Chartered Accountants




                                                                   March 2011
                                             Update: Carbon and Sustainability
                                                   Risk Management Services
The Carbon debate is                         Carbon Price Mechanism                          agricultural emissions would be excluded
                                                                                             from the carbon pricing mechanism, and
picking up pace again                        Strategy                                        that a phased approach may be adopted
                                                                                             in relation to different sectors. So far,
with the announcement                        The Multi-Party Climate Change
                                                                                             sectors included in the Carbon pricing
                                             Committee (Government, Green and
that a carbon price                          Independents) has just announced its            mechanism would be:
would be introduced in                       high level strategy to introduce a carbon
                                             price in the Australian economy by July
                                                                                             •    Energy
Australia by 2012.                           2012.                                           •    Transport
                                                                                             •    Industrial Processes
RSM Bird Cameron urges medium and            Benjamine Lahousse, of
small businesses to get prepared for         RSM Bird Cameron Risk                           •    Fugitive Emissions (coal seam gas)
the introduction of a carbon price in the
Australian economy and initiate moves        Management Carbon &                             •    Emissions from non-legacy waste.
to understand their carbon exposure.         Sustainability Services says                    There is still a lot of uncertainty linked to
Questions businesses ought to ask            “When a carbon price is finally                 the details of the plan. The Government
themselves are:                              introduced in the Australian                    still have to provide details of whether
                                                                                             and how much affected businesses will
•    What risks does the organisation        economy, greenhouse gas                         be assisted to transition to a low carbon
     run by ignoring existing and future     emissions will translate into                   economy. Nor is it known how low income
     carbon emissions regulations?
                                             real costs for Australian                       households will be compensated if
•    Do we understand our carbon             businesses.”                                    carbon prices are ultimately passed on by
     footprint? How much energy do we                                                        business in consumer prices. It is also not
     consume? How much greenhouse            The strategy specifies that a fixed carbon      known how climate change programs will
     gas do we produce?                      price would start on July 1, 2012, before       be funded.
•    What is our carbon reduction            moving to a market based solution and a         This plan is meant to initiate behavioural
     strategy?                               cap-and-trade emissions trading scheme          changes and instil additional certainty
                                             with a flexible price linked to international   on the long term solution – the ETS -
•    How will additional carbon              markets and a 2020 carbon reduction
     emissions regulations - in particular                                                   enabling carbon pricing in Australia.
                                             target within three to five years.
     the introduction of a carbon price
     - impact our financial bottom line      The aim is to put a price on carbon             “The carbon price will firstly
     and our accounting and reporting        pollution to incentivise large emitting
                                             companies to reduce their emissions, and        affect big polluters which will
     practices?
                                             to enable Australia to shift towards a low      most likely transfer extra costs
•    Will our stakeholers demand more        carbon economy.                                 onto consumers. Products and
     transparency on your actions to
     reduce carbon emissions?                It has already been confirmed that              services which are made from
relatively less polluting material                                  committee, which could range from 5 to           your investors, regulators and
will become cheaper in relation to                                  20% reduction below 1990 level by 2020.          stakeholders’ confidence.”
                                                                    This emissions target will then translated
products which are made through                                     into a set number of carbon permits
processes that incur more carbon                                                                                     RSM Bird Cameron is the largest mid-tier
                                                                    which will give permission to the owner
                                                                                                                     accounting firm in Australia and offer a full
pollution.”                                                         to emit 1 tonne of greenhouse gas in
                                                                                                                     range of specialist advisory services, including
                                                                    the following year. The total amount of
                                                                                                                     business consulting and advisory, assurance
The strategy has provisions for consumers’                          permit will decrease over time and supply
                                                                                                                     and advisory, taxation consulting, corporate
compensation which will in theory enable                            and demand will ultimately determine
                                                                                                                     consulting and turnaround and insolvency.
consumers to use this additional purchase                           the carbon price. The higher the price,
                                                                                                                     RSM Bird Cameron is a core member firm of
