SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Johnboy on December 21, 2011 at 11:40 pm said:
Your comment is awaiting moderation.
For Hugh (and likely a few others)
RE: The optimal nondual (contemplative) approach to reality is
multifaceted in that it aspires to 1) intersubjective intimacy
via our unitive strivings whereby different subjects/persons
celebrate coming together 2) intraobjective identity via our
realization of unitary being whereby all realities present as
somehow intricately interconnected as objects/functions within
a divine matrix 3) intrasubjective integrity via each
subject/person’s growth in human authenticity or true-self
realization and 4) interobjective indeterminacy whereby
created and Uncreated subjects/persons and objects/functions
present as also somehow distinct. The nondual approach is
profoundly relational as it seamlessly, hence optimally,
realizes the truth, beauty and goodness that ensues from these
different eternal relationships.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
When I say nondual or contemplative, I am talking about the
way I interact with my granddaughter when she knocks on my
door. My heart leaps and we delight in each other’s presence.
When I say dualistic, I think of doing my taxes.
Talking about a putative ultimate reality, God for most of us,
a nondual intersubjective intimacy would be like that between
spouses, parent and child, or, like in my example, grandparent
and grandchild. That’s one way aspire to interact with God in
the West. If, however, we interact with God like He’s a
policeman or judge, that would be dualistic in a moral
problem-solving sense. St. Bernard spoke of a “love of God for
sake of self.” In catechism we learned imperfect contrition or
sorrow for the consequences our sins have on us. CS Lewis
spoke of eros or the “what’s in it for me” dynamic of
relationships. All of those would be examples of practical
dualistic problem-solving. Those who spend a lot of time on
metaphysical proofs and the apologetics of natural theology in
philosophy internet forums are engaging God in a rational
dualistic problem-solving. This is another way we interact
with God in the West, which is okay but we miss the deeper
invitation to intimacy if we don’t go beyond it to the
nondual.
A nondual intraobjective integrity refers primarily to
Enlightenment experiences of the East, where folks
experientially realize, beyond all concepts, the grand unity
of all reality, how everything is related to everything else.
This is not a metaphysical insight such that one would come
away a pantheist (God is merely the whole that is greater than
the sum of His parts) or materialist monist (the philosophical
naturalism of an atheist). Rather, it is a profound
existential realization of our radical solidarity with all
being and the experience blossoms into a profound compassion,
sometimes for all sentient beings. The Western experience of
love moves us to compassion, also, but more so from having
experienced being so well loved. This does have practical
1
metaphysical implications that some Christians have resolved
as a pan-en-theism, which more so suggests God indwelling in
all rather than be comprised of all (pan-theism). The
Enlightenment experience is nondual. There is no problemsolving going on, just an ineffable … well, we cannot tell
untellable stories. Elaborating a panentheist approach on
paper is a rational dualistic problem-solving, which is great
but not the same as an existential realization.
Intrasubjective integrity speaks to our growth within each of
us as subject. Think of Kohlberg’s stages of moral
development; Fowler’s stages of faith development; Piaget’s
stages of cognitive developmet; or Lonergan’s conversions –
intellectual, affective, moral, sociopolitical and religious.
Religious conversion is a two-step dance. Having been loved
unqualifiedly, we start loving, more & more through time, in
the same way, gifting others in return by cooperating with
that gift of divine love, which is nothing less than the
activity (mission) of the Holy Spirit. The more we cooperate
with that gift, which was given freely, apart from anything we
have ever known (or been educated to) or ever done (whether an
ascetical practice or moral deed), the stronger our own
unqualified loving & the more evident our cooperation with the
Holy Spirit vis a vis beatitudes, corporal & spiritual works
of mercy, charismatic gifts, gifts of the Spirit, fruits of
the Spirit, theological & cardinal virtues. Our
intrasubjective growth has dualistic and nondual moments,
also. Our intellectual, moral, social and political growth is
primarily dualistic problem-solving (that we would not want to
proceed without!). Our affective (emotional) and religious
development has both but realize their unitive summit in the
nondual, when our other neediness is quieted.
Interobjective indeterminacy speaks to the unspeakable. It is
really just a placeholder for the possibility of realities
that are wholly beyond us, like some aspects of God.
We also interact with fellow creatures in the above-listed
ways but that takes us into arcane metaphysics with all sorts
of root metaphors like substance, process, experience and so
on.
**************************************************************
*****************************
RE: The dualistic (empirical, logical, aesthetical, practical
& moral) approaches to reality represent our imbibing of
eternity from a temporal eyedropper that our finite existence
might not be drowned in God’s ocean of truth, beauty and
goodness, a heavenly tsunami that no earthly finite reality
could withstand or contain! Our dualistic approach does not
represent a theoretical capitulation or departure from our
nondual aspirations, only a compassionate and practical
accommodation of our radical finitude, while we take the
transformative journey.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
The above statement is a recognition that our dualistic
approach is good and necessary, just not sufficient to realize
the value offered us in the Good News — that God wants an
intimate relationship with us via a more nondual engagement —
2
as St. Bernard would say, a love of God for sake of God. Our
dualistic approach is, however, both necessary and sufficient
to nevertheless live a life of abundance under, for example,
the Old Covenant because all God really expects of us is an
enlightened self-interest. Like any good parent, who wants
what is best for a child and will settle for them being safe,
healthy, happy and moral even if they do not fully reciprocate
our deep, deep love of them – God’s cool with our erotic love
of Him (what’s in it for us) and imperfect contrition. The
nondual and dualistic are not over-against is what I was
trying to say. The dualistic is an invitation to a wedding
shower; the nondual is an invitation to the bridal chamber.
**************************************************************
******************
RE: Dysfunctional religion presents in many ways, primarily
from an overemphasis of the dualistic and underemphasis of the
nondual. For example, on the journey to intrasubjective
integrity, we recognize it as our clinging to the false-self.
In moral theology, some have overemphasized the procreative
and under-emphasized the unitive dimension of conjugal love.
In spiritual theology, some have overemphasized the moral and
ascetical at the expense of the mystical and contemplative.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
For those familiar with the teachings of Merton on false self
and true self, especially as amplified by Fr. Richard, true
self realization is the paragon of the nondual approach vis a
vis intra-subjective (within oneself) integrity or human
authenticity. For those who grew up Roman Catholic, the birth
control fiasco came from an overemphasis on the biologistic
and physicalistic and rationalistic problem-solving approach
and an underemphasis on the nondual unitive value of conjugal
love. In homiletics, an overemphasis on fire and brimstone,
church disciplines and other matters is primarily dualistic,
true-enough, perhaps, but missing the deeper invitation to
contemplative prayer.
**************************************************************
************************
RE: How does all of this apply to the political life? Most
political dysfunction is rooted in the either-or/all or
nothing thinking of our dualistic approach. Further, this
insidious dualism gets way overemphasized at the expense of
our nondual vision of temporal reality. If we look through a
Lukan prism, we might see a fivefold Christology, which
recognizes that Christ came to orient, sanctify, empower, heal
and save us. As Luke’s narrative continues in Acts, we see the
Spirit continuing this divine work. A nondual approach
inspired, indeed inspirited, by a pneumatological (Spiritrelated) imagination sees the Holy Spirit infusing each realm
of our temporal reality, always and everywhere, historically
orienting humankind, culturally sanctifying us, socially
