The document summarizes the results of a firm-level survey in Pakistan about trade with Afghanistan. It finds that while Pakistan remains Afghanistan's largest trading partner, competition from Iran and India is increasing. The survey finds that costs of doing business have risen significantly for Pakistani firms in recent years, including transportation, warehousing, inputs and insurance. Firms report this has hurt their competitiveness compared to competitors in Iran and India. The increased costs are also reducing the potential for Pakistani manufactured goods to gain a larger share of bilateral trade, as targeted by the two countries.
Trade between Afghanistan and Pakistan has been declining in recent years due to several factors including slow pace of reforms, security issues, and lack of implementation of agreements; while addressing barriers like cross-border banking and infrastructure is important, fully implementing decisions from joint economic council meetings and revising the transit trade agreement could help boost trade in the near term; however, ongoing challenges around customs procedures, insurance costs, and lack of banking facilities will still hamper efforts to significantly increase bilateral trade flows.
This chapter examines trade and transit cooperation between Pakistan and Afghanistan. It finds that while Pakistan remains Afghanistan's largest trading partner, trade has been increasing with other partners like India and Iran in recent years. The top exports from Pakistan to Afghanistan include cement, food, and oil. However, Afghan imports through illicit means and informal trade pose challenges for Pakistani industries. Improving transit procedures and reducing costs could help scale up regional economic cooperation and mitigate risks of smuggling. The chapter argues for extending bilateral cooperation to cross-border investment and trade in services.
Arsalan Yaqoob is a a corporate finance professional by profession and also passionate about transforming organisations and lives; he is dedicated, ambitious and goal-driven trainer with 8 years’ progressive experience in professional training of Business Analysis subjects (E pillars) of CIMA, BMS of ICAP, Strategic Business Leader (SBL) of ACCA. ......... Almighty ALLAH SWT has equipped him with professional certifications and academic qualification, in professional he is Professional Accounting Affiliate (PAA-ICAP), ACCA Member, PIPFA Member, and CIA (USA) Member and in academic he has completed post-graduation / 16 years of education from Karachi University. His accountancy career was started with big audit firm, first move to industry was with TRG (A high-tech US Based MNC conglomerate) group Companies (namely Digital Globe Services – DGS Group) listed on London Stock Exchange (AIM), at present he is working as a senior finance professional at leading organization in healthcare industry (Services & Pharma Manufacturing, both). ...... As a true transformational trainer his journey has been like a roller coaster from ICAP Inter-firm presentation skills competition to teaching ACCA Paper F4 at Hot FM105; he champed Chartered Accountants’ Students Association Conference 2012 as a lead presenter on Topic “Hope sustains life” – As a professional trainer he is loaded to connect Academia with Corporate Industry, his next big thing is to progress with his methodology and sharing the same in books and videos.
This document summarizes the economic relations between Pakistan and Afghanistan. It discusses that Pakistan provides Afghanistan access to seaports and the two countries have established various mechanisms like the Joint Economic Council to facilitate bilateral and transit trade. However, political tensions sometimes hamper economic cooperation. The document argues that deeper political cooperation is needed to further liberalize trade between the countries and realizes the economic benefits of closer economic ties.
1) The document discusses several topics related to Pakistan including the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), regional security dynamics, sacred art and architecture, and national action plans.
2) It provides details on CPEC including its significance, concerns about debt and impact on the economy, and opportunities it may provide for improved infrastructure, trade, and cultural exchange.
3) One article discusses how artists and calligraphists have expressed their devotion to Allah through buildings, art, and calligraphy using Arabic letters from Allah's name.
This document provides estimates of the informal flow of merchandise from India to Pakistan. It finds that the value of informal trade between the two countries is approximately $1.79 billion annually. Several key sectors are involved in informal trade, including fruits and vegetables, textiles, automotive parts, jewelry, cosmetics, medicines, tobacco, herbs, spices, paper products, and crockery. Major transit routes for informal goods include Dubai, Kabul, Kandahar, Chaman, and Bander Abbas. While informal trade has benefits, it also poses challenges such as loss of government revenue and threat to human health if safety standards are not met for items like food and medicines. The document calls for measures to formalize current
Trade between Afghanistan and Pakistan has been declining in recent years due to several factors including slow pace of reforms, security issues, and lack of implementation of agreements; while addressing barriers like cross-border banking and infrastructure is important, fully implementing decisions from joint economic council meetings and revising the transit trade agreement could help boost trade in the near term; however, ongoing challenges around customs procedures, insurance costs, and lack of banking facilities will still hamper efforts to significantly increase bilateral trade flows.
This chapter examines trade and transit cooperation between Pakistan and Afghanistan. It finds that while Pakistan remains Afghanistan's largest trading partner, trade has been increasing with other partners like India and Iran in recent years. The top exports from Pakistan to Afghanistan include cement, food, and oil. However, Afghan imports through illicit means and informal trade pose challenges for Pakistani industries. Improving transit procedures and reducing costs could help scale up regional economic cooperation and mitigate risks of smuggling. The chapter argues for extending bilateral cooperation to cross-border investment and trade in services.
Arsalan Yaqoob is a a corporate finance professional by profession and also passionate about transforming organisations and lives; he is dedicated, ambitious and goal-driven trainer with 8 years’ progressive experience in professional training of Business Analysis subjects (E pillars) of CIMA, BMS of ICAP, Strategic Business Leader (SBL) of ACCA. ......... Almighty ALLAH SWT has equipped him with professional certifications and academic qualification, in professional he is Professional Accounting Affiliate (PAA-ICAP), ACCA Member, PIPFA Member, and CIA (USA) Member and in academic he has completed post-graduation / 16 years of education from Karachi University. His accountancy career was started with big audit firm, first move to industry was with TRG (A high-tech US Based MNC conglomerate) group Companies (namely Digital Globe Services – DGS Group) listed on London Stock Exchange (AIM), at present he is working as a senior finance professional at leading organization in healthcare industry (Services & Pharma Manufacturing, both). ...... As a true transformational trainer his journey has been like a roller coaster from ICAP Inter-firm presentation skills competition to teaching ACCA Paper F4 at Hot FM105; he champed Chartered Accountants’ Students Association Conference 2012 as a lead presenter on Topic “Hope sustains life” – As a professional trainer he is loaded to connect Academia with Corporate Industry, his next big thing is to progress with his methodology and sharing the same in books and videos.
This document summarizes the economic relations between Pakistan and Afghanistan. It discusses that Pakistan provides Afghanistan access to seaports and the two countries have established various mechanisms like the Joint Economic Council to facilitate bilateral and transit trade. However, political tensions sometimes hamper economic cooperation. The document argues that deeper political cooperation is needed to further liberalize trade between the countries and realizes the economic benefits of closer economic ties.
1) The document discusses several topics related to Pakistan including the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), regional security dynamics, sacred art and architecture, and national action plans.
2) It provides details on CPEC including its significance, concerns about debt and impact on the economy, and opportunities it may provide for improved infrastructure, trade, and cultural exchange.
3) One article discusses how artists and calligraphists have expressed their devotion to Allah through buildings, art, and calligraphy using Arabic letters from Allah's name.
This document provides estimates of the informal flow of merchandise from India to Pakistan. It finds that the value of informal trade between the two countries is approximately $1.79 billion annually. Several key sectors are involved in informal trade, including fruits and vegetables, textiles, automotive parts, jewelry, cosmetics, medicines, tobacco, herbs, spices, paper products, and crockery. Major transit routes for informal goods include Dubai, Kabul, Kandahar, Chaman, and Bander Abbas. While informal trade has benefits, it also poses challenges such as loss of government revenue and threat to human health if safety standards are not met for items like food and medicines. The document calls for measures to formalize current
This document provides an overview and analysis of economic relations between China and the countries of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). It finds that while China is a major trade and investment partner for ASEAN as a whole, the significance of the relationship varies considerably between wealthy, middle-income, and low-income ASEAN members. Since the implementation of the ASEAN-China Free Trade Area in 2010, ASEAN's goods trade balance with China has shifted to a large deficit. The document also examines China's trade and investment ties with individual ASEAN countries.
This document discusses the growing socioeconomic crisis in Pakistan. It provides an overview of Pakistan's population, GDP, economic growth rates, budget priorities, tax rates, income inequality, water resources, and other development indicators in comparison to India. It also examines issues such as the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor, urbanization trends, youth unemployment, the illicit narcotics trade, military spending, and the impacts of climate change on water resources in the Indus River basin. Overall, the document presents a concerning outlook for Pakistan's economy and stability if ongoing issues are not addressed.
The OSCE Parliamentary Assembly held its 15th winter meeting in Vienna, Austria to discuss the refugee crisis and situation in Ukraine. Kazakh Senate Chairman Kassym-Jomart Tokayev addressed the assembly, urging implementation of the Minsk agreements to solve the Ukraine crisis and cooperation to combat threats like terrorism. He invited members to a May conference in Astana on religions against terrorism and updated the group on Kazakhstan's reforms under the Plan of the Nation, including upcoming early parliamentary elections monitored by OSCE observers.
Jharkhand is a mineral-rich state in eastern India. It has extensive reserves of coal, iron ore, copper, and other minerals. Mining and mineral extraction are major industries. Jharkhand produces 40% of India's minerals and is the sole producer of coking coal, uranium, and pyrite. The state has experienced strong economic growth in recent years, with its GSDP increasing at a CAGR of over 10% between 2011-2012 and 2017-2018. Tertiary sector activities like trade and services have been the largest contributor to GSVA. The government is working to develop infrastructure and promote sectors like tourism to further improve the state's economy.
Jharkhand is a mineral-rich state in eastern India known for its abundant coal and iron ore reserves. It accounts for 40% of India's mineral wealth and is a leading producer of minerals, steel, and electricity. The state aims to increase annual steel production from 14.9 million tonnes in 2015-16 to 25 million tonnes by 2017-18. Jharkhand also has a strong tourism industry and is the largest producer of tussar silk in India. The state government is working to improve infrastructure and attract investment in key sectors like mining, manufacturing, and renewable energy.
The document provides information about the state of Rajasthan in India. Some key points:
- Rajasthan has a thriving tourism industry centered around historic palaces and forts, as well as wildlife sanctuaries and desert locations.
- It is a leading producer of agricultural products like oilseeds, spices and cereals. There are opportunities in organic farming and infrastructure development related to agriculture.
- The state's economy has grown steadily with GDP expanding at an average rate of 5.16% from 2011-12 to 2016-17. Renewable energy such as solar and wind are a focus.
Rajasthan has a thriving tourism industry centered around its historic palaces. It is also a leading producer of agricultural products. The state has experienced strong economic growth, with its GDP expanding at a CAGR of 12.32% from 2005-06 to 2015-16. Rajasthan has immense potential for renewable energy generation, particularly solar and wind power. The state offers a conducive policy environment for business and is focusing on attracting large investments.
This document summarizes the next phase of developments expected under the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) initiative. It discusses how early harvest projects in the energy and infrastructure sectors are starting to benefit Pakistan's economy. The next phase is expected to focus on developing nine Special Economic Zones. It also analyzes the impact on bilateral trade between China and Pakistan, noting growing Chinese exports and efforts to increase Pakistani exports. Addressing Pakistan's trade deficit with China and fostering conditions for local businesses to export to Chinese markets will be important for maximizing the economic benefits of CPEC.
The document discusses the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) collaborative research grant (CPEC-CRG) program. The CPEC-CRG aims to support research partnerships between Chinese and Pakistani academics to address problems related to CPEC projects and promote socioeconomic development. It will provide funding of 50-100 million Pakistani rupees over 3 years for research related to sustainable agriculture, clean water, health, science and technology, poverty alleviation, and other areas. The selection process will be merit-based and transparent to hire researchers to conduct collaborative research between the two countries.
India’s behaviour towards elimination of trade barriers in south asiaSardar Ahmad
The study focuses on India‘s role in economic cooperation
in South Asia. It explores: what role India has played in
conclusion of different trading arrangements in the region;
and how far India has dispelled the economic concerns of
smaller regional countries (SRCs). India played leading role
in conclusion of SAPTA and SAFTA as well as bilateral
trade arrangements with Bhutan, Bangladesh, Maldives,
Nepal and Sri Lanka. The agreements with Nepal and Sri
Lanka encountered difficulties after showing initial
successes. SRCs including Bangladesh and Pakistan face
obstacles in enhancing their exports to India. New Delhi has
so far not taken enough measures to address the concerns of
the SRCs. The prevailing tariffs, non-tariff and para-tariff
barriers impede access to Indian market for regional
products. The resultant widening trade imbalances strain
relations between India and SRCs and also impede the
development of overall regional cooperation process in
South Asia.
