SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Regular
Market
Ugly Fruits
Market
Current Scenario. Lets say that we
currently have a fresh produce
market of a total of 100kg of
selected Class I products.
First Effect . An over supplied market will pressure down all
fresh produce prices.
Regular
Market
First Issue:
Does anybody believe that we can
increase demand by 15% from one day
to another?
New Scenario. An over supplied
market = 100kg of selected fresh
produce + 15*kg of Ugly fruits.
Total 115kg.
Summary. There is an excess of 15kg in this new
market and so there is an excess of growers that
produce them. The less efficient growers that
cannot life with the reduced prices will
disappear.
Market with
Ugly Fruits
*Hypothesis. 15
extra kilos of ugly
fruits out of a
production of 100kg
currently sold. Based
on own estimations
of proponents of this
trend (meaning that
currently 10% to
15% of edible but
ugly fruits are
discarded).
15% of the Supply Base will disappear. We can
even assume (almost impossible) that after the
initial oversupply market-shock, prices of Class I
fruits get back to normal.
The total consumption of this new market will
continue to be 100kg. (or a very modest increase
due to the reduced prices; because eating habits do
not change dramatically when prices get reduced but
rather when prices heavily increase)
Summary. So even at best possible scenario (discount price
reduction of 30%), the total size of the market gets
reduced by 4,5%.
100kg x 2€ (Hypothetical Retail
Price) = (200 €)
Size of the Regular Market
Size of Regular
Market (€)
Size of Market
with Ugly Fruits
(€)
*Hypothesis.
Retailers estimate
that Ugly Fruits are
regularly sold at a
discount price
reduction that range
from 30% to 50
85kg x 2€ (Hypothetical
Retail Price)
15kg x 1,40€ (Hypothetical
Retail Price -30%)
Size of market with Ugly
Fruits: 191 €
Following our reasoning, the size of the
market is reduced by 4,5%, but we also
need to address the impact on the Producers’
Turnover taking into consideration all
Supply Chain Costs*.
Summary: Producer’s Turnover gets reduced by 18% .
*Hypothesis. To simplify
calculation we estimate all
Supply Chain Costs together.
According to last available
data, average gross
Producers’ turnover account
for ¼ of Retail Price.
Produce Turnover
Regular Market
Producer Turnover
M. With Ugly Fruits
Supply Chain Costs and
margins: 200€ x ¾ = 150€
Producers’ Turnover:
200€ x 1/4 = 50€
or
200€-150€= 50€
Supply Chain Costs and
margins= 150€ (same costs
and margins in the new market)
Producers’ Turnover:
191€ - 150 = 41€
We are told that this new product
Ugly Fruits niche market
maximize Growers’ Turnover and
Profit by selling all crop and not
only the selected Class I.
As previously seen (see
previous slide) not only
turnover does not increase
but rather reach to a
minimum of 18%. Now
we concentrate on how
profits get impacted.
To review growers’ profits we will
estimate all farming costs at once.
Growers’ Profits
Regular Market
Grower’s Profits
M. with Ugly Fruits
*Hypothesis. To simplify
theoretical Analysis, we
assume a generous 50%
margin (excluding
amortization, interests
and unpaid family labor)
To be able to sell 100kg,
growers produce an excess that
is discarded
(Ugly/Unfit/Deficient).
Kilos Grown (100+15%)=
117,64kg
Growers’ Profits:
50€ (Turnover)-25€ (Costs)=
25€
Unit Costs:
25€/117,64kg=0,20€
We assume growers produce no
excess (use all crop)
Kilos Grown 100kg
We apply same Unit costs :
0,20€/kg
Grower’s Costs:
41€ (Turnover)-20,40€
(Costs)=
20,60€ (-17,60%)
Total Market
(in €) is reduced
by 4,5%
Growers’ Profits get
trimmed by 17,60%
Growers’
turnover is lowered
by 18%
The less efficient growers
representing 15% of the
production are expelled from
the business.
The New Market
with
Ugly Fruits”
“A widespread introduction of a new
segment of ugly fruit and vegetables”
is a complete disaster for farmers in general;
and especially for those who this measure
leaves out of the “ugly fruits” market..
This is good example on how good intentions
(from institutions, retailers and NGOs) can
introduce with this movement perverse
incentives that hinder the improvement and
progress of the efficiency of production
systems.