empowering us, economically healing us and politically saving
us.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
What I really wish to convey here is that the major categories
of our explicit faith include 1) eschatology (where are we
3
headed? orienting us), 2) theology (to whom are we dedicated?
sanctifying us), 3) ecclesiology (how are we a people?
empowering us), 4) sacramentology (how are we sustained &
nourished? healing us) and 5) soteriology (what’s wrong and
what can we do about it? saving us). EVEN in our otherwise
secular culture, EVEN among nonbelievers, the SPIRIT is the
One coaxing humankind along, always and everywhere, already 1)
orienting us through our shared history 2) sanctifying us
through our cultures 3) empowering us through our social
institutions 4) sustaining and healing us through our
economies 5) saving us and freeing us through our politics!
THERE IS NO COMPARTMENTALIZATION FOR THE HOLY SPIRIT BETWEEN
THE SECULAR AND THE SACRED.
**************************************************************
***********************
RE: This is not to deny that, from time to time, place to
place, people to people and person to person, the Spirit’s
work has been variously amplified or frustrated in matters of
degree; it is to affirm, however, that all good gifts have One
Source, Who has coaxed all of humankind along on the journey!
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Of course, for reasons due to poor formation or even
deformation or developmental inadequacies we encounter
different degrees of manifestation of God-presence as various
people(s) fail or even refuse to cooperate with the Spirit.
Thing is, we must discern when and where it is we see failures
to cooperate but we can never know which failures result from
inabilities (as above-listed) or refusals (sin), because we
are not in a position to judge.
**************************************************************
************************
RE: An overly dualistic approach, again, in an all or
nothing/either-or way, contrastingly, always sees the Spirit –
then but not now, there but not here, in this position but not
that or vice versa. Worse, yet, it will see the Spirit in him
but not her, us but not them, and not as a matter of degree
but to the extent one gets thoroughly demonized and another
absolutely deified! This is at the very root of the extremely
polarizing rhetorical back and forth between our political
parties.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Once we employ a more robustly nondual view of human
realities, we’ll see the Spirit at work even in Republicans
and Democrats.
**************************************************************
***************************
RE: The wisdom of the catholic subsidiarity principle is
rooted in the gift of Third Eye seeing, which affirms our
eternal nondual aspirations and their proleptic realizations
even while compassionately accommodating our temporal
dualistic situations within their historical, cultural,
social, economic and political contexts. It celebrates the
fruits of our prayer that the Kingdom will come, indeed, on
earth as it is in heaven.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
So, when a people’s history is explicitly eschatological
(knowing where we’re headed per the Good News), when a
4
people’s culture is explicitly theological (even if
pluralistically so), when a people’s society is explicitly
ecclesiological (church-going), when a people’s economy is
explicitly sacramental and when a people’s politics is
explicitly salvific and liberating, we can rejoice that the
Kingdom which is to come is at least being more fully realized
in part. When it is not explicitly so — but merely historical,
cultural, social, economic and political, we can STILL REJOICE
knowing it is the same Holy Spirit providing all good gifts!
**************************************************************
**************************
RE: There is nothing intrinsically wrong with an approach that
takes from each according to one’s ability and gives to each
according to one’s need; at least, it’s worked in convents,
monasteries and families for millennia! Because of our radical
finitude, however, without theoretically abandoning our
ideals, we compassionately accommodate our radical finitude
and, precisely because we are not angels, we institute
government in the place of anarchy and regulated free markets
in the place of any rigid capitalism or socialistic communism.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
The point is that, like a just war, any government at all is a
necessary evil and so no political philosophies are grounded
in eternal principles and no politics is deserving of
idolization or demonization.
**************************************************************
************************
RE: To the extent the ideals of our nondual, relational
approach are being realized, governmental, regulatory and
socialization processes must recede to optimize that freedom
which best fosters authentic love. However, to the extent they
are frustrated, then coercive government, regulatory and
socialized means must be instituted to maintain order and
advance the common good. The classical liberal or libertarian
impulse (modern conservatism), then, is but a pragmatic
critique of anarchism; it errs (and becomes indistinguishable
from anarchism) when it treats the ideals of limited
government as absolute values and ignores the practical
realities that result from our radical finitude. The modern
liberal or progressive impulse, then, is but a pragmatic
critique of libertarianism; it errs when it treats
governmental, regulatory and socialization processes as the
default bias, when, in fact, limited government, whenever and
wherever practicable, is the proper bias. What both
libertarian and progressive approaches have in common, then,
is that they are grounded in pragmatic critiques and practical
accommodations and not so-called eternal principles; so, all
of the pious talk about so-called consistent principles is
actually misplaced!
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Common sense tells us not to habitually do for anyone what
they can do for themselves. Compassion instructs us to do for
anyone what they cannot do for themselves, best we are able.
While the aims of love and politics may often coincide,
including both Gospel imperatives and injunctives, they
otherwise differ in their means. The Gospel is not coercive or
ever violent. The government is inherently coercive, as a
5
necessary evil. To the extent our historical, cultural,
social, economic and political lives are realizing the values
of our otherwise explicitly eschatological, theological,
ecclesiological, sacramental and soteriological lives,
government can and should back off. Otherwise, unfortunately,
we need it to maintain the social order and to establish the
common good. This doesn’t mean we have abandoned the Gospel,
only that we are weak and cannot fully implement it.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
RE: Finally, when it comes to strategic approaches, the
subsidiarity principle sometimes sees the virtue in flipping,
at other times in flopping. It is only in moral approaches
that consistency is fully warranted. But political systems are
already grounded, for the most part, in a broad moral
consensus (e.g Constitution, Declaration of Independence,
Universal Declaration of Human Rights), and political
differences are mostly rooted in practical and strategic
differences toward goals that are otherwise already shared,
like establishing world peace and eliminating poverty. To
always recast our practical and strategic differences in terms
of moral reality is just a sinister way to emotionally charge
(they say energize) a political base. A nondual approach, via
subsidiarity principles and relational ideals, however,
transcends all of these differences and nurtures their
creative tensions with a peace that surpasses all earthly
understanding.
**************************************************************
************************
Here’s a lively example. The abortion debate. Even if everyone
agreed on the metaphysics of ensoulment and the morality of
abortion at every stage of gestation, there could be
legitimate PRACTICAL disagreements on the best way to
eliminate and or reduce the numbers of abortions. For example,
it is a question of jurisprudence not morality on whether or
not any given law is enforceable and whose role should or
should not be criminalized. Has this law worked in South
America or Europe or Kansas? Can it work in California?
Differences in jurisprudence and strategy are not moral
positions. Even if one agreed on jurisprudential issues, there
could still be legitimate differences regarding political
strategies and what would work best. One would never know it,
listening to much of the rhetoric surrounding this moral
reality. We should be able to advance this issue based on
common ground.

