SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 13
TONY TRAVERS
DIRECTOR
GREATER LONDON GROUP LSE
                    ,
Regeneration and capital
development in a cold climate


   Tony Travers
   London School of Economics
The policy environment
  Abolition of RDAs, GROs, etc
      inc LDA
  Move from ‘grants’ to ‘incentives’
  ‘Big Society’ and ‘localism’
         Shift of power downwards and to
          neighbourhoods
  Greater SE councils faced with many
   radical changes, esp budget cuts
  Olympics: a help and/or a distraction?
Last year’s Budget
    ‘Budget for Growth’
    Expression of Coalition economic policy
    Little, if any, new public expenditure
    Possibility of new incentives
    London/GSE not a key priority?
              Better starting point
              Recession less bad
              Strong private sector – across Greater SE
              Subsequent evidence suggests GSE growing
               relatively faster than rest of UK
Incentives and financial
mechanisms
  Enterprise Zones
  Local Enterprise Partnerships/
   Regional Growth Fund
  Tax Increment Financing
  Reform of local government finance
        ‘resource review’
  Business Rate Supplement, Business
   Improvement Districts, Community
   Infrastructure Levy etc
Enterprise Zones
  New EZ for Royal Docks
  Back to the Future?
  Isle of Dogs experience
        Dynamic?
        Inefficient?
        But certainly an element in Docklands’ success

  More may follow
        Which areas to be chosen? By councils?
        LEPs keep additional local tax revenue
LEPs and RGF
  LEPs are the government’s new
   approach to the promotion of
   enterprise
        Business-local government partnerships
        ‘Organic’
        To foster an “environment for business and
         growth”
        To bid for resources from RGF
        Significant excess of demand over RGF supply
        Still in formative stage
Tax Increment Finance
  Around for a number of years
  Last week’s LG resource review terms of
   reference stated the review should
   consider: “how to deliver Tax Increment
   Financing proposals against a context of
   greater retention of business rate
   revenues”
  Attempt to fund projects to allow a project
   to go ahead with the expected increased
   local tax payments resulting from the
   development
         Development to be ‘conditional’ on the TIF scheme
Local government ‘resource review’
  ‘Resource’ review now under way
         TORs published in spring 2011
  Business rate retention
  New Homes Bonus
  Together, these reforms = ‘self-
   sufficiency’ for some councils
         Incentives to deliver tax base growth
  Need for ‘pool’ for equalisation
  Tax competition….
Other, related, policies
  Business Rate Supplement
        Crossrail funding
        Could be extended?

  Business Improvement Districts
        Successful over a number of years
        Could be extended to sectors or areas?

  Community Infrastructure Levy
        Levy on developments to pay for infrastructure
        Many parts of London/GSE likely to produce a
         better yield than elsewhere
London and the GSE– maximising
the resources available
  There are opportunities for London and its
   region in all of this…
  but, the new world of incentives and tax-
   base growth will be different from one of
   grants etc
  Need to bring forward schemes and make
   their impacts clear to national, city-wide
   and local politicians
  Land values relatively powerful and growth
   potential strong in London/much of GSE
         a good start…
What will be needed…
  Further strengthening of relationship
   between councils, developers and
   communities
       NB Localism Bill and planning
  Realism in the extent to which major
   developments can be ‘taxed’
       Different from the ‘years of plenty’
  Public-private joint ventures?
       Certainly contributions from both
       Consistency of approach
Regeneration and capital
development in a cold climate


   Tony Travers
   London School of Economics

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

CREATIVE PPP DEVELOPMENT - A NEW PARTNERSHIP: Richard Upton, CEO of Cathedral...
CREATIVE PPP DEVELOPMENT - A NEW PARTNERSHIP: Richard Upton, CEO of Cathedral...CREATIVE PPP DEVELOPMENT - A NEW PARTNERSHIP: Richard Upton, CEO of Cathedral...
CREATIVE PPP DEVELOPMENT - A NEW PARTNERSHIP: Richard Upton, CEO of Cathedral...Cathedral Group Plc
 
THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY - EMERGING MODELS OF DELIVERING REGENERATION: ...
THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY - EMERGING MODELS OF DELIVERING REGENERATION: ...THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY - EMERGING MODELS OF DELIVERING REGENERATION: ...
THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY - EMERGING MODELS OF DELIVERING REGENERATION: ...Cathedral Group Plc
 
