Blunders in music study !

Unless disabled by physical defects, every child displays some sense of
    musical sound and rhythmic motion. It is a constant occurrence for
     children, without a word of direction, to mark the time of a stirring
   tune with hands, feet and swaying motions of the body. A lullaby will
almost invariably soothe a restless infant, and most children old enough
 to distinguish and articulate groups of tones will make some attempt at
  singing the melodies they have often heard. The average child begins
                    music lessons with evident pleasure.


 Many a mother when advised to direct her child's practicing, or at least
to encourage it by her presence, has excused herself on the plea that it
        would bore her to listen. If the work bores the mother it is not
      surprising that the child attacks it with mind fixed on metal more
 attractive and eyes seeking the clock. Occupations which are repellent
    in early life leave behind them a memory calculated to render them
   forever distasteful. It is therefore a grave mistake not to make music
       study from the outset throb with vital interest. An appeal to the
  intellect will quicken the aesthetic instincts, be they never so slender,
      and almost any one will love work that engages all the faculties.

    It should be no more difficult to strengthen the musical instincts than
    any other faculties. On the contrary, it too often chances that a child
 whose early song efforts have been in excellent time and tune, and not
without expression, who has marched in time and beat time accurately,
      will, after a period of instruction, utterly disregard sense of rhythm,
    sing out of tune, play wrong notes, or fail to notice when the musical
     instrument used is ever so cruelly out of tune. Uneducated people,
    trusting to intuitive perceptions, promptly decide that such or such a
       child, or person, has been spoiled by cultivation. This is merely a
           failure to trace a result to its rightful cause, which lies not in
                 cultivation, but in certain blunders in music study.
These blunders begin with the preliminary course on the piano or violin,
 for instance, when a child, having no previous training in the rudiments
    of music, starts with one weekly lesson, and is required to practice a
      prescribed period daily without supervision. To the difficulties of an
introduction to a musical instrument are added those of learning to read
    notes, to locate them, to appreciate time values and much else. The
       teacher, it may be, knows little of the inner life of music, still less
       of child nature. Manifold perplexities arise, and faltering through
   these the pupil acquires a halting use of the musical vocabulary, with
  other bad habits equally hard to correct. A constant repetition of false
        notes, wrong phrasing, irregular accents, faulty rhythms and a
 meaningless jumble of notes dulls the outer ear and deadens the inner
  tone-sense. Where there is genius, or decided talent, no obstacle can
wholly bar the way to music. Otherwise, it retreats before the
                              blundering approach.

      Those pupils are fortunate who come under the influence of a teacher
        with strong, well-balanced personality and ripe knowledge, and are
      treated as rational beings, capable of feeling, thinking and acting. Too
    many music teachers learn their business by experimenting on beginners.
       It has been suggested as a safeguard against their blunders, and all
   ignorance, carelessness and imposture, that music might be placed under
        the same legal protection accorded other important factors in social
      life, and that no one be permitted to teach it without a license granted
          by a competent board of judges after the applicant had passed a
     successful examination, theoretical and practical. This would be well if
         there was any certainty of choosing suitable persons to select the
                                        judges.
      Many times a child who can readily explain the relative value of every
     note and dot will stumble in the time movement when confronted with a
           mixture of the same notes and dots. This is because no mental
   connection has been established between the mechanical time sign and its
      sound, which is the outgrowth of instinctive impulses. Time confusion
       may also be caused by confiding too implicitly in loud and persistent
           counting, instead of trusting to the intelligently guided rhythmic
                                         pulse.

      Sounding notes, even sounding them smoothly, clearly, and rapidly, is
     not necessarily making music, and a succession of them without warmth
          and coloring is truly as inartistic as painting without shading. If it
       were more commonly realized that it is an essential part of the music
     teacher's vocation to train the mind and the emotions and through them
        the will and the character, there would be a higher standard for the
         music pupils' recital. No one would be permitted to play, or sing in
public who could not give an artistic, as well as a technically correct performance.




               http://www.lesvoiesdelamusique.com

Blunders in music study pdf

  • 1.
    Blunders in musicstudy ! Unless disabled by physical defects, every child displays some sense of musical sound and rhythmic motion. It is a constant occurrence for children, without a word of direction, to mark the time of a stirring tune with hands, feet and swaying motions of the body. A lullaby will almost invariably soothe a restless infant, and most children old enough to distinguish and articulate groups of tones will make some attempt at singing the melodies they have often heard. The average child begins music lessons with evident pleasure. Many a mother when advised to direct her child's practicing, or at least to encourage it by her presence, has excused herself on the plea that it would bore her to listen. If the work bores the mother it is not surprising that the child attacks it with mind fixed on metal more attractive and eyes seeking the clock. Occupations which are repellent in early life leave behind them a memory calculated to render them forever distasteful. It is therefore a grave mistake not to make music study from the outset throb with vital interest. An appeal to the intellect will quicken the aesthetic instincts, be they never so slender, and almost any one will love work that engages all the faculties. It should be no more difficult to strengthen the musical instincts than any other faculties. On the contrary, it too often chances that a child whose early song efforts have been in excellent time and tune, and not without expression, who has marched in time and beat time accurately, will, after a period of instruction, utterly disregard sense of rhythm, sing out of tune, play wrong notes, or fail to notice when the musical instrument used is ever so cruelly out of tune. Uneducated people, trusting to intuitive perceptions, promptly decide that such or such a child, or person, has been spoiled by cultivation. This is merely a failure to trace a result to its rightful cause, which lies not in cultivation, but in certain blunders in music study. These blunders begin with the preliminary course on the piano or violin, for instance, when a child, having no previous training in the rudiments of music, starts with one weekly lesson, and is required to practice a prescribed period daily without supervision. To the difficulties of an introduction to a musical instrument are added those of learning to read notes, to locate them, to appreciate time values and much else. The teacher, it may be, knows little of the inner life of music, still less of child nature. Manifold perplexities arise, and faltering through these the pupil acquires a halting use of the musical vocabulary, with other bad habits equally hard to correct. A constant repetition of false notes, wrong phrasing, irregular accents, faulty rhythms and a meaningless jumble of notes dulls the outer ear and deadens the inner tone-sense. Where there is genius, or decided talent, no obstacle can
  • 2.
    wholly bar theway to music. Otherwise, it retreats before the blundering approach. Those pupils are fortunate who come under the influence of a teacher with strong, well-balanced personality and ripe knowledge, and are treated as rational beings, capable of feeling, thinking and acting. Too many music teachers learn their business by experimenting on beginners. It has been suggested as a safeguard against their blunders, and all ignorance, carelessness and imposture, that music might be placed under the same legal protection accorded other important factors in social life, and that no one be permitted to teach it without a license granted by a competent board of judges after the applicant had passed a successful examination, theoretical and practical. This would be well if there was any certainty of choosing suitable persons to select the judges. Many times a child who can readily explain the relative value of every note and dot will stumble in the time movement when confronted with a mixture of the same notes and dots. This is because no mental connection has been established between the mechanical time sign and its sound, which is the outgrowth of instinctive impulses. Time confusion may also be caused by confiding too implicitly in loud and persistent counting, instead of trusting to the intelligently guided rhythmic pulse. Sounding notes, even sounding them smoothly, clearly, and rapidly, is not necessarily making music, and a succession of them without warmth and coloring is truly as inartistic as painting without shading. If it were more commonly realized that it is an essential part of the music teacher's vocation to train the mind and the emotions and through them the will and the character, there would be a higher standard for the music pupils' recital. No one would be permitted to play, or sing in public who could not give an artistic, as well as a technically correct performance. http://www.lesvoiesdelamusique.com