6

More Related Content

What's hot

Christ and hinduism and buddhism
Christ and hinduism and buddhismChrist and hinduism and buddhism
Christ and hinduism and buddhism
johnboy_philothea_net
 
An icon from an evening in glas and apocalyptic writings
An icon from an evening in glas and apocalyptic writingsAn icon from an evening in glas and apocalyptic writings
An icon from an evening in glas and apocalyptic writings
michael-bolerjack
 
Cynthia Bourgeault's Wisdom Jesus
Cynthia Bourgeault's Wisdom JesusCynthia Bourgeault's Wisdom Jesus
Cynthia Bourgeault's Wisdom Jesus
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Enlightenment and contemplation per polydoxy
Enlightenment and contemplation per polydoxyEnlightenment and contemplation per polydoxy
Enlightenment and contemplation per polydoxy
johnboy_philothea_net
 
TampaBayNWC - Super Saturday
TampaBayNWC - Super SaturdayTampaBayNWC - Super Saturday
TampaBayNWC - Super Saturday
Zac Morton
 
Spirituality and Social Transformation II
Spirituality and Social Transformation IISpirituality and Social Transformation II
Spirituality and Social Transformation II
ruffing
 
Psychology and Spirituality II
Psychology and Spirituality IIPsychology and Spirituality II
Psychology and Spirituality II
ruffing
 
Jesus was the source of confidence
Jesus was the source of confidenceJesus was the source of confidence
Jesus was the source of confidence
GLENN PEASE
 
Bourgeault Rohr et al 10jan2012
Bourgeault Rohr et al 10jan2012Bourgeault Rohr et al 10jan2012
Bourgeault Rohr et al 10jan2012
johnboy_philothea_net
 
That Far Be from Milton: Divine Goodness and Justification in Paradise Lost
That Far Be from Milton: Divine Goodness and Justification in Paradise LostThat Far Be from Milton: Divine Goodness and Justification in Paradise Lost
That Far Be from Milton: Divine Goodness and Justification in Paradise Lost
Ryan Horton
 
Sbnr
SbnrSbnr
Intro to Process Theology - Science and Religion
Intro to Process Theology - Science and ReligionIntro to Process Theology - Science and Religion
Intro to Process Theology - Science and Religion
Trinity Lutheran Church, Stillwater, MN
 
Theological Foundations part 1
Theological Foundations part 1Theological Foundations part 1
Theological Foundations part 1
Steve Thomason
 
The holy spirit for understanding
The holy spirit for understandingThe holy spirit for understanding
The holy spirit for understanding
GLENN PEASE
 
A study of worship part 2
A study of worship part 2A study of worship part 2
A study of worship part 2
GLENN PEASE
 
A practical universalism
A practical universalismA practical universalism
A practical universalism
johnboy_philothea_net
 

What's hot (16)

Christ and hinduism and buddhism
Christ and hinduism and buddhismChrist and hinduism and buddhism
Christ and hinduism and buddhism
 
An icon from an evening in glas and apocalyptic writings
An icon from an evening in glas and apocalyptic writingsAn icon from an evening in glas and apocalyptic writings
An icon from an evening in glas and apocalyptic writings
 
Cynthia Bourgeault's Wisdom Jesus
Cynthia Bourgeault's Wisdom JesusCynthia Bourgeault's Wisdom Jesus
Cynthia Bourgeault's Wisdom Jesus
 
Enlightenment and contemplation per polydoxy
Enlightenment and contemplation per polydoxyEnlightenment and contemplation per polydoxy
Enlightenment and contemplation per polydoxy
 
TampaBayNWC - Super Saturday
TampaBayNWC - Super SaturdayTampaBayNWC - Super Saturday
TampaBayNWC - Super Saturday
 
Spirituality and Social Transformation II
Spirituality and Social Transformation IISpirituality and Social Transformation II
Spirituality and Social Transformation II
 
Psychology and Spirituality II
Psychology and Spirituality IIPsychology and Spirituality II
Psychology and Spirituality II
 
Jesus was the source of confidence
Jesus was the source of confidenceJesus was the source of confidence
Jesus was the source of confidence
 
Bourgeault Rohr et al 10jan2012
Bourgeault Rohr et al 10jan2012Bourgeault Rohr et al 10jan2012
Bourgeault Rohr et al 10jan2012
 
That Far Be from Milton: Divine Goodness and Justification in Paradise Lost
That Far Be from Milton: Divine Goodness and Justification in Paradise LostThat Far Be from Milton: Divine Goodness and Justification in Paradise Lost
That Far Be from Milton: Divine Goodness and Justification in Paradise Lost
 
Sbnr
SbnrSbnr
Sbnr
 
Intro to Process Theology - Science and Religion
Intro to Process Theology - Science and ReligionIntro to Process Theology - Science and Religion
Intro to Process Theology - Science and Religion
 
Theological Foundations part 1
Theological Foundations part 1Theological Foundations part 1
Theological Foundations part 1
 
The holy spirit for understanding
The holy spirit for understandingThe holy spirit for understanding
The holy spirit for understanding
 
A study of worship part 2
A study of worship part 2A study of worship part 2
A study of worship part 2
 
A practical universalism
A practical universalismA practical universalism
A practical universalism
 

Viewers also liked

Political philosophy jss 2011 sept
Political philosophy jss 2011 septPolitical philosophy jss 2011 sept
Political philosophy jss 2011 sept
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Cynthia bourgeault's wisdom jesus
Cynthia bourgeault's wisdom jesusCynthia bourgeault's wisdom jesus
Cynthia bourgeault's wisdom jesus
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Economics & politics
Economics & politicsEconomics & politics
Economics & politics
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Natural theology vs theology of nature
Natural theology vs theology of natureNatural theology vs theology of nature
Natural theology vs theology of nature
johnboy_philothea_net
 
