SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Easier Said Than Done
A Review of the Literature: Myths, Facts, &
Implications Concerning the Misperceptions of
Mental Illness
SAMHSA Internship Final Presentation
John Arthur Jackson, III, B.A. Intern
CMHS Office of the Director
April 23, 2015
ntroduction
Purpose
• SAMHSA has a rather critical role in producing and advancing
the knowledge with respect to misperceptions about mental
illness. This includes the relationship between that of mental
illness and violence. The evident volatility of this topic only
affirms that we need to contribute to further dialogue
• In presenting the literature about some of the myths and
implications concerning the social perceptions of those who
are mentally ill, will reveal the nature in which discussions
about mental illness has been distorted.
Background
• We should know that there is an ever present and
ongoing prejudice associated with people who have
mental illness. Compounded with the assumption of a
violent predisposition we find that this does not
facilitate a climate that encourages recovery but
hinders. This type of discrimination about people with
mental illness is something we need to reassess.
Common Misperceptions & Myths
Myth: People with mental illnesses are violent and unpredictable.
Fact: In reality, the vast majority of people who have mental
health needs are no more violent than anyone else. You probably
know someone with a mental illness and don't even realize it.
Myth: Once people develop mental illnesses, they will never recover.
Fact: Studies show that most people with mental illnesses get better, and
many recover completely. Recovery refers to the process in which people are
able to live, work, learn, and participate fully in their communities. For some
individuals, recovery is the ability to live a fulfilling and productive life. For
others, recovery implies the reduction or complete remission of symptoms.
Science has shown that having hope plays an integral role in an individual's
recovery.
Method
• An exploratory study that reviewed a myriad of
electronic bibliographic databases (e.g. CDC,
NSDUH, APA, AMA, HHS and Google Scholar)
utilizing the search: “mental illness”; “mental health”;
“integration”; inclusion”; “social acceptance”;
“exclusion”; “discrimination”; “social exclusion”.
Articles selected were full text, qualitative semi-
structured interviews, systematic reviews and peer
reviewed articles published between 2006-2014.
A Look At Previous Literature
• Dr. Jonathan Metzl, Vanderbilt University
– Mental illness and Gun violence
• Societal need to blame as a way to obtain security from
reality (Metzl 2011).
New York Times “A Misguided Focus on Mental Illness in
Gun Control Debate
Dr. Jeffrey Swanson
Displacing and limiting threat of violence to a small, well-defined group.
Overwhelming epidemiological evidence that the vast majority of people with
mental psychiatric disorders to not commit violent acts.
The Assumption
Adam Lanza James Holmes
Seung-Hui Cho
Jared Loughner
Results/Findings (cont.)
• National Institute of Mental Health’s
Epidemiologic Catchment Area study
– (Swanson, Holze, Ganju & Jono) 2001
Results/Findings (cont.)
Mental illness is NOT a precursor for crime
• Certain mental illnesses make people less likely to
commit violent acts
– Schizophrenia can cause people to isolate or withdraw from
society
• Dr. Linda A. Teplin; National Crime Victimization Survey
(NCVS) of 2005
While it is estimated that,
of America’s crimes may be
committed by people with
mental illness.
Appelbaum, P. & Swanson, J. (2010).
‘Victims’
About¼of People with
mental illness are more likely to be the
Which is 11 times the rate of the general population
National Crime Victimization
Survey (NCVS) of 2005
• SAMHSA’s Resource Center to Promote
Acceptance, Dignity and Social Inclusion
Associated with Mental Health (ADS Center)
» No longer funded but vital resource; possibly replicate
• NIMH & SAMHSA’s coordinated facilitation
• Administrator, Center Director Article (2013)
• SAMHSA Mental Illness Violence Paper
Recommendations
• SAMHSA Expert Panel
• SAMHSA should review existing contracts, grants and
other programs and resulting inventory can be used to
identify strengths, gaps and opportunities for
SAMHSA to immerse themselves in an active
discussion conducive to potential solutions concerning
risk
• Programs targeted to early intervention
• Foster an attitude of inclusiveness
Final Thoughts
Questions ?
Thank You For Your Time!
SAMHSA Internship Final Presentation
John Arthur Jackson, III, Intern to Deputy Director
CMHS Office of the Director
April 23, 2015

More Related Content

What's hot

Mental Health In Prison
Mental Health In PrisonMental Health In Prison
Mental Health In Prison
esquiredre
 
Mental Health Policy - Defining mental illness, epidemiology, service use, an...
Mental Health Policy - Defining mental illness, epidemiology, service use, an...Mental Health Policy - Defining mental illness, epidemiology, service use, an...
Mental Health Policy - Defining mental illness, epidemiology, service use, an...
Dr. James Swartz
 
