS STUTTGART: Aktienmärkte tendieren seitwärts
 

Similar to YC_AffordabilityIndex2015

Youthful Cities Index 2014
Youthful Cities Index 2014Youthful Cities Index 2014
Youthful Cities Index 2014
Alice Junqueira
 
Cities of-opportunity-2014
Cities of-opportunity-2014Cities of-opportunity-2014
Cities of-opportunity-2014
LAZOVOY
 
Cities of-opportunity-2014
Cities of-opportunity-2014Cities of-opportunity-2014
Cities of-opportunity-2014
Diana Sirghi
 
Worlds Best-Cities Post-Covid
Worlds Best-Cities Post-CovidWorlds Best-Cities Post-Covid
Worlds Best-Cities Post-Covid
CMassociates
 
Global city index
Global city indexGlobal city index
Global city index
Piter Biswas
 
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global WebSustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global WebLisa Campbell
 
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global WebSustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global WebLauren Cavender
 
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global WebSustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global WebJohn Batten
 
Global cities
Global citiesGlobal cities
Global cities
HacheroBrivi
 
Etude PwC 2012 Cities of Opportunities
Etude PwC 2012 Cities of OpportunitiesEtude PwC 2012 Cities of Opportunities
Etude PwC 2012 Cities of Opportunities
PwC France
 
2012 cities-of-opportunity
2012 cities-of-opportunity2012 cities-of-opportunity
2012 cities-of-opportunity
Luis Taveras EMBA, MS
 
Informe Cities of Opportunity 2016
Informe Cities of Opportunity 2016 Informe Cities of Opportunity 2016
Informe Cities of Opportunity 2016
PwC España
 
MODULE 6.pptx
MODULE 6.pptxMODULE 6.pptx
MODULE 6.pptx
iamysenpai
 
He128 best cities_28
He128 best cities_28He128 best cities_28
He128 best cities_28Majorick
 
Graebel_CitySynopsis_NYC
Graebel_CitySynopsis_NYCGraebel_CitySynopsis_NYC
Graebel_CitySynopsis_NYCPat Liberati
 
3a3a66_24c59522cbd9436bb2bb7800ee501d85
3a3a66_24c59522cbd9436bb2bb7800ee501d853a3a66_24c59522cbd9436bb2bb7800ee501d85
3a3a66_24c59522cbd9436bb2bb7800ee501d85Sonja Miokovic
 
City Report Toronto Final 2014
City Report Toronto Final 2014City Report Toronto Final 2014
City Report Toronto Final 2014Aaron Joshua Pinto
 
Sustainable Cities Index 2015 - Arcadis report
Sustainable Cities Index 2015 - Arcadis reportSustainable Cities Index 2015 - Arcadis report
Sustainable Cities Index 2015 - Arcadis report
Graciela Mariani
 
Resonance 2019-worlds-best-cities-report
Resonance 2019-worlds-best-cities-reportResonance 2019-worlds-best-cities-report
Resonance 2019-worlds-best-cities-report
David Mora
 
arcadis-sustainable-cities-index-report
arcadis-sustainable-cities-index-reportarcadis-sustainable-cities-index-report
arcadis-sustainable-cities-index-reportLauren Cavender
 

Similar to YC_AffordabilityIndex2015 (20)

Youthful Cities Index 2014
Youthful Cities Index 2014Youthful Cities Index 2014
Youthful Cities Index 2014
 
Cities of-opportunity-2014
Cities of-opportunity-2014Cities of-opportunity-2014
Cities of-opportunity-2014
 
Cities of-opportunity-2014
Cities of-opportunity-2014Cities of-opportunity-2014
Cities of-opportunity-2014
 
Worlds Best-Cities Post-Covid
Worlds Best-Cities Post-CovidWorlds Best-Cities Post-Covid
Worlds Best-Cities Post-Covid
 
Global city index
Global city indexGlobal city index
Global city index
 
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global WebSustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
 
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global WebSustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
 
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global WebSustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
Sustainable Cities Index 2016 Global Web
 
Global cities
Global citiesGlobal cities
Global cities
 
Etude PwC 2012 Cities of Opportunities
Etude PwC 2012 Cities of OpportunitiesEtude PwC 2012 Cities of Opportunities
Etude PwC 2012 Cities of Opportunities
 
