SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Katy Hicks, Weber State University
Research Mentors: Dr. Courtney Flint, Dr. Doug Jackson-Smith, Mallory Dolan, Utah State University
Risk Portrayal of the Proposed Lake Powell
Water Pipeline in the News Media
Objectives
•  Contribute to research methods for analyzing
news media.
•  Determine types of stakeholders given voice in
water news coverage of the proposed Lake
Powell water pipeline.
•  Examine how perceived risks associated with
the proposed Lake Powell pipeline are
communicated by different types of
stakeholders by assessing incidents of risk
amplification (intensifying risk concerns) or
attenuation (lowering risk concerns).1
Impact
•  Risk communication through the news media can
shape public perception of risks.
•  Amplifying or attenuating risks can generate ripple
effects of behavioral, social, and economic impacts.
Methodology
•  Pull articles from 2012 and 2013 in The Salt Lake
Tribune regarding the proposed Lake Powell pipeline
in which stakeholders are paraphrased or quoted.
•  Code articles in an excel spreadsheet according to
stakeholder type, risk amplification, attenuation, or
mixed portrayal of risk.
•  Analyze data to quantify stakeholder voice and risk
amplification/attenuation.
IFELLOWS UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH PROGRAM
http://iutahepscor.orgkatlynhicks@mail.weber.edu
Results
http://www.deseretnews.com/article/705284732/Lake-Powell-Pipeline-clears-another-hurdle.html?pg=all
Figure 1. The proposed water pipeline route from Lake Powell
through Kane and Washington counties.
Risk
Event
Information
Flow
Interpretation
and
Response
Spread
of
Impact
Type of
Impact
Figure 2. Flow chart of the social amplification of risk adapted from Kasperson et
al. (1988).1
1 Adapted from Kasperson, R.E., Ortwin, R., Slovic, P., Brown, H.S., Emel,
J., Goble, R., Kasperson J.X., Ratick, S. (1988). The Social Amplification
of Risk: A Conceptual Framework. Risk Analysis, 8 (2)177-187.
http://historytogo.utah.gov/salt_lake_tribune/
Amplification
51%
Attenuation
31%
Mixed
7%
N/A
11%
Figure 3. Proportions of amplification and attenuation of risks associated
with the proposed Lake Powell pipeline.
a Stakeholder types without voice in The Salt Lake Tribune articles
about the proposed Lake Powell pipeline include unaffiliated
individuals, private water providers, tribal organizations, federal
agencies, and the federal government.
•  Overall, risk portrayal of the pipeline was more
amplified than attenuated by stakeholders.
•  Nonprofit and environmental groups had the
biggest voice in pipeline risk amplification.
•  Water districts had the biggest voice in
attenuating risks linked to the proposed pipeline.
Table 1. Stakeholder Risk Portrayal of the Proposed
Lake Powell Pipeline
Stakeholder
Typea
Amplification Attenuation Mixed N/A
Local Municipal/
County
Government
3 3 0 0
Water District 1 11 1 1
Private Business 3 0 0 2
State Government 8 10 3 3
Academic 3 0 0 0
Nonprofit/
Environmental
Group
26 0 0 2
State Agency 0 3 2 2
Other 1 0 0 0
Total 45 27 6 10
!

More Related Content

Similar to HicksKaty_iUTAHPoster_7_8_14

Cross National Newspaper Coverage of Coastal Contamination: A Community Struc...
Cross National Newspaper Coverage of Coastal Contamination: A Community Struc...Cross National Newspaper Coverage of Coastal Contamination: A Community Struc...
Cross National Newspaper Coverage of Coastal Contamination: A Community Struc...
Rebecca Mamrosh
 
Love Canal - Public Health through the lens of the Environmental Movement
Love Canal  - Public Health through the lens of the Environmental MovementLove Canal  - Public Health through the lens of the Environmental Movement
Love Canal - Public Health through the lens of the Environmental Movement
Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai
 
Assessing the vulnerability of different age groups regarding flood fatalities
Assessing the vulnerability of different age groups regarding flood fatalitiesAssessing the vulnerability of different age groups regarding flood fatalities
Assessing the vulnerability of different age groups regarding flood fatalities
Karina Vink
 
Mapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C England
Mapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C EnglandMapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C England
Mapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C England
Kurtis Garbutt
 
Refer to EMAN610 Topic Case Study Research Paper.docx
Refer to EMAN610 Topic Case Study Research Paper.docxRefer to EMAN610 Topic Case Study Research Paper.docx
Refer to EMAN610 Topic Case Study Research Paper.docx
bkbk37
 
Ending Conflicts Over Water: Solutions to Water and Security Challenges
Ending Conflicts Over Water: Solutions to Water and Security ChallengesEnding Conflicts Over Water: Solutions to Water and Security Challenges
Ending Conflicts Over Water: Solutions to Water and Security Challenges
World Resources Institute (WRI)
 
Naim decentralisation benin
Naim decentralisation beninNaim decentralisation benin
Naim decentralisation benin
guru5017
 