Depression and anxiety screening ucaya
Depression and anxiety screening ucayaDepression and anxiety screening ucaya
Depression and anxiety screening ucaya
Greenville Health System
 
Recovery from Mental Illness: Offering hope through your personal journey
Recovery from Mental Illness: Offering hope through your personal journeyRecovery from Mental Illness: Offering hope through your personal journey
Recovery from Mental Illness: Offering hope through your personal journey
The Royal Mental Health Centre
 
SOJ Psychology
SOJ Psychology SOJ Psychology
Assessing the Burden of Mental Illness in Jackson County
Assessing the Burden of Mental Illness in Jackson CountyAssessing the Burden of Mental Illness in Jackson County
Assessing the Burden of Mental Illness in Jackson CountyRichard Thoune
 
Prevalence of depression and factors
Prevalence of depression and factorsPrevalence of depression and factors
Prevalence of depression and factors
amsjournal
 
Foon_Symposium Poster
Foon_Symposium PosterFoon_Symposium Poster
Foon_Symposium PosterChloe Foon
 
Chapter 8 Disaster Mental Health
Chapter 8 Disaster Mental HealthChapter 8 Disaster Mental Health
Chapter 8 Disaster Mental Health
martinevanhuuksloot
 
A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY ANALYSING THE LEVEL OF DEPRESSION AND ITS CAUSATIVE F...
A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY ANALYSING THE LEVEL OF DEPRESSION AND ITS CAUSATIVE F...A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY ANALYSING THE LEVEL OF DEPRESSION AND ITS CAUSATIVE F...
A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY ANALYSING THE LEVEL OF DEPRESSION AND ITS CAUSATIVE F...
amsjournal
 
Teens Volunteering: Implications for mental health
Teens Volunteering: Implications for mental healthTeens Volunteering: Implications for mental health
Teens Volunteering: Implications for mental health
Michael Torres
 
The way back Information Resources Project_Developing evidence-informed infor...
The way back Information Resources Project_Developing evidence-informed infor...The way back Information Resources Project_Developing evidence-informed infor...
The way back Information Resources Project_Developing evidence-informed infor...
Hunter Institute of Mental Health
 
Problems with well-being: Mental illness
Problems with well-being: Mental illness Problems with well-being: Mental illness
Problems with well-being: Mental illness
natasharyckman10
 
Assessment and Treatment in Child Psychology
Assessment and Treatment in Child PsychologyAssessment and Treatment in Child Psychology
Assessment and Treatment in Child Psychology
AlexandraPerkins5
 
Jmedeth00282 0040
Jmedeth00282 0040Jmedeth00282 0040
Jmedeth00282 0040
Jan Bergmans
 
Final%20 submission%20of%20non suicidal%20self-injury%20project
Final%20 submission%20of%20non suicidal%20self-injury%20projectFinal%20 submission%20of%20non suicidal%20self-injury%20project
Final%20 submission%20of%20non suicidal%20self-injury%20projectA.J. Panneton
 
MHEI transcript 4 specific screening for suicidal risk
MHEI transcript 4 specific screening for suicidal riskMHEI transcript 4 specific screening for suicidal risk
MHEI transcript 4 specific screening for suicidal risk
Regina Motarjeme, MSc
 

What's hot (20)

Mental Health In Prison
Mental Health In PrisonMental Health In Prison
Mental Health In Prison
 
Mental Health Policy - Defining mental illness, epidemiology, service use, an...
Mental Health Policy - Defining mental illness, epidemiology, service use, an...Mental Health Policy - Defining mental illness, epidemiology, service use, an...
Mental Health Policy - Defining mental illness, epidemiology, service use, an...
 
Depression and anxiety screening ucaya
Depression and anxiety screening ucayaDepression and anxiety screening ucaya
Depression and anxiety screening ucaya
 
Recovery from Mental Illness: Offering hope through your personal journey
Recovery from Mental Illness: Offering hope through your personal journeyRecovery from Mental Illness: Offering hope through your personal journey
Recovery from Mental Illness: Offering hope through your personal journey
 
Behavioral Paper_Mental Health
Behavioral Paper_Mental HealthBehavioral Paper_Mental Health
Behavioral Paper_Mental Health
 
SOJ Psychology
SOJ Psychology SOJ Psychology
SOJ Psychology
 
Mental Health Advocacy
Mental Health AdvocacyMental Health Advocacy
Mental Health Advocacy
 