2012 cities-of-opportunity
2012 cities-of-opportunity2012 cities-of-opportunity
2012 cities-of-opportunity
 
Informe Cities of Opportunity 2016
Informe Cities of Opportunity 2016 Informe Cities of Opportunity 2016
Informe Cities of Opportunity 2016
 
MODULE 6.pptx
MODULE 6.pptxMODULE 6.pptx
MODULE 6.pptx
 
He128 best cities_28
He128 best cities_28He128 best cities_28
He128 best cities_28
 
Graebel_CitySynopsis_NYC
Graebel_CitySynopsis_NYCGraebel_CitySynopsis_NYC
Graebel_CitySynopsis_NYC
 
3a3a66_24c59522cbd9436bb2bb7800ee501d85
3a3a66_24c59522cbd9436bb2bb7800ee501d853a3a66_24c59522cbd9436bb2bb7800ee501d85
3a3a66_24c59522cbd9436bb2bb7800ee501d85
 
City Report Toronto Final 2014
City Report Toronto Final 2014City Report Toronto Final 2014
City Report Toronto Final 2014
 
Sustainable Cities Index 2015 - Arcadis report
Sustainable Cities Index 2015 - Arcadis reportSustainable Cities Index 2015 - Arcadis report
Sustainable Cities Index 2015 - Arcadis report
 
Resonance 2019-worlds-best-cities-report
Resonance 2019-worlds-best-cities-reportResonance 2019-worlds-best-cities-report
Resonance 2019-worlds-best-cities-report
 
arcadis-sustainable-cities-index-report
arcadis-sustainable-cities-index-reportarcadis-sustainable-cities-index-report
arcadis-sustainable-cities-index-report
 

