This 3-step recipe explains how to make homemade cinnamon toast. First, toast bread for over 2 minutes until golden brown. Second, spread butter over the toasted bread using a butter knife and tablespoon of butter. Third, top the buttered toast with cinnamon and sugar by shaking small amounts of each seasoning over the toast. The simple recipe uses bread, butter, cinnamon, and sugar to create a sweet homemade cinnamon toast snack.