Worktrek 2Towards JerusalemJune 2011
ItineraryMon:  Tel Aviv to JerichoTue:  Jericho,  Ramallah,  NablusWed:  Nablus, Sebastia, NazarethThu: Galilee, Capernaum,  NazarethFri:  Galilee, Banyas, Golan, NazarethSat: Bet Sean, Qumran, WildernessSun:  Bethlehem, WildernessMon: BethlehemThe second week was based in Bethlehem, with visits to Herodium, Hebron,  Jerusalem,  Masada,  Engedi, Dead SeaMon:  via YadVashem to Tel Aviv
The WallWeek 2  Monday
UN Resolution 194, Article 11:Resolves that the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date, and that compensation should be paid for the property of those choosing not to return and for loss of or damage to property which, under principles of international law or in equity, should be made good by the Governments or authorities responsible.  Instructs the Conciliation Commission to facilitate the repatriation, resettlement and economic and social rehabilitation of the refugees and the payment of compensation, and to maintain close relations with the Director of the United Nations Relief for Palestine Refugees and, through him, with the appropriate organs and agencies of the United Nations;
Resolution 194Rejected or reinterpreted by IsraelUSA regularly vetoes UN resolutions calling on Israel to act justlyKeys are used as a symbol of the right of returnChannel 4 - “The Promise”
Dheisheh Refugee CampJust south of Bethlehem1948 - Arab-Israeli war1949 - Camp establishedTemporary tent refuge for 3,400 Palestinians from Hebron and 45 villagesNow about 10,000 people in 1 km2 with narrow paved streets and concrete buildings
Dheisheh Refugee CampConnected to mains water and electricityWater is taken by Israel from under Palestinian land and sold to PalestiniansOnly switched on once a monthPalestinian houses all have water tanks on the roofPalestinian families like to live nearby, so they need to build upwards
Dheisheh Refugee CampMany refugees are now third or fourth generationSchools have a shift pattern Class size up to 50 (max)“Sardine rooms”Some houses are not connected to mains sewage, so they use common percolation pits
Dheisheh Refugee Camp6 families in this yard shared 1 WCChildren are taught how to plant trees
Settlement
Road being built for Israeli useISRAELIPALESTINIAN
Tuesday
Herodium
Herod the GreatBorn in 74 BCE‘King of the Jews’ in 40 BCECalled ‘Great’ because of his building and irrigation projects:Caesarea, Masada, Temple MountHeavy taxesRuthless, hated, paranoidSlaughter of innocents in Matthew 2
Herod the Great10 wives – all political15 childrenFavourite wife - MariamneConspired against himKilled her, then regretted it Preserved her in honey
HerodiumNear Tekoa (Amos) on site of Herod’s victory over ParthiansSummer palace and fortressMan-made mountainEarth from nearby mountain was moved to make the fortress look like a hill.
Herodium
Herodium
Travel to HebronBiggest commercial centre in West Bank – pottery and glassVery important in ancient timesCurrently difficult5 Jewish settlements in cityIsrael’s aim – connect them all to another outside the cityStrategy – daily harassment Commercial life almost deadShoppers intimidated, soldiers just watch1500 soldiers for 400 settlers
Hebron
HebronSettlers live above streetThrow rocks and sewage out of windowsChicken wire as protectionEthnic cleansing? City divided into H1 (Palestinian) and H2 (Israeli)
Tomb of the Patriarchs (Mosque)
Tomb of the Patriarchs (Mosque)
Tomb of the Patriarchs (Mosque)
HRCHebron Rehabilitation CommitteeAims to restore buildings and cultureCars are not allowed, so horses and donkeys bring building materials
Wali at HRC Building
Solomon’s PoolsHuge reservoirs – main water source for Jerusalem, Bethlehem and Hebron
Efrata Settlement
Efrata SettlementSouthern West Bank between Bethlehem and HebronPart of a cluster of settlements, known as Gush EtzionPalestinians not allowed inGuarded by armed soldiersLong thin settlement, maximising disruption for Palestinians
Efrat Synagogue
Ardie GoldmanSecular Jewish upbringing in ChicagoBecame an orthodox Jewish ZionistFamily moved to EfratThe land was promised to Abraham and his descendents foreverNothing has changed thatJews have a right and responsibility to claim the landI want to be able to travel to Jinin and order a kosher meal
Early startWednesdayQueue at checkpointTo apply for a work permit, Palestinian men must beover 30married with childrenno record of troubleOnly work for young men:building the wallbuilding settlements
6.30 – Getting light
Holy Land Trust Mission StatementThrough a commitment to the principles of nonviolence, the Holy Land Trust seeks to strengthen and empower the Palestinian community in developing spiritual, pragmatic and strategic approaches that will allow it to resist all forms of oppression and build a future that makes the Holy Land a global model and pillar of understanding, respect, justice, equality and peaceful coexistence.To strengthen international involvement and advocacy in order to achieve this purpose, Holy Land Trust has created unique travel and encounter programs as well as authentic and comprehensive media and news programs.
