Strategy and Options
for Preserving Indian
Heritage
Jit Kumar Gupta
EX- Director COA-IET Bhaddal,
Jit.kumar1944@gmail.com
Cities and their Context
Cities and their Context
• -Cities have been part of human history.
• - Cities- known to command power and authority
• Cities-have existed in past, continue to be relevant in
present and shall continue to dominate the future
• Cities known as --areas of concentration of population ,
infrastructures, buildings, institutions, trade and commerce
• Cities known as- incubators of innovations, industry,
technology, entrepreneurship and creativity.
• Cities- physical manifestation of history and culture
• Cities -- known as areas of concentration of art, culture
and architecture
• Cities known - as repositories of Heritage
• Cities grow in layers- each layer has distinct character,
culture, heritage
Cities and their Context
• Cities - materialization of humanity’s noblest ideas,
creation, ambitions and aspirations,
• Cities- product of political structure, social, economic,
religious fabric, technology and resources
• Cities- remain a manmade & mechanical habitat
• Cities- known to be anti-thesis to bio-diversity
• Cities- known to destroy natural habitat
• Cities – known to preserve/destroy Heritage-
• Each City --remains different / distinct- No two cities are
similar
• Cities – need to be planned differently , distinctly- to
preserve heritage, nature, bio-diversity, flora & fauna
• Cities–- preserving- value art, culture architecture, Heritage
– known to be vibrant, sustainable, livable, qualitative
IntoductionI
Defining Heritage
Heritage- context
• Heritage -reflects personality of a community/area
• Heritage- -gives -distinct Identity and Character,
Recognition, Makes Value addition and-- a Sense of Pride to
Community/Area/City, State & Nation
-- provides information about culture
-- way of life, art & architecture
- creates-- Vital link between past & present
- -- showcases past skill in planning of human
settlements; art, architecture, construction of Buildings,
way of life and infrastructures
--promotes development, employment ,economy,
-- removes poverty -- by promoting tourism, leisure, recreation
• -India-- 5000 years history, -- inherited enormous wealth of
natural &built environment.
• Heritage --needs conservation & preservation - carefully
and thoughtfully.

SDGs Target 11.4 -- “Strengthen efforts to protect/
safeguard world’s cultural and natural heritage”
Heritage- context- SDG 11.4
Heritage –Changing context

Heritage concept -- changed during last few decades.

Moved From monument centric to - vernacular
structures / historic urban areas/ cultural landscapes --
intangible aspects,

Separating past from present --to linking past/
present with local social/ environmental context.

From Protection to Conservation-.

-- pitting heritage conservation -- not against
development, but making part of development.

Considering challenges posed by -- rapid urbanization,
disasters / impacts of climate change--focusing on --
preparedness / protection for risks/disasters --
building resilience- using traditional knowledge .
Legal context of Heritage
• Considering importance/ need for preserving valuable heritage,
• through a well-defined legal framework;
• involving people, communities , states;
• Constitution of India made several important / valuable provisions
Article 29 of Constitution states:--
 - “Any section of citizens/communities
 --residing in territory of India or any part thereof,
 -- having a distinct language, script or culture of its own,
 -- shall have the right to conserve the same.”
Article 51 A (f) of Constitution mandates Citizens that:
 -“It shall be the duty of every citizen of India
 -to value and preserve the rich heritage of our composite culture; and
 - to protect and improve the natural environment including
 -forests, lakes, rivers and wild life, and
 - to have compassion for living creatures.”
 - It is essential for people of India to be
 - aware of the international conventions and
 -with the respective national & state laws,
 -significant to the security and protection and
 -conservation of the art and the cultural heritage of a nation
Legal context of Heritage
Article 49 -of Indian Constitution – lays obligation on State to;
-- protect every monument or place or object of artistic or historic
interests,
- declared by/under law made by Parliament to be of national importance,
- from spoliation, disfigurement, destruction, removal, disposal or export,
as the case may be
•The Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act
1958 provides for ;
•--- declaring , preserving ancient & historical monuments and
archaeological sites and remains of national importance,
•-- for regulation of archaeological excavations and
•-- for the protection of sculptures, carvings and other like objects.
•-- for constitution of National Monument Authority
•- Making recommendations-
•- for grading/ classifying protected monuments /protected areas- ---------
oversee working of competent authorities
•-- suggest measures for implementation of Act .
Legal context of Heritage
• 'THE PUNJAB ANCIENT AND HISTORICAL MONUMENTS
AND ARCHAEOLOGICAL SlTES AND REMAINS ACT, 1964.
• 'ancient and historical monument' means
• -any structure, erection or ,monument, or
• - any tumulus or place of internment, or
• any cave, rock- sculpture, inscription or monolith,
• which is of historical, ‘archaeological or artistic interest and
• --in existence for not less than one hundred years and includes-
• (i) the remains of an ancient and historical monument ;
• (ii) ‘ site of an ancient and historical monument ;
• (ii] such portion of land adjoining site of an ancient and historical monument
as may be required for fencing or covering in
• or otherwise protecting such monument ; and
• ... (iv) the means of access to, and convenient inspection of, an ancient and
historical monument ;
• - but does not include any ancient or historical monument declared by or
under law made by parliament to be of national importance ;
Conservation and Preservation
• Conservation and preservation two important approaches
used for protecting natural / cultural resources
• terms used interchangeably–
• - but have distinct meanings and different approaches.
• Conservation –management/ protection of natural
resources--wildlife / habitats- for maintaining their ecological
integrity & ensuring sustainability for future generations.
• Preservation - protection of cultural/ historical sites, to
maintain their authenticity and historical significance.
• Difference - approach taken toward protecting resources.
