(
e
3 3
A3BD
p m q
1
h o
3
7
n
Francis Bacon
George Berkeley
Thomas Hobbes John Locke
David Hume
Michael PolanyiMerleau-PontyHeideggerHusserl
n
n
Quine PutnamDavidson Rorty
Lacan
Levi-Strauss
Deleuze
Foucault
Derrida
Wittgenstein
Wittgenstein
Austin
Ryle
n
Sartre
Kierkegaard
Nietzsche
n
WittgensteinTuring
Church
Peirce
Boole
Saussure
i n
Spinoza
Pascal
Descartes
Leibniz
G
Cusanus
n
Kant Hegel Schopenhauer
Pyrrho
I
Pythagoras of Samos
Zeno of
Elea
Democritus
Zeno of Citium
Socrates
Plato
Aristotle
Thales of
Miletus Heraclitus
Diogenes
Epicurus
n
Frege
Russell
Hilbert
Whitehead
Machiavelli
Copernicus
a
Jesus of Nazareth
William of Ockham
t
Thomas Aquinas
Augustine of Hippo
C8
hq
” h
f
” h h
t
6T P[PW]TLU 7WRTWP
UUP[
5SL[UP 4LMMLRP
5aMP[WP]TN
,
SW N5L[]Sa
p q
,
)&&
-
p q
,-
n 6 ]P[]o 4 nCSP[TOLWo
c T YaP[aPOLaPV VT UaT Y [aPO ] V [aPNST dtcGP
][LW VT] ]S RS] Ma VPLW YPPNS d
D Wa @P]]TWRP[ TW ]SP
N []aL[O 5UL[P 5 UUPRP
5LVM[TORP
ʻ à
PL] à
LYYUP à
(&&&
,-
,
4L[ TUUPU @P]]TWRP[
,& ,)
“ ”
He	saw	a	woman	in	the	garden	with	a	telescope.
or
or
The	spirit	is	willing,	but	the	flesh	is	weak.
The	vodka	is	good,	but	the	meat	is	rotten.
,,
ALPAC
1956
Logical	Theorist
19561955 thinking	machine
Newell Simon
1957
General	Problem	Solver	(GPS)
Cliff	Shaw,	1960
52 38
S
D A
C
H
F
G
I E B
EE I B
D B D H D I J
A H J F I D
S
E
B
D
A
I
C
F
H
J G
S
E
B
D
A
I
C
F
H
J G
S
D A
C
H
F
G
I E B
EE I B
D B D H D I J
A H J F I D
…
10120 10220 10360
1080
•
•
•
9AC y
”y
1967
26
…
…
26
“ ”
p9AC” q
t n o y
p ” ” n o q
→
Ulric	Selfridge
@UT P[ PT P[
ALWOPV WT V
Bernard Gold
AL]]P[W BPN RWT]T W Ma LNSTWP
,&
Uhr and Vossler
Computers	and	Thought
1974
p ” q
p
q
t ”
p y iq
l ,. p qt
p q
s
l g 2 ,.
l
p q
t
t
“ ”
u
“ ”
(
“ ”
(
”
”
“ ”
(
“ ”
)
p LVTUa [P PVMULWNP q nNUL VPVMP[ STYo
p q
e e
( p q
)
p
q
“ ”
p q
“ ”
t
(
)
”
Simon
Heuristic	Problem	Solving:	
Next	Advance	of	Operation	
Research
In	from	three	to	eight	years	
we	will	have	a	machine	with	
the	general	intelligence	of	
an	average	human	being.
Marvin	Minsky	in	Life	
Magazine,	1970.
R.I.P.	Hubert	Dreyfus	(1929 -2017.4.22.)
1972 1979 1992
26
Herbert	Simon	and	
Allen	Newell	playing	
chess	in	1958
Minsky	at	MIT
y
26
26
p AT g e e
y
hqn ”e
y e
e ho
“ ”
26
“ ”
p q p q
p qp q
p l q p q
p q p q
p iq
p iqh
”
CDE67 D ,-
7 I3 ,
p q ”
h
”
CDE67 D ,-
7 I3 ,
CDE67 D ,-
“
( ʻ
)
”
”
CDE67 D ,-
“
ʻ ”
CDE67 D ,-
( ʻ
tpm ]TVP q pm qpm
PZ LU q
CDE67 D ,-
)
pm ]TVP qtpm q
CDE67 D ,-
”
ʻ
CDE67 D ,-
x ”
t
26
“ ”
7A3 Ma ”
e
y r
7F3 Cb 3 3 @9H AB@9B3
3 4
5 6u 6v 6
3 4 5
6 6( 6)
7F3 Cb 3 3 @9H AB@9B3
3 4
5 6u 6v 6
3 4 5
6 6( 6)
7F3 Cb 3 3 @9H AB@9B3
3 4
5 6u 6v 6
3 4 5
6 6( 6)
Rudolph Arnheim
C B6 E
MYCIN
DENDRAL
RI
AIMATHLAB
LISP
PROLOG
AI
•
•
• Hofstadter )
GPS
(LFGNS)
AI
• N5L[]Sa ,
• n [L PN .. o
• &
RI
2012
Deep	Learning
1950 20101960 2000199019801970
ENIAC	‘Giant	
Brain’
AI AI
PC
8
NNXOR
AI
EM PAC SVM Lasso
NN !
6T ]4PUTP 9 RUP 5L]
VLRP P] 5 3UP P]
D[ W] TN[ ] 9 RUP 4
9 RUP P [LU D[LW UL] [
6 5 6T P[PW]TLMUP P [LU 5 VY ]P[
5rJ& 5brJ&
• r p ir t ) (
) )( n e r i
• C B ( n e s
l o
• m k
• l
• P
• b B
• h ac
n A
m
NN
a
n
a
i

楽観論と打ち砕かれた夢 ~哀れな人工知能研究者たち~