PICTURE IN THE FOYER
BeitSahour YMCANidal Abu ZulofJoint author of Kairos document calling for an end to occupationPanel of 16 authorsNow endorsed by most churchesJAI – coalition of Christians in Bethlehem areaencourages church groups to engage with peace and justice
Olive Tree CampaignSince 2001 over 500,000 olive trees have been destroyed by settlers and soldiersPlant 8,000 trees per yearFinanced by sponsorship50,000 planted so farEasy way to get involvedVisit in 5 years to see your treeCome and pick olives – see for yourself
Boycott Israeli goodsInternational Court of Justice advised that Israel’s wall is illegalIsrael continues to build itIsrael continues discrimination Israel continues to colonise East Jerusalem & the West BankHundreds of UN resolutions condemn Israel’s actions as illegalAll attempts at negotiation have failedAll that remains is an international boycott of Israeli goods.
Falafel Takeaway
Manger Square
Manger Square
AmalNassar - Tent of Nationshttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_cPS6CznSI4
Journey to JerusalemThursday
Journey to JerusalemThursday
Waiting for Rotan
Rotan
British MandateBritain will look favourably on the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people  without  prejudicing the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine, or of Jews in any other country.1897 Zionism1917 Balfour Declaration1920-1948 British Mandate1936 Arab Revolt against Jewish and British targets1947 UN Partition Proposal
UN Proposals 1947Jewish state (56% of land)Arab state    (42% of land)UN-administered Jerusalem (2%)
UN Proposals 1947Jewish stateArab stateUN-administered Jerusalem“Israel agreed,  Arabs refused”British withdrew 1948Arab-Israeli War 1948:“War of Independence”“the Catastrophe” (al-Nakba)
1948Israel declared independenceTook 78% of the land (UN had proposed 56%)750,000 Palestinian refugees
After 1948Jordan controlled West BankEgypt controlled Gaza StripSyria controlled Golan Heights1950 Jewish Law of ReturnEuropean Jews settled near coast1 m Arab Jews settled near borderPalestinian Refugee Camps in Gaza,  West Bank,  Jordan, etc.
Continuing TensionJordan controlled West BankEgypt controlled Gaza StripSyria controlled Golan Heights1950 Jewish Law of ReturnEuropean Jews came to coast1 m Arab Jews settled near borderPalestinian Refugee Camps in Gaza, West Bank, Jordan, etc.1967 6-day war1970’s  Israeli Black Panthers1990’s            First Intifada
1993 - Oslo AccordIsraeli forces withdraw from Gaza & West BankPLO renounces violencePLO recognised IsraelIsrael recognised PLO5-year interim period1995 – Oslo 2 - ABC
Swiss Cheese MapUSA/Israeli Proposal“Bantustan”Why did PLO sign?
2000 – Camp DavidUSA/Israel proposed interim “bantustan” as the final partition.PLO refused to sign.Israel resorted to force.Second intifadaMassacres by Israeli armyPalestinian suicide bombingsOperation Defensive Shield
Operation Defensive Shield 2002Build Wall
Settlement Master Plans
Settlement blocs
“Greater Jerusalem”Free Gilad
Free Gilad
East Jerusalem
Black Panther TerritoryPoor area settled by Arab (Ashkenazi) Jews1971 Black PanthersUneducated youth protest movementDownfall in 19731977 Likud party spoke to Middle Eastern Jews
Black Panther TerritoryMany joined LikudDisillusionedSHAF party now speaks for middle-Eastern Jews in parliament
Ancient .....
