SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Analysis of data from a unique survey experiment Adam B. Schaeffer, Ph.D. Center for Educational Freedom Cato Institute How to Think and Talk About Education Tax Credits & Vouchers
What Messages Work & Why How Do Different Arguments Impact the Expected Effects of Private Choice?  Are There Differences Between Effective Voucher & Credit Messages? How to Talk About Private Choice Policies
What Policies Were Tested? Vouchers: Government funds paid to families for use in obtaining a private education.  Personal Use Tax Credits:Tax credits given to individual taxpayers for education expenditures made on behalf of their own children. Individual Donation Tax Credit:Tax credits given to individual taxpayers for donations to scholarship organizations that support private choice for lower income families. Business Donation Tax Credit:Tax credits given to businesses for donations to scholarship organizations that support private choice for lower income families. Benefit was pegged at $2,700 for all policies (in 2010 dollars).
What’s a Message “Frame?” Message Frame: A frame “is a central organizing idea for making sense of relevant events and suggesting what is at issue.”  Frames answer the question, “Why?”  Why should the public care about the issue in the first place? Why should a citizen do anything about it?  Why should a politician do something about it?  Why should one solution be adopted rather than another?
How Were the Frames Tested? Three messages (Frames, or emphases) were tested in separate combination with vouchers and tax credits.  The test was performed like a clinical drug trial; respondents were randomly assigned to one of 6 treatment conditions or one of 2 control groups. Each frame, or emphasis, modified a basic overview of choice policy which noted that; parents will have more control achievement will increase due to competition/choice.
What Frames Were Tested? Equity Frame:School choice is presented as a way to make educational opportunities and outcomes for lower-income children more equitable. Financial Frame: School choice is presented as a way to help keep taxes low because private and other schools of choice cost less and parents spend education dollars more wisely than bureaucrats.   Moral Values Frame: School choice is presented as a way to help make sure schools teach good values, because parents know best what values their children should learn in school and would be able to choose good schools that teach them.
Support for Choice Policies, By Frame(Scale from 1-Strongly Oppose, to 7-Strongly Favor; 4-Neither )
So . . . Why Does the Financial Frame Have the Most Consistent Positive Impact? What’s Driving This Response?
NOTE: These results are from before the financial crisis. It’s likely financial/cost concerns are even greater today.
What Performance Advantages are Most Important? Perceptions of Public vs. Private School Performance
Increase in Rating for Local Private Schools Compared to Rating for Local Public School
What Do the Regression Models Tell Us? The perception that Private Schools use money more efficiently than Public Schools has the biggest and most consistent positive impact on support for private choice. Perceived differences in academic achievement is second to efficiency and not always significant.
What’s Expected and Which Expectations Are Most Important? Anticipated Effects of Private Choice
Expected Effect on Property Values Doesn’t Seem to Matter . . .
Expected  Effect of Private Choice Policies on Property Values in Respondent’s Area(Percent Choosing Decrease, Neither, or Increase)
Margin of Respondents Who Expect Policy to Increase Cost, Achievement & Equity(Percent Choosing Increase minus Percent Decrease)
What Do the Regression Models Tell Us? The expected effects  on academic achievement has the biggest impact on support for private choice policies, followed by; The impact on cost, and The impact on educational equity.
Why Do People Think Vouchers Will Cost More?
Focus Group Results
How Do Different Frames Change What the Public Expects?
Impact of Frame on Expected  Effect Policies Will Have on Educational Costs (Scale from 1-Reduce A Lot, to 7-Increase A Lot; 4-Neither )
Impact of Frame on Expected  Effect Policies Will Have on Educational Achievement (Scale from 1-Reduce A Lot, to 7-Increase A Lot; 4-Neither )
Impact of Frame on Expected  Effect Policies Will Have on Educational Equality (Scale from 1-Reduce A Lot, to 7-Increase A Lot; 4-Neither )
Party ID Policy Knowledge  Parent/Non-Parent Demographics and Support for Private Choice Policy
Democratic Margin of Support for Policies(By Knowledge of Policy)
Democratic Margin of Support for Vouchers(By Frame & Knowledge of Vouchers)
Are Vouchers or Education Tax Credits More Popular? Targeted or Broad-Based?
 Margin of Support for School Choice Policies(Percent Favor minus Oppose)
Margin of Support for Choice Policies                                               (Percent Favor minus Opposition)
Margin of Support for Coverage Levels(Percent Support minus Opposition)
Emphasize $$ Savings & Academic Improvements Educational Equity Argument Can Help, But Also Cause Blowback! Credits Are More Popular Than Vouchers Broad-Based Coverage Is More Popular Than Targeted Conclusions

