This case involves R. v. Smagin, where Eugene Smagin was charged with careless driving. The defense counsel requested disclosure on multiple occasions dating back to December 16th, but did not receive any documents from the prosecution until March 15th, just two weeks before the scheduled trial date. The judge criticized the untimely manner in which disclosure was provided by the investigating officer. As a result, the judge dismissed the careless driving charge, finding that the late disclosure did not provide adequate time for the defense to prepare for trial.