Preparing for Abrupt Climate Change: Building Civic Capacity and Overcoming P...
Preparing for Abrupt Climate Change: Building Civic Capacity and Overcoming P...Preparing for Abrupt Climate Change: Building Civic Capacity and Overcoming P...
Preparing for Abrupt Climate Change: Building Civic Capacity and Overcoming P...
Matthew Nisbet
 
Capstone Presentation
Capstone PresentationCapstone Presentation
Capstone Presentation
Kynan Witters-Hicks
 
Inequities in Enviornmental Stressors
Inequities in Enviornmental StressorsInequities in Enviornmental Stressors
Inequities in Enviornmental Stressors
LarryBaker
 
Shoreline Owners Perception study-Sebago Lake
Shoreline Owners Perception study-Sebago LakeShoreline Owners Perception study-Sebago Lake
Shoreline Owners Perception study-Sebago Lake
Jennifer Leonard
 
AdamsDiss.Defense.Nov.2016.FINAL
AdamsDiss.Defense.Nov.2016.FINALAdamsDiss.Defense.Nov.2016.FINAL
AdamsDiss.Defense.Nov.2016.FINAL
Bill Adams
 
social vulnerability to environmental hazards
social vulnerability to environmental hazards social vulnerability to environmental hazards
social vulnerability to environmental hazards
salinnasriworaweat
 
TWJ_feedback interfaces 2016
TWJ_feedback interfaces 2016TWJ_feedback interfaces 2016
TWJ_feedback interfaces 2016
Chelsea Hawkins, Esq.
 
Cross-National Coverage of GMOs Final copy
Cross-National Coverage of GMOs Final copyCross-National Coverage of GMOs Final copy
Cross-National Coverage of GMOs Final copy
Krysti Peitz
 
Upstate Rural New York Residents’ Perceptions of Climate Change
Upstate Rural New York Residents’ Perceptions of Climate ChangeUpstate Rural New York Residents’ Perceptions of Climate Change
Upstate Rural New York Residents’ Perceptions of Climate Change
Cornell University Cooperative Extension, Human Dimensions Research Unit
 
Popeco
PopecoPopeco
Popeco
zjmnzava
 
population ecology
population ecologypopulation ecology
population ecology
imlovestruck
 
Smd Qtr1 population ecology
Smd Qtr1 population ecologySmd Qtr1 population ecology
Smd Qtr1 population ecology
Alyssa Boller
 
Hanson.GIS.DHS_FinalReport.Revised.04.20.2016 (1)
Hanson.GIS.DHS_FinalReport.Revised.04.20.2016 (1)Hanson.GIS.DHS_FinalReport.Revised.04.20.2016 (1)
Hanson.GIS.DHS_FinalReport.Revised.04.20.2016 (1)
Angelina Hanson
 

Similar to HicksKaty_iUTAHPoster_7_8_14 (20)

Cross National Newspaper Coverage of Coastal Contamination: A Community Struc...
Cross National Newspaper Coverage of Coastal Contamination: A Community Struc...Cross National Newspaper Coverage of Coastal Contamination: A Community Struc...
Cross National Newspaper Coverage of Coastal Contamination: A Community Struc...
 
Love Canal - Public Health through the lens of the Environmental Movement
Love Canal  - Public Health through the lens of the Environmental MovementLove Canal  - Public Health through the lens of the Environmental Movement
Love Canal - Public Health through the lens of the Environmental Movement
 
Assessing the vulnerability of different age groups regarding flood fatalities
Assessing the vulnerability of different age groups regarding flood fatalitiesAssessing the vulnerability of different age groups regarding flood fatalities
Assessing the vulnerability of different age groups regarding flood fatalities
 
Mapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C England
Mapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C EnglandMapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C England
Mapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C England
 
Refer to EMAN610 Topic Case Study Research Paper.docx
Refer to EMAN610 Topic Case Study Research Paper.docxRefer to EMAN610 Topic Case Study Research Paper.docx
Refer to EMAN610 Topic Case Study Research Paper.docx
 
Ending Conflicts Over Water: Solutions to Water and Security Challenges
Ending Conflicts Over Water: Solutions to Water and Security ChallengesEnding Conflicts Over Water: Solutions to Water and Security Challenges
Ending Conflicts Over Water: Solutions to Water and Security Challenges
 
Naim decentralisation benin
Naim decentralisation beninNaim decentralisation benin
Naim decentralisation benin
 
Preparing for Abrupt Climate Change: Building Civic Capacity and Overcoming P...
Preparing for Abrupt Climate Change: Building Civic Capacity and Overcoming P...Preparing for Abrupt Climate Change: Building Civic Capacity and Overcoming P...
Preparing for Abrupt Climate Change: Building Civic Capacity and Overcoming P...
 