More Related Content

Similar to Ugly fruits

The NatureView Farm Case Study
The NatureView Farm Case StudyThe NatureView Farm Case Study
The NatureView Farm Case Study
Ayush Gupta
 
Economics inflation
Economics inflationEconomics inflation
Economics inflation
Renedict De Leon
 
2015 Ontario greenhouse vegetables
2015 Ontario greenhouse vegetables2015 Ontario greenhouse vegetables
2015 Ontario greenhouse vegetables
Artin Demiri
 
ECONOMICS 100A INTERMEDIATE MACROECONOMICSAMJAD TOUKANSummer
ECONOMICS 100A INTERMEDIATE MACROECONOMICSAMJAD TOUKANSummer ECONOMICS 100A INTERMEDIATE MACROECONOMICSAMJAD TOUKANSummer
ECONOMICS 100A INTERMEDIATE MACROECONOMICSAMJAD TOUKANSummer
EvonCanales257
 
GM Agriculture & Farming
GM Agriculture & FarmingGM Agriculture & Farming
GM Agriculture & Farming
solaritaly
 
Monopoly market
Monopoly marketMonopoly market
Monopoly market
Dr. Shweta Uppadhyay
 
Perfect Competition in the Long Run
Perfect Competition in the Long RunPerfect Competition in the Long Run
Perfect Competition in the Long Run
Lumen Learning
 
Price Ceiling and Price Floors. 2022.ppt
Price Ceiling and Price Floors. 2022.pptPrice Ceiling and Price Floors. 2022.ppt
Price Ceiling and Price Floors. 2022.ppt
Jon Newland
 
CEU lecture 1 2016
CEU lecture 1 2016CEU lecture 1 2016
CEU lecture 1 2016
Jorge Nunez Ferrer
 
Equilibrium
EquilibriumEquilibrium
Equilibrium
Yashika Parekh
 
Macro 6 macroeconomic+measures-gdp+and+economic+growth+
Macro 6 macroeconomic+measures-gdp+and+economic+growth+Macro 6 macroeconomic+measures-gdp+and+economic+growth+
Macro 6 macroeconomic+measures-gdp+and+economic+growth+
RadhakrishnanP21
 
Question 1A factor of production whose quantity can be changed d.docx
Question 1A factor of production whose quantity can be changed d.docxQuestion 1A factor of production whose quantity can be changed d.docx
Question 1A factor of production whose quantity can be changed d.docx
makdul
 
Agribusiness market analysis
Agribusiness market analysisAgribusiness market analysis
Agribusiness market analysis
Daisy Ifeoma
 
PURE COMPETITION
 PURE COMPETITION PURE COMPETITION
PURE COMPETITION
rizza salinas
 
Presentation on food cost concept
Presentation on food cost conceptPresentation on food cost concept
Presentation on food cost concept
Shakir Chataiwala
 
Managerial_economics (3).docx
Managerial_economics (3).docxManagerial_economics (3).docx
Managerial_economics (3).docx
AbhishekModak17
 
123
123123
Cournot's Duopoly model
Cournot's Duopoly modelCournot's Duopoly model
Cournot's Duopoly model
MuhammedSuhaibM
 
Microeconomic_Perfect Competition
Microeconomic_Perfect CompetitionMicroeconomic_Perfect Competition
Microeconomic_Perfect Competition
Holly Nmn
 
consumer and producer surplus
consumer and producer surplusconsumer and producer surplus
consumer and producer surplus
sehrish628
 

Similar to Ugly fruits (20)

The NatureView Farm Case Study
The NatureView Farm Case StudyThe NatureView Farm Case Study
The NatureView Farm Case Study
 
Economics inflation
Economics inflationEconomics inflation
Economics inflation
 
2015 Ontario greenhouse vegetables
2015 Ontario greenhouse vegetables2015 Ontario greenhouse vegetables
2015 Ontario greenhouse vegetables
 
ECONOMICS 100A INTERMEDIATE MACROECONOMICSAMJAD TOUKANSummer
ECONOMICS 100A INTERMEDIATE MACROECONOMICSAMJAD TOUKANSummer ECONOMICS 100A INTERMEDIATE MACROECONOMICSAMJAD TOUKANSummer
ECONOMICS 100A INTERMEDIATE MACROECONOMICSAMJAD TOUKANSummer
 
GM Agriculture & Farming
GM Agriculture & FarmingGM Agriculture & Farming
GM Agriculture & Farming
 
Monopoly market
Monopoly marketMonopoly market
Monopoly market
 
Perfect Competition in the Long Run
Perfect Competition in the Long RunPerfect Competition in the Long Run
Perfect Competition in the Long Run
 
Price Ceiling and Price Floors. 2022.ppt
Price Ceiling and Price Floors. 2022.pptPrice Ceiling and Price Floors. 2022.ppt
Price Ceiling and Price Floors. 2022.ppt
 
CEU lecture 1 2016
CEU lecture 1 2016CEU lecture 1 2016
CEU lecture 1 2016
 
Equilibrium
EquilibriumEquilibrium
Equilibrium
 
Macro 6 macroeconomic+measures-gdp+and+economic+growth+
Macro 6 macroeconomic+measures-gdp+and+economic+growth+Macro 6 macroeconomic+measures-gdp+and+economic+growth+
Macro 6 macroeconomic+measures-gdp+and+economic+growth+
 
Question 1A factor of production whose quantity can be changed d.docx
Question 1A factor of production whose quantity can be changed d.docxQuestion 1A factor of production whose quantity can be changed d.docx
Question 1A factor of production whose quantity can be changed d.docx
 