Rajasthan has a thriving tourism industry centered around its historic palaces. It is a leading producer of agricultural products and has experienced strong economic growth. The state focuses on renewable energy and has a conducive policy environment for industry. Rajasthan is one of India's largest crude oil producers.
Rajasthan has a thriving tourism industry centered around its historic palaces. It is a leading producer of agricultural products in India. The state has focused on renewable energy and seen strong economic growth with its GDP expanding at a CAGR of 11.6% from 2011-12 to 2017-18. Rajasthan also has a conducive policy environment and is one of India's largest crude oil producers.
23rd june ,2016 daily global,regional & local rice e newsletter by rice...Riceplus Magazine
Daily Global Rice e-Newsletter is a news gathering service related to Rice stake holders. It is designed to help you keep up to date with the rice news you need to know everything about RICE. Riceplus Magazine has a range of services available for individuals and organizations from free email alerts to professional monitoring with real-time email delivery. News letters are shared under the umbrella of Riceplus Magazine (RPM). RPM also delivers more customized services and tailored News Feeds to media, websites, internet in a variety of formats. You can promote services and producing by giving advertisement in daily news letters and blog including website www.ricepluss.com.
Daily global news is highly and widely circulated to rice industry, R&D organizations and policy makers including related organizations across the globe.
Contact: Mujahid Ali mujhaid.riceplus@gmail.com
www.riceplusmagazine.blogspot.com & www.ricepluss.com
Maharashtra has the highest GSDP among Indian states, contributing 14.89% to India's GDP in 2017-18. The state attracted the highest FDI in India between April 2000 to June 2018, receiving US$ 118.13 billion. Mumbai is India's financial capital and Pune is an educational hub. Jawaharlal Nehru Port is India's largest container port. Maharashtra is a leader in industry and manufacturing and a top producer of sugarcane and pomegranates.
Rajasthan has a thriving tourism industry centered around its historic palaces. It is a leading producer of agricultural products and crude oil. The state has focused on renewable energy and provides a conducive policy environment for business. Rajasthan's economy has grown strongly, with services becoming the largest sector, and the state continues to invest in agriculture, infrastructure, and social development.
Jharkhand is a mineral-rich state in eastern India known for its mining industry. It has significant reserves of coal, iron ore, copper, and other minerals. Some key points:
- Jharkhand has around 40% of India's mineral reserves and is one of the largest producers of minerals like coal, iron ore, and copper.
- Major industries include mining, steel production, and mineral extraction. The state accounts for 20-25% of India's total steel production.
- The government aims to increase steel production from 14.9 million tonnes in 2015-16 to 25 million tonnes by 2017-18.
- Other resources in the state include uranium (
Maharashtra is the most industrialized state in India with the highest GDP and FDI. It accounts for 14.8% of India's GDP. Mumbai is India's financial hub while Pune is an educational hub. The state has well-developed infrastructure including ports and power. Maharashtra is a leader in sectors like automobiles, pharmaceuticals and IT/ITeS. It is also a major producer of agricultural crops like sugarcane, cotton, rice and fruits. The state government is focused on further boosting the economy through policies supporting industry, infrastructure, agriculture and skill development.
The document provides information on Rajasthan's economy, industries, and business opportunities. Some key points include:
- Rajasthan has a thriving tourism industry centered around historic palaces in Jaipur and Udaipur, and is the largest producer of oilseeds, cereals, and spices in India.
- The state economy has grown at a CAGR of 12.38% between 2004-05 to 2015-16, with services contributing 48% to GSDP.
- Rajasthan has immense potential for renewable energy such as solar and wind power.
- The document outlines the state's vision to promote economic development, education, agriculture, and infrastructure by 2022.
Jharkhand is a mineral-rich state in eastern India known for its coal and iron ore reserves. It accounts for 40% of India's mineral resources and 29% of coal reserves. Some key facts about Jharkhand's economy:
- It is the second largest producer of iron ore in India, with 25.7% of national reserves.
- Jharkhand produces 20-25% of India's total steel and is the sole producer of coking coal, uranium, and pyrite in the country.
- The state aims to increase annual steel production from 14.9 million tons in 2015-16 to 25 million tons by 2017-18.
Rajasthan has experienced strong economic growth in recent years. Its Gross State Domestic Product expanded at a compound annual growth rate of 11.60% between 2011-12 and 2017-18. The state's Net State Domestic Product also increased at a robust CAGR of 11.45% during this period. Rajasthan's per capita GSDP and NSDP increased at CAGRs of 10.02% and 9.86%, respectively between 2011-12 and 2017-18, reaching US$1,730.64 and US$1,560.14 in 2017-18. The state has focused on developing sectors like tourism and renewable energy.
This document is a thesis proposal by Hanif Ullah about improving cross-border trade between Pakistan and Afghanistan through the Ghulam Khan border crossing. The proposal discusses how smuggling has caused significant losses of government revenue. It aims to facilitate legal trade by providing a dedicated trade space at the Ghulam Khan border crossing to help the local economy and promote peace between the two countries. The research will examine case studies of other trade centers and identify opportunities to formalize and increase cross-border trade volume through the Ghulam Khan route.
Pakistan and Iran have long-standing economic and cultural ties. Recent sanctions relief has improved prospects for increased trade, including through projects like the Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline. However, security issues, political influences, and financial obstacles have previously impeded greater economic cooperation. With recent banking agreements and KPMG's renewed presence in Iran, there is now an opportunity to further develop both countries' energy and financial sectors through strengthened bilateral cooperation.
This document provides an overview and analysis of economic relations between China and the countries of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). It finds that while China is a major trade and investment partner for ASEAN as a whole, the significance of the relationship varies considerably between wealthy, middle-income, and low-income ASEAN members. Since the implementation of the ASEAN-China Free Trade Area in 2010, ASEAN's goods trade balance with China has shifted to a large deficit. The document also examines China's trade and investment ties with individual ASEAN countries.
This document discusses the growing socioeconomic crisis in Pakistan. It provides an overview of Pakistan's population, GDP, economic growth rates, budget priorities, tax rates, income inequality, water resources, and other development indicators in comparison to India. It also examines issues such as the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor, urbanization trends, youth unemployment, the illicit narcotics trade, military spending, and the impacts of climate change on water resources in the Indus River basin. Overall, the document presents a concerning outlook for Pakistan's economy and stability if ongoing issues are not addressed.
The OSCE Parliamentary Assembly held its 15th winter meeting in Vienna, Austria to discuss the refugee crisis and situation in Ukraine. Kazakh Senate Chairman Kassym-Jomart Tokayev addressed the assembly, urging implementation of the Minsk agreements to solve the Ukraine crisis and cooperation to combat threats like terrorism. He invited members to a May conference in Astana on religions against terrorism and updated the group on Kazakhstan's reforms under the Plan of the Nation, including upcoming early parliamentary elections monitored by OSCE observers.
Jharkhand is a mineral-rich state in eastern India. It has extensive reserves of coal, iron ore, copper, and other minerals. Mining and mineral extraction are major industries. Jharkhand produces 40% of India's minerals and is the sole producer of coking coal, uranium, and pyrite. The state has experienced strong economic growth in recent years, with its GSDP increasing at a CAGR of over 10% between 2011-2012 and 2017-2018. Tertiary sector activities like trade and services have been the largest contributor to GSVA. The government is working to develop infrastructure and promote sectors like tourism to further improve the state's economy.
Jharkhand is a mineral-rich state in eastern India known for its abundant coal and iron ore reserves. It accounts for 40% of India's mineral wealth and is a leading producer of minerals, steel, and electricity. The state aims to increase annual steel production from 14.9 million tonnes in 2015-16 to 25 million tonnes by 2017-18. Jharkhand also has a strong tourism industry and is the largest producer of tussar silk in India. The state government is working to improve infrastructure and attract investment in key sectors like mining, manufacturing, and renewable energy.
The document provides information about the state of Rajasthan in India. Some key points:
- Rajasthan has a thriving tourism industry centered around historic palaces and forts, as well as wildlife sanctuaries and desert locations.
- It is a leading producer of agricultural products like oilseeds, spices and cereals. There are opportunities in organic farming and infrastructure development related to agriculture.
- The state's economy has grown steadily with GDP expanding at an average rate of 5.16% from 2011-12 to 2016-17. Renewable energy such as solar and wind are a focus.
Rajasthan has a thriving tourism industry centered around its historic palaces. It is also a leading producer of agricultural products. The state has experienced strong economic growth, with its GDP expanding at a CAGR of 12.32% from 2005-06 to 2015-16. Rajasthan has immense potential for renewable energy generation, particularly solar and wind power. The state offers a conducive policy environment for business and is focusing on attracting large investments.
This document summarizes the next phase of developments expected under the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) initiative. It discusses how early harvest projects in the energy and infrastructure sectors are starting to benefit Pakistan's economy. The next phase is expected to focus on developing nine Special Economic Zones. It also analyzes the impact on bilateral trade between China and Pakistan, noting growing Chinese exports and efforts to increase Pakistani exports. Addressing Pakistan's trade deficit with China and fostering conditions for local businesses to export to Chinese markets will be important for maximizing the economic benefits of CPEC.
The document discusses the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) collaborative research grant (CPEC-CRG) program. The CPEC-CRG aims to support research partnerships between Chinese and Pakistani academics to address problems related to CPEC projects and promote socioeconomic development. It will provide funding of 50-100 million Pakistani rupees over 3 years for research related to sustainable agriculture, clean water, health, science and technology, poverty alleviation, and other areas. The selection process will be merit-based and transparent to hire researchers to conduct collaborative research between the two countries.
India’s behaviour towards elimination of trade barriers in south asiaSardar Ahmad
The study focuses on India‘s role in economic cooperation
in South Asia. It explores: what role India has played in
conclusion of different trading arrangements in the region;
and how far India has dispelled the economic concerns of
smaller regional countries (SRCs). India played leading role
in conclusion of SAPTA and SAFTA as well as bilateral
trade arrangements with Bhutan, Bangladesh, Maldives,
Nepal and Sri Lanka. The agreements with Nepal and Sri
Lanka encountered difficulties after showing initial
successes. SRCs including Bangladesh and Pakistan face
obstacles in enhancing their exports to India. New Delhi has
so far not taken enough measures to address the concerns of
the SRCs. The prevailing tariffs, non-tariff and para-tariff
barriers impede access to Indian market for regional
products. The resultant widening trade imbalances strain
relations between India and SRCs and also impede the
development of overall regional cooperation process in
South Asia.
Rajasthan has a thriving tourism industry centered around its historic palaces. It is a leading producer of agricultural products and has experienced strong economic growth. The state focuses on renewable energy and has a conducive policy environment for industry. Rajasthan is one of India's largest crude oil producers.
Rajasthan has a thriving tourism industry centered around its historic palaces. It is a leading producer of agricultural products in India. The state has focused on renewable energy and seen strong economic growth with its GDP expanding at a CAGR of 11.6% from 2011-12 to 2017-18. Rajasthan also has a conducive policy environment and is one of India's largest crude oil producers.
23rd june ,2016 daily global,regional & local rice e newsletter by rice...Riceplus Magazine
Daily Global Rice e-Newsletter is a news gathering service related to Rice stake holders. It is designed to help you keep up to date with the rice news you need to know everything about RICE. Riceplus Magazine has a range of services available for individuals and organizations from free email alerts to professional monitoring with real-time email delivery. News letters are shared under the umbrella of Riceplus Magazine (RPM). RPM also delivers more customized services and tailored News Feeds to media, websites, internet in a variety of formats. You can promote services and producing by giving advertisement in daily news letters and blog including website www.ricepluss.com.
Daily global news is highly and widely circulated to rice industry, R&D organizations and policy makers including related organizations across the globe.
Contact: Mujahid Ali mujhaid.riceplus@gmail.com
www.riceplusmagazine.blogspot.com & www.ricepluss.com
Maharashtra has the highest GSDP among Indian states, contributing 14.89% to India's GDP in 2017-18. The state attracted the highest FDI in India between April 2000 to June 2018, receiving US$ 118.13 billion. Mumbai is India's financial capital and Pune is an educational hub. Jawaharlal Nehru Port is India's largest container port. Maharashtra is a leader in industry and manufacturing and a top producer of sugarcane and pomegranates.
Rajasthan has a thriving tourism industry centered around its historic palaces. It is a leading producer of agricultural products and crude oil. The state has focused on renewable energy and provides a conducive policy environment for business. Rajasthan's economy has grown strongly, with services becoming the largest sector, and the state continues to invest in agriculture, infrastructure, and social development.
Jharkhand is a mineral-rich state in eastern India known for its mining industry. It has significant reserves of coal, iron ore, copper, and other minerals. Some key points:
- Jharkhand has around 40% of India's mineral reserves and is one of the largest producers of minerals like coal, iron ore, and copper.
