SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1
Small enterprise owners/managers attitude towards the
Application of major elements of Accounting
System (a case study in Debre Markos town)
A Senior essay submitted for the partial Fulfillment of bachelors of arts degree in Accounting
and Finance
BY; SIMENEH ALMAW
Advisor; ABATE GASHAW (MSC)
Debre Markos University
College of business and economics
Department of Accounting and finance
June 2007
Debre Markos, Ethiopia
2
Table of Contents
DECLARATION OF ORGINALITY ………………………………………………………………………………………………..I
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………..II
LIST OF TABLE …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..III
LISTOF ACRONYMS …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..IV
ABSTRACT …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………V
CHAPTER _ ON INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................... 9
1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY..................................................................................... 9
1.2 Statement of the problem.................................................................................................... 11
1.3 Objective of the study......................................................................................................... 12
1.3.1 General objective ......................................................................................................... 12
1.3.2 Specific objective......................................................................................................... 12
1.4 Scope of the study............................................................................................................... 12
1.5 Limitations of the study ...................................................................................................... 12
1.6 Significance of the study..................................................................................................... 12
CHAPTER_ TWO REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE..................................................... 14
2.1 INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................. 14
2.2 NEEDS FOR ACCOUNTING ........................................................................................... 15
2.3 ACCOUNTING SYSTEM ................................................................................................. 15
2 .4 BUSINESS EVENTS (ACCOUNTING TRANSACTIONS)........................................... 15
2.5 ACCOUNTING CYCLE.................................................................................................... 15
2.6 SYSTEM OF BOOKKEEPING ......................................................................................... 16
2.6.1 Double entry bookkeeping ........................................................................................... 16
2.6.2 Single entry bookkeeping............................................................................................. 17
2.7 INVENTORY SYSTEM .................................................................................................... 17
2.7.1 Perpetual inventory system.......................................................................................... 17
2.7.2 Periodic inventory system............................................................................................ 17
2.7.3 INVENTORY VALUATION METHOD........................................................................ 18
2.8 ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS AND CONTROLS FOR SMALL ENTERPRISES............. 18
2.8.1 INTERNAL CONTROL SYSTEM................................................................................. 18
2.8.1.1 Internal control concepts and issues ......................................................................... 19
2.9 PRIOR STUDY ON SMALL ENTERPEISES .................................................................. 19
CHAPTER THREE RESEARCH METHODS ........................................................................... 21
3.1 RESEARCH DESIGN........................................................................................................ 21
3
3.2 PARTICIPANT OF THE STUD Y .................................................................................... 21
3.3 SAMPLING TECHNIQUES.............................................................................................. 21
3.4 SAMPLE SIZE ................................................................................................................... 21
3.5 DATA TYPE AND SOURCE............................................................................................ 22
3.6 DATA COLLECTION TECHNIQUES ............................................................................. 22
3.7 DATA PROCESSING, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION...................................... 22
CHAPTER_ FOUR DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION....................................... 23
CHAPTER- FIVE......................................................................................................................... 29
SUMMARE, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONs.................................................... 29
Summary of the findings........................................................................................................... 29
CONCLUSIONs ....................................................................................................................... 29
RECOMMENDATIONs........................................................................................................... 31
REFERANCES............................................................................................................................. 32
APPENDIX................................................................................................................................... 34
4
DECLARATION OF ORIGINALITY
I the undersigned , SIMENEH ALMAW, confirm that the senior essay entitled ”SMALL
ENTERPRISE MANAGER’S ATTITUDE TOWARDS THE APPLICATION OF MAJOR
ELEMENT OF ACCOUNTING SYSTEM( a case study in Debre Markos town)” is my original
work and is being submitted in partial fulfillment of BA degree in accounting and Finance in
Debre Markos university. This study have not been submitted for any degree or diploma program
in this or other institutions and that all source of materials used for the paper have been duly
acknowledged.
Declared by
Name: SIMENEH ALMAW
Signature: ___________________
Date: _______________________
Place: Debre Markos, Ethiopia
Advisor: ABATE GASHAW (MSC)
Signature: _______________________
Date: --------------------------------------
I
5
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
It is the grace, mercy, charity, forgiveness, help and kindness of the almighty of god that made
me alive, achieve this success and strength. Next to this I would like to thank all my teachers
who fill my mind by accounting knowledge.
While there are several people ,who have helped me in one or another way to achieve the
completion of this paper, it would have not been without the guidance, support and expertise of
my advisor ABATE GASHAW( Msc). I would like to begin by thanking ABATE GASHAW for
his constructive comments and outstanding help with this paper and for making me to use the
potential that i have with confidence on my ability.
IN addition, I am thankful to all my family and friends for their moral and financial support.
Especially, I would like to thanks my brother BAMLAKU and my friends YIHUN
ESUBALEW, BAMLAKU ASEMARE AND MELSEW ABEBE.
I would also like to extend my thanks to Debre Markos town small enterprise managers or
owners for their cooperation for filling the questionnaires.
Finally yet importantly, I would also want to extend my appreciation to everyone who supported
me at the preparation of this study.
II
6
LIST OF TABLE
Table 1- Respondent’s background
Table 2- Preparation of financial statements
Table 3- Reasons for not preparing financial statement
Table 4- Attitude of owners/managers towards internal control
Table 5- Business transaction and its accounting treatment
Table 6- attitudes towards system of recording business transaction
Table 7-Attitude towards inventory system
Table 8 – Attitude towards accounting system
Table 9- owners/managers filling by not applying accounting system
III
7
LIST OF ACRONYMS
SEs small enterprises
SEos small enterprise owners
ETB Ethiopian birr
DMT Debre Markos town
MSEs micro and small enterprises
VI
8
ABSTRACT
Small scale enterprises play a vital role in the economic development of any country. In
Ethiopia, most small scale enterprise owners/managers handle their business traditionally. This
study aimed at investigating the attitude of small enterprise owners/managers towards the
application of major elements of accounting system in Debre Markos. The population of the
study consists of ‘82’small enterprise owners/managers. ‘46’ respondents were selected through
a stratified simple random sampling techniques. Structured questionnaire (both open ended and
close ended) was employed in the course of gathering relevant data for the study. Data were
analyzed by using percentage and frequency. The result indicates that most small enterprise
owners/managers have a positive tendency towards internal control and inventory system.
Moreover, it shows that a significant number of small enterprise owners/managers have a
tendency towards single entry system of bookkeeping and most of them do not prepare financial
statements for their enterprise. The study therefore concludes that small enterprise
owners/managers have a positive attitude to apply elements of accounting system when different
constraints solved and they were highly willing to learn more about how to keep accurate records
of their business transactions. Following this the study recommended that, the ministry
responsible for SEs development should initiate, in a more strengthen way, record keeping
training program for entrepreneurs running small business and bookkeeping in SEs should be
made mandatory to change their tendency in to practice and to make them beneficiary. Finally it
is recommended that Debre Markos University, specially accounting and finance department like
that of law school, should establish a free community service in bookkeeping institute to
facilitate small enterprise owners to apply accounting system in their enterprise.
VII
9
CHAPTER _ ON INTRODUCTION
1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY
The contribution of small enterprises (SEs) to the economic development of most developing
countries is overwhelming. Providing employment opportunity for the country’s working
population, contribution to the government revenue generation through the payment of income
tax, As well as providing income in terms of profit and wage to households, has been the
ultimate hallmark of SE’s to a developing country, of which Ethiopia is no exception.
Small enterprises are an important ingredient for stable and equitable growth in any national
economy. Ethiopia takes the development and expansion of SEs as the main way to solve many
of the social problems. Yet despite, specific global efforts to strengthen the SE sector these
business face a number of problems, particularly in developing countries. In Ethiopia, one of the
main problems of ESs may be their accounting practices and access to finance (TAFA, 2011).
Studies show that it is hard for the small enterprises to access finance from the financial
institutions, since they lack proper financial record as requirement (GIBRET, 2013). Providers of
finance and other interesting parties often rely on information before making the formal decision
either to invest or not to invest in a given business. An adequate Accounting system will generate
the needed information for whatever purpose. It is recommend by many researchers that SEs
keep detail accounting records and Audits their financial statements on annual basis.
For most developing countries achieving low unemployment, improving income level and
reducing poverty which eventually lead to economic success largely depends on whether SE's are
doing well or not. As GIBERT says, for the SEs also to do well there is the need for them to
attract and secure finance. Providers of finance will not invest or provide funds unless they are
assure that they will not lose their investment. Most providers of finance assure themselves with
accounting information generated from an adequate accounting system in order to reduce risk.
Unfortunately because owners manage SEs in Ethiopia, they sometimes believe, they have less
need for financial accounting information because of their personal involvement in the day-to-
day operation.
An accounting system consists of the personnel, procedures, technologies and records used by an
organization to develop accounting information and to communicate this information to decision
makers. Therefore, the basic purpose of accounting system is to meet the organization’s need for
information as efficiently as possible (Williams et al, 2006).
Accounting information is used by every profit seeking business organizations that uses
economic resources and by nonprofit seeking organizations. The accounting system used by
profit seeking organization may viewed as an information system designed to provide relevant
financial information on the resource of business and the effect of the use of these resources
(Fess warren, 1984).
There are five basic elements of an accounting system; These are source documents, input
devices, information processors, information storage and output devices (Adams University
College, 2014). Source documents provide basic information to process by the accounting
10
system. Input devices captures information from source document and enables its accounting
system. Transfer to the information-processing component. Information processing is a system
that interprets transfers and summarizes information for use in analysis and reporting. Output
devices are the mean to take information out of an accounting system and to make it available to
users. Generally, for this study purpose, the above elements viewed as an accounting cycle. This
study was also focuses on other different major element of accounting system those are internal
control and inventory system.
Accounting cycle is a complete sequence of accounting procedures, used to record, classify and
summarize accounting information in financial reports, that is repeated in the same order during
each accounting period( WILLIAMS et al,2006).it includes
● Journalizing transaction
● posting to ledger accounts
● preparing trial balance
● making end of period adjustment
● preparing an adjusted trial balance
● preparing financial statements
● journalizing and posting closing entries and
● preparing an after closing trial balance
Management needs assurance that accounting information it receives to be accurate and reliable.
This accuracy comes from the company’s system of internal control. This study was also focused
on general control activities.
Inventors are asset items held for sell in the ordinary course of business or are goods that will be
used or consumed in the production of goods to be sold. The description and measure of
inventory required careful intention because the investment in inventory is frequently the largest
current asset of merchandise and manufacturing business (DONALD KIESO, 1998). Thus in this
study the researcher tried to understand and describe the attitude of small enterprise managers
towards the application of those major elements of Accounting system.
11
1.2 Statement of the problem
Today it is impossible to manage business operation without accurate and up-to-date accounting
information. managers and employees, lenders, suppliers and government agencies are rely on
the information contained in two financial statement each not more than one page in length.
According to JILL HUSSY and ROGER HUSSY (1999), cost and management accounting, all
efficiently managed organization needs to keep some form of accounting system. For big
organization like limited companies there are legal requirement that must be adhered. For small
enterprises, it is important to keep some form of accounting records for taxation and decision
making purpose.
Previous researches has indicate that small firms are a group of business driven by the attitude
and motivation of one person, tends to control all functional areas of the business and accord less
time to the accounting and finance function. This is often viewed as unimportant and thus
received less attention on the part of the owners (as cited in k padachi, 2012:2).
The researcher’s personal observation also witnessed that most of small enterprise managers
handle their business traditionally. They do not have any knowledge of accounting/ modern
business. All large or small business have to establish accounting system in order to produce
financial statements so as to give precise information for personal/ groups in business to satisfy
external parties. In addition to this, accounting system provides information to understand better,
how business has get profit and help to management or organization to plan for future of the
business. To the best of the researcher’s knowledge, no specific researches have undertaken to
investigate small enterprise manager’s attitude towards the application of accounting system.
Hence, in this study the researcher tried to answer the following research questions.
What is the attitude of small business managers towards business event and the accounting
treatment?
Does the enterprise managers prepare crucial financial statements periodically?
What is the attitude of those enterprise managers towards internal control system?
What is the attitude of those enterprise managers towards inventory system?
What is the attitude of small enterprise managers towards Double entry bookkeeping system?
Why managers apply major elements of accounting system?
12
1.3 Objective of the study
1.3.1 General objective
The general objective of this study was to evaluate the attitude of small enterprise managers
towards the application of major element of accounting system.
1.3.2 Specific objective
★To assess the attitude of small enterprise managers towards business events and its accounting
treatment.
★To find out whether the enterprise owners/managers prepare crucial financial statement.
★To assess the attitude of enterprise owners/managers towards establishing internal control
system.
★To assess the tendency of small enterprise owners/ managers towards inventory system.
★To assess the attitude of small enterprise owners/managers towards Double entry
bookkeeping.
★To identify reasons which hinder owners/managers from applying accounting system.
1.4 Scope of the study
This study was very important, if it would conducted over the country wide, but because of the
restriction of time and finance, it was intended to conduct in Debre Markos town. Moreover, this
study focused on small enterprises; with employees 6-30, and which has a paid up capital for,
industrial sector from ETB 100,001 up to ETB 1.5million, and for services sector from ETB
50,001 up to ETB 500,000(ZEMENU et al, 2014) excluding high technological consultancy
services and other higher technological establishments.
1.5 Limitations of the study
The researcher was face the following limitations
●The time provided for the study was not enough for the researcher to collect all necessary
information
●The financial means for the study was insufficient to conduct the study as the price of
everything in the market increased.
●The respondents had heavy work and did not provide the information on time.
●Some of the respondents did not understand the objective of the study and think otherwise.
 It was very difficult to get the particular location of small enterprise.
1.6 Significance of the study
13
This study has expected to use for the following significance.
It provides important information in accounting system as having knowledge of Accounting
system in running business is most important solution for the growth of Business.
It gives important information on the important accounting system for the profitability of
enterprises.
It would identify the reasons that hinder small enterprise managers from applying accounting
system.
It would indicate to the government, the intention of small enterprises managers towards
growth.
It might help other researchers who want to conduct a research on similar topics or area.
1.7 organization of the paper
This study has organized into five chapters, which consist of different categories. The first
chapter includes background, statement of the problem, objective of the study, scope of the
study, limitation of the study and significance of the study. The second chapter deals with review
of related literature. The third chapter is about research methods. The fourth chapter presents the
collected data analysis and the last chapter is about the conclusion and recommendation of the
study.
14
CHAPTER_ TWO REVIEW OF RELATED
LITERATURE
2.1 INTRODUCTION
Small enterprises (SEs) defined in a variety of ways using various factors. Although many
countries around the globe seem to use common factors in their definition the degree of emphasis
and measures used differ quite considerably. These factors include number of employees,
volume of sales and the capital value of the business. In recent times, there has been some degree
of convergence in SEs definitions particularly in Europe.
The European commission defines SEs using a combination of employee numbers, annual
turnovers or balance sheet total and ownership. However, the above convergence does not
suggest in any way a common agreement of the specific numbers in terms of these variables.
To this end, different governments and writers in small enterprise definition differ considerably.
This difference influenced largely by two factors. These are population and stage of a countries
economic development and industry within which the SEs is competing (ZEMENU et al, 2014).
The definition of small enterprises in the developed world would differ from how SEs is defined
in the third world. For example, the accepted definition of small enterprise in USA is “an entity
with average annual gross revenue for the preceding three years not to exceed $15 million. The
Ethiopian government defines SEs based on the size of the capital and level of automation
(MSEs Strategy, 2004). Accordingly small enterprises are those business enterprises with paid up
capital of above ETB 20,000 and not exceeding ETB 50,000.
In the improved definition of MSEs, Ethiopian ministry of trade and industry and central
statistical authority(CSA) defines SEs according to the number of employees and capital as
follows( ZEMENU et al, 2014):industry sector with employees 6-30, and capital of ETB
