SlideShare a Scribd company logo
P R E S E N T E D B Y: D E V O R A A B R E H A M
M O D E R AT O R : D R . T E S F AY E
MEDICAL ETHICS
CASE 5.10
1
09/02/2023
Earl is sixty-three years old and has been on hemodialysis for
about one year because of renal failure resulting from his long
standing diabetes. He also has a history of coronary artery
disease, stroke, and early dementia. He has had several
infections in his indwelling dialysis shunts ( often called “line
infections”), resulting in three admissions to the ICU in the past
year with ventilator support. He was admitted from his nursing
home yesterday with another episode of sepsis from a line
infection. His shunt was removed and he has been stabilized
overnight. He was scheduled to have a temporary dialysis
catheter inserted today. Consent had been given by his wife, but
the patient said he didn’t want it and physically resisted
insertion by Dr. Chandler.
2
09/02/2023
His wife reports that Earl was a farmer and cheese maker who
has been disabled for 25 years from his diabetes and heart
disease. He did quite well until about two years ago when he
became unable to walk and developed frequent urinary infections.
She describes him as a quiet, private person who loved his three
children and several grandchildren. Two children are living close
by. The other, Jimmy, died of an apparent heart attack while
driving four years ago; he was a close pal of the patient.
3
09/02/2023
Both Dr. Chandler and Earl’s wife report that he has been
ambivalent about dialysis since it started, and since he was admitted to
the nursing home four months ago, has frequently said he wanted to
stop. He otherwise settled into the nursing home routine better than
expected. Dr. Chandler has cared for Earl for some time. He believes
that Earl still has decision-making capacity in spite of his early
dementia.
His wife told Dr. Chandler that Earl told her this morning he wanted
to stop dialysis and die unless he could have a kidney transplant,
preferably using one of her kidneys. She has hypertension and diabetes
and thus is not a candidate for kidney donation. Transplantation was
discussed early on, and it was acknowledged that patients report a
better quality of life after transplant than while on dialysis. However, it
was not felt to be an option for Earl because of his other medical
problems
4
09/02/2023
I spoke with Earl in the presence of his wife, his medical
resident and his nurse. He consistently nodded yes and no to
multiple questions and clearly indicated he didn’t want the line
reinserted and didn’t want any more dialysis. When asked what
would happen without dialysis he said, “ l’ll die.” He was
unwilling to verbalize a reason why he wanted to stop now, but
with “20 Questions” said it was not because of pain or other
correctable symptoms, but because life on dialysis was not good
enough. When his wife asked if it was so he could join Jimmy, he
nodded his head, burst into tears, and said to her, "That's mean!"
5
09/02/2023
• Is it ethically permissible to replace an intravenous line
for hemodialysis over the objection of the patient?
6
09/02/2023
DISCUSSION POINTS
• Which principle of medical ethics should be taken into
consideration in this case?
• When a patient with decision-making capacity refuses a
lifesaving intervention or refuses to continue life-
sustaining technology, what are the important points that
should be addressed?
• What factor can one consider that led the patient to have
made this decision?
7
09/02/2023
RECOMMENDATION
1) 
If his caregivers believe all efforts at optimizing his
quality of life have been exhausted, it would be ethically
permissible to honor this man's request to stop dialysis.
2) 
If there is concern that a treatable depression may be a
factor in the timing of his decision, it might be appropriate
to try a short course of a rapid-acting mood stimulator.
Unless there is a significant likelihood of improving his
mood sufficiently to accept continued dialysis, it would be
ethically troublesome to impose line reinsertion and dialysis
over his objection.
8
09/02/2023
FOLLOW UP
• Earl continued to say he wanted transplantation, though
his nephrology consultant feels he is not a good
candidate. The transplant surgeon was willing to
reconsider his candidacy and said he would pursue an
outpatient evaluation. Earl was willing to continue
dialysis until a determination about transplantation could
be made. He was discharged back to the nursing home.
9
09/02/2023

More Related Content

Similar to ME5.10.pptx

what will happen if you ignore the patients suicidal thoughts expla.pdf
what will happen if you ignore the patients suicidal thoughts expla.pdfwhat will happen if you ignore the patients suicidal thoughts expla.pdf
what will happen if you ignore the patients suicidal thoughts expla.pdf
amirajsharma
 
Case law medicines management
Case law medicines managementCase law medicines management
Case law medicines management
Gerardo Medina
 
Mrs. B. is 97 years old, and was admitted to your LTC faci.pdf
Mrs. B. is 97 years old, and was admitted to your LTC faci.pdfMrs. B. is 97 years old, and was admitted to your LTC faci.pdf
Mrs. B. is 97 years old, and was admitted to your LTC faci.pdf
aliracreations
 
