Introduce yourself, auditing contractors 4 years.The industry has changed. In order to evaluate companies better. Need to start looking at more than financial information Look at also at how the information is being producedOne of the ways to do that, look at internal controls.
Summarize the above three points
I have used the word internal controls a couple times now…Cite the three examples shownThese are just some basic examples, we will go into more detail later on.
So why is this more important than say three years ago?Companies are downsizing and reorganizing.Especially true of administrative staff, companies looking to cut overhead.Employees responsible for multiple functions.Employees spending less time checking information.Maybe information is getting to management before it gets reviewed.This all speaks to reliability of financial informationLet’s face it, employees are under lots of pressure to produce good numbersGive an example of the underbillingThis would not have happened had the CEO of CFO been looking in detail.
- Now why would a bond holder or surety care about all this?It all speaks to reliability of financial information When you get those financial statements…Feel better about the information you are basing your bonding capacity on.If processes are in place, you can feel better about how company is run-If you talk to your client and find that everything is reviewed…It can give you some insight into how management is running their company.Committed to producing accurate and reliable financial information.
Most of the time you are getting financial statements from someone like us, a public accounting firm.Comes in a nice cover, has a report in the front saying the numbers are good.Why care about the processes in place to produce that information? Isn’t this all you need?Well I’m going to give you guys a piece of insider information, we don’t look at everythingPut in a lot of effort, but the financial statements will not be perfect at predicting information.This is especially true of estimates like estimated costs at completion.When we perform a audit, get an idea what controls are in place then do a walkthrough.Reviews and comps, nothing is done with internal controls.Even if you get financial statements from a public accounting firm, you still have to satisfy yourself your self.A good way to do that is evaluate the system put in place to produce that information.Mention the SAS 115 letter
Well lucky for you all, we will now go into how to determine the effectiveness of your clients internal controls.If you look at the handouts we have provided you, you can see we have developed a comprehensive checklist.Broken these out into three categories” minimum, expected, and best in class.
First up are the basic minimum controls. Should be present for any companyAre duties properly segregated? Are there conflicting duties? Authorization, recording, and custody.Give the kiting exampleReconciliation of general ledger accounts. Easy for these to get out of synch.Reviewing A/R for collectability. Even for state receivables, are they factoring in long delays to cash flow.Cash flow management, everyone does this. Is it effective? Early pay?
Next up are the expected controls. We would expect to these present at most companies.Looking at WIPS? Contract values, estimated costs, large underbillings, unusual margins.Mentioned spreadsheet errors as it relates to WIP schedules.Frequent communicationPurchasing and job costs. Approval needed. Process to make sure items get charged to the correct job and periodDoes someone review time cards. Look at employee rosters to make sure someone hasn’t set up a ghost employee.Accruing payroll properly at the end of the year?
These are what we consider to be above and beyond or “best in class”Cross trained to perform multiple functions. As staff sizes decrease, have to be dynamic. Will everything still operate smoothly?Can you only purchase from pre-established vendors? A common fraud is phony vendors.Systematic application of overhead. Labor hours? A systematic approach? Think high and low margin jobs.Finally, any control can be improved by greater separation and management involvement. Independent review of WIP? Reviewing overhead cost pool?
So after you have evaluated your client’s internal controls using the checklist provided, you may find…Even items are present or not, it is all about your comfort level with the information they are giving you.Have them explain how they are producing good / accurate financial information.At that point, you can make suggestions that would make you more comfortable with the information being provided.