SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Digital Insurance
in Italy
The Time to Act Is Now
The Boston Consulting Group (BCG) is a global management consulting firm and the world’s
leading advisor on business strategy. We partner with clients from the private, public, and not-for-
profit sectors in all regions to identify their highest-value opportunities, address their most critical
challenges, and transform their enterprises. Our customized approach combines deep in­sight into
the dynamics of companies and markets with close collaboration at all levels of the client
organization. This ensures that our clients achieve sustainable compet­itive advantage, build more
capable organizations, and secure lasting results. Founded in 1963, BCG is a private company with
81 offices in 45 countries. For more information, please visit bcg.com.
March 2015 | The Boston Consulting Group
Digital Insurance
in Italy
The Time to Act Is Now
Ugo Cotroneo
emanuele costa
Giovanni Ciarlariello
in collaboration with
2 | Digital Insurance in Italy
Contents
	 3	 executive summary
	 5	 Digitization Is a Disruptive Trend
The Digital Economy
Italy’s Digital Evolution
	 7	 Follow Your Clients Online
The Effect of Digital Channels
The Potential Is Untapped
Changing the Go-to-Market Approach
	12	 Mobile is the Emerging Digital Trend
Providing a Satisfactory Mobile Experience
Engaging Customers
	16	 A Transformation Journey
Phase One: Preparing the Foundation
Phase Two: Digitizing the Business Model
Phase Three: Creating a Distinguishing Digital Spike
Taking a Cultural Leap
	20	 Loss Prevention: A Digital Opportunity
Reducing Motor Vehicle Risks
Reducing Health Care and Household Risks
	23	 The Main Challenge: Internal Legacies
Legacy IT
Legacy Processes
Organization
Management Buy-In
Budget Objections
	26	 The Time to Act Is Now
	27	 Note to the Reader
The Boston Consulting Group | 3
Digitization is receiving widespread attention from business
leaders. The global megatrend is causing customers to modify
their purchasing habits and expectations when buying new products
and services, including insurance.
Italy is not excluded from this force that is changing the company-
customer relationship. Customer behaviors highlight the relevance of
digital touchpoints, and e-commerce is on the rise, fostered by the
widespread use of mobile devices. The insurance industry’s awareness
in Italy has rapidly increased in the past years, but only a few players
have a clear path of digital transformation already ongoing.
This report, a collaboration of The Boston Consulting Group and
Google, outlines the opportunities and threats that lie ahead for Ital-
ian insurers and makes the case that the time to act is now.
First, we observe that at least 30 billion to 36 billion in premiums is
affected by customers researching insurance online, making it a must
for insurers to be present where customers are looking for informa-
tion and advice, comparing products and prices, and forming their
purchase decisions.
Furthermore, we argue that insurers should build their digital
presence considering the fast-growing importance of mobile
connectivity; Google’s experience shows that searches using
smartphones and tablets across multiple insurance lines have
increased dramatically since 2008. This means that insurers should
not only ensure a user-friendly display of information and a simple
interface but also take advantage of mobile technology that enables
“geo-fencing” and click-to-call functionality.
Moreover, this report addresses the typical dilemma of how to start a
digital transformation with a three-phase approach: laying the foun-
dation with some no-regret initiatives, such as simplifying interaction
Executive Summary
4 | Digital Insurance in Italy
at digital touchpoints and gradually building up data assets; digitizing
the business model by developing digital tools and applications that
facilitate sales and service the customer; and finally, developing com-
petitive differentiation with a uniquely recognized “digital spike.” In
addition, we stress the key role that an innovation-oriented culture
plays in the success of a digital transformation.
Looking at specific digital opportunities in insurance, we see that im-
proving loss-prevention effectiveness has huge, untapped potential.
According to BCG, insurers that take this step could improve their op-
erating margins by as much as 1 to 2 percent of premiums. Reducing
motor vehicle risks is a good place to start, owing to the widespread
use of telematics, or black boxes. Connectivity is also rapidly spread-
ing in health care and household management, making them promis-
ing areas for innovation, too.
Finally, we conclude with a collection of the challenges that Italian in-
surers believe are hampering their digital development, such as the
complexity of their legacy IT systems and current processes. A lack of
alignment among an organization’s various stakeholders and the in-
ability to secure management buy-in and investment are also stalling
digital efforts. To help managers address these challenges, we offer
some practical suggestions stemming from our experience and that of
successful innovators.
The report draws on BCG’s experience and research in the digital
insurance sector in Italy and abroad; analysis and insights from
Google’s research and experts; and interviews—jointly conducted by
BCG and Google—with several Italian insurance managers to provide
a new, practical, Italy-specific perspective on the insurers’ digital
opportunity.