CASE STUDY - THE NEW WOOLWICH CENTRE: John Comber, LB Greenwich
CASE STUDY - THE NEW WOOLWICH CENTRE: John Comber, LB GreenwichCASE STUDY - THE NEW WOOLWICH CENTRE: John Comber, LB Greenwich
CASE STUDY - THE NEW WOOLWICH CENTRE: John Comber, LB GreenwichCathedral Group Plc
 
FUNDING PPP PROJECTS IN THE CURRENT CLIMATE: Amelia Henning, Royal Bank of Ca...
FUNDING PPP PROJECTS IN THE CURRENT CLIMATE: Amelia Henning, Royal Bank of Ca...FUNDING PPP PROJECTS IN THE CURRENT CLIMATE: Amelia Henning, Royal Bank of Ca...
FUNDING PPP PROJECTS IN THE CURRENT CLIMATE: Amelia Henning, Royal Bank of Ca...Cathedral Group Plc
 
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving Cars
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving CarsStudy: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving Cars
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving CarsLinkedIn
 
Hype vs. Reality: The AI Explainer
Hype vs. Reality: The AI ExplainerHype vs. Reality: The AI Explainer
Hype vs. Reality: The AI ExplainerLuminary Labs
 

Viewers also liked (6)

CREATIVE PPP DEVELOPMENT - A NEW PARTNERSHIP: Richard Upton, CEO of Cathedral...
CREATIVE PPP DEVELOPMENT - A NEW PARTNERSHIP: Richard Upton, CEO of Cathedral...CREATIVE PPP DEVELOPMENT - A NEW PARTNERSHIP: Richard Upton, CEO of Cathedral...
CREATIVE PPP DEVELOPMENT - A NEW PARTNERSHIP: Richard Upton, CEO of Cathedral...
 
THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY - EMERGING MODELS OF DELIVERING REGENERATION: ...
THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY - EMERGING MODELS OF DELIVERING REGENERATION: ...THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY - EMERGING MODELS OF DELIVERING REGENERATION: ...
THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY - EMERGING MODELS OF DELIVERING REGENERATION: ...
 
CASE STUDY - THE NEW WOOLWICH CENTRE: John Comber, LB Greenwich
CASE STUDY - THE NEW WOOLWICH CENTRE: John Comber, LB GreenwichCASE STUDY - THE NEW WOOLWICH CENTRE: John Comber, LB Greenwich
CASE STUDY - THE NEW WOOLWICH CENTRE: John Comber, LB Greenwich
 
FUNDING PPP PROJECTS IN THE CURRENT CLIMATE: Amelia Henning, Royal Bank of Ca...
FUNDING PPP PROJECTS IN THE CURRENT CLIMATE: Amelia Henning, Royal Bank of Ca...FUNDING PPP PROJECTS IN THE CURRENT CLIMATE: Amelia Henning, Royal Bank of Ca...
FUNDING PPP PROJECTS IN THE CURRENT CLIMATE: Amelia Henning, Royal Bank of Ca...
 
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving Cars
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving CarsStudy: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving Cars
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving Cars
 
Hype vs. Reality: The AI Explainer
Hype vs. Reality: The AI ExplainerHype vs. Reality: The AI Explainer
Hype vs. Reality: The AI Explainer
 

Similar to Regeneration and Development Incentives in London

Thursday 30 June, F11 - LEPs opportunities and challenges, Birmingham City Co...
Thursday 30 June, F11 - LEPs opportunities and challenges, Birmingham City Co...Thursday 30 June, F11 - LEPs opportunities and challenges, Birmingham City Co...
Thursday 30 June, F11 - LEPs opportunities and challenges, Birmingham City Co...lgconf11
 
Fringe birmingham lep
Fringe   birmingham lepFringe   birmingham lep
Fringe birmingham leplgconf11
 
Board generic presentation
Board generic presentationBoard generic presentation
Board generic presentationPhilip Locke
 
Localis Facing the future
Localis Facing the futureLocalis Facing the future
Localis Facing the futureBarry Maginn
 
Dawn Zimmer Tax Revolt Response
Dawn Zimmer Tax Revolt ResponseDawn Zimmer Tax Revolt Response
Dawn Zimmer Tax Revolt ResponseHoboken Resistance
 
LEPs to Date and the Importance of the Evidence Base - Andrew Field (BIS)
LEPs to Date and the Importance of the Evidence Base - Andrew Field (BIS)LEPs to Date and the Importance of the Evidence Base - Andrew Field (BIS)
LEPs to Date and the Importance of the Evidence Base - Andrew Field (BIS)South West Observatory
 
