SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The Republic of Georgia
I. Social Facts
The Republic of Georgia is a
predominantly urban, low-income, and
Orthodox Christian society. The largest city
in Georgia is the capital Tbilisi. Roughly
twenty percent of the population resides in
Tbilisi, and over half of the Georgian
population lives in urban areas. The median
income is approximately 6,100 USD, and
approximately one-third of Georgians
between ages 15 and 24 are unemployed.
The largest religious group in the
Republic of Georgia is the Georgian
Orthodox Church. Orthodox Christianity
including the Armenian, Georgian, and
Russian Orthodox Churches comprise
approximately 90 percent of Georgian
religious adherents. More than other
Orthodox sects, however, the Georgian
Orthodox Church occupies a distinct cultural
and historic place in Georgian society.
Georgia’s sizeable Azeri minority largely
adheres to Islam, and there is a historic
Roman Catholic presence. Smaller
protestant groups also claim congregations
in Georgia, although these groups comprise
a small percentage of Georgian believers.
Georgia has a small but historic Jewish
community as well. Less than one percent of
Georgians identify as atheists.
Since the early 1990s, the central
government in Tbilisi has not administered
de facto government over the regions of
Abkhazia and South Ossetia. During
Georgia’s 2008 war with the Russian
Federation these regions declared
independence from Georgia. Abkhazian
religious demography shows widespread
adherence to the Abkhazian Orthodox
Church, with sizeable Muslim, atheist, and
neo-pagan minorities. South Ossetia is
similar, with a large Orthodox Christian
majority and smaller Jewish and Muslim
communities.
II. Historical Background
Throughout its history, Georgia acted as
a buffer state between larger powers.
Neighboring Roman, Persian, Arab, and
Russian empires influenced Georgia’s
development throughout its history, but did
not prevent Georgia from developing a
distinct identity. With the exception of
outside a few outside sources, Georgia’s
internal chronicles provide much of its
history until 1783. During much of
antiquity, the current area the state of
Georgia occupies was the home of smaller
nations who spoke distinct but related
dialects. During this time the cult of Mithras
was likely the most widespread religion in
ancient Georgia and the trans-Caucasus.
While Orthodox Christianity eventually
occupied an integral place in Georgian
national identity, some historians link the
iconic Georgian image of St. George on
horseback to Georgia’s past association with
the cult of Mithras.
While Georgia has a long history of
religious diversity, Christianity in particular
played an integral role in Georgia’s history,
specifically in the form of the Georgian
Orthodox Church. A Georgian tradition
holds that devout Jewish Christians brought
Christ’s robe from the Holy Land to Georgia
shortly after Jesus Christ ascended into
heaven. Officially, however, Christianity’s
role as Georgia’s state religion began in the
early fourth century when the Georgian
Orthodox Church consecrated its archbishop
in 335 A.D. Historians note that adopting
Christianity, among other things, was likely
a means of resistance against a resurgent
Persian Empire and its official
Zoroastrianism. The Georgian chronicles
2 GEORGIA
report miraculous healings and other events
as convincing early Georgian kings to
convert to Christianity. Georgia’s
conversion was likely more gradual,
however, but its rulers likely played an
integral part in promoting the new religion
throughout the nation.
Georgian Christianity developed
independently from other branches of
orthodox Christianity, especially in its early
structure. Due to Georgia’s largely rural
population, its Church did not develop along
a governance structure focused in urban
centers as was common in both eastern and
western Christianity. Georgia’s early
Christian period also saw the birth of its
script and first written works as Christian
monks translated religious works into
Georgian, representing significant
developments in early Georgian culture.
A strong Arab presence in the caucuses
during the seventh century caused Georgian
Orthodox Christianity to develop more
independently from other Christian
traditions, and began a period of cultural and
political strength for the Orthodox Church in
Georgia. By the eleventh century, it was the
most politically powerful force in Georgia.
A growing number of Orthodox clergyman
from the Middle East left the Holy Land
during this time, and further enriched
Georgia's religious culture. From the ninth
to the thirteenth centuries, Georgian
Orthodox Christianity flourished as the
predominant cultural influence in Georgia.
When the Mongol Empire conquered the
modern territory of Georgia and the
Ottoman Empire began to dominate the
region, however, Catholic and Islamic
influences began found room to expand in
Georgian society. As the Byzantine Empire
receded and the Ottoman Empire replaced it
Islam made significant inroads into
Georgian culture, although Georgian
Orthodox Christianity remained the most
socially dominant faith during the period. As
the Ottoman Empire's influence grew in the
Caucuses, French Catholic missionary
efforts expanded in the region as well. For
two hundred years beginning in the mid
seventeenth century, Catholicism built a
sizeable religious minority in Georgia and
provided a link to the rest of Europe. The
first printed works in Georgian, for example,
were Catholic missionary tracts.
During this period, traditionalist forces
in Georgia began looking to the growing
Russian Empire to strengthen Orthodoxy's
position in Georgian society. Although
Catholic missionaries were responsible for
the first works printed in the Georgian
language, a printing press in Moscow
produced the first bible printed in Georgian.
Georgia's links to Russia eventually led to
Georgia's absorption into the Empire by
1801.
For the first three decades of its
inclusion the Russian Empire, the Tsars
hoped that the Georgian Orthodox Church
would act as an intermediary between the
Orthodox monarchy and a largely Orthodox
population, much like the Russian Orthodox
Church did at that time. The Georgian
Orthodox hierarchy, however, traditionally
occupied a more influential role in Georgian
government and was less willing to
accommodate Imperial directives than its
Russian counterpart was. As a result, the
Russian Orthodox Church absorbed the
Georgian church in 1811. Thereafter, the
Bishop responsible for the Church in
Georgia was typically a Russian. During the
Russian Imperial period, Georgian Orthodox
Christianity became more like its Russian
counterpart and religious trends in general
followed those of the wider Russian Empire.
Although Georgian religious life moved
along with Russian religious trends, it
remained somewhat independent. When the
Russian Empire collapsed after the First
GEORGIA 3
World War, the Georgian Orthodox Church
regained its independent status. Although
Georgian Orthodoxy became independent of
the Russian Church at this time, public
attitudes towards religion in Georgia
reflected more apathy towards religion than
at any other point in Georgia's prior history,
weakening Georgian Orthodox Church's
social and political influence. When the
Georgian Soviet Socialist Republic became
a republic of the Soviet Union in the 1920s,
however, religion in Georgia faced the same
official persecution religious groups endured
throughout the USSR. The Soviet
government imprisoned much of Georgia's
religious leadership during the 1920s and
1930s, and promulgated its official atheism
throughout Georgia.
During the Second World War, however,
the Soviet Union enlisted the aid of several
traditional religious groups, including the
Georgian Orthodox Church, to strengthen
national resolve. As a result, religious life in
Georgia became more open during the post-
war Soviet period. Like many institutions in
the post-war Soviet Union, however, the
Georgian Orthodox Church succumb to
pervasive corruption. The post-war Soviet
period also saw an increased focus on the
Church’s status in the world from a growing
Georgian diaspora.
After the Soviet Union’s collapse in
1991, the Georgian Orthodox Church
asserted itself in Georgian society by linking
itself to renewed Georgian nationalism.
While the first decade of post-Soviet
independence began with weak public
institutions throughout Georgian society, the
Georgian Orthodox Church presented a pre-
Soviet and even pre-Russian link to a unique
Georgian identity. Eduard Shevardnadze’s
election 1995 began a period of increased
isolationism and Georgian nationalism, and
the Georgian Orthodox Church became a
component of the new nationalism. During
this time, the Georgian government signed a
concordant agreement granting the Georgian
Orthodox Church special legal privileges,
and the Church adopted a more anti-western,
isolationist perspective.
Georgia’s 2003 rose revolution occurred
out of popular frustration with ineffective
and corrupt institutions, and reversed the
country’s previous anti-western, anti-global
perspective. Despite the value and policy
shifts of the Rose Revolution, the Georgian
Orthodox Church retained its post-Soviet
isolationist position and remains a principle
conservative force in Georgian society.
During the early twenty-first century, the
Church also maintained close relations with
the Russian Orthodox Church, even as
Georgian Society became more western.
Even after the 2008 war with the Russian
Federation, the Georgian Orthodox Church
maintained ties with the Russian Orthodox
Church and continues to have a presence in
the breakaway regions of Abkhazia and
South Ossetia.
III. Legal Sources and Basic
Approaches to Religion and Belief
The Republic of Georgia articulates
separation between religion and the State in
the text of its Constitution, but this