Ancient ..... and Modern
Lunch at the Jerusalem Hotel
AviShushaniCentre for Middle Eastern Classical Music
East Jerusalem250,000 Israelis and 250,000 Palestinians.Palestinians built homes on land leased from Jordanians.After 1967 war, land was controlled by Israel.Many Palestinians evicted or homes demolished.
East JerusalemSmall house shared by 2 Palestinian families.One moved out and their half was occupied by Zionist settlers.
Meeting with Saleh (refugee)
Saleh (refugee)After our house was taken, we started to work with an Israeli peace group.  We met every Friday as a protest.  We think the current Israeli government is racist, and does not want peace.  But at least we have international support for a 2-state solution.  This is important to us.
Saleh (refugee)There is acceleration of taking over spaces in East Jerusalem.Britain has done bad things in the past, but there is now a lot of support from Britain.
Loss of IDRefugees lose their                                                    East Jerusalem ID if they are absent                                                  (have no Jerusalem address) for 3 years.The white building is used as an address for absent refugees.
$2 million offer – stay or sell?
Next doorMany nearby houses were knocked down within hours of people moving out.
Meeting with Hamas leaders
Meeting with Hamas leadersElected to parliament in 2006Israel did not respect the results64 arrested for links with HamasImprisoned for 3½ years – lost ID2010 – asked to resign from parltI refused – only electorate can askOne recently arrested for living illegally in JerusalemWe took refuge in Red Cross building but we cannot leave the compound
Hamas’ Vision1967 bordersRefugees’ right of returnBUT increasing occupation by settlers, demolition and evictionSO we resist occupation.Is violence OK?  Only against army.Killing by Israel is 10 times killing by Palestinians.No violence by Hamas since 2005.
SabeelFridayEcumenical liberation theology organisationStarted in 1990’sThree aims:Justice by nonviolent resistance : occupation is evilMuslim-Christian reconciliation : Palestinians are one peopleJust and durable peaceYouth programmeWeekly bible study translated into actionChristian project, but Muslims work with usJoint action better than inter-faith dialogue
SabeelYouth Bible Study
SabeelYouth Bible Study
Ready for ActionSabeelYouth Bible Study
ActionSabeelDown to earth instructions in the loo!
Lunch
Jerusalem streets
Jerusalem streets
Order
Chaos
Antonia Fortress
Aglaia
Church of the Holy Sepulchre
Hotel Staff
Building a houseThird floor just startedSecond floor almost finishedFirst floor inhabitedGround floor inhabited
MasadaSaturday
Masada
Masada
Masada
MasadaHerod went to Rome to be made king around 40 BCE.On return he built many citiesMasada was a fortress in case of troubleCaptured by the ZealotsIn Jewish Revolt (66-70 CE) Romans wanted it back.Position made that difficult.
The RampRomans built a ramp using Jewish slaves.Zealots would not stone fellow-Jews.Zealots’ mass death2 women & 5 children were found hiding.Story is in Josephus
Engedi
Dead Sea
SundayBreakfast
Rabbis for Human RightsIn 1948 David Ben-Gurion promised equality for all = call of prophets.On 60th anniversary RHR broadcast this promise, with progress report.We aim to understand the prophets’ writings about justice and peace, and to apply them to human rights and social justice.
ArikAshermanPoll after poll says that both sides want peace, but each thinks that the other doesn’t.All know there is no military solution.Palestinians have a negative view of religious Jews.  HRH can break this stereotype.We work in the courts, with the press, lobbying parliament & direct action.
Mount of Olives
Bread and Wine
The Temple Mount
Monday
YadVashem - Holocaust Museum

Worktrek 2

  • 1.
  • 2.