More Related Content

Similar to How to Think and Talk about Education Tax Credits and Vouchers

Conducting a Cost-Benefit AnalysisIt is relatively easy to dev.docx
Conducting a Cost-Benefit AnalysisIt is relatively easy to dev.docxConducting a Cost-Benefit AnalysisIt is relatively easy to dev.docx
Conducting a Cost-Benefit AnalysisIt is relatively easy to dev.docx
margaretr5
 
Leading for School Mental Health: Creating Sustainable and Equitable Funding ...
Leading for School Mental Health: Creating Sustainable and Equitable Funding ...Leading for School Mental Health: Creating Sustainable and Equitable Funding ...
Leading for School Mental Health: Creating Sustainable and Equitable Funding ...
California School-Based Health Alliance
 
Analysis frameworks
Analysis frameworksAnalysis frameworks
Analysis frameworks
adoglaromeo
 
Holding an SRP Referendum
Holding an SRP ReferendumHolding an SRP Referendum
Holding an SRP Referendum
World University Service of Canada
 
Applying Behavioral Economics
Applying Behavioral EconomicsApplying Behavioral Economics
Applying Behavioral EconomicsC.A.F.C.A.
 
5 Benefits of a Nonprofit Theory of Change
5 Benefits of a Nonprofit Theory of Change5 Benefits of a Nonprofit Theory of Change
5 Benefits of a Nonprofit Theory of Change
Nell Edgington
 
Policy oriented solutions
Policy oriented solutionsPolicy oriented solutions
Policy oriented solutions
Bonner Foundation
 
Submission to JOE by Wintford Thornton
Submission to JOE by Wintford ThorntonSubmission to JOE by Wintford Thornton
Submission to JOE by Wintford ThorntonWintford Thornton
 
Webinar: Adult Learners: A Key Piece of the College Completion Puzzle
Webinar: Adult Learners: A Key Piece of the College Completion PuzzleWebinar: Adult Learners: A Key Piece of the College Completion Puzzle
Webinar: Adult Learners: A Key Piece of the College Completion Puzzle
Cleveland-Marshall College of Law
 
Better cheaper faster board-ceo partnership for change
Better cheaper faster   board-ceo partnership for changeBetter cheaper faster   board-ceo partnership for change
Better cheaper faster board-ceo partnership for change
Ellen Chaffee
 
Effective Advocacy: Best Practices from Ilm Ideas on Slide Share
Effective Advocacy: Best Practices from Ilm Ideas on Slide ShareEffective Advocacy: Best Practices from Ilm Ideas on Slide Share
Effective Advocacy: Best Practices from Ilm Ideas on Slide Share
ilmideas
 
ADVOCACY 101: Introduction to Student Leadership and Advocacy
ADVOCACY 101: Introduction to Student Leadership and AdvocacyADVOCACY 101: Introduction to Student Leadership and Advocacy
ADVOCACY 101: Introduction to Student Leadership and Advocacy
Leneka Rhoden
 
SWK311 Assessment 2 Final EssayWhat is t.docx
SWK311 Assessment 2 Final EssayWhat is t.docxSWK311 Assessment 2 Final EssayWhat is t.docx
SWK311 Assessment 2 Final EssayWhat is t.docx
mabelf3
 
Is recruitment your pain?
Is recruitment your pain?Is recruitment your pain?
Is recruitment your pain?
Amplifinity
 
Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary.docx
Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary.docxDonor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary.docx
Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary.docx
DonorVoice
 
Donor voice donor+commitment+study_2011+executive+summary_final2(1)
Donor voice donor+commitment+study_2011+executive+summary_final2(1)Donor voice donor+commitment+study_2011+executive+summary_final2(1)
Donor voice donor+commitment+study_2011+executive+summary_final2(1)Giles Pegram CBE
 
Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary_final2
Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary_final2Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary_final2
Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary_final2DonorVoice
 

