SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
Download to read offline
2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail
Page 1 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/
GLOBE EDITORIAL
Vancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads
The Globe and Mail
Published Tuesday, Jun. 17, 2014 6:30PM EDT
Last updated Tuesday, Jun. 17, 2014 6:30PM EDT
Twenty out of 21 mayors in Metro Vancouver have, remarkably, put their names to a regional-
transportation proposal that includes not only the dreaded word “tolls,” but also the somewhat mysterious
phrase “mobility pricing.”
In any case, one gets the drift. All these elected politicians are in favour of schemes to relieve congestion
and gridlock, which would be partly paid for by drivers in proportion to their actual use of the roads.
Hitherto at least, it would have been very surprising if municipal politicians of the Greater Toronto and
Hamilton Area, or those of Greater Montreal, were to advocate market-based payment for roads. But ideas
can change. Examples can be set.
London – thanks to a socialist mayor, Ken Livingstone – has had a congestion charge since 2003.
Naturally, there was considerable discontent at first, but it is now quite well accepted.
In the mayors’ council proposal for transportation in the Lower Mainland (Derek Corrigan of Burnaby is
the one dissenter), mobility pricing is one element, not the whole $7.5-billion capital-spending plan.
Nonetheless, it is politically courageous.
The Minister of Transportation of British Columbia, Todd Stone, has praised the achievement of
consensus, but has put a damper on any thoughts that the provincial carbon tax would be drawn upon.
Premier Christy Clark had already stipulated for a regional referendum on funding sources for
transportation. And the contribution of the federal government, if any, is unknown.
The mayors’ report never quite defines “mobility pricing,” but their principles are clear enough. They
recognize that more and wider roads are not the solution. They look forward to 2045, when they hope that
commuting distances will be reduced by 24 per cent, “fully three-quarters” of that improvement coming
from “the introduction of time- and distance-based road tolls.”
They are well along on the right track. Let other large Canadian cities follow their lead.
2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail
Page 2 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/
Follow us on Twitter: @GlobeDebate [https://twitter.com/@GlobeDebate]
Next Story
B.C. government must stop hiding the data on house buyers
Tuesday, Nov. 03, 2015 10:39PM EST
Investigators return to Russian plane crash site in Egypt
Tuesday, Nov. 03, 2015 5:52PM EST
Nov. 4: Your daily horoscope
Wednesday, Nov. 04, 2015 12:01AM EST
Share this selection
Tweet
2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail
Page 3 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/
2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail
Page 4 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/
2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail
Page 5 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/
2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail
Page 6 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/
2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail
Page 7 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/
Log in
Don’t have an account? Create one here.
We did not find an account associated with the account below:
Create new account Cancel
With your social account
OR with your email and password
Your email address
Your password Show
Keep me logged in
Trouble logging in?

More Related Content

Similar to Vancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail

Decongesting New York
Decongesting New YorkDecongesting New York
Decongesting New Yorkstreetsblog
 
Moving in a Livable Region - Urban Futures Survey
Moving in a Livable Region - Urban Futures SurveyMoving in a Livable Region - Urban Futures Survey
Moving in a Livable Region - Urban Futures SurveyPlaceSpeak
 
Unequal bus and subway services across New York City's five Boroughs
Unequal bus and subway services across New York City's five BoroughsUnequal bus and subway services across New York City's five Boroughs
Unequal bus and subway services across New York City's five BoroughsAustralian National University
 
Transit - Ridership and Transit Revenue - Canada - May 2018
Transit - Ridership and Transit Revenue - Canada - May 2018Transit - Ridership and Transit Revenue - Canada - May 2018
Transit - Ridership and Transit Revenue - Canada - May 2018paul young cpa, cga
 
Transportation - Pubilshed in San Diego CityBeat
Transportation - Pubilshed in San Diego CityBeatTransportation - Pubilshed in San Diego CityBeat
Transportation - Pubilshed in San Diego CityBeatDana Sargent
 