separation is more often honored in the
breach. It also establishes a privileged space
for the Georgian Orthodox Church. Article
9, clause 1 of the Georgian Constitution
declares “complete freedom of belief and
religion.” It also recognizes the “special
role of the Apostle Autocephalous Orthodox
Church of Georgia in the history of its
independence from the state.” Clause 2
states a “constitutional agreement” will
determine the relationship between the
Georgian Orthodox Church and the
Georgian Government. Article 73, clause 1,
section a states that the President of Georgia
shall “conclude a constitutional agreement”
4 GEORGIA
with the Georgian Orthodox Church. This
agreement gives the Georgian Orthodox
Church favorable tax and legal privileges
such as immunity for the Patriarch,
exemptions for clergy from military service,
and government subsidies. No other
religious group enjoys a legal status on par
with the Georgian Orthodox Church.
Georgian statutory law also expresses
freedom of religion. Georgia’s criminal
code, for example, prohibits religious
discrimination and hate crime in a variety of
ways. Article 109 punishes homicide
motivated by religious or ethnic intolerance
by a prison term of up to fifteen years.
Intentional damage to another’s health for
the same motivation warrants a sentence of
twelve years, and Article 126 punishes
torture committed with the same motivation.
Chapter XIII begins with Article 142’s
prohibition on violating another individual’s
human rights and freedoms as well.
Articles 155 and 156 in particular
address criminal prohibitions on interfering
in a religious right and religious persecution.
Violently interfering in religious rites or
insulting religious sensitivities. Persecuting
others for their religious beliefs is also
punishable with imprisonment and fines.
Other provisions prohibit preventing the
creation of religious organizations or unions,
desecrating religious burial sites, and
committing terrorism or genocide for
religious motivations.
The combination of Georgia’s
constitutional provisions on religion and
related legislation creates a tired system of
religious organizations. Religious
organizations can incorporate themselves as
“legal entities of public law” or “legal
entities of private law.” While both statuses
give religious organizations legal rights and
privileges, legal entities of public law enjoy
a higher legal status than legal entities of
private law. The Georgian Orthodox
Church, for example, is a legal entity of
public law.
While the Georgian Orthodox Church
enjoys a uniquely privileged status, the
Georgian Constitution articulates values
consistent with religious freedom. Article 14
of the constitution guarantees that all
citizens are free and equal before the law
regardless of numerous characteristics,
including religion. Article 19 further
protects religious freedom. Clause 1 states
that everyone has the right to freedom of
speech, thought, conscience, religion, and
belief. Clause 2 prohibits religious
persecution, and Clause 3 limits the
protection of religious freedom so that they
do not infringe “upon the rights of others.”
Georgian administrative law provides
unequal protection and opportunities for
Georgia’s religious minorities. Until 2011,
for example, only the Georgian Orthodox
Church could access prisoners in the
Georgian corrections system. However, the
Minster of Corrections now allows minority
religions to access their adherents in prison.
Minority religious groups also face
administrative obstacles in the course of
conducting their activities. Jehovah’s
Witnesses, for example, often face
procedural difficulties in obtaining
permission to construct new buildings. A
Muslim congregation recently faced similar
problems when Georgian customs officials
temporarily blocked the delivery of a
minaret skeleton manufactured in Turkey.
Georgian customs officials detained it for
alleged customs irregularities.
Education policy also reflects
administrative difficulties for minority
religious groups. The Georgian Ministry of
Education operates under conflicting laws,
creating an administrative dilemma within
Georgia’s public school system. While
Georgian classes traditionally began with
GEORGIA 5
prayer, Parliament passed a law secularizing
the education system. The Georgian
Orthodox Church’s elevated status,
however, may trump parliamentary actions
or administrative decisions. Regardless,
school prayer remains common in Georgia
and minority religious receive little to no
accommodation.
As a signatory to the European
Convention on Human Rights, the European
Court on Human Rights’ jurisprudence
binds Georgia as well, and its jurisprudence
speaks to religious freedom in Georgia
specifically. Begheluri and others v.
Georgia, for example, arose out of thirty
cases of persecution against Jehovah’s
Witnesses in Georgia. Much of this
persecution resulted from the work of a
fundamentalist Georgian Orthodox group
led by a priest named Father Basil. These
episodes of persecution fall into three
categories; incidents involving Georgian
authorities’ participation, incidents in which
Georgian authorities failed to protect
Jehovah’s Witnesses from violence, and
incidents where Georgian authorities had
little or no involvement. The plaintiffs
alleged that this treatment amounted to
violations of Article 3 (prohibition on
torture, inhuman, or degrading treatment and
punishment), Article 9 (protection of
religious freedom and thought), Article 13
(right to a remedy), and Article 14
(prohibition of discrimination based on race,
religion, sex, or other immutable
characteristics) of the European Convention
on Human Rights.
The Georgian government argued that
the Jehovah’s Witnesses’ claims were highly
exaggerated and that the Georgian criminal
justice system provided adequate remedies
to any actual offenses. The Court held,
however, that the Jehovah’s Witnesses
suffered a violation of Article 3 because of
the authorities’ “systematic practice” of
participation and compliance with
persecution of Jehovah’s Witnesses. These
actions also prevented the Jehovah’s
Witnesses from exercising their rights under
Article 9, and constituted a violation of
Article 14.
IV. Individual Freedom of Religion
or Belief
Georgian statutory law enshrines
equality before the law regardless of, among
other things, religious belief. The law does
not, however, provide many exceptions for
religious objectors. Clause 3 of Article 14 of
the Constitution limits religious freedom so
that they do not infringe “upon the rights of
others.”
Conscientious objection to military
service is a primary source of important
constitutional rulings on individual freedom
of religion. In 2011, the Georgian
Constitutional Court heard five cases from
Jehovah’s Witnesses who objected to
compulsory military service. In two of the
cases, the Court found in favor of the
objectors. While the plain text of Georgia’s
law on Military Reserve Service does not
discriminate against religious pacifists,
Georgian state prosecutors often used it to
compel conscientious objectors into military
service or used to impose criminal sanctions
against them. Within Georgia’s military
service statute, the only state religious
exemption belongs to Georgian Orthodox
clergy. The Constitutional Court found that
sections of the law on Military Reserve
Service conflicted with Articles 14 and 19 of
the Constitution, and therefore
unconstitutional.
V. The Legal Status of Religious
Communities
The Georgian Orthodox Church’s
concordant agreement with the Georgian
government. Modeled after the concordant
6 GEORGIA
agreements between the Catholic Church
and governments around the world. In some
senses, it resembles an arrangement between
two sovereigns rather than an agreement
between a government and a domestic entity
because of its superiority to other legislation
should a conflict between the concordant
agreement and other domestic law arise. The
Georgian Orthodox Church enjoys unique
privileges like the power to perform legally
recognized marriages, an exemption for its
clergy from military service, immunity for
the Georgian Orthodox Patriarch, and a
tendency towards affirming the Orthodox
Church’s property rights.
The Roman Catholic Church attempted
to reach a similar agreement with the
Georgian government in 2003, but failed to
do so. Although the Catholic Church
claimed 50,000 members in Georgia at the
time, only the Georgian Orthodox Church
enjoyed legal personality. While President
Shevardnadze expressed his support at the
time, a popular campaign the Orthodox
Church organized against recognizing the
Catholic Church is the likely reason the
agreement failed.
Despite the Orthodox Church’s
opposition, the Georgian civil code now
allows religious groups to become legal
entities. Article 1506 provided the first
avenue of legal incorporation by allowing
religious organizations to organize
themselves as funds or unions. While
religious organizations had some avenue of
legal incorporation, Article 1506 presented
only a narrow range of options for Georgia’s
religious organizations.
Georgia’s Parliament later amended civil
code article 1509 to allow religious groups
to organize themselves as legal persons of
public law or private law, as discussed
above. This allows religious groups to own
property, open their own bank accounts, and
go to court in their own names. Article 1153
prohibits religious discrimination in
“domestic relation” as well. Although
Article 1509 gives religious organizations
the ability to organize as legal entities,
specific issues like financing, when religious
entities and the government may cooperate,
and military exemptions for clergymen
remain unresolved in Georgia’s statutory
law.
Only registered entities may own
property, open bank accounts, or bring
matters before a court in their own names.
While the Georgian Orthodox Church is
