Mickey finds out from his mother that he had a twin brother who was given away at birth because his mother could not afford to keep both boys. His mother gave one of the twins to a woman who could not have children. Upon learning this, Mickey becomes upset and questions why he was not the one who was given away. The narrator then tells the story of the Johnstone twins, who were as alike as two new pins but one was kept while the other was given away, and how they were both born and died on the same day.