Final project submitted towards completion of requirements associated with the MOOC on Unlocking Finance and Investment in Emerging Markets and Developing Economies
1. Financial Inclusion in
Gloria
SUBMITTED TOWARDS FINAL PROJECT FOR THE MOOC RELATED TO
UNLOCKING INVESTMENT AND FINANCE IN EMERGING MARKETS AND
DEVELOPING ECONOMIES
2. The Scenario
I am a government official in the Ministry of Finance in an imaginary
Emerging Market country named Gloria, whose currency is called Glory (1
US Dollar (USD) = 70 Glories)
The year is 2014. Gloria’s economic and demographic characteristics are
similar to India in 2014.
A new government has just been elected
One of its major planks in the general election was financial inclusion
The Government has declared that one year from now, i.e. from mid-2015
commercial banks need to be able to roll out zero-balance bank accounts for
people earning less than 50,000 glories per annum
60% of the bank transactions are carried out by public sector banks and the
Ministry of Finance is accountable for their financial health
3. The estimated financing need
The bank accounts should target women as the priority customer and each bank
account should have the following features:
Zero balance
A debit card using the payments interface promoted by the Central Bank of Gloria
Accident insurance worth two years annual income of the account owner or the main
bread-earner of the family with an upper cap of 50,000 glories
An overdraft facility for account owners who act as small entrepreneurs to the extent of
5,000 glories
Target is to open 100 million accounts over two three years, with public sector
banks accounting for 80% of the target, i.e. 80 million accounts
From inception to operation, it would take about 60 USD to setup the
infrastructure, open and maintain each account, bringing the total expense to 60*
80 million = USD 4.8 billion, the estimated financing need
4. Sources of finance available and mode of access
The major sources of finance available are:
Domestic
Public - Government of Gloria (GoG) can infuse capital in the public sector banks
However, if the total amount is sourced in that manner, the Government will fall foul of the Fiscal
Responsibility Act since fiscal deficit would be much greater than the 3% of GDP cap that the Act
imposes on the government in normal economic circumstances
While the GoG’s debt to GDP ratio is about 60%, it’s credit rating is not low enough for the interest
rates to be really cheap. So, while debt can provide partial funding, it cannot be used as the sole source
Private - Private sector banks can be coaxed and cajoled to increase their targets from 20 million
accounts to 40 million accounts since they can source money from Gloria’s strong equity market
International
Public - Ask for Official Development Assistance (ODA) from friendly nations like Japan and USA
who would be willing to help out in such a noble cause
Private - Partner with international institutions like IFC to tap sources like impact investors who
would be interested through the equity infusion route
5. How to address barriers to get impact investors to
invest?
The impact picture
Promoting financial inclusion in one of the largest economies of the world,
especially for women
The returns picture
Public sector banks average profitability has been about 8% over the last five
years, much better than the returns available in developed markets
The risks picture
International executives have rated Gloria as excellent on political stability,
macroeconomic conditions and the regulatory environment. However, they
have concerns with the legal environment since it takes a long time to enforce
contracts in case there is a breach
Apart from taking IFC’s help in working with the private investors, GoG can
use MIGA’s insurance products to provide guarantees to impact investors
in case their investment run into any legal hurdles