YC_AffordabilityIndex2015

  • 1. 1 Y O U T H F U L C I T I E S A F F O R D A B I L I T Y R E P O R T 2 0 1 5
  • 2. 2 3 WHY AFFORDABILITY? - 3 INTRODUCTION - 4 OVERALL CITIES SCORE - 6 CITIES AS AFFORDABLE PLACES - 7 WHY WE’RE DIFFERENT - 8 YOUTH AFFORDABILITY SERIES - 9 COST OF A FAST FOOD MEAL - 10 MINIMUM WAGE - 11 COST OF 12 EGGS - 12 COST OF A TUBE OF TOOTHPASTE - 13 COST OF A GYM MEMBERSHIP - 14 STANDING RATE FOR A TAXI - 15 COST OF A MOVIE TICKET - 16 COST OF RENTAL HOUSING - 17 FINAL DATA - 18 PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS - 22 ABOUT YOUTHFULCITIES - 23 C O N T E N T S 3 W H Y A F F O R D A B I L I T Y ? C I T I E S A R E O U R C O L L E C T I V E F U T U R E Today’s young people are at the centre of building Welcome to YouthfulCities. We are a global social enterprise that illuminates and decodes the power of urban youth. We’re a two-year old social startup with big ambitions – to lead cities around the world towards youthfulness. Our goal is to be the catalyst for boosting prosperity and happiness for all citizens of the world’s 100 biggest cities by 2025. It may be bold, but we’re ready for the challenge. Over the last three years we have been working with thousands of youth in the world’s largest cities to uncover the best places to live, work and play. Civic leaders, policy makers, and municipal strategists in cities around the world are beginning to recognize youth as their city’s greatest assets. Youth are now widely recognized to be the world’s largest untapped resource — and the secret sauce to driving a city’s competitive edge, stimulating development, and finding new solutions to pressing urban problems. The rich and comprehensive reservoir of youth-centric knowledge we have helped gather is empowering and engaging civic leaders to build better, connected, dynamic, open, fun, curious, and inventive cities. The YouthfulCities Index is a first-of-its-kind statistical ranking of the world’s top cities from a youth perspective. And Affordability is a critical issue. Young people from around the world have told us that affordability is among their top urban priorities. Results from our Urban Attitudes Survey of 10,000+ global youth show it to be more important than having access to education, having a great film/ music culture, and even having access to healthcare. Keeping all the above in mind, we want to answer the following: I N W H I C H C I T Y D O A L L T H E A S P E C T S O F A F F O R D A B I L I T Y F R O M A Y O U T H P E R S P E C T I V E B E S T A L I G N ? Read further and find out! 3
  • 3. 4 5 This year Sydney has been awarded the title of Most Affordable City for Youth. And like Paris last year, Sydney is the city in this year’s YouthfulCities Index with the highest local minimum wage. Most of the cities in the top five show up there because of their relatively high minimum wages. Sydney is top in both cases, Montreal has the 5th highest minimum, San Francisco 4th and Berlin 3rd. Detroit’s high finish in affordability is driven less by its minimum wage and more-so by its affordable housing stock. For more on how we integrated minimum wage into our calculations check out our “Problems and Solutions” on page 20. The YouthfulCities Affordability Index draws attention to the important role that minimum wage plays in cities’ affordability and appeal to youth. Given this, when thinking about the future of cities, mayors, policy makers and employers should have a focus on high minimum wage at the top of their urban to-do lists. Read on to see visuals for select indicators. The overall results for all cities are included at the end of this report in the appendix. 2. Montreal 3. Detroit 4. San Francisco 5. Berlin 6. Tokyo 7. Boston 8. Osaka 9. Paris 10. Los Angeles T H E M O S T A F F O R D A B L E C I T Y F O R Y O U N G P E O P L E I S . . . SYDNEY