Similar to How to Think and Talk about Education Tax Credits and Vouchers (20)

Comp plan ppt copy
Comp plan ppt   copyComp plan ppt   copy
Comp plan ppt copy
 
Conducting a Cost-Benefit AnalysisIt is relatively easy to dev.docx
Conducting a Cost-Benefit AnalysisIt is relatively easy to dev.docxConducting a Cost-Benefit AnalysisIt is relatively easy to dev.docx
Conducting a Cost-Benefit AnalysisIt is relatively easy to dev.docx
 
Leading for School Mental Health: Creating Sustainable and Equitable Funding ...
Leading for School Mental Health: Creating Sustainable and Equitable Funding ...Leading for School Mental Health: Creating Sustainable and Equitable Funding ...
Leading for School Mental Health: Creating Sustainable and Equitable Funding ...
 
Analysis frameworks
Analysis frameworksAnalysis frameworks
Analysis frameworks
 
Holding an SRP Referendum
Holding an SRP ReferendumHolding an SRP Referendum
Holding an SRP Referendum
 
Applying Behavioral Economics
Applying Behavioral EconomicsApplying Behavioral Economics
Applying Behavioral Economics
 
5 Benefits of a Nonprofit Theory of Change
5 Benefits of a Nonprofit Theory of Change5 Benefits of a Nonprofit Theory of Change
5 Benefits of a Nonprofit Theory of Change
 
Policy oriented solutions
Policy oriented solutionsPolicy oriented solutions
Policy oriented solutions
 
Submission to JOE by Wintford Thornton
Submission to JOE by Wintford ThorntonSubmission to JOE by Wintford Thornton
Submission to JOE by Wintford Thornton
 
Webinar: Adult Learners: A Key Piece of the College Completion Puzzle
Webinar: Adult Learners: A Key Piece of the College Completion PuzzleWebinar: Adult Learners: A Key Piece of the College Completion Puzzle
Webinar: Adult Learners: A Key Piece of the College Completion Puzzle
 
Better cheaper faster board-ceo partnership for change
Better cheaper faster   board-ceo partnership for changeBetter cheaper faster   board-ceo partnership for change
Better cheaper faster board-ceo partnership for change
 
Epe talk for Supervisors
Epe talk for SupervisorsEpe talk for Supervisors
Epe talk for Supervisors
 
Effective Advocacy: Best Practices from Ilm Ideas on Slide Share
Effective Advocacy: Best Practices from Ilm Ideas on Slide ShareEffective Advocacy: Best Practices from Ilm Ideas on Slide Share
Effective Advocacy: Best Practices from Ilm Ideas on Slide Share
 
MMAA Dec 2013 Pub
MMAA Dec 2013 PubMMAA Dec 2013 Pub
MMAA Dec 2013 Pub
 
ADVOCACY 101: Introduction to Student Leadership and Advocacy
ADVOCACY 101: Introduction to Student Leadership and AdvocacyADVOCACY 101: Introduction to Student Leadership and Advocacy
ADVOCACY 101: Introduction to Student Leadership and Advocacy
 
SWK311 Assessment 2 Final EssayWhat is t.docx
SWK311 Assessment 2 Final EssayWhat is t.docxSWK311 Assessment 2 Final EssayWhat is t.docx
SWK311 Assessment 2 Final EssayWhat is t.docx
 
Is recruitment your pain?
Is recruitment your pain?Is recruitment your pain?
Is recruitment your pain?
 
Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary.docx
Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary.docxDonor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary.docx
Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary.docx
 
Donor voice donor+commitment+study_2011+executive+summary_final2(1)
Donor voice donor+commitment+study_2011+executive+summary_final2(1)Donor voice donor+commitment+study_2011+executive+summary_final2(1)
Donor voice donor+commitment+study_2011+executive+summary_final2(1)
 
Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary_final2
Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary_final2Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary_final2
Donor voice donor commitment study_2011 executive summary_final2
 

Recently uploaded

Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptxInstructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
Jheel Barad
 
Honest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptx
Honest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptxHonest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptx
Honest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptx
timhan337
 
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech RepublicPolish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Anna Sz.
 