power to opt for less polluting products and                        the higher the incentives are to redirect
                                                                                                                     RSM International, the sixth largest network of
realise behavioural changes. This mechanism                         investment to low carbon technologies and
                                                                                                                     independent accounting and consulting firms
will drive innovation and make greener and                          solutions.
                                                                                                                     in the world.
more innovative products more accessible for                        The more Australia continues to generate
consumers.                                                                                                           We have experience in working with clients on
                                                                    additional carbon emissions, the higher
                                                                                                                     specific emissions, energy and environmental
                                                                    the carbon price and the more expensive
                                                                                                                     risk management assignments, including
What does it mean for you?                                          reduction strategies will become. This is
                                                                                                                     corporate, large public departments, local
                                                                    why businesses have a real incentive to
                                                                                                                     councils, and universities.
The committee has not provided details on                           start accounting for carbon now rather
                                                                    than later. As it is already the case in other
how the carbon tax is going to be applied to
                                                                    regions of the world, including Europe
                                                                                                                     On Watch
businesses operating in affected sectors.                           and China, Australia will ultimately have a      In November 2010, Pr Garnaut was
                                                                    carbon reduction mechanism in place.             commissioned to provide an update to the
“Rather than imposing a carbon tax                                                                                   2008 Review for the Australian Government
across the board, it would be fair                                  How can we help?                                 and community.
to develop a progressive taxation                                   Whether your organisation goal is                The Garnaut Climate Change Review—Update
system with thresholds that would                                   to prepare for future environmental              2011 will release a series of papers between
                                                                    regulations, comply with existing legislative    February and March addressing developments
consider the relative carbon                                                                                         across a range of subjects including climate
                                                                    requirements or report under voluntary
efficiency of business operations.”                                 reporting commitments, RSM Bird Cameron’s        change science and impacts, international
                                                                    specialised services will help you find ways     mitigation progress, land, carbon pricing,
Anyhow, a fixed carbon price will have the                                                                           technology, and the electricity sector. A final
                                                                    to effectively improve the carbon and
benefit to bring certainty to businesses so                                                                          report is to be presented to the Government by
                                                                    sustainability reporting procedures, systems
they can factor carbon prices in forecasts and                                                                       31 May 2011.
                                                                    and internal controls of your organisation.
decision making tools used to evaluate potential
future investments. It will be beneficial for the                   RSM Bird Cameron can help at various
Australian economy if the fixed price period is                     levels including identifying carbon data              For more information:
limited to a few years. As other schemes are                        sources, establishing new processes for data
already in place internationally, the Australian                    gathering and raising awareness of senior        Sydney
carbon market should align naturally with                           management for carbon emissions and              Benjamine Lahousse, Manager
foreign carbon markets.                                             energy management.                               Email: benjamine.lahousse@rsmi.com.au
                                                                    Our team of registered Greenhouse and            T: + 61 2 9233 8933
“It is ultimately the markets and not                               Energy auditors and certified ISO 14001
the Australian government which will                                Lead Environmental auditors are able to
                                                                    provide clients with advisory and assurance      Melbourne
be more efficient at pricing carbon as                              services on their greenhouse and energy          Tim Pittaway, Principal
an international commodity.”                                        data collection, calculation and reporting       Email: tim.pittaway@rsmi.com.au
                                                                    processes.
With the flexible price mechanism, the                                                                               T: + 61 3 9286 1800
government will be setting a cap on carbon
                                                                    “We provide you with independent
emissions over a certain period of time.
The cap also has to be determined by the                            and objective expertise and
                                                                    assurance that will bolster