Conservation - proactive and aims to use resources in a
sustainable manner,
• Preservation -- reactive and aims to protect and maintain
existing resources.
Issues Facing Heritage
• Built heritage under enormous threat due to :
- lack of identification of heritage
--Misuse and abuse of existing heritage
- Lack of proper Legal Framework
- -According low priority to heritage
- neglecting/misuse of identified heritage
- Ever growing and rapid urbanization
-- haphazard & uncontrolled urban development.
-Unregulated subdivision of land/ buildings
- - Unchecked Change of land use
- - Heritage– kept outside planning process
-Limited use of technology in mapping/protecting heritage
- High vulnerability to disasters manmade/natural-
fire/earthquake- Sendai framework-Disaster Risk Reduction)
Issues Facing Heritage
--Rapid commercialization.
- Large scale speculation in land
-rapidly rising real estate prices.
- low capacity/resources at local level
- Limited availability of courses on Heritage
- Low availability of trained manpower
- Lack of recognition of importance of heritage
- Lack of Understanding at ULB level
-Lack of resources- financial& Technical
• -- Inadequate innovative strategies/ policies.
• -government Led Program and not community-led
• -- Multiplicity of agencies- lack of co-ordination
Issues Facing Heritatge
• UNESCO describes factors which pose
major problems to World Heritage .
• Armed conflict
• wars
• earthquakes &other natural
disasters,
• pollution,
• poaching,
• uncontrolled urbanization
•
.
Strategies- Redefining
OPTIONS--REDEFINING /MAPPING HERITAGE
• --Majority of heritage lost due to lack of identification
• -Indian legal framework links Heritage to time scale;100
years.
• - excludes large Heritage created during last 100 years
• -Heritage needs re-definition with detailed guidelines
• -- well defined process and machinery for identification
• --involving trained manpower
• -- Need Capacity building at national/state /local levels
• ---Indian heritage largely building specific
• -- Scope needs to be widened to include; natural resources
• -- From urban spaces, bazaars, complexes, cities.
• --Concept enlarged to include heritage zones
• -Modern heritage needs Recognition- Capitol of
Chandigarh
Strategies- making Heritage
part of urban planning process
Making Heritage Part of Planning process
Making Heritage Part of Planning process
• Heritage suffered from haphazard/ unplanned
development
• Lack of focus on conservation - in urban planning
• Effective heritage management requires – making Heritage
integral part of settlement planning.
• Regional Plans Master plans/ Development Plans to;
• -- identify heritage areas/zones/buildings in planning area
• - Identify areas of natural bio-diversity, flora/fauna
• -- prepare inventory of manmade/natural heritage, tangible,
intangible
• -- Carry out detailed study and analysis
• -- define strategies - to preserve, conserve/ promote/
manage heritage
• --frame dedicated schemes for heritage areas development
• -- Enlarge scope of Town Planning laws to provide for
Heritage conservation as priority area
• Regional /Master Plans- a dedicated a Chapter on Heritage
Making Heritage safe
Making Heritage Safe
• Disasters- both natural/ manmade
• -threaten integrity of Heritage
• -- compromise value of Heritage
• -- lead to loss/deterioration of outstanding properties
• - negatively impacts -- local / national communities, - dilute cultural
importance, socio-economic value.
• For promoting Safety—
• --Understanding typology/intensity of disaster risk
• -Strengthening disaster risk governance/build culture of
prevention
• --Investing in disaster risk preparedness/reduction for
resilience
• Enhancing disaster preparedness for effective response
• -- “Build Back Better” --in recovery, rehabilitation and
reconstruction-Using Traditional knowledge/ understanding
• -leveraging support within global, regional, national and local
institutions for disaster mitigation
Involving communities
Involving Communities
• Ignoring communities/ public participation-root-cause of
damage/ destruction of valuable heritage
• - Moving Heritage management from government led to
people centric-- key to success
• - People legitimate owners--community sees heritage as a
“good thing to have”- need active involvement
• Involving communities through -- Holding public meetings
• -- making people part of discussions
• --‘listening to’ and giving voice to people
• --Holding workshops/ Heritage Exhibitions/using print med
• -Organizing Heritage Marches/ competition/ asset mapping
• - bringing leaflets, maps / brochures, highlighting heritage
• --Involving local educational institutions/students in
heritage management
• -- training local inhabitants as tourist guides
Involving Communities
•
Involving Communities
•
involving academic/
professional institutions
Involving academic/ professional institutions
• - Heritage suffered -due to inadequate trained manpower
• --According low priority to heritage-- in institutions
imparting education in Architecture/ Planning /Engineering
• - Planners/ Architects /Engineers - role critical in heritage
• -- Only few institutions run specialised courses in heritage
• --Need to make heritage integral part of study in school/
colleges/technical institutions
• -Starting of undergraduate/Master level courses on heritage
preservation/management in IIT’s/SPA’s/NIT’s
• -- Involving institutions– ITPI/ IIA/ Institute of Engineers/
INTACH/ Voluntary agencies/NGOs/ civil society/pressure
groups-- for safeguarding/promoting heritage.
• -Sensitizing in-service /professionals-architects/ planners
/engineers/students -- by making heritage part of study
curricula/holding seminars / workshops/awareness
programs for professionals
INV0LVING EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS
Redefining Legal
Framework & Development
LEGAL FRAMEWORK & DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS :
• Existing legal framework related to planning, development
/ management of human settlements - done more harm
than good to heritage management.