Assessing the Burden of Mental Illness in Jackson County
Assessing the Burden of Mental Illness in Jackson CountyAssessing the Burden of Mental Illness in Jackson County
Assessing the Burden of Mental Illness in Jackson County
 
Prevalence of depression and factors
Prevalence of depression and factorsPrevalence of depression and factors
Prevalence of depression and factors
 
Foon_Symposium Poster
Foon_Symposium PosterFoon_Symposium Poster
Foon_Symposium Poster
 
Chapter 8 Disaster Mental Health
Chapter 8 Disaster Mental HealthChapter 8 Disaster Mental Health
Chapter 8 Disaster Mental Health
 
A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY ANALYSING THE LEVEL OF DEPRESSION AND ITS CAUSATIVE F...
A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY ANALYSING THE LEVEL OF DEPRESSION AND ITS CAUSATIVE F...A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY ANALYSING THE LEVEL OF DEPRESSION AND ITS CAUSATIVE F...
A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY ANALYSING THE LEVEL OF DEPRESSION AND ITS CAUSATIVE F...
 
Teens Volunteering: Implications for mental health
Teens Volunteering: Implications for mental healthTeens Volunteering: Implications for mental health
Teens Volunteering: Implications for mental health
 
The way back Information Resources Project_Developing evidence-informed infor...
The way back Information Resources Project_Developing evidence-informed infor...The way back Information Resources Project_Developing evidence-informed infor...
The way back Information Resources Project_Developing evidence-informed infor...
 
General Practice Psychiatry
General Practice PsychiatryGeneral Practice Psychiatry
General Practice Psychiatry
 
Problems with well-being: Mental illness
Problems with well-being: Mental illness Problems with well-being: Mental illness
Problems with well-being: Mental illness
 
Assessment and Treatment in Child Psychology
Assessment and Treatment in Child PsychologyAssessment and Treatment in Child Psychology
Assessment and Treatment in Child Psychology
 
Jmedeth00282 0040
Jmedeth00282 0040Jmedeth00282 0040
Jmedeth00282 0040
 
Final%20 submission%20of%20non suicidal%20self-injury%20project
Final%20 submission%20of%20non suicidal%20self-injury%20projectFinal%20 submission%20of%20non suicidal%20self-injury%20project
Final%20 submission%20of%20non suicidal%20self-injury%20project
 
MHEI transcript 4 specific screening for suicidal risk
MHEI transcript 4 specific screening for suicidal riskMHEI transcript 4 specific screening for suicidal risk
MHEI transcript 4 specific screening for suicidal risk
 

Similar to Misperceptions of MentalHealth _Spring

Mental illness in a societal context
Mental illness in a societal contextMental illness in a societal context
Mental illness in a societal context
Lyndon Woytuck
 
Mental health wellbeing sfs
Mental health wellbeing sfsMental health wellbeing sfs
Mental health wellbeing sfs
Bikash Bage
 
Biases surrounding mental health
Biases surrounding mental healthBiases surrounding mental health
Biases surrounding mental health
Florida Mental Health Helpline
 
Public attitudes to mental health
Public attitudes to mental healthPublic attitudes to mental health
Public attitudes to mental healthMorin Carew MBA
 
Briceno 2Sophia BricenoProfessor Elizabeth Nappo ENC 1102.docx
Briceno 2Sophia BricenoProfessor Elizabeth Nappo ENC 1102.docxBriceno 2Sophia BricenoProfessor Elizabeth Nappo ENC 1102.docx
Briceno 2Sophia BricenoProfessor Elizabeth Nappo ENC 1102.docx
robert345678
 
Vulnerable share characteristics making them susceptible.docx
Vulnerable share characteristics making them susceptible.docxVulnerable share characteristics making them susceptible.docx
Vulnerable share characteristics making them susceptible.docx
write22
 
Misconception of mental illness
Misconception of mental illnessMisconception of mental illness
Misconception of mental illness
Raghu M SACH
 

Similar to Misperceptions of MentalHealth _Spring (7)

Mental illness in a societal context
Mental illness in a societal contextMental illness in a societal context
Mental illness in a societal context
 
Mental health wellbeing sfs
Mental health wellbeing sfsMental health wellbeing sfs
Mental health wellbeing sfs
 
Biases surrounding mental health
Biases surrounding mental healthBiases surrounding mental health
Biases surrounding mental health
 
Public attitudes to mental health
Public attitudes to mental healthPublic attitudes to mental health
Public attitudes to mental health
 
Briceno 2Sophia BricenoProfessor Elizabeth Nappo ENC 1102.docx
Briceno 2Sophia BricenoProfessor Elizabeth Nappo ENC 1102.docxBriceno 2Sophia BricenoProfessor Elizabeth Nappo ENC 1102.docx
Briceno 2Sophia BricenoProfessor Elizabeth Nappo ENC 1102.docx
 