  • 4. 766 Special Thanks To EXPATISTAN WWW.EXPATISTAN.COM The collaborative, crowd-sourced international cost of living index - We’d like to thank Expatistan for providing us full and open access to cost of living data in all our cities. O V E R A L L A F F O R D A B I L I T Y I N D E X R A N K I N G 1. Sydney 1118.97 2. Montreal1082.84 3. Detroit 1074.59 4. San Francisco 1068.75 5. Berlin 1067.44 6. Tokyo 1065.09 7. Boston 1063.35 8. Osaka 1062/27 9. Paris 1060.60 10. Los Angeles 1057.79 11. Washington 1055.87 12. Dallas 1054.08 13. Toronto 1053.72 14. Miami 1051.99 15. Vancouver 1050.12 16. Chicago 1046.10 17. New York City 1042.52 18. Tel Aviv 1039.32 19. Tehran 1035.90 20. Seoul 1035.08 21. Amsterdam 1029.64 22. Madrid 1011.51 23. London 1010.32 24. Quito 1001.85 25. Rome 996.84 26. Hong Kong 995.19 27. Dubai 992.91 28. Shanghai 987.10 29. Lima 986.66 30. Singapore 986.57 31. Cairo 984.49 32. Jakarta 975.90 33. Warsaw 975.32 34. Buenos Aires 973.52 35. Casablanca 961.38 36. Bangkok 960.38 37. Manila 958.55 38. Istanbul 956.92 39. New Delhi 952.24 40. Santiago 944.33 41. Bogota 938.54 42. Durban 922.44 43. Karachi 915.97 44. Nairobi 908.72 45. Johannesburg 900.43 46. Sao Paulo 900.33 47. Rio de Janeiro 898.66 48. Moscow 881.42 49. Lagos 877.87 50. Beirut 859.84 51. Mexico City 840.92 52. Mumbai 837.21 53. Dar Es Salaam 569.85 54. Accra 453.85 55. Caracas 319.73 *Each city is scored out of a possible 1181.3 points. We've included each city's total score. ASIA/AUSTRALIA U S A / C A N A D A L AT I N A M E R I C A A F R I C A M I D D L E E A S T E U R O P E C I T I E S A S A F F O R D A B L E P L A C E S O U R C O L L E C T I V E C H A L L E N G E I S T O M A K E C I T I E S M O R E A F F O R D A B L E F O R Y O U T H . The YouthfulCities Affordability Index takes 55 of the world’s biggest cities and compares the cost of everyday items like food, housing and public transit. The index also covers some basic entertainment costs, like the cost of a movie ticket, since letting loose on a budget is key to making a city an exhilarating, liveable and youthful place. Finally, in each city it looks at the base wage that young people make at entry-level jobs and the base tax rate for everyday goods. W E P O S E T H I S T O C I T Y G O V E R N M E N T S : You rely on the brains and brawn of young people. You need to ensure that young talent, creativity and energy is nurtured, in order to foster the social, cultural and economic capital of this crucial demographic and your city as a whole. We dare you to guarantee that you will be a place young people can afford to live today and tomorrow. W E P O S E T H I S C H A L L E N G E T O C O M PA N I E S : Your bottom lines rely on young people. We want to afford your products or services. But you often price yourself out of the market. Take a cue from the growing contingent of companies working with municipalities to promote affordability, as well as those promoting the sharing economy. These businesses are working towards cities as more affordable places and are encouraging all of us to capitalize on our underused assets, which in turn push affordability.