• Town Planning laws to be reviewed and redefined on
priority to make them heritage friendly
• Master Plans/Regional Plans to focus on heritage
conservation
• Development schemes -- define agenda for heritage
conservation
• Considering critical role of development control, zoning/
regulations/ bye-laws -- in heritage conservation
• .-- -- Define controls sensitive to heritage
• -- based on study/ analysis
• Concept of Listed buildings -- included in legal framework
to identify/ preserve heritage
COLONIAL ARCHITECTURE
GATEWAY OF INDIA
HOTEL TAJ MUMBAI
Constituting Heritage
commissions/committees
CONSTITUTING HERITAGE COMMISSIONS/BOARDS/ COMMITTEES
• India --must constitute – network of Heritage focused
institutions-- at the state/local levels for
• - Identification/Mapping of Heritage- state/local level
• Heritage Institutions to – aid, advise, assist / guide state
government /local governments
• - Evolve policy framework-- for identification, notification,
preserving ,managing and financing heritage in state
• Heritage Identification- Adopting concept of listed
buildings.
• Recruiting heritage experts -- Planning development
authorities/agencies-- town planning
/architecture/PWD/Archeology departments
• -State archeology department – should be headed bya
trained professionals.
• - Implementing 74th
Constitutional Amendment Act
JAIN ARCHITECTURE
DILWARA TEMPLE
Creating a dedicated
Heritage Fund
Creating Heritage Fund
• Heritage management- a resource intensive activity.
• Heritage management Suffered- Non-availability of
dedicated resources
• Need for Generating resources for heritage by
• -- Creating dedicated fund at National/State / Local level.
• - involving Corporate Sector
• --Involving Artists / Professionals for raising funds
• --using Part of tourism earning
- Starting Heritage lotteries - levying Cess on tourists----
----earmarking fund-- in budgets of ULB,s/ Dev. Authority
– -- Promoting public –private partnership.
– involving industries -in maintenance
Making Heritage-- part of External Development Charges
– --making heritage conservation part of CSR activities
MADURAI TEMPLES
MEENAKSHI TEMPLE
16th
Century
Dedicated to Parvati
Capacity Building
Capacity Building
• Absence of Nodal Agency on heritage at states/local level
• Poor capacity of stakeholders- financial/technical
• Effective heritage management– needs creating
appropriate capacity at local, state /national for ;
• - identification/conservation of heritage
• -- Promoting Research and Development
• - Creating appropriate literature on heritage
• -- learning good practices,
• -- imparting hands on training,
• -- learning from case studies/ communication tools
• - engaging local stakeholders – owners of heritage
properties
• --Involving experts, educational institutions, craftsmen
• - Following Ahmedabad example
CAPACITY BUILDING
Role of Technology in Heritage
• Role of Technology in Heritage
• Technology transforming-
• -Identifying Heritage, Documentation, Conservation
• -Promoting Heritage
• -Mapping Heritage
• -Managing heritage
• -Planning /developing Heritage Area
• Understanding How people interact with history & heritage,
• providing insight into past.-- Unfolding Heritage
• Dissecting Heritage-
• Mapping inside of built environment/ natural environment
• deciphering ancient manuscripts with image processing
• 3D modelling of priceless artefacts,
• bringing people closer to past -Connecting people with heritage
• - widening horizons of millions.
• Digitization of documents- for preservation; accessibility with museums,
libraries/ ensuring - accessibility for generations
•
• .
Heritage City Development and
Augmentation Yojna- HRIDAY
Heritage City Development and Augmentation
Yojna- HRIDAY
•
•
HRIDAY strategized efforts like;
-- planning, development, implementation ,management of heritage
cities
-- in partnership with State Governments
-- to Preserve / revitalise-- soul of heritage city
-- to reflect city’s unique character-- by encouraging
-- aesthetic based, accessible, informative & secured environment.
-- undertaking strategic / planned development of heritage cities
--improving overall quality of life with specific focus
-- on sanitation, security, tourism, heritage revitalization / livelihood
-- retaining city’s cultural identity.
Duration of HRIDAY scheme --- 4 years starting January 21, 2015
Scheme focused on development of twelve heritage cities namely;
1. Ajmer 2. Amravati 3. Amritsar
4. Badami 5. Dwarka 6. Gaya
7. Kanchipuram 8. Mathura 9. Puri
10. Varanasi 11. Velankanni 12. Warangal
HRIDAY need to be continued-- extended to all cities
- making part of smart city /urban development /AMRUT
Using GIS Based Heritage Management
• A geographic information system (GIS) is a;
• - computer system - for capturing, storing, checking, and displaying data
• - related to positions on Earth’s surface.
• Creates detailed inventory of Cultural Heritage Sites
• Helps Evolving conservation strategies for management/ decision
making
Important tool for
• --documenting & Monitor conditions of Heritage Buildings/sites
• --Tracking changes over time
• - Prioritizing Conservation Efforts
• -- Developing Management Plans
• GIS technology
• -integrates spatial & attribute data of heritage sites, -
• -providing a powerful modern tool
• -for better understanding, preservation, management of heritage
resources.
• GIS applied in - promoting research / intervention,- heritage
COLONIAL ARCHITECTURE
VICTORIA HALL KOLKATA
SECRETARIAT- MODERN HERITAGE
Evolving Comprehensive
Conservation Heritage Strategy
Evolving Conservation Heritage Strategy
• Comprehensive Conservation Heritage Strategy should
stand on four distinct pillars of
• -- promoting Understanding of Heritage -- Ensuring Positive Action,
• -- Developing Partnerships -- Promoting Best Practices.
Conservation / Heritage Strategy must revolve around;
• -- Creating Effective/efficient/ heritage friendly legal framework for
identification/conservation of heritage
• --Making heritage people centric - involving communities
• --Promoting partnerships between different stakeholders
• -- Creating awareness / appreciation of value of heritage assets
• -- Making heritage management part of planning /development process
• -- Incentivising conservation /promoting / monitoring/reviewing
heritage sites on regular basis..