incorporated as an entity of public law, other
religious organizations only have the option
of incorporating themselves as legal entities
of private law. This groups them with
entities such as secular non-governmental
entities, and may create difficulties for them
as they register for legal status. One
requirement to register as an entity of
private law, for example, is to list the
organizations founding members in Georgia.
For religious groups with a long history in
Georgia like the Catholic Church or
Georgian Muslim congregations this can
create an awkward situation. Membership
criteria is also a requirement for registration,
and can create similarly difficult situations
for some groups.
VI. Religious Autonomy
After Georgian religious groups
achieve legal entity status it is unclear the
amount of autonomy the law grants them. In
one respect, the law does not specifically
address how much autonomy religious
groups enjoy. With the exception of the
Orthodox Church’s unique legal status,
religious groups exist in the legal space also
reserved for non-profit, non-governmental
organizations who are largely autonomous
to pursue their aims within the greater
confines of Georgian law.
GEORGIA 7
In another respect, however,
minority religious groups face extra-legal
threats to their autonomy. As was the case in
Begheluri and others v. Georgia, Jehovah’s
Witnesses were unable fully exercise their
religious rights in part because of
government complacency with popular
persecution. The traditionally Muslim region
of Ajaria near the Georgia-Turkey border
experienced a wave of conversions to
Orthodox Christianity in part because
membership in the Georgian Orthodox
Church is considered a necessary component
of Georgian identity. This social trend
towards linking Georgian identity with the
Orthodox Church restricts the power
religious groups have to, in the case of the
Jehovah’s Witnesses, conduct their own
business or, in the case of Ajairan Muslims,
ensure the survival of their religious
community.
VII. Education
The role of Georgian Orthodox
Christianity in Georgia’s public school
system, as previously mentioned, is a legal
controversy. The traditional practice,
however, is to include Orthodox doctrine
into the public school curriculum. Minority
religious do not enjoy this same privilege.
Despite this tradition, the Ministry of
Education is statutorily obligated to provide
a secular education.
Georgia’s law on freedom of
conscience leaves religious instruction to
religious organizations, and protects the
ability of parents to pass their faith to their
children. The law also protects religious
groups’ ability to establish schools of
religious instruction. The Georgian
Orthodox Church, however, operates Tbel
Abuseridze State University and Saint
Andrews University while other religious
groups do not operate educational intuitions
on a similar scale.
VIII. Religion and Personnel
Matters
The Georgian Constitution forbids
religious discrimination in Article 14. The
increasingly public role of the Georgian
Orthodox Church and what scholar Ayşegül
Aydıngün calls the “depriviatization” of
religion, however, questions the amount of
actual protection religious minorities enjoy.
Georgian statutory law, however,
forbids religious discrimination in the
workplace. Section 17 forbids religious
preferences in hiring practices, and section
75 prohibits religious preferences in
compensating employees. As is the case
throughout Georgian statutory law, the law
does not contain many religious exceptions,
and Georgian labor law does not provide
special provisions to accommodate religious
practices or beliefs outside the social
mainstream.
IX. Finance
The tax code defines religious
organizations as conducting charitable
activities. Article 9 exempts both religious
and charitable activities from taxation as
“economic activities.” Article 10 also
includes religious organizations as charitable
activities. This only applies to recognized
religious organizations, however. Article
99(d) exempts any profits made from the
sale of religious paraphernalia by the
Georgian Orthodox Church. In practice, the
tax code applies religious exemptions
unequally. All religious groups but the
Georgian Orthodox Church pay taxes on
religious items, value added taxes, import
taxes, and taxes related construction and
restoration.
As is the case throughout Georgia’s
law regarding religion, the Georgian
Orthodox Church enjoys unique privileges.
8 GEORGIA
The Tax Inspectorate of the Ministry of
Finance grants legal entities of private law a
“basic level” status while legal entities of
public law (i.e. the Georgian Orthodox
Church) enjoys special tax exemptions.
Although Article IX of the
Constitution articulates a separation between
the state and religion, the Republic of
Georgia provides significant financial
assistance to the Georgian Orthodox Church.
Much of this funding comes in the form of
financial assistance to the Orthodox
Church’s Tbel Abuseridze State University
and in-kind donations from the government
to the Orthodox Church. Observes estimate
that the government provided approximately
13.6 million USD in 2012. Other religious
groups do not enjoy such financial support.
X. Religious Assistance in and
Access to Public Institutions
Per a separate agreement between
the Ministry of Justice and the Georgian
Orthodox Patriarchate, the Orthodox Church
enjoys special access to Georgia’s prisons.
Only clergy from the Georgian Orthodox
Church, for example, serve as prison
chaplains. While other religious groups may
access their adherents in prison, the
Orthodox clergy within the prison typically
supervise all interactions between prisoners
and religious personnel.
Religious organizations occupy
contradictory legal space within the
Georgian education system. On one hand,
the 2005 General Education law recognized
the independence of public education from
religious education. This is a large step away
from the prior practice of beginning class
with mandatory prayer in the Georgian
Orthodox tradition. On the other hand, the
Orthodox Church’s concordant agreement is
legally superior to normal legislation and
may therefore render such measures
unconstitutional. Three months before the
Georgian Parliament passed the General
Education Law, the Ministry of Education
agreed with the Orthodox Patriarch that the
Orthodox Church’s would retain an
important role in public education. This
created a contradictory situation in which
the rights of students belonging to minority
religions and the Orthodox Church are both
unclear.
XI. Religion and Family Matters
The Georgian Orthodox Church is
unique in that it is the only religious
organization with the ability to legal ability
to perform civilly binding marriages. Civil
registrars must perform all other legal
marriages.
Other church positions on family law
issues do not have the same legal effect.
Abortion is legal and widely utilized in
Georgia despite the Orthodox Church’s
opposition. Divorce is also widely
acceptable in Georgia despite the Orthodox
Church’s doctrine against opposing divorce
and no provision within the Orthodox
Church’s doctrine for divorce. Georgia’s
Muslim community employs arranged
marriages, but this is only a social
convention.
Regardless of religion, Georgian society
is predominately patriarchal. This creates
gender imbalances within Georgia across all
religious groups. Other trends transcend
religious divides as well. Contraception, for
example, is prohibitively expensive for most
Georgian families. This makes abortion the
most common form of birth control despite
the opposition of Georgia’s largest religious
groups.
XII. Religion and Criminal Law
and Other Public Regulations
Other than the Georgian Orthodox
Church’s power to conduct legally binding
GEORGIA 9
marriage ceremonies, religious ceremonies
do not carry legal force in Georgia. The
Georgian government’s efforts to return
properties taken during the Soviet period
represent largest area in which public
regulations affect religious organizations. In
this effort, the government shows favoritism
toward the Georgian Orthodox Church in
addressing its claims. For example, the
Georgian Orthodox Church and the Roman
Catholic Church contest ownership over five
properties. Despite the conflicting claims,
the Georgian Orthodox Church legally
controls those properties. While the
government typically acts promptly to
secure the Orthodox Church’s property
claims, the Armenian Orthodox Church and
Georgian Muslim congregations find more
delays in enforcing their claims.
Select Bibliography and Leading
Documents
Periodicals
Aydıngün, Ayşegül. "The ethnification and
nationalisation of religion in the post-Soviet
Georgian nation-state building process: a
source of discrimination and minority rights
violations?." The International Journal of
Human Rights 17, no. 7-8 (2013): 810-828.
"Bad Location." The Economist, May 24,
2012.
Liles, Thomas. "Islam and Religious
Transformation in Adjara." (2012).
Seminar, UniDem. "European Commission
for Democracy through law (Venice
commission)." PhD diss., Universidade de
Coimbra, 2005.
Tsintsadze, Khatuna. "Legal Aspects of
Church-State Relations in Post-
Revolutionary Georgia." BYU L.
Rev. (2007): 751.
Legislative Documents
Law of the Republic of Georgia on Citizenship
of Georgia, as amended 24.06.2004
International Agreements
Council of Europe, European Convention
for the Protection of Human Rights and
Fundamental Freedoms, as amended by
Protocols Nos. 11 and 14, 4 November 1950
Cases
Begheluri and others v. Georgia (App. No.
28490/02) (2014)
Internet Sources
Emery, Robert E. Cultural Sociology of
Divorce: An Encyclopedia, Volume 1, pages
492-495, 2013.
"Georgia." CIA: The Word Factbook.
Accessed June 1, 2015.
"Georgia's Mighty Orthodox Church." BBC
News, July 2, 2013.
Kyrlov, Aleksandr. "The Religious Situation
in Abkhazia." Abkhaz World. February 25,
1998. Accessed June 1, 2015.

