1. SUPPLY CHAIN LEADERSHIP FORUM
AUGUST31- SEPT. 2, 2015
SAN ANTONIO, TX
Non-Profit Service Providers:
COST EFFECTIVE SOUTIONS
within the Supply-Chains
2. Overview: A quick look
Who we Are: We operate a large and growing Social Enterprise on the East Coast. We are a nonprofit
third party service provider that has been providing cost-effective B2B value-added secondary packaging,
contract packaging, assembly/kitting and fulfillment services over the past 35 years. Employ 200.
A Nonprofit is just a TAX status Only and we operate as business. No money…No Mission.
Social Enterprise: These are organizations typically nonprofits that apply commercial strategies to
maximize improvements in human well-being. This may include maximizing social impact rather than
profits to external shareholders. Many consider this a double bottom line and a blended or shared value
model as well.
Our Commercial Value Proposition: Provide consumer centric driven, customized, cost-effective,
value-added service solutions to streamline process to enhance a company’s bottom line.
Our Social Impact Value Proposition: Provide sustainable and meaningful jobs for people with
disabilities and others whom face significant barriers to employment.
OUR NEW BRAND:
Our name signifies the core essence of our unique model. Working side by side and together with industry
to achieve common goals.
4. Some Terms and Definitions:
1. Non-Profit Organization -NPO –is an organization that uses
surplus revenues to achieve its goals rather than distributing them as profit
or dividends.
2. Triple Bottom Line- TBL-adds two more “bottom lines,” social
and environmental concerns. All three together are often paraphrased as:
Profit-People-Planet.
3. People with Disabilities-PWD-Disability is a consequence of an
impairment that maybe physical, cognitive, sensory, emotional, developmental, or
some combination of these.
4. Corporate Social Responsibility-CSR-is a form of
corporate self-regulation integrated into the business model. CSR Policy
functions as a built-in self regulating mechanism whereby a business
monitors its active compliance with the spirit of the law, ethical standard,
and international norms.
6. Main types of value-added service
supply-chain operations most Nonprofits offer?
Forward Logistics:
Secondary Packaging, Contact Packaging, Co-Packing, Assembly, kitting and
fulfilment. Retail Ready-Customization projects: Shelf Ready, Display Ready, and
Replenishment Ready. Point of Purchase Display pack-out operations, bagging,
repacking, and more including operating franchises.
Reverse Logistics:
Operate as a node and decentralized product returns processing centers.
Compliance functions: 100% Auditing, QC, sort & report, inspection,
triage and gate-keeping etc. Re-Packing, sorting, and high-touch
operations. Light assembly, disassembly, and rework. Sustainability
programs, take-back/salvage projects. Closed loop re-use and recycling
programs. Easy Depot Repair operations: Plug n Play, and level 1 triage
operations. As most consumer electronics returns, 75% + have no trouble
found. Food Reclamation centers and reuse facilities. Parts Harvesting.
7. Top 10 Reasons:
What do Nonprofits bring to the Party?
1. On-Demand, large labor force that is cost effective, and typically is a
budget neutral or better solution.
2. Added flex space /capacity and act as a node or satellite returns location
to reduce freight spend in RL which is a high-cost factor.
3. High-touch jobs and high-velocity jobs you can outsource.
4. Great way for a company to demonstrate Corporate Social Responsibility.
5. A unique way to achieve the Triple Bottom Line.
6. RL can not be fully automated and still requires touches in the process.
7. Level 1 types of operation like -plug-in play. Pre-screen before products
get sent to a repair depot or facility with higher labor costs.
8. Easy to integrate IT systems- keep product tracking and flow visible.
9. Non-profits have been doing RL operations for decades and doing the
operations required in reverse logistics is their core competency.
10. RL is a non-core activity that should be outsourced. Nonprofits do many
of the common RL functions very well.
8. What are Corporations doing now
with Nonprofits and the disabled?
OEMs-Retailers, 3PLs, Liquidators, and CPGs all utilize
nonprofits/employ the disabled:
Forward and Reverse logistics operations.
Wal-Mart: E-recycle Initiative- utilizes non-profit network. Also, have a goal of
hiring 100,000 disabled veterans
Canon: Accessories-parts-re-kitting and various RL operations
Dell: Recycle computers-Goodwill Industries
Target- Australia utilizes Disability Works Australia. (DWA)
Walgreen’s: DC and store operations, and Lowes: DC- operations
P&G: Flexi-Center-Tambrands- Auburn, ME- 30% total workforce- (Have a
Physical or Developmental Disability). Asked why they are doing this: Cited a
study that showed over 70% of consumers would switch to a brand that
supports a great social cause.
Microsoft: Started pilot in 2015 to hire autistic folks.
UK: Remploy works with 2,500 businesses to place and hire PWD.
11. Why Utilize Nonprofits in (RL)
Reverse Logistics ?
Problem:
The three key issues with Reverse Logistics:
Sustainability, Risk mitigation and
optimizing product recovery values.
Labor + Transportation costs are the main cost factors in RL.
