Post 2nd round Elections
            Power Structure in Egypt– Post Elections
                           Draft 2.0

This is a draft - please let me know your thoughts /comments so I can update the document
   The purpose of this document is to highlight some facts about the political
    power structure in Egypt,

   This document provides a map of the main power centers in Egypt including
    the Hire/Fire command chain post 2nd round elections and the latest
    announcements from SCAF,

   The document proposes some objectives for the post elections (transition)
    period,

   This document has the initial power center analysis (pre elections, as well as
    the two post elections scenarios (moved to the end) for reference.
Both are fighting to dominate
Egypt for a long period..

And both are welling to do
WHATEVER It takes to control
Egypt
If you want the best for your future,
If you want hope for your kids,
 and the best for Egypt..
            Let us continue to balance the power
               and establish a creative conflict between the two powers
If you want the best for your future,
If you want hope for your kids,
 and the best for Egypt..
             Let us continue to balance the power
                and establish a creative conflict between the two powers
 Remember what we planned for before the
  Elections -
“In any scenario, El-Thawra has to play a major
  role to defend the Loser and control the
  Winner’s power grab during the transition
  period.”
 Now, I think we should support SCAF to make
  sure they have enough power to stay in the
  game
Informal
                                                                                                                     Powers
                                                                                                               (no hire /fire Authority)


                President
                                                                            Parliament
                                                              Judicial


                                                                                                     Corrupt              Corrupt
Defense                                                    Constitutional
                                                                                            Hire     Business             officials
                                                              Court
Minister                                          Admin.
                          Hire /Fire




                                                   Court
                                                                Fire only
                                                                                 Constitutional
                                                                                                        MB                      Corrupt
                                                                                     Panel
                                                                                  (100 Person)         Militia                   Police
 SCAF


                                                                                                      Ultras              Melyoneyyat
                       Prime
                      Minister
                                                                                                     Sabba7y                 Private
                                                                                                     /A.Fotoh                Media
           Interior                    National
            affairs                    Security

                                                                Presidential Control
           Official
           Media               Intelligence
                                                                SCAF                                   People/Revolution

                                                                MB                                     Hire or Fire Authority
                                                                International /regional Influence is outside the focus of this analysis
Egypt’s Selected Scenario –                                                 Before SCAF Announcement
Thawra has to support SCAF
                                                                 This is the scenario we expected (if Moursi won) without
to protect the constitution                                      the recent SCAF announcements. In yellow the big yellow
and people’s freedom (my                                         bubble on the left was our plan if Moursi got elected.
proposed plan – pre elections)




                                                                                                                   Informal
                                                                                                                    Powers
                     President                                                                                (no hire /fire Authority)

                                                                                Parliament
                                                                  Judicial


                                                                                                    Corrupt              Corrupt
   Defense                                                     Constitutional
                                                                                             Hire   Business             officials
                                                                  Court
   Minister                                           Admin.
                              Hire /Fire




                                                       Court
                                                                    Fire only
                                                                                  Constitutional
                                                                                                       MB                      Corrupt
                                                                                      Panel
                                                                                   (100 Person)       Militia                   Police
     SCAF


                                                                                                     Ultras              Melyoneyyat
                           Prime
                          Minister
                                                                                                    Sabba7y                 Private
                                                                                                    /A.Fotoh                Media
               Interior                    National
                affairs                    Security

                                                                    Presidential Control              SCAF and moving to MB
               Official
                               Intelligence
               Media
                                                                    SCAF                             People/Revolution

                                                                    MB                                Hire or Fire Authority
Egypt’s Selected Scenario –                                              After SCAF Announcement
Thawra has to support                                       SCAF was proactive (did not wait for our support) to
SCAF to protect                                             protect themselves from MB (expected). I truly believe it is
                                                            the best for Egypt. This is the power of the creative
minorities, constitution, an                                balance between the two powers. It puts both of them in
d people’s freedom                                          defensive mode that helps Egypt’s cause.
                                                                                 Balance the Powers

                                                                                                              Informal
                   Assumption*                  President                                                      Powers
                                                                                                         (no hire /fire Authority)
                 Parliament
                                                                                               Corrupt              Corrupt
  Defense                                                                                      Business             officials
  Minister
                                                                                                  MB                      Corrupt
                                                                                                 Militia                   Police
     SCAF           Judicial                                        Prime
                                                                   Minister

         Hire
                   Admin.      Constitutional           Interior          National              Ultras              Melyoneyyat
Constitutional      Court         Court                  affairs          Security
    Panel
 (100 Person)
                                                                                               Sabba7y                 Private
                                                        Official        Intelligence                                   Media
                                                                                               /A.Fotoh
                                                        Media
 •Assuming MB will get most of the seats
 in the coming re-elections
                                                                 Presidential Control              SCAF and moving to MB

                                                                 SCAF                             People/Revolution
                                                                 MB                               Hire or Fire Authority
   Separate Military from State -   to protect themselves


   Assigning the Constitution Council (to protect the
    new constitution, minorities, and freedom from
    MB) – to protect us

   I think we should support these changes and
    adding them to the permanent constitution. This
    is the only way (in my mind) we can maintain a
    meaningful power balance between MB and SCAF
   Please read more about the Turkish model
    and the involvement of the military in politics.