More Related Content

What's hot

POPE FRANCIS
POPE FRANCISPOPE FRANCIS
POPE FRANCIS
VarunSanthosh2
 
Response To My Dear Friend Floyd
Response To My Dear Friend FloydResponse To My Dear Friend Floyd
Response To My Dear Friend Floyd
Daniel H
 
George washington the christian
George washington the christianGeorge washington the christian
George washington the christian
GLENN PEASE
 
Sample_Watson1
Sample_Watson1Sample_Watson1
Sample_Watson1
Navar Watson
 
Chapter 6 theo
Chapter 6 theoChapter 6 theo
Chapter 6 theo
Madeline Schmidt
 
10 Quotes from Pope Francis on Leadership, Politics, and Religion
10 Quotes from Pope Francis on Leadership, Politics, and Religion10 Quotes from Pope Francis on Leadership, Politics, and Religion
10 Quotes from Pope Francis on Leadership, Politics, and Religion
Image Books
 
Vocation of Laity
Vocation of LaityVocation of Laity
Vocation of Laity
Denise Angelica Saldajeno
 
Why Orchard Lake? Overview of Challenges and Opportunities
Why Orchard Lake? Overview of Challenges and OpportunitiesWhy Orchard Lake? Overview of Challenges and Opportunities
Why Orchard Lake? Overview of Challenges and Opportunities
Joseph Serwach
 
RELIGION
RELIGIONRELIGION
RELIGION
jeymaykah
 
Russian orthodox christmas
Russian orthodox christmasRussian orthodox christmas
Russian orthodox christmas
Irina Yankovskaya
 
Brad religion & traditions
Brad religion & traditionsBrad religion & traditions
Brad religion & traditions
bru027
 
Celtic art
Celtic artCeltic art
Celtic art
Helena Nikiforova
 
Bushkovitch-article-Muslims
Bushkovitch-article-MuslimsBushkovitch-article-Muslims
Bushkovitch-article-Muslims
sinekdokha
 
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared ResourceSociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
sociologyexchange.co.uk
 
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared ResourceSociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
sociologyexchange.co.uk
 
Lecture 3, Christ Against Culture
Lecture 3, Christ Against CultureLecture 3, Christ Against Culture
Lecture 3, Christ Against Culture
COACH International Ministries
 
A260111
A260111A260111
Historical account of christian conversions in india
Historical account of christian conversions in indiaHistorical account of christian conversions in india
Historical account of christian conversions in india
Domenic Marbaniang
 

What's hot (18)

POPE FRANCIS
POPE FRANCISPOPE FRANCIS
POPE FRANCIS
 
Response To My Dear Friend Floyd
Response To My Dear Friend FloydResponse To My Dear Friend Floyd
Response To My Dear Friend Floyd
 
George washington the christian
George washington the christianGeorge washington the christian
George washington the christian
 
Sample_Watson1
Sample_Watson1Sample_Watson1
Sample_Watson1
 
Chapter 6 theo
Chapter 6 theoChapter 6 theo
Chapter 6 theo
 
10 Quotes from Pope Francis on Leadership, Politics, and Religion
10 Quotes from Pope Francis on Leadership, Politics, and Religion10 Quotes from Pope Francis on Leadership, Politics, and Religion
10 Quotes from Pope Francis on Leadership, Politics, and Religion
 
Vocation of Laity
Vocation of LaityVocation of Laity
Vocation of Laity
 
Why Orchard Lake? Overview of Challenges and Opportunities
Why Orchard Lake? Overview of Challenges and OpportunitiesWhy Orchard Lake? Overview of Challenges and Opportunities
Why Orchard Lake? Overview of Challenges and Opportunities
 
RELIGION
RELIGIONRELIGION
RELIGION
 
Russian orthodox christmas
Russian orthodox christmasRussian orthodox christmas
Russian orthodox christmas
 
Brad religion & traditions
Brad religion & traditionsBrad religion & traditions
Brad religion & traditions
 
Celtic art
Celtic artCeltic art
Celtic art
 
Bushkovitch-article-Muslims
Bushkovitch-article-MuslimsBushkovitch-article-Muslims
Bushkovitch-article-Muslims
 
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared ResourceSociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
 
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared ResourceSociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
 
Lecture 3, Christ Against Culture
Lecture 3, Christ Against CultureLecture 3, Christ Against Culture
Lecture 3, Christ Against Culture
 
A260111
A260111A260111
A260111
 
Historical account of christian conversions in india
Historical account of christian conversions in indiaHistorical account of christian conversions in india
Historical account of christian conversions in india
 

Viewers also liked

Ростелеком. Александр Карпузиков. "Развитие сервисов по защите от DDoS атак: ...
Ростелеком. Александр Карпузиков. "Развитие сервисов по защите от DDoS атак: ...Ростелеком. Александр Карпузиков. "Развитие сервисов по защите от DDoS атак: ...
Ростелеком. Александр Карпузиков. "Развитие сервисов по защите от DDoS атак: ...
Expolink
 
Magazine styling
Magazine stylingMagazine styling
Magazine styling
charlottehosie
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
Skye17262923
 
Teorias del desarrollo
Teorias del desarrolloTeorias del desarrollo
Teorias del desarrollo
AlejandraNYA
 
Portfolio Peter Hogan '15
Portfolio Peter Hogan '15Portfolio Peter Hogan '15
Portfolio Peter Hogan '15
Peter Hogan
 

Viewers also liked (7)

Ростелеком. Александр Карпузиков. "Развитие сервисов по защите от DDoS атак: ...
Ростелеком. Александр Карпузиков. "Развитие сервисов по защите от DDoS атак: ...Ростелеком. Александр Карпузиков. "Развитие сервисов по защите от DDoS атак: ...
Ростелеком. Александр Карпузиков. "Развитие сервисов по защите от DDoS атак: ...
 
