1. What Do Actual Visitors To Dealership Web Sites Have To Say?
By Ralph Paglia
Since starting my role at ADP Dealer Services about a year ago, I have been contacted by several
people who worked with me in the past. I worked with Rudy Martin at Reynolds and Reynolds and he
is now vice president of The Intellimark Group, which supplies a variety of products and services to
dealerships throughout North America. Rudy contacted me about a survey Intellimark had aggregated
from data collected in over 5,000 completed questionnaires submitted by dealer web site visitors.
These were consumers who had visited the web sites of dealerships served by Rudy’s company,
Intellimark Group. After discussing the aggregated survey results, Rudy agreed to collaborate with me
on this article to explore insights gained.
Let’s take a look at some of the charts and graphs which show the aggregated survey answers from
over 5,000 dealer web site visitors… One of the more interesting results comes from when dealer web
site visitors were asked how soon they would be buying their next vehicle. Their responses to the
“how soon” question is shown in chart #1 below:
Chart #1: IN-MARKET VEHICLE PURCHASE TIMING
DEALER WEB SITE VISITORS - ALL CUSTOMER SEGMENTS
45.0% 41.1%
40.0% 67% OF ALL SURVEYS INDICATED A PLANNED PURCHASE WITHIN 90 DAYS.
62% OF THOSE PLANNED TO PURCHASE WITHIN 30 DAYS.
35.0%
30.0%
25.0%
17.4%
20.0% 15.3% 15.8%
15.0% 10.4%
10.0%
5.0%
0.0%
Within 30 days Within 60 days Within 90 days Within 3 - 6 months Within 6 - 12 months
For Internet Sales Specialists and Managers who have been working with a mix of dealer web site
generated leads and leads from other sources, this comes as no surprise. The Survey data validates the
experience of most dealerships in finding that Internet leads coming in from their own web sites result
in vehicle sales at a far higher rate than Internet leads from 3rd party lead producers and aggregators.
If you are like me, when a customer says they will be buying a vehicle in the near future, one of the
first things you want to know if there is a trade-in involved. In trying not to be overly transparent as to
your concern over the customer’s trade-in situation, you might ask the question in this type of format:
“Will you be replacing a vehicle, or adding another vehicle to what you currently own?” The dealer

2. web site visitors who answered the “how soon” question responded to the replacement or trade-in
question as shown in the next illustration, which is chart #2:
Chart #2: VEHICLE REPLACEMENT OR ACQUISITION PURCHASE DRIVERS
Undecided
11%
Additional
22%
Replacement
67%
What the above chart goes to show is that visitors to dealership web sites who are in the market for a
vehicle are highly likely (67%) to be interested in the value of the vehicle they are replacing as a trade-
in. Although some of these people may intend to sell or otherwise dispose of their current vehicle,
there would still be a desire to see an estimated value. This helps to prove the value proposition of the
industry’s two leading dealer web site trade-in evaluation tools, Kelley Blue Book’s LeadDriver and
Black Book Online.
So… What are these wonderful dealer web site sales prospects considering for their next vehicle
purchase? Aggregating the surveys shows that almost half of them say (before they buy) that they are
interested in a new vehicle. However, of the 51% that did not indicate an interest in a new vehicle,
16% of them are undecided, or what I like to describe as “open minded”. Their actual purchase will be
based upon situational opportunity factors including price and availability. Chart #3 is shown below
and shows dealer web site visitor responses to the question about what type of vehicle they plan to buy
next:

3. Chart #3: VEHICLE PURCHASE INTEREST
Undecided Certified Pre-Owned
16% 19%
Pre-Owned
16%
New
49%
With over 35% of dealer web site visitors saying that they intend to buy a pre-owned vehicle as their
next purchase, and 51% stating right up front that they are not interested in a new vehicle for their next
purchase, it makes sense to consider putting an emphasis on used vehicle specials as featured content
on dealership web sites. With so much emphasis and effort being made on competing in the hyper-
competitive new vehicle sales arena, this data suggests that an equal amount of effort in using dealer
web sites to promote used vehicles may yield a higher return. With used vehicles being somewhat
more unique, and less of a commodity than new vehicles, the argument for featuring and promoting
used vehicles on dealer web sites gets even stronger when reviewing the survey data.
Despite the software based tracking metrics that most digital marketing professionals use, it is
interesting to see what answers you get when simply asking dealer web site visitors how they found
the dealer’s web site. The answers received on the surveys show a different makeup than what we
usually see when looking at Omniture SiteCatalyst or WebTrends reports for dealer web site visitors.
Take a look at chart #4 below and consider the differences between what “stimulated” a consumer’s
search for a dealer’s web site and the technology they chose to get there:

