FedCASIC 2019: Designing, implementing, and analyzing Leverage Saliency Theor...
The NBA in China- How to
1. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
1
The NBA in China: How to Maximize International Profits
Travis Malott
San Diego State University
May 11, 2015
B.A. Economics and International Studies
2. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
2
Introduction
The National Basketball Association has become a global brand behemoth that isn’t
to be meddled with. Created in 1946, it’s still considered a new association, years younger
than its American professional sport siblings, the NFL, MLB, and NHL. Basketball fans are
generally found in the United States, but being the fastest growing sport on earth today, its
international fandom presence is beginning to be felt. “With 30 teams in the United States
and Canada, NBA games and related programming are broadcast to 214 countries in 43
languages via 157 telecasters;” they are one of the largest suppliers of sports television and
internet programming in the world (Cheong 2005, p.2). Thus, research on such an emergent
sport in an expanding country seems inevitable, in this case, the NBA in China. China has
seen a spike of fandom towards the NBA in the last decade, and today has obtained the
attention of nearly 70 million viewers, which giants the 400,000 Chinese viewers that the
NFL captures. China being, “the most populous nation on earth, with 1.3 billion people” in
comparison to United States’ 284 million, demonstrates the need to apprehend such a
massive population of individuals that make up a large part of the world (LaFleur 2003 p. 4).
The potential here is skyscraping, yet it waits in broad daylight leaving Americans
befuddled by the towering silhouette in front of them. The NBA took a step backwards when
they found themselves in the 2011 lockout, the fourth lockout the NBA has bequeathed upon
the public, but three years later it’s worth taking a look at the global economic impacts the
2011 lockout could have made. In addition, newly designated NBA Commissioner Adam
Silver holds a global vision that reaches out as far as the Asian markets. This investigation is
not only to try and discover possibilities that rest in the Middle Kingdom, but rather answer
3. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
3
why they are even there in the first place, and how The National Basketball Association can
make the most of these international waters.
The research question chosen for this study is as follows; what is the most economical
direction for the National Basketball Association to take in order to broaden its global brand
name to the Chinese basketball fandom market, with the intent of maximizing its
international profits?
Pre-departure Methodology
Participants
It is anticipated that ages across the board would make for the most usable data.
Participants should be 18-60 years of age, born and raised Chinese citizens. They should be
a mixture of basketball fans and people who simply don’t care. To ensure unbiased results,
sex should be split down the middle, and identities should remain unanimous. The desired
amount of surveys collected is 40, or 45 to be safe.
Materials
-80 printed surveys and carrying portfolio
-Writing utensils
-Willing participants
Procedure
4. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
4
For a research project of a topic such as this, a quantitative analysis method is most
appropriate. Quantitative data collection seemed most efficient, and was chosen as the
primary source of research. For the bulk of the information retrieved in China, a survey
consisting of approximately 20 questions will ensure the least biased results. The survey will
allow specific questions to be asked that have been prepared for this study, questions
designed to lead to the most effective marketing techniques in both America and China, and
maximizing profits in both markets. Correlation data is most efficiently collected through
quantitative methods, and it will break down the language barrier many run into when
performing a research project overseas. If any ambiguities are found in the first couple
surveys, changes will be made for the following participants so that the preferred
information is addressed and misunderstandings are discontinued. It is anticipated that parts
of the survey might not be clear, due to lack of language skills, but with this being expected
it will be easy to detect. This challenge can be hurdled with on the go adjustments that come
from locals and participants.
The data collector’s trip to China begins at Capital Normal University, Beijing. He
will be partaking in the Beijing Language Program for four weeks, practicing Mandarin
Chinese skills, but not wasting any time in the research department. After getting settled in
for three days, it is back to the grind and it begins with making sure the survey is completely
translated and ready for use in China. More than one residential student will be asked to go
over the grammar of the survey, and make sure questions are easy to understand and answer.
This is essential and will raise the accuracy of what the participants are really trying to say.