CSSAC
CSSACCSSAC
CSSAC
 
Magazine styling
Magazine stylingMagazine styling
Magazine styling
 
BCSS
BCSSBCSS
BCSS
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
 
Teorias del desarrollo
Teorias del desarrolloTeorias del desarrollo
Teorias del desarrollo
 
Portfolio Peter Hogan '15
Portfolio Peter Hogan '15Portfolio Peter Hogan '15
Portfolio Peter Hogan '15
 

Similar to Georgia ELR Article

The State, Religion and Belief
The State, Religion and BeliefThe State, Religion and Belief
The State, Religion and Belief
diversityforum2011
 
Asian church an overview
Asian church an overview Asian church an overview
Asian church an overview
Bigbrother Ajith
 
155© The Author(s) 2019J.-F. Caron (ed.), Kazakhstan and the.docx
155© The Author(s) 2019J.-F. Caron (ed.), Kazakhstan and the.docx155© The Author(s) 2019J.-F. Caron (ed.), Kazakhstan and the.docx
155© The Author(s) 2019J.-F. Caron (ed.), Kazakhstan and the.docx
novabroom
 
orthodox church in russia.pptx
orthodox church in russia.pptxorthodox church in russia.pptx
orthodox church in russia.pptx
PrashantBhardwaj266153
 
Workingpaper52WHY DID KING FASILÄDÄS KILL HIS BROTHER ? SHARING POWER IN THE...
Workingpaper52WHY DID KING FASILÄDÄS KILL HIS BROTHER ?  SHARING POWER IN THE...Workingpaper52WHY DID KING FASILÄDÄS KILL HIS BROTHER ?  SHARING POWER IN THE...
Workingpaper52WHY DID KING FASILÄDÄS KILL HIS BROTHER ? SHARING POWER IN THE...
Ethio-Afric News en Views Media!!
 
A Bibliography on Christianity in Ethiopia
A Bibliography on Christianity in  EthiopiaA Bibliography on Christianity in  Ethiopia
A Bibliography on Christianity in Ethiopia
Ethio-Afric News en Views Media!!
 
Final Paper Relg.Intl.Aff 4
Final Paper Relg.Intl.Aff 4Final Paper Relg.Intl.Aff 4
Final Paper Relg.Intl.Aff 4
Enayat Younes
 
Jürg Widmer Probst Guatemala special feature: religion in Guatemala | Jürg Wi...
Jürg Widmer Probst Guatemala special feature: religion in Guatemala | Jürg Wi...Jürg Widmer Probst Guatemala special feature: religion in Guatemala | Jürg Wi...
Jürg Widmer Probst Guatemala special feature: religion in Guatemala | Jürg Wi...
Jürg Widmer Probst
 
ReligionThe Power of SocietyCan a person’s.docx
ReligionThe Power of SocietyCan a person’s.docxReligionThe Power of SocietyCan a person’s.docx
ReligionThe Power of SocietyCan a person’s.docx
audeleypearl
 
The following just needs a reply to atleast 100 wordsInstructor .docx
The following just needs a reply to atleast 100 wordsInstructor .docxThe following just needs a reply to atleast 100 wordsInstructor .docx
The following just needs a reply to atleast 100 wordsInstructor .docx
mallisonshavon
 
4.1 CulturalRussiaonly.pptx
4.1 CulturalRussiaonly.pptx4.1 CulturalRussiaonly.pptx
4.1 CulturalRussiaonly.pptx
Pinecrest Academy Nevada
 
Brazil's Charismatic Catholic and Pentecostal population
Brazil's Charismatic Catholic and Pentecostal populationBrazil's Charismatic Catholic and Pentecostal population
Brazil's Charismatic Catholic and Pentecostal population
mila veilleux
 
NCERT Solutions for Understanding Secularism Class 8 Notes
NCERT Solutions for Understanding Secularism Class 8 NotesNCERT Solutions for Understanding Secularism Class 8 Notes
NCERT Solutions for Understanding Secularism Class 8 Notes
Vivekanand Anglo Vedic Academy
 
This weeks readings pertain to the ways in which post-Soviet Cent.docx
This weeks readings pertain to the ways in which post-Soviet Cent.docxThis weeks readings pertain to the ways in which post-Soviet Cent.docx
This weeks readings pertain to the ways in which post-Soviet Cent.docx
juliennehar
 
islamfinal
islamfinalislamfinal
islamfinal
Dylan Farley
 
6-Whitaker Tonghak Rebellion 10
6-Whitaker Tonghak Rebellion 106-Whitaker Tonghak Rebellion 10
6-Whitaker Tonghak Rebellion 10
Mark Whitaker
 
The Lost History of Christianity - There's so much more than thought!
The Lost History of Christianity - There's so much more than thought!The Lost History of Christianity - There's so much more than thought!
The Lost History of Christianity - There's so much more than thought!
Frank
 
Christianity and korean culture
Christianity and  korean cultureChristianity and  korean culture
Christianity and korean culture
Hankuk University of Foreign Studies
 

Similar to Georgia ELR Article (18)

The State, Religion and Belief
The State, Religion and BeliefThe State, Religion and Belief
The State, Religion and Belief
 
Asian church an overview
Asian church an overview Asian church an overview
Asian church an overview
 
155© The Author(s) 2019J.-F. Caron (ed.), Kazakhstan and the.docx
155© The Author(s) 2019J.-F. Caron (ed.), Kazakhstan and the.docx155© The Author(s) 2019J.-F. Caron (ed.), Kazakhstan and the.docx
155© The Author(s) 2019J.-F. Caron (ed.), Kazakhstan and the.docx
 
orthodox church in russia.pptx
orthodox church in russia.pptxorthodox church in russia.pptx
orthodox church in russia.pptx
 
Workingpaper52WHY DID KING FASILÄDÄS KILL HIS BROTHER ? SHARING POWER IN THE...
Workingpaper52WHY DID KING FASILÄDÄS KILL HIS BROTHER ?  SHARING POWER IN THE...Workingpaper52WHY DID KING FASILÄDÄS KILL HIS BROTHER ?  SHARING POWER IN THE...
Workingpaper52WHY DID KING FASILÄDÄS KILL HIS BROTHER ? SHARING POWER IN THE...
 
A Bibliography on Christianity in Ethiopia
A Bibliography on Christianity in  EthiopiaA Bibliography on Christianity in  Ethiopia
A Bibliography on Christianity in Ethiopia
 
Final Paper Relg.Intl.Aff 4
Final Paper Relg.Intl.Aff 4Final Paper Relg.Intl.Aff 4
Final Paper Relg.Intl.Aff 4
 
Jürg Widmer Probst Guatemala special feature: religion in Guatemala | Jürg Wi...
Jürg Widmer Probst Guatemala special feature: religion in Guatemala | Jürg Wi...Jürg Widmer Probst Guatemala special feature: religion in Guatemala | Jürg Wi...
Jürg Widmer Probst Guatemala special feature: religion in Guatemala | Jürg Wi...
 
ReligionThe Power of SocietyCan a person’s.docx
ReligionThe Power of SocietyCan a person’s.docxReligionThe Power of SocietyCan a person’s.docx
ReligionThe Power of SocietyCan a person’s.docx
 
The following just needs a reply to atleast 100 wordsInstructor .docx
The following just needs a reply to atleast 100 wordsInstructor .docxThe following just needs a reply to atleast 100 wordsInstructor .docx
The following just needs a reply to atleast 100 wordsInstructor .docx
 
4.1 CulturalRussiaonly.pptx
4.1 CulturalRussiaonly.pptx4.1 CulturalRussiaonly.pptx
4.1 CulturalRussiaonly.pptx
 
Brazil's Charismatic Catholic and Pentecostal population
Brazil's Charismatic Catholic and Pentecostal populationBrazil's Charismatic Catholic and Pentecostal population
Brazil's Charismatic Catholic and Pentecostal population
 
NCERT Solutions for Understanding Secularism Class 8 Notes
NCERT Solutions for Understanding Secularism Class 8 NotesNCERT Solutions for Understanding Secularism Class 8 Notes
NCERT Solutions for Understanding Secularism Class 8 Notes
 
This weeks readings pertain to the ways in which post-Soviet Cent.docx
This weeks readings pertain to the ways in which post-Soviet Cent.docxThis weeks readings pertain to the ways in which post-Soviet Cent.docx
This weeks readings pertain to the ways in which post-Soviet Cent.docx
 
islamfinal
islamfinalislamfinal
islamfinal
 
6-Whitaker Tonghak Rebellion 10
6-Whitaker Tonghak Rebellion 106-Whitaker Tonghak Rebellion 10
6-Whitaker Tonghak Rebellion 10
 
The Lost History of Christianity - There's so much more than thought!
The Lost History of Christianity - There's so much more than thought!The Lost History of Christianity - There's so much more than thought!
The Lost History of Christianity - There's so much more than thought!
 