- Major industries include mining, steel production, and mineral extraction. The state accounts for 20-25% of India's total steel production.
- The government aims to increase steel production from 14.9 million tonnes in 2015-16 to 25 million tonnes by 2017-18.
- Other resources in the state include uranium (
Maharashtra is the most industrialized state in India with the highest GDP and FDI. It accounts for 14.8% of India's GDP. Mumbai is India's financial hub while Pune is an educational hub. The state has well-developed infrastructure including ports and power. Maharashtra is a leader in sectors like automobiles, pharmaceuticals and IT/ITeS. It is also a major producer of agricultural crops like sugarcane, cotton, rice and fruits. The state government is focused on further boosting the economy through policies supporting industry, infrastructure, agriculture and skill development.
The document provides information on Rajasthan's economy, industries, and business opportunities. Some key points include:
- Rajasthan has a thriving tourism industry centered around historic palaces in Jaipur and Udaipur, and is the largest producer of oilseeds, cereals, and spices in India.
- The state economy has grown at a CAGR of 12.38% between 2004-05 to 2015-16, with services contributing 48% to GSDP.
- Rajasthan has immense potential for renewable energy such as solar and wind power.
- The document outlines the state's vision to promote economic development, education, agriculture, and infrastructure by 2022.
Jharkhand is a mineral-rich state in eastern India known for its coal and iron ore reserves. It accounts for 40% of India's mineral resources and 29% of coal reserves. Some key facts about Jharkhand's economy:
- It is the second largest producer of iron ore in India, with 25.7% of national reserves.
- Jharkhand produces 20-25% of India's total steel and is the sole producer of coking coal, uranium, and pyrite in the country.
- The state aims to increase annual steel production from 14.9 million tons in 2015-16 to 25 million tons by 2017-18.
Rajasthan has experienced strong economic growth in recent years. Its Gross State Domestic Product expanded at a compound annual growth rate of 11.60% between 2011-12 and 2017-18. The state's Net State Domestic Product also increased at a robust CAGR of 11.45% during this period. Rajasthan's per capita GSDP and NSDP increased at CAGRs of 10.02% and 9.86%, respectively between 2011-12 and 2017-18, reaching US$1,730.64 and US$1,560.14 in 2017-18. The state has focused on developing sectors like tourism and renewable energy.
This document is a thesis proposal by Hanif Ullah about improving cross-border trade between Pakistan and Afghanistan through the Ghulam Khan border crossing. The proposal discusses how smuggling has caused significant losses of government revenue. It aims to facilitate legal trade by providing a dedicated trade space at the Ghulam Khan border crossing to help the local economy and promote peace between the two countries. The research will examine case studies of other trade centers and identify opportunities to formalize and increase cross-border trade volume through the Ghulam Khan route.
Pakistan and Iran have long-standing economic and cultural ties. Recent sanctions relief has improved prospects for increased trade, including through projects like the Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline. However, security issues, political influences, and financial obstacles have previously impeded greater economic cooperation. With recent banking agreements and KPMG's renewed presence in Iran, there is now an opportunity to further develop both countries' energy and financial sectors through strengthened bilateral cooperation.
Aghan Transit Trade Treaty with Pakistan (Pharmaceuticals)Arsalan Yaqoob
Arsalan Yaqoob is a a corporate finance professional by profession and also passionate about transforming organisations and lives; he is dedicated, ambitious and goal-driven trainer with 8 years’ progressive experience in professional training of Business Analysis subjects (E pillars) of CIMA, BMS of ICAP, Strategic Business Leader (SBL) of ACCA.
.........
Almighty ALLAH SWT has equipped him with professional certifications and academic qualification, in professional he is Professional Accounting Affiliate (PAA-ICAP), ACCA Member, PIPFA Member, and CIA (USA) Member and in academic he has completed post-graduation / 16 years of education from Karachi University. His accountancy career was started with big audit firm, first move to industry was with TRG (A high-tech US Based MNC conglomerate) group Companies (namely Digital Globe Services – DGS Group) listed on London Stock Exchange (AIM), at present he is working as a senior finance professional at leading organization in healthcare industry (Services & Pharma Manufacturing, both).
......
As a true transformational trainer his journey has been like a roller coaster from ICAP Inter-firm presentation skills competition to teaching ACCA Paper F4 at Hot FM105; he champed Chartered Accountants’ Students Association Conference 2012 as a lead presenter on Topic “Hope sustains life” – As a professional trainer he is loaded to connect Academia with Corporate Industry, his next big thing is to progress with his methodology and sharing the same in books and videos.
The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), also known as the One Belt One Road (OBOR) (Chinese: 一带一路) or the Silk Road Economic Belt and the 21st-century Maritime Silk Road (Chinese: 丝绸之路经济带和21世纪海上丝绸之路), is a development strategy adopted by the Chinese government involving infrastructure development and investments in 152 countries and international organizations in Europe, Asia, Middle East, Latin America and Africa. This paper provides some perspectives from Pakistan. We also discuss the next phase of CPEC.
Review of FBR Export Promotion & Exemption Schemes
---
The Government of Pakistan has approved several export promotional schemes at the
federal and provincial level. Besides, FBR has tax-related export-oriented schemes which
incentivize exports. Traditionally, these schemes were limited to five zero-rated sectors,
however realization has grown that a level playing field should be created where similar
schemes should be available to potential and new export sectors. While this thinking
takes ground, the private sector in erstwhile zero-rated sectors also complains about the
difficulties in accessing the export-oriented schemes allowed by FBR most notably,
manufacturing under bond, Duty and Tax Remission of Exports Scheme, Duty Drawback,
and Export Oriented Units and Small and Medium Enterprises Rules.
International North-South Transport Corridor (INSTC), is a multi modal transportation established in 12 SEP 2000 in St. Petersburg, by Iran, Russia and India for the purpose of promoting transportation cooperation among the Member States. This corridor connects India Ocean and Persian Gulf to the Caspian Sea via Islamic republic of IRAN, then is connected to St. Petersburg and North European via Russian Federation.
The INSTC was expanded to include eleven new members, namely: Republic of Azerbaijan, Republic of Armenia, Republic of Kazakhstan, Kyrgyz Republic, Republic of Tajikistan, Republic of Turkey, Republic of Ukraine, Republic of Belarus, Oman, Syria, Bulgaria (Observer).
Ports in India handle around 95% of the country's international trade volume. Cargo traffic at major ports has increased at a CAGR of 2.73% between FY08-18, reaching 679.36 million tonnes in FY18. Non-major ports are also growing rapidly and now account for 42% of total port traffic. The government has launched various initiatives such as the Sagarmala project to develop port infrastructure and increase capacity to 3,130 MT by 2020. Major commodities handled by ports include coal, iron ore, fertilizers and containers.
This document provides an analysis of the implications of non-tariff barriers (NTBs) on Pakistan's trade. It discusses Pakistan's NTB regulations and the effects of NTBs between Pakistan and neighboring countries like India. The analysis finds that India has more restrictive trade policies and higher NTBs than Pakistan. Reducing NTBs could significantly increase bilateral trade between India and Pakistan, especially if Pakistan were to grant Most Favored Nation status to India. The document also examines Pakistan's tariff and non-tariff reform policies.
The paper aims to identify the various types of non-tariff measures (NTMs) affecting Pakistan’s textile sector. The textile industry is of great importance to Pakistan and is a major contributor to its gross domestic product. However, Pakistan’s textile exports are facing market access challenges, in part due to trade barriers of some developed countries. An in-depth analysis of Pakistan’s textile sector and NTMs country-wise and category-wise for the period of 2010-2017 was conducted. Statistics about the textile industry of Pakistan were obtained from the State Bank of Pakistan, while categorical export data on NTMs was taken from UNCTAD’s TRAINS database. Face-to-face informal interviews were also conducted with 15 participants from relevant stakeholder groups, including public and private sector officials.
The authors found that Pakistan’s global share in textiles has declined significantly since 2010 and that it relies heavily on a few international markets such as the United States, China and the European Union. Turkey was found to have the highest number of NTMs targeting textile products, followed by the United States. Additionally, not only do countries importing Pakistani goods impose NTMs, Pakistan’s own export procedures also hamper the trade. Interviewed exporters mentioned that they face difficulties in the costly and time-consuming acquisition of certification, whereas Government officials claimed the certification process improved competitiveness. Exporters also complained about the high cost of doing business, which results in the shifting of exports to China, Bangladesh and India.
The paper recommends that trade agreements and their implementation be rationalized and simplified, uniform certification requirements for exporters be implemented to save costs and time, cheaper tests be made available in Pakistan rather than abroad, and that business-to-business forums be developed to promote information exchange. It is also suggested that a clear framework to deal with NTMs is needed. The development of Pakistan’s textile exports will be difficult to sustain without addressing these challenges.
Pakistan is facing a balance of payments crisis as its current account deficit has reached over $12 billion. This is due to negative growth in exports and high growth in imports. Pakistan's total debt has also increased 11% in the last fiscal year. Weak trade diplomacy has contributed to declining exports to key trading partners like China, US, Afghanistan, and Iran. To address its balance of payments issues, Pakistan needs to improve its foreign policy to boost exports and pursue free trade agreements, in addition to domestic measures like adjusting its exchange rate, restricting non-essential imports, and increasing remittances.
Aviation as an industry is structurally extremely unattractive. It is very difficult to make profit in this industry. The industry is, weighed down by regulations, and influenced by several uncontrollable factors. The combined effect of these factors is historically the industry has never earned a rate of return above its investors’ capital; in fact, it has destroyed more money than it has created. The main objective of the paper is to highlight the major characteristics of the industry. Factors such as cost of oil or security have direct impact on operational effectiveness and risk management of an airline company. Factors such as natural disasters or health emergencies and socio-political culture of a country too affect the financial health of the industry. The paper deals with the Indian Civil Aviation Industry. This paper is a theoretical review. by providing some suggestions.
Major ports in India handled 679.36 million tonnes of cargo in FY18, growing at a CAGR of 2.73% over FY08-18. Cargo capacity at major ports increased from 505 million tonnes in FY07 to 1,451 million tonnes in FY18. Solid cargo contributes the largest share of traffic, followed by liquid cargo and containers. The document provides an overview of ports in India, including categories of ports, major ports, cargo traffic trends, cargo profiles, and capacity and profit increases in recent years.
Ports in India handle around 95% of the country's international trade volume. Cargo traffic at major ports has increased at a CAGR of 2.73% between FY08-18, reaching 679.36 million tonnes in FY18. Capacity at major ports has also increased over the years, growing to 1,451 million tonnes in FY18 from 505 million tonnes in FY07. Non-major ports are also gaining importance, with their share of total cargo traffic rising to 42% in FY18. Various initiatives such as Sagarmala and developing new mega ports aim to further boost port infrastructure and capacity in India.
The document provides an overview of ports in India. It notes that ports in India handle around 95% of the country's international trade volume. Major developments in the ports sector include increasing private participation, the development of port-based special economic zones near major ports, and a focus on increasing draft depths and developing specialist terminals. The government is also targeting to power all major ports with renewable energy by 2019. Traffic at major ports has been growing at a CAGR of 2.73% over FY08-18 and capacity has increased significantly over the years.
Export supply-chain-analysis of surgical instrumentsMOHSAN RAZA
This document summarizes an export supply chain analysis of Basmati rice exports from Pakistan to Iran and China. The analysis maps out the core business processes, actors, documents, and time required to export Basmati rice from Pakistan. It identifies bottlenecks that cause delays and makes recommendations to streamline the export process. Key findings include that it takes an average of 16 business days and 16 documents to complete the export supply chain. The goal is to boost Basmati rice exports by reducing bottlenecks and expediting the regional export of this important agricultural commodity.
Major ports in India saw steady growth in cargo traffic and capacity over the past decade. Cargo traffic at major ports grew at a CAGR of 2.5% from FY08-FY17 to reach 647 MMT in FY17. Capacity at major ports also increased over the years to reach 1,065 MMT in FY17, a CAGR of 7.75% since FY07. Non-major ports are also growing rapidly, handling over 42% of total cargo traffic in FY17, and traffic at non-major ports grew at a CAGR of 10.7% from FY07-FY16. The different cargo types saw varying growth rates over the
The document provides an overview of ports in India. It notes that ports handle 95% of India's international trade volume and capacity at major ports has grown from 505 million tonnes in FY07 to 1,477 million tonnes in FY19. Cargo traffic at major ports reached 679 million tonnes in FY18, growing at a CAGR of 2.73% from FY08-18. The document also discusses trends like increasing private participation in ports, the setting up of port-based special economic zones, a focus on improving draft depth, and plans for renewable energy use at ports.