Reform of the local state and new learning needs
Reform of the local state and new learning needsReform of the local state and new learning needs
Reform of the local state and new learning needs30088
 
2008 a framework for regeneration more questions than answers - pugalis
2008 a framework for regeneration more questions than answers - pugalis2008 a framework for regeneration more questions than answers - pugalis
2008 a framework for regeneration more questions than answers - pugalisLee Pugalis
 
The Importance Of Being Earners
The Importance Of Being EarnersThe Importance Of Being Earners
The Importance Of Being EarnersKarl Wilding
 
Ros Dunn & John Williams - Localism Seminar
Ros Dunn & John Williams - Localism Seminar Ros Dunn & John Williams - Localism Seminar
Ros Dunn & John Williams - Localism Seminar TGLP
 
Commissioning-and-Procurement-final-web
Commissioning-and-Procurement-final-webCommissioning-and-Procurement-final-web
Commissioning-and-Procurement-final-webKen Cole
 
Commissioning-and-Procurement-final-web
Commissioning-and-Procurement-final-webCommissioning-and-Procurement-final-web
Commissioning-and-Procurement-final-webKen Cole
 
Keep calm and carry on - presentation for High Peak CVS
Keep calm and carry on - presentation for High Peak CVSKeep calm and carry on - presentation for High Peak CVS
Keep calm and carry on - presentation for High Peak CVStonyosailing
 
Rail Conference January 9 2009 Tax Plan
Rail Conference January 9 2009   Tax PlanRail Conference January 9 2009   Tax Plan
Rail Conference January 9 2009 Tax PlanPaige Rasid
 
The role of Government in the Social Economy
The role of Government in the Social EconomyThe role of Government in the Social Economy
The role of Government in the Social EconomyOECD CFE
 
Solace_Local_Roots_to_Growth
Solace_Local_Roots_to_GrowthSolace_Local_Roots_to_Growth
Solace_Local_Roots_to_GrowthHenry Hall
 

Similar to Regeneration and Development Incentives in London (20)

Thursday 30 June, F11 - LEPs opportunities and challenges, Birmingham City Co...
Thursday 30 June, F11 - LEPs opportunities and challenges, Birmingham City Co...Thursday 30 June, F11 - LEPs opportunities and challenges, Birmingham City Co...
Thursday 30 June, F11 - LEPs opportunities and challenges, Birmingham City Co...
 
Fringe birmingham lep
Fringe   birmingham lepFringe   birmingham lep
Fringe birmingham lep
 
Board generic presentation
Board generic presentationBoard generic presentation
Board generic presentation
 
07.12.11 utrecht
07.12.11 utrecht07.12.11 utrecht
07.12.11 utrecht
 
Localis Facing the future
Localis Facing the futureLocalis Facing the future
Localis Facing the future
 
Dawn Zimmer Tax Revolt Response
Dawn Zimmer Tax Revolt ResponseDawn Zimmer Tax Revolt Response
Dawn Zimmer Tax Revolt Response
 
Day1 sess1&2
Day1 sess1&2Day1 sess1&2
Day1 sess1&2
 
LEPs to Date and the Importance of the Evidence Base - Andrew Field (BIS)
LEPs to Date and the Importance of the Evidence Base - Andrew Field (BIS)LEPs to Date and the Importance of the Evidence Base - Andrew Field (BIS)
LEPs to Date and the Importance of the Evidence Base - Andrew Field (BIS)
 
Reform of the local state and new learning needs
Reform of the local state and new learning needsReform of the local state and new learning needs
Reform of the local state and new learning needs
 
2008 a framework for regeneration more questions than answers - pugalis
2008 a framework for regeneration more questions than answers - pugalis2008 a framework for regeneration more questions than answers - pugalis
2008 a framework for regeneration more questions than answers - pugalis
 
Opportunity zones webinar
Opportunity zones webinarOpportunity zones webinar
Opportunity zones webinar
 
The Importance Of Being Earners
The Importance Of Being EarnersThe Importance Of Being Earners
The Importance Of Being Earners
 
Ros Dunn & John Williams - Localism Seminar
Ros Dunn & John Williams - Localism Seminar Ros Dunn & John Williams - Localism Seminar
Ros Dunn & John Williams - Localism Seminar
 
Commissioning-and-Procurement-final-web
Commissioning-and-Procurement-final-webCommissioning-and-Procurement-final-web
Commissioning-and-Procurement-final-web
 
