SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Cory Satter
19 November 2015
REL 345
Huntington
The Pure Land: A New Conception of Justice
While sitting in class, I had a thought concerning the inherent compassion of Buddhism as
expressed by Shin Buddhism in the Tannisho. Brainstorming deeply, something about Shinran’s
claim that anyone may be born in the Pure Land — “how much more so the evil person” — struck
me. The Pure Land as an abode, however influenced by or similar similar in concept to the
Christian heaven (this is a separate topic), is characterized as a place of bliss and free from all
temptations. This includes women which, unsurprisingly, might be viewed as sexist to the non-
Buddhist. The goal of all this is to lead those reborn in the Pure Land on a path towards
enlightenment, to nirvana. I then remembered the Zoroastrian and some Islamic interpretations of
hell which is meant more as a place of purification rather than punishment, rehabilitative rather
than punitive. This, then, I see as the essence of the Pure Land.
To many in Western societies or, perhaps, to humans in general, the idea that an evil person
may be reborn in such a place as the Pure Land could be seen as a slight or as an injustice. To the
Shin Buddhist, however, it would be seen as quite the opposite. It would be seen as justice. Justice
is not characterized by revenge in this interpretation of it, but as a means to rehabilitate a
wrongdoer in order to realize the end of suffering. When samsara is broken, dukkha ceases. This
goes for the individual but, in many cases, suffering is contagious. If all are born in the Pure Land
and hence become enlightened or drawn towards nirvana, then suffering for all ceases. It could be
argued to be a quite revolutionary world view, akin to the Christian concept of “universal
reconciliation” shared in some circles.
If there is any lesson in this, I would say that Shin Buddhism as expressed by Shinran
encourages us to forgive a person rather than seek vengeance against him or her. It seeks to fix
people; it does not seek to inflict more harm on them. If anything, such a response would only
serve to corrupt the offender further. Indeed, we have seen real-world applications of such an idea.
Norway, for example, drew confused remarks from many in the United States and abroad with its
treatment of Anders Behring Breivik, the perpetrator of the 2011 terrorist attacks. There was no
execution, no torture. Even his sentencing has not been so much to punish as with the hopes of
rehabilitating him so that he may be again a productive, safe member of society one day. Norway
has itself admitted this will unlikely occur but continues to try. This is just one example where
forgiveness has triumphed over revenge. Sometimes it is unpopular, but a Buddhist — of any
denomination for that matter — may rebut that revenge is not conducive to enlightenment. And if
enlightenment and subsequent liberation is the goal to be pursued in life, it should not be obstructed
by the emotions of the ego.

More Related Content

What's hot

John the baptist revised
John the baptist revisedJohn the baptist revised
John the baptist revisedMrsSevCTK
 
Jesus was the walker on the water
Jesus was the walker on the waterJesus was the walker on the water
Jesus was the walker on the waterGLENN PEASE
 
5th february 2016 - The ministry of Jesus
5th february 2016 - The ministry of Jesus5th february 2016 - The ministry of Jesus
5th february 2016 - The ministry of JesusThorn Group Pvt Ltd
 
The Quintilemma
The QuintilemmaThe Quintilemma
The Quintilemmaguest60535
 
Advent 2018 peace_message_12.9.18
Advent 2018 peace_message_12.9.18Advent 2018 peace_message_12.9.18
Advent 2018 peace_message_12.9.18Vintage Church
 
Sermon Slide Deck: "The Resurrection of the Son of God" (Romans 1:1-4)
Sermon Slide Deck: "The Resurrection of the Son of God" (Romans 1:1-4)Sermon Slide Deck: "The Resurrection of the Son of God" (Romans 1:1-4)
Sermon Slide Deck: "The Resurrection of the Son of God" (Romans 1:1-4)New City Church
 
Vintage 10.3.21 the_bookofjob
Vintage 10.3.21 the_bookofjobVintage 10.3.21 the_bookofjob
Vintage 10.3.21 the_bookofjobVintage Church
 
Vintage 1.6.19 matthew2
Vintage 1.6.19 matthew2Vintage 1.6.19 matthew2
Vintage 1.6.19 matthew2Vintage Church
 
10 Things We've Forgotten About Evangelism
10 Things We've Forgotten About Evangelism10 Things We've Forgotten About Evangelism
10 Things We've Forgotten About EvangelismJesse Gardner
 
Jesus was compelling love
Jesus was compelling loveJesus was compelling love
Jesus was compelling loveGLENN PEASE
 
Introduction to theology of the body class 3
Introduction to theology of the body class 3Introduction to theology of the body class 3
Introduction to theology of the body class 3Incarnation0325
 
Lesson 13 - Three Phases of Xian Life
Lesson 13 - Three Phases of Xian LifeLesson 13 - Three Phases of Xian Life
Lesson 13 - Three Phases of Xian LifeDanny Medina
 
Medicine, Culture and Ethics, Autonomy.
Medicine, Culture and Ethics, Autonomy. Medicine, Culture and Ethics, Autonomy.
Medicine, Culture and Ethics, Autonomy. Mendy K
 
Do not be deceived mar 4
Do not be deceived mar 4Do not be deceived mar 4
Do not be deceived mar 4hekmaan
 
Jesus was the angel of his presence
Jesus was the angel of his presenceJesus was the angel of his presence
Jesus was the angel of his presenceGLENN PEASE
 

What's hot (20)

John the baptist revised
John the baptist revisedJohn the baptist revised
John the baptist revised
 