    ItineraryMon: TelAviv to JerichoTue: Jericho, Ramallah, NablusWed: Nablus, Sebastia, NazarethThu: Galilee, Capernaum, NazarethFri: Galilee, Banyas, Golan, NazarethSat: Bet Sean, Qumran, WildernessSun: Bethlehem, WildernessMon: BethlehemThe second week was based in Bethlehem, with visits to Herodium, Hebron, Jerusalem, Masada, Engedi, Dead SeaMon: via YadVashem to Tel Aviv
  • 3.
  • 5.
    UN Resolution 194,Article 11:Resolves that the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date, and that compensation should be paid for the property of those choosing not to return and for loss of or damage to property which, under principles of international law or in equity, should be made good by the Governments or authorities responsible. Instructs the Conciliation Commission to facilitate the repatriation, resettlement and economic and social rehabilitation of the refugees and the payment of compensation, and to maintain close relations with the Director of the United Nations Relief for Palestine Refugees and, through him, with the appropriate organs and agencies of the United Nations;
  • 6.
    Resolution 194Rejected orreinterpreted by IsraelUSA regularly vetoes UN resolutions calling on Israel to act justlyKeys are used as a symbol of the right of returnChannel 4 - “The Promise”
  • 8.
    Dheisheh Refugee CampJustsouth of Bethlehem1948 - Arab-Israeli war1949 - Camp establishedTemporary tent refuge for 3,400 Palestinians from Hebron and 45 villagesNow about 10,000 people in 1 km2 with narrow paved streets and concrete buildings
  • 9.
    Dheisheh Refugee CampConnectedto mains water and electricityWater is taken by Israel from under Palestinian land and sold to PalestiniansOnly switched on once a monthPalestinian houses all have water tanks on the roofPalestinian families like to live nearby, so they need to build upwards
  • 10.
    Dheisheh Refugee CampManyrefugees are now third or fourth generationSchools have a shift pattern Class size up to 50 (max)“Sardine rooms”Some houses are not connected to mains sewage, so they use common percolation pits
  • 11.
    Dheisheh Refugee Camp6families in this yard shared 1 WCChildren are taught how to plant trees
  • 12.
  • 13.
    Road being builtfor Israeli useISRAELIPALESTINIAN
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
    Herod the GreatBornin 74 BCE‘King of the Jews’ in 40 BCECalled ‘Great’ because of his building and irrigation projects:Caesarea, Masada, Temple MountHeavy taxesRuthless, hated, paranoidSlaughter of innocents in Matthew 2
  • 17.
    Herod the Great10wives – all political15 childrenFavourite wife - MariamneConspired against himKilled her, then regretted it Preserved her in honey
  • 18.
    HerodiumNear Tekoa (Amos)on site of Herod’s victory over ParthiansSummer palace and fortressMan-made mountainEarth from nearby mountain was moved to make the fortress look like a hill.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Travel to HebronBiggestcommercial centre in West Bank – pottery and glassVery important in ancient timesCurrently difficult5 Jewish settlements in cityIsrael’s aim – connect them all to another outside the cityStrategy – daily harassment Commercial life almost deadShoppers intimidated, soldiers just watch1500 soldiers for 400 settlers
  • 22.
  • 23.
    HebronSettlers live abovestreetThrow rocks and sewage out of windowsChicken wire as protectionEthnic cleansing? City divided into H1 (Palestinian) and H2 (Israeli)
  • 24.
    Tomb of thePatriarchs (Mosque)
  • 25.
    Tomb of thePatriarchs (Mosque)
  • 26.
    Tomb of thePatriarchs (Mosque)
  • 27.
    HRCHebron Rehabilitation CommitteeAimsto restore buildings and cultureCars are not allowed, so horses and donkeys bring building materials
  • 28.
    Wali at HRCBuilding
  • 29.
    Solomon’s PoolsHuge reservoirs– main water source for Jerusalem, Bethlehem and Hebron
  • 30.
  • 31.
    Efrata SettlementSouthern WestBank between Bethlehem and HebronPart of a cluster of settlements, known as Gush EtzionPalestinians not allowed inGuarded by armed soldiersLong thin settlement, maximising disruption for Palestinians
  • 32.
  • 33.