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulnessIn defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathyMoral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
johnboy_philothea_net
 

Viewers also liked (7)

Political philosophy jss 2011 sept
Political philosophy jss 2011 septPolitical philosophy jss 2011 sept
Political philosophy jss 2011 sept
 
Cynthia bourgeault's wisdom jesus
Cynthia bourgeault's wisdom jesusCynthia bourgeault's wisdom jesus
Cynthia bourgeault's wisdom jesus
 
Faith as epistemic virtue
Faith as epistemic virtueFaith as epistemic virtue
Faith as epistemic virtue
 
Economics & politics
Economics & politicsEconomics & politics
Economics & politics
 
Natural theology vs theology of nature
Natural theology vs theology of natureNatural theology vs theology of nature
Natural theology vs theology of nature
 
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulnessIn defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
 
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathyMoral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
 

Similar to Translation rohr's blog

Nondual christianity 2011 dec 18
Nondual christianity 2011 dec 18Nondual christianity 2011 dec 18
Nondual christianity 2011 dec 18
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Nondual christianity
Nondual christianityNondual christianity
Nondual christianity
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Bourgeault contd 07jan2012
Bourgeault contd 07jan2012Bourgeault contd 07jan2012
Bourgeault contd 07jan2012
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism revised
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism revisedChristian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism revised
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism revised
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Nondual christianity xmas 2011
Nondual christianity xmas 2011Nondual christianity xmas 2011
Nondual christianity xmas 2011
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Nondual considerations
Nondual considerationsNondual considerations
Nondual considerations
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Intentional nonduality
Intentional nondualityIntentional nonduality
Intentional nonduality
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Nonduality week morrell
Nonduality week morrellNonduality week morrell
Nonduality week morrell
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Intentional nonduality
Intentional nondualityIntentional nonduality
Intentional nonduality
johnboy_philothea_net
 
dual vs nondual consciouness
dual vs nondual consciounessdual vs nondual consciouness
dual vs nondual consciouness
johnboy_philothea_net
 
The Importance of Purity to Holiness
The Importance of Purity to HolinessThe Importance of Purity to Holiness
The Importance of Purity to Holiness
Sandy Kress
 
Nondual christianity xmas 2011
Nondual christianity xmas 2011Nondual christianity xmas 2011
Nondual christianity xmas 2011
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchismChristian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Philosophicaltheologyinterreligious
PhilosophicaltheologyinterreligiousPhilosophicaltheologyinterreligious
Philosophicaltheologyinterreligious
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Philosophicaltheologyinterreligious
PhilosophicaltheologyinterreligiousPhilosophicaltheologyinterreligious
Philosophicaltheologyinterreligious
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Bourgeault rohr et al10jan2012
Bourgeault rohr et al10jan2012Bourgeault rohr et al10jan2012
Bourgeault rohr et al10jan2012
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Sorting truth claims and categories
Sorting truth claims and categoriesSorting truth claims and categories
Sorting truth claims and categories
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Uniting unitary and unitive consciousness
Uniting unitary and unitive consciousnessUniting unitary and unitive consciousness
Uniting unitary and unitive consciousness
johnboy_philothea_net
 
infatuations & comforts, loves & consolations
infatuations & comforts, loves & consolationsinfatuations & comforts, loves & consolations
infatuations & comforts, loves & consolations
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchismChristian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism
johnboy_philothea_net
 

Similar to Translation rohr's blog (20)

Nondual christianity 2011 dec 18
Nondual christianity 2011 dec 18Nondual christianity 2011 dec 18
Nondual christianity 2011 dec 18
 
Nondual christianity
Nondual christianityNondual christianity
Nondual christianity
 
Bourgeault contd 07jan2012
Bourgeault contd 07jan2012Bourgeault contd 07jan2012
Bourgeault contd 07jan2012
 
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism revised
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism revisedChristian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism revised
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism revised
 
Nondual christianity xmas 2011
Nondual christianity xmas 2011Nondual christianity xmas 2011
Nondual christianity xmas 2011
 
Nondual considerations
Nondual considerationsNondual considerations
Nondual considerations
 
Intentional nonduality
Intentional nondualityIntentional nonduality
Intentional nonduality
 
Nonduality week morrell
Nonduality week morrellNonduality week morrell
Nonduality week morrell
 
Intentional nonduality
Intentional nondualityIntentional nonduality
Intentional nonduality
 
dual vs nondual consciouness
dual vs nondual consciounessdual vs nondual consciouness
dual vs nondual consciouness
 
The Importance of Purity to Holiness
The Importance of Purity to HolinessThe Importance of Purity to Holiness
The Importance of Purity to Holiness
 
Nondual christianity xmas 2011
Nondual christianity xmas 2011Nondual christianity xmas 2011
Nondual christianity xmas 2011
 
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchismChristian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism
 
Philosophicaltheologyinterreligious
PhilosophicaltheologyinterreligiousPhilosophicaltheologyinterreligious
Philosophicaltheologyinterreligious
 
Philosophicaltheologyinterreligious
PhilosophicaltheologyinterreligiousPhilosophicaltheologyinterreligious
Philosophicaltheologyinterreligious
 
Bourgeault rohr et al10jan2012
Bourgeault rohr et al10jan2012Bourgeault rohr et al10jan2012
Bourgeault rohr et al10jan2012
 
Sorting truth claims and categories
Sorting truth claims and categoriesSorting truth claims and categories
Sorting truth claims and categories
 
Uniting unitary and unitive consciousness
Uniting unitary and unitive consciousnessUniting unitary and unitive consciousness
Uniting unitary and unitive consciousness
 
infatuations & comforts, loves & consolations
infatuations & comforts, loves & consolationsinfatuations & comforts, loves & consolations
infatuations & comforts, loves & consolations
 
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchismChristian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism
Christian nonduality, panentheism & anarchism
 

More from johnboy_philothea_net

Emerging christianity interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
Emerging christianity   interfaith account of orthodoxic spiEmerging christianity   interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
Emerging christianity interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Eucharistic model
Eucharistic modelEucharistic model
Eucharistic model
johnboy_philothea_net
 
The missing divine attribute omnipathy
The missing divine attribute   omnipathyThe missing divine attribute   omnipathy
The missing divine attribute omnipathy
johnboy_philothea_net
 