  • 5. 98 Y O U T H F U L C I T I E S A F F O R D A B I L I T Y S E R I E S 2 0 1 5 W H Y W E ’ R E D I F F E R E N T Our Index is different in that we place a strong emphasis on base wages. Too often, discussions about affordability focus solely on the cost of everyday items, products and services, usually normalized to U.S. dollars, and indexed against a baseline city. We think these fail to take into account the varying levels of income present in each city. Our Affordability Index is unique in the way we measure costs as relative to one hour of minimum wage labour in each of our cities. Looking at the results, you’ll see that Sydney takes the top spot, followed by Montreal, Detroit, San Francisco and Berlin. These aren’t all cities that normally place at the top of similar lists. What’s happening in these cities, however, is that minimum wage has come to be framed as a key policy area not only for young people, but for the growing overall demographic that relies on minimum wage jobs. In these places a fair wage has become a key concern for policy makers too, as they’ve begun to wake up to the reality that youth are highly mobile and likely to leave town if a city isn’t doing enough to protect their pocketbook. Since youth rely on entry level jobs when they enter the workforce, we feel tying costs to an hour of minimum wage labour is the best way to measure a city’s affordability from a youth perspective. And the fact that it’s within the legislative reach of many of the municipalities in our Index to increase wages only adds to the impact of this factor. Measuring it this way, we look at affordability from both a cost perspective, as well as from an entry- level income perspective. Both sides of the coin, we feel, are necessary to accurately state how reasonably priced life in any given city is.
  • 6. 10 11 11. Chicago 12. Osaka 13. Montreal 14. New York City 15. Washington 16. Miami 17. Boston 18. Dallas 19. Amsterdam 20. London 21. Hong Kong 22. Seoul 23. Rome 24. Madrid 25. Singapore 26. Shanghai 27. Tel Aviv 28. Warsaw 29. Karachi 30. Quito 31. Santiago 32. Istanbul 33. Jakarta 34. Manila 35. Buenos Aires 36. Durban 37. Lima 38. Dubai 39. Johannesburg 40. Bangkok 41. Rio De Janeiro 42. Bogota 43. Sao Paulo 44. Casablanca 45. Cairo 46. Moscow 47. Beirut 48. New Delhi 49. Nairobi 50. Mumbai 51. Mexico City 52. Lagos 53. Dar Es Salaam 54. Accra 55. Caracas 11. New York City 12. Osaka 13. Chicago 14. Washington 15. Detroit 16. Miami 17. Boston 18. Rome 19. London 20. Dallas 21. Tel Aviv 22. Madrid 23. Seoul 24. Singapore 25. Hong Kong 26. Buenos Aires 27. Shanghai 28. Warsaw 29. Santiago 30. Istanbul 31. Rio De Janeiro 32. Sao Paulo 33. Tehran 34. Quito 35. Bogota 36. Dubai 37. Casablanca 38. Jakarta 39. Lima 40. Beirut 41. Durban 42. Johannesburg 43. Manila 44. Bangkok 45. Moscow 46. Cairo 47. Nairobi 48. Lagos 49. New Delhi 50. Mexico City 51. Caracas 52. Karachi 53. Mumbai 54. Accra 55. Dar Es Salaam
  • 7. 12 13 11. Karachi 12. Los Angeles 13. Paris 14. Vancouver 15. New York City 16. Washington 17. Boston 18. Madrid 19. San Francisco 20. Berlin 21. Lima 22. Tel Aviv 23. London 24. Rome 25. Singapore 26. Seoul 27. Rio De Janeiro 28. Shanghai 29. Buenos Aires 30. Quito 31. Hong Kong 32. Casablanca 33. Warsaw 34. Istanbul 35. Sao Paulo 36. Manila 37. Santiago 38. Bogota 39. Jakarta 40. Dubai 41. Durban 42. New Delhi 43. Moscow 44. Tehran 45. Cairo 46. Bangkok 47. Johannesburg 48. Mumbai 49. Nairobi 50. Beirut 51. Lagos 52. Mexico City 53. Dar Es Salaam 54. Accra 55. Caracas 11. New York City 12. London 13. Miami 14. Rome 15. San Francisco 16. Amsterdam 17. Madrid 18. Washington 19. Boston 20. Tokyo 21. Vancouver 22. Seoul 23. Rio De Janeiro 24. Singapore 25. Sao Paulo 26. Hong Kong 27. Tel Aviv 28. Warsaw 29. Durban 30. Bogota 31. Johannesburg 32. Shanghai 33. Buenos Aires 34. Jakarta 35. Quito 36. Santiago 37. Istanbul 38. Casablanca 39. Cairo 40. Karachi 41. New Delhi 42. Manila 43. Bangkok 44. Nairobi 45. Lima 46. Dubai 47. Moscow 48. Beirut 49. Tehran 50. Mumbai 51. Mexico City 52. Lagos 53. Dar Es Salaam 54. Caracas 55. Accra