    Ardie GoldmanSecular Jewishupbringing in ChicagoBecame an orthodox Jewish ZionistFamily moved to EfratThe land was promised to Abraham and his descendents foreverNothing has changed thatJews have a right and responsibility to claim the landI want to be able to travel to Jinin and order a kosher meal
  • 34.
    Early startWednesdayQueue atcheckpointTo apply for a work permit, Palestinian men must beover 30married with childrenno record of troubleOnly work for young men:building the wallbuilding settlements
  • 37.
  • 40.
    Holy Land TrustMission StatementThrough a commitment to the principles of nonviolence, the Holy Land Trust seeks to strengthen and empower the Palestinian community in developing spiritual, pragmatic and strategic approaches that will allow it to resist all forms of oppression and build a future that makes the Holy Land a global model and pillar of understanding, respect, justice, equality and peaceful coexistence.To strengthen international involvement and advocacy in order to achieve this purpose, Holy Land Trust has created unique travel and encounter programs as well as authentic and comprehensive media and news programs.
  • 41.
  • 42.
    BeitSahour YMCANidal AbuZulofJoint author of Kairos document calling for an end to occupationPanel of 16 authorsNow endorsed by most churchesJAI – coalition of Christians in Bethlehem areaencourages church groups to engage with peace and justice
  • 43.
    Olive Tree CampaignSince2001 over 500,000 olive trees have been destroyed by settlers and soldiersPlant 8,000 trees per yearFinanced by sponsorship50,000 planted so farEasy way to get involvedVisit in 5 years to see your treeCome and pick olives – see for yourself
  • 44.
    Boycott Israeli goodsInternationalCourt of Justice advised that Israel’s wall is illegalIsrael continues to build itIsrael continues discrimination Israel continues to colonise East Jerusalem & the West BankHundreds of UN resolutions condemn Israel’s actions as illegalAll attempts at negotiation have failedAll that remains is an international boycott of Israeli goods.
  • 45.
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 48.
    AmalNassar - Tentof Nationshttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_cPS6CznSI4
  • 49.
  • 50.
  • 51.
  • 52.
  • 54.
    British MandateBritain willlook favourably on the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people without prejudicing the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine, or of Jews in any other country.1897 Zionism1917 Balfour Declaration1920-1948 British Mandate1936 Arab Revolt against Jewish and British targets1947 UN Partition Proposal
  • 55.
    UN Proposals 1947Jewishstate (56% of land)Arab state (42% of land)UN-administered Jerusalem (2%)
  • 56.
    UN Proposals 1947JewishstateArab stateUN-administered Jerusalem“Israel agreed, Arabs refused”British withdrew 1948Arab-Israeli War 1948:“War of Independence”“the Catastrophe” (al-Nakba)
  • 57.
    1948Israel declared independenceTook78% of the land (UN had proposed 56%)750,000 Palestinian refugees
  • 58.
    After 1948Jordan controlledWest BankEgypt controlled Gaza StripSyria controlled Golan Heights1950 Jewish Law of ReturnEuropean Jews settled near coast1 m Arab Jews settled near borderPalestinian Refugee Camps in Gaza, West Bank, Jordan, etc.
  • 59.
    Continuing TensionJordan controlledWest BankEgypt controlled Gaza StripSyria controlled Golan Heights1950 Jewish Law of ReturnEuropean Jews came to coast1 m Arab Jews settled near borderPalestinian Refugee Camps in Gaza, West Bank, Jordan, etc.1967 6-day war1970’s Israeli Black Panthers1990’s First Intifada
  • 60.
    1993 - OsloAccordIsraeli forces withdraw from Gaza & West BankPLO renounces violencePLO recognised IsraelIsrael recognised PLO5-year interim period1995 – Oslo 2 - ABC
  • 61.
    Swiss Cheese MapUSA/IsraeliProposal“Bantustan”Why did PLO sign?
  • 62.
    2000 – CampDavidUSA/Israel proposed interim “bantustan” as the final partition.PLO refused to sign.Israel resorted to force.Second intifadaMassacres by Israeli armyPalestinian suicide bombingsOperation Defensive Shield
  • 63.
  • 64.
  • 65.
  • 66.
  • 67.
  • 68.
  • 69.