The next step is data collection, which means handing out surveys. Starting with the college
students surrounding Capital Normal University in the heart of Beijing, it is estimated that
5. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
5
approximately 15 surveys will be fully completed by the end of this week. Surveyed
students can be asked if they can refer the investigator to any near friends for number of
results purposes and simply ease purposes. Because the target demographic isn’t as specified
as college students only, the second week will be more focused on retrieving data from
individuals outside Capital Normal University. Unless recommendations are received of the
best places to find willing middle-aged Chinese citizens to survey, the streets and strangers
will have to do in order to retrieve non-student data. Adjustments should be made by this
time to ensure the best possible survey, with no mistakes. This section might be difficult, so
persistency is key, and anybody would be lucky if fifteen more surveys were filled out by
the end of the week, though it is only expected to finalize ten. This same method should
serve well the third week abroad, only more smoothly and efficiently. Investigator should be
working at an optimal speed, finding themselves with more time on their hands. This allots
for the opportunity to begin looking over filled out surveys for any flaws or unusable
surveys. If this problem arises, adjustments should be made accordingly. Week four will roll
around quickly, and it would be wise to coast to the finish of the first half abroad in China
with ten more surveys completed.
The goal for the four week duration in Beijing, the less rural portion of the data
collection, is 45 surveys completed. As stated earlier, the survey is to be no more than 20
questions, including the socio-demographic questions. It will consist of questions that are
related to the NBA and interest in NBA. They will be premeditated to measure the
difference of attentiveness between entire franchises and single-star players. They will also
cover the importance level of season tickets for the NBA, if it were to expand to China. All
6. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
6
surveying will be done publicly. The main priority is that the location is safe and that the
participant feels comfortable.
Four weeks in, and it’s time to start the second half of the data collection process in
China. In this case, our investigator will be teaching English in rural parts of Beijing. The
Program is called the Summer Service Learning Program and is run through Tsinghua
University, the highest acclaimed University in China. The opportunity to survey local
Chinese on the rural side of the spectrum presents itself and only furthers the study, so
surveys will be handed out willingly, while taking observational side notes. This diversity
expands research and its range of information. The students joining the teaching exhibition
will all be studying at Tsinghua University, and are considered to be the top students China
has to offer at a collegiate level. Surveys are to be completed until there is a total of about 45
surveys, and observational notes on behavior and attitude towards basketball and the NBA
throughout the eight weeks in China.
Research Methodology Actually Used
Participants
It was anticipated that ages across the board would make for the most usable data.
This was not the case in reality, as most consisted of students aged 16-21 residing in rural
Guizhou, China. It proved extremely difficult to get other Chinese citizens involved. Of the
Guizhou students, all of which were born and raised Chinese citizens. They were a mixture
of basketball fans and students who simply didn’t care. To ensure unbiased results, sex was
split down the middle as much as possible, and identities remained unanimous on the
7. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
7
surveys. The amount of surveys collected was 40 Chinese, and 40 American. The American
participants aged ranged from 16-55, landing the desired participants for China. They were
born and raised American citizens. They were a mixture of basketball fans and not fans. To
ensure unbiased results, sex was split down the middle as much as possible, and identities
remained unanimous on the surveys. The American portion of surveyors was on track with
pre-departure requirements.
Materials
-80 printed surveys and carrying portfolio
-Writing utensils
-Willing participants
Procedure
Obtaining data was harder than presumed, and because of this, research methodology
had to be altered. There were a few differences between how research was assumed to be
performed, although luckily many things went according to plan. When the investigator
landed in Beijing, a student was asked at Capital Normal University (who was excellent at
English) to translate the survey into full characters. This proved invaluable, as it served as an
exceptional survey the rest of the trip. All 40 surveys were filled out by students of the
Guizhou high school, and there were no questions regarding the Mandarin Chinese in the
survey. This wasn’t the demographic intentionally sought after, but any data is good data. In
addition, many behavioral notes were taken during the time abroad. The investigator played
basketball with his students during recess, a game that took everyone’s focus on the
blacktop. And during teaching hours, the investigator talked to them about sports and how
8. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
8
interested they are. The information wasn’t numerically usable, but it could be paired with
quantitative data.
The method of gathering data in America is much different. There is more time
available, and more people willing. Without the language barrier, the investigator should
have no time getting 40 surveys completed by a diverse selection of willing participants. The
surveys are exactly the same questions as on the Chinese version. A simple method that
worked in this case was standing on campus and asking if anybody would like to participate.
This saw a great deal of responses and accounted for approximately half the surveys filled
out.