• -- Organising exhibitions/conferences /workshops at Heritage sites
• -- Synthesising historic resources with economic development
strategies.
• - Avoiding commercialization of heritage over conservation values.
Conclusion- Managing Heritage
Managing Heritage
 Mapping the entire available heritage at local level
 Making Heritage conservation - integral part of planning
and Development process- Regional Plans Master/
Development Plans/Zonal Plans/Local Area Plans.
 Making Heritage Conservation - integral part of legal
framework governing urban & rural planning, development
and management .
 Making Heritage conservation-- public-led
movement/mission involving communities /their resources.
 Allocating Dedicated funds in budget of institutions--
involved in urban/ruralplanning, development management
 Creating dedicated centers- for identifying, preserving,
promoting and safeguarding local heritage.
 Coming out-- with a state policy dedicated to heritage
management.
Managing Heritage
 Reviewing and Rationalising -- National policy of
monument preservation and conservation -to include all
typologies of heritage
 Starting dedicated courses in heritage conservation-- in all
professional institutions of higher learning for creating
adequately trained manpower
 Involving professional institutions – IIA, ITPI, Institute of
Engineers; Institute of Landscape Architects; Institute of
Urban Designers ,INTACH etc.
 Creating a dedicated cadre of heritage conservation and
preservation- in all major cities and towns
 Heritage- made part of public reflection, debate,
discussion
 Leveraging globalization-- for disseminating knowledge,
promoting understanding, collaboration-co-operation.
Managing Heritage
 Bringing heritage & sustainability on same platform-
Making heritage conservation-- integral part of
sustainable development
 Heritage conservation strategies- to include
cultural , historical, ecological and natural assets
 Undertaking conservation & preservation - carefully
and thoughtfully.
 “Strengthening efforts-- to protect/ safeguard world’s
cultural, natural heritage-- SDGs Target 11.4.
 Heritage concept -- not restricted to preservation but
also to include continuity of past into future.
.
 .
Managing Heritage
• .Promoting partnerships- public-private, non-
governmental sectors, - for achieving sustainability in
conservation.
 Promoting research– in heritage conservation,
preservation & management -- for safety/ security
• Actively involving all stakeholders-- in initiating &
Completion for sustaining heritage place
• Eliminating silos -Separating natural, cultural , historical
heritage -at local/state /national levels.
 Heritage conservation strategies to focus- on promoting
well-being of communities / ensuring human security in
heritage areas.
• Leveraging heritage – for creating employment, promoting
economy , removing poverty ; promoting local industry
Shahjahanabad
Shahjahanabad
Shahjahanabad
• Established by Mughal Emperor Shahjahan-383 years ago
• Built over 699 hectare for a population of 60,000
• House 783 Heritage structure including 229 historical
buildings and 325 Havelis
• Have a network of 10 major roads and 60 main streets and
15 big markets- having large daily footfalls
• Population 1961-4.2 lakh;1981- 4 lakh; 2017- 3.20lakh
• Commercial establishments[ 1961- 22,000;1981-1.55lakh&
2017- 1.53 lakh(10.53% operating from home))
• Walled city declared slum-under Slum Area Act
• 2008- Delhi Govt established SPV- Shahjahanabad
Development Corporation SDRC – for Preparing
conservation& Revitalization plan
• MPD 2041 - includes chapter for regeneration /
conservation of heritage Walled City.
Red Fort
Jama Masjid
Twarikhana
Evolving Conservation Heritage Strategy
• Conservation strategy of heritage must involve and revolve around
• --Leveraging heritage for creating opportunities, generating
employment , reducing poverty.
• --Building institutional capacity -in heritage planning/ management
• -- Promoting active re-use of heritage buildings --for larger public use /
making value addition to heritage- like museums, palaces etc
• -- Generating resources for maintenance & upkeep of heritage
• -Adopting best practice for- preservation , conservation and
management of heritage sites
• -- Promoting partnership-- public, private& voluntary organisations
• - Promoting actions / initiatives -- to ensure preservation /
enhancement of heritage assets by local communities
• --Fostering continued use/ enjoyment /access to diverse historic
assets
• - Ensuring contribution to quality of life, skill, knowledge, of --
present / future generations.
• --Developing short, medium / long term targets-- within available
resources
Evolving Conservation Heritage Strategy
• Framing a dedicated National Policy on Heritage Management in India
• Creating a dedicated fund for heritage management at local/ state and
national level.
• Creating a common platform for bringing all stakeholder on one board
and promoting co-ordinated approach for manging heritage
• Creating large reservoir/pool of trained manpower for heritage
identification/conservation.
• -- Improving communication with communities & stakeholders
• --Making heritage integral part of teaching- learning process
• -Making people believe that development and heritage are positively
co-related -- for promoting
• -- economy-- quality of life, -- removing poverty
• Promoting participative governance -- by empowered local
communities in the planning / implementation /promoting vigilance of
the heritage sites
• Creating local ownership among communities-- holding festivals etc
• Making rational choices between-- restoration, rehabilitation/
preservation for promoting valuable heritage.
Evolving Conservation Heritage Strategy
– Making - heritage protection not an impediment – but a pre-
condition for economic/sustainable development
• Developing culture of participative, Collaborative decision making
• – moving towards good-governance

- Help building urban identity / pride in residents.

-Going beyond just resorting / preserving
historical assets,

--leading to well-being / security, through broad
community participation and involvement.

-Using/leveraging Technologies in
identification/mapping/ evaluating/
preserving/managing heritage

--“Strengthening efforts to protect / safeguard
world’s cultural and natural heritage”
Evolving Conservation Heritage Strategy
• Making heritage part of planning and development process
• Shifting heritage conservation from –government- led
programme to community-led mission
• - creating dedicated cadre of experts in;
• -- all planning/development agencies- ULBs, UDA for
• -- identification of heritage.—-- aiding, advising, assisting&
guiding development agencies on heritage /conservation.