100,001_ETB 1.5 million and service sector with employees 6-30 and capital of ETB 50,001
_ETB 500,000.
The government of Ethiopia has recognized the importance of micro and small enterprises
development to the overall economic growth of country and poverty alleviation. It has
established micro and small enterprise development agency to coordinate and support this
sectors. According to proclamation number, 33/1998, the agency shall be involved in designing
policies and strategies for the development and expansion of micro and small-scale enterprises.
To this end many developing economy have developed and have been providing credit to poor
and small business through micro finance schemes. In Ethiopia, several institutions have
established and have been operating towards resolving credit access problem of poor particularly
those participate in small business activities. Since small enterprises has great role to the
economy of a given country, it matter to economy whether they work well or not. However,
without support of micro finance institutions small business may not well by them self due to
15
capital constraint. If a given small enterprise works well in addition to help of micro finance, it
also assumed that accounting system of the business to be well, which is the subject area of this
study.
2.2 NEEDS FOR ACCOUNTING
In a business organization, innumerable monetary transactions take place. Accounting keeps a
systematic record of such transactions and summarizes them through entries in various accounts.
A clear picture of functions of the business emerges from Accounting and it reveals what the
business owns, owes, profit and loss (NADHANI, 2000).
2.3 ACCOUNTING SYSTEM
The unabridged version of the random house dictionary provides more than a dozen of definition
for the term ‘system’. Paraphrasing and merging several of those definitions, a system is a
coordinated network of plans and procedures designed to achieve a stated goal in an orderly
effective and efficient manner. Not surprisingly, this definition applies very well to the typical
accounting system. From this accounting system is a systematic approach to collecting,
processing and communicating financial information to decision makers. This consists of the
methods and records established to identify, assemble, analyze, classify, record and report on an
entity’s transaction and to maintain accountability for the related assets and liabilities. Note that,
the later part of this definition indicates that an accounting system has ‘accountability ‘or control
feature (KNAPP, 1996).
2 .4 BUSINESS EVENTS (ACCOUNTING TRANSACTIONS)
An Accounting (business) event is an economic occurrence that changes an enterprises assets,
liabilities or stockholders (owners) equity. A transaction is a particular kind of events that
involves transferring something of value between two entities
(EDMONDS/OLDS/NCMIR/TSAY, 2010). These can classify into three. These are;
1, Asset source transaction; a transaction that increase the total amount of assets and increase the
total amount of claims.
2, Asset exchange transaction; a transaction that decreases one asset and increases another assets.
The total amount of asset is unchanged.
3, Asset use transactions; a transaction that decreases the total amount of asset and claims.
2.5 ACCOUNTING CYCLE
In a well-designed accounting system, all accounting processes have undertaken in a form of a
cycle, known as the accounting cycle.
An accounting cycle is a complete sequence of accounting procedure, within an accounting
system of an enterprise that repeated in the same order during each accounting period (Fess
warren, 1984). It outlines the various accounting processes that undertaken by the accountant to
process transaction data through the book of accounts such as journals, cashbooks, ledgers, to
summarize and draw up financial statements and reports on the enterprises performance
16
continuously and at year-ends. An accounting cycle for the typical business organization consists
of the following key procedures;
Record daily transaction data in source documents; this is a piece of paper or document that
initiates a transaction and reports its occurrence, example; Invoice, cash receipts etc.
Analyses and record day by day and in chronological order the daily source document
transaction data in the journal.
classify and post the journal transaction data to the ledger.
Balance and foot the ledger accounts to ascertain the balance in such accounts.
prepare a trial balance to summarize and list balances in the ledger account to test their
arithmetical accuracy.
Prepare a worksheet as a tool used to short out, update and organize trial balance information
needed at the end of the period (it may be optional).
Correct, adjust and update the trial balance information in the worksheet to ensure that all the
transaction data and other accounting information that ought to be recorded in the accounts have
in-fact been recorded and that errors committed in in the processing of accounting information in
the source document, the journal ,the ledger and trial balance are corrected.
prepare financial statements in the form of income statements, balance sheet, owner’s equity
statement and statement of cash flow. The two most widely used are income statement and
balance sheet. Income statement is a summary of revenue and expense of business entity for
specific period such as month or year. Balance sheet is a list of assets, liabilities and owners
equity at a specific date, usually at the close of the last day of the month or year.
2.6 SYSTEM OF BOOKKEEPING
2.6.1 Double entry bookkeeping
Double entry bookkeeping is the most efficient and effective method for recording financial
transaction in a way which allows the easy preparation of financial statements. In a double entry
bookkeeping system every transactions recorded twice. This reflects the dual nature of
transactions and provides an arithmetical check.
Advantages of double entry bookkeeping
● presents a complete picture of the initiation and occurrence of each transaction.
● It gives operation support for the accounting equation framework that is the total economic
resource of the business (its asset) must always be equal to the source of funds which were used
to acquire the resources.
● It makes easy to logically follow the movement of funds in the course of trading.
● It gives a double check on each transaction recorded in the accounts as equal debit and credit
entries are made for every transaction.
● provides a reliable way for the basic requirements expected from an accounting record.
17
2.6.2 Single entry bookkeeping
Single entry system defined as any system, which is not exactly the double entry system. In other
words, single entry may consists of ;
1. Double entry in respect of certain transaction such as cash received from debtors, cash paid to
creditors etc.
2. Single entry in respect of certain transactions such as cash purchase, cash sales etc.
3. No entry in respect of certain transactions such as depreciation, bad debts etc.
Thus, a business said to be using single entry system, if it is not following completely the
principle of double entry bookkeeping system (MAHESHWARI, 2005).
Disadvantage of single entry system
●Arithmetical accuracy cannot be checked
●True profit cannot be known
●Financial position of the business cannot be judged
2.7 INVENTORY SYSTEM
There are two alternative approaches or systems as to the determination of inventory; Those are
perpetual and periodic inventory system. Under periodic inventory system, no attempt is made to
record the cost of inventories sold until at the end of the period.
On the other hand, perpetual inventory system uses accounting record that continuously discloses
inventory of each type of commodity at least once a year. The records are then compared with
actual quantities on hand, any difference then corrected.
2.7.1 Perpetual inventory system
It is also knows as automotive inventory system a methods of recording inventory balance after
every receipt and issue to facilitated regular checking and to closing down for stocktaking. The
basic objective of this system is to make available details about the quantity and value of stock of
each item at all time it provides a rigid control over stock of materials as physical stock can
regularly be verified with the stock records kept in the stores and the cost office.
The evaluations of inventory and of the cost of good solids are critically importance to managers
and external user of financial statements due to the cases that inventory is the company largest
current asset and inventory is the company largest current assets and cost of goods sold is its
largest expense. These two accounts have significant effect on the financial statement sub totals
and ratios used in evaluating the solvency and profitability of business. (HORNGREN et al,
2002)
2.7.2 Periodic inventory system
In case of this system the quantity and value of inventory is found out only at the end of the
accounting period after having physical verifications of the unit in hand. The system does not
provide the information regarding the quantity and value of materials in hand on continuous
basis.
18
2.7.3 INVENTORY VALUATION METHOD
The price of many kind of merchandises are subject to frequent changes when identical lots of
merchandise are purchased at various duties during the year each lot may be acquired at different
cost price.
There are several assumptions of inventory valuation methods, each assumption made as to the
cost of units ending inventory leads to different methods of pricing inventory and to different
amounts in financial statement. Those four accepted assumptions are; Specific identification,
Average cost, first in first out, and last in first out methods (ROBERT, 2006).
First in first out; an inventory valuation (costing) method under which, per unit cost of the most
recently acquired goods are used to establish the cost basis of ending inventory.
Last in first out; an inventory valuation method under which, per unit cost of the earliest acquired
goods are used to establish the cost basis of ending inventory.
Specific identification method; an inventory costing method under which actual per unit costs are
used to establish the cost of basis of ending inventory.
Weighted average method; an inventory costing method under which average per unit costs are
computed for goods available for sale during an accounting period, these average per unit costs
are then used to establish the cost basis of ending inventory ( KNAPP,2002).
2.8 ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS AND CONTROLS FOR SMALL ENTERPRISES
HUSSEIN (as cited in Mbroh and Attom, 2013:31) noted that, a good accounting system is not
only judged by how well records are kept but by how well it is able to meet the information need
of both internal and external decision makers. In his view, Clute (as cited in Mbroh and Attom,
2013:31) maintained that it is common for qualified accountants to do a good job of keeping
records up to date but they fail to provide information needed by decision makers. For a business
person, an accounting system should be capable of providing the following.
1. Interim statements, quarterly/six monthly that can provide information about the
progress of the business. Such a statement need not be detailed, but capable of
addressing the special needs of the business. Such documents can also be
circulated, if necessary, among external users such as lenders.
2. Efficiency, cash flow planning is very important for the small business. As cited
in Mbroh and Attom, 2013:31) fuller felt that an annual cash flow forecast,
reviewed periodically , could indicate over all financial requirements such a
statement can be prepared only with help of a well designed accounting system.
3. An accounting system, in addition to provide financial statement, must be capable
of generating other useful information in the form of reports. These includes,
aged account receivable, aged account payable, stock and bank balance etc.
4. In the case of manufacturing enterprises, cost records are usually useful in estimating
costs and determining prices. The accounting system for such enterprises must provide
reliable data forecast estimation.
2.8.1 INTERNAL CONTROL SYSTEM
Internal control system is designed by the organization for the purpose of;
1) Protecting its resources against waste and frauds.
2) Securing compliance with management policies.
3) Ensuring the accuracy and reliability of accounting and reporting data.
19
The system of internal control includes all policies and procedures that enable an organization to
operate in accordance with management plans and policies (EDMOND’s/OLDS, 2010).
Internal control focus into two categories; These are Accounting control and administrative
controls. Accounting controls are measures that relate directly to the protection of assets or to the
reliability of accounting information. Administrative controls are policies designed to increase
operational efficiency. They have no direct brought up on reliability of accounting records.
However, sound administrative control may have vital role in successful operation of the
business (ROBERT, 1990).
2.8.1.1 Internal control concepts and issues
An accounting system is one component of an overall control system that business executives
use to monitor and control their organization. For small businesses, this control system is quite
informal; the principal method a sole proprietor may use to control his/her business is
involvement in the day to day operation of the firm. Employees have less opportunity to take
unfair advantage of their employer if he/she is working side by side with them.(KNAPP, 2002).
2.9 PRIOR STUDY ON SMALL ENTERPEISES
In Nigeria, there have been a large number of empirical studies conducted on small enterprise
such as ONAOLAPO and ADEGBITE,(2014).
These studies investigate the impact of accounting records on small enterprises. The finding
indicates that there is a strong positive relationship between accounting system and performance
of small-scale enterprises. Accounting system is essential for decision making which invariably
affects performance of small-scale enterprises.
Other studies were conducted in various countries to examine the accounting practice of small
scale enterprises and its effect on their performance and access to finance for example
(MICHAEL and CHIGOZI,2014) in Nigeria,(MBROH and BENEBO,2013) in
Ghana,(BRHANE,2014),(TAFA,2011) and ( FETENE, 2010) in Ethiopia. These studies found
that there is poor performance in small enterprises accounting practices. Those studies also found
that most of the owners and managers of (operators) of SEs do not know the accounting skills
required to enhance the economic status of their business.
A study conducted in Zimbabwe on 100 SEs by MASEKLO and MANYANI (as cited in
Amoako, 2013:76) bring out that SEs do not keep complete records of accounts due to lack of
knowledge in accounting and the cost of engaging professional accountants. Consequently, the
use of accounting information to support measurements of financial performance by SEs is
ineffective. The study proposes that regulatory bodies must develop specific guidelines for SEs
accounting and organize training programs for entrepreneurs in small business.
20
As discussed by (OLATUNJI, 2013), small enterprises are gaining widespread acceptance as
viable drivers of economic growth. However, several of these enterprises demise without
fulfilling expectations due to poor management arising from week accounting structure. It also
showed that adoption of sound accounting system enhances performance of small enterprises.
In those studies, JOHN and BEN (2012) stated that there are fundamental problems militating
against the realization of small enterprises role to the benefit of economies especially in a
developing countries. They also stated that the absence of control system has contributed
significantly to their exposure to lapses, perceived misappropriation and reported losses with
small business segments being the worse affected. In addition, the other researcher KP ADACHI
(2012) argued that small enterprises poor performance often ascribed to external factors such as
burdensome character of legal framework, limited scope to penetrate the export market and
access to finance. However, internal factors such as marketing, operation, and in particular
accounting system may be equally responsible to such state of affairs. Moreover, other
researcher BRAHNE (2014) in Debre Markos town stated that many of SEs are poor at
bookkeeping and did not prepare formal financial statements.
In this study the researcher tried to evaluate the attitudes of small enterprise managers towards
,business transaction, and its accounting treatment, internal control systems, inventory systems,
double entry bookkeeping and also tried to identify the reasons that hinder them from applying
accounting system.
21
CHAPTER THREE RESEARCH METHODS
3.1 RESEARCH DESIGN
This descriptive type of research would be followed both qualitative and quantitative data
collection approach. The researcher would be used open ended and close-ended questions for
qualitative and quantitative approaches respectively. Moreover, the researcher would used
questionnaires in order to get detailed information about the attitude of enterprise managers
towards the application of elements of accounting system. Structured questionnaires (open ended
and closed ended) have been distributed to 46 SE owners/ managers.
3.2 PARTICIPANT OF THE STUD Y
The managers or owners of the enterprise were the human participant of the study.
3.3 SAMPLING TECHNIQUES
This research is conducted by using stratified simple random sampling techniques because, the
target population (participant) of the study is most populous and they manage enterprises
engaged in different or heterogeneous business activities such as manufacturing, construction,
urban agriculture, service and trade. So as to obtain the most representative sample the researcher
used stratified simple random sampling technique by making strata based on their business
activity, so that each business group is represented.
3.4 SAMPLE SIZE
From the total population of ‘82’ registered small enterprise(DMT MSEs development
agency,2004), the researcher used a sample size of ‘46’ enterprise managers or owners, based on
YAMANE (1996) sample size determination formula at 90% level of confidence and 0.1
precision levels.
n= N/ (1+N(e)2)
Where; n= sample size
N =total population
e= sampling error/precision level (1-level of Confidence)
Among those sampled enterprises 23 were from manufacturing, 5 were from construction, 13
were from service, 2 were from urban agriculture and 3 were from trade based on their
proportion.
22
3.5 DATA TYPE AND SOURCE
The most important data used for this study was primary data that collected from managers or
owners of the enterprises. There is no secondary data, used to measure the attitudes.
3.6 DATA COLLECTION TECHNIQUES
Those data used for this study was collected by using primary data collection techniques that was
questionnaires (both open ended and close ended).
3.7 DATA PROCESSING, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION
After the collection of available data, from small enterprise managers about their attitude towards
the application of major element of accounting system, the data was processed. In processing the
data, filled and completed questionnaires has been carefully checked to assure that the data is
accurate and to arrange to facilitate the tabulation systems. Since, this research type is simply
descriptive, the data have been analyzed by simple statistical tools (using tabulation) that is in the
form of tables, frequency and percentages and finally with statements.
23
CHAPTER_ FOUR DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION
This data analysis and interpretation is made based on the questionnaires distributed to the
small enterprise owners or managers of Debre Markos town.
Total of ‘46’ questionnaires were distributed to ‘46’ SE owners or managers of which, ‘43’
questionnaires (93.47% response rate) were collected. The remaining ‘3’ questionnaires have not
been collected due to the lack of cooperation of the respondents and carelessly filling the
questionnaires. Therefore this data analysis and interpretation is made by ‘43’ respondents
questionnaire.
Table1: Respondent’s background
Description Response Frequency percentage
Gender Male 34 79.07%
Female 9 20.93%
Educational level Certificate and below 30 69.76%
Diploma 9 20.93%
Degree 4 9.4%
Above Degree 0 0%
Work experience Below 1 year 5 11.62%
1-2 years 8 18.61%
3-5 years 20 46.51%
Above 5 years 10 23.26%
Position in the
enterprise
Only manager 7 16.27%
Owner and manager 36 83.73%
Source: questionnaire, 2015
Education is critical in understanding the dynamics and challenges of business encounter. It is
expected that if an SE operators has a reasonable educational background, it will undoubtedly
enable to directly or indirectly implement the necessary elements of accounting system in his/her
business (Mbroh, 2013). The results in the above table indicates that about 69.78% (30) of the
SE owners/managers had attained primary, secondary or college education followed by those
attained diploma(20.93%). A few enterprise owners/managers (9.4%) attained degree. A gender
has also a great implication in this understanding because of its impact on the educational
background. The results show that, about 79.07% (34) of the SE owners/managers are males and
20.93% (9) are females.
The going concern concept of accounting assumes that businesses are to exist in perpetuity. To
attain the going concern however, businesses are expected to survive all business trials in their
operations since there are often many challenges in the running of a business regardless of the
size and type of industry. Like individuals business events gain experience in various aspect of
their operations with time. In view of this it is expected that, the longer business unit operates,
the better positioned it is to account and implement controls in their business (MBROH, 2013).
Results in table-1 show that, majority (about 46.51%) of the studied SE operators have been in
their business between 3 to 5 years followed by those in business over 5 years (about 23.26%).
Few businesses (11.62%) had been established in the past year. The closeness of family
involvement is expected to influence the extent of accounting tasks. Where firms run by more
non family members (only managers) tend to keep formal accounts. In the opposite fashion,
firms run by more closely family members (owners) do not see the need to keep formal
accounting systems (K PADACHI, 2012). Table 1 shows that most of (about 83.73%) the SE
24
operators are owners and only 16.27 % (7) of the operators are managers (non family members).
This implies that most of the small enterprises are managed by owners (family members).