Literature Review
For a long time, sports in China were mainly organized in a way that maximized
their contribution to national prestige (Bardon 2008, p.39). The emergence of a true sports
market is a very recent phenomenon. Tracking the development of China's sports market,
Severine Bardon (2008) explained in ‘The Economics of Sport in China: A Maturing
Sector’, that the sports market might be too risky to attract investors… right now. China is a
blossoming country, and with its maturity comes developing markets, sports being one of
them. Some of the downsides to an immature market is that the chance of failure is
inevitably extremely high. Chinese in-house sports hasn’t seen an explosion in revenue in
the last few decades, which in turn creates a domino effect. “Low revenue is caused by less
attraction to the market”, which then creates less talent to accumulate, lowering revenue
more (Hughson 2007 p.4). This is why there are teams that are constantly bad in one sport,
9. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
9
i.e. The Jacksonville Jaguars. It’s a proven equation and makes digging out of slumps a
challenge. Well, imagine that instead of one team, we’re talking about an entire country’s
sports market, and instead of the NFL were talking about the entire global sports economics.
China just can’t seem to get out of that rut and start making money and creating attention for
their local fans or talent, “China tends to choose sports that are popular abroad in order to
attract international sponsors”, this lack in domestic revenue explains the demand for the
NBA brand (Bardon 2008 pg. 42). Because the sports market in China is still immature, the
investment risk is too high to try to do anything in China’s backyard, and this leads us to the
question, where do we turn? We don’t need to turn, the Chinese already turned to us.
Fandom is a significant element in this equation, or in other words, how big of fans
are the Chinese in relation to Americans? And in what sports? Dr. Sam Kaplan performed an
extensive research project between the two countries, and found some very interesting
information. Through quantitative analysis involving several hundred participants from both
countries, Kaplan found that, “significantly more American participants followed baseball,
American football, golf, ice hockey, tennis and other sports. Significantly more Chinese
participants followed automobile racing and basketball” (Kaplan 2012 p.13). He also points
out that American fans tend to follow certain teams, i.e. the Boston Red sox, New England
Patriots, etc. While China’s fandom seems to be focused more towards certain superstar
players, cue the Kobe Bryant’s, and Derek Rose’s. Essentially, the typical Chinese NBA fan
is lacking a true loyalty towards just one team. This is significant because it might be the
key to exploitation of the Chinese market. A difference this intangible oozes clues of profit
to be made.
10. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
10
Sports participation in China has emerged with new spaces, forms, contents and
concepts. Although elite sport has still been tightly “controlled by the state as a political
instrument, sport and exercise at its roots has become an individual and social activity” as a
new feature in Chinese urban life (Huang 2013 p.12). The Chinese people have “benefited
from increased opportunities and have made great progress in sports participation,”
particularly the increase in basketball playtime (Huan 2007 p.441). More and more Chinese
are playing basketball as a leisure sport, and hoops are popping up at record rates. With this,
basketball awareness has only increased as well.
However, awareness isn’t the only aspect of value. There is a direct correlation
between annual income per capita and willingness to be involved in the sporting industry.
While playing sports and physical activity vary when discussing upper and lower class
differences from sport to sport, one thing holds true; viewing of sports is directly correlated
with social class, and the majority of sports fans lie in the middle class (Huan 2007 p.442).
This has been proven across the world, and is of relevance when discussing the NBA and
China forming a merge. Why? China, as a nation, is experiencing the formation of a middle
class as we speak. Yang (2012) discussed the middle class in China as a “side-effect of its
capitalistic movement” in recent years (p.525). Political transformation has taken place since
the passing of Mao Zedong, and in the span of three decades, China has evolved from an
autarkic and underdeveloped backwater into the world's second largest economy and its
largest trader. The creation of such a powerful labor force and middle class are essential to
sport viewing growth in China’s economy, and will play a major role in the final decision as
to whether the NBA should invest it’s time in such a risky sporting market.
11. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
11
Findings
Being reported in the findings section is the results of the 40 surveys from China and
40 surveys from America. It is 80 in total, but 2 of the surveys from china had unreadable
Mandarin and were considered unusable. All of the surveys given to American participants
had high end anonymity and were considered usable. The survey was 20 questions in total,
and one sheet double sided. Of the 80 people surveyed, it is hoped that the findings answer
the research question stated earlier, and can help whomever needs this research in help of
marketing the National Basketball Association in China. On to the survey format, and
eventually, the results.
Unsurprisingly, the survey began with a couple dichotomous questions that asked
age, sex, education level, and whether or not the participant enjoys watching basketball on
the television. This was so the data could be looked back on, and it could be ensured the
participants covered almost all the demographics being targeted. Sex was less evenly
distributed than wished, with 35% of Chinese participants being female, and 42% of
American participants being female, it seemed as if there weren’t many females interested in
helping in the experiment. In addition to the dichotomous data gathered, a question that
should be pointed out was, “Do you enjoy watching basketball games?” 1 being yes, and 2
being no. The Chinese participants scored an average of 1.21 out of the 38 surveyed. This
trumps the 40 Americans surveyed, who tallied up an average of 1.725, proving the majority
of Americans did not enjoy watching the NBA on TV. Though it is expected that the
averages would be closer, this will probably prove true if more participants are involved.