Christianity and korean culture
Christianity and  korean cultureChristianity and  korean culture
Christianity and korean culture
 

Georgia ELR Article

  • 1. The Republic of Georgia I. Social Facts The Republic of Georgia is a predominantly urban, low-income, and Orthodox Christian society. The largest city in Georgia is the capital Tbilisi. Roughly twenty percent of the population resides in Tbilisi, and over half of the Georgian population lives in urban areas. The median income is approximately 6,100 USD, and approximately one-third of Georgians between ages 15 and 24 are unemployed. The largest religious group in the Republic of Georgia is the Georgian Orthodox Church. Orthodox Christianity including the Armenian, Georgian, and Russian Orthodox Churches comprise approximately 90 percent of Georgian religious adherents. More than other Orthodox sects, however, the Georgian Orthodox Church occupies a distinct cultural and historic place in Georgian society. Georgia’s sizeable Azeri minority largely adheres to Islam, and there is a historic Roman Catholic presence. Smaller protestant groups also claim congregations in Georgia, although these groups comprise a small percentage of Georgian believers. Georgia has a small but historic Jewish community as well. Less than one percent of Georgians identify as atheists. Since the early 1990s, the central government in Tbilisi has not administered de facto government over the regions of Abkhazia and South Ossetia. During Georgia’s 2008 war with the Russian Federation these regions declared independence from Georgia. Abkhazian religious demography shows widespread adherence to the Abkhazian Orthodox Church, with sizeable Muslim, atheist, and neo-pagan minorities. South Ossetia is similar, with a large Orthodox Christian majority and smaller Jewish and Muslim communities. II. Historical Background Throughout its history, Georgia acted as a buffer state between larger powers. Neighboring Roman, Persian, Arab, and Russian empires influenced Georgia’s development throughout its history, but did not prevent Georgia from developing a distinct identity. With the exception of outside a few outside sources, Georgia’s internal chronicles provide much of its history until 1783. During much of antiquity, the current area the state of Georgia occupies was the home of smaller nations who spoke distinct but related dialects. During this time the cult of Mithras was likely the most widespread religion in ancient Georgia and the trans-Caucasus. While Orthodox Christianity eventually occupied an integral place in Georgian national identity, some historians link the iconic Georgian image of St. George on horseback to Georgia’s past association with the cult of Mithras. While Georgia has a long history of religious diversity, Christianity in particular played an integral role in Georgia’s history, specifically in the form of the Georgian Orthodox Church. A Georgian tradition holds that devout Jewish Christians brought Christ’s robe from the Holy Land to Georgia shortly after Jesus Christ ascended into heaven. Officially, however, Christianity’s role as Georgia’s state religion began in the early fourth century when the Georgian Orthodox Church consecrated its archbishop in 335 A.D. Historians note that adopting Christianity, among other things, was likely a means of resistance against a resurgent Persian Empire and its official Zoroastrianism. The Georgian chronicles
  • 2. 2 GEORGIA report miraculous healings and other events as convincing early Georgian kings to convert to Christianity. Georgia’s conversion was likely more gradual, however, but its rulers likely played an integral part in promoting the new religion throughout the nation. Georgian Christianity developed independently from other branches of orthodox Christianity, especially in its early structure. Due to Georgia’s largely rural population, its Church did not develop along a governance structure focused in urban centers as was common in both eastern and western Christianity. Georgia’s early Christian period also saw the birth of its script and first written works as Christian monks translated religious works into Georgian, representing significant developments in early Georgian culture. A strong Arab presence in the caucuses during the seventh century caused Georgian Orthodox Christianity to develop more independently from other Christian traditions, and began a period of cultural and political strength for the Orthodox Church in Georgia. By the eleventh century, it was the most politically powerful force in Georgia. A growing number of Orthodox clergyman from the Middle East left the Holy Land during this time, and further enriched Georgia's religious culture. From the ninth to the thirteenth centuries, Georgian Orthodox Christianity flourished as the predominant cultural influence in Georgia. When the Mongol Empire conquered the modern territory of Georgia and the Ottoman Empire began to dominate the region, however, Catholic and Islamic influences began found room to expand in Georgian society. As the Byzantine Empire receded and the Ottoman Empire replaced it Islam made significant inroads into Georgian culture, although Georgian Orthodox Christianity remained the most socially dominant faith during the period. As the Ottoman Empire's influence grew in the Caucuses, French Catholic missionary efforts expanded in the region as well. For two hundred years beginning in the mid seventeenth century, Catholicism built a sizeable religious minority in Georgia and provided a link to the rest of Europe. The first printed works in Georgian, for example, were Catholic missionary tracts. During this period, traditionalist forces in Georgia began looking to the growing Russian Empire to strengthen Orthodoxy's position in Georgian society. Although Catholic missionaries were responsible for the first works printed in the Georgian language, a printing press in Moscow produced the first bible printed in Georgian. Georgia's links to Russia eventually led to Georgia's absorption into the Empire by 1801. For the first three decades of its inclusion the Russian Empire, the Tsars hoped that the Georgian Orthodox Church would act as an intermediary between the Orthodox monarchy and a largely Orthodox population, much like the Russian Orthodox Church did at that time. The Georgian Orthodox hierarchy, however, traditionally occupied a more influential role in Georgian government and was less willing to accommodate Imperial directives than its Russian counterpart was. As a result, the Russian Orthodox Church absorbed the Georgian church in 1811. Thereafter, the Bishop responsible for the Church in Georgia was typically a Russian. During the Russian Imperial period, Georgian Orthodox Christianity became more like its Russian counterpart and religious trends in general followed those of the wider Russian Empire. Although Georgian religious life moved along with Russian religious trends, it remained somewhat independent. When the Russian Empire collapsed after the First
  • 3. GEORGIA 3 World War, the Georgian Orthodox Church regained its independent status. Although Georgian Orthodoxy became independent of the Russian Church at this time, public attitudes towards religion in Georgia reflected more apathy towards religion than at any other point in Georgia's prior history, weakening Georgian Orthodox Church's social and political influence. When the Georgian Soviet Socialist Republic became a republic of the Soviet Union in the 1920s, however, religion in Georgia faced the same official persecution religious groups endured throughout the USSR. The Soviet government imprisoned much of Georgia's religious leadership during the 1920s and 1930s, and promulgated its official atheism throughout Georgia. During the Second World War, however, the Soviet Union enlisted the aid of several traditional religious groups, including the Georgian Orthodox Church, to strengthen national resolve. As a result, religious life in Georgia became more open during the post- war Soviet period. Like many institutions in the post-war Soviet Union, however, the Georgian Orthodox Church succumb to pervasive corruption. The post-war Soviet period also saw an increased focus on the Church’s status in the world from a growing Georgian diaspora. After the Soviet Union’s collapse in 1991, the Georgian Orthodox Church asserted itself in Georgian society by linking itself to renewed Georgian nationalism. While the first decade of post-Soviet independence began with weak public institutions throughout Georgian society, the Georgian Orthodox Church presented a pre- Soviet and even pre-Russian link to a unique Georgian identity. Eduard Shevardnadze’s election 1995 began a period of increased isolationism and Georgian nationalism, and the Georgian Orthodox Church became a component of the new nationalism. During this time, the Georgian government signed a concordant agreement granting the Georgian Orthodox Church special legal privileges, and the Church adopted a more anti-western, isolationist perspective. Georgia’s 2003 rose revolution occurred out of popular frustration with ineffective and corrupt institutions, and reversed the country’s previous anti-western, anti-global perspective. Despite the value and policy shifts of the Rose Revolution, the Georgian Orthodox Church retained its post-Soviet isolationist position and remains a principle conservative force in Georgian society. During the early twenty-first century, the Church also maintained close relations with the Russian Orthodox Church, even as Georgian Society became more western. Even after the 2008 war with the Russian Federation, the Georgian Orthodox Church maintained ties with the Russian Orthodox Church and continues to have a presence in the breakaway regions of Abkhazia and South Ossetia. III. Legal Sources and Basic Approaches to Religion and Belief The Republic of Georgia articulates separation between religion and the State in the text of its Constitution, but this separation is more often honored in the breach. It also establishes a privileged space for the Georgian Orthodox Church. Article 9, clause 1 of the Georgian Constitution declares “complete freedom of belief and religion.” It also recognizes the “special role of the Apostle Autocephalous Orthodox Church of Georgia in the history of its independence from the state.” Clause 2 states a “constitutional agreement” will determine the relationship between the Georgian Orthodox Church and the Georgian Government. Article 73, clause 1, section a states that the President of Georgia shall “conclude a constitutional agreement”