    Black Panther TerritoryPoorarea settled by Arab (Ashkenazi) Jews1971 Black PanthersUneducated youth protest movementDownfall in 19731977 Likud party spoke to Middle Eastern Jews
  • 70.
    Black Panther TerritoryManyjoined LikudDisillusionedSHAF party now speaks for middle-Eastern Jews in parliament
  • 71.
  • 72.
  • 73.
    Lunch at theJerusalem Hotel
  • 74.
    AviShushaniCentre for MiddleEastern Classical Music
  • 75.
    East Jerusalem250,000 Israelisand 250,000 Palestinians.Palestinians built homes on land leased from Jordanians.After 1967 war, land was controlled by Israel.Many Palestinians evicted or homes demolished.
  • 76.
    East JerusalemSmall houseshared by 2 Palestinian families.One moved out and their half was occupied by Zionist settlers.
  • 77.
  • 78.
    Saleh (refugee)After ourhouse was taken, we started to work with an Israeli peace group. We met every Friday as a protest. We think the current Israeli government is racist, and does not want peace. But at least we have international support for a 2-state solution. This is important to us.
  • 79.
    Saleh (refugee)There isacceleration of taking over spaces in East Jerusalem.Britain has done bad things in the past, but there is now a lot of support from Britain.
  • 80.
    Loss of IDRefugeeslose their East Jerusalem ID if they are absent (have no Jerusalem address) for 3 years.The white building is used as an address for absent refugees.
  • 81.
    $2 million offer– stay or sell?
  • 82.
    Next doorMany nearbyhouses were knocked down within hours of people moving out.
  • 83.
  • 84.
    Meeting with HamasleadersElected to parliament in 2006Israel did not respect the results64 arrested for links with HamasImprisoned for 3½ years – lost ID2010 – asked to resign from parltI refused – only electorate can askOne recently arrested for living illegally in JerusalemWe took refuge in Red Cross building but we cannot leave the compound
  • 85.
    Hamas’ Vision1967 bordersRefugees’right of returnBUT increasing occupation by settlers, demolition and evictionSO we resist occupation.Is violence OK? Only against army.Killing by Israel is 10 times killing by Palestinians.No violence by Hamas since 2005.
  • 86.
    SabeelFridayEcumenical liberation theologyorganisationStarted in 1990’sThree aims:Justice by nonviolent resistance : occupation is evilMuslim-Christian reconciliation : Palestinians are one peopleJust and durable peaceYouth programmeWeekly bible study translated into actionChristian project, but Muslims work with usJoint action better than inter-faith dialogue
  • 87.
  • 88.
  • 89.
  • 90.
    ActionSabeelDown to earthinstructions in the loo!
  • 91.
  • 98.
  • 99.
  • 101.
  • 102.
  • 103.
  • 104.
  • 105.
    Church of theHoly Sepulchre
  • 108.
  • 109.
    Building a houseThirdfloor just startedSecond floor almost finishedFirst floor inhabitedGround floor inhabited
  • 110.
  • 111.
  • 112.
  • 114.
  • 116.
    MasadaHerod went toRome to be made king around 40 BCE.On return he built many citiesMasada was a fortress in case of troubleCaptured by the ZealotsIn Jewish Revolt (66-70 CE) Romans wanted it back.Position made that difficult.
  • 117.
    The RampRomans builta ramp using Jewish slaves.Zealots would not stone fellow-Jews.Zealots’ mass death2 women & 5 children were found hiding.Story is in Josephus
  • 118.
  • 119.
  • 121.
  • 122.
    Rabbis for HumanRightsIn 1948 David Ben-Gurion promised equality for all = call of prophets.On 60th anniversary RHR broadcast this promise, with progress report.We aim to understand the prophets’ writings about justice and peace, and to apply them to human rights and social justice.
  • 123.
    ArikAshermanPoll after pollsays that both sides want peace, but each thinks that the other doesn’t.All know there is no military solution.Palestinians have a negative view of religious Jews. HRH can break this stereotype.We work in the courts, with the press, lobbying parliament & direct action.
  • 124.
  • 128.
  • 129.
  • 136.
  • 139.