But if not, this data is valuable as it would support the idea of expanding the NBA, or simply
the TV time across the Atlantic, to the Chinese market.
12. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
12
Next the survey asked a simple multiple choice question, Q9. Who do you think is
the best of these four players? A (1), B (2), C (3), or D (4). The first four are all point guards
in the NBA right now. Stephan Curry, who was crowned the MVP of the NBA in the 2015
regular season, Kyrie Irving, Jeremy Lin, and Deron Williams. The ‘trap’ answer in this
question is Jeremy Lin. A Chinese American who graduated from Harvard. He made a huge
splash in the media in 2013 when he played for the New York Knicks, and started an
epidemic titled ‘Linsanity’. The catch was that he was simply an average player, an
undersized Chinese American, who made up for his lack in physical attributes in
fundamentals, smart basketball, and pure will power. Unfortunately true, anybody who
knows about the NBA will tell you he is now extremely overrated, as he plays for the
Lakers, who are considered one of the worst teams in the NBA and is not even a starter.
Jeremy Lin is the equivalent of Tim Tebow in the NFL, or Keynes in Economics, who has
been disproved multiple times yet still has the majority of the population on his side. So the
desired result with this multiple choice question, are the Chinese viewers of the NBA going
to choose Jeremy Lin based completely on his ethnicity? How much power does the media
hold over many of us? The findings were fascinating. 2/3rds, nearly 66% of the participants
in China selected Jeremy Lin as the best player, even when Stephan Curry was available, the
league’s Most Valuable Player in 2015. For the American participants, 32.5% chose Jeremy
Lin, roughly 1/3rd
. This is still too high, and the discussion can be saved for another research
study titled, “Do We Choose our Favorite Athletes, or Does the Media?” The player selected
most by American participants was actually Kyrie Irving, sitting atop at 45%. The next
question, Q10, regarding NBA players had another trap answer for the Chinese participants.
Who is the best? Kareem Abdul Jabar, Bill Russell, Wilt Chamberlin, or Yao Ming? Though
13. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
13
there is no clear answer, it does not matter. What matters is the data. Are the Chinese going
to lean towards Yao Ming? A pattern began to emerge, making a regression analysis
between Q9 (Jeremy Lin) and Q10 (Yao Ming) calculable in regards to our desired results.
Allow the P-value given to be highlighted. At .00000172, this pattern is extremely justified,
and the data is considered significant. Many Chinese are either only aware of, or simply
supportive of their own ethnicity. 87% of the Chinese people sampled believed Yao Ming
was better than Bill Russell (holds 11 championship rings), Wilt Chamberlin (scored 100
points in a game), and Kareem Abdul Jabar (single handedly forced the NBA to enforce a
SUMMARY OUTPUT
Regression Statistics
Multiple R 0.241234
R Square 0.058194
Adjusted R
Square 0.032033
Standard
Error 0.789336
Observations 38
ANOVA
df SS MS F
Significance
F
Regression 1 1.385933 1.385933 2.224428 0.144555
Residual 36 22.42986 0.623052
Total 37 23.81579
Coefficients
Standard
Error t Stat P-value Lower 95%
Upper
95%
Lower
95.0%
Upper
95.0%
Intercept 3.068345 0.537693 5.7065 1.72E-06 1.977853 4.158837 1.977853 4.158837
X Variable 1 -0.21763 0.145915 -1.49145 0.144555 -0.51356 0.078304 -0.51356 0.078304
14. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
14
goaltending rule, because he was too dominant for the competition of his time). The
significance of this data speaks volumes, and opens a window that could explain how the
NBA can seek to maximize profits abroad if they wish to do so. The Americans surveyed
voted Yao Ming a mere 15%, with the average of all the answers sitting at 2.375, right in the
middle of all 4 options. The Americans were much more all over the board than the
seemingly unanimous decision by the 38 Chinese surveyed.
The next question sampled for four NBA players, and none of them are of the
Chinese ethnicity. Many common players, and keeping to the routine, the survey asked who
is the best; Chris Paul, Kevin Durant, Kobe Bryant, or LeBron James? 66% of the Chinese
said the California hero, Kobe Bryant. The Americans surveyed were skeptical in their
decision, and spread out the answers evenly, with the majority choosing LeBron “The King”
James. As Dr. Kaplan mentioned earlier in his own findings, “American fans tend to follow
certain teams, i.e. the Boston Red sox, New England Patriots, etc. While China’s fandom
seems to be focused more towards certain superstar players, cue the Kobe Bryant’s, and
Derek Rose’s” (Kaplan 2012 p.13).
