Samantha receives a call from her father informing her that her friend Connor has been found dead. When she tells Abbey the news, Abbey is shocked. They go to the police station where Sheriff Davis questions Samantha, Abbey, Nathan, Claire, and Billy about their whereabouts the previous night. Billy lies about where he was, claiming he was at Samantha's house even though she knows he left in the middle of the night. This raises suspicions about Billy from Samantha and Abbey.