Table 2: preparation of financial statements
statement response frequency percentage
Do you prepare
financial statement
for your enterprise?
Yes 16 37.21%
No 27 62.79%
total 43 100%
Source: questionnaire, 2015
After taking some general information from the respondents, the main questioned was posed “Do
you prepare a crucial financial statement for your enterprise?” This question sought to categories
the respondents. Those respond ‘yes’ were continue to answer other questions whilst those who
answered ‘no’ were asked to give reasons why he/she prepare financial statement. Out of the
43, 37.21% (16) respondents answered “Yes”. The yes meant that per their Owen understanding
of the financial statements they are in place. The 27 (62.79%) were answered “no”.
Table 3: Reasons for not preparing financial statements
Response frequency percentage
It is not important for small
business
5 18.52%
Lack of skilled labor 12 44.44%
It is not obligated by the
government
1 3.70%
It haven’t benefit for success
unlike production
9 33.34%
total 27 100%
Source: questionnaire, 2015
The above table shows that among the respondents who answered ‘no’ in table two, 44.44% says
lack of skilled labor is the main reason for not preparing financial statements. In addition to this
33.34% of the respondent owners/managers who did not prepare financial statement, thinks as it
haven’t benefit for success unlike production. This implies that there is lack of educated
manpower and lack of understanding the use of financial statements. Jointly the above two tables
implies that most of the respondents did not prepare financial statements since they have not
skilled labor and good understanding on the benefit of financial statements.
Table 4: attitude of owners/managers towards internal control system
statement response frequency percentage
Does your enterprise
have the designed
control system?
Yes 29 67.44%
No 14 32.56%
total 43 100%
Do you plan to use
internal control system
for your business?
Yes 33 76.74%
No 10 23.26%
total 43 100%
Internal control in small
business enables the
control of cash,
purchase and different
disbursements.
Strongly agree 19 44.19%
agree 22 51.16%
neutral 0 0%
disagree 2 4.65%
Strongly disagree 0 0%
25
total 43 100%
Source: questionnaire, 2015
Regarding control procedures for small enterprise Sathyamoorthi (as cited in MBROH, 2013:31)
observed that it is important to have a system of control over all business activity as a well-
designed and properly implemented control system can ensure; protection of resources against
waste and fraud, accuracy and reliability in accounting data, and success in the evaluation of the
performance of the business. Any business regardless of its type and size should have a designed
internal control system to achieve its objective (plan). Table 4 of this paper indicates that 67.44%
of the respondents had understanding of internal control and are already in use in their business
and 32.56% of the respondents had not understanding of internal control. The second statement
also shows that 76.74% of the respondents have a plan to use internal control in their business,
and only 23.26% of them have not a plan to use it. Thirdly, Most of the respondents (about
44.14%) also strongly agree on the third statement and about 51.16% of the respondents agree on
that statement. This implies that most of small enterprise owners/managers have a positive
(good) attitude towards internal control.
Table 5: Business transaction and its accounting treatment
Statement response frequency percentage
Do you record all
transactions timely?
Yes 9 20.93%
NO 15 34.88%
mezzanine 19 41.19%
total 43 100%
If your answer is
mezzanine what type of
business transaction is
recorded
Asset change 2 10.53%
Asset use 9 47.39%
Asset source 8 42.10%
total 19 100%
Recording all business
events (transaction) of
small business is tedious
and less fruit full.
Strongly disagree 13 30.24%
Disagree 11 25.26%
Neutral 3 6.98%
Agree 14 32.56%
Strongly agree 2 4.66%
total 43 100%
Source: questionnaire, 2015
Okoli (2011) in his study argues that in order to enhance the profitability of small enterprises and
their continuity, there is a need for adequate recording all business transaction, which will help
the operators to keep track of the performance of these enterprises. Bulter (2009) also show that
without accurate and complete records of business transactions, the business doomed to fail at its
on set. Table 5 of this study in the above shows that only 20.93% of the respondents record all
business transactions on a timely basis and 34.88% of them do not record all business
transactions. 41.19% of the respondents are mezzanine in the statement. About 47.39% of the
respondents, who answer mezzanine, records asset use transactions followed by asset source
transactions. Moreover, most of the respondents (about 55.5%) disagree on the third statement.
This implies that, even though they do not apply, most of the owners/managers have a positive
tendency towards business transactions.
Table 6: system of recording business transaction
Statement Response Frequency Percentage
Through what system Double entry 7 6.27%
26
you record business
events?
Single entry 2 4.65%
Neutral 34 79.08%
total 43 100%
If your answer is neutral
what system do you
think important for your
enterprise?
Double entry 13 38.24%
Single entry 21 61.76%
I don’t know 0 0%
total 34 100%
Source: questionnaire, 2015
OGUNLADE and BAUMBACK (1983) and OSUALAL (1993) noted that most of small scale
enterprises make use of single entry system of accounting. The reason behind the use of single
entry system of accounting is probably due to its simplicity and low level of accounting
education of operators. In table 6, the results show that most of the respondents (about 61.76%)
think as single entry system is important for their enterprise. The results partly agreed with the
above arguers. It implies that most of small owners/managers have a tendency to apply single
entry system and have not positive attitude towards double entry system of accounting
(bookkeeping).
Table 7: Attitude towards inventory system
statements Strongly
agree
Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly
disagree
total
Inventory system is
important for one
enterprise.
22 10 6 5 0 43
51.16% 23.26% 13.95% 11.63% 0% 100%
Adequate inventory
system is important for
a complete accounting
system and
performance planning
17 17 6 1 2 43
39.53% 39.53% 13.95% 2.33% 4.65% 100%
a
Statement Response Frequency Percentage
If your answer is agree
or strongly agree, what
system you think
important?
Perpetual 27 81.57%
Periodic 7 18.43%
total 34 100%
What method of
inventory valuation you
think important?
FIFO 10 23.26%
LIFO 2 4.63%
Average 20 46.52%
Specific identification 0 0%
Neither of them 11 25.59%
total 43 100%
B Source: questionnaire, 2015
In table 7a, the results show that, most of the respondents, 51.16% strongly agree and 23.26%
agree on the first statement. 13.95% 0f the respondents were neutral and 11.63% disagree on that
statement. In the second statement 34 respondents (about 79.06%) agreed, 6 respondents
(13.92%) are neutral, 1(2.33%) disagreed and 2 (4.66%) are strongly disagreed. This implies that
most (more than half) of the enterprise owners/managers have a positive tendency towards
inventory system. To strengthen this idea, in table 7b, results show that about 81.57% of the
respondents believe as perpetual inventory system is important for their enterprise. In the second
27
statement 20 respondents (about 46.52%) believed that average inventory valuation method is
important for their business.
Table 8: Accounting system
Statement Strongly agree agree neutral disagree Strongly
disagree
total
Accounting system is vital
to small business
18 20 2 3 0 43
41.86% 46.51% 4.66% 6.98% 0% 100%
All business ,including
small business require
accounting
13 10 4 9 7 43
30.24% 23.26% 9.3% 20.93% 16.27% 100%
I would appreciate if given
opportunity to learn about
accounting.
22 20 0 1 0 43
51.16% 46.51% 0% 2.33% 0% 100%
Source: questionnaire, 2015
Penen and Grant noted that decision making processes in small scale enterprises are more
sophisticated than anticipated, but they lacked effective accounting information and control
systems to support their decision. Furthermore, International Federation of Accountants also
suggest that small firms are aware the importance of accounting system (as cited in Amoako,
2013:75). The result of table 8 in the above indicates that most of the respondents (about
46.51%) agreed on the first statement followed by 41.86% strongly agree. On the second and
third statements also most of the respondents (30.24% and 51.16% respectively) strongly agreed
followed by 23.26% and 46.51% agree respectively. This result supports the argument of
International Federation of Accountants. This implies that most of small enterprise
owners/managers have a positive tendency towards the important of accounting system.
Table 9: owners/managers filling by not applying accounting system
Statement Response Frequency Percentage
Do you think that your
business can save some
money by not applying
accounting system
Yes 25 58.14%
No 18 41.86%
total 43 100%
Source: questionnaire, 2015.
In a related study John and Ben (2013) and International federation of accountants (as cited in
Amoako, 2013:75) found that small firms are aware the important of accounting system. In spite
of this aware most SEOs lack basic working knowledge in accounting to keen the use of standard
accounting system to run the day-to-day activity of their enterprise. The above table result shows
that 58.14% of the respondents think as they can save some money by not applying accounting
system. Only 18 (41.86%) respondents said no on the statement. This implies that most of the
small enterprise owners/managers believed, as the application of accounting system is costly in
addition to the lack of skilled labor they face.
When we come to the analysis of the data that obtained from open ended questions they does not
blamed their filer to hold a record towards tax. In opposite fashion, as most of the respondents’
response they believe as the tax system become fair if they have financial statement. Moreover
they also responded as they will not embezzle by tax assessors. Most of them also responded for
the question “ why government advises you as you have accounting system ” ? As the
government makes it for their own purpose but some of them (small in amount) believes as the
28
government do it for its own tax collection system. From this it is possible to conclude as most of
the respondents know the advantage of accounting system and as they do not attach to the tax
increasment problem. For the other open end question, what is the importance of accounting
system? , most of them responded as it has the following importance:
The first advantage that they give is to issue financial statements that used for out said parties
especially for lenders. With regard to this they also explain as they cannot gat loan if they have
not some tangible property without exception.
With regard to the last question most of them responds as they have not accurate knowledge to
decide about the elements of accounting system which must be implemented by their business. In
support of this most of them said we have not any knowledge for this, we only apply what the
government said to us and what our experienced friends advises us. From this the researcher
concludes as they have positive attitude towards the application of accounting system.
29
CHAPTER- FIVE
SUMMARE, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
Summary of the finding
 Majority of the small enterprise owners/managers (about46.51%) had been in
business between 3 to 5 years. 11.66% had been began in the past year. A
majority of (69.78%) had up to certificate and below certificate education. 9.4%
had degree level education.
 62.79% of the respondents do not prepared financial statements for their
enterprise. Among those who did not prepare financial statement 44.44% blamed
to lack of skilled labor. 33.34% thinks as it have not benefit for success unlike
production. 3.7% reasoned as it is not obli gated by the government.
 Among the respondents 67.44%s have a designed internal control system that they
think important for their business. 76.74% plans to use internal control system in
their enterprise. 51.16% agreed on the role of internal control in small enterprise.
44.19% strongly agreed and 4.65% disagreed.
 Most of SMEOS (34.88%) does not record business transaction on a timely basis.
47.39% of them record only asset use transaction and 42.10% record asset source
transactions.32.56% agreed on the tediousness and fruitless of recording all
business transactions of small enterprises. 30.24% and 25.26% of the respondents
strongly disagree and agree on the statement respectively.
 61.76% of the respondents think as single entry system of bookkeeping is
important for their enterprise.
 From the total respondents 51.16% strongly agree on the important of inventory
system for one enterprise. 81.57% thinks as perpetual inventory system is
important for their enterprise and 46.52% of them inclined to use average
inventory valuation method.
 Among the respondents 46.51% agreed on the vital of accounting system to small
business. 30.24% strongly agreed on the importance of accounting for all business
and 51.16% are willing to learn more about accounting if given opportunity.
2.33% disagreed.
 58.14% of the respondents think as their business can save money by not applying
accounting system.
CONCLUSION
30
 The study revealed that SMEOs do not prepare crucial financial statements for
their enterprise because of the lack of accounting knowledge (skilled labor) and
due to lack of understanding the ultimate importance of financial statements. As
result there is inefficient use of accounting information to support the financial
performance measurement by small enterprises.
 More over based on the finding the researcher concludes that, Even though they
do not prepare financial statements and do not record business transactions timely
because of lack of skill (skilled labor) in accounting and worry on the cost of
hiring accountants, they have the positive attitude to apply elements of accounting
system when the above constraints solved. This study ignores the idea proposed in
K padachi (2012:3).
 The study further revealed that the owners/managers of SEs were highly willing
to learn more about how to keep accurate records of their business transactions.
The finding of the study showed that the owners/managers of SEs had a positive
attitude towards internal control, inventory system and business transaction. In
addition to this, this study concludes that except deferent restriction small
enterprise managers believe as accounting system is important for one enterprise
including theirs.
 Additionally, the finding showed that SEOs, because of the simplicity of single
entry bookkeeping, are more inclined to adopt single entry system of
bookkeeping.
 Finally, it revealed that the failure of not applying accounting system was highly
blamed by small enterprise owners/managers to lack of skilled labor and cost of
hiring professional accountants and in some extent to the size of the enterprises.
31
RECOMMENDATION
After a detailed investigations made on the attitude of small enterprise owners/managers
towards the application of accounting system the researcher would like to forward the
following recommendation.
 It is recommended that the ministry responsible for SEs development should
initiate, in more strengthen way, record keeping training program for
entrepreneurs running small business.
 Bookkeeping in SEs should be made mandatory to change their tendency in to
practice and to improve their accounting practice to enhance financial and
economic decision making for business growth.
 Since there is international acceptance that SEs requires simplified financial
reporting standard fitting their reduced size and narrow stockholders base, the
government needs to adopt simplified accounting standard sets for SEs.
 Debre markos university, specially accounting department like that of law school,
should establish a free community services in bookkeeping support institute to
facilitate small enterprise owners to apply accounting system in their enterprise.
32
REFERANCES
Admas University College (2014) principle of accounting, teaching material,
unpublished.
Amoako .G.K (2013) accounting practice of SMEs; a case study of Kumesi Metropolies
in GANA, International journal of business and management,vol.8,No.24, published by
Canadian center of science and education.
Brhane Tadesse (2014), access to finance for Micro and Small enterprise in Debre
Markos town Ethiopia, Global journal of current research, vol.2, No.2; pp.36-46.
Donald E.kieso and jerry j.Weygandt (1998), intermediate accounting, 9th edition.
Edmonds/olds/mcnair/tsay(2010), survey of accounting,2nd edition.
Fess warren (1984), principle of accounting, 16th edition.
Fetene zeru (2010), access to finance and its challenge for small enterprises: in case of
Addis Abeba city, unpublished
Jane, Williams et al (2006), Accounting for decision making and control.
Mbroh J.K and Attom B.E (2013) Accounting and control system practiced by small and
micro enterprise owners within the cape coast metropolital area of Ghana, Asian journal
of business and management sciences, vol.1 No.1; pp. 28-47.
Okoli B.E (2011) Evaluation of the accounting system used by small scale enterprise in
Nigeria: the case of Enugu- south east Nigeria, Asian journal of business management,
vol.3, No.4; pp.235-240.
Olatunji T.E (2013) The impact of accounting system on the performance of small and
medium scale enterprises in Nigeria: a survey of SMEs in oyo state- Nigeria,
International journal of business and management invention, vol.2;pp 13-17.
Padachji k (2013) factors affecting the adoption of Formal Accounting system by SMEs,
Business and Economics journal, vol. 2012, BEJ 67.
Robert F, meigs and Walter B(1990),accounting the base for business decision,8th
33
edition.
Robert, Anthony, James Reece (2006), accounting principle, 6th edition.
Tafa (2011) Accounting practice of small and medium sized enterprises and its effect on
access to finance in addise abebe; unpublished.
Zemenu A and Mohamed M (2014) determinant of growth of micro and small enterprises
in Ethiopia: a case of Mse in mekelle city, tigry, international journal of Advance
research in computer since and studies, vol2; pp149- 157.
Debre markos town administration micro and small enterprises agency total summary
data slip, code 004.
website
http:/ www.gov.et/ micro and small enterprise development agency.
http:/ www.memoireonline.com/accounting system in small enterprise.
34
APPENDIX
DEBRE MARKOS UNIVERSITY
COLLEGE OF BUSINESS AND ECONOMICS
DEPARTMENT OF ACCOUNTING AND FINANCE
Deer respondent,
I am the student of Debre Markos university college of Business and Economics, department of
Accounting and Finance. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the attitude of small enterprise
managers towards the application of major element of accounting system, so this study needs to
gather information to achieve its objective. So your response is very crucial and hence you are
kindly requested to respond genuinely. The researcher wants to assure you that it will be used
only for academic purpose and to be kept confidential. Please do not write your name anywhere
on the questionnaire
. I appreciate your cooperation in this study
. If you have any question please call, 0928579011 or 0948707012
Thanks in advance!!!
Respondent background
1, Gender
Male female
2, work experience
<1 year 1-2 Years
3 -5 Years >5 years
3, level of education
Below certificate and certificate degree
Master other………………………………………………….
4, position in your enterprise
Only manager
Managers and owners
5, Do you prepare a crucial financial statement for your enterprise?
Yes no
6, If your answer for question number 6 is no why?
It is not important for small business
Lack of skilled labor others----------------
It is not obligated by government
It have not benefit for success unlike production
7, Does your enterprise have the designed internal control system?
Yes No
8, If your answer for question number 8 is no why?
It is not as much important
It is costly to apple
35
The employees of our business is family members
the size of the business is small
others specify-------------------------------------------------
9, DO you plan to use internal control system for your business?
Yes No
10, Does your enterprise record all transactions timely?
Yes No
Mezzanine
11, If your answer is mezzanine, what type of business transaction (business event) is (shall)
Recorded?
Asset source Asset use
Asset exchange
12, If your answer for question number 11 is yes through what system your enterprise record
business events?
Double entry neutral
Single entry neutral
13, If your answer for question No’12’ is neutral, what system do you think important for your
enterprise?
Double entry others specify ---------------------------------
Single entry
14, inventory system is important for one enterprise.
Strongly agree Neutral strongly disagree
Agree disagree
15, If your answer for question No ‘14 is agree or strongly agree what system is you think
important?
Perpetual
Periodic
16,What method of inventory valuation you are applying or needs to apply?
FIFO LIFO
AVERGE
Specific identification neither of them
17, accounting system is vital to my business.
strongly agree neutral
agree
disagree
strongly disagree
18, all business, including, small business require accounting
Strongly agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly disagree
19, recording all business events (transactions) of small business is tedious and less fruitful.
Strongly agree
Agree neutral
36
Disagree
Strongly disagree
20, I would appreciate if given opportunity to learn about accounting
Strongly agree Disagree
Agree Strongly disagree
Neutral
21, do you think that your business can save some money by not applying accounting system.
Yes No
22, adequate inventory system is important for complete accounting system and for performance
planning
Strongly agree neutral
Agree
Disagree strongly disagree
23, Internal control in small business enables the control of cash, purchase and different
disbursement
Strongly agree Disagree
Agree Strongly disagree
Neutral
24, what do you think about the importance of accounting?----------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------
25, why government advises as you shall have accounting system? ------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------
26, do you believe that financial statement increases the amount of tax--------------------------------
----------------------------------------
27, What is your overall opinion about the element of accounting system that shall be applied by
small enterprises? ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------
37