Agribusiness market analysis
Agribusiness market analysisAgribusiness market analysis
Agribusiness market analysis
 
PURE COMPETITION
 PURE COMPETITION PURE COMPETITION
PURE COMPETITION
 
Presentation on food cost concept
Presentation on food cost conceptPresentation on food cost concept
Presentation on food cost concept
 
Managerial_economics (3).docx
Managerial_economics (3).docxManagerial_economics (3).docx
Managerial_economics (3).docx
 
123
123123
123
 
Cournot's Duopoly model
Cournot's Duopoly modelCournot's Duopoly model
Cournot's Duopoly model
 
Microeconomic_Perfect Competition
Microeconomic_Perfect CompetitionMicroeconomic_Perfect Competition
Microeconomic_Perfect Competition
 
consumer and producer surplus
consumer and producer surplusconsumer and producer surplus
consumer and producer surplus
 

Ugly fruits

  • 2. Current Scenario. Lets say that we currently have a fresh produce market of a total of 100kg of selected Class I products. First Effect . An over supplied market will pressure down all fresh produce prices. Regular Market First Issue: Does anybody believe that we can increase demand by 15% from one day to another? New Scenario. An over supplied market = 100kg of selected fresh produce + 15*kg of Ugly fruits. Total 115kg. Summary. There is an excess of 15kg in this new market and so there is an excess of growers that produce them. The less efficient growers that cannot life with the reduced prices will disappear. Market with Ugly Fruits *Hypothesis. 15 extra kilos of ugly fruits out of a production of 100kg currently sold. Based on own estimations of proponents of this trend (meaning that currently 10% to 15% of edible but ugly fruits are discarded).
  • 3. 15% of the Supply Base will disappear. We can even assume (almost impossible) that after the initial oversupply market-shock, prices of Class I fruits get back to normal. The total consumption of this new market will continue to be 100kg. (or a very modest increase due to the reduced prices; because eating habits do not change dramatically when prices get reduced but rather when prices heavily increase) Summary. So even at best possible scenario (discount price reduction of 30%), the total size of the market gets reduced by 4,5%. 100kg x 2€ (Hypothetical Retail Price) = (200 €) Size of the Regular Market Size of Regular Market (€) Size of Market with Ugly Fruits (€) *Hypothesis. Retailers estimate that Ugly Fruits are regularly sold at a discount price reduction that range from 30% to 50 85kg x 2€ (Hypothetical Retail Price) 15kg x 1,40€ (Hypothetical Retail Price -30%) Size of market with Ugly Fruits: 191 €
  • 4. Following our reasoning, the size of the market is reduced by 4,5%, but we also need to address the impact on the Producers’ Turnover taking into consideration all Supply Chain Costs*. Summary: Producer’s Turnover gets reduced by 18% . *Hypothesis. To simplify calculation we estimate all Supply Chain Costs together. According to last available data, average gross Producers’ turnover account for ¼ of Retail Price. Produce Turnover Regular Market Producer Turnover M. With Ugly Fruits Supply Chain Costs and margins: 200€ x ¾ = 150€ Producers’ Turnover: 200€ x 1/4 = 50€ or 200€-150€= 50€ Supply Chain Costs and margins= 150€ (same costs and margins in the new market) Producers’ Turnover: 191€ - 150 = 41€
  • 5. We are told that this new product Ugly Fruits niche market maximize Growers’ Turnover and Profit by selling all crop and not only the selected Class I. As previously seen (see previous slide) not only turnover does not increase but rather reach to a minimum of 18%. Now we concentrate on how profits get impacted. To review growers’ profits we will estimate all farming costs at once. Growers’ Profits Regular Market Grower’s Profits M. with Ugly Fruits *Hypothesis. To simplify theoretical Analysis, we assume a generous 50% margin (excluding amortization, interests and unpaid family labor) To be able to sell 100kg, growers produce an excess that is discarded (Ugly/Unfit/Deficient). Kilos Grown (100+15%)= 117,64kg Growers’ Profits: 50€ (Turnover)-25€ (Costs)= 25€ Unit Costs: 25€/117,64kg=0,20€ We assume growers produce no excess (use all crop) Kilos Grown 100kg We apply same Unit costs : 0,20€/kg Grower’s Costs: 41€ (Turnover)-20,40€ (Costs)= 20,60€ (-17,60%)
  • 6. Total Market (in €) is reduced by 4,5% Growers’ Profits get trimmed by 17,60% Growers’ turnover is lowered by 18% The less efficient growers representing 15% of the production are expelled from the business. The New Market with Ugly Fruits” “A widespread introduction of a new segment of ugly fruit and vegetables” is a complete disaster for farmers in general; and especially for those who this measure leaves out of the “ugly fruits” market.. This is good example on how good intentions (from institutions, retailers and NGOs) can introduce with this movement perverse incentives that hinder the improvement and progress of the efficiency of production systems.