--integrating efforts of all stake-holders parastatal agencies,
individuals, institutions , NGOs/CBOs
• -- preparing comprehensive vocabulary of heritage
• --Making India -globally recognized resource/ repository of
• -- Heritage Management and preferred tourist destination
• -- with high degree of sensitivity / commitment to Indian
heritage- leveraging global good practices
.
Strategies for heritage conservationHeritage.ppt

Strategies for heritage conservationHeritage.ppt

  • 1.
    Strategy and Options forPreserving Indian Heritage Jit Kumar Gupta EX- Director COA-IET Bhaddal, Jit.kumar1944@gmail.com
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Cities and theirContext • -Cities have been part of human history. • - Cities- known to command power and authority • Cities-have existed in past, continue to be relevant in present and shall continue to dominate the future • Cities known as --areas of concentration of population , infrastructures, buildings, institutions, trade and commerce • Cities known as- incubators of innovations, industry, technology, entrepreneurship and creativity. • Cities- physical manifestation of history and culture • Cities -- known as areas of concentration of art, culture and architecture • Cities known - as repositories of Heritage • Cities grow in layers- each layer has distinct character, culture, heritage
  • 4.
    Cities and theirContext • Cities - materialization of humanity’s noblest ideas, creation, ambitions and aspirations, • Cities- product of political structure, social, economic, religious fabric, technology and resources • Cities- remain a manmade & mechanical habitat • Cities- known to be anti-thesis to bio-diversity • Cities- known to destroy natural habitat • Cities – known to preserve/destroy Heritage- • Each City --remains different / distinct- No two cities are similar • Cities – need to be planned differently , distinctly- to preserve heritage, nature, bio-diversity, flora & fauna • Cities–- preserving- value art, culture architecture, Heritage – known to be vibrant, sustainable, livable, qualitative
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
    Heritage- context • Heritage-reflects personality of a community/area • Heritage- -gives -distinct Identity and Character, Recognition, Makes Value addition and-- a Sense of Pride to Community/Area/City, State & Nation -- provides information about culture -- way of life, art & architecture - creates-- Vital link between past & present - -- showcases past skill in planning of human settlements; art, architecture, construction of Buildings, way of life and infrastructures --promotes development, employment ,economy, -- removes poverty -- by promoting tourism, leisure, recreation • -India-- 5000 years history, -- inherited enormous wealth of natural &built environment. • Heritage --needs conservation & preservation - carefully and thoughtfully.  SDGs Target 11.4 -- “Strengthen efforts to protect/ safeguard world’s cultural and natural heritage”
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Heritage –Changing context  Heritageconcept -- changed during last few decades.  Moved From monument centric to - vernacular structures / historic urban areas/ cultural landscapes -- intangible aspects,  Separating past from present --to linking past/ present with local social/ environmental context.  From Protection to Conservation-.  -- pitting heritage conservation -- not against development, but making part of development.  Considering challenges posed by -- rapid urbanization, disasters / impacts of climate change--focusing on -- preparedness / protection for risks/disasters -- building resilience- using traditional knowledge .
  • 10.
    Legal context ofHeritage • Considering importance/ need for preserving valuable heritage, • through a well-defined legal framework; • involving people, communities , states; • Constitution of India made several important / valuable provisions Article 29 of Constitution states:--  - “Any section of citizens/communities  --residing in territory of India or any part thereof,  -- having a distinct language, script or culture of its own,  -- shall have the right to conserve the same.” Article 51 A (f) of Constitution mandates Citizens that:  -“It shall be the duty of every citizen of India  -to value and preserve the rich heritage of our composite culture; and  - to protect and improve the natural environment including  -forests, lakes, rivers and wild life, and  - to have compassion for living creatures.”  - It is essential for people of India to be  - aware of the international conventions and  -with the respective national & state laws,  -significant to the security and protection and  -conservation of the art and the cultural heritage of a nation
  • 11.
    Legal context ofHeritage Article 49 -of Indian Constitution – lays obligation on State to; -- protect every monument or place or object of artistic or historic interests, - declared by/under law made by Parliament to be of national importance, - from spoliation, disfigurement, destruction, removal, disposal or export, as the case may be •The Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act 1958 provides for ; •--- declaring , preserving ancient & historical monuments and archaeological sites and remains of national importance, •-- for regulation of archaeological excavations and •-- for the protection of sculptures, carvings and other like objects. •-- for constitution of National Monument Authority •- Making recommendations- •- for grading/ classifying protected monuments /protected areas- --------- oversee working of competent authorities •-- suggest measures for implementation of Act .
  • 12.
    Legal context ofHeritage • 'THE PUNJAB ANCIENT AND HISTORICAL MONUMENTS AND ARCHAEOLOGICAL SlTES AND REMAINS ACT, 1964. • 'ancient and historical monument' means • -any structure, erection or ,monument, or • - any tumulus or place of internment, or • any cave, rock- sculpture, inscription or monolith, • which is of historical, ‘archaeological or artistic interest and • --in existence for not less than one hundred years and includes- • (i) the remains of an ancient and historical monument ; • (ii) ‘ site of an ancient and historical monument ; • (ii] such portion of land adjoining site of an ancient and historical monument as may be required for fencing or covering in • or otherwise protecting such monument ; and • ... (iv) the means of access to, and convenient inspection of, an ancient and historical monument ; • - but does not include any ancient or historical monument declared by or under law made by parliament to be of national importance ;
  • 14.