  • 8. 14 15 11. Los Angeles 12. Boston 13. Paris 14. Rome 15. Chicago 16. New York City 17. London 18. Osaka 19. Tokyo 20. Washington 21. Tel Aviv 22. Madrid 23. Seoul 24. Hong Kong 25. Warsaw 26. Shanghai 27. Santiago 28. Singapore 29. Karachi 30. Johannesburg 31. Rio De Janeiro 32. Buenos Aires 33. Durban 34. Jakarta 35. Quito 36. Bogota 37. Istanbul 38. Tehran 39. Sao Paulo 40. Casablanca 41. Lima 42. Manila 43. New Delhi 44. Dubai 45. Bangkok 46. Beirut 47. Cairo 48. Nairobi 49. Mumbai 50. Mexico City 51. Moscow 52. Lagos 53. Dar Es Salaam 54. Accra 55. Caracas 11. Karachi 12. New York City 13. Dallas 14. Detroit 15. Vancouver 16. Los Angeles 17. San Francisco 18. Boston 19. Montreal 20. Miami 21. Chicago 22. Washington 23. Amsterdam 24. Berlin 25. Madrid 26. Toronto 27. Jakarta 28. London 29. Rome 30. Tel Aviv 31. Dubai 32. Cairo 33. Seoul 34. Hong Kong 35. Buenos Aires 36. Istanbul 37. Singapore 38. New Delhi 39. Shanghai 40. Sao Paulo 41. Tokyo 42. Osaka 43. Mumbai 44. Bangkok 45. Warsaw 46. Rio De Janeiro 47. Bogota 48. Mexico City 49. Johannesburg 50. Lima 51. Nairobi 52. Dar Es Salaam 53. Lagos 54. Accra 55. Caracas
  • 9. 1716 11. Rome 12. Chicago 13. Dallas 14. Los Angeles 15. Boston 16. Washington 17. Amsterdam 18. New York City 19. Tel Aviv 20. Madrid 21. Seoul 22. Tokyo 23. Osaka 24. Singapore 25. London 26. Quito 27. Hong Kong 28. Buenos Aires 29. Warsaw 30. Jakarta 31. Bogota 32. Santiago 33. Istanbul 34. Durban 35. Manila 36. Lima 37. Rio De Janeiro 38. Sao Paulo 39. Shanghai 40. Casablanca 41. Bangkok 42. Johannesburg 43. Karachi 44. Cairo 45. Dubai 46. Nairobi 47. New Delhi 48. Beirut 49. Mexico City 50. Mumbai 51. Moscow 52. Lagos 53. Dar Es Salaam 54. Accra 55. Caracas 11. Tehran 12. Amsterdam 13. Madrid 14. Los Angeles 15. Paris 16. Rome 17. Washington 18. Tel Aviv 19. Tokyo 20. Boston 21. San Francisco 22. Seoul 23. New York City 24. Buenos Aires 25. London 26. Warsaw 27. Quito 28. Istanbul 29. Santiago 30. Cairo 31. Karachi 32. Shanghai 33. Lima 34. Casablanca 35. Durban 36. New Delhi 37. Sao Paulo 38. Johannesburg 39. Bogota 40. Singapore 41. Manila 42. Rio De Janeiro 43. Bangkok 44. Jakarta 45. Beirut 46. Hong Kong 47. Dubai 48. Nairobi 49. Mumbai 50. Mexico City 51. Moscow 52. Lagos 53. Dar Es Salaam 54. Caracas 55. Accra
  • 10. 19 City Minimum wage (USD 2014) Consumption tax rate GINI Coefficient† Cost of rental housing* Cost of one prepaid cellular minute* Cost of 12 eggs* Cost of monthly transit pass Price per square meter to buy an apartment* Cost of a tube of toothpaste* Standing rate for a taxi* Cost of a movie ticket* Cost of a fast food meal* Cost of 1 month of gym membership in business district* Cost of 1 pair of sport shoes (Nike, Adidas, or similar)* Accra 453.85 0.37 15% 0.43 10805.24 0.48 10.94 131.05 4392.79 30.89 19.77 26.00 26.42 382.78 388.17 Amsterdam 1029.64 9.28 21% 0.34 255.68 0.05 0.37 12.88 739.88 0.34 0.40 1.51 1.01 5.80 12.80 Bangkok 960.38 1.22 7% 0.40 1046.91 0.17 2.05 26.72 3059.59 1.95 0.94 4.85 3.96 73.81 83.89 Beirut 859.84 1.40 10% 0.86 1159.45 0.23 2.95 59.32 2.88 2.46 0.00 7.16 6.41 74.32 83.75 Berlin 1067.44 11.29 19% 0.28 131.15 0.01 0.46 9.35 414.99 0.15 0.40 0.94 0.77 3.97 11.41 Bogota 938.54 1.72 16% 0.54 988.55 0.08 1.39 27.79 1203.10 0.80 1.05 3.14 4.03 35.53 51.89 Boston 1063.35 8.00 6% 0.48 379.75 0.07 0.42 3.25 369.43 0.38 0.33 1.49 0.90 8.40 10.68 Buenos Aires 973.52 3.44 21% 0.37 476.72 0.15 0.91 9.52 185.66 1.01 0.64 2.91 