In all religions we are invited to dig deeper
In all religions we are invited to dig deeperIn all religions we are invited to dig deeper
In all religions we are invited to dig deeper
johnboy_philothea_net
 
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxyA soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Deconstructing deconstructionism
Deconstructing deconstructionismDeconstructing deconstructionism
Deconstructing deconstructionism
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionismFaith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
johnboy_philothea_net
 
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics   not so fastThe role of change in metaphysics   not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
johnboy_philothea_net
 
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics   not so fastThe role of change in metaphysics   not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as loverOrthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as loverOrthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
johnboy_philothea_net
 
To john caputo yes, but
To john caputo   yes, butTo john caputo   yes, but
To john caputo yes, but
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theologicalOntologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Deconstruct this!
Deconstruct this!Deconstruct this!
Deconstruct this!
johnboy_philothea_net
 
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrismThe (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
johnboy_philothea_net
 
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage pointA look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Dorothy day and gospel norms
Dorothy day and gospel normsDorothy day and gospel norms
Dorothy day and gospel norms
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchangeInterfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Why bourgeault is right that sophiology matters
Why bourgeault is right that sophiology mattersWhy bourgeault is right that sophiology matters
Why bourgeault is right that sophiology matters
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Polydoxy
PolydoxyPolydoxy

More from johnboy_philothea_net (20)

Emerging christianity interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
Emerging christianity   interfaith account of orthodoxic spiEmerging christianity   interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
Emerging christianity interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
 
Eucharistic model
Eucharistic modelEucharistic model
Eucharistic model
 
The missing divine attribute omnipathy
The missing divine attribute   omnipathyThe missing divine attribute   omnipathy
The missing divine attribute omnipathy
 
In all religions we are invited to dig deeper
In all religions we are invited to dig deeperIn all religions we are invited to dig deeper
In all religions we are invited to dig deeper
 
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxyA soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
 
Deconstructing deconstructionism
Deconstructing deconstructionismDeconstructing deconstructionism
Deconstructing deconstructionism
 
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionismFaith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
 
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics   not so fastThe role of change in metaphysics   not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
 
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics   not so fastThe role of change in metaphysics   not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
 
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as loverOrthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
 
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as loverOrthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
 
To john caputo yes, but
To john caputo   yes, butTo john caputo   yes, but
To john caputo yes, but
 
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theologicalOntologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
 
Deconstruct this!
Deconstruct this!Deconstruct this!
Deconstruct this!
 
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrismThe (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
 
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage pointA look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
 
Dorothy day and gospel norms
Dorothy day and gospel normsDorothy day and gospel norms
Dorothy day and gospel norms
 
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchangeInterfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
 
Why bourgeault is right that sophiology matters
Why bourgeault is right that sophiology mattersWhy bourgeault is right that sophiology matters
Why bourgeault is right that sophiology matters
 
Polydoxy
PolydoxyPolydoxy
Polydoxy
 

Recently uploaded

July 19, 1813: First Vows of the Sisters of Charity of St. Joseph's, St. Eliz...
July 19, 1813: First Vows of the Sisters of Charity of St. Joseph's, St. Eliz...July 19, 1813: First Vows of the Sisters of Charity of St. Joseph's, St. Eliz...
July 19, 1813: First Vows of the Sisters of Charity of St. Joseph's, St. Eliz...
Famvin: the Worldwide Vincentian Family
 
Parishioners Mourning Their Loss | Toronto Star
Parishioners Mourning Their Loss | Toronto StarParishioners Mourning Their Loss | Toronto Star
Parishioners Mourning Their Loss | Toronto Star
Victoria Gaitskell
 
Sermon on the Mount: Part 7 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Poor in ...
Sermon on the Mount: Part 7 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Poor in ...Sermon on the Mount: Part 7 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Poor in ...
Sermon on the Mount: Part 7 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Poor in ...
Vintage Church
 
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_109_Divine_Plan.pptx
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_109_Divine_Plan.pptxThe_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_109_Divine_Plan.pptx
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_109_Divine_Plan.pptx
Network Bible Fellowship
 
SUNY-Bin degree offer diploma Transcript
SUNY-Bin degree offer diploma TranscriptSUNY-Bin degree offer diploma Transcript
SUNY-Bin degree offer diploma Transcript
azeyhun
 
Vip Girls Call Visakhapatnam 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And...
Vip Girls Call Visakhapatnam 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And...Vip Girls Call Visakhapatnam 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And...
Vip Girls Call Visakhapatnam 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And...
sapnas9823
 
High Girls Call Coimbatore 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And N...
High Girls Call Coimbatore 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And N...High Girls Call Coimbatore 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And N...
High Girls Call Coimbatore 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And N...
singhlata50dh
 
Hyderabad, India Namaz Salah Prayer Timings Chart (Single page)
Hyderabad, India Namaz Salah Prayer Timings Chart (Single page)Hyderabad, India Namaz Salah Prayer Timings Chart (Single page)
Hyderabad, India Namaz Salah Prayer Timings Chart (Single page)
Abdullah Akbar
 
One Thing: Martha & Mary
One Thing: Martha & MaryOne Thing: Martha & Mary
One Thing: Martha & Mary
Dave546130
 
Alabama love spells caster +27789571548 London Birmingham Liverpool Nottingha...
Alabama love spells caster +27789571548 London Birmingham Liverpool Nottingha...Alabama love spells caster +27789571548 London Birmingham Liverpool Nottingha...
Alabama love spells caster +27789571548 London Birmingham Liverpool Nottingha...
mammanginangina1
 
UofM degree offer diploma Transcript
UofM degree offer diploma TranscriptUofM degree offer diploma Transcript
UofM degree offer diploma Transcript
azeyhun
 
Chennai Girls Call Chennai 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service...
Chennai Girls Call Chennai 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service...Chennai Girls Call Chennai 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service...
Chennai Girls Call Chennai 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service...
aparnaseth12
 
Baluchi Child Discipline Training Tract.pdf
Baluchi Child Discipline Training Tract.pdfBaluchi Child Discipline Training Tract.pdf
Baluchi Child Discipline Training Tract.pdf
Filipino Tracts and Literature Society Inc.
 