Please respond to both students Use APA format and.docx
Please respond to both students Use APA format and.docxPlease respond to both students Use APA format and.docx
Please respond to both students Use APA format and.docx
bkbk37
 
A family divided.docx
A family divided.docxA family divided.docx
A family divided.docx
write31
 
A family divided.docx
A family divided.docxA family divided.docx
A family divided.docx
write5
 
1Health History2Health HistoryHealth H.docx
1Health History2Health HistoryHealth H.docx1Health History2Health HistoryHealth H.docx
1Health History2Health HistoryHealth H.docx
hyacinthshackley2629
 
Cardiology Clinical Case Study.docx
Cardiology Clinical Case Study.docxCardiology Clinical Case Study.docx
Cardiology Clinical Case Study.docx
stirlingvwriters
 
For this assignment, consider the following case and then using th.docx
For this assignment, consider the following case and then using th.docxFor this assignment, consider the following case and then using th.docx
For this assignment, consider the following case and then using th.docx
budbarber38650
 
Palliative care motivational style ámsterdam
Palliative care motivational style ámsterdamPalliative care motivational style ámsterdam
Palliative care motivational style ámsterdammanu campiñez
 
case study on Cardiomyopathy
case study on Cardiomyopathycase study on Cardiomyopathy
case study on Cardiomyopathy
education4227
 
doctors are human annals submission
doctors are human annals submissiondoctors are human annals submission
doctors are human annals submissionWard Buckingham
 
NSG6001 Advanced Practice Nursing I Page 1 of 5 © 2007 S.docx
NSG6001 Advanced Practice Nursing I Page 1 of 5 © 2007 S.docxNSG6001 Advanced Practice Nursing I Page 1 of 5 © 2007 S.docx
NSG6001 Advanced Practice Nursing I Page 1 of 5 © 2007 S.docx
henrymartin15260
 
Second chances part 1-Lee Chen Hoe
Second chances part 1-Lee Chen HoeSecond chances part 1-Lee Chen Hoe
Second chances part 1-Lee Chen HoeChen Hoe Lee
 
Refusal of care.pptx
Refusal of care.pptxRefusal of care.pptx
Refusal of care.pptx
Keerthanadurai2
 
Test Slides
Test SlidesTest Slides
Test Slides
sundarpatel1
 
Cardiology Clinical Case.pdf
Cardiology Clinical Case.pdfCardiology Clinical Case.pdf
Cardiology Clinical Case.pdf
bkbk37
 
Running Head INTRODUCTION TO THE MILLER FAMILY 1Miller Fa.docx
Running Head INTRODUCTION TO THE MILLER FAMILY 1Miller Fa.docxRunning Head INTRODUCTION TO THE MILLER FAMILY 1Miller Fa.docx
Running Head INTRODUCTION TO THE MILLER FAMILY 1Miller Fa.docx
charisellington63520
 

Similar to ME5.10.pptx (20)

what will happen if you ignore the patients suicidal thoughts expla.pdf
what will happen if you ignore the patients suicidal thoughts expla.pdfwhat will happen if you ignore the patients suicidal thoughts expla.pdf
what will happen if you ignore the patients suicidal thoughts expla.pdf
 
Case law medicines management
Case law medicines managementCase law medicines management
Case law medicines management
 
Mrs. B. is 97 years old, and was admitted to your LTC faci.pdf
Mrs. B. is 97 years old, and was admitted to your LTC faci.pdfMrs. B. is 97 years old, and was admitted to your LTC faci.pdf
Mrs. B. is 97 years old, and was admitted to your LTC faci.pdf
 
Please respond to both students Use APA format and.docx
Please respond to both students Use APA format and.docxPlease respond to both students Use APA format and.docx
Please respond to both students Use APA format and.docx
 
Discharge Cost Analysis
Discharge Cost AnalysisDischarge Cost Analysis
Discharge Cost Analysis
 
A family divided.docx
A family divided.docxA family divided.docx
A family divided.docx
 
A family divided.docx
A family divided.docxA family divided.docx
A family divided.docx
 
1Health History2Health HistoryHealth H.docx
1Health History2Health HistoryHealth H.docx1Health History2Health HistoryHealth H.docx
1Health History2Health HistoryHealth H.docx
 
Cardiology Clinical Case Study.docx
Cardiology Clinical Case Study.docxCardiology Clinical Case Study.docx
Cardiology Clinical Case Study.docx
 
For this assignment, consider the following case and then using th.docx
For this assignment, consider the following case and then using th.docxFor this assignment, consider the following case and then using th.docx
For this assignment, consider the following case and then using th.docx
 