Trade relationships between India and AfghanistanAfzalshah Sayed
Bilateral relations between the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan and India
Status of Afghanistan’s economy – Country Analysis
India’s foreign trade with Afghanistan
The document provides an overview of ports in India. It notes that cargo traffic at major ports reached 578.86 million tonnes in FY19, growing at a CAGR of 2.73% from FY08-18. Capacity at major ports has increased from 505 million tonnes in FY07 to a projected 1,477 million tonnes in FY19. Private participation is increasing in the ports sector and port-based special economic zones are being developed. The average turnaround time at major ports has decreased from 107 hours in FY12 to 72 hours in FY19.
Similar to Trade and Transit Cooperation with Afghanistan (20)
This report sheds light on the significance of digital trade integration for Pakistan and selected
Central Asian countries including Afghanistan, Kazakhstan, Tajikistan, and Uzbekistan. Digital trade
integration involves regulatory structures/policy designs, digital technologies, and business
processes along the entire global/regional digital value chain. Digital trade
integration requires free cross-border movement of not only digital products, services, and
technologies but also other manufactured goods, data, capital, talent, and ideas along with the
availability of integrated physical and virtual infrastructure. Hence, digital trade integration requires
the removal of digital trade barriers as well as extensive technology, and legal and policy
coordination between member states.
Countries around the world have actively engaged in establishing new and progressive bilateral and
regional trade agreements to boost trade and economic growth. The significance of digital trade has
increased considerably after the COVID-19 pandemic. Improvement in digital connectivity, ease in
regulations, and skilled workers are key factors to facilitate trade integration and promote the
growth of the e-commerce sector. The report examines the regional trade agreements of Pakistan
and selected Central Asian countries and their relevance for digital trade integration. It also
scrutinizes the challenges faced by the public institutions of Pakistan in the implementation of digital
trade policy. Besides this, the report also observes the challenges faced by SMEs dealing with digital
trade-related products.
The findings show that Pakistan and selected Central Asian countries are at different levels of digital
adoption, including mobile connectivity index and download speed of mobile and broadband.
Kazakhstan and Pakistan have a higher export and import volume compared with other countries.
However, neither country has any major trading partner from the countries selected in this study,
which demonstrates the lack of regional cooperation and the need for regional trade agreements to
boost bilateral and regional trade.
The report discusses the e-commerce laws of Pakistan and selected Central Asian countries, whereas
domestic policies and measures to increase digital trade are also reviewed. The countries are at a
different level in terms of implementing digital trade facilitation measures. Lack of effective
enforcement of intellectual property rights, non-tariff measures, foreign investment restrictions in
digital space, data and information costs, cyber security, and tax policy and administration are all key
policy issues that influence digital trade integration.
The study offers a way forward in which action points are provided for governments, the nongovernmental
sector (notably, business associations and networks), academia and think tanks, and
development partners. #DigitalTradeIntegration
#RegionalTradeAgreements
#EconomicGrowth
#DigitalConnectivity
#EcommerceLaws
The policy brief by the Sustainable Development Policy Institute (SDPI) outlines the urgent need to address the high consumption of Industrially Produced Trans Fatty Acids (iTFA) in Pakistan, which poses significant health risks, particularly in contributing to cardiovascular diseases. Despite being the second-highest per capita consumer of iTFA in the WHO-Eastern Mediterranean Region, Pakistan lacks comprehensive regulations and enforcement mechanisms to mitigate iTFA consumption effectively. The brief recommends a multi-faceted approach involving uniform standards, transparent enforcement, public awareness campaigns, capacity building for regulatory authorities, and collaboration with the food industry to promote healthier alternatives. It highlights the importance of political commitment, intersectoral collaboration, and public-private dialogue to successfully eliminate iTFA from the food supply chain and improve public health outcomes in Pakistan.
In his comprehensive analysis, Vaqar Ahmed highlights the challenges and impediments faced by Pakistan's trade and industrial policies, particularly concerning macroeconomic stability, energy shortages, rising costs, and regulatory constraints. The recent decline in the value of the Pakistani Rupee has further intensified issues for the manufacturing sector. The adverse macroeconomic conditions, including high inflation and a policy rate exceeding 20 percent, have hampered the sector's ability to secure working capital. Large firms' reluctance to operate in special economic zones due to supply-side gaps, coupled with global economic uncertainties, has delayed the next phase of the China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC). Ends with some policy recommendations.
Creating a conducive environment for sustainable economic development, improve living standards for all citizens, and secure a brighter future for the nation.
The document discusses the benefits of exercise for mental health. Regular physical activity can help reduce anxiety and depression and improve mood and cognitive functioning. Exercise causes chemical changes in the brain that may help boost feelings of calmness, happiness and focus.
The Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Urban Policy aims to transform KP's urban centers into engines of social, economic, and cultural growth by promoting vibrant communities, sustainable practices, and economic opportunities. It focuses on inclusive development, infrastructure improvement, efficient governance, environmental protection, and cultural preservation, aiming to make cities globally competitive and provide a high quality of life for all citizens. This policy, reviewed every five years, provides a roadmap for urban development in KP, seeking to create a brighter future for its residents.
This study aims to explain the macroeconomic and welfare impacts of changes in indirect taxes brought about in response to COVID-19. We study whether the tax relief provided for in the federal budget for fiscal year 2020-21 was effective in providing relief to private enterprises and the trade sector. We also study whether production subsidies granted during the first wave of COVID-19 were effectively able to support firms in the agricultural sector. This assessment allows us to draw lessons that may be useful for designing tax benefit policies amid future waves of the pandemic or during other emergency times.
The Government of Pakistan has offered export facilitation schemes
to exporters with the objectives to lower trade costs and expand
output. Currently, nearly one dozen export facilitation schemes are
active. They also include those which are run by the Federal Board
of Revenue (FBR). The question of ‘effectiveness’ of such schemes
in boosting Pakistan’s exports has remained a consistent theme of
interest among policymakers, international development partners
and private sector. This policy brief builds on a firm-level survey,
conducted by the Sustainable Development Policy Institute (SDPI),
and is an attempt to understand the effectiveness, overall gains,
and shortcomings of four major export facilitation schemes offered
by the FBR, including Duty and Tax Remission for Exports (DTRE),
Manufacturing Bond (MB), Export Oriented Unit (EOU) and Export
Facilitation Scheme (EFS). The study aims to provide insights on how
best to improve design of Export Facilitation Scheme 2021, which will
absorb all other schemes by the end of 2023.
The document discusses the benefits of exercise for mental health. Regular physical activity can help reduce anxiety and depression and improve mood and cognitive function. Exercise causes chemical changes in the brain that may help protect against mental illness and improve symptoms.
The Ministry of Commerce in Pakistan unveiled the National Tariff Policy 2019-24 (NTP 2019-
24) in November 2019. The core aims of the policy were to: i) remove tariff-related
anomalies in the short-term to lower businesses’ cost of inputs and increase their
turnover, ii) increase employment generation in the medium-term, and iii) gain
competitiveness and exports in the long-term.
After its announcement, there remains a need to analyze the effectiveness and
impact of the policy. SDPI team conducted primary research to assess the impact
of tariff policy on Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) with the help of a firm-level
survey.
This specific survey aims to bridge the evidence gap by providing an in-depth
analysis on the NTP-2019-24 impact in terms of its three prime objectives. Besides,
the study also attempts to understand the business community’s challenges and
expectations vis-à-vis tariff-related matters.
Digital trade is increasing rapidly throughout the world whereas digital platforms and Coronavirus have further enhanced the importance of the digital economy and digital trade. Countries are focusing on promoting digital trade and integration through various measures including free trade agreements and bilateral negotiations. This study examined digital trade as defined by WTO E-commerce work and USITC. The study included the items that come under the definition of digital trade and examined the digital trade volume of Pakistan from 2010-2020 through three-step methodology. This includes the identification of digital trade items based on Harmonized System at a six-digit level, examining trade volume for digital goods, and identification of top ten export and import items along with top ten markets for digital trade. Favorable government policies and measures have helped Pakistan in promoting digital trade flows. However, there is a need to develop information and communication technology infrastructure in Pakistan to flourish trading activities. Furthermore, Pakistan has to reduce the fiscal and trade barriers such as rules and regulations for foreign investment in digital space, data and information costs, and ensure online security and data protection to promote digital trade integration.
by Asif Javed & Vaqar Ahmed
This study presents a pathway for fostering regional digital trade integration through
South-South and Triangular cooperation. Our main study goals include answering the
following questions:
» What are the challenges faced in the digital trade sector of Afghanistan, Pakistan
and Sri Lanka? How can these be overcome through various cooperative models?
» How can inclusive regional and free trade agreements help to overcome barriers
and enable digital trade integration?
» What can Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) dealing with digital trade-related
products learn from literature on South-South and Triangular cooperation?
Suggested citation:
Ahmed, V. and Javed, M. Digital Trade Integration: South-South and Triangular
Cooperation in South Asia (unpublished). South-South Idea Paper Series, United Nations
Office for South-South Cooperation (UNOSSC),Washington D.C.New York, 2022.
Pakistan is facing numerous socioeconomic impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic, including on food security. Food insecurity, which is a long-standing issue, has become more visible since the pandemic. Covid-19 Responses for Equity (CORE) partner the Sustainable Development Policy Institute (SDPI) – a leading policy research thinktank – has been supporting the Government of Pakistan to maintain essential economic activity and protect workers and small producers during the pandemic. One notable contribution has been the development of a Food Security Portal, which is being used by the government to better manage food security in the country. It is the first track and trace system from farm to fork for essential food items.
URI
https://opendocs.ids.ac.uk/opendocs/handle/20.500.12413/17619
Citation
Suleri, A.Q.; Ahmed, V.; Ahmad, S.M.; Shah, Q.; Zahid, J. and Gatellier, K. (2022) Strengthening Food Security in Pakistan During the Covid-19 Pandemic, Covid-19 Responses for Equity (CORE) Stories of Change, Brighton: Institute of Development Studies, DOI: 10.19088/CORE.2022.008
This document provides an introduction to the book "Global Pakistan: Pakistan's Role in the International System". It makes three main points:
1. Pakistan's economy is integrated into the global market and is influenced by international economic forces like commodity prices, currency values, and trade rules that it cannot control.
2. Pakistan faces serious environmental challenges from global issues like climate change and plastic pollution that impact the country despite its small contribution to causing them. Higher temperatures and more extreme weather will threaten lives and livelihoods.
3. Cultural globalization is increasing the spread of Western cultural products, while Pakistani culture has less global influence. This imbalanced cultural exchange is driven by the market power of large Western corporations.
The Covid-19 pandemic and related
restrictions have had profound
socioeconomic impacts worldwide.
Governments have been faced with
responding urgently to mitigate such
effects, especially for the most
vulnerable. Covid-19 Responses for
Equity (CORE) partner Partnership for
Economic Policy (PEP) – a Southernled
organisation which believes that
evidence produced from an in-country
perspective, by empowered and
engaged local researchers and
policymakers, results in better policy
choices – has been working closely
with policymakers in Pakistan to
assess the Covid-19 impacts and the
effectiveness of current and potential
policies. As a result, PEP has helped
introduce tax reforms for the hardest
hit, agricultural subsidies for farmers,
and the reduction of trade tariffs for
struggling businesses.
The document discusses lessons learned from SEDI's experience brokering evidence to support decision-making in Pakistan's Ministry of Commerce and other government partners during the COVID-19 pandemic. Key lessons included:
1) Stakeholder engagement through a series of virtual dialogues helped inform government decisions and strengthened the use of stakeholder inputs.
2) A multi-pronged communication approach including media reporting and social media helped amplify key issues and keep conversations ongoing.
3) Ensuring an inclusive conversation with diverse stakeholders like women owners required dedicated effort to create a safe space for participation.
The document discusses lessons from successful pension reforms globally and within Pakistan that could help inform the Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa's ongoing efforts to transition to a more sustainable contributory pension system. It identifies five key lessons: 1) ensuring an inclusive reform process that represents all stakeholders; 2) reaching consensus on contribution ratios between employers and employees; 3) investing strategically for safe asset growth; 4) proactively managing risks through transparency; and 5) establishing a well-designed regulatory framework. The transition aims to reduce the growing fiscal burden of pensions on development spending while still meeting obligations to existing employees.