    Conservation and Preservation •Conservation and preservation two important approaches used for protecting natural / cultural resources • terms used interchangeably– • - but have distinct meanings and different approaches. • Conservation –management/ protection of natural resources--wildlife / habitats- for maintaining their ecological integrity & ensuring sustainability for future generations. • Preservation - protection of cultural/ historical sites, to maintain their authenticity and historical significance. • Difference - approach taken toward protecting resources. Conservation - proactive and aims to use resources in a sustainable manner, • Preservation -- reactive and aims to protect and maintain existing resources.
  • 15.
    Issues Facing Heritage •Built heritage under enormous threat due to : - lack of identification of heritage --Misuse and abuse of existing heritage - Lack of proper Legal Framework - -According low priority to heritage - neglecting/misuse of identified heritage - Ever growing and rapid urbanization -- haphazard & uncontrolled urban development. -Unregulated subdivision of land/ buildings - - Unchecked Change of land use - - Heritage– kept outside planning process -Limited use of technology in mapping/protecting heritage - High vulnerability to disasters manmade/natural- fire/earthquake- Sendai framework-Disaster Risk Reduction)
  • 16.
    Issues Facing Heritage --Rapidcommercialization. - Large scale speculation in land -rapidly rising real estate prices. - low capacity/resources at local level - Limited availability of courses on Heritage - Low availability of trained manpower - Lack of recognition of importance of heritage - Lack of Understanding at ULB level -Lack of resources- financial& Technical • -- Inadequate innovative strategies/ policies. • -government Led Program and not community-led • -- Multiplicity of agencies- lack of co-ordination
  • 17.
    Issues Facing Heritatge •UNESCO describes factors which pose major problems to World Heritage . • Armed conflict • wars • earthquakes &other natural disasters, • pollution, • poaching, • uncontrolled urbanization •
  • 18.
  • 19.
    OPTIONS--REDEFINING /MAPPING HERITAGE •--Majority of heritage lost due to lack of identification • -Indian legal framework links Heritage to time scale;100 years. • - excludes large Heritage created during last 100 years • -Heritage needs re-definition with detailed guidelines • -- well defined process and machinery for identification • --involving trained manpower • -- Need Capacity building at national/state /local levels • ---Indian heritage largely building specific • -- Scope needs to be widened to include; natural resources • -- From urban spaces, bazaars, complexes, cities. • --Concept enlarged to include heritage zones • -Modern heritage needs Recognition- Capitol of Chandigarh
  • 20.
    Strategies- making Heritage partof urban planning process
  • 21.
    Making Heritage Partof Planning process
  • 22.
    Making Heritage Partof Planning process • Heritage suffered from haphazard/ unplanned development • Lack of focus on conservation - in urban planning • Effective heritage management requires – making Heritage integral part of settlement planning. • Regional Plans Master plans/ Development Plans to; • -- identify heritage areas/zones/buildings in planning area • - Identify areas of natural bio-diversity, flora/fauna • -- prepare inventory of manmade/natural heritage, tangible, intangible • -- Carry out detailed study and analysis • -- define strategies - to preserve, conserve/ promote/ manage heritage • --frame dedicated schemes for heritage areas development • -- Enlarge scope of Town Planning laws to provide for Heritage conservation as priority area • Regional /Master Plans- a dedicated a Chapter on Heritage
  • 23.
  • 24.
    Making Heritage Safe •Disasters- both natural/ manmade • -threaten integrity of Heritage • -- compromise value of Heritage • -- lead to loss/deterioration of outstanding properties • - negatively impacts -- local / national communities, - dilute cultural importance, socio-economic value. • For promoting Safety— • --Understanding typology/intensity of disaster risk • -Strengthening disaster risk governance/build culture of prevention • --Investing in disaster risk preparedness/reduction for resilience • Enhancing disaster preparedness for effective response • -- “Build Back Better” --in recovery, rehabilitation and reconstruction-Using Traditional knowledge/ understanding • -leveraging support within global, regional, national and local institutions for disaster mitigation
  • 25.
  • 26.
    Involving Communities • Ignoringcommunities/ public participation-root-cause of damage/ destruction of valuable heritage • - Moving Heritage management from government led to people centric-- key to success • - People legitimate owners--community sees heritage as a “good thing to have”- need active involvement • Involving communities through -- Holding public meetings • -- making people part of discussions • --‘listening to’ and giving voice to people • --Holding workshops/ Heritage Exhibitions/using print med • -Organizing Heritage Marches/ competition/ asset mapping • - bringing leaflets, maps / brochures, highlighting heritage • --Involving local educational institutions/students in heritage management • -- training local inhabitants as tourist guides
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
    Involving academic/ professionalinstitutions • - Heritage suffered -due to inadequate trained manpower • --According low priority to heritage-- in institutions imparting education in Architecture/ Planning /Engineering • - Planners/ Architects /Engineers - role critical in heritage • -- Only few institutions run specialised courses in heritage • --Need to make heritage integral part of study in school/ colleges/technical institutions • -Starting of undergraduate/Master level courses on heritage preservation/management in IIT’s/SPA’s/NIT’s • -- Involving institutions– ITPI/ IIA/ Institute of Engineers/ INTACH/ Voluntary agencies/NGOs/ civil society/pressure groups-- for safeguarding/promoting heritage. • -Sensitizing in-service /professionals-architects/ planners /engineers/students -- by making heritage part of study curricula/holding seminars / workshops/awareness programs for professionals
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
    LEGAL FRAMEWORK &DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS : • Existing legal framework related to planning, development / management of human settlements - done more harm than good to heritage management. • Town Planning laws to be reviewed and redefined on priority to make them heritage friendly • Master Plans/Regional Plans to focus on heritage conservation • Development schemes -- define agenda for heritage conservation • Considering critical role of development control, zoning/ regulations/ bye-laws -- in heritage conservation • .-- -- Define controls sensitive to heritage • -- based on study/ analysis • Concept of Listed buildings -- included in legal framework to identify/ preserve heritage
  • 34.