High Girls Call Ahmedabad 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No...
High Girls Call Ahmedabad 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No...High Girls Call Ahmedabad 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No...
High Girls Call Ahmedabad 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No...
ankurwariko242
 
Irish Bard's Imprint Seen in Celtic Church | Anglican Journal
Irish Bard's Imprint Seen in Celtic Church  |  Anglican JournalIrish Bard's Imprint Seen in Celtic Church  |  Anglican Journal
Irish Bard's Imprint Seen in Celtic Church | Anglican Journal
Victoria Gaitskell
 
MSU degree offer diploma Transcript
MSU degree offer diploma TranscriptMSU degree offer diploma Transcript
MSU degree offer diploma Transcript
azeyhun
 
Story of Buddha Gautama ~ A Free Full-Color eBook (Eng. & Chi.).pdf
Story of Buddha Gautama ~ A Free Full-Color eBook (Eng. & Chi.).pdfStory of Buddha Gautama ~ A Free Full-Color eBook (Eng. & Chi.).pdf
Story of Buddha Gautama ~ A Free Full-Color eBook (Eng. & Chi.).pdf
OH TEIK BIN
 
Sermon on the Mount: Part 8 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Peacemakers
Sermon on the Mount: Part 8 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the PeacemakersSermon on the Mount: Part 8 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Peacemakers
Sermon on the Mount: Part 8 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Peacemakers
Vintage Church
 
High Girls Call Bhubaneswar 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And ...
High Girls Call Bhubaneswar 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And ...High Girls Call Bhubaneswar 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And ...
High Girls Call Bhubaneswar 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And ...
ankurwariko242
 
Kanpur Girls Call Kanpur 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service A...
Kanpur Girls Call Kanpur 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service A...Kanpur Girls Call Kanpur 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service A...
Kanpur Girls Call Kanpur 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service A...
rachitkumar09887
 

Recently uploaded (20)

July 19, 1813: First Vows of the Sisters of Charity of St. Joseph's, St. Eliz...
July 19, 1813: First Vows of the Sisters of Charity of St. Joseph's, St. Eliz...July 19, 1813: First Vows of the Sisters of Charity of St. Joseph's, St. Eliz...
July 19, 1813: First Vows of the Sisters of Charity of St. Joseph's, St. Eliz...
 
Parishioners Mourning Their Loss | Toronto Star
Parishioners Mourning Their Loss | Toronto StarParishioners Mourning Their Loss | Toronto Star
Parishioners Mourning Their Loss | Toronto Star
 
Sermon on the Mount: Part 7 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Poor in ...
Sermon on the Mount: Part 7 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Poor in ...Sermon on the Mount: Part 7 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Poor in ...
Sermon on the Mount: Part 7 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Poor in ...
 
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_109_Divine_Plan.pptx
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_109_Divine_Plan.pptxThe_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_109_Divine_Plan.pptx
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_109_Divine_Plan.pptx
 
SUNY-Bin degree offer diploma Transcript
SUNY-Bin degree offer diploma TranscriptSUNY-Bin degree offer diploma Transcript
SUNY-Bin degree offer diploma Transcript
 
Vip Girls Call Visakhapatnam 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And...
Vip Girls Call Visakhapatnam 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And...Vip Girls Call Visakhapatnam 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And...
Vip Girls Call Visakhapatnam 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And...
 
High Girls Call Coimbatore 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And N...
High Girls Call Coimbatore 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And N...High Girls Call Coimbatore 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And N...
High Girls Call Coimbatore 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And N...
 
Hyderabad, India Namaz Salah Prayer Timings Chart (Single page)
Hyderabad, India Namaz Salah Prayer Timings Chart (Single page)Hyderabad, India Namaz Salah Prayer Timings Chart (Single page)
Hyderabad, India Namaz Salah Prayer Timings Chart (Single page)
 
One Thing: Martha & Mary
One Thing: Martha & MaryOne Thing: Martha & Mary
One Thing: Martha & Mary
 
Alabama love spells caster +27789571548 London Birmingham Liverpool Nottingha...
Alabama love spells caster +27789571548 London Birmingham Liverpool Nottingha...Alabama love spells caster +27789571548 London Birmingham Liverpool Nottingha...
Alabama love spells caster +27789571548 London Birmingham Liverpool Nottingha...
 
UofM degree offer diploma Transcript
UofM degree offer diploma TranscriptUofM degree offer diploma Transcript
UofM degree offer diploma Transcript
 
Chennai Girls Call Chennai 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service...
Chennai Girls Call Chennai 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service...Chennai Girls Call Chennai 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service...
Chennai Girls Call Chennai 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service...
 
Baluchi Child Discipline Training Tract.pdf
Baluchi Child Discipline Training Tract.pdfBaluchi Child Discipline Training Tract.pdf
Baluchi Child Discipline Training Tract.pdf
 
High Girls Call Ahmedabad 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No...
High Girls Call Ahmedabad 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No...High Girls Call Ahmedabad 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No...
High Girls Call Ahmedabad 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No...
 
Irish Bard's Imprint Seen in Celtic Church | Anglican Journal
Irish Bard's Imprint Seen in Celtic Church  |  Anglican JournalIrish Bard's Imprint Seen in Celtic Church  |  Anglican Journal
Irish Bard's Imprint Seen in Celtic Church | Anglican Journal
 
MSU degree offer diploma Transcript
MSU degree offer diploma TranscriptMSU degree offer diploma Transcript
MSU degree offer diploma Transcript
 
Story of Buddha Gautama ~ A Free Full-Color eBook (Eng. & Chi.).pdf
Story of Buddha Gautama ~ A Free Full-Color eBook (Eng. & Chi.).pdfStory of Buddha Gautama ~ A Free Full-Color eBook (Eng. & Chi.).pdf
Story of Buddha Gautama ~ A Free Full-Color eBook (Eng. & Chi.).pdf
 
Sermon on the Mount: Part 8 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Peacemakers
Sermon on the Mount: Part 8 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the PeacemakersSermon on the Mount: Part 8 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Peacemakers
Sermon on the Mount: Part 8 - A Costly Interruption: Blessed are the Peacemakers
 
High Girls Call Bhubaneswar 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And ...
High Girls Call Bhubaneswar 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And ...High Girls Call Bhubaneswar 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And ...
High Girls Call Bhubaneswar 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And ...
 
Kanpur Girls Call Kanpur 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service A...
Kanpur Girls Call Kanpur 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service A...Kanpur Girls Call Kanpur 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service A...
Kanpur Girls Call Kanpur 0X0000000X Unlimited Short Providing Girls Service A...
 