Commissioning-and-Procurement-final-web
Commissioning-and-Procurement-final-webCommissioning-and-Procurement-final-web
Commissioning-and-Procurement-final-web
 
Keep calm and carry on - presentation for High Peak CVS
Keep calm and carry on - presentation for High Peak CVSKeep calm and carry on - presentation for High Peak CVS
Keep calm and carry on - presentation for High Peak CVS
 
Chapel Hill Town Manager Roger Stancil's Presentation on the Budget
Chapel Hill Town Manager Roger Stancil's Presentation on the BudgetChapel Hill Town Manager Roger Stancil's Presentation on the Budget
Chapel Hill Town Manager Roger Stancil's Presentation on the Budget
 
Rail Conference January 9 2009 Tax Plan
Rail Conference January 9 2009   Tax PlanRail Conference January 9 2009   Tax Plan
Rail Conference January 9 2009 Tax Plan
 
The role of Government in the Social Economy
The role of Government in the Social EconomyThe role of Government in the Social Economy
The role of Government in the Social Economy
 
Solace_Local_Roots_to_Growth
Solace_Local_Roots_to_GrowthSolace_Local_Roots_to_Growth
Solace_Local_Roots_to_Growth
 

Regeneration and Development Incentives in London

  • 2. Regeneration and capital development in a cold climate Tony Travers London School of Economics
  • 3. The policy environment   Abolition of RDAs, GROs, etc   inc LDA   Move from ‘grants’ to ‘incentives’   ‘Big Society’ and ‘localism’   Shift of power downwards and to neighbourhoods   Greater SE councils faced with many radical changes, esp budget cuts   Olympics: a help and/or a distraction?
  • 4. Last year’s Budget   ‘Budget for Growth’   Expression of Coalition economic policy   Little, if any, new public expenditure   Possibility of new incentives   London/GSE not a key priority?   Better starting point   Recession less bad   Strong private sector – across Greater SE   Subsequent evidence suggests GSE growing relatively faster than rest of UK
  • 5. Incentives and financial mechanisms   Enterprise Zones   Local Enterprise Partnerships/ Regional Growth Fund   Tax Increment Financing   Reform of local government finance   ‘resource review’   Business Rate Supplement, Business Improvement Districts, Community Infrastructure Levy etc
  • 6. Enterprise Zones   New EZ for Royal Docks   Back to the Future?   Isle of Dogs experience   Dynamic?   Inefficient?   But certainly an element in Docklands’ success   More may follow   Which areas to be chosen? By councils?   LEPs keep additional local tax revenue
  • 7. LEPs and RGF   LEPs are the government’s new approach to the promotion of enterprise   Business-local government partnerships   ‘Organic’   To foster an “environment for business and growth”   To bid for resources from RGF   Significant excess of demand over RGF supply   Still in formative stage
  • 8. Tax Increment Finance   Around for a number of years   Last week’s LG resource review terms of reference stated the review should consider: “how to deliver Tax Increment Financing proposals against a context of greater retention of business rate revenues”   Attempt to fund projects to allow a project to go ahead with the expected increased local tax payments resulting from the development   Development to be ‘conditional’ on the TIF scheme
  • 9. Local government ‘resource review’   ‘Resource’ review now under way   TORs published in spring 2011   Business rate retention   New Homes Bonus   Together, these reforms = ‘self- sufficiency’ for some councils   Incentives to deliver tax base growth   Need for ‘pool’ for equalisation   Tax competition….
  • 10. Other, related, policies   Business Rate Supplement   Crossrail funding   Could be extended?   Business Improvement Districts   Successful over a number of years   Could be extended to sectors or areas?   Community Infrastructure Levy   Levy on developments to pay for infrastructure   Many parts of London/GSE likely to produce a better yield than elsewhere
  • 11. London and the GSE– maximising the resources available   There are opportunities for London and its region in all of this…   but, the new world of incentives and tax- base growth will be different from one of grants etc   Need to bring forward schemes and make their impacts clear to national, city-wide and local politicians   Land values relatively powerful and growth potential strong in London/much of GSE   a good start…
  • 12. What will be needed…   Further strengthening of relationship between councils, developers and communities   NB Localism Bill and planning   Realism in the extent to which major developments can be ‘taxed’   Different from the ‘years of plenty’   Public-private joint ventures?   Certainly contributions from both   Consistency of approach
  • 13. Regeneration and capital development in a cold climate Tony Travers London School of Economics