   And compare it to what SCAF has announced
    for Egypt.
   Our only hope for a better future is to always
    work/vote to maintain the power balance
    between MB and SCAF,

   Now as MB got the presidential seat our focus
    should be to support SCAF in separating the
    military from the state and controlling the
    Constitution,

   This get us closer to the Turkish Political Model
    which is one of very few successful political
    models in the Islamic world.
“They that fight for freedom undertake the
  noblest cause mankind can have at stake”
   The struggle for our Freedom will start with the voting
Thanks a lot to all of you who provided ideas/feedback and help



The original (Pre Election) Scenario slides will follow for your reference
Pre Elections -Scenario One - SCAF
                                                             In this case, Thawra has
                                                             to support MB and stop
                                                             SCAF from changing the
                                                             Parliament
                                                                                                               Informal
                                                                                                                Powers
                                                                                                          (no hire /fire Authority)


                President
                                                                            Parliament
                                                              Judicial


                                                                                                Corrupt              Corrupt
Defense                                                    Constitutional
                                                                                         Hire   Business             officials
                                                              Court
Minister                                          Admin.
                          Hire /Fire




                                                   Court
                                                                Fire only
                                                                              Constitutional
                                                                                                   MB                      Corrupt
                                                                                  Panel
                                                                               (100 Person)       Militia                   Police
 SCAF


                                                                                                 Ultras              Melyoneyyat
                       Prime
                      Minister
                                                                                                Sabba7y                 Private
                                                                                                /A.Fotoh                Media
           Interior                    National
            affairs                    Security

                                                                Presidential Control
           Official
           Media               Intelligence
                                                                SCAF                             People/Revolution

                                                                MB                                Hire or Fire Authority
Pre Elections - Scenario Two - MB
Thawra has to support
SCAF to protect the
constitution and people’s
freedom
                                                                                                                Informal
                                                                                                                 Powers
                                                                                                           (no hire /fire Authority)


                 President
                                                                             Parliament
                                                               Judicial


                                                                                                 Corrupt              Corrupt
 Defense                                                    Constitutional
                                                                                          Hire   Business             officials
                                                               Court
 Minister                                          Admin.
                           Hire /Fire




                                                    Court
                                                                 Fire only
                                                                               Constitutional
                                                                                                    MB                      Corrupt
                                                                                   Panel
                                                                                (100 Person)       Militia                   Police
  SCAF


                                                                                                  Ultras              Melyoneyyat
                        Prime
                       Minister
                                                                                                 Sabba7y                 Private
                                                                                                 /A.Fotoh                Media
            Interior                    National
             affairs                    Security

                                                                 Presidential Control              SCAF and moving to MB
            Official
                            Intelligence
            Media
                                                                 SCAF                             People/Revolution