The rest of the survey is taken in an interval level. Questions 18-21 were formatted
as follows; ‘rate on a scale from 1-5, 1 being strongly disagree, 5 being strongly agree’. The
first question was upfront and asked the participants if they want the NBA to focus its
attention on China more? The results were shocking. The Chinese surveyed had an average
score of 1.52, leaning heavily on the strongly disagree. Even more surprisingly, the
Americans scored higher! With an average of 1.75, this data would suggest that Americans
want the NBA to focus on China more than the Chinese. See figure 1 below.
15. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
15
Figure 1.
The trend line above sits uncomfortably low at 1.5, only showing a slight increase as
participants were surveyed. This is alarming as it could be a hint towards proving that the
NBA should not try to make any profits in China, and that it is a waste of time. The next
interval question was regarding NBA apparel. It asked the surveyor if they were interested in
buying signed jerseys or apparel from the NBA. This way the NBA could make up some of
that lost effort by simply creating a program in which they exploit the wants of the specific
Chinese market. They returned with an impressive average of 3.05 of interest. The American
side scored a 2.3.
In figure 2 below, the more green you see the more interest the Chinese have in
signed apparel. In other terms, the Chinese rated their interest in signed apparel by the NBA
26% higher than the American fans. Something worth looking at in the future.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
Degree
of
Interest
Par.cipants
Chinese
on
if
the
NBA
Should
Focus
its
Efforts
on
China
16. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
16
Figure 2.
To help specify all the participants interests, the next question asked ‘1 to 5, are you
interested in role-players that benefit the entire team in the NBA, whether you know their
name or not?’ Chinese average was a 1.65, and the Americans was 2.3. This statistic is very
interesting to me, and it will be discussed why in the next section. Lastly, the investigator
asked if the person being surveyed wanted to see more NBA on their TV. Both the
American’s and the Chinese scored an average of 1.95, agreeing on the amount of NBA they
see on TV being enough. That is great news for the NBA as it means they are not too much
or too little in national broadcasting. They seem to be in that equilibrium of just right
exposure.
The findings above provide insights that are beneficial, but mistakes were made that
could jeopardize the results of this research study. To start, all the Chinese participants
surveyed are 16-20 years old, when my American participants range from 16-50. This is
huge as it changes the wants and needs drastically, and data may be misinterpreted from
China, because it may just be an age difference, not a cultural difference that is observed.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
9
17
25
33
Level
of
Interest
ParMcipants
Are
the
Chinese
interested
in
Purchasing
Signed
Apparel?
17. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
17
Another notable mistake is that the sex differential is not 50/50. And lastly, the questions on
the survey could have been better in determining exactly how to specify a strategy to
maximizing profits in China. Only about 8 of the questions out of the 20 held statistical
value, and more research before departure to China could have allowed little data to go a
long way.
Discussion
Restating of Hypothesis
1.) If jersey sales is related to market-clearing price, then lowering the price of authentic apparel
in order to combat the amount of faux jerseys circulating through the market should increase
sales. The NBA brand in China is already well known, leaving the ball in the NBA’s court
for apparel exploitation. Lowering the price of jerseys and other apparel would bring the
quantity demanded up, bringing the NBA one step closer to equilibrium in the Chinese
market, and minimizing dead weight losses.
2.) The more TV time the NBA can snag in China the better. Because if television broadcasting
is linked to familiarizing the NBA brand with Chinese citizens and consumers, then
exposing China to as much NBA TV coverage as possible will indeed make the NBA more
recognizably preferred over former sport viewing options.
3.) Lastly, if superstar fandom is correlated to NBA product consumption in China, then
broadcasting teams with more popular players such as Kobe Bryant, LeBron James, and
Carmelo Anthony would maximize international profits. In addition to television
18. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
18
broadcasting, autographing and meet and greets in public settings would also increase
demand in the NBA global brand.