The Boston Consulting Group | 5
Digitization is everywhere. Today,
there are 7.3 billion mobile-phone
subscriptions,1
3 billion Internet users,2
and
2 billion social-media users.3
There are more
digital connections in the world than there
are people. Digital innovation happens at a
rapid pace, and its influence spreads at an
exponential rate.
The Digital Economy
The new digital economy is a product of digi-
tization and is radically different from the tra-
ditional one. If we consider the ways compa-
nies interact with their customers, digitization
has increased the number of touchpoints, im-
proved the ability to target specific segments,
and broadened and accelerated the reach of
companies’ actions. Digitization is driving a
fundamental shift in the relationships that
companies have with their customers.
Digitization is also a major disruptive force
that has completely reshaped traditional
business models that have been in place for
decades; so-called digital disruptors have
emerged in many industries.
Digitization is not about doing the same
things only faster or cheaper; rather, it is
about enabling new business ideas and busi-
ness models—from a sharing economy to
global scalable platforms. There are many ex-
amples of winning companies with “digital
DNA.” Uber, the app-based transportation
network and taxi company, has been quickly
disrupting city transportation services and
the traditional taxi business. Netflix, a con-
tent distributor, has upended the media in-
dustry, causing giants such as Blockbuster to
yield to more agile and digital-savvy players.
Every day there are new businesses being cre-
ated that are generating revenues in new ways.
Digital innovation is never ending. Digital gi-
ants such as Google and Amazon continuous-
ly innovate, reinventing their value proposi-
tion to remain relevant to their customers and
making their industries fluid and dynamic.
Italy’s Digital Evolution
As of October 2014, there were 41 million In-
ternet users in Italy,4
more than 25 million ac-
tive social-network users,5
and about 95 mil-
lion active mobile-phone subscriptions.6
The
country’s Internet penetration of 66 percent
is lower than that of other advanced econo-
mies in Western Europe. In Norway, for ex-
ample, Internet penetration is 87 percent.
However, Italy’s Internet usage has grown in
the past two years by 6.8 percent, and 84 per-
cent of the population use the Internet if we
only consider people between the ages of
11 and 74.
What is surprising about Italy is the wide-
spread use of mobile phones, which had a
DIGITIZATION IS A
DISRUPTIVE TREND
6 | Digital Insurance in Italy
market penetration of 82.2 percent in 2014.
Smartphones are increasing their share
among mobile devices and are projected to
grow from 49.5 percent in 2014 to almost
72 percent in 2018.7
Rapid smartphone adoption is fueling the
dramatic increase in online usage. Every day,
more than 15 million Italians access the Inter-
net from their smartphones, compared with
13 million people who log on from their per-
sonal computers and 5 million who access it
from their tablets.8
E-commerce is also growing. According to a
study from Politecnico di Milano, revenue
from e-commerce sales totaled about 13 bil-
lion in 2014 after growing, on average, 18 per-
cent per year since 2009.9
An even more ac-
celerated growth pattern applies for
purchasing transactions from mobile devices.
Notes
1. GSMA Intelligence, https://gsmaintelligence.com/,
January, 2015.
2. EMarketer, “Worldwide Internet and Mobile Users,”
January, 2015.
3. We Are Social, “Digital Statshot 002,” http://www
.slideshare.net/wearesocialsg/we-are-socials-digital
-statshot-002.
4. Audiweb Database (powered by Nielsen), October
2014.
5. Audiweb Database (powered by Nielsen), October
2014.
6. AGCOM, Osservatorio trimestrale sulle
Telecomunicazioni, September 2014.
7. EMarketer, “Smartphone Users and Penetration in
Western Europe, by Country, 2013 through 2018.”
8. Audiweb Database (powered by Nielsen), October
2014.
9. Pagamenti elettronici e mobile payment & commerce:
i valori del transato, Osservatori.net.
The Boston Consulting Group | 7
Digital transformation has come to
the insurance industry, bringing with it a
huge business opportunity that will grow in
the coming years. Given that most insurance
players are still exploring the digital land-
scape, the potential is mostly untapped.
Interestingly, the 2014 BCG Global Innovators
Survey—which collected the opinions of
more than 1,500 senior executives world-
wide—shows that insurance managers are
well aware of the coming impact of digitiza-
tion. In fact, this survey reveals that about
40 percent of insurance executives expect big
data and mobile devices to have a significant
impact on the industry over the next three to
five years, placing insurance behind only the
technology and telecommunications indus-
tries in terms of the most affected sectors.