Palliative care motivational style ámsterdam
Palliative care motivational style ámsterdamPalliative care motivational style ámsterdam
Palliative care motivational style ámsterdam
 
case study on Cardiomyopathy
case study on Cardiomyopathycase study on Cardiomyopathy
case study on Cardiomyopathy
 
doctors are human annals submission
doctors are human annals submissiondoctors are human annals submission
doctors are human annals submission
 
NSG6001 Advanced Practice Nursing I Page 1 of 5 © 2007 S.docx
NSG6001 Advanced Practice Nursing I Page 1 of 5 © 2007 S.docxNSG6001 Advanced Practice Nursing I Page 1 of 5 © 2007 S.docx
NSG6001 Advanced Practice Nursing I Page 1 of 5 © 2007 S.docx
 
Second chances part 1-Lee Chen Hoe
Second chances part 1-Lee Chen HoeSecond chances part 1-Lee Chen Hoe
Second chances part 1-Lee Chen Hoe
 
Refusal of care.pptx
Refusal of care.pptxRefusal of care.pptx
Refusal of care.pptx
 
Test Slides
Test SlidesTest Slides
Test Slides
 
Nursing history gordons
Nursing history gordonsNursing history gordons
Nursing history gordons
 
Cardiology Clinical Case.pdf
Cardiology Clinical Case.pdfCardiology Clinical Case.pdf
Cardiology Clinical Case.pdf
 
Running Head INTRODUCTION TO THE MILLER FAMILY 1Miller Fa.docx
Running Head INTRODUCTION TO THE MILLER FAMILY 1Miller Fa.docxRunning Head INTRODUCTION TO THE MILLER FAMILY 1Miller Fa.docx
Running Head INTRODUCTION TO THE MILLER FAMILY 1Miller Fa.docx
 

Recently uploaded

Dimensions of Healthcare Quality
Dimensions of Healthcare QualityDimensions of Healthcare Quality
Dimensions of Healthcare Quality
Naeemshahzad51
 
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima  SpaTop massage center in ajman chandrima  Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
Chandrima Spa Ajman
 
One Gene One Enzyme Theory.pptxvhvhfhfhfhf
One Gene One Enzyme Theory.pptxvhvhfhfhfhfOne Gene One Enzyme Theory.pptxvhvhfhfhfhf
One Gene One Enzyme Theory.pptxvhvhfhfhfhf
AbdulMunim54
 
KEY Points of Leicester travel clinic In London doc.docx
KEY Points of Leicester travel clinic In London doc.docxKEY Points of Leicester travel clinic In London doc.docx
KEY Points of Leicester travel clinic In London doc.docx
NX Healthcare
 
DECODING THE RISKS - ALCOHOL, TOBACCO & DRUGS.pdf
DECODING THE RISKS - ALCOHOL, TOBACCO & DRUGS.pdfDECODING THE RISKS - ALCOHOL, TOBACCO & DRUGS.pdf
DECODING THE RISKS - ALCOHOL, TOBACCO & DRUGS.pdf
Dr Rachana Gujar
 
CANSA support - Caring for Cancer Patients' Caregivers
CANSA support - Caring for Cancer Patients' CaregiversCANSA support - Caring for Cancer Patients' Caregivers
CANSA support - Caring for Cancer Patients' Caregivers
CANSA The Cancer Association of South Africa
 
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference version 2.4.pdf
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference  version  2.4.pdfDRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference  version  2.4.pdf
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference version 2.4.pdf
Robert Cole
 
Global launch of the Healthy Ageing and Prevention Index 2nd wave – alongside...
Global launch of the Healthy Ageing and Prevention Index 2nd wave – alongside...Global launch of the Healthy Ageing and Prevention Index 2nd wave – alongside...
Global launch of the Healthy Ageing and Prevention Index 2nd wave – alongside...
ILC- UK
 
定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
khvdq584
 
Cardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing student
Cardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing studentCardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing student
Cardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing student
fahmyahmed789
 
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's Strategy
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's StrategyUnder Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's Strategy
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's Strategy
Kenneth Kruk
 
Ginseng for Stamina Boost Your Energy and Endurance Naturally.pptx
Ginseng for Stamina Boost Your Energy and Endurance Naturally.pptxGinseng for Stamina Boost Your Energy and Endurance Naturally.pptx
Ginseng for Stamina Boost Your Energy and Endurance Naturally.pptx
SkyTagBioteq
 
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured ApproachBringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Brian Frerichs
 
ICH Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance.pdf
ICH Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance.pdfICH Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance.pdf
ICH Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance.pdf
NEHA GUPTA
 