Translation rohr's blog

  • 1. Johnboy on December 21, 2011 at 11:40 pm said: Your comment is awaiting moderation. For Hugh (and likely a few others) RE: The optimal nondual (contemplative) approach to reality is multifaceted in that it aspires to 1) intersubjective intimacy via our unitive strivings whereby different subjects/persons celebrate coming together 2) intraobjective identity via our realization of unitary being whereby all realities present as somehow intricately interconnected as objects/functions within a divine matrix 3) intrasubjective integrity via each subject/person’s growth in human authenticity or true-self realization and 4) interobjective indeterminacy whereby created and Uncreated subjects/persons and objects/functions present as also somehow distinct. The nondual approach is profoundly relational as it seamlessly, hence optimally, realizes the truth, beauty and goodness that ensues from these different eternal relationships. ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ When I say nondual or contemplative, I am talking about the way I interact with my granddaughter when she knocks on my door. My heart leaps and we delight in each other’s presence. When I say dualistic, I think of doing my taxes. Talking about a putative ultimate reality, God for most of us, a nondual intersubjective intimacy would be like that between spouses, parent and child, or, like in my example, grandparent and grandchild. That’s one way aspire to interact with God in the West. If, however, we interact with God like He’s a policeman or judge, that would be dualistic in a moral problem-solving sense. St. Bernard spoke of a “love of God for sake of self.” In catechism we learned imperfect contrition or sorrow for the consequences our sins have on us. CS Lewis spoke of eros or the “what’s in it for me” dynamic of relationships. All of those would be examples of practical dualistic problem-solving. Those who spend a lot of time on metaphysical proofs and the apologetics of natural theology in philosophy internet forums are engaging God in a rational dualistic problem-solving. This is another way we interact with God in the West, which is okay but we miss the deeper invitation to intimacy if we don’t go beyond it to the nondual. A nondual intraobjective integrity refers primarily to Enlightenment experiences of the East, where folks experientially realize, beyond all concepts, the grand unity of all reality, how everything is related to everything else. This is not a metaphysical insight such that one would come away a pantheist (God is merely the whole that is greater than the sum of His parts) or materialist monist (the philosophical naturalism of an atheist). Rather, it is a profound existential realization of our radical solidarity with all being and the experience blossoms into a profound compassion, sometimes for all sentient beings. The Western experience of love moves us to compassion, also, but more so from having experienced being so well loved. This does have practical 1
  • 2. metaphysical implications that some Christians have resolved as a pan-en-theism, which more so suggests God indwelling in all rather than be comprised of all (pan-theism). The Enlightenment experience is nondual. There is no problemsolving going on, just an ineffable … well, we cannot tell untellable stories. Elaborating a panentheist approach on paper is a rational dualistic problem-solving, which is great but not the same as an existential realization. Intrasubjective integrity speaks to our growth within each of us as subject. Think of Kohlberg’s stages of moral development; Fowler’s stages of faith development; Piaget’s stages of cognitive developmet; or Lonergan’s conversions – intellectual, affective, moral, sociopolitical and religious. Religious conversion is a two-step dance. Having been loved unqualifiedly, we start loving, more & more through time, in the same way, gifting others in return by cooperating with that gift of divine love, which is nothing less than the activity (mission) of the Holy Spirit. The more we cooperate with that gift, which was given freely, apart from anything we have ever known (or been educated to) or ever done (whether an ascetical practice or moral deed), the stronger our own unqualified loving & the more evident our cooperation with the Holy Spirit vis a vis beatitudes, corporal & spiritual works of mercy, charismatic gifts, gifts of the Spirit, fruits of the Spirit, theological & cardinal virtues. Our intrasubjective growth has dualistic and nondual moments, also. Our intellectual, moral, social and political growth is primarily dualistic problem-solving (that we would not want to proceed without!). Our affective (emotional) and religious development has both but realize their unitive summit in the nondual, when our other neediness is quieted. Interobjective indeterminacy speaks to the unspeakable. It is really just a placeholder for the possibility of realities that are wholly beyond us, like some aspects of God. We also interact with fellow creatures in the above-listed ways but that takes us into arcane metaphysics with all sorts of root metaphors like substance, process, experience and so on. ************************************************************** ***************************** RE: The dualistic (empirical, logical, aesthetical, practical & moral) approaches to reality represent our imbibing of eternity from a temporal eyedropper that our finite existence might not be drowned in God’s ocean of truth, beauty and goodness, a heavenly tsunami that no earthly finite reality could withstand or contain! Our dualistic approach does not represent a theoretical capitulation or departure from our nondual aspirations, only a compassionate and practical accommodation of our radical finitude, while we take the transformative journey. ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ The above statement is a recognition that our dualistic approach is good and necessary, just not sufficient to realize the value offered us in the Good News — that God wants an intimate relationship with us via a more nondual engagement — 2
  • 3. as St. Bernard would say, a love of God for sake of God. Our dualistic approach is, however, both necessary and sufficient to nevertheless live a life of abundance under, for example, the Old Covenant because all God really expects of us is an enlightened self-interest. Like any good parent, who wants what is best for a child and will settle for them being safe, healthy, happy and moral even if they do not fully reciprocate our deep, deep love of them – God’s cool with our erotic love of Him (what’s in it for us) and imperfect contrition. The nondual and dualistic are not over-against is what I was trying to say. The dualistic is an invitation to a wedding shower; the nondual is an invitation to the bridal chamber. ************************************************************** ****************** RE: Dysfunctional religion presents in many ways, primarily from an overemphasis of the dualistic and underemphasis of the nondual. For example, on the journey to intrasubjective integrity, we recognize it as our clinging to the false-self. In moral theology, some have overemphasized the procreative and under-emphasized the unitive dimension of conjugal love. In spiritual theology, some have overemphasized the moral and ascetical at the expense of the mystical and contemplative. ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ For those familiar with the teachings of Merton on false self and true self, especially as amplified by Fr. Richard, true self realization is the paragon of the nondual approach vis a vis intra-subjective (within oneself) integrity or human authenticity. For those who grew up Roman Catholic, the birth control fiasco came from an overemphasis on the biologistic and physicalistic and rationalistic problem-solving approach and an underemphasis on the nondual unitive value of conjugal love. In homiletics, an overemphasis on fire and brimstone, church disciplines and other matters is primarily dualistic, true-enough, perhaps, but missing the deeper invitation to contemplative prayer. ************************************************************** ************************ RE: How does all of this apply to the political life? Most political dysfunction is rooted in the either-or/all or nothing thinking of our dualistic approach. Further, this insidious dualism gets way overemphasized at the expense of our nondual vision of temporal reality. If we look through a Lukan prism, we might see a fivefold Christology, which recognizes that Christ came to orient, sanctify, empower, heal and save us. As Luke’s narrative continues in Acts, we see the Spirit continuing this divine work. A nondual approach inspired, indeed inspirited, by a pneumatological (Spiritrelated) imagination sees the Holy Spirit infusing each realm of our temporal reality, always and everywhere, historically orienting humankind, culturally sanctifying us, socially empowering us, economically healing us and politically saving us. +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ What I really wish to convey here is that the major categories of our explicit faith include 1) eschatology (where are we 3