Like executives in many other industries,
however, a significantly lower percentage of
insurance managers are actively targeting big
data and mobile devices in their innovation
programs, hence missing the opportunity.
(See Exhibit 1.)
The Effect of Digital Channels
A recent BCG survey on global consumer sen-
timent highlighted that in Italy, insurance
consumers are turning to digital channels. Ac-
cording to the research, about 50 to 55 per-
cent of protection, health, and property and
casualty (P&C) consumers require both rela-
tionship channels (an agent, bank, or broker)
and digital channels.
In addition, approximately 15 percent of cus-
tomers are ready to transition to digital-only
interactions, bringing the overall reach of dig-
ital channels to almost 70 percent of insur-
ance customers in terms of their future buy-
ing channels. The remaining customers, a
little more than 30 percent, still prefer rela-
tionship channels only, but that number is
decreasing. (See Exhibit 2.)
From 2008 through 2013,
online searches related to
insurance grew 128 percent.
Italian consumers are not only leaning to-
ward digital channels but also making a sig-
nificant part of their purchasing decisions
outside insurers’ domains. Consumers are
increasingly using digital tools to search for
product information, prices, and reviews.
From 2008 through 2013, online searches
related to insurance grew 128 percent, and
more specifically, searches related to car in-
surance grew 185 percent.
These numbers give us a sense of the massive
business opportunity for digital insurance in
FOLLOW YOUR
CLIENTS ONLINE
8 | Digital Insurance in Italy
0
10
20
30
40
50
10 20 30 40 50 60
Chemicals
Consumer products
Energy
Financial services
Industrial/manufacturing
Pharma/biotech/health care
Telecommunications
Retail
Insurance
Technology (IT services)
Technology (soware)
Technology (hardware)
Respondents actively targeting mobile products
in their innovation program (%)
Respondents expecting a significant impact from mobile
products over the next three to five years (%)
Autos/motor vehicles
Tech industry AverageOther industry
Behavior = belief
Impact of mobile products1
Attitude
toward
digital
channels
Property and casualty1
High
10.5
16.7
6.1
Medium
12.0
16.2
5.2
Low
14.2
4.6
14.6
Income
∑ ∑
Protection1
37%
47%
16%
Owners (%) Owners (%)
37%
51%
12%
High
12.1
18.7
2.5
Medium
11.6
16.4
5.4
Low
13.7
15.4
4.3
Health1
High
8.3
20.9
4.1
Medium
9.9
18.5
4.9
Low
15.9
15.3
2.2
∑
34%
55%
11%
Owners (%)
Prefer relationship channelsHybridsPrefer digital channels
Source: 2014 BCG Global Innovators Survey.
1
There is a similar pattern in other digital areas, such as big-data analytics.
Source: 2012 BCG Global Consumer Sentiment Survey.
Note: Interviewees were selected from 11 income brackets. Interviewees were asked this question: In general, how useful are or would the
following interactions modes be to you when it comes to dealing with your insurance providers?
1
Any apparent discrepancies in totals are the result of rounding.
Exhibit 1 | Many Insurance Executives Expect Digital Products to Have a High Impact, but Few
Are Taking Action
Exhibit 2 | Many Insurance Customers in Italy Are Already “Hybrids”
The Boston Consulting Group | 9
Italy. Let’s take this a step further, however. A
recent market study by Google shows, by in-
surance category, the share of consumers that
use the Web to gather information and com-
pare prices. Using this research, we can better
quantify the size of the opportunity.
Considering that the overall 2013 retail P&C
market (that is, excluding commercial insur-
ance) in Italy was worth 28 billion to 30 bil-
lion in premiums and that the percentage of
insurance buyers who research online ranges
from 29 percent (those interested in house-
hold insurance) to 56 percent (those research-
ing automotive insurance), we can estimate
that the value of digital insurance premiums
is approximately 12 billion to 14 billion (as-
suming the middle of the range). (See Exhibit 3.)
With regards to the life insurance business,
we start from an overall market of roughly
80 billion in retail life-insurance premiums.
Furthermore, our data suggests that about
50 percent of buyers of financial products
research online for information before
purchasing. Hence, even if we prudently
assume that the percentage of life insurance
buyers researching online is much lower than
the broad average for financial products
because of the inherent complexity of the
product—say 20 to 30 percent of buyers—
then we can estimate that the value of digital
life-insurance premiums is 18 billion to
22 billion. This brings the total value of
digital insurance premiums to 30 billion to
36 billion.