Transportation Talk with Matt Cole
Transportation Talk with Matt ColeTransportation Talk with Matt Cole
Transportation Talk with Matt ColeMatthew Cole
 
Google CIC 2012 - Transportation Issues
Google CIC 2012 - Transportation IssuesGoogle CIC 2012 - Transportation Issues
Google CIC 2012 - Transportation IssuesDavid Wilson
 
Transportation Planning for Car Free Living: The Evolution of Zurich, Switzer...
Transportation Planning for Car Free Living: The Evolution of Zurich, Switzer...Transportation Planning for Car Free Living: The Evolution of Zurich, Switzer...
Transportation Planning for Car Free Living: The Evolution of Zurich, Switzer...TheLastMile
 
The Best of CityLab's The Future of Transportation
The Best of CityLab's The Future of TransportationThe Best of CityLab's The Future of Transportation
The Best of CityLab's The Future of TransportationThe Rockefeller Foundation
 
Rotary 2015 final 2
Rotary 2015 final 2Rotary 2015 final 2
Rotary 2015 final 2Gordon James
 
Traffic Pollution
Traffic PollutionTraffic Pollution
Traffic PollutionGina Alfaro
 
Bi-County Parkway Presentation
Bi-County Parkway PresentationBi-County Parkway Presentation
Bi-County Parkway Presentationjazztothebone
 
The Rail Line Extension Of The Metro Bus System
The Rail Line Extension Of The Metro Bus SystemThe Rail Line Extension Of The Metro Bus System
The Rail Line Extension Of The Metro Bus SystemAshley Lovato
 

Similar to Vancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail (20)

Decongesting New York
Decongesting New YorkDecongesting New York
Decongesting New York
 
Moving in a Livable Region - Urban Futures Survey
Moving in a Livable Region - Urban Futures SurveyMoving in a Livable Region - Urban Futures Survey
Moving in a Livable Region - Urban Futures Survey
 
Unequal bus and subway services across New York City's five Boroughs
Unequal bus and subway services across New York City's five BoroughsUnequal bus and subway services across New York City's five Boroughs
Unequal bus and subway services across New York City's five Boroughs
 
Transit - Ridership and Transit Revenue - Canada - May 2018
Transit - Ridership and Transit Revenue - Canada - May 2018Transit - Ridership and Transit Revenue - Canada - May 2018
Transit - Ridership and Transit Revenue - Canada - May 2018
 
Transit - Canada - May 2018
Transit -  Canada - May 2018Transit -  Canada - May 2018
Transit - Canada - May 2018
 
Transportation - Pubilshed in San Diego CityBeat
Transportation - Pubilshed in San Diego CityBeatTransportation - Pubilshed in San Diego CityBeat
Transportation - Pubilshed in San Diego CityBeat
 
Transportation Talk with Matt Cole
Transportation Talk with Matt ColeTransportation Talk with Matt Cole
Transportation Talk with Matt Cole
 
Google CIC 2012 - Transportation Issues
Google CIC 2012 - Transportation IssuesGoogle CIC 2012 - Transportation Issues
Google CIC 2012 - Transportation Issues
 
CNUNE Summit Norman Garrick
CNUNE Summit Norman GarrickCNUNE Summit Norman Garrick
CNUNE Summit Norman Garrick
 
State budget 2016
State budget 2016State budget 2016
State budget 2016
 
Transportation Planning for Car Free Living: The Evolution of Zurich, Switzer...
Transportation Planning for Car Free Living: The Evolution of Zurich, Switzer...Transportation Planning for Car Free Living: The Evolution of Zurich, Switzer...
Transportation Planning for Car Free Living: The Evolution of Zurich, Switzer...
 