一比一原版纽约大学毕业证(NYU毕业证)成绩单留信认证
一比一原版纽约大学毕业证(NYU毕业证)成绩单留信认证一比一原版纽约大学毕业证(NYU毕业证)成绩单留信认证
一比一原版纽约大学毕业证(NYU毕业证)成绩单留信认证
o6ov5dqmf
 
Feeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptx
Feeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptxFeeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptx
Feeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptx
SatvikaPrasad
 
Veterinary Diagnostics Market PPT 2024: Size, Growth, Demand and Forecast til...
Veterinary Diagnostics Market PPT 2024: Size, Growth, Demand and Forecast til...Veterinary Diagnostics Market PPT 2024: Size, Growth, Demand and Forecast til...
Veterinary Diagnostics Market PPT 2024: Size, Growth, Demand and Forecast til...
IMARC Group
 
PrudentRx's Function in the Management of Chronic Illnesses
PrudentRx's Function in the Management of Chronic IllnessesPrudentRx's Function in the Management of Chronic Illnesses
PrudentRx's Function in the Management of Chronic Illnesses
PrudentRx Program
 
Nursing Care of Client With Acute And Chronic Renal Failure.ppt
Nursing Care of Client With Acute And Chronic Renal Failure.pptNursing Care of Client With Acute And Chronic Renal Failure.ppt
Nursing Care of Client With Acute And Chronic Renal Failure.ppt
Rommel Luis III Israel
 
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
Ameena Kadar
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Dimensions of Healthcare Quality
Dimensions of Healthcare QualityDimensions of Healthcare Quality
Dimensions of Healthcare Quality
 
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima  SpaTop massage center in ajman chandrima  Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
 
One Gene One Enzyme Theory.pptxvhvhfhfhfhf
One Gene One Enzyme Theory.pptxvhvhfhfhfhfOne Gene One Enzyme Theory.pptxvhvhfhfhfhf
One Gene One Enzyme Theory.pptxvhvhfhfhfhf
 
KEY Points of Leicester travel clinic In London doc.docx
KEY Points of Leicester travel clinic In London doc.docxKEY Points of Leicester travel clinic In London doc.docx
KEY Points of Leicester travel clinic In London doc.docx
 
DECODING THE RISKS - ALCOHOL, TOBACCO & DRUGS.pdf
DECODING THE RISKS - ALCOHOL, TOBACCO & DRUGS.pdfDECODING THE RISKS - ALCOHOL, TOBACCO & DRUGS.pdf
DECODING THE RISKS - ALCOHOL, TOBACCO & DRUGS.pdf
 
CANSA support - Caring for Cancer Patients' Caregivers
CANSA support - Caring for Cancer Patients' CaregiversCANSA support - Caring for Cancer Patients' Caregivers
CANSA support - Caring for Cancer Patients' Caregivers
 
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference version 2.4.pdf
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference  version  2.4.pdfDRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference  version  2.4.pdf
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference version 2.4.pdf
 
Global launch of the Healthy Ageing and Prevention Index 2nd wave – alongside...
Global launch of the Healthy Ageing and Prevention Index 2nd wave – alongside...Global launch of the Healthy Ageing and Prevention Index 2nd wave – alongside...
Global launch of the Healthy Ageing and Prevention Index 2nd wave – alongside...
 
定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
定制(wsu毕业证书)美国华盛顿州立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
 
Cardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing student
Cardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing studentCardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing student
Cardiac Arrhythmias (2).pdf for nursing student
 
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's Strategy
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's StrategyUnder Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's Strategy
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's Strategy
 
Ginseng for Stamina Boost Your Energy and Endurance Naturally.pptx
Ginseng for Stamina Boost Your Energy and Endurance Naturally.pptxGinseng for Stamina Boost Your Energy and Endurance Naturally.pptx
Ginseng for Stamina Boost Your Energy and Endurance Naturally.pptx
 
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured ApproachBringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
 
ICH Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance.pdf
ICH Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance.pdfICH Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance.pdf
ICH Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance.pdf
 
一比一原版纽约大学毕业证(NYU毕业证)成绩单留信认证
一比一原版纽约大学毕业证(NYU毕业证)成绩单留信认证一比一原版纽约大学毕业证(NYU毕业证)成绩单留信认证
一比一原版纽约大学毕业证(NYU毕业证)成绩单留信认证
 
Feeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptx
Feeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptxFeeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptx
Feeding plate for a newborn with Cleft Palate.pptx
 
Veterinary Diagnostics Market PPT 2024: Size, Growth, Demand and Forecast til...
Veterinary Diagnostics Market PPT 2024: Size, Growth, Demand and Forecast til...Veterinary Diagnostics Market PPT 2024: Size, Growth, Demand and Forecast til...
Veterinary Diagnostics Market PPT 2024: Size, Growth, Demand and Forecast til...
 