This estimate is expected to increase as pro-
spective customers change their purchasing
behaviors. The BCG 2012 Insurance and New
Media Consumer Survey shows that 43 per-
cent of respondents met an agent in person
for past transactions, but only 40 percent will
do so for future transactions. In addition, the
use of digital channels is on the rise: 58 per-
cent of respondents will visit company web-
sites, compared with 18 percent who did so
for past transactions, and 45 percent will use
a Web search engine, compared with 9 per-
cent who did so in the past.
Demographics will play a significant part in
fueling the size of the opportunity in the fu-
ture. Younger Italians are significantly more
Property and
casualty*
Life*
Retail premiums in the Italian market, 2013†
€28 billion
to
€30 billion
Purchasers who researchedonline before buyinginsurance
Total premiums affected by online search
€79 billion
to
€81 billion
€12 billion
to
€14 billion‡
€18 billion
to
€22 billion
29–56% 20–30%
€30 billion
to
€36 billion
Sources: ANIA; Google Consumer Barometer.
*
Estimates.
†
Including European Union companies.
‡
Assuming middle of range.
Exhibit 3 | The Size of the Insurance Market Influenced by the Web Is Already
€30 Billion to €36 Billion
10 | Digital Insurance in Italy
proficient in using digital resources and pre-
fer those channels over the traditional ones.
The Potential Is Untapped
BCG and Google conducted interviews with
major industry players and found that there
is a shared sense of urgency for digital trans-
formation. Most players recognize the impact
of digital channels. Nonetheless, there is
widespread concern given that the industry is
unprepared to cope because of its structural
shortcomings.
Since 2007, traditional insurers have been
gradually losing online brand share to direct
players and aggregators—companies that
have built a significant position online in re-
cent years. Traditional insurers’ brand share
of overall online insurance searches declined
from 39 percent in 2007 to 34 percent in
2014, well below their fair share when we
consider premium revenues. (See Exhibit 4.)
By contrast, direct insurers and then aggrega-
tors filled this gap. Aggregators alone repre-
sented almost a fifth (17 percent) of online
brand share in 2014.
When we compare online brand share with
real brand share for each player (excluding
aggregators), the vast majority of traditional
insurers is underrepresented online. (See
Exhibit 5.) If we consider emerging buying
behaviors, the gap between online and real
brand share should be worrisome for
established insurers in the medium term and
calls for a review of their go-to-market
strategy. That said, some early recovery signs
in 2014 might indicate a greater focus by
traditional insurers on advertising and an
online presence.
Changing the Go-to-Market
Approach
Changing the way an insurer interacts with its
clients is critical to harvesting the potential of
digital insurance.
With rising acquisition costs and surging
churn rates, customer retention is an impera-
tive for Italian insurers. For example, churn
rates for third-party-liability automotive in-
surance in Italy increased from less than
10 percent to approximately 20 percent in the
past five years.
To be successful, industry players should de-
vote the effort necessary to truly understand
the “moments of truth” in the customer jour-
Trend inversion in 2014 potentially signals efforts by traditional insurers
to increase advertising and improve Web presence
39 40 37 33 29 30 31 34
59 59 61
65
60
53 49
49
10
16 20 17
80
100
40
20
0
60
1
Traditional insurers Direct players
Insurers’ brand share of online search (%)
11
Aggregators
20142013201220112010200920082007
2
Source: Google proprietary data.
Note: Any apparent discrepancies in totals are the result of rounding.
Exhibit 4 | Online Brand Share Is Dominated by Direct Players and Aggregators
The Boston Consulting Group | 11
ney and explore how digital channels can
help improve the customer experience at
those touchpoints.
BCG experience shows that when improving
the digital experience for customers, it is criti-
cal to segment them on the basis of behaviors
and needs, since the reasons for an insurance
purchase may vary significantly across clus-
ters of consumers. Digital features multiply
the number of possibilities to personalize the
selling proposition—if the insurer is able to
identify the segment in which a customer be-
longs early on in the sales process.
Digital channels have multiplied the number
of touchpoints and taken away the early stages
of the sales process—when customers look for
information, compare companies, and form a
buying decision—from physical channels.
Thus, having a direct insurance subsidiary
alongside traditional operations is not suffi-
cient anymore. But, indeed, we see an oppor-
tunity to better leverage the specific experi-
ence and skills that such subsidiaries have
typically developed.
Some insurers have invested in digital mar-
keting not only to target consumers more di-
rectly and effectively but also to gain an addi-
tional opportunity to interact and engage
with their clients. For example, SunLife, a di-
rect-distribution brand of AXA, structured its
online presence to increase trust and brand
recognition through extensive customer re-
views and clearer corporate communications.
Other insurers have taken advantage of mul-
tiple digital channels. For instance, in 2012,
Allianz Germany further expanded its multi-
channel approach and established social
networks as an additional platform for sales
agents.