Solution:
There are over 2,400 service providers in the nonprofit
network in the US. (map-slide 23)
Reduce freight spend by using these sites and locations.
Untapped Labor Force: Unemployment rate among people
with disabilities (PWD) is 80%
PWD excel in repetitive, and rouge process work
The operations can stay within the US and cost neutral
13. What are the Numbers?
56.7 Million or 19% of the US population disabled. US Census-ADA
566,188 Intellectual and Developmentally Disabled
people getting services in the US. (2013) (ICI –UMass)
Only 20.1% of these folks are working in an
integrated employment setting. (ICI-UMass)
The current unemployment rate with people with
disabilities is near 80% in the US.
Over 56 million people in the US have a disability.
This customer market segment is often overlooked
and represents a total of billion dollars in annual
disposable income or purchasing power.
23. Where are the Nonprofit Service Network Providers
located that provide jobs for people with disabilities?
24. Dispelling the MYTHS: The Facts
Walgreen’s -Data Analysis Findings:
1. Productivity: There was no difference in picking rates for people with disabilities than
the rest of the workforce.
2. Turnover: Turnover for people with disabilities was 48% less than the rest of the
workforce.
3. Safety: In every measurement, people with disabilities were safer and costs were lower.
(based on the four metrics below)
A. Relative incidents-accidents per 1,000 motion hours.
B. Relative comparison of incidents/accidents/1,000 hours.
C. DART and OSHA Recordable.
D. Workers Compensation Costs Per Case.
Sears: Costs to Reasonably Accommodate: 1978-1996 data:
The total 436 people during this period: 69% of these were
$0. cost, 28% were less than $1,000. and only 3% cost over
$1,000 -to make worksite accommodations.
26. 2013: Diversity Inc-Top 10 Companies
for hiring People with Disabilities
1. Ernst and Young
2. Proctor and Gamble
3. IBM
4. KPMG
5. WellPoint
6. AT&T
7. Kaiser Permanente
8. Prudential Financial
9. Microsoft
10. Accenture
27. Summary
The Nonprofit network and its labor force in the US is a hidden but an
untapped asset & outsourcing solution for the reverse logistics industry.
Nonprofit is just a tax status. They do the many of same types of
operations/functions and process steps in RL as the For-Profits do.
You can create jobs or create inclusion for PWD within your operations.
The entire RL process will never be completely automated and labor is
needed. Nonprofits offer a cost effective solution for companies to
achieve their zero waste/sustainability goals and objectives.
Strongly encourage industry to tour nonprofits doing RL functions and
explore doing potential pilots, partnerships, and collaborations.
28. In Closing….
1. Want to explore innovative ways to streamline your
Supply chain process, minimize your costs, enhance
speed to market, or increase the recovery yields on
your products?
2. Want to proactively embrace your company’s CSR-
corporate social responsibility policies?
3. Want great customer service and the employees of
your logistics vendor/partner to “truly” love and
appreciate working for you?
If you answered “YES” to any of these questions, then you need to reach
out to a nonprofit service provider and explore how they can leverage
their resources to help your company.
30. Logistics and Supply Chain
executives need to change their thinking !
Insanity: Doing the same thing over and over again
and expecting the different results.
- Albert Einstein
31. Questions?
Thank You
Brian F. Eddy, MBA
Director, Business Development & Marketing
The ReHabilitation Center
(716) 375-4730, ext. 353
beddy@rehabcenter.org
www.rehabcenter.org
Editor's Notes
USBLN and US Chamber of Commerce: Leading Practices on Disability Inclusion- Many Case Studies
Marc Slegers: VP Supply Chain & Procurement at Telenet-BELGIUM
BW IMSIR: Nonprofit Service Provider
In 2013: Telenet won Supply-chain award for the collaboration on social responsibility
Saved 600 tons from the landfill and created 40 jobs for people at BW IMSIR
95% workforce disabled and former Remploy workers.
61,000 Sq. ft. Facility
PWD: People with Disabilities
RL: Reverse Logistics
45 people-Employed Disabled
TOTAL MEDICAID Spend-Federal & State- I/DD=407 Billion or 9.4% total-2012-RTCCL
TOTAL MEDICAID ENROLLMENT in US of I/DD=805,000 or 1.4% of the total 58.6 Million folks
Source: Sustainable Value Creation through Disability-April 3-2013-Rich Donavan
Source: www.disabiltiysurveys.org
2009: GDP 2.28% US. Dr. Dale Rodgers & Ron Lembke
Source: Resolvebyarrow
Goodwill of Indiana and Pride Industries
Employ folks that are deaf and have won many awards from the State of Texas
There are over 2,400 nonprofits that provide services in the US. Total US workforce of PWD exceeds 200,000 people- Dept. of labor 2014.
Walgreen’s Distribution Centers-Inclusion
De Paul Study
Dupont Study
MH&L: April 15, 2013: CSR Sustains Walgreen’s Supply Chain
Goal: Spend at least 1 Billion annually on diverse suppliers