Marginalization of Researchers in the Global
South in Global, Regional, and National
Economic-Development Consulting
Authors Ramos E. Mabugu | Vaqar Ahmed | Margaret R Chitiga-Mabugu
| Kehinde O. Omotoso
Date February 2022
Working Paper 2022-05
PEP Working Paper Series
ISSN 2709-7331
More from Sustainable Development Policy Institute (20)
3 Simple Steps To Buy Verified Payoneer Account In 2024SEOSMMEARTH
Buy Verified Payoneer Account: Quick and Secure Way to Receive Payments
Buy Verified Payoneer Account With 100% secure documents, [ USA, UK, CA ]. Are you looking for a reliable and safe way to receive payments online? Then you need buy verified Payoneer account ! Payoneer is a global payment platform that allows businesses and individuals to send and receive money in over 200 countries.
If You Want To More Information just Contact Now:
Skype: SEOSMMEARTH
Telegram: @seosmmearth
Gmail: seosmmearth@gmail.com
❼❷⓿❺❻❷❽❷❼❽ Dpboss Matka Result Satta Matka Guessing Satta Fix jodi Kalyan Final ank Satta Matka Dpbos Final ank Satta Matta Matka 143 Kalyan Matka Guessing Final Matka Final ank Today Matka 420 Satta Batta Satta 143 Kalyan Chart Main Bazar Chart vip Matka Guessing Dpboss 143 Guessing Kalyan night
Company Valuation webinar series - Tuesday, 4 June 2024FelixPerez547899
This session provided an update as to the latest valuation data in the UK and then delved into a discussion on the upcoming election and the impacts on valuation. We finished, as always with a Q&A
Easily Verify Compliance and Security with Binance KYCAny kyc Account
Use our simple KYC verification guide to make sure your Binance account is safe and compliant. Discover the fundamentals, appreciate the significance of KYC, and trade on one of the biggest cryptocurrency exchanges with confidence.
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdownjeffkluth1
Introduction
The global retail industry has weathered numerous storms, with the financial crisis of 2008 serving as a poignant reminder of the sector's resilience and adaptability. However, as we navigate the complex landscape of 2024, retailers face a unique set of challenges that demand innovative strategies and a fundamental shift in mindset. This white paper contrasts the impact of the 2008 recession on the retail sector with the current headwinds retailers are grappling with, while offering a comprehensive roadmap for success in this new paradigm.
Taurus Zodiac Sign: Unveiling the Traits, Dates, and Horoscope Insights of th...my Pandit
Dive into the steadfast world of the Taurus Zodiac Sign. Discover the grounded, stable, and logical nature of Taurus individuals, and explore their key personality traits, important dates, and horoscope insights. Learn how the determination and patience of the Taurus sign make them the rock-steady achievers and anchors of the zodiac.
Top mailing list providers in the USA.pptxJeremyPeirce1
Discover the top mailing list providers in the USA, offering targeted lists, segmentation, and analytics to optimize your marketing campaigns and drive engagement.
Zodiac Signs and Food Preferences_ What Your Sign Says About Your Tastemy Pandit
Know what your zodiac sign says about your taste in food! Explore how the 12 zodiac signs influence your culinary preferences with insights from MyPandit. Dive into astrology and flavors!
How to Implement a Real Estate CRM SoftwareSalesTown
To implement a CRM for real estate, set clear goals, choose a CRM with key real estate features, and customize it to your needs. Migrate your data, train your team, and use automation to save time. Monitor performance, ensure data security, and use the CRM to enhance marketing. Regularly check its effectiveness to improve your business.
Industrial Tech SW: Category Renewal and CreationChristian Dahlen
Every industrial revolution has created a new set of categories and a new set of players.
Multiple new technologies have emerged, but Samsara and C3.ai are only two companies which have gone public so far.
Manufacturing startups constitute the largest pipeline share of unicorns and IPO candidates in the SF Bay Area, and software startups dominate in Germany.
IMPACT Silver is a pure silver zinc producer with over $260 million in revenue since 2008 and a large 100% owned 210km Mexico land package - 2024 catalysts includes new 14% grade zinc Plomosas mine and 20,000m of fully funded exploration drilling.
Brian Fitzsimmons on the Business Strategy and Content Flywheel of Barstool S...Neil Horowitz
On episode 272 of the Digital and Social Media Sports Podcast, Neil chatted with Brian Fitzsimmons, Director of Licensing and Business Development for Barstool Sports.
What follows is a collection of snippets from the podcast. To hear the full interview and more, check out the podcast on all podcast platforms and at www.dsmsports.net
Structural Design Process: Step-by-Step Guide for BuildingsChandresh Chudasama
The structural design process is explained: Follow our step-by-step guide to understand building design intricacies and ensure structural integrity. Learn how to build wonderful buildings with the help of our detailed information. Learn how to create structures with durability and reliability and also gain insights on ways of managing structures.
Structural Design Process: Step-by-Step Guide for Buildings
Trade and Transit Cooperation with Afghanistan
1. Working Paper #153
Trade & Transit Cooperation with
Afghanistan: Results from a
Firm-level survey from Pakistan
By:
Vaqar Ahmed1
and Saad Shabbir2
1
Vaqar Ahmed is the Deputy Executive Director at Sustainable Development Policy Institute. He can be reached at
vaqar@sdpi.org
2
Saad Shabbir is a research associate at Sustainable Development Policy Institute. He can be reached at
saad.s88@gmail.com
The authors are associated with Sustainable Development Policy Institute. We are grateful for technical and data
related inputs from Sadika Hameed, Nohman Ishtiaq, Abdul Wahab, Asif Javed and Mohsin Kazmi.
4. 2
Abstract
This paper aims to inform academia and policymakers about ways and means to first increase trade with
Afghanistan, and second, to discuss trade-related procedures and processes that could be streamlined
for reducing the cost of doing business (with Afghanistan). Using a firm-level survey of exporters,
traders, transporters and distributors, it also discusses how best the Pakistani business community can
position itself under various economic scenarios in Afghanistan. It also contends as to how the increased
cost of doing business is already hurting the competitiveness of Pakistani manufacturing and trading
community. Besides highlighting upcoming competition from Iran and India, the paper argues that small
improvements in transit facility for Afghan goods (via Pakistan) may lead to more commercial trade
prospects between the two countries.
JEL: F13, F21, F23, F43, F53, F55, C83
Keywords: Pakistan, Afghanistan, Trade, Asia, economy
1. Introduction
Afghanistan’s exports of goods and services were recorded around USD 500 million whereas the
imports rose from USD 3 billion in 2009 to USD 10.6 billion in 2014. The current account balance
remained negative and decreased over the years. These statistics, however, do not account for the
substantial informal trade between Afghanistan and Iran, and Afghanistan and Pakistan. Trade
activity has been on the rise for the most part of the last decade. Pakistan remains the largest
trading partner of Afghanistan with a share of 28 per cent followed by the United States, which has
a share of 17.8 per cent.3
Afghanistan was the third largest destination for Pakistani exports in 2012-
13.4
Since 2006 both the trading nations have been managing to keep collective export and import value
above USD 1.5 billion. Though Pakistan’s growth rate of exports to Afghanistan has slightly
decreased since 2011, Afghan exports to Pakistan have steadily been on the rise (Box 1). There is,
however, competition for Pakistan as exports from Iran and India have risen. Additionally,
differential treatment by Pakistani authorities, longer clearance time at the port, high demurrage
charges, and issues related to transit guarantees in Pakistan are some factors which make transit via
Iran relatively more attractive.
3
Eurostat, European Commission (2013)
4
State Bank of Pakistan Annual Report (2012)
5. 3
The top products exported from Pakistan to Afghanistan in the last seven years include milk, cream
and sugar, animal and vegetable oil, cement, crude oil, wheat and rice, and household furniture.
Analysis of a wider list of export items in 2014 reveals the dominance of cement, food, and oil
supplies. However items in the export basket are subject to substantial variation due to the fast
changing demand in Afghanistan.5
Box 1: Export Patterns of Key Partners for Afghanistan
Afghanistan Pakistan Trade 2006-14 Exports to Afghanistan by India, Iran & Pakistan
Source: World Development Indicators 2014, State Bank of Pakistan
The Afghanistan Pakistan Transit Trade Agreement (APTTA), signed in 2010, allows Afghan trucks to
use the seaports of Karachi, Port Qasim, and Gwadar via the Torkhum and Chaman border points.
Replacing the Afghanistan Transit Trade Agreement (ATTA 1965), APTTA allowed the Pakistani
traders to export their goods to central Asia via Afghanistan. It was also agreed to constitute a joint
5
For example a number of high-end food items were destined as supplies for the ISAF. The value of such items is
subject to the number of ISAF personnel on-ground. Another example is Kerosene Type Jet Fuel, which had
negligible export demand from Pakistan to Afghanistan in 2013 and this jumped to USD 83 million a year later.
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
2005-062006-072007-082008-092009-102010-112011-122012-13 2013-14
USDMillions
Exports Imports Balance
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
US$Million
Iran India Pakistan
6. 4
co-ordination committee comprising government officials and private stakeholders from both sides
to address the issues related to the transit trade agreement.6
The agreement has attracted the attention of other landlocked countries. On the request of
Tajikistan to be the part of this arrangement, an expert level group meeting on Trilateral Transit
Trade Arrangement among Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Tajikistan was held on 3rd January 2015 in
Islamabad. In another meeting of the commerce secretaries from seven Central Asian countries
(held on 7th March 2015 in UAE and facilitated by the World Bank), Pakistan has offered similar
arrangement to these countries.
A key challenge is whether the imports of Afghanistan from India or elsewhere are making their way
into Pakistan through illicit or even legitimate means, posing a threat to the indigenous industries in
Pakistan.7
It has been reported that Pakistani traders with the help of Afghan traders, import goods
under transit trade, ship them to Afghanistan and then smuggle them back into Pakistan. Another
factor is that a number of cargo containers that were imported under transit trade go missing and
their products end up selling in the Pakistani markets. The incentives to smuggle also arise because
of Pakistan’s trade restrictions on Indian imports. It is likely that once such restrictions are relaxed,
informal imports or smuggling from Afghanistan may also decline.8
Independent studies9
point out that often the goods imported in Afghanistan are in excess that’s
why the surplus is sent to Pakistan through illicit trade. Black tea is not commonly used in
Afghanistan, as green tea is preferred, yet a large quantity of tea was reported to be imported in
Afghanistan for sending back to Pakistan. Similarly a large quantity of electronic goods is also
smuggled back to Pakistan.
6
Article 34, Section X of APTTA 2010. APTTCA shall be established to monitor, facilitate, and effectively implement
APTTA 2010. APTTCA to be co-chaired by Deputy Commerce Minister (Afghanistan) and Secretary Commerce
(Pakistan). For further details please see: http://www.commerce.gov.pk/Downloads/APTTA.pdf
7
Interviews conducted with SAARC CCI.
8
Afghanistan has also complained regarding transit goods from Pakistan finding their way into Afghanistan’s
market. See Ahmed et al. 2015 for details.
9
PILDAT (2012) Pak-Afghan Trade. Discussion paper by Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development and
Transparency www.pildat.org
7. 5
Further analysis though shows that there is a substantial decrease in the Afghan commercial as well
as non-commercial transit trade via Pakistan. Compared to 2009-10 the commercial transit (as
measured by the number of containers) has dropped to half from more than 75,000 to just above
35,000 in 2014. However, according to an anecdotal source, the dollar value of the transit trade has
increased over the years. This may have been due to better and increased valuation by Pakistan
Customs for the sake of obtaining transit guarantee. Given the uncertainty, surrounding
International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) withdrawal from the region, non-commercial transit
has decreased to 6000 containers in 2013-14.10
Recent empirical literature points towards the following additional challenges in the way of
expanding trade ties with Afghanistan:
Higher compliance costs of trade and transit related documentation (PILDAT 2012)
Weak road and ports related infrastructure to support an increased transit flow (Shabbir and
Ahmed 2014)
Frequent changes in on-ground customs regime specific to Afghanistan (Hussain 2008)
Thriving trade via informal channels reduces incentives for formal trade (Hameed 2012). Estimates
of informal trade between Afghanistan and Pakistan vary across anecdotal evidence. This amount is
said to be equivalent to or greater than formal trade between both countries.
The latter sections in this paper will discuss the emerging economic scenarios in Afghanistan and the
corresponding effects on regional economies and businesses. It will also examine Pakistan's role as a
conduit, i.e. opportunities of scaling up efforts for South and Central Asia economic corridors and
measures to mitigate these risks. Finally, we make a case to extend the bilateral economic
cooperation to cross-border investment in supply chain linkages and trade in services.
2. Methodology
For this paper, we adopted a methodology that directly surveyed the business community about the
above-mentioned issues affecting them and the specific reforms they would like to be put in place.
Using a mix of desk review, qualitative and quantitative survey, this paper aims to:
Explore perceptions regarding economic opportunities and major challenges in Afghanistan and
their impact on Pakistan and other actors in Central Asia. The term ‘actors’ here is not limited to
10
The International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) was a NATO-led security mission, established by the United
Nations Security Council for Afghanistan.