  • 4. headed? orienting us), 2) theology (to whom are we dedicated? sanctifying us), 3) ecclesiology (how are we a people? empowering us), 4) sacramentology (how are we sustained & nourished? healing us) and 5) soteriology (what’s wrong and what can we do about it? saving us). EVEN in our otherwise secular culture, EVEN among nonbelievers, the SPIRIT is the One coaxing humankind along, always and everywhere, already 1) orienting us through our shared history 2) sanctifying us through our cultures 3) empowering us through our social institutions 4) sustaining and healing us through our economies 5) saving us and freeing us through our politics! THERE IS NO COMPARTMENTALIZATION FOR THE HOLY SPIRIT BETWEEN THE SECULAR AND THE SACRED. ************************************************************** *********************** RE: This is not to deny that, from time to time, place to place, people to people and person to person, the Spirit’s work has been variously amplified or frustrated in matters of degree; it is to affirm, however, that all good gifts have One Source, Who has coaxed all of humankind along on the journey! ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Of course, for reasons due to poor formation or even deformation or developmental inadequacies we encounter different degrees of manifestation of God-presence as various people(s) fail or even refuse to cooperate with the Spirit. Thing is, we must discern when and where it is we see failures to cooperate but we can never know which failures result from inabilities (as above-listed) or refusals (sin), because we are not in a position to judge. ************************************************************** ************************ RE: An overly dualistic approach, again, in an all or nothing/either-or way, contrastingly, always sees the Spirit – then but not now, there but not here, in this position but not that or vice versa. Worse, yet, it will see the Spirit in him but not her, us but not them, and not as a matter of degree but to the extent one gets thoroughly demonized and another absolutely deified! This is at the very root of the extremely polarizing rhetorical back and forth between our political parties. +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Once we employ a more robustly nondual view of human realities, we’ll see the Spirit at work even in Republicans and Democrats. ************************************************************** *************************** RE: The wisdom of the catholic subsidiarity principle is rooted in the gift of Third Eye seeing, which affirms our eternal nondual aspirations and their proleptic realizations even while compassionately accommodating our temporal dualistic situations within their historical, cultural, social, economic and political contexts. It celebrates the fruits of our prayer that the Kingdom will come, indeed, on earth as it is in heaven. ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ So, when a people’s history is explicitly eschatological (knowing where we’re headed per the Good News), when a 4
  • 5. people’s culture is explicitly theological (even if pluralistically so), when a people’s society is explicitly ecclesiological (church-going), when a people’s economy is explicitly sacramental and when a people’s politics is explicitly salvific and liberating, we can rejoice that the Kingdom which is to come is at least being more fully realized in part. When it is not explicitly so — but merely historical, cultural, social, economic and political, we can STILL REJOICE knowing it is the same Holy Spirit providing all good gifts! ************************************************************** ************************** RE: There is nothing intrinsically wrong with an approach that takes from each according to one’s ability and gives to each according to one’s need; at least, it’s worked in convents, monasteries and families for millennia! Because of our radical finitude, however, without theoretically abandoning our ideals, we compassionately accommodate our radical finitude and, precisely because we are not angels, we institute government in the place of anarchy and regulated free markets in the place of any rigid capitalism or socialistic communism. +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ The point is that, like a just war, any government at all is a necessary evil and so no political philosophies are grounded in eternal principles and no politics is deserving of idolization or demonization. ************************************************************** ************************ RE: To the extent the ideals of our nondual, relational approach are being realized, governmental, regulatory and socialization processes must recede to optimize that freedom which best fosters authentic love. However, to the extent they are frustrated, then coercive government, regulatory and socialized means must be instituted to maintain order and advance the common good. The classical liberal or libertarian impulse (modern conservatism), then, is but a pragmatic critique of anarchism; it errs (and becomes indistinguishable from anarchism) when it treats the ideals of limited government as absolute values and ignores the practical realities that result from our radical finitude. The modern liberal or progressive impulse, then, is but a pragmatic critique of libertarianism; it errs when it treats governmental, regulatory and socialization processes as the default bias, when, in fact, limited government, whenever and wherever practicable, is the proper bias. What both libertarian and progressive approaches have in common, then, is that they are grounded in pragmatic critiques and practical accommodations and not so-called eternal principles; so, all of the pious talk about so-called consistent principles is actually misplaced! +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Common sense tells us not to habitually do for anyone what they can do for themselves. Compassion instructs us to do for anyone what they cannot do for themselves, best we are able. While the aims of love and politics may often coincide, including both Gospel imperatives and injunctives, they otherwise differ in their means. The Gospel is not coercive or ever violent. The government is inherently coercive, as a 5
  • 6. necessary evil. To the extent our historical, cultural, social, economic and political lives are realizing the values of our otherwise explicitly eschatological, theological, ecclesiological, sacramental and soteriological lives, government can and should back off. Otherwise, unfortunately, we need it to maintain the social order and to establish the common good. This doesn’t mean we have abandoned the Gospel, only that we are weak and cannot fully implement it. +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ RE: Finally, when it comes to strategic approaches, the subsidiarity principle sometimes sees the virtue in flipping, at other times in flopping. It is only in moral approaches that consistency is fully warranted. But political systems are already grounded, for the most part, in a broad moral consensus (e.g Constitution, Declaration of Independence, Universal Declaration of Human Rights), and political differences are mostly rooted in practical and strategic differences toward goals that are otherwise already shared, like establishing world peace and eliminating poverty. To always recast our practical and strategic differences in terms of moral reality is just a sinister way to emotionally charge (they say energize) a political base. A nondual approach, via subsidiarity principles and relational ideals, however, transcends all of these differences and nurtures their creative tensions with a peace that surpasses all earthly understanding. ************************************************************** ************************ Here’s a lively example. The abortion debate. Even if everyone agreed on the metaphysics of ensoulment and the morality of abortion at every stage of gestation, there could be legitimate PRACTICAL disagreements on the best way to eliminate and or reduce the numbers of abortions. For example, it is a question of jurisprudence not morality on whether or not any given law is enforceable and whose role should or should not be criminalized. Has this law worked in South America or Europe or Kansas? Can it work in California? Differences in jurisprudence and strategy are not moral positions. Even if one agreed on jurisprudential issues, there could still be legitimate differences regarding political strategies and what would work best. One would never know it, listening to much of the rhetoric surrounding this moral reality. We should be able to advance this issue based on common ground. 6