The Best of CityLab's The Future of Transportation
The Best of CityLab's The Future of TransportationThe Best of CityLab's The Future of Transportation
The Best of CityLab's The Future of Transportation
 
Rotary 2015 final 2
Rotary 2015 final 2Rotary 2015 final 2
Rotary 2015 final 2
 
Final Project
Final ProjectFinal Project
Final Project
 
Tomorrows Way
Tomorrows WayTomorrows Way
Tomorrows Way
 
Traffic Pollution
Traffic PollutionTraffic Pollution
Traffic Pollution
 
Bi-County Parkway Presentation
Bi-County Parkway PresentationBi-County Parkway Presentation
Bi-County Parkway Presentation
 
100 years of transport in Canberra Australia.ppt
100 years of transport in Canberra Australia.ppt100 years of transport in Canberra Australia.ppt
100 years of transport in Canberra Australia.ppt
 
SIDEWALK TALK
SIDEWALK TALKSIDEWALK TALK
SIDEWALK TALK
 
The Rail Line Extension Of The Metro Bus System
The Rail Line Extension Of The Metro Bus SystemThe Rail Line Extension Of The Metro Bus System
The Rail Line Extension Of The Metro Bus System
 

Vancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail

  • 1. 2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail Page 1 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/ GLOBE EDITORIAL Vancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads The Globe and Mail Published Tuesday, Jun. 17, 2014 6:30PM EDT Last updated Tuesday, Jun. 17, 2014 6:30PM EDT Twenty out of 21 mayors in Metro Vancouver have, remarkably, put their names to a regional- transportation proposal that includes not only the dreaded word “tolls,” but also the somewhat mysterious phrase “mobility pricing.” In any case, one gets the drift. All these elected politicians are in favour of schemes to relieve congestion and gridlock, which would be partly paid for by drivers in proportion to their actual use of the roads. Hitherto at least, it would have been very surprising if municipal politicians of the Greater Toronto and Hamilton Area, or those of Greater Montreal, were to advocate market-based payment for roads. But ideas can change. Examples can be set. London – thanks to a socialist mayor, Ken Livingstone – has had a congestion charge since 2003. Naturally, there was considerable discontent at first, but it is now quite well accepted. In the mayors’ council proposal for transportation in the Lower Mainland (Derek Corrigan of Burnaby is the one dissenter), mobility pricing is one element, not the whole $7.5-billion capital-spending plan. Nonetheless, it is politically courageous. The Minister of Transportation of British Columbia, Todd Stone, has praised the achievement of consensus, but has put a damper on any thoughts that the provincial carbon tax would be drawn upon. Premier Christy Clark had already stipulated for a regional referendum on funding sources for transportation. And the contribution of the federal government, if any, is unknown. The mayors’ report never quite defines “mobility pricing,” but their principles are clear enough. They recognize that more and wider roads are not the solution. They look forward to 2045, when they hope that commuting distances will be reduced by 24 per cent, “fully three-quarters” of that improvement coming from “the introduction of time- and distance-based road tolls.” They are well along on the right track. Let other large Canadian cities follow their lead.
  • 2. 2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail Page 2 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/ Follow us on Twitter: @GlobeDebate [https://twitter.com/@GlobeDebate] Next Story B.C. government must stop hiding the data on house buyers Tuesday, Nov. 03, 2015 10:39PM EST Investigators return to Russian plane crash site in Egypt Tuesday, Nov. 03, 2015 5:52PM EST Nov. 4: Your daily horoscope Wednesday, Nov. 04, 2015 12:01AM EST Share this selection Tweet
  • 3. 2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail Page 3 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/
  • 4. 2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail Page 4 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/
  • 5. 2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail Page 5 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/
  • 6. 2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail Page 6 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/
  • 7. 2015-11-03, 9:18 PMVancouver mayors are right to want to price the roads - The Globe and Mail Page 7 of 7http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/vancouver-mayors-are-right-to-want-to-price-the-roads/article19212466/ Log in Don’t have an account? Create one here. We did not find an account associated with the account below: Create new account Cancel With your social account OR with your email and password Your email address Your password Show Keep me logged in Trouble logging in?