    COLONIAL ARCHITECTURE GATEWAY OFINDIA HOTEL TAJ MUMBAI Constituting Heritage commissions/committees
  • 35.
    CONSTITUTING HERITAGE COMMISSIONS/BOARDS/COMMITTEES • India --must constitute – network of Heritage focused institutions-- at the state/local levels for • - Identification/Mapping of Heritage- state/local level • Heritage Institutions to – aid, advise, assist / guide state government /local governments • - Evolve policy framework-- for identification, notification, preserving ,managing and financing heritage in state • Heritage Identification- Adopting concept of listed buildings. • Recruiting heritage experts -- Planning development authorities/agencies-- town planning /architecture/PWD/Archeology departments • -State archeology department – should be headed bya trained professionals. • - Implementing 74th Constitutional Amendment Act
  • 36.
  • 37.
    Creating Heritage Fund •Heritage management- a resource intensive activity. • Heritage management Suffered- Non-availability of dedicated resources • Need for Generating resources for heritage by • -- Creating dedicated fund at National/State / Local level. • - involving Corporate Sector • --Involving Artists / Professionals for raising funds • --using Part of tourism earning - Starting Heritage lotteries - levying Cess on tourists---- ----earmarking fund-- in budgets of ULB,s/ Dev. Authority – -- Promoting public –private partnership. – involving industries -in maintenance Making Heritage-- part of External Development Charges – --making heritage conservation part of CSR activities
  • 38.
  • 39.
    Capacity Building • Absenceof Nodal Agency on heritage at states/local level • Poor capacity of stakeholders- financial/technical • Effective heritage management– needs creating appropriate capacity at local, state /national for ; • - identification/conservation of heritage • -- Promoting Research and Development • - Creating appropriate literature on heritage • -- learning good practices, • -- imparting hands on training, • -- learning from case studies/ communication tools • - engaging local stakeholders – owners of heritage properties • --Involving experts, educational institutions, craftsmen • - Following Ahmedabad example
  • 40.
  • 41.
    Role of Technologyin Heritage
  • 42.
    • Role ofTechnology in Heritage • Technology transforming- • -Identifying Heritage, Documentation, Conservation • -Promoting Heritage • -Mapping Heritage • -Managing heritage • -Planning /developing Heritage Area • Understanding How people interact with history & heritage, • providing insight into past.-- Unfolding Heritage • Dissecting Heritage- • Mapping inside of built environment/ natural environment • deciphering ancient manuscripts with image processing • 3D modelling of priceless artefacts, • bringing people closer to past -Connecting people with heritage • - widening horizons of millions. • Digitization of documents- for preservation; accessibility with museums, libraries/ ensuring - accessibility for generations • • .
  • 44.
    Heritage City Developmentand Augmentation Yojna- HRIDAY
  • 45.
    Heritage City Developmentand Augmentation Yojna- HRIDAY • • HRIDAY strategized efforts like; -- planning, development, implementation ,management of heritage cities -- in partnership with State Governments -- to Preserve / revitalise-- soul of heritage city -- to reflect city’s unique character-- by encouraging -- aesthetic based, accessible, informative & secured environment. -- undertaking strategic / planned development of heritage cities --improving overall quality of life with specific focus -- on sanitation, security, tourism, heritage revitalization / livelihood -- retaining city’s cultural identity. Duration of HRIDAY scheme --- 4 years starting January 21, 2015 Scheme focused on development of twelve heritage cities namely; 1. Ajmer 2. Amravati 3. Amritsar 4. Badami 5. Dwarka 6. Gaya 7. Kanchipuram 8. Mathura 9. Puri 10. Varanasi 11. Velankanni 12. Warangal HRIDAY need to be continued-- extended to all cities - making part of smart city /urban development /AMRUT
  • 46.
    Using GIS BasedHeritage Management • A geographic information system (GIS) is a; • - computer system - for capturing, storing, checking, and displaying data • - related to positions on Earth’s surface. • Creates detailed inventory of Cultural Heritage Sites • Helps Evolving conservation strategies for management/ decision making Important tool for • --documenting & Monitor conditions of Heritage Buildings/sites • --Tracking changes over time • - Prioritizing Conservation Efforts • -- Developing Management Plans • GIS technology • -integrates spatial & attribute data of heritage sites, - • -providing a powerful modern tool • -for better understanding, preservation, management of heritage resources. • GIS applied in - promoting research / intervention,- heritage
  • 47.
    COLONIAL ARCHITECTURE VICTORIA HALLKOLKATA SECRETARIAT- MODERN HERITAGE Evolving Comprehensive Conservation Heritage Strategy
  • 48.
    Evolving Conservation HeritageStrategy • Comprehensive Conservation Heritage Strategy should stand on four distinct pillars of • -- promoting Understanding of Heritage -- Ensuring Positive Action, • -- Developing Partnerships -- Promoting Best Practices. Conservation / Heritage Strategy must revolve around; • -- Creating Effective/efficient/ heritage friendly legal framework for identification/conservation of heritage • --Making heritage people centric - involving communities • --Promoting partnerships between different stakeholders • -- Creating awareness / appreciation of value of heritage assets • -- Making heritage management part of planning /development process • -- Incentivising conservation /promoting / monitoring/reviewing heritage sites on regular basis.. • -- Organising exhibitions/conferences /workshops at Heritage sites • -- Synthesising historic resources with economic development strategies. • - Avoiding commercialization of heritage over conservation values.
  • 49.
  • 50.