More Related Content

What's hot

Classroom assessment manual
Classroom assessment  manualClassroom assessment  manual
Classroom assessment manual
Arega Mamaru
 
Survey on corporate governance | Excellence Enablers
Survey on corporate governance | Excellence EnablersSurvey on corporate governance | Excellence Enablers
Survey on corporate governance | Excellence Enablers
SwatiDobriyal
 
Minnesota Faculty Teaching Contract mscf final 2013_2015
Minnesota Faculty Teaching Contract mscf final 2013_2015Minnesota Faculty Teaching Contract mscf final 2013_2015
Minnesota Faculty Teaching Contract mscf final 2013_2015
Children's Hospitals and Clinics
 
internship report on Nestle Pakistan ltd.
internship report on Nestle Pakistan ltd.internship report on Nestle Pakistan ltd.
internship report on Nestle Pakistan ltd.
Yousuf Razzaq
 
Internship report on marketing
Internship report on marketingInternship report on marketing
Internship report on marketing
Awais Jamil
 
Teaching english language
Teaching english languageTeaching english language
Teaching english language
paolasparapani
 
Develop a portfolio to demonstrate school leadership and management competenc...
Develop a portfolio to demonstrate school leadership and management competenc...Develop a portfolio to demonstrate school leadership and management competenc...
Develop a portfolio to demonstrate school leadership and management competenc...
Saide OER Africa
 
Welcome packet 8.20.13
Welcome packet 8.20.13Welcome packet 8.20.13
Welcome packet 8.20.13jcoggeshall
 
2011 illinois-state-budget
2011 illinois-state-budget2011 illinois-state-budget
2011 illinois-state-budget
club1075
 
The Regional Resource Curse (online)
The Regional Resource Curse (online)The Regional Resource Curse (online)
The Regional Resource Curse (online)James Middleton
 
Senate Academic Planning Task Force : DRAFT Report March 2013
Senate Academic Planning Task Force : DRAFT Report March 2013Senate Academic Planning Task Force : DRAFT Report March 2013
Senate Academic Planning Task Force : DRAFT Report March 2013
eraser Juan José Calderón
 
Www.moip.gov.pk ip final_report_revised_aug_13_2011
Www.moip.gov.pk ip final_report_revised_aug_13_2011Www.moip.gov.pk ip final_report_revised_aug_13_2011
Www.moip.gov.pk ip final_report_revised_aug_13_2011faheemmacro
 
Ewrt1A Reader Writing Resources
Ewrt1A Reader Writing ResourcesEwrt1A Reader Writing Resources
Ewrt1A Reader Writing ResourcesKaren Chow
 
The impact of human resource on corporate social responsibility of small and ...
The impact of human resource on corporate social responsibility of small and ...The impact of human resource on corporate social responsibility of small and ...
The impact of human resource on corporate social responsibility of small and ...
Dichvuthuctap.com
 
AN ANALYSIS OF THE IMPORTANCE OF CORPORATE REPUTATION IN HIGHER EDUCATION INS...
AN ANALYSIS OF THE IMPORTANCE OF CORPORATE REPUTATION IN HIGHER EDUCATION INS...AN ANALYSIS OF THE IMPORTANCE OF CORPORATE REPUTATION IN HIGHER EDUCATION INS...
AN ANALYSIS OF THE IMPORTANCE OF CORPORATE REPUTATION IN HIGHER EDUCATION INS...Maz Nyatsambo
 
Review for Private Sector Participation in Water and Sanitation in Indonesia
Review for Private Sector Participation in Water and Sanitation in IndonesiaReview for Private Sector Participation in Water and Sanitation in Indonesia
Review for Private Sector Participation in Water and Sanitation in Indonesia
Oswar Mungkasa
 
Syllabus diploma ict [1](1)
Syllabus diploma ict [1](1)Syllabus diploma ict [1](1)
Syllabus diploma ict [1](1)
gwadenya
 

What's hot (20)

Classroom assessment manual
Classroom assessment  manualClassroom assessment  manual
Classroom assessment manual
 
Survey on corporate governance | Excellence Enablers
Survey on corporate governance | Excellence EnablersSurvey on corporate governance | Excellence Enablers
Survey on corporate governance | Excellence Enablers
 
Minnesota Faculty Teaching Contract mscf final 2013_2015
Minnesota Faculty Teaching Contract mscf final 2013_2015Minnesota Faculty Teaching Contract mscf final 2013_2015
Minnesota Faculty Teaching Contract mscf final 2013_2015
 
internship report on Nestle Pakistan ltd.
internship report on Nestle Pakistan ltd.internship report on Nestle Pakistan ltd.
internship report on Nestle Pakistan ltd.
 
Internship report on marketing
Internship report on marketingInternship report on marketing
Internship report on marketing
 
Teaching english language
Teaching english languageTeaching english language
Teaching english language
 
IFRS GLOSSARY
IFRS GLOSSARYIFRS GLOSSARY
IFRS GLOSSARY
 
Develop a portfolio to demonstrate school leadership and management competenc...
Develop a portfolio to demonstrate school leadership and management competenc...Develop a portfolio to demonstrate school leadership and management competenc...
Develop a portfolio to demonstrate school leadership and management competenc...
 
Welcome packet 8.20.13
Welcome packet 8.20.13Welcome packet 8.20.13
Welcome packet 8.20.13
 
2011 illinois-state-budget
2011 illinois-state-budget2011 illinois-state-budget
2011 illinois-state-budget
 
The Regional Resource Curse (online)
The Regional Resource Curse (online)The Regional Resource Curse (online)
The Regional Resource Curse (online)
 
Senate Academic Planning Task Force : DRAFT Report March 2013
Senate Academic Planning Task Force : DRAFT Report March 2013Senate Academic Planning Task Force : DRAFT Report March 2013
Senate Academic Planning Task Force : DRAFT Report March 2013
 
ACTIVITY REPORT 2010
ACTIVITY  REPORT    2010ACTIVITY  REPORT    2010
ACTIVITY REPORT 2010
 
Academic Policies and Procedures Handbook
Academic Policies and Procedures HandbookAcademic Policies and Procedures Handbook
Academic Policies and Procedures Handbook
 
Www.moip.gov.pk ip final_report_revised_aug_13_2011
Www.moip.gov.pk ip final_report_revised_aug_13_2011Www.moip.gov.pk ip final_report_revised_aug_13_2011
Www.moip.gov.pk ip final_report_revised_aug_13_2011
 
Ewrt1A Reader Writing Resources
Ewrt1A Reader Writing ResourcesEwrt1A Reader Writing Resources
Ewrt1A Reader Writing Resources
 
The impact of human resource on corporate social responsibility of small and ...
The impact of human resource on corporate social responsibility of small and ...The impact of human resource on corporate social responsibility of small and ...
The impact of human resource on corporate social responsibility of small and ...
 
AN ANALYSIS OF THE IMPORTANCE OF CORPORATE REPUTATION IN HIGHER EDUCATION INS...
AN ANALYSIS OF THE IMPORTANCE OF CORPORATE REPUTATION IN HIGHER EDUCATION INS...AN ANALYSIS OF THE IMPORTANCE OF CORPORATE REPUTATION IN HIGHER EDUCATION INS...
AN ANALYSIS OF THE IMPORTANCE OF CORPORATE REPUTATION IN HIGHER EDUCATION INS...
 