These and other success stories show that dig-
ital channels enable a wide range of opportu-
nities for insurers to shape the customer ex-
perience across the entire front end of a
company.
9 8
6
3 3 2
14
10
5
4 3
1211
0
5
10
15
#3 #4 #5 #7#6 #11 #12 Others1
#10#8 #9#1
Brands associated with insurance online queries, 2014 (%)
#2
Traditional insurersDirect players
Online share versus
market share
Online market
position
Source: Google proprietary data.
Note: Online brand share, excluding aggregators.
1
Mostly traditional insurance companies.
Exhibit 5 | Most Traditional Insurers Are Underrepresented in Online Share
“Digital channels provide a huge opportuni-
ty to listen to our clients. We are not doing it
seriously, and churn rates prove it.”
—Head of marketing at a large
insurance group
12 | Digital Insurance in Italy
Mobile Is the EMERGING
DIGITAL TREND
Mobile devices are a major consumer
trend in Italy. In 2014, the number of
mobile-device users was 50.7 million, of
which 24.1 million were equipped with
smartphones. On a daily basis, these smart-
phone users made 16.6 million connections
and spent an average of 1 hour and 37 min-
utes online, exceeding the number of connec-
tions and the amount of time spent online by
users of traditional desktops.1
By 2018, the
number of smartphone users will climb to
37 million.
The importance of mobile devices will in-
crease over time, as younger consumers are
naturally more inclined to use these devices.
The 2013 BCG Global Consumer Sentiment
Survey highlights that 76 percent of Italian
respondents between the ages of 18 and 24
use a smartphone, compared with 31 percent
over the age of 65; similarly, 30 percent of re-
spondents between the ages of 18 and 24 use
a smartphone as a shopping platform, com-
pared with 5 percent over the age of 65. A
step change is expected as those under the
age of 18, who consider using mobile devices
“standard practice,” gain purchasing power.
The presence of mobile devices has become
so ubiquitous that, according to Google,
78 percent of all smartphone users are online
daily with their device, compared with
60 percent of laptop users and 49 percent of
tablet users.
Mobile shopping is rapidly gaining share in
Italy. Research by comScore indicates that the
penetration rate of mobile commerce com-
pared with total e-commerce in Italy is the
second highest in Europe and the fastest
growing. (See Exhibit 6.) Mobile shoppers are
usually frequent purchasers; approximately
60 percent buy something through a mobile
device at least once a month.2
By 2018, the number of
smartphone users will climb
to 37 million.
The use of location services on smartphones
is growing exponentially: 92 percent of smart-
phone users access their phone to find infor-
mation on local stores, and 28 percent access
local information every day. More important,
those who research local information are
more likely to engage in specific actions: com-
Score’s research indicates that 48 percent
contacted stores directly, 60 percent visited
them, and 30 percent purchased something.3
Nonetheless, it would be an error to envision
mobile devices purely as substitutes for tradi-
tional laptop connections. According to a study
by Google and TNS, 51 percent of consumers
use at least two types of devices to connect to
The Boston Consulting Group | 13
the Internet, and 13 percent of consumers con-
nect using up to three types of devices.
This phenomenon, referred to as “multi-
screening,” is another important trend and
proves that digital interaction should not be
thought of as a linear process. Rather, con-
necting with consumers happens on a num-
ber of devices and platforms that are activat-
ed from various places.
In 2015, the potential number of personal
connected devices will increase from
three—a laptop, tablet, and smartphone—to
six, as consumers add Web TV, smart watches,
and connected cars to their mix, giving com-
panies multiple new touchpoints.
Providing a Satisfactory Mobile
Experience
The use of new devices is booming among in-
surance customers. Google’s experience
shows that searches using smartphones
across multiple insurance lines increased dra-
matically since 2008. (See Exhibit 7.)
However, as of September 2014, only two out
of five major insurance groups in Italy had a
native mobile site, or m-site. In addition,
these m-sites mainly focused on providing
fast quotes and agency locations; they didn’t
offer a complete range of services. The re-
maining three insurance groups presented a
smaller version of their desktop website to
mobile users, deteriorating the customer ex-
perience. This is even more surprising if we
consider that statistics from Google show that
67 percent of consumers who access the In-
ternet through a smartphone or tablet are
more likely to take action—buy a product,
complete a form, or download an app—on a
website that is optimized for mobile devices.4
Engaging Customers
A large number of insurers outside Italy have
redesigned their entire approach for mobile
devices, adopting simplicity and ease of use to
improve the customer experience. For exam-
ple, Oscar, a U.S.-based health-insurance com-
pany, designed a straightforward instant-
quote system for mobile devices that lets
customers easily adjust predefined parame-
ters to receive instant pricing information.