    Managing Heritage  Mappingthe entire available heritage at local level  Making Heritage conservation - integral part of planning and Development process- Regional Plans Master/ Development Plans/Zonal Plans/Local Area Plans.  Making Heritage Conservation - integral part of legal framework governing urban & rural planning, development and management .  Making Heritage conservation-- public-led movement/mission involving communities /their resources.  Allocating Dedicated funds in budget of institutions-- involved in urban/ruralplanning, development management  Creating dedicated centers- for identifying, preserving, promoting and safeguarding local heritage.  Coming out-- with a state policy dedicated to heritage management.
  • 51.
    Managing Heritage  Reviewingand Rationalising -- National policy of monument preservation and conservation -to include all typologies of heritage  Starting dedicated courses in heritage conservation-- in all professional institutions of higher learning for creating adequately trained manpower  Involving professional institutions – IIA, ITPI, Institute of Engineers; Institute of Landscape Architects; Institute of Urban Designers ,INTACH etc.  Creating a dedicated cadre of heritage conservation and preservation- in all major cities and towns  Heritage- made part of public reflection, debate, discussion  Leveraging globalization-- for disseminating knowledge, promoting understanding, collaboration-co-operation.
  • 52.
    Managing Heritage  Bringingheritage & sustainability on same platform- Making heritage conservation-- integral part of sustainable development  Heritage conservation strategies- to include cultural , historical, ecological and natural assets  Undertaking conservation & preservation - carefully and thoughtfully.  “Strengthening efforts-- to protect/ safeguard world’s cultural, natural heritage-- SDGs Target 11.4.  Heritage concept -- not restricted to preservation but also to include continuity of past into future. .  .
  • 53.
    Managing Heritage • .Promotingpartnerships- public-private, non- governmental sectors, - for achieving sustainability in conservation.  Promoting research– in heritage conservation, preservation & management -- for safety/ security • Actively involving all stakeholders-- in initiating & Completion for sustaining heritage place • Eliminating silos -Separating natural, cultural , historical heritage -at local/state /national levels.  Heritage conservation strategies to focus- on promoting well-being of communities / ensuring human security in heritage areas. • Leveraging heritage – for creating employment, promoting economy , removing poverty ; promoting local industry
  • 55.
  • 56.
  • 57.
    Shahjahanabad • Established byMughal Emperor Shahjahan-383 years ago • Built over 699 hectare for a population of 60,000 • House 783 Heritage structure including 229 historical buildings and 325 Havelis • Have a network of 10 major roads and 60 main streets and 15 big markets- having large daily footfalls • Population 1961-4.2 lakh;1981- 4 lakh; 2017- 3.20lakh • Commercial establishments[ 1961- 22,000;1981-1.55lakh& 2017- 1.53 lakh(10.53% operating from home)) • Walled city declared slum-under Slum Area Act • 2008- Delhi Govt established SPV- Shahjahanabad Development Corporation SDRC – for Preparing conservation& Revitalization plan • MPD 2041 - includes chapter for regeneration / conservation of heritage Walled City.
  • 59.
  • 60.
  • 63.
  • 66.
    Evolving Conservation HeritageStrategy • Conservation strategy of heritage must involve and revolve around • --Leveraging heritage for creating opportunities, generating employment , reducing poverty. • --Building institutional capacity -in heritage planning/ management • -- Promoting active re-use of heritage buildings --for larger public use / making value addition to heritage- like museums, palaces etc • -- Generating resources for maintenance & upkeep of heritage • -Adopting best practice for- preservation , conservation and management of heritage sites • -- Promoting partnership-- public, private& voluntary organisations • - Promoting actions / initiatives -- to ensure preservation / enhancement of heritage assets by local communities • --Fostering continued use/ enjoyment /access to diverse historic assets • - Ensuring contribution to quality of life, skill, knowledge, of -- present / future generations. • --Developing short, medium / long term targets-- within available resources
  • 67.
    Evolving Conservation HeritageStrategy • Framing a dedicated National Policy on Heritage Management in India • Creating a dedicated fund for heritage management at local/ state and national level. • Creating a common platform for bringing all stakeholder on one board and promoting co-ordinated approach for manging heritage • Creating large reservoir/pool of trained manpower for heritage identification/conservation. • -- Improving communication with communities & stakeholders • --Making heritage integral part of teaching- learning process • -Making people believe that development and heritage are positively co-related -- for promoting • -- economy-- quality of life, -- removing poverty • Promoting participative governance -- by empowered local communities in the planning / implementation /promoting vigilance of the heritage sites • Creating local ownership among communities-- holding festivals etc • Making rational choices between-- restoration, rehabilitation/ preservation for promoting valuable heritage.
  • 68.
    Evolving Conservation HeritageStrategy – Making - heritage protection not an impediment – but a pre- condition for economic/sustainable development • Developing culture of participative, Collaborative decision making • – moving towards good-governance  - Help building urban identity / pride in residents.  -Going beyond just resorting / preserving historical assets,  --leading to well-being / security, through broad community participation and involvement.  -Using/leveraging Technologies in identification/mapping/ evaluating/ preserving/managing heritage  --“Strengthening efforts to protect / safeguard world’s cultural and natural heritage”
  • 69.
    Evolving Conservation HeritageStrategy • Making heritage part of planning and development process • Shifting heritage conservation from –government- led programme to community-led mission • - creating dedicated cadre of experts in; • -- all planning/development agencies- ULBs, UDA for • -- identification of heritage.—-- aiding, advising, assisting& guiding development agencies on heritage /conservation. --integrating efforts of all stake-holders parastatal agencies, individuals, institutions , NGOs/CBOs • -- preparing comprehensive vocabulary of heritage • --Making India -globally recognized resource/ repository of • -- Heritage Management and preferred tourist destination • -- with high degree of sensitivity / commitment to Indian heritage- leveraging global good practices .