4. Chart #4: SOURCE OF DEALER WEB SITE VISITORS
SURVEY RESPONDENTS - ALL CUSTOMER SEGMENTS
Direct Mail eBay Motors
2% 1%
Friend/Neighbor
Current Customer
10%
17%
Google
or other search engine
TV/Cable 14%
13%
Manufacturer Website
13%
Other
16%
Radio
7%
Newspaper Advertisement
6%
The dealer web site visitor responses aggregated into chart #4 shows there is a very real opportunity to
drive more traffic into dealership web sites using integrated marketing campaigns. Integrated
Marketing campaigns are those that include both conventional media and online digital marketing.
Despite the current situation of few dealers focusing on using advertising to specifically drive
customers to their web sites, 44% of the Intellimark Surveyed dealer web site visitors indicated they
got there as a result of dealership advertising in non-digital conventional media sources such as TV,
Radio, Newspaper and direct mail. What is glaring to me is the low percentage (14%) of dealership
web site visitors who got there using search engines… These results indicate there are significant areas
of opportunity for dealer web site traffic growth using Search Engine Marketing (SEM) and Digital
Advertising Campaigns.
When we break down the aggregated data from these Surveys within categories of those who say they
intend to get a new vehicle, versus those who intend to get a used vehicle, or are undecided (open
minded), we get a clearer picture of what is important to each type. For example, among those that
indicated they intend to buy a used vehicle, or are open minded about their next vehicle purchase, we
wanted to see what vehicle type they were most likely to consider. Understanding buyer intentions
helps to guide us on what to feature in our online specials and when we advertise on other web sites to
attract more traffic. In chart #5, we see that almost 40% were looking for passenger cars… And, over
40% were looking for SUV and Sport or Specialty vehicles. I was surprised to see that only 7.9% of
the used car buyers were looking for pickup trucks. Chart #5 is shown below:

5. Chart #5: VEHICLE OF INTEREST
(PRE-OWNED & UNDECIDED)
39.8%
40.0%
Purchase interest in light-duty trucks
(Pickups, SUVs & Minivans) was nearly
35.0% equal to that of passenger cars.
30.0% 28.5%
25.0%
20.0%
15.0%
12.1%
10.0% 7.9%
6.8%
5.0%
2.8%
1.6%
0.5%
0.0%
Commercial Light Duty Luxury Mini Van Passenger Car Passenger Sport or SUV
Vehicle Truck Van Speciality
The high interest in used passenger cars shown in chart #5 may have been influenced by the last 3
years of sustained high gas prices. Used vehicle demand may be a leading indicator of what will sell
on the new car lot. This survey result also shows why the domestic auto industry’s continued emphasis
on trucks and SUV’s is not generating the level of interest we experienced prior to 2005.
So, what is most important to these used car buyers visiting dealer web sites? The aggregated survey
results from over 5,000 visitors to dealership web sites shows that price and payment is still king with
pre-owned buyers. With fuel economy rising to third place in importance and overtaking the previous
perennial favorite, vehicle safety. In chart #6, we see what the dealer web site visitor who is either
undecided on new versus used, or wants a used vehicle, says are the most important decision criteria
used to determine the actual vehicle they will end up buying:

6. Chart #6: VEHICLE PURCHASE DECISION "HOT BUTTONS"
(PRE-OWNED & UNDECIDED)
40.0% 38.4%
Inspite of the high cost of gas, Fuel Economy
placed a distant 3rd to monthly payment and
total selling price with the Pre-owned and
35.0%
Undecided segments.
30.0% 28.3%
25.0%
20.0%
14.4%
15.0%
10.0%
6.5%
5.0%
5.0% 3.9%
2.8%
0.8%
0.0%
Fuel Economy Immediate Monthly Other Total Selling Trade-In Value Vehicle Styling Vehicle
Availability Payment Price Warranty
In Chart #6 we see that the most effective advertising may be that which features monthly payments,
followed by selling price… I know, very few of you are surprised. So, why do we continue to place
advertisements intended to drive traffic to dealer web sites that do not feature payments, price or even
fuel economy? I was guilty of thinking availability was a key factor, as in the outdoor advertisement
shown in the image below:

7. Looking at the results of these Intellimark Surveys, it is no longer a mystery why the ad shown below
seemed to drive so many more web site visitors and phone calls than the “Largest Inventory”
advertising campaigns:
These considerations, what to advertise and which message will get the most attention are the
questions best answered by surveys such as what Intellimark Group has put together. After all, if the
message doesn’t hit the car shopper’s hot spots, then it won’t get their attention amidst all the media
clutter that is out there today.
Which brings me to another interesting insight from this survey research… What are the most
significant factors in deciding what type of vehicle to buy and when to pull the trigger? Of course, this
is based on what car shoppers say is important… Anyone who has sold cars long enough will tell you
that how buyers act is often different than what they say. Still, there is a lot of value in studying what
car shoppers believe are the reasons they will decide on a particular vehicle or deal. With that said,
there are a lot of differences in what motivates vehicle buyers depending on the vehicle type they are
considering. So let’s take a look at chart #7 which shows the considerations that dealer web site
visitors reported when asked what factors would determine what, where and when they would make
their next vehicle purchase. These responses were aggregated and then segmented by the specific
vehicle types the buyers said they were looking for. Chart #7 breaks down vehicle purchase
consideration factors by type of vehicle the dealer web site visitor reported as being their primary
vehicle of interest:

8. Chart #7: Vehicle Purchase Consideration Factors
100% 0.0% 0.0%
1.4% 0.0% 0.0% 0.3% 0.8% 1.8%
3.7% 3.1%
9.1% 7.6% 4.1% Vehicle
10.0% 3.7% 4.9%
Warranty
90% 5.0% 10.4%
6.1% 25.0%
Vehicle
80% 25.7% Styling
33.3% 13.1%
50.0% 0.0% 24.4%
70% 37.1% 31.8% Trade-In
5.9% Value
2.9%
25.0%
60%
10.9% Total Selling
7.4% Price
3.0%
50%
7.1%
7.1% Other
40.8% 46.2%
40%
31.8% 35.3% Monthly
30% 30.0% 44.4% Payment
28.6%
50.0%
1.8%
20% Immediate
5.0% Availability
4.5% 2.5%
0.0%
5.7% 20.5%
10%
14.3% 13.6% 13.4% 13.6% Fuel
8.6% 3.7% Economy
3.7%
0% 0.0%
Commercial Light Duty Luxury Mini Van Passenger Passenger Sport or SUV
Vehicle Truck Car Van Speciality
It is interesting to note that once again, monthly payments and vehicle selling price are the two most
important criteria. Fuel economy is more significant than at any time since the Arab Oil Embargoes of
a generation ago, especially for passenger car and commercial vehicle buyers. Surprising to me,
coming from a vehicle sales background, is the low level of importance placed on vehicle styling. Of
course, once again I would like to remind readers that these are what car shoppers “say” is most
important and how they actually end up buying may or may not correlate to what they said before they
make their purchase… But, this still shows us what these visitors to dealer web sites report as being
most important and what will get their attention more effectively than ads or specials focused on other
criteria.
One of the many factors to consider when looking at these survey results is that these are shoppers
who are very deep into the sales process funnel. As indicated in chart #1, these are people who will be
buying a vehicle fairly soon and may have already gone through the process of determining what type
of vehicle they will be getting next. For these reasons, the degree of importance placed on price and
payments may be far more significant than people further away from their next vehicle purchase, who
have not yet determined the type, make or model they are most interested in. After all, when
interviewing people who have already found your dealership’s web site, how likely would it be that
they have already decided on a make and model and are now looking for the right deal, salesperson,
convenience and financing terms? The results of this Intellimark Survey of dealership web site
visitors may not be too surprising to many people, but they do confirm that most dealerships are better
served by generating more visitors to their store’s web sites.
When considering the ways we can most effectively drive traffic to dealership web sites, it is highly
logical to look at what consumers who have already visited dealer web sites find most important to
them… Then we can use those most important criteria as a means of deciding what is most likely to

9. work in trying to get more of an already good thing; the car shoppers that visit our dealership’s web
sites. These aggregated survey results are all the more significant because of the sheer size of the
sample… 5,000 dealer web site visitors is highly significant from a statistical perspective. There are
many ways to interpret and act upon these results, but one plan of action should be strikingly clear.
The use of integrated marketing campaigns that use a mixed blend of media such as TV, Radio,
Outdoor, geotargeted search engine and display advertising on web sites… This is what works in
driving the most valuable leads we can generate. The leads and phone calls coming from visitors to
our own dealership web sites.
Editor’s notes: Ralph Paglia is the Director of Digital Marketing for ADP Dealer Services and can be
reached by email at ralph_paglia@adp.com or by phone at 505-301-6369. Rudy Martin is Vice
President and General Manager of the Intellimark Group, a division of Rocket City Automotive
Group, Inc. and can be reached by email at rmartin@imarkpro.com or by phone at 407-219-3636.