8. 6
states or their institutions. Efforts of multilateral organizations and the private sector in the
region were also explored.
Review estimates from recent studies highlighting expected changes in Afghanistan-Pakistan
commercial and transit (commercial and non-commercial) trade flows following ISAF drawdown
in Afghanistan
Review perceptions regarding current arrangements and future possibilities of strengthening
bilateral trade arrangements and agreements between Afghanistan and Pakistan
The firm-level survey helped in estimating the firm income models as well as the investment and
expenditure functions (of these firms). In order to have a representative sample we have
interviewed 260 firms.11
These firms were:
split across exporters who are also producers (and not traders)
owners of businesses falling under wholesale trade, retail trade, transport, distribution and
warehousing
Firms acting as clearing agents.
Such a sample distribution allowed observing both: the impact of ISAF drawdown on industries
servicing the transit trade, and the impact of perceived political or security related upheavals on
formal trade and commercial transit.
We have tried to ensure that the sample is representative of the firms currently trading with
Afghanistan and Central Asia. As a starting point we resorted to the directory available with the
Pakistan Afghanistan Joint Chamber of Commerce and Industries. This directory was further
augmented through information about 2013-14 membership provided by Chambers of Commerce in
Karachi and Peshawar. This consolidated list was split into 3 categories namely: a) exporters
(manufacturing community), b) trade, transport, distribution & warehousing (TTDW) sector, and c)
clearing agents. Next we split each of these lists according to the cities where each category is
concentrated. For example, the exporter’s list was split across Karachi, Quetta and Peshawar. Given
the resource and time already invested to reach each of these cities, we acquired equal responses
from the each city. In our opinion, this should not influence our policy conclusions given the
objectives of this survey were only to record current and future perceptions. Finally under each
category and city, random selection was ensured.
11
Interested readers can request a copy of the questionnaire administered from the research team at SDPI.
9. 7
Figure 1: Study Methodology
Table 1: Number of Respondents by City and Category
City Exporters* TTDW** Sector Clearing Agents Total
Karachi 30 30 60
Chaman 20 20 40
Quetta 30 30 60
Peshawar 30 30 60
Torkhum 20 20 40
Total Sample 260
*These will be producer-exporters, ** TTDW= Trade, Transport, Distribution & Warehousing
Methodology
Desk Review
Formal Trade
Informal Trade
Transit Trade
Quantitative
Survey
Firm-level survey
Karachi
Chaman
Torkhum
Peshawar
Islamabad
Qualitative Survey
Focus Group
Discussions
Karachi
Peshawar
Islamabad
Key Informant
Interviews
Pakistan
Afghanistan
10. 8
3. Survey Results and Findings
Most respondents said that to realize the USD 5 billion target of bilateral trade between the two
economies (as set by the two Ministries of Commerce), the share of manufactured products needs
to increase.12
For this to happen, one needs to start by looking at how Pakistani firms compete in
Afghanistan.
Around 25 per cent of the revenues of firms sampled are from sales abroad. Given the energy
crisis faced by the firms in Pakistan, annual turnover and exports have decreased. This is
particularly the case for firms in Balochistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa provinces. Most
respondents reported highly increasing costs of doing business. Some of these costs are
discussed below.
There was a consensus that the cost of electricity is prohibitively high for doing business and
efficiency. Both India and Iran (who are competitors for Pakistani products) heavily subsidize
their energy sectors. However, Pakistan due to its weak budgetary position cannot match such
subsidies. In a more recent reform under the IMF programme, Pakistan is expected to further
phase out subsidies and increase both power and gas tariffs. However, subsidies should be
phased out gradually as the energy sector is deregulated in order to allow the private sector to
enter and create competitive pricing for consumers. This requires investing in long-term energy
needs of firms wishing to scale up exports to Afghanistan. Most of these firms are still classified
as SMEs and can be helped through export-related rebates on the consumption of energy.
52% of firms reported that transportation costs have increased by 5-15% during the past 12
months (Figure 1).13
However, for 19% of the firms the increase in these costs was between 15-
25%. Similarly in the case of warehousing, 45% firms reported an increase in such costs to the
tune of 5-15% and 8% firms saying that these had increased between 15-25%. Most of the latter
firms were from the agriculture sector that faces a high risk of loss in perishable merchandise.
Figure 1: Magnitude of Change in Logistics Costs
12
Pakistan’s exports still largely focus on agriculture and livestock in Afghanistan while there is a growing
industrial sector in Afghanistan which is projected to contribute to processed food manufacturing
(particularly in the case of fruits and vegetables).
13
The survey team was mobilized in June 2014. Therefore past 12 months refer to the period prior to June 2014.
11. 9
Source: SDPI Monitoring & Evaluation (M&E) Unit 2014
In the past year (2013-14), the cost of inputs has risen more than 20 per cent and the prices of
finished products increased as a result.14
For the same period firms reported a rise in increased
wage bills and spending on power and gas.
60 per cent of firms have outsourced transportation and warehousing services. The
transportation costs of goods had increased due to increase in oil prices in the international
market during 2013-14.15
Businesses’ expressed concerns that as international oil prices fall in
the coming months, the federal government will not pass on the full effect of the price decline.
58% of firms reported that the insurance cost of trade consignments has significantly risen in the
past 12 months. In some cases, the insurance cost was almost one-third of the consignment
cost, discouraging smaller traders specifically. These increases in trade costs have made it
difficult for exporters to compete in Afghanistan with pressures from India and Iran. Most
14
Firms producing and exporting cement, milk and sugar, rice, animal and vegetable oil, and petroleum extracts
were interviewed. Thus, inputs here refer to the raw material used for the different products.
15
For economy-wide impacts of fuel price shocks in Pakistan, see Ahmed and O’ Donoghue (2010).
27%
52%
19%
2% 0%
Increase in Transportation Costs (%)
0-5 5-15 15-25 25-50 More than 50
44%
45%
8%
2% 1%
Increase in Warehousing Costs (%)
0-5 5-15 15-25 25-50 More than 50
12. 10
established insurance enterprises in Pakistan are not providing these services for trading with
Afghanistan, and any Afghan trader wishing to import from Pakistan is also expected to arrange
their own transport and logistics services. The lack of an EXIM bank that can facilitate trade-
related guarantees also exacerbates the problems of traders wishing to export higher value
merchandise.
30 per cent of the firms reported that they wanted to see an increased supply of skilled labour
(for servicing trade, transport and warehousing sectors). However, 95 per cent of firms also
reported an increase in their wage bills since December 2013. This rising cost of doing business
has forced firms to restructure their human resources and reported lay-offs (i.e. 30% of their
skilled employees). 85 per cent of the overall lay-offs comprised clerical and support staff.16
A better law and order situation is imperative for the firms to flourish as 50 per cent of the firms
indicated that they bear the damage costs. The damage costs include theft of goods, missing
containers, damaged containers comprising the quality of products being exported particularly
in cases where containers are set on fire. The skilled labour also moves out as law and order
deteriorates. Security remains a major concern for businesses, particularly those requiring fixed
investments from abroad. Exporters consider the law and order of the region to be the most
significant hurdle to smooth and efficient trade. Security in general is a hindrance and the trade
routes are not considered secure. The threats are not just to the trucks passing across the
border. There is also the issue of theft and pilferage.
Half of the respondents reported that APTTA has led to an increase in informal trade and
smuggling.17
Pakistani businessmen are of the view that significant portion of goods imported in
Pakistan for onward transmission to Afghanistan get lost in Pakistan and never enter
Afghanistan, and those that do, sometimes come back into Pakistan. It is felt that it has severely
hampered the domestic and international business in Pakistan and prospects for enhanced
transit and trade relations. There are no evidence based estimates of either the informal trade
or smuggling.
16
The estimates regarding the unskilled and semi-skilled workers getting unemployed, are weak as many are not
registered with the labor market institutions.
17
Informal trade may not be pure smuggling of goods if it comes under extra-legal trading and tolerated in practice
by the State even if illegal by law. Our distinction between informal trade and smuggling follows Taneja and Pohit
(2004).
13. 11
Trolleys and trucks are at times delayed by two to three days because the clearance system
installed at Torkhum is not very much organized and systematic. At the time of this study, the
customs automated Weboc facility on the Pakistani side of the borders does not synchronize
with the automated facility at the border crossings in Afghanistan.
Respondents stressed the need for expediting the various promised infrastructure related
projects by the Government of Pakistan. They explained that if trade with Afghanistan is to be
scaled upwards, the road networks that need to be urgently revamped include the Indus
Highway (N-55), Regional Cooperation for Development Highway (N-25) connecting Karachi to
Chaman via Lakpass, Lakpaas-Taftan (N-40), Sukkur-Quetta (N-65), and Nowshera – Dir – Chitral
(N-45) Highway, Gwadar – Hoshab – Khuzdar – Ratodero Motorway (M-8) and Hasanabdal –
Mansehra Expressway. Additionally, if increased trade and transit traffic is to be facilitated
across Afghanistan-Pakistan border, then a diversification of transport modes is required
particularly in favour of railways. Railways will add to economies of scale for any trading activity
in future. The security of cargo is also relatively better in the case of railways.
Despite the lack of infrastructure, the private sector representatives explained that it takes less
than 20 hours for transit from Torkhum border to Tajikistan and then other parts of Central Asia.
Pakistan already has a 60 per cent share of the cement used in Tajikistan construction. Pakistan
has shown through the signing of APPTA and extension to Tajikistan the seriousness for
expanding regional trade. However the progress seen on the eastern border has yet to be seen
on the western side. For example, the development on Wagah border with India has been
exceptional with five lane crossing points and scanner machines that scan the trucks without
opening the containers.
An example of upgrading infrastructure, particularly for transit trade, is the road from Jamrod to
Torkhum, from a single road to a dual carriage road with security. While USAID has attempted to
fund and implement this it remains incomplete. Both cash strapped governments may not be
able to afford such investments. There is a great scope for the private sector in Pakistan to
complete or undertake initiatives such as this.
Our discussions with Ministry of Commerce and Trade Development Authority of Pakistan
revealed that the government has recently approved the plan to operate trains twice a week
under the APTTA. One of the abandoned projects of rail links between Chaman and Spin Boldak,
which was approved in 2004, is now being reconsidered. After re-evaluating the cost of the
project, the proposal is under consideration. This rail link was the first phase of the three phase
project that will join Pakistan to central Asia via Spin Boldak – Kandahar – Herat to
Turkmenistan. The funding agency is yet to be finalized. Furthermore, on the request of
Afghanistan, Pakistan is considering extending technical support and trainings for capacity
building of the staff of the newly-established Afghanistan Railway Authority (AFRA).
14. 12
The business community also felt that both Pakistan and Afghanistan need to diversify the
transport infrastructure, thus including not just road linkages, but rail, seaport infrastructure
(from Pakistan) and air.
Almost 48 per cent of the survey respondents benefitted from APPTA, despite the fact that
many of the respondents believed that their businesses were adversely impacted due to the
inefficient and opaque practices of customs. Similarly, more than 50 per cent were not satisfied
by the examination of goods undertaken by the customs authorities. Only 15 per cent of the
firms had been able to file any complaints against APTTA due to the cumbersome grievance
redressal mechanisms (entailing high transaction costs). There also appears to be a
communication gap between the business community and the relevant authorities, as 80 per
cent of the complaints were never addressed by the relevant authorities.
In summary, the following are the key issues raised by firms engaged in commercial trade with
Afghanistan:
Securing en route merchandise and at borders
Missing border-related trade infrastructure
Inadequate banking facilities
Weak Marketing of ‘Made in Pakistan’ in Afghanistan
Weak road and rail networks to facilitate any expansion in bilateral trade and transit
Lack of harmonized customs operations at Torkhum and Chaman
Similarly, following is the summary of issues raised by firms engaged in transit trade:
Torkhum terminal for passengers and cargo is still awaiting finances to be completed
Multiple costs borne by Afghan importers, including transport, warehousing, tracker cost, and
insurance guarantee cost
There is a maximum limit of 40 feet containers. The charges are established according to weight;
and the average charges from Karachi to Peshawar is PKR 110,000 per container. However, for
Afghan transit, these charges are higher by a variance of PKR 10,000-20,000 per container.
Multiple containers under one importer are processed all together. In the case of a missing
container, the entire shipment is blocked. The traders have the option to either file individual
declarations for each container, but as this increases the cost, hence single declaration is filed
for a consignment which may contain multiple containers.
Online system (WeBoC) is not yet synchronized with the Afghan system resulting in time delays
because of requisite clarifications from exporters or their agents. Respondents were also not
satisfied with the examination of goods at various stages of transit. Around 80 per cent revealed
that complaints were not addressed by the relevant authorities.