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation

www.rsmi.com.au
© 2011 RSM Bird Cameron

Carbon Price Brief

  • 1.
    Chartered Accountants March 2011 Update: Carbon and Sustainability Risk Management Services The Carbon debate is Carbon Price Mechanism agricultural emissions would be excluded from the carbon pricing mechanism, and picking up pace again Strategy that a phased approach may be adopted in relation to different sectors. So far, with the announcement The Multi-Party Climate Change sectors included in the Carbon pricing Committee (Government, Green and that a carbon price Independents) has just announced its mechanism would be: would be introduced in high level strategy to introduce a carbon price in the Australian economy by July • Energy Australia by 2012. 2012. • Transport • Industrial Processes RSM Bird Cameron urges medium and Benjamine Lahousse, of small businesses to get prepared for RSM Bird Cameron Risk • Fugitive Emissions (coal seam gas) the introduction of a carbon price in the Australian economy and initiate moves Management Carbon & • Emissions from non-legacy waste. to understand their carbon exposure. Sustainability Services says There is still a lot of uncertainty linked to Questions businesses ought to ask “When a carbon price is finally the details of the plan. The Government themselves are: introduced in the Australian still have to provide details of whether and how much affected businesses will • What risks does the organisation economy, greenhouse gas be assisted to transition to a low carbon run by ignoring existing and future emissions will translate into economy. Nor is it known how low income carbon emissions regulations? real costs for Australian households will be compensated if • Do we understand our carbon businesses.” carbon prices are ultimately passed on by footprint? How much energy do we business in consumer prices. It is also not consume? How much greenhouse The strategy specifies that a fixed carbon known how climate change programs will gas do we produce? price would start on July 1, 2012, before be funded. • What is our carbon reduction moving to a market based solution and a This plan is meant to initiate behavioural strategy? cap-and-trade emissions trading scheme changes and instil additional certainty with a flexible price linked to international on the long term solution – the ETS - • How will additional carbon markets and a 2020 carbon reduction emissions regulations - in particular enabling carbon pricing in Australia. target within three to five years. the introduction of a carbon price - impact our financial bottom line The aim is to put a price on carbon “The carbon price will firstly and our accounting and reporting pollution to incentivise large emitting companies to reduce their emissions, and affect big polluters which will practices? to enable Australia to shift towards a low most likely transfer extra costs • Will our stakeholers demand more carbon economy. onto consumers. Products and transparency on your actions to reduce carbon emissions? It has already been confirmed that services which are made from
  • 2.
    relatively less pollutingmaterial committee, which could range from 5 to your investors, regulators and will become cheaper in relation to 20% reduction below 1990 level by 2020. stakeholders’ confidence.” This emissions target will then translated products which are made through into a set number of carbon permits processes that incur more carbon RSM Bird Cameron is the largest mid-tier which will give permission to the owner accounting firm in Australia and offer a full pollution.” to emit 1 tonne of greenhouse gas in range of specialist advisory services, including the following year. The total amount of business consulting and advisory, assurance The strategy has provisions for consumers’ permit will decrease over time and supply and advisory, taxation consulting, corporate compensation which will in theory enable and demand will ultimately determine consulting and turnaround and insolvency. consumers to use this additional purchase the carbon price. The higher the price, RSM Bird Cameron is a core member firm of power to opt for less polluting products and the higher the incentives are to redirect RSM International, the sixth largest network of realise behavioural changes. This mechanism investment to low carbon technologies and independent accounting and consulting firms will drive innovation and make greener and solutions. in the world. more innovative products more accessible for The more Australia continues to generate consumers. We have experience in working with clients on additional carbon emissions, the higher specific emissions, energy and environmental the carbon price and the more expensive risk management assignments, including What does it mean for you? reduction strategies will become. This is corporate, large public departments, local why businesses have a real incentive to councils, and universities. The committee has not provided details on start accounting for carbon now rather than later. As it is already the case in other how the carbon tax is going to be applied to regions of the world, including Europe On Watch businesses operating in affected sectors. and China, Australia will ultimately have a In November 2010, Pr Garnaut was carbon reduction mechanism in place. commissioned to provide an update to the “Rather than imposing a carbon tax 2008 Review for the Australian Government across the board, it would be fair How can we help? and community. to develop a progressive taxation Whether your organisation goal is The Garnaut Climate Change Review—Update system with thresholds that would to prepare for future environmental 2011 will release a series of papers between regulations, comply with existing legislative February and March addressing developments consider the relative carbon across a range of subjects including climate requirements or report under voluntary efficiency of business operations.” reporting commitments, RSM Bird Cameron’s change science and impacts, international specialised services will help you find ways mitigation progress, land, carbon pricing, Anyhow, a fixed carbon price will have the technology, and the electricity sector. A final to effectively improve the carbon and benefit to bring certainty to businesses so report is to be presented to the Government by sustainability reporting procedures, systems they can factor carbon prices in forecasts and 31 May 2011. and internal controls of your organisation. decision making tools used to evaluate potential future investments. It will be beneficial for the RSM Bird Cameron can help at various Australian economy if the fixed price period is levels including identifying carbon data For more information: limited to a few years. As other schemes are sources, establishing new processes for data already in place internationally, the Australian gathering and raising awareness of senior Sydney carbon market should align naturally with management for carbon emissions and Benjamine Lahousse, Manager foreign carbon markets. energy management. Email: benjamine.lahousse@rsmi.com.au Our team of registered Greenhouse and T: + 61 2 9233 8933 “It is ultimately the markets and not Energy auditors and certified ISO 14001 the Australian government which will Lead Environmental auditors are able to provide clients with advisory and assurance Melbourne be more efficient at pricing carbon as services on their greenhouse and energy Tim Pittaway, Principal an international commodity.” data collection, calculation and reporting Email: tim.pittaway@rsmi.com.au processes. With the flexible price mechanism, the T: + 61 3 9286 1800 government will be setting a cap on carbon “We provide you with independent emissions over a certain period of time. The cap also has to be determined by the and objective expertise and assurance that will bolster Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation www.rsmi.com.au © 2011 RSM Bird Cameron