PrudentRx's Function in the Management of Chronic Illnesses
PrudentRx's Function in the Management of Chronic IllnessesPrudentRx's Function in the Management of Chronic Illnesses
PrudentRx's Function in the Management of Chronic Illnesses
 
Nursing Care of Client With Acute And Chronic Renal Failure.ppt
Nursing Care of Client With Acute And Chronic Renal Failure.pptNursing Care of Client With Acute And Chronic Renal Failure.ppt
Nursing Care of Client With Acute And Chronic Renal Failure.ppt
 
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
 

ME5.10.pptx

  • 1. P R E S E N T E D B Y: D E V O R A A B R E H A M M O D E R AT O R : D R . T E S F AY E MEDICAL ETHICS CASE 5.10 1 09/02/2023
  • 2. Earl is sixty-three years old and has been on hemodialysis for about one year because of renal failure resulting from his long standing diabetes. He also has a history of coronary artery disease, stroke, and early dementia. He has had several infections in his indwelling dialysis shunts ( often called “line infections”), resulting in three admissions to the ICU in the past year with ventilator support. He was admitted from his nursing home yesterday with another episode of sepsis from a line infection. His shunt was removed and he has been stabilized overnight. He was scheduled to have a temporary dialysis catheter inserted today. Consent had been given by his wife, but the patient said he didn’t want it and physically resisted insertion by Dr. Chandler. 2 09/02/2023
  • 3. His wife reports that Earl was a farmer and cheese maker who has been disabled for 25 years from his diabetes and heart disease. He did quite well until about two years ago when he became unable to walk and developed frequent urinary infections. She describes him as a quiet, private person who loved his three children and several grandchildren. Two children are living close by. The other, Jimmy, died of an apparent heart attack while driving four years ago; he was a close pal of the patient. 3 09/02/2023
  • 4. Both Dr. Chandler and Earl’s wife report that he has been ambivalent about dialysis since it started, and since he was admitted to the nursing home four months ago, has frequently said he wanted to stop. He otherwise settled into the nursing home routine better than expected. Dr. Chandler has cared for Earl for some time. He believes that Earl still has decision-making capacity in spite of his early dementia. His wife told Dr. Chandler that Earl told her this morning he wanted to stop dialysis and die unless he could have a kidney transplant, preferably using one of her kidneys. She has hypertension and diabetes and thus is not a candidate for kidney donation. Transplantation was discussed early on, and it was acknowledged that patients report a better quality of life after transplant than while on dialysis. However, it was not felt to be an option for Earl because of his other medical problems 4 09/02/2023
  • 5. I spoke with Earl in the presence of his wife, his medical resident and his nurse. He consistently nodded yes and no to multiple questions and clearly indicated he didn’t want the line reinserted and didn’t want any more dialysis. When asked what would happen without dialysis he said, “ l’ll die.” He was unwilling to verbalize a reason why he wanted to stop now, but with “20 Questions” said it was not because of pain or other correctable symptoms, but because life on dialysis was not good enough. When his wife asked if it was so he could join Jimmy, he nodded his head, burst into tears, and said to her, "That's mean!" 5 09/02/2023
  • 6. • Is it ethically permissible to replace an intravenous line for hemodialysis over the objection of the patient? 6 09/02/2023
  • 7. DISCUSSION POINTS • Which principle of medical ethics should be taken into consideration in this case? • When a patient with decision-making capacity refuses a lifesaving intervention or refuses to continue life- sustaining technology, what are the important points that should be addressed? • What factor can one consider that led the patient to have made this decision? 7 09/02/2023
  • 8. RECOMMENDATION 1)  If his caregivers believe all efforts at optimizing his quality of life have been exhausted, it would be ethically permissible to honor this man's request to stop dialysis. 2)  If there is concern that a treatable depression may be a factor in the timing of his decision, it might be appropriate to try a short course of a rapid-acting mood stimulator. Unless there is a significant likelihood of improving his mood sufficiently to accept continued dialysis, it would be ethically troublesome to impose line reinsertion and dialysis over his objection. 8 09/02/2023
  • 9. FOLLOW UP • Earl continued to say he wanted transplantation, though his nephrology consultant feels he is not a good candidate. The transplant surgeon was willing to reconsider his candidacy and said he would pursue an outpatient evaluation. Earl was willing to continue dialysis until a determination about transplantation could be made. He was discharged back to the nursing home. 9 09/02/2023