  • 4. 4 GEORGIA with the Georgian Orthodox Church. This agreement gives the Georgian Orthodox Church favorable tax and legal privileges such as immunity for the Patriarch, exemptions for clergy from military service, and government subsidies. No other religious group enjoys a legal status on par with the Georgian Orthodox Church. Georgian statutory law also expresses freedom of religion. Georgia’s criminal code, for example, prohibits religious discrimination and hate crime in a variety of ways. Article 109 punishes homicide motivated by religious or ethnic intolerance by a prison term of up to fifteen years. Intentional damage to another’s health for the same motivation warrants a sentence of twelve years, and Article 126 punishes torture committed with the same motivation. Chapter XIII begins with Article 142’s prohibition on violating another individual’s human rights and freedoms as well. Articles 155 and 156 in particular address criminal prohibitions on interfering in a religious right and religious persecution. Violently interfering in religious rites or insulting religious sensitivities. Persecuting others for their religious beliefs is also punishable with imprisonment and fines. Other provisions prohibit preventing the creation of religious organizations or unions, desecrating religious burial sites, and committing terrorism or genocide for religious motivations. The combination of Georgia’s constitutional provisions on religion and related legislation creates a tired system of religious organizations. Religious organizations can incorporate themselves as “legal entities of public law” or “legal entities of private law.” While both statuses give religious organizations legal rights and privileges, legal entities of public law enjoy a higher legal status than legal entities of private law. The Georgian Orthodox Church, for example, is a legal entity of public law. While the Georgian Orthodox Church enjoys a uniquely privileged status, the Georgian Constitution articulates values consistent with religious freedom. Article 14 of the constitution guarantees that all citizens are free and equal before the law regardless of numerous characteristics, including religion. Article 19 further protects religious freedom. Clause 1 states that everyone has the right to freedom of speech, thought, conscience, religion, and belief. Clause 2 prohibits religious persecution, and Clause 3 limits the protection of religious freedom so that they do not infringe “upon the rights of others.” Georgian administrative law provides unequal protection and opportunities for Georgia’s religious minorities. Until 2011, for example, only the Georgian Orthodox Church could access prisoners in the Georgian corrections system. However, the Minster of Corrections now allows minority religions to access their adherents in prison. Minority religious groups also face administrative obstacles in the course of conducting their activities. Jehovah’s Witnesses, for example, often face procedural difficulties in obtaining permission to construct new buildings. A Muslim congregation recently faced similar problems when Georgian customs officials temporarily blocked the delivery of a minaret skeleton manufactured in Turkey. Georgian customs officials detained it for alleged customs irregularities. Education policy also reflects administrative difficulties for minority religious groups. The Georgian Ministry of Education operates under conflicting laws, creating an administrative dilemma within Georgia’s public school system. While Georgian classes traditionally began with
  • 5. GEORGIA 5 prayer, Parliament passed a law secularizing the education system. The Georgian Orthodox Church’s elevated status, however, may trump parliamentary actions or administrative decisions. Regardless, school prayer remains common in Georgia and minority religious receive little to no accommodation. As a signatory to the European Convention on Human Rights, the European Court on Human Rights’ jurisprudence binds Georgia as well, and its jurisprudence speaks to religious freedom in Georgia specifically. Begheluri and others v. Georgia, for example, arose out of thirty cases of persecution against Jehovah’s Witnesses in Georgia. Much of this persecution resulted from the work of a fundamentalist Georgian Orthodox group led by a priest named Father Basil. These episodes of persecution fall into three categories; incidents involving Georgian authorities’ participation, incidents in which Georgian authorities failed to protect Jehovah’s Witnesses from violence, and incidents where Georgian authorities had little or no involvement. The plaintiffs alleged that this treatment amounted to violations of Article 3 (prohibition on torture, inhuman, or degrading treatment and punishment), Article 9 (protection of religious freedom and thought), Article 13 (right to a remedy), and Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination based on race, religion, sex, or other immutable characteristics) of the European Convention on Human Rights. The Georgian government argued that the Jehovah’s Witnesses’ claims were highly exaggerated and that the Georgian criminal justice system provided adequate remedies to any actual offenses. The Court held, however, that the Jehovah’s Witnesses suffered a violation of Article 3 because of the authorities’ “systematic practice” of participation and compliance with persecution of Jehovah’s Witnesses. These actions also prevented the Jehovah’s Witnesses from exercising their rights under Article 9, and constituted a violation of Article 14. IV. Individual Freedom of Religion or Belief Georgian statutory law enshrines equality before the law regardless of, among other things, religious belief. The law does not, however, provide many exceptions for religious objectors. Clause 3 of Article 14 of the Constitution limits religious freedom so that they do not infringe “upon the rights of others.” Conscientious objection to military service is a primary source of important constitutional rulings on individual freedom of religion. In 2011, the Georgian Constitutional Court heard five cases from Jehovah’s Witnesses who objected to compulsory military service. In two of the cases, the Court found in favor of the objectors. While the plain text of Georgia’s law on Military Reserve Service does not discriminate against religious pacifists, Georgian state prosecutors often used it to compel conscientious objectors into military service or used to impose criminal sanctions against them. Within Georgia’s military service statute, the only state religious exemption belongs to Georgian Orthodox clergy. The Constitutional Court found that sections of the law on Military Reserve Service conflicted with Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution, and therefore unconstitutional. V. The Legal Status of Religious Communities The Georgian Orthodox Church’s concordant agreement with the Georgian government. Modeled after the concordant
  • 6. 6 GEORGIA agreements between the Catholic Church and governments around the world. In some senses, it resembles an arrangement between two sovereigns rather than an agreement between a government and a domestic entity because of its superiority to other legislation should a conflict between the concordant agreement and other domestic law arise. The Georgian Orthodox Church enjoys unique privileges like the power to perform legally recognized marriages, an exemption for its clergy from military service, immunity for the Georgian Orthodox Patriarch, and a tendency towards affirming the Orthodox Church’s property rights. The Roman Catholic Church attempted to reach a similar agreement with the Georgian government in 2003, but failed to do so. Although the Catholic Church claimed 50,000 members in Georgia at the time, only the Georgian Orthodox Church enjoyed legal personality. While President Shevardnadze expressed his support at the time, a popular campaign the Orthodox Church organized against recognizing the Catholic Church is the likely reason the agreement failed. Despite the Orthodox Church’s opposition, the Georgian civil code now allows religious groups to become legal entities. Article 1506 provided the first avenue of legal incorporation by allowing religious organizations to organize themselves as funds or unions. While religious organizations had some avenue of legal incorporation, Article 1506 presented only a narrow range of options for Georgia’s religious organizations. Georgia’s Parliament later amended civil code article 1509 to allow religious groups to organize themselves as legal persons of public law or private law, as discussed above. This allows religious groups to own property, open their own bank accounts, and go to court in their own names. Article 1153 prohibits religious discrimination in “domestic relation” as well. Although Article 1509 gives religious organizations the ability to organize as legal entities, specific issues like financing, when religious entities and the government may cooperate, and military exemptions for clergymen remain unresolved in Georgia’s statutory law. Only registered entities may own property, open bank accounts, or bring matters before a court in their own names. While the Georgian Orthodox Church is incorporated as an entity of public law, other religious organizations only have the option of incorporating themselves as legal entities of private law. This groups them with entities such as secular non-governmental entities, and may create difficulties for them as they register for legal status. One requirement to register as an entity of private law, for example, is to list the organizations founding members in Georgia. For religious groups with a long history in Georgia like the Catholic Church or Georgian Muslim congregations this can create an awkward situation. Membership criteria is also a requirement for registration, and can create similarly difficult situations for some groups. VI. Religious Autonomy After Georgian religious groups achieve legal entity status it is unclear the amount of autonomy the law grants them. In one respect, the law does not specifically address how much autonomy religious groups enjoy. With the exception of the Orthodox Church’s unique legal status, religious groups exist in the legal space also reserved for non-profit, non-governmental organizations who are largely autonomous to pursue their aims within the greater confines of Georgian law.