Review for Private Sector Participation in Water and Sanitation in Indonesia
Review for Private Sector Participation in Water and Sanitation in IndonesiaReview for Private Sector Participation in Water and Sanitation in Indonesia
Review for Private Sector Participation in Water and Sanitation in Indonesia
 
Syllabus diploma ict [1](1)
Syllabus diploma ict [1](1)Syllabus diploma ict [1](1)
Syllabus diploma ict [1](1)
 

Viewers also liked

Microfinance in india
Microfinance in indiaMicrofinance in india
Microfinance in india
Malko29
 
Micro Financing
Micro FinancingMicro Financing
Micro FinancingAmna Abid
 
Reverse mortgage at sbi mba finance project report
Reverse mortgage  at sbi mba finance project reportReverse mortgage  at sbi mba finance project report
Reverse mortgage at sbi mba finance project report
Babasab Patil
 
Microfinance
MicrofinanceMicrofinance
Microfinance
arsal87
 
51432284 project-finance
51432284 project-finance51432284 project-finance
51432284 project-financeamritakamarath
 
Full summer training report
Full summer training reportFull summer training report
Full summer training reportwadhwa.ritika8
 
Risk management in banking
Risk management in bankingRisk management in banking
Risk management in banking7939790a
 
Report - Risk Management in Banks
Report - Risk Management in BanksReport - Risk Management in Banks
Report - Risk Management in BanksSharad Srivastava
 
Micro finance in India
Micro finance in IndiaMicro finance in India
Micro finance in India
DEEPAK TIWARI
 
Presentation on Microfinance
Presentation on MicrofinancePresentation on Microfinance
Presentation on Microfinance
Carol_Rodrigues
 
Risk management in banking sector project report mba finance
Risk management in banking sector project report mba financeRisk management in banking sector project report mba finance
Risk management in banking sector project report mba finance
Babasab Patil
 
Microfinance : Project Report
Microfinance : Project ReportMicrofinance : Project Report
Microfinance : Project Report
yogi3250
 
Project Financing
Project FinancingProject Financing
Project Financing
khankm
 
Summer internship report L&T
Summer internship report L&TSummer internship report L&T
Summer internship report L&TUmed Paliwal
 
Summer internship project hr mba mms
Summer internship project hr mba mmsSummer internship project hr mba mms
Summer internship project hr mba mms
Sria
 
Microfinance An Introduction
Microfinance An IntroductionMicrofinance An Introduction
Microfinance An Introduction
Kabare Piyush
 
Dissertation report on issue and success factors in micro financing
Dissertation report on issue and success factors in micro financingDissertation report on issue and success factors in micro financing
Dissertation report on issue and success factors in micro financing
Free MBA Projects
 
Mba project report
Mba project reportMba project report
Mba project report
Cochin University
 
Finance projects topics
Finance projects topicsFinance projects topics
Finance projects topics
Babasab Patil
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Microfinance in india
Microfinance in indiaMicrofinance in india
Microfinance in india
 
Micro Financing
Micro FinancingMicro Financing
Micro Financing
 
Reverse mortgage at sbi mba finance project report
Reverse mortgage  at sbi mba finance project reportReverse mortgage  at sbi mba finance project report
Reverse mortgage at sbi mba finance project report
 
Microfinance
MicrofinanceMicrofinance
Microfinance
 
51432284 project-finance
51432284 project-finance51432284 project-finance
51432284 project-finance
 
Full summer training report
Full summer training reportFull summer training report
Full summer training report
 
Risk management in banking
Risk management in bankingRisk management in banking
Risk management in banking
 
Report - Risk Management in Banks
Report - Risk Management in BanksReport - Risk Management in Banks
Report - Risk Management in Banks
 
Micro finance in India
Micro finance in IndiaMicro finance in India
Micro finance in India
 
Presentation on Microfinance
Presentation on MicrofinancePresentation on Microfinance
Presentation on Microfinance
 
Risk management in banking sector project report mba finance
Risk management in banking sector project report mba financeRisk management in banking sector project report mba finance
Risk management in banking sector project report mba finance
 
Microfinance : Project Report
Microfinance : Project ReportMicrofinance : Project Report
Microfinance : Project Report
 
Project Financing
Project FinancingProject Financing
Project Financing
 
Summer internship report L&T
Summer internship report L&TSummer internship report L&T
Summer internship report L&T
 
Summer internship project hr mba mms
Summer internship project hr mba mmsSummer internship project hr mba mms
Summer internship project hr mba mms
 
Internship report
Internship reportInternship report
Internship report
 
Microfinance An Introduction
Microfinance An IntroductionMicrofinance An Introduction
Microfinance An Introduction
 
Dissertation report on issue and success factors in micro financing
Dissertation report on issue and success factors in micro financingDissertation report on issue and success factors in micro financing
Dissertation report on issue and success factors in micro financing
 
Mba project report
Mba project reportMba project report
Mba project report
 
Finance projects topics
Finance projects topicsFinance projects topics
Finance projects topics
 

Similar to research pp simeneh's

small_enterprise_managers_attitude_towar1.doc
small_enterprise_managers_attitude_towar1.docsmall_enterprise_managers_attitude_towar1.doc
small_enterprise_managers_attitude_towar1.doc
MohammedDemssieMoham
 
Idosa tolesa final paper
Idosa tolesa final paper Idosa tolesa final paper
Idosa tolesa final paper
IdosaTolesa
 
Μελέτη της ΕE για την επιχειρηματικότητα
Μελέτη της ΕE για την επιχειρηματικότηταΜελέτη της ΕE για την επιχειρηματικότητα
Μελέτη της ΕE για την επιχειρηματικότηταWin to Win - Business Consultants
 
the implementation and adopting of activity based costing in manufacturing vi...
the implementation and adopting of activity based costing in manufacturing vi...the implementation and adopting of activity based costing in manufacturing vi...
the implementation and adopting of activity based costing in manufacturing vi...
nataliej4
 
Assessment Of E- Banking Service Quality On Customer Satisfaction In Commerci...
Assessment Of E- Banking Service Quality On Customer Satisfaction In Commerci...Assessment Of E- Banking Service Quality On Customer Satisfaction In Commerci...
Assessment Of E- Banking Service Quality On Customer Satisfaction In Commerci...
Brittany Brown
 
Experiences and practices of eight oecd countries
Experiences and practices of eight oecd countriesExperiences and practices of eight oecd countries
Experiences and practices of eight oecd countriesALEXANDRASUWANN
 
Nellywizzoo report(TRA)
Nellywizzoo report(TRA)Nellywizzoo report(TRA)
Nellywizzoo report(TRA)Nelson Maimu
 
1 BEST-Assesment of Cost Accounting Practice Rev.-converted-BOTTLING.pdf
1 BEST-Assesment of Cost Accounting Practice Rev.-converted-BOTTLING.pdf1 BEST-Assesment of Cost Accounting Practice Rev.-converted-BOTTLING.pdf
1 BEST-Assesment of Cost Accounting Practice Rev.-converted-BOTTLING.pdf
MinawBelay
 
Gsfp accounting procedures_manual1
Gsfp accounting procedures_manual1Gsfp accounting procedures_manual1
Gsfp accounting procedures_manual1
saluddarren
 
Economic and-management-sciences-grade-9
Economic and-management-sciences-grade-9Economic and-management-sciences-grade-9
Economic and-management-sciences-grade-9
Luzuko Maseko
 
Prediction of economical recession with the signal approach, and the turkey case
Prediction of economical recession with the signal approach, and the turkey casePrediction of economical recession with the signal approach, and the turkey case
Prediction of economical recession with the signal approach, and the turkey caseDeniz Özgür Tiryaki
 
e-invoicing european market guide
e-invoicing european market guidee-invoicing european market guide
e-invoicing european market guideBoni
 
E invoicing 2010
E invoicing 2010E invoicing 2010
E invoicing 2010
Boni
 
Bisrat Tesfaye Research proposal.doc
Bisrat Tesfaye Research proposal.docBisrat Tesfaye Research proposal.doc
Bisrat Tesfaye Research proposal.doc
teza bekele
 
ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES Determinants Of Commercial ...
ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES Determinants Of Commercial ...ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES Determinants Of Commercial ...
ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES Determinants Of Commercial ...
Andrew Parish
 
Assignment on management accounting
Assignment on management accountingAssignment on management accounting
Assignment on management accounting
Moshfiqur Rahman
 
Creating and measuring shareholders value
Creating and measuring shareholders valueCreating and measuring shareholders value
Creating and measuring shareholders valueEdward Asinyo
 
Final research-draft-2016-g.c (1)
Final research-draft-2016-g.c (1) Final research-draft-2016-g.c (1)
Final research-draft-2016-g.c (1)
ESHETIE MEKONENE AMARE
 

Similar to research pp simeneh's (20)

small_enterprise_managers_attitude_towar1.doc
small_enterprise_managers_attitude_towar1.docsmall_enterprise_managers_attitude_towar1.doc
small_enterprise_managers_attitude_towar1.doc
 
Idosa tolesa final paper
Idosa tolesa final paper Idosa tolesa final paper
Idosa tolesa final paper
 
Μελέτη της ΕE για την επιχειρηματικότητα
Μελέτη της ΕE για την επιχειρηματικότηταΜελέτη της ΕE για την επιχειρηματικότητα
Μελέτη της ΕE για την επιχειρηματικότητα
 
the implementation and adopting of activity based costing in manufacturing vi...
the implementation and adopting of activity based costing in manufacturing vi...the implementation and adopting of activity based costing in manufacturing vi...
the implementation and adopting of activity based costing in manufacturing vi...
 
Assessment Of E- Banking Service Quality On Customer Satisfaction In Commerci...
Assessment Of E- Banking Service Quality On Customer Satisfaction In Commerci...Assessment Of E- Banking Service Quality On Customer Satisfaction In Commerci...
Assessment Of E- Banking Service Quality On Customer Satisfaction In Commerci...
 
Experiences and practices of eight oecd countries
Experiences and practices of eight oecd countriesExperiences and practices of eight oecd countries
Experiences and practices of eight oecd countries
 
Wcm
WcmWcm
Wcm
 
Nellywizzoo report(TRA)
Nellywizzoo report(TRA)Nellywizzoo report(TRA)
Nellywizzoo report(TRA)
 
1 BEST-Assesment of Cost Accounting Practice Rev.-converted-BOTTLING.pdf
1 BEST-Assesment of Cost Accounting Practice Rev.-converted-BOTTLING.pdf1 BEST-Assesment of Cost Accounting Practice Rev.-converted-BOTTLING.pdf
1 BEST-Assesment of Cost Accounting Practice Rev.-converted-BOTTLING.pdf
 
Gsfp accounting procedures_manual1
Gsfp accounting procedures_manual1Gsfp accounting procedures_manual1
Gsfp accounting procedures_manual1
 
Economic and-management-sciences-grade-9
Economic and-management-sciences-grade-9Economic and-management-sciences-grade-9
Economic and-management-sciences-grade-9
 
Prediction of economical recession with the signal approach, and the turkey case
Prediction of economical recession with the signal approach, and the turkey casePrediction of economical recession with the signal approach, and the turkey case
Prediction of economical recession with the signal approach, and the turkey case
 
e-invoicing european market guide
e-invoicing european market guidee-invoicing european market guide
e-invoicing european market guide
 
E invoicing 2010
E invoicing 2010E invoicing 2010
E invoicing 2010
 
Bisrat Tesfaye Research proposal.doc
Bisrat Tesfaye Research proposal.docBisrat Tesfaye Research proposal.doc
Bisrat Tesfaye Research proposal.doc
 
ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES Determinants Of Commercial ...
ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES Determinants Of Commercial ...ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES Determinants Of Commercial ...
ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES Determinants Of Commercial ...
 
Assignment on management accounting
Assignment on management accountingAssignment on management accounting
Assignment on management accounting
 
Creating and measuring shareholders value
Creating and measuring shareholders valueCreating and measuring shareholders value
Creating and measuring shareholders value
 
A
AA
A
 
Final research-draft-2016-g.c (1)
Final research-draft-2016-g.c (1) Final research-draft-2016-g.c (1)
Final research-draft-2016-g.c (1)
 