More broadly, mobile devices should be part
of a multichannel business model, in order to
23 21 18
12 10
34
70
36
40
30
0
20
40
60
80
Growth across
European countries
averaged 42.5%
France
Mobile e-commerce in Europe (%)
SpainGermanyItalyUK
Year-over-year growth
Penetration (m-commerce compared with total e-commerce)
Italy is Europe’s second-highest market when m-commerce is compared
with total e-commerce and is the fastest growing
Source: ComScore, “The Role of Mobile in Online Shopping and Buying,” May 21, 2014.
Exhibit 6 | Mobile E-commerce in Italy Is Widespread and Fast Growing
14 | Digital Insurance in Italy
drive customers to physical locations. Creat-
ing a smooth customer process requires an
understanding of consumer habits and effec-
tive cooperation with the distribution net-
work. Some real-world examples from other
industries may provide food for thought.
Nissan used mobile technology to increase
the number of digital leads for dealerships. In
July 2013, the automotive company launched
a Nissan Note group for the Waze app that
helps drivers locate the closest dealership for
test-driving the car. In November 2013, Nis-
san launched a “geo-fencing” campaign: cus-
tomers who entered a defined geographic
area received dynamic advertising banners
that included click-to-call buttons to book a
test-drive and directed potential customers to
nearby dealerships. As a result of both ef-
forts, 20 percent of Nissan’s digital leads
came from mobile devices in 2013, and
35 percent of its global Web traffic now
comes from mobile devices in the U.S.
Carrefour Bank’s experience demonstrates
how mobile devices can be instrumental to
both providing value-added services and seg-
menting customers. The French company dif-
ferentiated its mobile presence with two in-
terfaces. The first was a mobile site with a
loan calculator (to determine monthly pay-
ments depending on the amount borrowed),
Web callback, and simple inquiry forms de-
signed to attract new customers. The second
was an app designed to enhance interaction
with existing customers by pushing personal-
ized offers and scheduling retargeting cam-
paigns. The impact was a twofold increase in
conversions on mobile devices, compared
with conversions on desktops. The overall
goal was to have mobile devices account for
25 percent of Web sales in 2015.
Mobile devices can also enable new and inno-
vative business models, and some insurers
have created mobile applications to sell “on
the go” insurance products. Tokio Marine
50
100
0
+158%
2014201320122011201020092008
Mobile search queries (indexed)
Car insurance
100
0
50
+158%
2014201320122011201020092008
Health insurance
100
0
50
+156%
2014201320122011201020092008
Life insurance
0
100
50
+145%
2010 201320112009 2012 20142008
Home insurance
Source: Google internal data.
Exhibit 7 | The Use of Mobile Devices in Insurance Searches Is Booming
The Boston Consulting Group | 15
Management has introduced short-term in-
surance policies that can be purchased for
short periods of time, such as a day or a few
weeks. These policies are designed to protect
customers when they engage in infrequent
activities. The mobile app uses a global posi-
tioning system (GPS) to determine customers’
locations and proactively prompts them with
relevant one-time insurance products, such as
travel insurance when customers are at an
airport or accident insurance when they are
at a ski resort. Customers can complete the
purchase of the policy instantaneously on
their mobile devices.
Notes
1. Audiweb Database (powered by Nielsen), October
2014.
2. EMarketer, “The Role of Mobile in Online Shopping
and Buying,” May 2014.
3. Google, “Our Mobile Planet: Understanding the
Mobile Consumer,” May 2013.
4. Google, Sterling Research, and SmithGeiger, “What
Users Want Most From Mobile Sites Today.”
16 | Digital Insurance in Italy
A TRANSFORMATION
JOURNEY
Digital transformation is a process of
increasing complexity. Regardless of the
long-term target business model, we recom-
mend adopting a phased approach to the digital
transformation journey. The phases we propose
include initiatives that take into account the
starting point of Italian insurers and address the
major issues insurers face with a pragmatic ap-
proach. All in all, these initiatives represent
stepping stones for change. (See Exhibit 8.)
Phase One: Preparing the
Foundation
Most insurance companies have high ambi-
tions for a digital transformation. But when
companies begin the process, they struggle to
identify a starting point and a coherent
course of action. To help insurance compa-
nies lay the foundation for their transforma-
tion effort, we suggest undertaking the fol-
lowing five initiatives.
