2. A primer
share options //
A Share option is a right to acquire shares in the future (no obligation)
The price per share is called Strike Price
- Normally set as market price at time of allocation, but can be set at lower value
Options give upside similar to owning shares in the company, but no downside
- Key differences are cash exposure and tax
Options normally vest over a period of time
- Typically with 1/3 over 3 years
The duration – or time to expiry – of an option is an important part of its value
One key challenge in start-ups is that there is no liquidity in the shares
- Makes it difficult to exercise options that are “in the money” due to tax
Options are taxed as income (~47%), not as capital gains (~25%) in Norway
- Not start-up friendly
- Taxed when you exercise option, not when you are allocated an option.
3. An example
share options //
You are allocated 10 000 options
Strike price is NOK 10 with vesting 1/3 over 3 years
- NOK 10 is equal to share price at time of allocation
After 3 years, the share price has increased to NOK 100
You then exercise all options, i.e. you buy 10 000 shares at NOK 10
Your gain is NOK 90 per share, in total NOK 900 000
You are taxed as if it was income in Norway (~47%)
- Even if you don’t sell the shares
The company has to pay “arbeidsgiveravgift”
If you can sell the shares immediately, that is an advantage, because you will
need money to pay the tax bill
Any later gains on shares owned will be taxed as capital gain (~25%)
4. What we typically see
share options//
In Norway, a typical option pool represents ~10% of shares, often less
- In the US, typically 15-20%. Employees in US start-ups expect an option plan
Size of program depends on how “for hire” vs. “founders” the team is
Some companies allocate the same amount to all employees, some reserve
the program for a few key employees
The most common is a balanced approach, where allocation depends on
1) Salary, 2) Position/Seniority) and 3) When you get hired
Normally, founders do not participate, they own shares
Some employees don’t appreciate options, they view them with skepticism…
6. We like everybody to have a stake
alliance venture’s view//
We prefer employees owning shares
- Gives both upside and downside
- More tax efficient
If you keep company valuations low initially, it is easier for key hires to become
shareholders
Key benefits with options: Give stakeholders a free upside (no investment
needed at grant) while conserving company cash
We believe options could be a much more powerful tool in Norway if tax was
fixed (e.g. approved schemes)
We prefer a balanced approach in option programs
- Most options allocated to key employees, but everybody gets a small allocation
7. Governance& Practicalities
share options //
Allocating shares is an ownership issue
- New shares have to be approve by the General Meeting
- Allocating options potentially dilutes the other shareholders
Some authority is often delegated to Board of Directors
The BoD often delegate some authority to CEO
Use a standard option agreement
Try to use fixed dates, i.e. that options vest from a certain date, so that
employees do not have individual starting dates
Keep good overview of option grants together with your cap table/shareholder
registry
Give yourself flexibility to extend program (expiry date)