Vulnerable share characteristics making them susceptible.docx
Vulnerable share characteristics making them susceptible.docxVulnerable share characteristics making them susceptible.docx
Vulnerable share characteristics making them susceptible.docx
 
Misconception of mental illness
Misconception of mental illnessMisconception of mental illness
Misconception of mental illness
 

Misperceptions of MentalHealth _Spring

  • 1.
  • 2. Easier Said Than Done A Review of the Literature: Myths, Facts, & Implications Concerning the Misperceptions of Mental Illness SAMHSA Internship Final Presentation John Arthur Jackson, III, B.A. Intern CMHS Office of the Director April 23, 2015
  • 4. Purpose • SAMHSA has a rather critical role in producing and advancing the knowledge with respect to misperceptions about mental illness. This includes the relationship between that of mental illness and violence. The evident volatility of this topic only affirms that we need to contribute to further dialogue • In presenting the literature about some of the myths and implications concerning the social perceptions of those who are mentally ill, will reveal the nature in which discussions about mental illness has been distorted.
  • 5. Background • We should know that there is an ever present and ongoing prejudice associated with people who have mental illness. Compounded with the assumption of a violent predisposition we find that this does not facilitate a climate that encourages recovery but hinders. This type of discrimination about people with mental illness is something we need to reassess.
  • 6. Common Misperceptions & Myths Myth: People with mental illnesses are violent and unpredictable. Fact: In reality, the vast majority of people who have mental health needs are no more violent than anyone else. You probably know someone with a mental illness and don't even realize it. Myth: Once people develop mental illnesses, they will never recover. Fact: Studies show that most people with mental illnesses get better, and many recover completely. Recovery refers to the process in which people are able to live, work, learn, and participate fully in their communities. For some individuals, recovery is the ability to live a fulfilling and productive life. For others, recovery implies the reduction or complete remission of symptoms. Science has shown that having hope plays an integral role in an individual's recovery.
  • 7. Method • An exploratory study that reviewed a myriad of electronic bibliographic databases (e.g. CDC, NSDUH, APA, AMA, HHS and Google Scholar) utilizing the search: “mental illness”; “mental health”; “integration”; inclusion”; “social acceptance”; “exclusion”; “discrimination”; “social exclusion”. Articles selected were full text, qualitative semi- structured interviews, systematic reviews and peer reviewed articles published between 2006-2014.
  • 8. A Look At Previous Literature • Dr. Jonathan Metzl, Vanderbilt University – Mental illness and Gun violence • Societal need to blame as a way to obtain security from reality (Metzl 2011). New York Times “A Misguided Focus on Mental Illness in Gun Control Debate Dr. Jeffrey Swanson Displacing and limiting threat of violence to a small, well-defined group. Overwhelming epidemiological evidence that the vast majority of people with mental psychiatric disorders to not commit violent acts.
  • 9. The Assumption Adam Lanza James Holmes Seung-Hui Cho Jared Loughner
  • 10. Results/Findings (cont.) • National Institute of Mental Health’s Epidemiologic Catchment Area study – (Swanson, Holze, Ganju & Jono) 2001
  • 11. Results/Findings (cont.) Mental illness is NOT a precursor for crime • Certain mental illnesses make people less likely to commit violent acts – Schizophrenia can cause people to isolate or withdraw from society • Dr. Linda A. Teplin; National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS) of 2005
  • 12. While it is estimated that, of America’s crimes may be committed by people with mental illness. Appelbaum, P. & Swanson, J. (2010).
  • 13. ‘Victims’ About¼of People with mental illness are more likely to be the Which is 11 times the rate of the general population National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS) of 2005
  • 14. • SAMHSA’s Resource Center to Promote Acceptance, Dignity and Social Inclusion Associated with Mental Health (ADS Center) » No longer funded but vital resource; possibly replicate • NIMH & SAMHSA’s coordinated facilitation • Administrator, Center Director Article (2013) • SAMHSA Mental Illness Violence Paper
  • 15. Recommendations • SAMHSA Expert Panel • SAMHSA should review existing contracts, grants and other programs and resulting inventory can be used to identify strengths, gaps and opportunities for SAMHSA to immerse themselves in an active discussion conducive to potential solutions concerning risk • Programs targeted to early intervention • Foster an attitude of inclusiveness
  • 18. Thank You For Your Time! SAMHSA Internship Final Presentation John Arthur Jackson, III, Intern to Deputy Director CMHS Office of the Director April 23, 2015