“Hygiene” conditions to tap into digitization
• Simple and coherent digital interfaces
• Investment in data assets
• Aligned organization and partners
Digitization embedded in the business model
• Digitization enhances sales process, risk
management, and operations
• Redesign of products and channels
Digital spike is recognized in the market
• Areas of digital excellence, as a marketing lever
and competitive differentiator
• Customers delighted through digitization
A step-wise journey with a time horizon of at least two to three years
Distinguishing
digital spike
Business model
digitization
Foundation
Phase 1
Phase 2
Phase 3
Source: BCG analysis.
Exhibit 8 | How to Craft a Digital Transformation
The Boston Consulting Group | 17
Simplify interaction at digital touchpoints.
According to a BCG survey that asked
consumers to rate their digital interactions
with various industries, respondents rated
their digital experiences with the insurance
industry among the worst. The daunting
website registration process to get an online
quote was one reason for customers’
dissatisfaction.
At a minimum, then, an insurer should set up
a simple, effective website that has an intui-
tive registration process and that is easy to
navigate. The website should provide clear
product information and optimize the digi-
tal-conversion funnel. The proper use of fonts
and images can significantly improve custom-
er satisfaction, as can an appropriate amount
of information and interaction.
Insurers can improve cus-
tomer interaction simply by
creating a mobile presence.
Provide a coherent digital presence across
channels. Today, having a digital presence
means providing customers with access to
services anywhere and anytime. Customers
want to be able to choose any channel, or a
combination of channels, to interact with com-
panies. It is critical for insurers to provide this
choice at every step of the value chain. In
addition, insurers should have the same look
and feel across all channels and devices and
coherently manage distributors’ presence on
social media. Furthermore, companies should
ensure that information captured anywhere
online is also available through physical channels.
Create a mobile presence. Insurers can
improve customer interaction and the num-
ber of touchpoints simply by creating a
mobile presence. This is important given that
one of every three inquiries comes from
mobile devices and that 82 percent of the
population uses mobile phones.
Insurers should build websites with dedicated
mobile landing pages. In addition, compa-
nies’ mobile apps should provide customer-
centric—rather than product-centric—func-
tionality and offer support for every step of
the customer life cycle, rather than focusing
only on claims management. Both mobile
websites and mobile apps should implement
functionality that enables direct interactions
with clients. For example, click-to-call buttons
can redirect support requests or leads to the
closest agent available, thus increasing con-
version rates. Similarly, GPS services can be
used to offer customers one-time insurance
products on the basis of their location or to
target specific customer segments by alerting
them that they are close to an agency loca-
tion. Most of these activities can be launched
without running into IT legacy issues or seri-
ous budget constraints.
Build up data assets. Insurers often lack
information about their customers because of
infrequent contact with them; about half of
an insurer’s clients are contacted once a year
or less. In addition, this interaction often
happens with an agent or intermediary.
Insurers should start addressing their chronic
information gap and build up the firm’s data
assets by collecting all the available informa-
tion on existing clients and creating a single
data repository. Information can be collected
online by encouraging customers to use pri-
vate areas on a website, which are now com-
pulsory under Italian regulations. By having
customers log in, insurers can capture person-
al information as well as navigation patterns
and preferences—all of which insurers can
then analyze and monitor. To gather the in-
formation needed, insurers have to drive sig-
nificant traffic to these areas by providing ad-
ditional services—such as a client portal,
personalized information services, and cus-
tomized 24-7 chat support—that are attrac-
tive to customers.
“For us, digital transformation primarily
means to provide a multiaccess service mod-
el to customers, especially presale, creating
an awareness of the need for protection and
an interest in our products.”
—Manager of an Italian
bancassurance operator
18 | Digital Insurance in Italy
Information can also be collected offline
through the agent’s network. Most customer
information still resides in local databases
owned by agents. Insurers should work to inte-
grate and centralize that information through
a cooperative program with their agents. For
example, the adoption of cloud solutions for
document management in the agencies would
allow, at the same time, for improved function-
alities, digitization, and integration of data.
Customer data is a
strategic asset.
Customer data is such a strategic asset that
some innovators are gathering information
on customer behaviors and preferences using
ways that are normally employed by other
consumer-focused industries. For example,
some insurers are creating agreements with
external partners, such as retailers, to share
information about common clients, their be-
haviors, purchasing patterns, lifestyles, and so
on, whenever allowed by regulation. More-
over, the rise of the Internet of Things—the
connection of uniquely identifiable devices
(such as wearables, telematics boxes, and
house sensors) over the Internet—will give
insurers the opportunity to have real-time in-
formation on customers, their behaviors, and
their risks.