  • 7. GEORGIA 7 In another respect, however, minority religious groups face extra-legal threats to their autonomy. As was the case in Begheluri and others v. Georgia, Jehovah’s Witnesses were unable fully exercise their religious rights in part because of government complacency with popular persecution. The traditionally Muslim region of Ajaria near the Georgia-Turkey border experienced a wave of conversions to Orthodox Christianity in part because membership in the Georgian Orthodox Church is considered a necessary component of Georgian identity. This social trend towards linking Georgian identity with the Orthodox Church restricts the power religious groups have to, in the case of the Jehovah’s Witnesses, conduct their own business or, in the case of Ajairan Muslims, ensure the survival of their religious community. VII. Education The role of Georgian Orthodox Christianity in Georgia’s public school system, as previously mentioned, is a legal controversy. The traditional practice, however, is to include Orthodox doctrine into the public school curriculum. Minority religious do not enjoy this same privilege. Despite this tradition, the Ministry of Education is statutorily obligated to provide a secular education. Georgia’s law on freedom of conscience leaves religious instruction to religious organizations, and protects the ability of parents to pass their faith to their children. The law also protects religious groups’ ability to establish schools of religious instruction. The Georgian Orthodox Church, however, operates Tbel Abuseridze State University and Saint Andrews University while other religious groups do not operate educational intuitions on a similar scale. VIII. Religion and Personnel Matters The Georgian Constitution forbids religious discrimination in Article 14. The increasingly public role of the Georgian Orthodox Church and what scholar Ayşegül Aydıngün calls the “depriviatization” of religion, however, questions the amount of actual protection religious minorities enjoy. Georgian statutory law, however, forbids religious discrimination in the workplace. Section 17 forbids religious preferences in hiring practices, and section 75 prohibits religious preferences in compensating employees. As is the case throughout Georgian statutory law, the law does not contain many religious exceptions, and Georgian labor law does not provide special provisions to accommodate religious practices or beliefs outside the social mainstream. IX. Finance The tax code defines religious organizations as conducting charitable activities. Article 9 exempts both religious and charitable activities from taxation as “economic activities.” Article 10 also includes religious organizations as charitable activities. This only applies to recognized religious organizations, however. Article 99(d) exempts any profits made from the sale of religious paraphernalia by the Georgian Orthodox Church. In practice, the tax code applies religious exemptions unequally. All religious groups but the Georgian Orthodox Church pay taxes on religious items, value added taxes, import taxes, and taxes related construction and restoration. As is the case throughout Georgia’s law regarding religion, the Georgian Orthodox Church enjoys unique privileges.
  • 8. 8 GEORGIA The Tax Inspectorate of the Ministry of Finance grants legal entities of private law a “basic level” status while legal entities of public law (i.e. the Georgian Orthodox Church) enjoys special tax exemptions. Although Article IX of the Constitution articulates a separation between the state and religion, the Republic of Georgia provides significant financial assistance to the Georgian Orthodox Church. Much of this funding comes in the form of financial assistance to the Orthodox Church’s Tbel Abuseridze State University and in-kind donations from the government to the Orthodox Church. Observes estimate that the government provided approximately 13.6 million USD in 2012. Other religious groups do not enjoy such financial support. X. Religious Assistance in and Access to Public Institutions Per a separate agreement between the Ministry of Justice and the Georgian Orthodox Patriarchate, the Orthodox Church enjoys special access to Georgia’s prisons. Only clergy from the Georgian Orthodox Church, for example, serve as prison chaplains. While other religious groups may access their adherents in prison, the Orthodox clergy within the prison typically supervise all interactions between prisoners and religious personnel. Religious organizations occupy contradictory legal space within the Georgian education system. On one hand, the 2005 General Education law recognized the independence of public education from religious education. This is a large step away from the prior practice of beginning class with mandatory prayer in the Georgian Orthodox tradition. On the other hand, the Orthodox Church’s concordant agreement is legally superior to normal legislation and may therefore render such measures unconstitutional. Three months before the Georgian Parliament passed the General Education Law, the Ministry of Education agreed with the Orthodox Patriarch that the Orthodox Church’s would retain an important role in public education. This created a contradictory situation in which the rights of students belonging to minority religions and the Orthodox Church are both unclear. XI. Religion and Family Matters The Georgian Orthodox Church is unique in that it is the only religious organization with the ability to legal ability to perform civilly binding marriages. Civil registrars must perform all other legal marriages. Other church positions on family law issues do not have the same legal effect. Abortion is legal and widely utilized in Georgia despite the Orthodox Church’s opposition. Divorce is also widely acceptable in Georgia despite the Orthodox Church’s doctrine against opposing divorce and no provision within the Orthodox Church’s doctrine for divorce. Georgia’s Muslim community employs arranged marriages, but this is only a social convention. Regardless of religion, Georgian society is predominately patriarchal. This creates gender imbalances within Georgia across all religious groups. Other trends transcend religious divides as well. Contraception, for example, is prohibitively expensive for most Georgian families. This makes abortion the most common form of birth control despite the opposition of Georgia’s largest religious groups. XII. Religion and Criminal Law and Other Public Regulations Other than the Georgian Orthodox Church’s power to conduct legally binding
  • 9. GEORGIA 9 marriage ceremonies, religious ceremonies do not carry legal force in Georgia. The Georgian government’s efforts to return properties taken during the Soviet period represent largest area in which public regulations affect religious organizations. In this effort, the government shows favoritism toward the Georgian Orthodox Church in addressing its claims. For example, the Georgian Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholic Church contest ownership over five properties. Despite the conflicting claims, the Georgian Orthodox Church legally controls those properties. While the government typically acts promptly to secure the Orthodox Church’s property claims, the Armenian Orthodox Church and Georgian Muslim congregations find more delays in enforcing their claims. Select Bibliography and Leading Documents Periodicals Aydıngün, Ayşegül. "The ethnification and nationalisation of religion in the post-Soviet Georgian nation-state building process: a source of discrimination and minority rights violations?." The International Journal of Human Rights 17, no. 7-8 (2013): 810-828. "Bad Location." The Economist, May 24, 2012. Liles, Thomas. "Islam and Religious Transformation in Adjara." (2012). Seminar, UniDem. "European Commission for Democracy through law (Venice commission)." PhD diss., Universidade de Coimbra, 2005. Tsintsadze, Khatuna. "Legal Aspects of Church-State Relations in Post- Revolutionary Georgia." BYU L. Rev. (2007): 751. Legislative Documents Law of the Republic of Georgia on Citizenship of Georgia, as amended 24.06.2004 International Agreements Council of Europe, European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, as amended by Protocols Nos. 11 and 14, 4 November 1950 Cases Begheluri and others v. Georgia (App. No. 28490/02) (2014) Internet Sources Emery, Robert E. Cultural Sociology of Divorce: An Encyclopedia, Volume 1, pages 492-495, 2013. "Georgia." CIA: The Word Factbook. Accessed June 1, 2015. "Georgia's Mighty Orthodox Church." BBC News, July 2, 2013. Kyrlov, Aleksandr. "The Religious Situation in Abkhazia." Abkhaz World. February 25, 1998. Accessed June 1, 2015.