15. 13
Pakistan transit goods to central Asia have 110 per cent insurance costs in violation of APTTA
2010.
Small and medium scale traders have stopped trading after the dollar regime.18
As formal money
exchange companies at border points are missing, Pakistan should not expect to apply the same
trading rules to Afghanistan that are present for more advanced economies.
Exporters reported the need for some compensation in the cases where shipments were lost or
stolen.19
Pakistan Railways recently announced that it will operate two trains per week from Karachi to
Peshawar to facilitate goods under APTTA. However, traders were apprehensive that railways
as per the past record may have more uncertain timings than the trucking sector.
18
Traders now have to conduct trade in USD.
19
Currently in the case of loss even because of a terrorist activity there is no relief to the owner of shipment. The
bonded carrier also does not pay compensation. Earlier Pakistan Railways use to compensate some fraction of the
loss. However FBR had reversed the provision.
16. 14
3.1. Institutional Analysis
As part of this paper, we also organized focus group discussions and consultations in Islamabad,
Karachi and Peshawar to tap into qualitative knowledge available with various stakeholders for
promoting the bilateral economic cooperation. We have particularly taken into account (in this sub-
section) interventions by the government. There was a general consensus that while there is
immense potential for trade with Afghanistan, Pakistan currently lacks a coherent diplomatic and
economic foreign policy approach.
3.1.1. Increasing use of technology:
For the efficient and smooth flow of trade, border crossing points require modern technology.
Pakistan aims to build state-of-the-art border stations at Torkhum, Chaman, Wagah, and Taftan.
The Electronic Data Interchange will be developed to provide online real time information of
bilateral and transit trade. The issue of registration of Afghan importers is being expedited to
resolve issues of partial shipment and undue shipment delays at border crossing points. The
issue of multiple tracking devices on Afghan transit freights and requirement of jawaznama by
Pakistan is being revisited.
The trader community felt that Pakistani authorities can make an effort to harmonize
automated customs processing platforms through appropriate ICT tools and providing technical
assistance to the Afghan side, ensuring greater compatibility in systems and procedures. Also,
the introduction of such technology will assist in curbing informal trade and provide incentives
for businesses to use the formal channels for their goods and services. Similarly, at the moment
there is little monitoring of consignments arriving through the personal baggage.
3.1.2. Tariff Reforms for Afghanistan and Central Asia:
The customs duties levied on imports from Afghanistan are acting as a constraint on improved
trade relations. A reduction in tariffs could also prove beneficial especially given the Indian
example, where the Indian Government reduced customs duties and taxes by 50% on Afghan
origin goods, leading to an increase in bilateral trade. There is a fast booming plastics, rubber,
paper and paper board industry in Afghanistan. However, these sectors face comparatively
higher tariffs in Pakistan. The average tariff on plastics and rubber in Pakistan is 17% and 15.8%
respectively. The same in the case of India is 9.5 % and 9.1 % respectively.20
3.1.3. Outreach Programme:
20
Ahmad (2015)
17. 15
The Government of Pakistan has started realizing the difficulties that are faced by the private
sector. In the context of bilateral trade with Afghanistan, the current issues that the Ministry of
Commerce, Federal Board of Revenue and other relevant institutions in Pakistan are working
towards are: Customs cooperation agreement for data exchange, resolving issues related to re-
exports, expanding trade facilitation available at the trade gates (Torkhum and Chaman), and
build an integrated customs and border management facility. While this is being done an
outreach programme by the Ministry of Commerce is important so that the private sector is on-
board for these reforms.
3.1.4. Trade in Services:
The regulatory regime for the services sector will also need to be revisited. There is a lot of room
for service sector exports in Afghanistan. Pakistan’s service sector has proven effective and seen
high returns in Pakistan. There is a scope for Pakistani businesses to use their knowledge and
experience to invest and work in the service industries in Afghanistan. TDAP may take a lead in
linking Pakistani service providers in Afghanistan. Trade in services will also require an
agreement on treatment of double taxation. This can be done as part of the PTA process. A
study to quantify the potential of services trade between Afghanistan and Pakistan is also
required.
3.1.5. APTTA and Inclusion of Tajikistan:
APTTA perhaps provides the greatest promise of cross border trade and forward trade for both
governments. It provides realistic and sustainable steps for increased trade for Pakistan. The
stagnation has resulted from the lack of political will in the past to carry it forward – a trend that
exporters are expecting to change given the current relations between Pakistan and
Afghanistan. The following are the gaps and areas for improvement:
Pakistan and Afghanistan have different tariff regimes for the same class of products. Both
governments, with the help of technical assistance, should consider some harmonization of
tariff regimes. SAFTA provides a good framework even for bilateral harmonization. A PTA
between both countries could address this point, or at least provide the basis to a solution.
Pakistan should consider acceding to TIR convention (Convention on International Transport
of Goods Under Cover of Transports Internationaux Routiers Carnets, 1975) to simplify
guarantee procedures and smoother movement of transit transport across borders.
In the next round of improvements in APTTA, multiple stakeholders should be invited and
their recommendations should be considered. The PAJCCI is of the view that the
consultation process was not thorough in the finalisation of APTTA. Similarly, the business
18. 16
community favours transit facility for Tajikistan, however said that they were not consulted
fully before inviting Tajikistan for the January 2015 trilateral meeting in Islamabad.
3.1.6. Making Joint Economic Commission (JEC) Effective:
For streamlining the implementation of bilateral economic cooperation reforms, it is important
to make the JEC more effective and the following are the key recommendations:
The JEC should meet on a half yearly basis with pre-determined schedule of meetings
The JEC should also invite members of Pakistan Business Council, PAJCCI, consumer
associations and think tanks in the meetings to discuss outstanding issues faced by civil
society stakeholders of both the countries
The JEC should become the main forum to review status of large-scale projects that impact
both the countries, including CASA-1000, TAPI, road and rail networks.
3.2. Uncertain Role of Statutory Regulatory Orders (SROs)
Another area of concern highlighted by the respondents were the opaque and cost prohibitive SROs
issued by the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) which are hurting bilateral trade with Afghanistan.
The government of Pakistan is now deciding to enter into a preferential trade agreement (PTA) with
Afghanistan. A draft PTA has already been shared with the Afghan counterparts. This paper while
encouraging such steps recommends conducting a detailed analysis of those SROs which are
impeding bilateral trade and hurting government’s revenues. From key interviews and survey
respondents, a number of examples are highlighted below.
For example, wheat is a staple commodity in Afghanistan and important for its food security. The
government in Pakistan under SRO 1185(I)/2007 imposed 35% ad valorem regulatory duty on the
export of wheat products. This not only reduced the wheat exports to Afghanistan in value terms
(and thereby a disadvantage to Pakistani farmer) but also raised the price of the commodity for
Afghan consumers. Even in times of a bumper crop, the government of Pakistan remains reluctant
to relax this duty. Recently, when the Afghan government wanted to import wheat from India due
to a lower price vis-à-vis Pakistan, the latter did not allow transit of Indian wheat in to Afghanistan.
This is not only the case with wheat but also several other agricultural items. Another example with
high demand in Afghanistan is pulses. The SRO 492(I) 2006 imposes a 35% ad valorem regulatory
duty on the export of pulses. Afghanistan has at times demanded removal of such duties citing food
security reasons in the country.
Afghanistan also has a fast emerging industrial sector with a boom in the production of several fast
moving consumer goods (FMCGs). However Afghan importers face high duties on the imports of key
raw materials used in their production process. An example was given where SRO594(I)/2009
19. 17
imposes 25% ad valorem regulatory duty on the export of lead, scrap and waste. Similarly in the
case of the textile sector (another fast growing sector in Afghanistan) SRO 323(I)/2010 imposes 15%
ad valorem regulatory duty on all types of yarn.
Pakistani exporters reported that there are also some SROs acting as a barrier for new Pakistani
exporters to Afghanistan. Under SRO 888(I)/2009 the ‘Export Oriented Units & SMEs Enterprise
Rules 2008’ SMEs are allowed export-related incentives in sales tax and federal excise duty.
However 80% of firm’s production for other countries has to be certified by the Engineering
Development Board (EDB) for the last three years. Respondents believe that such a condition can
only be met by large and already established exporters. Mostly SMEs in Pakistan do not have export
capacity, however in the case of Afghanistan, several SMEs in Pakistan have prospects due to
proximity economies. Such firms cannot however arrange for the EDB certification as they are
merely starting to export.
It was also reported that Pakistani exporters had received orders from Afghanistan for winter
supplies, which could not go through due to the unfavourable SROs. The SRO1080 (I)/2005 issued
after the earthquake in Pakistan (October 2005) requires that exports of blankets, tents, and
tarpaulins will require approval of Federal and Provincial Disaster Management Authorities. It has
been over nine years since the earthquake and these SROs are still in place and acting as a barrier to
seasonal exports to Afghanistan (e.g. in winter season).
The nascent leather industry in Afghanistan has exhibited large growth in several sub-sectors. The
SRO 1011(I) 2005 imposes a 20% ad valorem regulatory duty on export of raw and wet-blue hides.
Owing to the energy shortages in Pakistan, the domestic leather value added sector has not been
able to benefit from the increased inventory of such hides. However making the exports expensive
through regulatory duty has also deprived the exporters of hides from catering to the foreign
demand.
Importers in Pakistan also reported a lack of knowledge with the customs authorities regarding SRO
provisions under SAARC and ECO. For example, the SRO 558(1)/2004 allows vegetables and fruits to
be exempt from customs duties. However, Pakistani officials lacked the knowledge of specific
vegetables under SAARC and Afghanistan’s status in SAARC. This sometimes leads to unnecessary
delays at the border checkpoint and can result in decaying of perishable items. Similarly, ‘Olive oil’ is
exempt from customs duty for ECO countries but not for Afghanistan. The reason provided was that
Afghanistan now comes under SAARC provisions. This will then have to be allowed to other SAARC
member countries as well. Importers recommend that such anomalies under the SROs should be
carefully checked and Pakistani consumers and exporters should not have to pay the price of such
inconsistencies in customs rules.
20. 18
There is also a dedicated SRO related to firms engaged in tracking and monitoring of cargo.
Respondents informed that willing bidders at the time of application are not asked for specific type
GSM/GPRS technology to be used. The FBR also has no mechanism for random physical audit
whether such technology has been upgraded. Some older specifications are also allowed which
becomes a key reason of pilferages. This SRO also requires an annual turnover of PKR 350 million to
complete registration with FBR. This is a barrier to entry for new and smaller firms who have better
technological solutions. The Ministry of Commerce is now keen to scale up railways operations for
catering to transit demand. However under this SRO there is no room for private rail carriers.
Finally, we discuss some SROs which delay the arbitration process in trading with Afghanistan.
Under the SRO 888(I)/2004 FBR has a comprehensive list of business persons in the Alternative
Dispute Resolution (ADR) committee. But most of these business persons were not found to have
current experience of Afghan trade.
The SRO 487(I)/2003 notes the ‘Takeover of Imported Goods Rules 2003’ which is heavily misused in
the case of Afghanistan. The discretion of border authorities is absolute and needs to be matched
with exporter’s safeguards. Respondents even informed of physical abuse to their clearing agent or
representative during the time their merchandise was being inspected. The authorities have little
monitoring on consignments arriving through the personal baggage. It was reported that 55,000
people daily pass through the land route at Torkhum (three-quarters without a visa). However those
in formal sector trade are being penalized in the form of visa and merchandise delays.
3.3. Preferential Treatment for Afghanistan
The data on the top five imports of Pakistan from Afghanistan include vegetables, fruits, raw cotton,
carpets, rugs, hides, and skins. If the government of Pakistan has to embark on a PTA with
Afghanistan, a key question will be how Pakistan can leverage the PTA for greater access to other
markets and deepening the basket of goods that Pakistan utilizes through this PTA. Through the
survey administered, data collected and key interviews with stakeholders, a number of issues have
been highlighted below:
A starting point for Pakistan could be to invest in increasing production capacity of these sectors
in Afghanistan. For this, the Board of Investment will have to allow ‘automatic route’ investment
on both sides and SBP will need to relax rules for transfer of foreign exchange. The Afghan
21. 19
government will need to reciprocate (an issue which Ministry of Foreign Affairs can take up with
their counterparts).21
The State Bank of Pakistan will need to ease capital repatriation rules for dollar-denominated
profits and also improve L/C’s processing and rules. There is a reported delay of several months
in L/Cs processing if trading via Chaman. These L/Cs carry financial limits and therefore need to
be broken into smaller denominations. The businessmen resort to Hawala system and there are
no banks near Chaman. Formal sector traders are required to travel back to a main city for
banking transactions.