3.09 31.89 69.40 Cairo 984.49 0.91 10% 0.31 698.70 0.08 2.03 20.63 939.96 1.49 0.56 5.69 5.83 79.75 113.46 Caracas 319.73 0.53 12% 0.39 9361.79 0.69 34.27 18.69 581.49 29.33 24.92 28.04 85.67 1345.87 1370.64 Casablanca 961.38 1.47 13% 0.41 794.71 0.22 0.98 15.52 1604.59 1.41 0.14 4.73 4.17 50.41 56.08 Chicago 1046.10 8.25 9% 0.47 241.89 0.12 0.29 10.91 396.96 0.22 0.39 1.43 0.81 10.43 10.80 Dallas 1054.08 7.25 8.25% 0.46 212.70 0.08 0.31 5.52 277.14 0.29 0.31 1.44 0.92 5.46 11.87 Dar Es Salaam 569.85 0.26 18% 0.39 8732.45 1.03 8.31 128.22 798.08 6.85 6.92 23.08 18.46 334.94 497.69 Detroit 1074.59 8.15 6% 0.47 191.66 0.02 0.27 5.77 102.53 0.24 0.31 1.18 0.76 4.11 9.60 Dubai 992.91 1.56 0% 0.30 1590.69 0.13 1.60 38.40 3294.28 2.25 0.52 6.38 3.82 66.95 78.76 Durban 922.44 1.38 14% 0.72 813.62 0.15 1.61 18.24 658.15 0.78 0.00 3.93 3.49 32.28 52.76 Hong Kong 995.19 3.87 0% 0.54 1388.59 0.06 0.95 19.32 6754.32 0.75 0.63 2.81 1.16 18.74 24.35 Istanbul 956.92 2.47 18% 0.40 541.33 0.10 1.18 32.17 1225.95 1.33 0.68 3.34 2.84 36.72 35.92 Jakarta 975.70 1.47 10% 0.38 1086.30 0.17 1.39 20.86 2426.15 1.10 0.48 2.98 2.92 35.11 60.86 Johannesburg 900.43 1.38 14% 0.60 968.12 0.11 2.18 58.96 940.22 0.90 2.44 4.89 3.91 29.12 62.63 Karachi 915.97 0.52 23% 0.30 730.26 0.37 0.37 28.80 1942.41 1.49 0.29 5.10 2.24 27.85 17.70 Lagos 877.87 0.71 5% 0.49 3139.65 0.24 3.20 2.22 641.20 4.11 10.65 13.31 12.91 172.02 93.33 Lima 986.66 1.47 5% 0.45 777.22 0.12 0.50 7.42 1505.65 2.20 3.84 4.13 3.58 52.39 69.87 London 1010.32 7.85 20% 0.34 487.20 0.03 0.57 20.81 1942.30 0.32 0.48 2.30 1.09 11.19 12.86 Los Angeles 1057.79 9.00 9% 0.49 266.13 0.07 0.37 4.78 520.49 0.21 0.32 1.45 0.75 6.00 9.14 Madrid 1011.51 6.24 21% 0.33 264.71 0.06 0.42 11.44 764.46 0.34 0.43 1.85 1.49 14.12 15.06 18 *Raw data supplied by expatistan.com † GINI coefficient is a standard economic measure of income inequality. Its range is between 0 (per fect equality) and 1 (total inequality). F I N A L D ATA All cost values below refer to the number of hours of work at the city’s minimum wage that it takes to purchase the given item.
  • 11. 20 City Minimum wage (USD 2014) Consumption tax rate GINI Coefficient† Cost of rental housing* Cost of one prepaid cellular minute* Cost of 12 eggs* Cost of monthly transit pass Price per square meter to buy an apartment* Cost of a tube of toothpaste* Standing rate for a taxi* Cost of a movie ticket* Cost of a fast food meal* Cost of 1 month of gym membership in business district* Cost of 1 pair of sport shoes (Nike, Adidas, or similar)* Manila 958.55 1.29 12% 0.43 1036.81 0.13 1.34 44.01 3013.48 1.87 0.06 4.07 2.96 56.24 68.61 Mexico City 840.92 0.57 16% 0.48 2649.71 0.29 3.71 6.99 451.28 3.67 1.20 9.00 9.73 141.97 150.87 Miami 1051.99 8.05 7% 0.50 251.79 0.11 0.34 4.76 367.00 0.32 0.37 1.41 0.88 5.38 10.60 Montreal 1082.84 10.05 10% 0.36 161.43 0.05 0.35 44.69 177.33 0.18 0.33 1.16 0.83 5.18 11.02 Moscow 881.42 1.21 18% 0.52 2678.37 0.04 1.86 43.74 16617.03 2.31 0.18 9.39 6.36 161.73 120.39 Mumbai 837.21 0.43 12.36% 0.34 2330.67 0.04 2.34 56.62 1547.11 2.85 0.84 9.34 8.72 134.02 123.78 Nairobi 908.72 0.90 15% 0.34 1659.47 0.06 2.71 12.41 5013.44 2.17 3.93 6.93 7.64 92.29 60.62 New Delhi 952.24 0.62 13% 0.34 837.73 0.03 1.72 13.31 1171.96 1.58 0.69 6.98 6.68 60.96 115.72 New York City 1043.52 8.75 8.88% 0.51 461.67 0.05 0.40 9.53 692.97 0.31 0.29 1.57 0.86 10.68 9.15 Osaka 1062.27 8.39 8% 0.42 226.57 0.05 0.31 6.84 989.77 0.30 0.83 2.09 0.82 11.43 8.45 Paris 1060.60 12.52 20% 0.32 276.48 0.03 0.39 8.67 610.33 0.27 0.21 1.05 0.78 8.60 10.54 Quito 1001.85 2.13 12% 0.42 516.43 0.07 0.93 34.31 2253.05 1.15 0.16 