                                                                 MB                                Hire or Fire Authority

Egypt post elections 2012 power structure-1

  • 1.
    Post 2nd roundElections Power Structure in Egypt– Post Elections Draft 2.0 This is a draft - please let me know your thoughts /comments so I can update the document
  • 2.
    The purpose of this document is to highlight some facts about the political power structure in Egypt,  This document provides a map of the main power centers in Egypt including the Hire/Fire command chain post 2nd round elections and the latest announcements from SCAF,  The document proposes some objectives for the post elections (transition) period,  This document has the initial power center analysis (pre elections, as well as the two post elections scenarios (moved to the end) for reference.
  • 4.
    Both are fightingto dominate Egypt for a long period.. And both are welling to do WHATEVER It takes to control Egypt
  • 5.
    If you wantthe best for your future, If you want hope for your kids, and the best for Egypt.. Let us continue to balance the power and establish a creative conflict between the two powers
  • 6.
    If you wantthe best for your future, If you want hope for your kids, and the best for Egypt.. Let us continue to balance the power and establish a creative conflict between the two powers
  • 7.
     Remember whatwe planned for before the Elections - “In any scenario, El-Thawra has to play a major role to defend the Loser and control the Winner’s power grab during the transition period.”  Now, I think we should support SCAF to make sure they have enough power to stay in the game
  • 8.
    Informal Powers (no hire /fire Authority) President Parliament Judicial Corrupt Corrupt Defense Constitutional Hire Business officials Court Minister Admin. Hire /Fire Court Fire only Constitutional MB Corrupt Panel (100 Person) Militia Police SCAF Ultras Melyoneyyat Prime Minister Sabba7y Private /A.Fotoh Media Interior National affairs Security Presidential Control Official Media Intelligence SCAF People/Revolution MB Hire or Fire Authority International /regional Influence is outside the focus of this analysis
  • 9.
    Egypt’s Selected Scenario– Before SCAF Announcement Thawra has to support SCAF This is the scenario we expected (if Moursi won) without to protect the constitution the recent SCAF announcements. In yellow the big yellow and people’s freedom (my bubble on the left was our plan if Moursi got elected. proposed plan – pre elections) Informal Powers President (no hire /fire Authority) Parliament Judicial Corrupt Corrupt Defense Constitutional Hire Business officials Court Minister Admin. Hire /Fire Court Fire only Constitutional MB Corrupt Panel (100 Person) Militia Police SCAF Ultras Melyoneyyat Prime Minister Sabba7y Private /A.Fotoh Media Interior National affairs Security Presidential Control SCAF and moving to MB Official Intelligence Media SCAF People/Revolution MB Hire or Fire Authority
  • 10.
    Egypt’s Selected Scenario– After SCAF Announcement Thawra has to support SCAF was proactive (did not wait for our support) to SCAF to protect protect themselves from MB (expected). I truly believe it is the best for Egypt. This is the power of the creative minorities, constitution, an balance between the two powers. It puts both of them in d people’s freedom defensive mode that helps Egypt’s cause. Balance the Powers Informal Assumption* President Powers (no hire /fire Authority) Parliament Corrupt Corrupt Defense Business officials Minister MB Corrupt Militia Police SCAF Judicial Prime Minister Hire Admin. Constitutional Interior National Ultras Melyoneyyat Constitutional Court Court affairs Security Panel (100 Person) Sabba7y Private Official Intelligence Media /A.Fotoh Media •Assuming MB will get most of the seats in the coming re-elections Presidential Control SCAF and moving to MB SCAF People/Revolution MB Hire or Fire Authority
  • 11.
    Separate Military from State - to protect themselves  Assigning the Constitution Council (to protect the new constitution, minorities, and freedom from MB) – to protect us  I think we should support these changes and adding them to the permanent constitution. This is the only way (in my mind) we can maintain a meaningful power balance between MB and SCAF
  • 12.
    Please read more about the Turkish model and the involvement of the military in politics.  And compare it to what SCAF has announced for Egypt.
  • 13.
    Our only hope for a better future is to always work/vote to maintain the power balance between MB and SCAF,  Now as MB got the presidential seat our focus should be to support SCAF in separating the military from the state and controlling the Constitution,  This get us closer to the Turkish Political Model which is one of very few successful political models in the Islamic world.
  • 14.
    “They that fightfor freedom undertake the noblest cause mankind can have at stake” The struggle for our Freedom will start with the voting
  • 15.
    Thanks a lotto all of you who provided ideas/feedback and help The original (Pre Election) Scenario slides will follow for your reference
  • 16.
    Pre Elections -ScenarioOne - SCAF In this case, Thawra has to support MB and stop SCAF from changing the Parliament Informal Powers (no hire /fire Authority) President Parliament Judicial Corrupt Corrupt Defense Constitutional Hire Business officials Court Minister Admin. Hire /Fire Court Fire only Constitutional MB Corrupt Panel (100 Person) Militia Police SCAF Ultras Melyoneyyat Prime Minister Sabba7y Private /A.Fotoh Media Interior National affairs Security Presidential Control Official Media Intelligence SCAF People/Revolution MB Hire or Fire Authority
  • 17.
    Pre Elections -Scenario Two - MB Thawra has to support SCAF to protect the constitution and people’s freedom Informal Powers (no hire /fire Authority) President Parliament Judicial Corrupt Corrupt Defense Constitutional Hire Business officials Court Minister Admin. Hire /Fire Court Fire only Constitutional MB Corrupt Panel (100 Person) Militia Police SCAF Ultras Melyoneyyat Prime Minister Sabba7y Private /A.Fotoh Media Interior National affairs Security Presidential Control SCAF and moving to MB Official Intelligence Media SCAF People/Revolution MB Hire or Fire Authority