After analyzing the data and how it compares to my hypothesis and literature review,
there is some room to discuss. The comparisons between the literature review and data
gathered are proven in the data. Firstly, Dr. Kaplun was spot on in saying that, “American
fans tend to follow certain teams, i.e. the Boston Red sox, New England Patriots, etc. While
China’s fandom seems to be focused more towards certain superstar players, cue the Kobe
Bryant’s, and Derek Rose’s” (Kaplun 2012 p.13). Looking back at questions surveyed that
were multiple choice regarding certain players, this was proven true over and over. Except
this can be taken a step further and it can be concluded that yes, the Chinese preferred stars
over role players much heavier than Americans, but they even preferred Chinese stars over
other star. Focusing more closely on Question 19 which asked ‘1 to 5, are you interested in
role-players that benefit the entire team in the NBA, whether you know their name or not?’
Chinese average was a 1.65, and the Americans was 2.3. The Chinese preference towards
star players over exceptional teamwork is extremely interesting, for cultural reasons. If
anybody travels to China, they will experience both capitalism and communism, but still
mostly communism. Communism stems from the sense of community, and playing roles for
the greater good of a group of people. It could be assumed the Chinese would support the
same ideologies on the basketball court, but it is the complete opposite. They prefer the
superstar, the player who may shoot under 50% after taking 40 shots, but regardless he
scored most the points. In America, viewers tend to prefer the teamwork, the ball passing,
and the spreading out of points. It’s more fundamentally known, and even though it’s more
common to look ahead, American’s are still a classical, reminiscing culture, ‘good –old’
19. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
19
Hoosier basketball is still proof of this. It should be highlighted and considered curious that
our political systems completely mirror each other’s, and so do our basketball fandom, only
oppositely.
As hypothesized and found in other literature such as Bardon S. (2008), Cheong S.
C. (2005, and Huang (2013), “the NBA can and should use this specified obsession to
exploit the Chinese markets” (Huang 2013). In doing so, they will show teams that appeal to
stardom, similar to the NBA today in America, only zero fans in China have a local priority
or inherited fandom, giving the NBA the opportunity of true flexibility. In America, the
NBA has as much control as Russell Wilson with a baseball, which is still an exceptional
amount of control. However, in China, the NBA can act like Russell Wilson with a
football... a perfect match. As much air coverage as the Los Angeles Lakers, New York
Knicks, and L.A. Clippers as possible, with no profit backlash of minor market teams. “With
a clean slate, the National Basketball Association can paint a picture of the fandom they
wish” (Bardon 2008). A powerful strategy would be offering signed apparel by certain
Chinese star players, possibly Chinese themed jerseys signed by them as well, and continue
to have major market teams travel across the pond to play in Beijing and Shanghai.
The first third of the profit maximizing hypothesis was correct, but what about the
second? The data says it was completely wrong. The Chinese participants, whether they
watched the NBA on TV or not, were not interested in increasing its TV time in any way,
shape, or form. The Chinese prefer the small increments they get, and it is possible that is
what makes the sport so appealing. Side note, “the government in China is still in charge of
nearly everything broadcasted on national public television” (Towns K. 2007), so whether
the people want more NBA or not, it might be a harder sale than presumed.
20. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
20
It seemed clear that nobody thought the NBA should focus their efforts towards
China. The American’s don’t want it, and neither do the Chinese. They seem to enjoy
witnessing from afar. But that doesn’t mean they don’t want to get in on the signed apparel
action. The survey results suggested that more Chinese than Americans would like to buy
signed apparel by NBA superstars, a market in itself waiting to emerge. This was discussed
in the third section of the hypothesis above, and seems to hold true. It would be an extremely
effective method of enhancing the NBA global brand, and a cheap one as well, who doesn’t
like more bang for your buck?
After the data and results discussed above, hopefully there can be a marketing
comprehension that will help the National Basketball Association in pinpointing just how
they can specialize in the up and coming Chinese demographic. Increasing efficiency, and
decreasing deadweight losses, the research performed has shown some surprises, also
solidified some assumptions, and it’s time for a conclusion in the matter.
Conclusion
The NBA has a good thing going for them. With 70 million people in China
interested enough to view the broadcast regularly, they have a chance at capitalizing on this
opportunity. The question is not whether or not they can; it’s how. What is the most
effective strategy to ensure success, and minimize deadweight losses? After traveling to
China and gathering data that focuses on answering that exact question, there is a multiple of
specific approaches that have been found are strong responses by the general Chinese public
if implemented by the National Basketball Association, as put in more detail below.
21. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
21
Foremost, specificity is huge. As proved via data gathered abroad, the Chinese are
extremely interested in supporting Chinese stars. Yao Ming, Jeremy Lin- they don’t have to
be good, they just have to be Chinese. This can be taken advantage of in a multitude of
ways. Jersey sales for such players should be targeted across major Chinese cities.