research pp simeneh's

  • 1. 1 Small enterprise owners/managers attitude towards the Application of major elements of Accounting System (a case study in Debre Markos town) A Senior essay submitted for the partial Fulfillment of bachelors of arts degree in Accounting and Finance BY; SIMENEH ALMAW Advisor; ABATE GASHAW (MSC) Debre Markos University College of business and economics Department of Accounting and finance June 2007 Debre Markos, Ethiopia
  • 2. 2 Table of Contents DECLARATION OF ORGINALITY ………………………………………………………………………………………………..I ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………..II LIST OF TABLE …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..III LISTOF ACRONYMS …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..IV ABSTRACT …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………V CHAPTER _ ON INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................... 9 1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY..................................................................................... 9 1.2 Statement of the problem.................................................................................................... 11 1.3 Objective of the study......................................................................................................... 12 1.3.1 General objective ......................................................................................................... 12 1.3.2 Specific objective......................................................................................................... 12 1.4 Scope of the study............................................................................................................... 12 1.5 Limitations of the study ...................................................................................................... 12 1.6 Significance of the study..................................................................................................... 12 CHAPTER_ TWO REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE..................................................... 14 2.1 INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................. 14 2.2 NEEDS FOR ACCOUNTING ........................................................................................... 15 2.3 ACCOUNTING SYSTEM ................................................................................................. 15 2 .4 BUSINESS EVENTS (ACCOUNTING TRANSACTIONS)........................................... 15 2.5 ACCOUNTING CYCLE.................................................................................................... 15 2.6 SYSTEM OF BOOKKEEPING ......................................................................................... 16 2.6.1 Double entry bookkeeping ........................................................................................... 16 2.6.2 Single entry bookkeeping............................................................................................. 17 2.7 INVENTORY SYSTEM .................................................................................................... 17 2.7.1 Perpetual inventory system.......................................................................................... 17 2.7.2 Periodic inventory system............................................................................................ 17 2.7.3 INVENTORY VALUATION METHOD........................................................................ 18 2.8 ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS AND CONTROLS FOR SMALL ENTERPRISES............. 18 2.8.1 INTERNAL CONTROL SYSTEM................................................................................. 18 2.8.1.1 Internal control concepts and issues ......................................................................... 19 2.9 PRIOR STUDY ON SMALL ENTERPEISES .................................................................. 19 CHAPTER THREE RESEARCH METHODS ........................................................................... 21 3.1 RESEARCH DESIGN........................................................................................................ 21
  • 3. 3 3.2 PARTICIPANT OF THE STUD Y .................................................................................... 21 3.3 SAMPLING TECHNIQUES.............................................................................................. 21 3.4 SAMPLE SIZE ................................................................................................................... 21 3.5 DATA TYPE AND SOURCE............................................................................................ 22 3.6 DATA COLLECTION TECHNIQUES ............................................................................. 22 3.7 DATA PROCESSING, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION...................................... 22 CHAPTER_ FOUR DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION....................................... 23 CHAPTER- FIVE......................................................................................................................... 29 SUMMARE, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONs.................................................... 29 Summary of the findings........................................................................................................... 29 CONCLUSIONs ....................................................................................................................... 29 RECOMMENDATIONs........................................................................................................... 31 REFERANCES............................................................................................................................. 32 APPENDIX................................................................................................................................... 34
  • 4. 4 DECLARATION OF ORIGINALITY I the undersigned , SIMENEH ALMAW, confirm that the senior essay entitled ”SMALL ENTERPRISE MANAGER’S ATTITUDE TOWARDS THE APPLICATION OF MAJOR ELEMENT OF ACCOUNTING SYSTEM( a case study in Debre Markos town)” is my original work and is being submitted in partial fulfillment of BA degree in accounting and Finance in Debre Markos university. This study have not been submitted for any degree or diploma program in this or other institutions and that all source of materials used for the paper have been duly acknowledged. Declared by Name: SIMENEH ALMAW Signature: ___________________ Date: _______________________ Place: Debre Markos, Ethiopia Advisor: ABATE GASHAW (MSC) Signature: _______________________ Date: -------------------------------------- I
  • 5. 5 ACKNOWLEDGMENT It is the grace, mercy, charity, forgiveness, help and kindness of the almighty of god that made me alive, achieve this success and strength. Next to this I would like to thank all my teachers who fill my mind by accounting knowledge. While there are several people ,who have helped me in one or another way to achieve the completion of this paper, it would have not been without the guidance, support and expertise of my advisor ABATE GASHAW( Msc). I would like to begin by thanking ABATE GASHAW for his constructive comments and outstanding help with this paper and for making me to use the potential that i have with confidence on my ability. IN addition, I am thankful to all my family and friends for their moral and financial support. Especially, I would like to thanks my brother BAMLAKU and my friends YIHUN ESUBALEW, BAMLAKU ASEMARE AND MELSEW ABEBE. I would also like to extend my thanks to Debre Markos town small enterprise managers or owners for their cooperation for filling the questionnaires. Finally yet importantly, I would also want to extend my appreciation to everyone who supported me at the preparation of this study. II
  • 6. 6 LIST OF TABLE Table 1- Respondent’s background Table 2- Preparation of financial statements Table 3- Reasons for not preparing financial statement Table 4- Attitude of owners/managers towards internal control Table 5- Business transaction and its accounting treatment Table 6- attitudes towards system of recording business transaction Table 7-Attitude towards inventory system Table 8 – Attitude towards accounting system Table 9- owners/managers filling by not applying accounting system III
  • 7. 7 LIST OF ACRONYMS SEs small enterprises SEos small enterprise owners ETB Ethiopian birr DMT Debre Markos town MSEs micro and small enterprises VI
  • 8. 8 ABSTRACT Small scale enterprises play a vital role in the economic development of any country. In Ethiopia, most small scale enterprise owners/managers handle their business traditionally. This study aimed at investigating the attitude of small enterprise owners/managers towards the application of major elements of accounting system in Debre Markos. The population of the study consists of ‘82’small enterprise owners/managers. ‘46’ respondents were selected through a stratified simple random sampling techniques. Structured questionnaire (both open ended and close ended) was employed in the course of gathering relevant data for the study. Data were analyzed by using percentage and frequency. The result indicates that most small enterprise owners/managers have a positive tendency towards internal control and inventory system. Moreover, it shows that a significant number of small enterprise owners/managers have a tendency towards single entry system of bookkeeping and most of them do not prepare financial statements for their enterprise. The study therefore concludes that small enterprise owners/managers have a positive attitude to apply elements of accounting system when different constraints solved and they were highly willing to learn more about how to keep accurate records of their business transactions. Following this the study recommended that, the ministry responsible for SEs development should initiate, in a more strengthen way, record keeping training program for entrepreneurs running small business and bookkeeping in SEs should be made mandatory to change their tendency in to practice and to make them beneficiary. Finally it is recommended that Debre Markos University, specially accounting and finance department like that of law school, should establish a free community service in bookkeeping institute to facilitate small enterprise owners to apply accounting system in their enterprise. VII
  • 9. 9 CHAPTER _ ON INTRODUCTION 1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY The contribution of small enterprises (SEs) to the economic development of most developing countries is overwhelming. Providing employment opportunity for the country’s working population, contribution to the government revenue generation through the payment of income tax, As well as providing income in terms of profit and wage to households, has been the ultimate hallmark of SE’s to a developing country, of which Ethiopia is no exception. Small enterprises are an important ingredient for stable and equitable growth in any national economy. Ethiopia takes the development and expansion of SEs as the main way to solve many of the social problems. Yet despite, specific global efforts to strengthen the SE sector these business face a number of problems, particularly in developing countries. In Ethiopia, one of the main problems of ESs may be their accounting practices and access to finance (TAFA, 2011). Studies show that it is hard for the small enterprises to access finance from the financial institutions, since they lack proper financial record as requirement (GIBRET, 2013). Providers of finance and other interesting parties often rely on information before making the formal decision either to invest or not to invest in a given business. An adequate Accounting system will generate the needed information for whatever purpose. It is recommend by many researchers that SEs keep detail accounting records and Audits their financial statements on annual basis. For most developing countries achieving low unemployment, improving income level and reducing poverty which eventually lead to economic success largely depends on whether SE's are doing well or not. As GIBERT says, for the SEs also to do well there is the need for them to attract and secure finance. Providers of finance will not invest or provide funds unless they are assure that they will not lose their investment. Most providers of finance assure themselves with accounting information generated from an adequate accounting system in order to reduce risk. Unfortunately because owners manage SEs in Ethiopia, they sometimes believe, they have less need for financial accounting information because of their personal involvement in the day-to- day operation. An accounting system consists of the personnel, procedures, technologies and records used by an organization to develop accounting information and to communicate this information to decision makers. Therefore, the basic purpose of accounting system is to meet the organization’s need for information as efficiently as possible (Williams et al, 2006). Accounting information is used by every profit seeking business organizations that uses economic resources and by nonprofit seeking organizations. The accounting system used by profit seeking organization may viewed as an information system designed to provide relevant financial information on the resource of business and the effect of the use of these resources (Fess warren, 1984). There are five basic elements of an accounting system; These are source documents, input devices, information processors, information storage and output devices (Adams University College, 2014). Source documents provide basic information to process by the accounting
  • 10. 10 system. Input devices captures information from source document and enables its accounting system. Transfer to the information-processing component. Information processing is a system that interprets transfers and summarizes information for use in analysis and reporting. Output devices are the mean to take information out of an accounting system and to make it available to users. Generally, for this study purpose, the above elements viewed as an accounting cycle. This study was also focuses on other different major element of accounting system those are internal control and inventory system. Accounting cycle is a complete sequence of accounting procedures, used to record, classify and summarize accounting information in financial reports, that is repeated in the same order during each accounting period( WILLIAMS et al,2006).it includes ● Journalizing transaction ● posting to ledger accounts ● preparing trial balance ● making end of period adjustment ● preparing an adjusted trial balance ● preparing financial statements ● journalizing and posting closing entries and ● preparing an after closing trial balance Management needs assurance that accounting information it receives to be accurate and reliable. This accuracy comes from the company’s system of internal control. This study was also focused on general control activities. Inventors are asset items held for sell in the ordinary course of business or are goods that will be used or consumed in the production of goods to be sold. The description and measure of inventory required careful intention because the investment in inventory is frequently the largest current asset of merchandise and manufacturing business (DONALD KIESO, 1998). Thus in this study the researcher tried to understand and describe the attitude of small enterprise managers towards the application of those major elements of Accounting system.
  • 11. 11 1.2 Statement of the problem Today it is impossible to manage business operation without accurate and up-to-date accounting information. managers and employees, lenders, suppliers and government agencies are rely on the information contained in two financial statement each not more than one page in length. According to JILL HUSSY and ROGER HUSSY (1999), cost and management accounting, all efficiently managed organization needs to keep some form of accounting system. For big organization like limited companies there are legal requirement that must be adhered. For small enterprises, it is important to keep some form of accounting records for taxation and decision making purpose. Previous researches has indicate that small firms are a group of business driven by the attitude and motivation of one person, tends to control all functional areas of the business and accord less time to the accounting and finance function. This is often viewed as unimportant and thus received less attention on the part of the owners (as cited in k padachi, 2012:2). The researcher’s personal observation also witnessed that most of small enterprise managers handle their business traditionally. They do not have any knowledge of accounting/ modern business. All large or small business have to establish accounting system in order to produce financial statements so as to give precise information for personal/ groups in business to satisfy external parties. In addition to this, accounting system provides information to understand better, how business has get profit and help to management or organization to plan for future of the business. To the best of the researcher’s knowledge, no specific researches have undertaken to investigate small enterprise manager’s attitude towards the application of accounting system. Hence, in this study the researcher tried to answer the following research questions. What is the attitude of small business managers towards business event and the accounting treatment? Does the enterprise managers prepare crucial financial statements periodically? What is the attitude of those enterprise managers towards internal control system? What is the attitude of those enterprise managers towards inventory system? What is the attitude of small enterprise managers towards Double entry bookkeeping system? Why managers apply major elements of accounting system?
  • 12. 12 1.3 Objective of the study 1.3.1 General objective The general objective of this study was to evaluate the attitude of small enterprise managers towards the application of major element of accounting system. 1.3.2 Specific objective ★To assess the attitude of small enterprise managers towards business events and its accounting treatment. ★To find out whether the enterprise owners/managers prepare crucial financial statement. ★To assess the attitude of enterprise owners/managers towards establishing internal control system. ★To assess the tendency of small enterprise owners/ managers towards inventory system. ★To assess the attitude of small enterprise owners/managers towards Double entry bookkeeping. ★To identify reasons which hinder owners/managers from applying accounting system. 1.4 Scope of the study This study was very important, if it would conducted over the country wide, but because of the restriction of time and finance, it was intended to conduct in Debre Markos town. Moreover, this study focused on small enterprises; with employees 6-30, and which has a paid up capital for, industrial sector from ETB 100,001 up to ETB 1.5million, and for services sector from ETB 50,001 up to ETB 500,000(ZEMENU et al, 2014) excluding high technological consultancy services and other higher technological establishments. 1.5 Limitations of the study The researcher was face the following limitations ●The time provided for the study was not enough for the researcher to collect all necessary information ●The financial means for the study was insufficient to conduct the study as the price of everything in the market increased. ●The respondents had heavy work and did not provide the information on time. ●Some of the respondents did not understand the objective of the study and think otherwise.  It was very difficult to get the particular location of small enterprise. 1.6 Significance of the study
  • 13. 13 This study has expected to use for the following significance. It provides important information in accounting system as having knowledge of Accounting system in running business is most important solution for the growth of Business. It gives important information on the important accounting system for the profitability of enterprises. It would identify the reasons that hinder small enterprise managers from applying accounting system. It would indicate to the government, the intention of small enterprises managers towards growth. It might help other researchers who want to conduct a research on similar topics or area. 1.7 organization of the paper This study has organized into five chapters, which consist of different categories. The first chapter includes background, statement of the problem, objective of the study, scope of the study, limitation of the study and significance of the study. The second chapter deals with review of related literature. The third chapter is about research methods. The fourth chapter presents the collected data analysis and the last chapter is about the conclusion and recommendation of the study.
  • 14. 14 CHAPTER_ TWO REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE 2.1 INTRODUCTION Small enterprises (SEs) defined in a variety of ways using various factors. Although many countries around the globe seem to use common factors in their definition the degree of emphasis and measures used differ quite considerably. These factors include number of employees, volume of sales and the capital value of the business. In recent times, there has been some degree of convergence in SEs definitions particularly in Europe. The European commission defines SEs using a combination of employee numbers, annual turnovers or balance sheet total and ownership. However, the above convergence does not suggest in any way a common agreement of the specific numbers in terms of these variables. To this end, different governments and writers in small enterprise definition differ considerably. This difference influenced largely by two factors. These are population and stage of a countries economic development and industry within which the SEs is competing (ZEMENU et al, 2014). The definition of small enterprises in the developed world would differ from how SEs is defined in the third world. For example, the accepted definition of small enterprise in USA is “an entity with average annual gross revenue for the preceding three years not to exceed $15 million. The Ethiopian government defines SEs based on the size of the capital and level of automation (MSEs Strategy, 2004). Accordingly small enterprises are those business enterprises with paid up capital of above ETB 20,000 and not exceeding ETB 50,000. In the improved definition of MSEs, Ethiopian ministry of trade and industry and central statistical authority(CSA) defines SEs according to the number of employees and capital as follows( ZEMENU et al, 2014):industry sector with employees 6-30, and capital of ETB 100,001_ETB 1.5 million and service sector with employees 6-30 and capital of ETB 50,001 _ETB 500,000. The government of Ethiopia has recognized the importance of micro and small enterprises development to the overall economic growth of country and poverty alleviation. It has established micro and small enterprise development agency to coordinate and support this sectors. According to proclamation number, 33/1998, the agency shall be involved in designing policies and strategies for the development and expansion of micro and small-scale enterprises. To this end many developing economy have developed and have been providing credit to poor and small business through micro finance schemes. In Ethiopia, several institutions have established and have been operating towards resolving credit access problem of poor particularly those participate in small business activities. Since small enterprises has great role to the economy of a given country, it matter to economy whether they work well or not. However, without support of micro finance institutions small business may not well by them self due to