The Meaning of Easter
The Meaning of EasterThe Meaning of Easter
The Meaning of Easter
 
Jesus was the walker on the water
Jesus was the walker on the waterJesus was the walker on the water
Jesus was the walker on the water
 
5th february 2016 - The ministry of Jesus
5th february 2016 - The ministry of Jesus5th february 2016 - The ministry of Jesus
5th february 2016 - The ministry of Jesus
 
The Quintilemma
The QuintilemmaThe Quintilemma
The Quintilemma
 
Advent 2018 peace_message_12.9.18
Advent 2018 peace_message_12.9.18Advent 2018 peace_message_12.9.18
Advent 2018 peace_message_12.9.18
 
Sermon Slide Deck: "The Resurrection of the Son of God" (Romans 1:1-4)
Sermon Slide Deck: "The Resurrection of the Son of God" (Romans 1:1-4)Sermon Slide Deck: "The Resurrection of the Son of God" (Romans 1:1-4)
Sermon Slide Deck: "The Resurrection of the Son of God" (Romans 1:1-4)
 
Vintage 10.3.21 the_bookofjob
Vintage 10.3.21 the_bookofjobVintage 10.3.21 the_bookofjob
Vintage 10.3.21 the_bookofjob
 
Vintage 1.6.19 matthew2
Vintage 1.6.19 matthew2Vintage 1.6.19 matthew2
Vintage 1.6.19 matthew2
 
19 John 3:22-36 He...
19 John 3:22-36 He...19 John 3:22-36 He...
19 John 3:22-36 He...
 
10 Things We've Forgotten About Evangelism
10 Things We've Forgotten About Evangelism10 Things We've Forgotten About Evangelism
10 Things We've Forgotten About Evangelism
 
Jesus was compelling love
Jesus was compelling loveJesus was compelling love
Jesus was compelling love
 
Introduction to theology of the body class 3
Introduction to theology of the body class 3Introduction to theology of the body class 3
Introduction to theology of the body class 3
 
The Apostolic Hour
The Apostolic HourThe Apostolic Hour
The Apostolic Hour
 
Lesson 13 - Three Phases of Xian Life
Lesson 13 - Three Phases of Xian LifeLesson 13 - Three Phases of Xian Life
Lesson 13 - Three Phases of Xian Life
 
Medicine, Culture and Ethics, Autonomy.
Medicine, Culture and Ethics, Autonomy. Medicine, Culture and Ethics, Autonomy.
Medicine, Culture and Ethics, Autonomy.
 
Do not be deceived mar 4
Do not be deceived mar 4Do not be deceived mar 4
Do not be deceived mar 4
 
To Vincentians around the world, this Lent
To Vincentians around the world, this LentTo Vincentians around the world, this Lent
To Vincentians around the world, this Lent
 
Jesus was the angel of his presence
Jesus was the angel of his presenceJesus was the angel of his presence
Jesus was the angel of his presence
 
Sovereignty of god
Sovereignty of godSovereignty of god
Sovereignty of god
 

The Pure Land and Justice

  • 1. Cory Satter 19 November 2015 REL 345 Huntington The Pure Land: A New Conception of Justice While sitting in class, I had a thought concerning the inherent compassion of Buddhism as expressed by Shin Buddhism in the Tannisho. Brainstorming deeply, something about Shinran’s claim that anyone may be born in the Pure Land — “how much more so the evil person” — struck me. The Pure Land as an abode, however influenced by or similar similar in concept to the Christian heaven (this is a separate topic), is characterized as a place of bliss and free from all temptations. This includes women which, unsurprisingly, might be viewed as sexist to the non- Buddhist. The goal of all this is to lead those reborn in the Pure Land on a path towards enlightenment, to nirvana. I then remembered the Zoroastrian and some Islamic interpretations of hell which is meant more as a place of purification rather than punishment, rehabilitative rather than punitive. This, then, I see as the essence of the Pure Land. To many in Western societies or, perhaps, to humans in general, the idea that an evil person may be reborn in such a place as the Pure Land could be seen as a slight or as an injustice. To the Shin Buddhist, however, it would be seen as quite the opposite. It would be seen as justice. Justice is not characterized by revenge in this interpretation of it, but as a means to rehabilitate a wrongdoer in order to realize the end of suffering. When samsara is broken, dukkha ceases. This goes for the individual but, in many cases, suffering is contagious. If all are born in the Pure Land and hence become enlightened or drawn towards nirvana, then suffering for all ceases. It could be argued to be a quite revolutionary world view, akin to the Christian concept of “universal reconciliation” shared in some circles. If there is any lesson in this, I would say that Shin Buddhism as expressed by Shinran encourages us to forgive a person rather than seek vengeance against him or her. It seeks to fix people; it does not seek to inflict more harm on them. If anything, such a response would only serve to corrupt the offender further. Indeed, we have seen real-world applications of such an idea. Norway, for example, drew confused remarks from many in the United States and abroad with its treatment of Anders Behring Breivik, the perpetrator of the 2011 terrorist attacks. There was no execution, no torture. Even his sentencing has not been so much to punish as with the hopes of rehabilitating him so that he may be again a productive, safe member of society one day. Norway has itself admitted this will unlikely occur but continues to try. This is just one example where forgiveness has triumphed over revenge. Sometimes it is unpopular, but a Buddhist — of any denomination for that matter — may rebut that revenge is not conducive to enlightenment. And if enlightenment and subsequent liberation is the goal to be pursued in life, it should not be obstructed by the emotions of the ego.