Marketing that promotes these player’s teams would also be highly productive. Even flying
certain players out for memorabilia signings could be considered a prolific venture. Adding
the best Chinese players in the CBA to the NBA would be a fruitful investment in the long
run. As the NBA is already doing, teams should continue playing in Beijing, Shanghai, and
Hong Kong multiple times per year, only to further this, the teams chosen should consist of
at least one Chinese super star. This will increase the popularity and a slight rise in TV
broadcast viewership might be a side effect of the process.
As strange as it sounds, another NBA lockout would be beneficial to the NBA for the
Chinese fans. Nearly all of the participants surveyed knew what the NBA lockout was, and
here’s why. When the lockout happened, many players traveled across the pond to find work
elsewhere. Many landed in the Chinese Basketball Association. This rose the level of
interest greatly, and the ripple effect is still being felt today. Pushing as many NBA players
towards the Chinese market as possible seems like it would be a negative thing, but it might
end up actually making the National Basketball Association more money in the down the
road.
And lastly, TV broadcasting does not need to be increased, in China or America. The
people surveyed were very clear about that. Keep in mind that does not mean it is in its most
efficient form as of now. If the NBA only showed major market teams in the Asian region,
they would gain more viewers with less TV time. More value for the money invested. Such
22. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
22
teams include the Los Angeles Lakers, fueled by the Kobe Bryant and newly acquired
Jeremy Lin loving Chinese Market, and the New York Knicks with Carmelo Anthony. Big
names, big cities, big viewership in little China. American TV broadcasting of the NBA
already has a recipe for success, focusing their efforts on the Playoffs and concentrating on
local broadcasting during regular season.
In Conclusion, the National Basketball Association is seeking a business tactic that
optimizes efforts in the international market of China. After gathering data from both China
and America on the subject, a method for success has been formulated just for this occasion.
From this research project, a lot has been gained regarding people and their attentiveness for
professional basketball. Different cultures have different interests, and in some cases require
different means of deliverance. This holds true when discussing the consumption of a
globally recognized brand such as the NBA. In this case, a different approach to the market
should be taken, even if the viewers are getting the exact same product of entertainment. In
brief, the research, data gathered, findings and information interpretation on the matter, The
National Basketball Association should have an easier time getting over this ‘great wall’ of a
marketing query.
23. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
23
Survey
1.) Age:
A. 20-30 C. 41-50
B. 31-40 D. 50+
2.) Sex:
A. Male B. Female
3.) Education Level:
A. High School D. College
B. Graduate Degree E. PhD
C. None F. I’d rather not say
4.) Do you play basketball for fun?
A. Yes B. No
5.) Have you ever heard of the NBA?
A. Yes B. No
6.) Do you enjoy watching basketball games?
A. Yes B. No
7.) Which do you enjoy watching more? Chinese Basketball Association or National Basketball
Association?
A. NBA B. CBA
8.) Do you own NBA apparel or jerseys?
A. Yes B. No
Is the man who gave you this survey in the NBA?
A. Yes B. No
v 9.) Who is the best player out of these four?
A. Stephon Curry C. Jeremy Lin
B. Kyrie Irving D. Deron Williams
10.) Who is the best player out of these four?
A. Kareem Abdul Jabar C. Wilt Chamberlin
B. Bill Russell D. Yao Ming
11.) Who is the best player out of these four?
A. Chris Paul C. Kevin Durant
B. Kobe Bryant D. LeBron James
12.) Which team is going to win it all next year?
A. Los Angeles Lakers C. New York Knicks
B. Miami Heat D. Boston Celtics
13.) Where do you think an NBA team would be in China, if there were one?
A. Hong Kong C. Shanghai
24. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
24
B. Beijing D. All of the Above
14.) How much would you be willing to pay for an authentic Kobe Bryant, LeBron James, or
Carmelo Anthony signed jersey, if he signed it right in front of you?
A. 600 Renminbi ($96) C. 1200 Renminbi ($192)
B. 1800 Renminbi ($288) D. 2400 Renminbi ($384)
15.) When did you begin watching the NBA?
A. 1990-1995 B. 1996-2000
C. 2001-2005 D.2006-2010
E.2011-present day F. I’ve never watched the NBA
16.) Do you know what the 2011 NBA Lockout is?
A. Yes! It’s when the Laker’s players, including Kobe Bryant, were locked out of their travel
bus, and had to forfeit a playoff game.