  • 15. 15 capital constraint. If a given small enterprise works well in addition to help of micro finance, it also assumed that accounting system of the business to be well, which is the subject area of this study. 2.2 NEEDS FOR ACCOUNTING In a business organization, innumerable monetary transactions take place. Accounting keeps a systematic record of such transactions and summarizes them through entries in various accounts. A clear picture of functions of the business emerges from Accounting and it reveals what the business owns, owes, profit and loss (NADHANI, 2000). 2.3 ACCOUNTING SYSTEM The unabridged version of the random house dictionary provides more than a dozen of definition for the term ‘system’. Paraphrasing and merging several of those definitions, a system is a coordinated network of plans and procedures designed to achieve a stated goal in an orderly effective and efficient manner. Not surprisingly, this definition applies very well to the typical accounting system. From this accounting system is a systematic approach to collecting, processing and communicating financial information to decision makers. This consists of the methods and records established to identify, assemble, analyze, classify, record and report on an entity’s transaction and to maintain accountability for the related assets and liabilities. Note that, the later part of this definition indicates that an accounting system has ‘accountability ‘or control feature (KNAPP, 1996). 2 .4 BUSINESS EVENTS (ACCOUNTING TRANSACTIONS) An Accounting (business) event is an economic occurrence that changes an enterprises assets, liabilities or stockholders (owners) equity. A transaction is a particular kind of events that involves transferring something of value between two entities (EDMONDS/OLDS/NCMIR/TSAY, 2010). These can classify into three. These are; 1, Asset source transaction; a transaction that increase the total amount of assets and increase the total amount of claims. 2, Asset exchange transaction; a transaction that decreases one asset and increases another assets. The total amount of asset is unchanged. 3, Asset use transactions; a transaction that decreases the total amount of asset and claims. 2.5 ACCOUNTING CYCLE In a well-designed accounting system, all accounting processes have undertaken in a form of a cycle, known as the accounting cycle. An accounting cycle is a complete sequence of accounting procedure, within an accounting system of an enterprise that repeated in the same order during each accounting period (Fess warren, 1984). It outlines the various accounting processes that undertaken by the accountant to process transaction data through the book of accounts such as journals, cashbooks, ledgers, to summarize and draw up financial statements and reports on the enterprises performance
  • 16. 16 continuously and at year-ends. An accounting cycle for the typical business organization consists of the following key procedures; Record daily transaction data in source documents; this is a piece of paper or document that initiates a transaction and reports its occurrence, example; Invoice, cash receipts etc. Analyses and record day by day and in chronological order the daily source document transaction data in the journal. classify and post the journal transaction data to the ledger. Balance and foot the ledger accounts to ascertain the balance in such accounts. prepare a trial balance to summarize and list balances in the ledger account to test their arithmetical accuracy. Prepare a worksheet as a tool used to short out, update and organize trial balance information needed at the end of the period (it may be optional). Correct, adjust and update the trial balance information in the worksheet to ensure that all the transaction data and other accounting information that ought to be recorded in the accounts have in-fact been recorded and that errors committed in in the processing of accounting information in the source document, the journal ,the ledger and trial balance are corrected. prepare financial statements in the form of income statements, balance sheet, owner’s equity statement and statement of cash flow. The two most widely used are income statement and balance sheet. Income statement is a summary of revenue and expense of business entity for specific period such as month or year. Balance sheet is a list of assets, liabilities and owners equity at a specific date, usually at the close of the last day of the month or year. 2.6 SYSTEM OF BOOKKEEPING 2.6.1 Double entry bookkeeping Double entry bookkeeping is the most efficient and effective method for recording financial transaction in a way which allows the easy preparation of financial statements. In a double entry bookkeeping system every transactions recorded twice. This reflects the dual nature of transactions and provides an arithmetical check. Advantages of double entry bookkeeping ● presents a complete picture of the initiation and occurrence of each transaction. ● It gives operation support for the accounting equation framework that is the total economic resource of the business (its asset) must always be equal to the source of funds which were used to acquire the resources. ● It makes easy to logically follow the movement of funds in the course of trading. ● It gives a double check on each transaction recorded in the accounts as equal debit and credit entries are made for every transaction. ● provides a reliable way for the basic requirements expected from an accounting record.
  • 17. 17 2.6.2 Single entry bookkeeping Single entry system defined as any system, which is not exactly the double entry system. In other words, single entry may consists of ; 1. Double entry in respect of certain transaction such as cash received from debtors, cash paid to creditors etc. 2. Single entry in respect of certain transactions such as cash purchase, cash sales etc. 3. No entry in respect of certain transactions such as depreciation, bad debts etc. Thus, a business said to be using single entry system, if it is not following completely the principle of double entry bookkeeping system (MAHESHWARI, 2005). Disadvantage of single entry system ●Arithmetical accuracy cannot be checked ●True profit cannot be known ●Financial position of the business cannot be judged 2.7 INVENTORY SYSTEM There are two alternative approaches or systems as to the determination of inventory; Those are perpetual and periodic inventory system. Under periodic inventory system, no attempt is made to record the cost of inventories sold until at the end of the period. On the other hand, perpetual inventory system uses accounting record that continuously discloses inventory of each type of commodity at least once a year. The records are then compared with actual quantities on hand, any difference then corrected. 2.7.1 Perpetual inventory system It is also knows as automotive inventory system a methods of recording inventory balance after every receipt and issue to facilitated regular checking and to closing down for stocktaking. The basic objective of this system is to make available details about the quantity and value of stock of each item at all time it provides a rigid control over stock of materials as physical stock can regularly be verified with the stock records kept in the stores and the cost office. The evaluations of inventory and of the cost of good solids are critically importance to managers and external user of financial statements due to the cases that inventory is the company largest current asset and inventory is the company largest current assets and cost of goods sold is its largest expense. These two accounts have significant effect on the financial statement sub totals and ratios used in evaluating the solvency and profitability of business. (HORNGREN et al, 2002) 2.7.2 Periodic inventory system In case of this system the quantity and value of inventory is found out only at the end of the accounting period after having physical verifications of the unit in hand. The system does not provide the information regarding the quantity and value of materials in hand on continuous basis.
  • 18. 18 2.7.3 INVENTORY VALUATION METHOD The price of many kind of merchandises are subject to frequent changes when identical lots of merchandise are purchased at various duties during the year each lot may be acquired at different cost price. There are several assumptions of inventory valuation methods, each assumption made as to the cost of units ending inventory leads to different methods of pricing inventory and to different amounts in financial statement. Those four accepted assumptions are; Specific identification, Average cost, first in first out, and last in first out methods (ROBERT, 2006). First in first out; an inventory valuation (costing) method under which, per unit cost of the most recently acquired goods are used to establish the cost basis of ending inventory. Last in first out; an inventory valuation method under which, per unit cost of the earliest acquired goods are used to establish the cost basis of ending inventory. Specific identification method; an inventory costing method under which actual per unit costs are used to establish the cost of basis of ending inventory. Weighted average method; an inventory costing method under which average per unit costs are computed for goods available for sale during an accounting period, these average per unit costs are then used to establish the cost basis of ending inventory ( KNAPP,2002). 2.8 ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS AND CONTROLS FOR SMALL ENTERPRISES HUSSEIN (as cited in Mbroh and Attom, 2013:31) noted that, a good accounting system is not only judged by how well records are kept but by how well it is able to meet the information need of both internal and external decision makers. In his view, Clute (as cited in Mbroh and Attom, 2013:31) maintained that it is common for qualified accountants to do a good job of keeping records up to date but they fail to provide information needed by decision makers. For a business person, an accounting system should be capable of providing the following. 1. Interim statements, quarterly/six monthly that can provide information about the progress of the business. Such a statement need not be detailed, but capable of addressing the special needs of the business. Such documents can also be circulated, if necessary, among external users such as lenders. 2. Efficiency, cash flow planning is very important for the small business. As cited in Mbroh and Attom, 2013:31) fuller felt that an annual cash flow forecast, reviewed periodically , could indicate over all financial requirements such a statement can be prepared only with help of a well designed accounting system. 3. An accounting system, in addition to provide financial statement, must be capable of generating other useful information in the form of reports. These includes, aged account receivable, aged account payable, stock and bank balance etc. 4. In the case of manufacturing enterprises, cost records are usually useful in estimating costs and determining prices. The accounting system for such enterprises must provide reliable data forecast estimation. 2.8.1 INTERNAL CONTROL SYSTEM Internal control system is designed by the organization for the purpose of; 1) Protecting its resources against waste and frauds. 2) Securing compliance with management policies. 3) Ensuring the accuracy and reliability of accounting and reporting data.
  • 19. 19 The system of internal control includes all policies and procedures that enable an organization to operate in accordance with management plans and policies (EDMOND’s/OLDS, 2010). Internal control focus into two categories; These are Accounting control and administrative controls. Accounting controls are measures that relate directly to the protection of assets or to the reliability of accounting information. Administrative controls are policies designed to increase operational efficiency. They have no direct brought up on reliability of accounting records. However, sound administrative control may have vital role in successful operation of the business (ROBERT, 1990). 2.8.1.1 Internal control concepts and issues An accounting system is one component of an overall control system that business executives use to monitor and control their organization. For small businesses, this control system is quite informal; the principal method a sole proprietor may use to control his/her business is involvement in the day to day operation of the firm. Employees have less opportunity to take unfair advantage of their employer if he/she is working side by side with them.(KNAPP, 2002). 2.9 PRIOR STUDY ON SMALL ENTERPEISES In Nigeria, there have been a large number of empirical studies conducted on small enterprise such as ONAOLAPO and ADEGBITE,(2014). These studies investigate the impact of accounting records on small enterprises. The finding indicates that there is a strong positive relationship between accounting system and performance of small-scale enterprises. Accounting system is essential for decision making which invariably affects performance of small-scale enterprises. Other studies were conducted in various countries to examine the accounting practice of small scale enterprises and its effect on their performance and access to finance for example (MICHAEL and CHIGOZI,2014) in Nigeria,(MBROH and BENEBO,2013) in Ghana,(BRHANE,2014),(TAFA,2011) and ( FETENE, 2010) in Ethiopia. These studies found that there is poor performance in small enterprises accounting practices. Those studies also found that most of the owners and managers of (operators) of SEs do not know the accounting skills required to enhance the economic status of their business. A study conducted in Zimbabwe on 100 SEs by MASEKLO and MANYANI (as cited in Amoako, 2013:76) bring out that SEs do not keep complete records of accounts due to lack of knowledge in accounting and the cost of engaging professional accountants. Consequently, the use of accounting information to support measurements of financial performance by SEs is ineffective. The study proposes that regulatory bodies must develop specific guidelines for SEs accounting and organize training programs for entrepreneurs in small business.
  • 20. 20 As discussed by (OLATUNJI, 2013), small enterprises are gaining widespread acceptance as viable drivers of economic growth. However, several of these enterprises demise without fulfilling expectations due to poor management arising from week accounting structure. It also showed that adoption of sound accounting system enhances performance of small enterprises. In those studies, JOHN and BEN (2012) stated that there are fundamental problems militating against the realization of small enterprises role to the benefit of economies especially in a developing countries. They also stated that the absence of control system has contributed significantly to their exposure to lapses, perceived misappropriation and reported losses with small business segments being the worse affected. In addition, the other researcher KP ADACHI (2012) argued that small enterprises poor performance often ascribed to external factors such as burdensome character of legal framework, limited scope to penetrate the export market and access to finance. However, internal factors such as marketing, operation, and in particular accounting system may be equally responsible to such state of affairs. Moreover, other researcher BRAHNE (2014) in Debre Markos town stated that many of SEs are poor at bookkeeping and did not prepare formal financial statements. In this study the researcher tried to evaluate the attitudes of small enterprise managers towards ,business transaction, and its accounting treatment, internal control systems, inventory systems, double entry bookkeeping and also tried to identify the reasons that hinder them from applying accounting system.
  • 21. 21 CHAPTER THREE RESEARCH METHODS 3.1 RESEARCH DESIGN This descriptive type of research would be followed both qualitative and quantitative data collection approach. The researcher would be used open ended and close-ended questions for qualitative and quantitative approaches respectively. Moreover, the researcher would used questionnaires in order to get detailed information about the attitude of enterprise managers towards the application of elements of accounting system. Structured questionnaires (open ended and closed ended) have been distributed to 46 SE owners/ managers. 3.2 PARTICIPANT OF THE STUD Y The managers or owners of the enterprise were the human participant of the study. 3.3 SAMPLING TECHNIQUES This research is conducted by using stratified simple random sampling techniques because, the target population (participant) of the study is most populous and they manage enterprises engaged in different or heterogeneous business activities such as manufacturing, construction, urban agriculture, service and trade. So as to obtain the most representative sample the researcher used stratified simple random sampling technique by making strata based on their business activity, so that each business group is represented. 3.4 SAMPLE SIZE From the total population of ‘82’ registered small enterprise(DMT MSEs development agency,2004), the researcher used a sample size of ‘46’ enterprise managers or owners, based on YAMANE (1996) sample size determination formula at 90% level of confidence and 0.1 precision levels. n= N/ (1+N(e)2) Where; n= sample size N =total population e= sampling error/precision level (1-level of Confidence) Among those sampled enterprises 23 were from manufacturing, 5 were from construction, 13 were from service, 2 were from urban agriculture and 3 were from trade based on their proportion.
  • 22. 22 3.5 DATA TYPE AND SOURCE The most important data used for this study was primary data that collected from managers or owners of the enterprises. There is no secondary data, used to measure the attitudes. 3.6 DATA COLLECTION TECHNIQUES Those data used for this study was collected by using primary data collection techniques that was questionnaires (both open ended and close ended). 3.7 DATA PROCESSING, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION After the collection of available data, from small enterprise managers about their attitude towards the application of major element of accounting system, the data was processed. In processing the data, filled and completed questionnaires has been carefully checked to assure that the data is accurate and to arrange to facilitate the tabulation systems. Since, this research type is simply descriptive, the data have been analyzed by simple statistical tools (using tabulation) that is in the form of tables, frequency and percentages and finally with statements.
  • 23. 23 CHAPTER_ FOUR DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION This data analysis and interpretation is made based on the questionnaires distributed to the small enterprise owners or managers of Debre Markos town. Total of ‘46’ questionnaires were distributed to ‘46’ SE owners or managers of which, ‘43’ questionnaires (93.47% response rate) were collected. The remaining ‘3’ questionnaires have not been collected due to the lack of cooperation of the respondents and carelessly filling the questionnaires. Therefore this data analysis and interpretation is made by ‘43’ respondents questionnaire. Table1: Respondent’s background Description Response Frequency percentage Gender Male 34 79.07% Female 9 20.93% Educational level Certificate and below 30 69.76% Diploma 9 20.93% Degree 4 9.4% Above Degree 0 0% Work experience Below 1 year 5 11.62% 1-2 years 8 18.61% 3-5 years 20 46.51% Above 5 years 10 23.26% Position in the enterprise Only manager 7 16.27% Owner and manager 36 83.73% Source: questionnaire, 2015 Education is critical in understanding the dynamics and challenges of business encounter. It is expected that if an SE operators has a reasonable educational background, it will undoubtedly enable to directly or indirectly implement the necessary elements of accounting system in his/her business (Mbroh, 2013). The results in the above table indicates that about 69.78% (30) of the SE owners/managers had attained primary, secondary or college education followed by those attained diploma(20.93%). A few enterprise owners/managers (9.4%) attained degree. A gender has also a great implication in this understanding because of its impact on the educational background. The results show that, about 79.07% (34) of the SE owners/managers are males and 20.93% (9) are females. The going concern concept of accounting assumes that businesses are to exist in perpetuity. To attain the going concern however, businesses are expected to survive all business trials in their operations since there are often many challenges in the running of a business regardless of the size and type of industry. Like individuals business events gain experience in various aspect of their operations with time. In view of this it is expected that, the longer business unit operates, the better positioned it is to account and implement controls in their business (MBROH, 2013). Results in table-1 show that, majority (about 46.51%) of the studied SE operators have been in their business between 3 to 5 years followed by those in business over 5 years (about 23.26%). Few businesses (11.62%) had been established in the past year. The closeness of family involvement is expected to influence the extent of accounting tasks. Where firms run by more non family members (only managers) tend to keep formal accounts. In the opposite fashion, firms run by more closely family members (owners) do not see the need to keep formal accounting systems (K PADACHI, 2012). Table 1 shows that most of (about 83.73%) the SE