678020731-Sumas-y-Restas-Para-Colorear.pdf
678020731-Sumas-y-Restas-Para-Colorear.pdf678020731-Sumas-y-Restas-Para-Colorear.pdf
678020731-Sumas-y-Restas-Para-Colorear.pdf
CarlosHernanMontoyab2
 
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdfspecial B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
Special education needs
 
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.pptThesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
EverAndrsGuerraGuerr
 
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptxSupporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Jisc
 
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
Celine George
 
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
Welcome to TechSoup   New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdfWelcome to TechSoup   New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
TechSoup
 
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCECLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
BhavyaRajput3
 
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptx
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptxSynthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptx
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptx
Pavel ( NSTU)
 
Embracing GenAI - A Strategic Imperative
Embracing GenAI - A Strategic ImperativeEmbracing GenAI - A Strategic Imperative
Embracing GenAI - A Strategic Imperative
Peter Windle
 
June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...
June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...
June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...
Levi Shapiro
 
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in EducationA Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
Peter Windle
 
2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...
2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...
2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...
Sandy Millin
 
Biological Screening of Herbal Drugs in detailed.
Biological Screening of Herbal Drugs in detailed.Biological Screening of Herbal Drugs in detailed.
Biological Screening of Herbal Drugs in detailed.
Ashokrao Mane college of Pharmacy Peth-Vadgaon
 
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free downloadThe French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
Vivekanand Anglo Vedic Academy
 
TESDA TM1 REVIEWER FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...
TESDA TM1 REVIEWER  FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...TESDA TM1 REVIEWER  FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...
TESDA TM1 REVIEWER FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...
EugeneSaldivar
 
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdf
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdfThe Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdf
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdf
kaushalkr1407
 
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official PublicationThe Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
Delapenabediema
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptxInstructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
 
Honest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptx
Honest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptxHonest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptx
Honest Reviews of Tim Han LMA Course Program.pptx
 
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech RepublicPolish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
 
678020731-Sumas-y-Restas-Para-Colorear.pdf
678020731-Sumas-y-Restas-Para-Colorear.pdf678020731-Sumas-y-Restas-Para-Colorear.pdf
678020731-Sumas-y-Restas-Para-Colorear.pdf
 
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdfspecial B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
 
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.pptThesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
 
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptxSupporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
 
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
 
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
Welcome to TechSoup   New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdfWelcome to TechSoup   New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
 
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCECLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
 
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptx
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptxSynthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptx
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptx
 
Embracing GenAI - A Strategic Imperative
Embracing GenAI - A Strategic ImperativeEmbracing GenAI - A Strategic Imperative
Embracing GenAI - A Strategic Imperative
 
June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...
June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...
June 3, 2024 Anti-Semitism Letter Sent to MIT President Kornbluth and MIT Cor...
 
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in EducationA Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
 
2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...
2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...
2024.06.01 Introducing a competency framework for languag learning materials ...
 
Biological Screening of Herbal Drugs in detailed.
Biological Screening of Herbal Drugs in detailed.Biological Screening of Herbal Drugs in detailed.
Biological Screening of Herbal Drugs in detailed.
 
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free downloadThe French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
 
TESDA TM1 REVIEWER FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...
TESDA TM1 REVIEWER  FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...TESDA TM1 REVIEWER  FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...
TESDA TM1 REVIEWER FOR NATIONAL ASSESSMENT WRITTEN AND ORAL QUESTIONS WITH A...
 
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdf
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdfThe Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdf
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdf
 
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official PublicationThe Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
 