Capstone Presentation
Capstone PresentationCapstone Presentation
Capstone Presentation
 
Inequities in Enviornmental Stressors
Inequities in Enviornmental StressorsInequities in Enviornmental Stressors
Inequities in Enviornmental Stressors
 
Shoreline Owners Perception study-Sebago Lake
Shoreline Owners Perception study-Sebago LakeShoreline Owners Perception study-Sebago Lake
Shoreline Owners Perception study-Sebago Lake
 
AdamsDiss.Defense.Nov.2016.FINAL
AdamsDiss.Defense.Nov.2016.FINALAdamsDiss.Defense.Nov.2016.FINAL
AdamsDiss.Defense.Nov.2016.FINAL
 
social vulnerability to environmental hazards
social vulnerability to environmental hazards social vulnerability to environmental hazards
social vulnerability to environmental hazards
 
TWJ_feedback interfaces 2016
TWJ_feedback interfaces 2016TWJ_feedback interfaces 2016
TWJ_feedback interfaces 2016
 
Cross-National Coverage of GMOs Final copy
Cross-National Coverage of GMOs Final copyCross-National Coverage of GMOs Final copy
Cross-National Coverage of GMOs Final copy
 
Upstate Rural New York Residents’ Perceptions of Climate Change
Upstate Rural New York Residents’ Perceptions of Climate ChangeUpstate Rural New York Residents’ Perceptions of Climate Change
Upstate Rural New York Residents’ Perceptions of Climate Change
 
Popeco
PopecoPopeco
Popeco
 
population ecology
population ecologypopulation ecology
population ecology
 
Smd Qtr1 population ecology
Smd Qtr1 population ecologySmd Qtr1 population ecology
Smd Qtr1 population ecology
 
Hanson.GIS.DHS_FinalReport.Revised.04.20.2016 (1)
Hanson.GIS.DHS_FinalReport.Revised.04.20.2016 (1)Hanson.GIS.DHS_FinalReport.Revised.04.20.2016 (1)
Hanson.GIS.DHS_FinalReport.Revised.04.20.2016 (1)
 

HicksKaty_iUTAHPoster_7_8_14

  • 1. Katy Hicks, Weber State University Research Mentors: Dr. Courtney Flint, Dr. Doug Jackson-Smith, Mallory Dolan, Utah State University Risk Portrayal of the Proposed Lake Powell Water Pipeline in the News Media Objectives •  Contribute to research methods for analyzing news media. •  Determine types of stakeholders given voice in water news coverage of the proposed Lake Powell water pipeline. •  Examine how perceived risks associated with the proposed Lake Powell pipeline are communicated by different types of stakeholders by assessing incidents of risk amplification (intensifying risk concerns) or attenuation (lowering risk concerns).1 Impact •  Risk communication through the news media can shape public perception of risks. •  Amplifying or attenuating risks can generate ripple effects of behavioral, social, and economic impacts. Methodology •  Pull articles from 2012 and 2013 in The Salt Lake Tribune regarding the proposed Lake Powell pipeline in which stakeholders are paraphrased or quoted. •  Code articles in an excel spreadsheet according to stakeholder type, risk amplification, attenuation, or mixed portrayal of risk. •  Analyze data to quantify stakeholder voice and risk amplification/attenuation. IFELLOWS UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH PROGRAM http://iutahepscor.orgkatlynhicks@mail.weber.edu Results http://www.deseretnews.com/article/705284732/Lake-Powell-Pipeline-clears-another-hurdle.html?pg=all Figure 1. The proposed water pipeline route from Lake Powell through Kane and Washington counties. Risk Event Information Flow Interpretation and Response Spread of Impact Type of Impact Figure 2. Flow chart of the social amplification of risk adapted from Kasperson et al. (1988).1 1 Adapted from Kasperson, R.E., Ortwin, R., Slovic, P., Brown, H.S., Emel, J., Goble, R., Kasperson J.X., Ratick, S. (1988). The Social Amplification of Risk: A Conceptual Framework. Risk Analysis, 8 (2)177-187. http://historytogo.utah.gov/salt_lake_tribune/ Amplification 51% Attenuation 31% Mixed 7% N/A 11% Figure 3. Proportions of amplification and attenuation of risks associated with the proposed Lake Powell pipeline. a Stakeholder types without voice in The Salt Lake Tribune articles about the proposed Lake Powell pipeline include unaffiliated individuals, private water providers, tribal organizations, federal agencies, and the federal government. •  Overall, risk portrayal of the pipeline was more amplified than attenuated by stakeholders. •  Nonprofit and environmental groups had the biggest voice in pipeline risk amplification. •  Water districts had the biggest voice in attenuating risks linked to the proposed pipeline. Table 1. Stakeholder Risk Portrayal of the Proposed Lake Powell Pipeline Stakeholder Typea Amplification Attenuation Mixed N/A Local Municipal/ County Government 3 3 0 0 Water District 1 11 1 1 Private Business 3 0 0 2 State Government 8 10 3 3 Academic 3 0 0 0 Nonprofit/ Environmental Group 26 0 0 2 State Agency 0 3 2 2 Other 1 0 0 0 Total 45 27 6 10 !