  • 24. 24 operators are owners and only 16.27 % (7) of the operators are managers (non family members). This implies that most of the small enterprises are managed by owners (family members). Table 2: preparation of financial statements statement response frequency percentage Do you prepare financial statement for your enterprise? Yes 16 37.21% No 27 62.79% total 43 100% Source: questionnaire, 2015 After taking some general information from the respondents, the main questioned was posed “Do you prepare a crucial financial statement for your enterprise?” This question sought to categories the respondents. Those respond ‘yes’ were continue to answer other questions whilst those who answered ‘no’ were asked to give reasons why he/she prepare financial statement. Out of the 43, 37.21% (16) respondents answered “Yes”. The yes meant that per their Owen understanding of the financial statements they are in place. The 27 (62.79%) were answered “no”. Table 3: Reasons for not preparing financial statements Response frequency percentage It is not important for small business 5 18.52% Lack of skilled labor 12 44.44% It is not obligated by the government 1 3.70% It haven’t benefit for success unlike production 9 33.34% total 27 100% Source: questionnaire, 2015 The above table shows that among the respondents who answered ‘no’ in table two, 44.44% says lack of skilled labor is the main reason for not preparing financial statements. In addition to this 33.34% of the respondent owners/managers who did not prepare financial statement, thinks as it haven’t benefit for success unlike production. This implies that there is lack of educated manpower and lack of understanding the use of financial statements. Jointly the above two tables implies that most of the respondents did not prepare financial statements since they have not skilled labor and good understanding on the benefit of financial statements. Table 4: attitude of owners/managers towards internal control system statement response frequency percentage Does your enterprise have the designed control system? Yes 29 67.44% No 14 32.56% total 43 100% Do you plan to use internal control system for your business? Yes 33 76.74% No 10 23.26% total 43 100% Internal control in small business enables the control of cash, purchase and different disbursements. Strongly agree 19 44.19% agree 22 51.16% neutral 0 0% disagree 2 4.65% Strongly disagree 0 0%
  • 25. 25 total 43 100% Source: questionnaire, 2015 Regarding control procedures for small enterprise Sathyamoorthi (as cited in MBROH, 2013:31) observed that it is important to have a system of control over all business activity as a well- designed and properly implemented control system can ensure; protection of resources against waste and fraud, accuracy and reliability in accounting data, and success in the evaluation of the performance of the business. Any business regardless of its type and size should have a designed internal control system to achieve its objective (plan). Table 4 of this paper indicates that 67.44% of the respondents had understanding of internal control and are already in use in their business and 32.56% of the respondents had not understanding of internal control. The second statement also shows that 76.74% of the respondents have a plan to use internal control in their business, and only 23.26% of them have not a plan to use it. Thirdly, Most of the respondents (about 44.14%) also strongly agree on the third statement and about 51.16% of the respondents agree on that statement. This implies that most of small enterprise owners/managers have a positive (good) attitude towards internal control. Table 5: Business transaction and its accounting treatment Statement response frequency percentage Do you record all transactions timely? Yes 9 20.93% NO 15 34.88% mezzanine 19 41.19% total 43 100% If your answer is mezzanine what type of business transaction is recorded Asset change 2 10.53% Asset use 9 47.39% Asset source 8 42.10% total 19 100% Recording all business events (transaction) of small business is tedious and less fruit full. Strongly disagree 13 30.24% Disagree 11 25.26% Neutral 3 6.98% Agree 14 32.56% Strongly agree 2 4.66% total 43 100% Source: questionnaire, 2015 Okoli (2011) in his study argues that in order to enhance the profitability of small enterprises and their continuity, there is a need for adequate recording all business transaction, which will help the operators to keep track of the performance of these enterprises. Bulter (2009) also show that without accurate and complete records of business transactions, the business doomed to fail at its on set. Table 5 of this study in the above shows that only 20.93% of the respondents record all business transactions on a timely basis and 34.88% of them do not record all business transactions. 41.19% of the respondents are mezzanine in the statement. About 47.39% of the respondents, who answer mezzanine, records asset use transactions followed by asset source transactions. Moreover, most of the respondents (about 55.5%) disagree on the third statement. This implies that, even though they do not apply, most of the owners/managers have a positive tendency towards business transactions. Table 6: system of recording business transaction Statement Response Frequency Percentage Through what system Double entry 7 6.27%
  • 26. 26 you record business events? Single entry 2 4.65% Neutral 34 79.08% total 43 100% If your answer is neutral what system do you think important for your enterprise? Double entry 13 38.24% Single entry 21 61.76% I don’t know 0 0% total 34 100% Source: questionnaire, 2015 OGUNLADE and BAUMBACK (1983) and OSUALAL (1993) noted that most of small scale enterprises make use of single entry system of accounting. The reason behind the use of single entry system of accounting is probably due to its simplicity and low level of accounting education of operators. In table 6, the results show that most of the respondents (about 61.76%) think as single entry system is important for their enterprise. The results partly agreed with the above arguers. It implies that most of small owners/managers have a tendency to apply single entry system and have not positive attitude towards double entry system of accounting (bookkeeping). Table 7: Attitude towards inventory system statements Strongly agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly disagree total Inventory system is important for one enterprise. 22 10 6 5 0 43 51.16% 23.26% 13.95% 11.63% 0% 100% Adequate inventory system is important for a complete accounting system and performance planning 17 17 6 1 2 43 39.53% 39.53% 13.95% 2.33% 4.65% 100% a Statement Response Frequency Percentage If your answer is agree or strongly agree, what system you think important? Perpetual 27 81.57% Periodic 7 18.43% total 34 100% What method of inventory valuation you think important? FIFO 10 23.26% LIFO 2 4.63% Average 20 46.52% Specific identification 0 0% Neither of them 11 25.59% total 43 100% B Source: questionnaire, 2015 In table 7a, the results show that, most of the respondents, 51.16% strongly agree and 23.26% agree on the first statement. 13.95% 0f the respondents were neutral and 11.63% disagree on that statement. In the second statement 34 respondents (about 79.06%) agreed, 6 respondents (13.92%) are neutral, 1(2.33%) disagreed and 2 (4.66%) are strongly disagreed. This implies that most (more than half) of the enterprise owners/managers have a positive tendency towards inventory system. To strengthen this idea, in table 7b, results show that about 81.57% of the respondents believe as perpetual inventory system is important for their enterprise. In the second
  • 27. 27 statement 20 respondents (about 46.52%) believed that average inventory valuation method is important for their business. Table 8: Accounting system Statement Strongly agree agree neutral disagree Strongly disagree total Accounting system is vital to small business 18 20 2 3 0 43 41.86% 46.51% 4.66% 6.98% 0% 100% All business ,including small business require accounting 13 10 4 9 7 43 30.24% 23.26% 9.3% 20.93% 16.27% 100% I would appreciate if given opportunity to learn about accounting. 22 20 0 1 0 43 51.16% 46.51% 0% 2.33% 0% 100% Source: questionnaire, 2015 Penen and Grant noted that decision making processes in small scale enterprises are more sophisticated than anticipated, but they lacked effective accounting information and control systems to support their decision. Furthermore, International Federation of Accountants also suggest that small firms are aware the importance of accounting system (as cited in Amoako, 2013:75). The result of table 8 in the above indicates that most of the respondents (about 46.51%) agreed on the first statement followed by 41.86% strongly agree. On the second and third statements also most of the respondents (30.24% and 51.16% respectively) strongly agreed followed by 23.26% and 46.51% agree respectively. This result supports the argument of International Federation of Accountants. This implies that most of small enterprise owners/managers have a positive tendency towards the important of accounting system. Table 9: owners/managers filling by not applying accounting system Statement Response Frequency Percentage Do you think that your business can save some money by not applying accounting system Yes 25 58.14% No 18 41.86% total 43 100% Source: questionnaire, 2015. In a related study John and Ben (2013) and International federation of accountants (as cited in Amoako, 2013:75) found that small firms are aware the important of accounting system. In spite of this aware most SEOs lack basic working knowledge in accounting to keen the use of standard accounting system to run the day-to-day activity of their enterprise. The above table result shows that 58.14% of the respondents think as they can save some money by not applying accounting system. Only 18 (41.86%) respondents said no on the statement. This implies that most of the small enterprise owners/managers believed, as the application of accounting system is costly in addition to the lack of skilled labor they face. When we come to the analysis of the data that obtained from open ended questions they does not blamed their filer to hold a record towards tax. In opposite fashion, as most of the respondents’ response they believe as the tax system become fair if they have financial statement. Moreover they also responded as they will not embezzle by tax assessors. Most of them also responded for the question “ why government advises you as you have accounting system ” ? As the government makes it for their own purpose but some of them (small in amount) believes as the
  • 28. 28 government do it for its own tax collection system. From this it is possible to conclude as most of the respondents know the advantage of accounting system and as they do not attach to the tax increasment problem. For the other open end question, what is the importance of accounting system? , most of them responded as it has the following importance: The first advantage that they give is to issue financial statements that used for out said parties especially for lenders. With regard to this they also explain as they cannot gat loan if they have not some tangible property without exception. With regard to the last question most of them responds as they have not accurate knowledge to decide about the elements of accounting system which must be implemented by their business. In support of this most of them said we have not any knowledge for this, we only apply what the government said to us and what our experienced friends advises us. From this the researcher concludes as they have positive attitude towards the application of accounting system.
  • 29. 29 CHAPTER- FIVE SUMMARE, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION Summary of the finding  Majority of the small enterprise owners/managers (about46.51%) had been in business between 3 to 5 years. 11.66% had been began in the past year. A majority of (69.78%) had up to certificate and below certificate education. 9.4% had degree level education.  62.79% of the respondents do not prepared financial statements for their enterprise. Among those who did not prepare financial statement 44.44% blamed to lack of skilled labor. 33.34% thinks as it have not benefit for success unlike production. 3.7% reasoned as it is not obli gated by the government.  Among the respondents 67.44%s have a designed internal control system that they think important for their business. 76.74% plans to use internal control system in their enterprise. 51.16% agreed on the role of internal control in small enterprise. 44.19% strongly agreed and 4.65% disagreed.  Most of SMEOS (34.88%) does not record business transaction on a timely basis. 47.39% of them record only asset use transaction and 42.10% record asset source transactions.32.56% agreed on the tediousness and fruitless of recording all business transactions of small enterprises. 30.24% and 25.26% of the respondents strongly disagree and agree on the statement respectively.  61.76% of the respondents think as single entry system of bookkeeping is important for their enterprise.  From the total respondents 51.16% strongly agree on the important of inventory system for one enterprise. 81.57% thinks as perpetual inventory system is important for their enterprise and 46.52% of them inclined to use average inventory valuation method.  Among the respondents 46.51% agreed on the vital of accounting system to small business. 30.24% strongly agreed on the importance of accounting for all business and 51.16% are willing to learn more about accounting if given opportunity. 2.33% disagreed.  58.14% of the respondents think as their business can save money by not applying accounting system. CONCLUSION
  • 30. 30  The study revealed that SMEOs do not prepare crucial financial statements for their enterprise because of the lack of accounting knowledge (skilled labor) and due to lack of understanding the ultimate importance of financial statements. As result there is inefficient use of accounting information to support the financial performance measurement by small enterprises.  More over based on the finding the researcher concludes that, Even though they do not prepare financial statements and do not record business transactions timely because of lack of skill (skilled labor) in accounting and worry on the cost of hiring accountants, they have the positive attitude to apply elements of accounting system when the above constraints solved. This study ignores the idea proposed in K padachi (2012:3).  The study further revealed that the owners/managers of SEs were highly willing to learn more about how to keep accurate records of their business transactions. The finding of the study showed that the owners/managers of SEs had a positive attitude towards internal control, inventory system and business transaction. In addition to this, this study concludes that except deferent restriction small enterprise managers believe as accounting system is important for one enterprise including theirs.  Additionally, the finding showed that SEOs, because of the simplicity of single entry bookkeeping, are more inclined to adopt single entry system of bookkeeping.  Finally, it revealed that the failure of not applying accounting system was highly blamed by small enterprise owners/managers to lack of skilled labor and cost of hiring professional accountants and in some extent to the size of the enterprises.
  • 31. 31 RECOMMENDATION After a detailed investigations made on the attitude of small enterprise owners/managers towards the application of accounting system the researcher would like to forward the following recommendation.  It is recommended that the ministry responsible for SEs development should initiate, in more strengthen way, record keeping training program for entrepreneurs running small business.  Bookkeeping in SEs should be made mandatory to change their tendency in to practice and to improve their accounting practice to enhance financial and economic decision making for business growth.  Since there is international acceptance that SEs requires simplified financial reporting standard fitting their reduced size and narrow stockholders base, the government needs to adopt simplified accounting standard sets for SEs.  Debre markos university, specially accounting department like that of law school, should establish a free community services in bookkeeping support institute to facilitate small enterprise owners to apply accounting system in their enterprise.
  • 32. 32 REFERANCES Admas University College (2014) principle of accounting, teaching material, unpublished. Amoako .G.K (2013) accounting practice of SMEs; a case study of Kumesi Metropolies in GANA, International journal of business and management,vol.8,No.24, published by Canadian center of science and education. Brhane Tadesse (2014), access to finance for Micro and Small enterprise in Debre Markos town Ethiopia, Global journal of current research, vol.2, No.2; pp.36-46. Donald E.kieso and jerry j.Weygandt (1998), intermediate accounting, 9th edition. Edmonds/olds/mcnair/tsay(2010), survey of accounting,2nd edition. Fess warren (1984), principle of accounting, 16th edition. Fetene zeru (2010), access to finance and its challenge for small enterprises: in case of Addis Abeba city, unpublished Jane, Williams et al (2006), Accounting for decision making and control. Mbroh J.K and Attom B.E (2013) Accounting and control system practiced by small and micro enterprise owners within the cape coast metropolital area of Ghana, Asian journal of business and management sciences, vol.1 No.1; pp. 28-47. Okoli B.E (2011) Evaluation of the accounting system used by small scale enterprise in Nigeria: the case of Enugu- south east Nigeria, Asian journal of business management, vol.3, No.4; pp.235-240. Olatunji T.E (2013) The impact of accounting system on the performance of small and medium scale enterprises in Nigeria: a survey of SMEs in oyo state- Nigeria, International journal of business and management invention, vol.2;pp 13-17. Padachji k (2013) factors affecting the adoption of Formal Accounting system by SMEs, Business and Economics journal, vol. 2012, BEJ 67. Robert F, meigs and Walter B(1990),accounting the base for business decision,8th
  • 33. 33 edition. Robert, Anthony, James Reece (2006), accounting principle, 6th edition. Tafa (2011) Accounting practice of small and medium sized enterprises and its effect on access to finance in addise abebe; unpublished. Zemenu A and Mohamed M (2014) determinant of growth of micro and small enterprises in Ethiopia: a case of Mse in mekelle city, tigry, international journal of Advance research in computer since and studies, vol2; pp149- 157. Debre markos town administration micro and small enterprises agency total summary data slip, code 004. website http:/ www.gov.et/ micro and small enterprise development agency. http:/ www.memoireonline.com/accounting system in small enterprise.
  • 34. 34 APPENDIX DEBRE MARKOS UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF BUSINESS AND ECONOMICS DEPARTMENT OF ACCOUNTING AND FINANCE Deer respondent, I am the student of Debre Markos university college of Business and Economics, department of Accounting and Finance. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the attitude of small enterprise managers towards the application of major element of accounting system, so this study needs to gather information to achieve its objective. So your response is very crucial and hence you are kindly requested to respond genuinely. The researcher wants to assure you that it will be used only for academic purpose and to be kept confidential. Please do not write your name anywhere on the questionnaire . I appreciate your cooperation in this study . If you have any question please call, 0928579011 or 0948707012 Thanks in advance!!! Respondent background 1, Gender Male female 2, work experience <1 year 1-2 Years 3 -5 Years >5 years 3, level of education Below certificate and certificate degree Master other…………………………………………………. 4, position in your enterprise Only manager Managers and owners 5, Do you prepare a crucial financial statement for your enterprise? Yes no 6, If your answer for question number 6 is no why? It is not important for small business Lack of skilled labor others---------------- It is not obligated by government It have not benefit for success unlike production 7, Does your enterprise have the designed internal control system? Yes No 8, If your answer for question number 8 is no why? It is not as much important It is costly to apple
  • 35. 35 The employees of our business is family members the size of the business is small others specify------------------------------------------------- 9, DO you plan to use internal control system for your business? Yes No 10, Does your enterprise record all transactions timely? Yes No Mezzanine 11, If your answer is mezzanine, what type of business transaction (business event) is (shall) Recorded? Asset source Asset use Asset exchange 12, If your answer for question number 11 is yes through what system your enterprise record business events? Double entry neutral Single entry neutral 13, If your answer for question No’12’ is neutral, what system do you think important for your enterprise? Double entry others specify --------------------------------- Single entry 14, inventory system is important for one enterprise. Strongly agree Neutral strongly disagree Agree disagree 15, If your answer for question No ‘14 is agree or strongly agree what system is you think important? Perpetual Periodic 16,What method of inventory valuation you are applying or needs to apply? FIFO LIFO AVERGE Specific identification neither of them 17, accounting system is vital to my business. strongly agree neutral agree disagree strongly disagree 18, all business, including, small business require accounting Strongly agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly disagree 19, recording all business events (transactions) of small business is tedious and less fruitful. Strongly agree Agree neutral
  • 36. 36 Disagree Strongly disagree 20, I would appreciate if given opportunity to learn about accounting Strongly agree Disagree Agree Strongly disagree Neutral 21, do you think that your business can save some money by not applying accounting system. Yes No 22, adequate inventory system is important for complete accounting system and for performance planning Strongly agree neutral Agree Disagree strongly disagree 23, Internal control in small business enables the control of cash, purchase and different disbursement Strongly agree Disagree Agree Strongly disagree Neutral 24, what do you think about the importance of accounting?---------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- 25, why government advises as you shall have accounting system? ------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------- 26, do you believe that financial statement increases the amount of tax-------------------------------- ---------------------------------------- 27, What is your overall opinion about the element of accounting system that shall be applied by small enterprises? ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------
  • 37. 37