Afghanistan and Pakistan should incorporate provisions for supply chains under the PTA. This
will also require removal of double taxation in services trade between both countries.
Afghanistan already has LDC status which can be utilized by Pakistani investors willing to enter
into value chain arrangements. This will allow Pakistani manufacturers in Afghanistan duty free
access to more advanced economies with the added advantage of repatriation of profits back to
Pakistan.
To date, there is no study that quantifies potential investment from Pakistan to Afghanistan or the
preparedness of Pakistani investors (e.g. in the mining sector) for investing in Afghanistan. Several
countries in the region have already started ensuring the presence of their investments in
Afghanistan. China has invested USD 3 billion to develop five million ton copper deposit near Kabul.
Several EU countries have expressed interests in tapping other natural resources. They are also
willing to assist Afghanistan in consumer industries. For example, the plastics industry is getting
established gradually within Afghanistan resulting in decline of plastics exports from Pakistan.
Pakistan’s private sector still finds it difficult to carry out projects inside Afghanistan. This will
require an amendment in foreign currency rules (by SBP) and provision of ‘automatic-route’
investments by Board of Investment in Pakistan.
SBP’s information portal on Pakistan’s bank branches currently informs us that Bank Al Falah has
two branches one in Kabul and Herat each. Habib Bank has one branch in Kabul and National Bank
has a branch in Kabul and Jalalabad each. Though, the research team was trying to access these
branches, only Bank Alfalah was found fully operational while the rest of the bank branches could
not be accessed or did not have a full portfolio of services. They also maintain a weak presence on
web sources.
21
This recommendation also applies in the case of other countries with whom Pakistan wishes to pursue
investment cooperation. See Ahmed et al. 2015b.
22. 20
The above-mentioned measures for value chain linkages will remain critical if Pakistan wishes to
increase its potential for trade-led investments in Afghanistan. Furthermore, these measures will
have important and favourable implications for improving trade in services with Afghanistan.
4. Conclusion
This paper discusses various issues that require negotiation between Afghan and Pakistani trade
officials including: customs clearance process; insurance of transport vehicles, safety of containers
and consignments; tracking and monitoring of consignments; role of SROs hurting bilateral trade;
credit facility for traders; currency swaps; sluggish progress on port, road and rail projects; high
costs of air cargo; and lack of banking channels. In order to strengthen the Afghanistan-Pakistan
economic cooperation, this concluding section points towards increased efforts required to
strengthen the institutional framework of trade diplomacy.
Pakistan has to have a very cogent Afghan policy and this policy must have inputs from its
economic, foreign and security advisors. The recent increased and more cordial dialogue
between the two countries provides hope for collaboration in the future. Once a cohesive policy
is put in place, Pakistan must follow it accordingly. Of course, the cornerstone of this policy
should be to improve relations with Afghanistan and to support them in their development and
progress.
The Ministry of Finance in both the countries, the Planning Commission, and multilateral
institutions should develop a ‘first loss’ equity fund, particularly for medium sized
entrepreneurs. A good example of such a fund which can provide the basis of this arrangement
can be extracted from OPICs (Overseas Private Investment Corporation) example. Similarly, for
addressing the issue of lack of insurance facilities while trading with Afghanistan, a proposal to
expedite the creation of an EXIM bank should be considered.
Expediting work on ongoing road and railways projects linking the various cities across the
Afghanistan-Pakistan border
The civil society and think tanks working on Afghanistan-Pakistan trade cooperation should be
strengthened by the governments and development partners. They should independently hold
annual Afghanistan-Pakistan trade summits which also benefit from the presence of investors
and business community of both sides. As Pakistan is hosting the 2015 Heart of Asia meeting, it
is recommended that civil society think tanks should facilitate in holding first annual summit
before the Heart of Asia meeting. Supporting Afghan think tanks will also help in building a
constituency for Pakistan’s view point in Kabul.
Independent think tanks should be supported to host an annual Afghanistan-Pakistan Economic
Summit which not only bring together the government and business community in a track-II
23. 21
setting, but also help strengthen a community, which can undertake long-term work on bilateral
cooperation.
Both Afghanistan and Pakistan will require technical and financial assistance in expediting reforms
towards bilateral economic cooperation. Following is a list of initiatives required on urgent basis.
The Ministry of Commerce in Pakistan should institutionalize a dedicated Afghanistan desk with
research, monitoring and evaluation capabilities. This unit will:
a) coordinate the implementation of decisions undertaken at various government forums
b) undertake specific research tasks related to Afghanistan-Pakistan bilateral trade and
investment cooperation.
Pakistan’s Ministry of Commerce, in collaboration with the customs officials, needs to update
current assessments on the missing facilities curtailing cross border transit and commercial
trade.
Support will also be required for undertaking tariff and tariff-harmonization reforms.
The current project tracking mechanisms within the federal government are weak and stronger
support may be required for monitoring the progress of ports, road and rail infrastructure
promised in the context of Afghanistan-Pakistan bilateral cooperation.
FBR may be supported to undertake a study on the identification of specific regulatory, tariff
and non-tariff measures, which may be reformed in order to formalize the currently growing
informal and illegal trade.
The planned trans-boundary cooperation projects in the Central Asian region should go beyond
the currently ongoing work on CASA-1000, TAPI and some road sector projects. A high-powered
working group comprising experts from Afghanistan, Pakistan and select Central Asian countries
should be facilitated so that an inventory of projects can be planned. Such projects will
strengthen economic and political interdependencies in the region.
The elected public representatives from Afghanistan and Pakistan need to fundamentally agree on
the steps to resolve the trust deficit. The trust deficit is actually not that wide – especially if benefits
are emphasized. The Pakhtun areas of Afghanistan have very good ties with the Pakhtun areas of
Pakistan whether in Balochistan or Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (Hussain 2000). Another benefit that
Pakistanis have at the Chaman border is that the people there are also well versed in Dari language.
Trade should leverage these linkages while addressing the trust deficit as well. At the moment while
India is perceived to be both a better and efficient partner in Afghanistan, there is a much scope and
potential for trade and business linkages between Afghanistan and Pakistan.
Pakistan has shown its willingness to address the security threats. In June of 2014, Pakistan started a
major army operation in North Waziristan. Increasing trade to a very large extent is dependent on
the success of this operation and the future stability of the security situation. Furthermore, capacity
24. 22
building for the police and other non-military law enforcers is vital. This however is a long-term
process and to the extent possible lies beyond the gamut of this paper. Of course, as the security
situation improves, the Pakistani private sector, along with the aid organizations and government
authorities will be able to undertake their duties more freely and effectively especially to increase
economic activity in conflict zones.22
Finally, for creating investment and services trade linkages between both countries, Afghanistan will
require support in strengthening the regulatory institutions, particularly those related to
competition policy, oil and gas, and mining regulatory authorities. Pakistan’s recent experience and
the evolution of Competition Commission of Pakistan have been citied in recent literature as a
regulatory success. Pakistan should offer formal support in building such institutions for Afghanistan
with possible financial support from development partners.
This paper has also pointed towards some research gaps which may be addressed in future studies:
A research study is required to look into the enhanced security measures for merchandise trade
along Afghanistan-Pakistan border. UNODC in Pakistan already has a baseline analysis on this
subject which may be updated in the context of cross-border trade and investment activities.
To date, there is no study that quantifies potential investment from Pakistan to Afghanistan or
the preparedness of Pakistani investors (e.g. in the mining sector) for investing in Afghanistan.
This is despite the realization in Pakistan that the business community would benefit from
Afghanistan’s LDC status for leveraging export revenues. A value chain analysis of Pakistani SMEs
currently trading with Afghanistan is also missing.
There are no evidence based estimates of either the informal trade or smuggling.
While Pakistan has undertaken tariff harmonization exercise with respect to South Asian
countries, there is a need to undertake a similar exercise with Central Asian Commerce
Ministries. The increased trade diplomacy with Tajikistan and Kyrgyz Republic will also prompt a
similar requirement.
The documented Grievance Redressal Mechanism in Afghanistan-Pakistan Trade and Transit is
rarely practiced. It is important to analyze the current challenges before PTA is signed and
transit facility is extended to Tajikistan.
The Commerce Ministries of Pakistan and Tajikistan have agreed to conceptualize in the coming
days the Peshawar – Dushanbe Economic Corridor project. It is important at this stage to
quantify potential gains from this corridor in trade, cross-border investments and infrastructure
cooperation (e.g. in energy and petroleum products).
22
See Khan and Ahmed 2014 for role of private sector in conflict zones.
25. 23
As a result of decline in NATO transit trade, the corresponding estimates regarding unskilled and
semi-skilled workers facing unemployment or underemployment are weak as many are not
registered with the labour market institutions. It is important that the Government of Khyber
Pakhtunkhwa along with the federal government put in place alternate livelihood schemes to
preserve peace, increase the overall economic wellbeing, as well as improve the quality of life.
A study to quantify the potential of services trade between Afghanistan and Pakistan is also
required. Such a study should highlight regulatory issues such as the desired agreement to
resolve double taxation.
5. References
Ahmad, M 2015, ‘Boosting Exports for Economic Growth’, Business Recorder (Special Supplement,
April 27), viewed 2 March 2016, http://www.brecorder.com/supplements/88/1181035/
Ahmed, V, Suleri, AQ, Wahab, MA & Javed A 2015, ‘Informal Flow of Merchandise from India: The
Case of Pakistan’, India-Pakistan Trade-Strengthening Economic Relations, Springer, India DOI:
10.1007/978-81-322-1949-1_3.
Ahmed, V, Suleri, A Q & Adnan, M 2015, ‘FDI in India: Prospects for Pakistan’, India-Pakistan Trade -
Strengthening Economic Relations, Springer, India
DOI: 10.1007/978-81-322-1949-1_7.
Ahmed, V & Shabbir, S 2014, ‘Afghanistan-Pakistan Trade: Welfare Impact on Balochistan and
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Policy Review, Sustainable Development Policy Institute (SDPI), viewed
(http://www.sdpi.org/publications/files/Policy%20Review-FEBRUARY.pdf).
Ahmed, V & Donoghue, CO 2010, ‘Global Economic Crisis and Poverty in Pakistan’, International
Journal of Microsimulation, vol. 3(1) p.127-129.
Blomberg, SB, Hess, GD & Orphanides, A 2004, ‘The macroeconomic consequences of terrorism’
Journal of Monetary Economics 51, 1007-1032.
26. 24
Gaibulloev, K & Sandler, T 2008, ‘The impact of terrorism and conflicts on growth in Asia’, Working
Paper, School of Economic, Political and Policy Sciences, University of Texas, Dallas
Hameed, S 2012, ‘Prospects for Indian-Pakistani Cooperation in Afghanistan’, A report of the CSIS
program on crisis, conflict, and cooperation, Centre for Strategic and International Studies August
2012, viewed http://csis.org/files/publication/120821_Hameed_ProspectsIndianPakistan_Web.pdf
Hussain, SI 2000, ‘Pukhtoon Tribes Along the Pak-Afghan Border’, Area Study Centre, Peshawar
Hussain, SW 2008, ‘The Impact of Afghan Transit Trade on the Economy of NWFP’, Henn Seidal
Foundation Germany, Islamabad .
Khan, MR 2011, ‘Afghanistan and Pakistan: Conflict, Extremism, and Resistance to Modernity’, Johns
Hopkins University Press
Khan, SA & Ahmed, V 2014, ‘Peaceful Economies: Assessing the Role of the Private Sector in Conflict
Prevention in Pakistan’, Stability: International Journal of Security & Development, Vol. 3(1): 24, pp.
1-9,
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5334/sta.dv
Nisar, M 2012, ‘Agreement for Traffic in Transit Among The Governments of The People’s Republic
Of China, The Kyrgyz Republic, The Republic Of Kazakhstan And The Islamic Republic Of Pakistan,’
Presentation at a Roundtable on Ways Forward for Corridor-Based Transport Facilitation
Arrangements in the CAREC Region July 2, Beijing
Pakistan-Afghanistan Joint Chamber of Commerce and Industry 2013, ‘Pak-Afghan Trade: Trend and
Issues, PAJCCI, December.
27. 25
Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development and Transparency, 2012, Pak-Afghan Trade, Discussion
Paper, PILDAT, viewed www.pildat.org.
Taneja, N, Sarvananthan, M, Binod, KM, Pohit, S 2004, ‘India's Informal Trade with Sri Lanka and
Nepal: An Estimation,’ South Asia Economic Journal, March 2004, vol. 5, no. 1 p.27-54
World Bank 2014, Afghanistan Economic Update, April 2014, The World Bank