2.35 2.48 35.42 52.56 Rio De Janeiro 898.66 2.31 19% 0.52 1040.81 0.34 0.89 5.83 1568.14 0.63 0.96 4.34 4.00 31.42 72.45 Rome 996.84 7.97 22% 0.49 284.64 0.02 0.60 7.24 827.99 0.33 0.50 1.41 1.22 9.44 14.47 San Francisco 1068.75 11.05 8.50% 0.48 386.90 0.05 0.43 26.92 886.50 0.33 0.32 1.17 0.64 5.58 7.73 Santiago 944.33 2.53 19% 0.49 559.91 0.13 1.36 37.10 1885.77 1.17 0.20 3.24 2.69 24.18 27.58 Sao Paulo 900.33 2.31 18.50% 0.56 857.97 0.27 1.27 11.16 2355.25 0.70 0.82 4.60 4.04 44.69 61.08 Seoul 1035.08 4.46 10% 0.31 439.32 0.06 0.79 11.77 3356.80 0.61 0.61 1.88 1.17 16.77 21.79 Shanghai 987.10 2.75 11.60% 0.37 763.10 0.09 0.90 23.99 4868.49 1.00 0.76 4.69 1.82 21.20 46.55 Singapore 986.57 4.00 7% 0.48 1001.63 0.10 0.62 8.09 672.77 0.65 0.68 2.18 1.49 26.03 30.40 Sydney 1118.97 16.28 10% 0.33 186.72 0.04 0.33 0.00 1167.43 0.24 0.21 1.11 0.51 3.77 7.78 Tehran 1035.90 2.24 4% 0.38 0.03 0.11 1.98 5.54 1205.00 2.63 0.00 1.34 0.00 43.93 125.38 Tel Aviv 1039.32 6.41 13% 0.37 329.38 0.03 0.56 8.38 811.57 0.77 0.50 73.80 1.84 13.26 20.72 Tokyo 1065.09 9.10 8% 0.42 369.40 0.05 0.31 12.00 637.27 0.39 0.82 72.89 0.72 11.44 8.38 Toronto 1053.72 9.95 13% 0.42 228.29 0.05 0.36 10.09 766.27 0.24 0.44 74.71 0.80 5.56 11.56 Vancouver 1050.12 9.95 12% 0.48 233.69 0.03 0.39 8.76 1196.62 0.41 0.31 74.96 0.80 5.42 11.68 Warsaw 975.32 2.66 23% 0.33 509.32 0.03 1.06 21.42 691.50 0.77 0.95 70.26 2.06 20.98 32.38 Washington 1055.87 8.25 5.75% 0.44 326.25 0.11 0.41 73.37 84.07 0.36 0.39 74.35 0.86 12.45 8.75 21 F I N A L D ATA ( C O N T ) All cost values below refer to the number of hours of work at the city’s minimum wage that it takes to purchase the given item. *Raw data supplied by expatistan.com † GINI coefficient is a standard economic measure of income inequality. Its range is between 0 (per fect equality) and 1 (total inequality).
  • 12. 22 23 Y O U T H F U L C I T I E S YouthfulCities is leading a unique urban regeneration. We are building a global network of 15 - to 29-year-olds who dive deep into youth-driven urban knowledge to create far-reaching inventive solutions from youth outward. And, we are illuminating youthful stories around the world. This leads to the 100 biggest cities and their almost one billion inhabitants becoming more connected, dynamic, open, fun, curious, and inventive – In other words, more youthful cities. It’s a bold direction for a social enterprise that’s only two years old. But we’re not shy about it. W H AT I S S U E S D I D W E R U N I N T O ? Problem: Some cities, for example Mumbai, have more than 1000 minimum wages. Solution: We take the average amount across all the given minimum wages in a city. Problem: Not all cities have an agreed upon minimum wage. Solution: For cities without a legislated minimum we take the base wage at a typical entry-level job, for example a fast food restaurant. Problem: The cost of an everyday item like subway fare is relative to the local currency value. Solution: All cost amounts were translated from local currencies into U.S. dollars at the average price between January 2013 and January 2014. Problem: Costs are relative to the local average income level. Solution: Since robust data for average youth income at the city level doesn’t exist, we use minimum wage as our baseline income level. While constructing this and other YouthfulCities Indexes we’ve run into logistical problems. Some are problems inherent to comparing the cost of items between cities, others are specific to establishing minimum wage values for all cities. Here we explain the key hurdles. For more information, contact our Research Director: matthew@youthfulcities.com