B. Yes! It’s when the players and owners couldn’t come to an agreement about how much
the players should be paid, and it forced many players to travel overseas in order to make any money
playing basketball
C. Yes! It’s when Jeremy Lin was drafted to the New York Knicks, before ‘linsanity’ began.
D. No, I have no idea what the NBA Lockout is.
17.) Is the man who gave you this survey in the NBA?
A. Yes B. No
v On a scale from 1-5, 1 being strongly disagree, 5 being strongly agree:
Strongly Disagree Strongly Agree
18.) I want the NBA to focus its attention on China more!
1 2 3 4 5
19.) I am interested in buying signed apparel and jerseys from the NBA
1 2 3 4 5
20.) I am interested in role-players that benefit the entire team in the NBA, whether their name is
well known or not.
1 2 3 4 5
21.) I want to see more NBA games on Television!
1 2 3 4 5
If answered 3, 4 or 5- do you have a preferred station you’d like to see the games on?
25. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
25
References
Cheong S. C. (2005). China Mobile and NBA Enter into Multi-Year Marketing
Partnership; M-Zone Allows NBA Fans to Stay Connected with Wireless NBA Content. New
York: Business Wire.
LaFleur, R. A. (2003). China: A global studies handbook. Santa Barbara, Calif.: ABC-
CLIO.
Bardon S. (2008). The Economics of Sport in China: A Maturing Sector. China
Perspectives, issue 1
Kaplan S. (2012). Chinese fandom and potential marketing strategies for expanding the
Market for American professional sports into China. Baltimore, Maryland: International
Journal of Sports Marketing & Sponsorship
Huan X. (2007). The Evolution of Urban Society and Social Changes in Sports
Participation at the Grassroots in China. University College Cork, Ireland. International
Review for the Sociology of Sport, volume 42 issue 4
Min-Chiang C. (2006). Communication Strategy of Sports Media in America from NBA.
Jinzhou, China: Journal of Bohai University (Philosophy and Social Science Edition),
volume 28 issue 1
Huang F. (2013). Glocalisation of Sport: The NBA's Diffusion in China. New York:
International Journal of the History of Sport, volume 30 issue 3
26. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
26
Hughson J. (2007). The Middle Class, Colonialism and the Making of Sport. London,
England: Sport in Society, volume 12 issue 1
Yang D. (2012). China's Emerging Middle Class: Beyond Economic Transformation.
University of Chicago, Illinois: Perspectives on Politics10.2
Green M. (2010). Policy Transfer and Learning from the West: Elite Basketball
Development in the People’s Republic of China. Loughborough University, Leicestershire,
UK: Journal of Sport & Social Issues, volume 34 issue 1
Bakers F., Cheong D., Guerra S., Miller H., and Marks L. (2011). Beyond Yao: The Future
of
Chinese Basketball. Knowledge of Wharton Marketing University of Pennsylvania,
Pennsylvania: Issue 1.
Towns K. (2007). The China Study South Australia Wakefield Press xviii, volume 15 issue 1
417 p. 23 cm.
Moreno, M. (2012). 99 reasons for China. Retrieved from
http://www.99reasonsforchina.com
Zhang, M. (2008). China and its Middle Class. Shanghai, China: Journal of Shanghai
University (Philosophy and Social Science Edition), volume 29 issue 2
Hessler F. (2013). Basketball finds a Way: The Uprising of a Newcomer. San Francisco:
International Journal of the History of Sport, volume 30 issue 3
27. RUNNING
HEAD-‐
THE
NBA
IN
CHINA:
HOW
TO
MAXIMIZE
INTERNATIONAL
PROFITS
27
Klung S. Z. (2006). Guangzhou and the History of Sport Guangzhou University, China
Volume 4 issue 1
Goldynn, P. R. (2013). Damns and Development in China. Los Angeles, Calif. United States
Mark Fruin W. (2010). Networks, Markets, and the Pacific Rim: Studies in Strategy: Studies
in
Strategy Keio University, Oxford, England. Volume 1 Issue 1. p. 198
Zemin J. (2010). Research on Energy Issues in China: First Edition. Peoples Republic
University of China, Beijing, China. Domestic and International energy situations
Volume 1 issue 1 p. 14.
Routledge J. J. (2014). Modern Sports in Asia [Book]. New York: International Journal of
the
History of Sport, volume 30 issue 1
Li G., Zhichao Y., Nan J., Shu X., Shuang M., Lu Z. (2012). Data You Need to Know about
China: Research Report of China Household Finance Survey [Book]. Southwestern
University of Finance and Economics, Chengdu, Sichuan province, China.