How to Think and Talk about Education Tax Credits and Vouchers

  • 1. Analysis of data from a unique survey experiment Adam B. Schaeffer, Ph.D. Center for Educational Freedom Cato Institute How to Think and Talk About Education Tax Credits & Vouchers
  • 2. What Messages Work & Why How Do Different Arguments Impact the Expected Effects of Private Choice? Are There Differences Between Effective Voucher & Credit Messages? How to Talk About Private Choice Policies
  • 3. What Policies Were Tested? Vouchers: Government funds paid to families for use in obtaining a private education. Personal Use Tax Credits:Tax credits given to individual taxpayers for education expenditures made on behalf of their own children. Individual Donation Tax Credit:Tax credits given to individual taxpayers for donations to scholarship organizations that support private choice for lower income families. Business Donation Tax Credit:Tax credits given to businesses for donations to scholarship organizations that support private choice for lower income families. Benefit was pegged at $2,700 for all policies (in 2010 dollars).
  • 4. What’s a Message “Frame?” Message Frame: A frame “is a central organizing idea for making sense of relevant events and suggesting what is at issue.” Frames answer the question, “Why?” Why should the public care about the issue in the first place? Why should a citizen do anything about it? Why should a politician do something about it? Why should one solution be adopted rather than another?
  • 5. How Were the Frames Tested? Three messages (Frames, or emphases) were tested in separate combination with vouchers and tax credits. The test was performed like a clinical drug trial; respondents were randomly assigned to one of 6 treatment conditions or one of 2 control groups. Each frame, or emphasis, modified a basic overview of choice policy which noted that; parents will have more control achievement will increase due to competition/choice.
  • 6. What Frames Were Tested? Equity Frame:School choice is presented as a way to make educational opportunities and outcomes for lower-income children more equitable. Financial Frame: School choice is presented as a way to help keep taxes low because private and other schools of choice cost less and parents spend education dollars more wisely than bureaucrats. Moral Values Frame: School choice is presented as a way to help make sure schools teach good values, because parents know best what values their children should learn in school and would be able to choose good schools that teach them.
  • 7. Support for Choice Policies, By Frame(Scale from 1-Strongly Oppose, to 7-Strongly Favor; 4-Neither )
  • 8. So . . . Why Does the Financial Frame Have the Most Consistent Positive Impact? What’s Driving This Response?
  • 9. NOTE: These results are from before the financial crisis. It’s likely financial/cost concerns are even greater today.
  • 10. What Performance Advantages are Most Important? Perceptions of Public vs. Private School Performance
  • 11. Increase in Rating for Local Private Schools Compared to Rating for Local Public School
  • 12. What Do the Regression Models Tell Us? The perception that Private Schools use money more efficiently than Public Schools has the biggest and most consistent positive impact on support for private choice. Perceived differences in academic achievement is second to efficiency and not always significant.
  • 13. What’s Expected and Which Expectations Are Most Important? Anticipated Effects of Private Choice
  • 14. Expected Effect on Property Values Doesn’t Seem to Matter . . .
  • 15. Expected Effect of Private Choice Policies on Property Values in Respondent’s Area(Percent Choosing Decrease, Neither, or Increase)
  • 16. Margin of Respondents Who Expect Policy to Increase Cost, Achievement & Equity(Percent Choosing Increase minus Percent Decrease)
  • 17. What Do the Regression Models Tell Us? The expected effects on academic achievement has the biggest impact on support for private choice policies, followed by; The impact on cost, and The impact on educational equity.
  • 18. Why Do People Think Vouchers Will Cost More?
  • 20. How Do Different Frames Change What the Public Expects?
  • 21. Impact of Frame on Expected Effect Policies Will Have on Educational Costs (Scale from 1-Reduce A Lot, to 7-Increase A Lot; 4-Neither )
  • 22. Impact of Frame on Expected Effect Policies Will Have on Educational Achievement (Scale from 1-Reduce A Lot, to 7-Increase A Lot; 4-Neither )
  • 23. Impact of Frame on Expected Effect Policies Will Have on Educational Equality (Scale from 1-Reduce A Lot, to 7-Increase A Lot; 4-Neither )
  • 24. Party ID Policy Knowledge Parent/Non-Parent Demographics and Support for Private Choice Policy
  • 25. Democratic Margin of Support for Policies(By Knowledge of Policy)
  • 26. Democratic Margin of Support for Vouchers(By Frame & Knowledge of Vouchers)
  • 27. Are Vouchers or Education Tax Credits More Popular? Targeted or Broad-Based?
  • 28. Margin of Support for School Choice Policies(Percent Favor minus Oppose)
  • 29. Margin of Support for Choice Policies (Percent Favor minus Opposition)
  • 30. Margin of Support for Coverage Levels(Percent Support minus Opposition)
  • 31. Emphasize $$ Savings & Academic Improvements Educational Equity Argument Can Help, But Also Cause Blowback! Credits Are More Popular Than Vouchers Broad-Based Coverage Is More Popular Than Targeted Conclusions