Unraveling the mystery behind typical obesity patterns in Asians. Why Asians burn fat sparingly
Why Asian BMI cut-offs are lower than that of western counterparts
2. BMI is "Body Mass Index".
It tells you whether your body weight is appropriate for your height.
In Indians it is advisable that the BMI be not more than 22.9*
BMI = Weight in kilograms / (Height in meters) 2
3. John Yudkin, 60, is an obesity
expert and director of the
International Health and Medical
Education Centre at University
College London. He has a healthy
European diet, runs marathons and
has a body mass index (BMI)—a
measure commonly used as a
benchmark of body fat—of 22.3.
Chittaranjan Yajnik, 52, is an
obesity expert and director of the
Diabetes Unit at the KEM Hospital
Research Centre in Pune, India.
Yajnik has a predominantly
vegetarian Indian diet, but his only
exercise is running to catch elevator
doors at the hospital. He, too, has a
BMI of 22.3.
Yajnik appears thinner than Yudkin
(see Photo), but by dual X-ray
absorptiometry imagery, it is clear
that his compact frame belies more
body fat than his colleague's: he
carries some 21.2% body fat,
compared with Yudkin's 9.1%.
4. Not all adults who have a BMI in the range labelled "healthy" are at their most
healthy weight.
They may have lots of fat but very little muscle.
Similarly, if you are an athlete or exercise a lot, then you may have lots of
muscle and less fat and if your BMI is more than the normal range, then it
may still be healthy.
5. Asian Indian Phenotype (Thin-Fat Asian Indian)
At any body mass index (BMI) and age, Asian Indians have
higher body fat, visceral fat and waist circumference (WC)
lower skeletal muscle mass
thinner hips; short legs
profoundly higher rates of insulin resistance
unique clinical and biochemical characteristics that are commonly found among
Asian Indians in particular and South Asians in general are collectively referred to
6.
7. Why Asia?
Some of the reasons for the escalating numbers are universal: king-sized candy
bars and super-sized sodas, more cars, more food—and more of it processed.
Traditional Asian diets are generally far healthier, but since the 1960s, Asians
have been consuming bigger proportions of high-fat, high-sodium and low-fiber
foods.
And there are compounding cultural factors: Asian cultures tend to use food as a
reward, and in many Asian countries, a large body is seen as a welcome sign of
prosperity.
8. Most explanations for Asians' obesity revolve around their genetic
predisposition to store fat, particularly around the abdomen.
There may also be environmental features that mask as genetic factors.
In India, there may be an underlying risk of diabetes because of early
malnutrition or low birth weight (Intl. J. Obes. 27, 173−180; 2003).
Yajnik, for instance, weighed less than five pounds at birth.
9. Thrifty gene hypothesis
In 1962, James Neel suggested that exposure to periods of famine during human
evolutionary history resulted in selection pressures in favour of a thrifty genotype
that led to highly efficient fat storage during periods of abundance
In the current climate of food overabundance and sedentary lifestyle, this thrifty
genotype is suggested to lead to metabolically disadvantageous phenotypes.