Bring distribution partners onboard. For
most of the insurance managers we inter-
viewed, being able to involve their agents in
the digital transformation is key. Insurers
should define a clear mutual-value proposi-
tion for their distribution network to ensure
cooperation. For example, a financial institu-
tion recently launched a co-investment Web
campaign for its insurance agents. Those that
participated would benefit from advertising
sponsored by the corporate marketing
department and targeting users who connect-
ed to the Internet from the agent’s local area.
Providing digital tools that empower agents
can also help get them onboard. Digital tools
not only support a paperless, one-stop sales
process but also have a substantial impact on
operational efficiency, with upsides for both
the company and the sales force.
By implementing these initiatives, insurers
can create momentum for their digital
transformation.
Phase Two: Digitizing the
Business Model
After laying the foundation for a digital trans-
formation, insurers should focus on digital
initiatives to enhance the core business.
Digital tools and applications need to be
leveraged to facilitate sales processes, free up
agents’ time for sales, and enable real-time
KPI monitoring.
If a company wants to pursue online sales, it
should develop a strong online channel with
clear customer segmentation and a strong
value proposition. This requires designing
simple products and services specifically for
the channel.
If a company wants to keep its agent network
as the main sales channel, a digital strategy
should be designed to integrate online and off-
line channels so traffic can be directed from
one to the other. For example, the strategy
should allow leads generated on the Web and
other digital platforms to be directed to agents,
and the strategy should let agents efficiently
and effectively direct their clients to digital
channels for customer care and renewal.
New tools to service and engage customers
proactively should also be created. The basis
for these tools should be an analytics engine,
which can use customer data and insights for
better monitoring and analysis of customer
issues and feedback.
Phase Three: Creating a
Distinguishing Digital Spike
Finally, insurers should enhance their digital
presence by identifying a unique value propo-
sition—be it superior customer care, com-
plete process digitization, or an enhanced
multichannel approach—that differentiates
them from the competition.
Allianz in Italy, for example, was the first in-
surer to offer and broadly advertise “fast
quote” functionality, through which potential
The Boston Consulting Group | 19
clients can quickly compare an Allianz offer
for automotive insurance by sending only
their birth date and car plate using short mes-
sage service (SMS).
Insurers can also extend their digital strategy
and efforts beyond the core business. They
can enhance the user experience by engaging
users in product design; ensure a seamless
multichannel experience by implementing an
end-to-end customer-relationship-manage-
ment system; or digitize back-office processes
to reduce cost and improve efficiency.
Taking a Cultural Leap
Many major insurers are still deeply rooted in
their traditional cultural and organizational
values, and this prevents real change. It is one
of the main reasons why, in past years, some
companies have launched and delivered
some easy quick wins but have not pursued a
deep digital transformation.
A culture ready for a digital transformation is,
first of all, a culture based on sharing infor-
mation, encouraging experimentation, and
reacting promptly. In particular, becoming a
digital company requires a new paradigm for
innovation that must pervade the entire orga-
nization. The old understanding of technolog-
ical disruption with systematic, long-cycle
R&D efforts based on heavy investments and
a lengthy time frame does not work any lon-
ger. A digital organization requires rapid-fire,
free-wheeling experimentation with minimal
investment requirements and a very short
time frame.
Becoming a digital company
requires a new paradigm.
The oversight process must also be different.
Many insurers are still focused on a few iso-
lated innovation projects, usually controlled
by a centralized committee-driven structure.
The solution is not to create highly detailed
business cases, which usually prove to be also
highly unrealistic, but to manage digital ini-
tiatives as a portfolio. Insurers should find
the right mix by balancing the level of disrup-
tion, the likelihood of success, and the re-
sources required by each initiative in the
portfolio. In this respect, failure should be
integrated as a source of learning: by testing
several, even conflicting ideas, insurers
should try to fail often, well, and soon. An in-
novative culture, which is profoundly differ-
ent from that of traditional large corpora-
tions, is the distinguishing asset of winning
digital players such as Google and Amazon.
Finally, the role of employees should be re-
considered. To support change, all employees
need to be empowered with the freedom to
generate bottom-up ideas. Time and resources
must be allocated to try and test these ideas
at an early stage. In addition, mechanisms
must be put in place to choose among the ini-
tiatives that work and then scale them.
A recent BCG global survey shows that more
than 70 percent of the most innovative com-
panies have a specific organizational entity
for managing radical innovation. Italian in-
surers should consider establishing such fo-
cused innovation units—as some large global
peers have already done—with the mandate
to scout out, nurture, and accelerate innova-
tion efforts. The mission of “digital labs” may
vary depending on the strategy and maturity
of each player, but a dedicated structure can
play a key role in orchestrating a company’s
digital-innovation portfolio and lead to an
overall cultural change.
“Out of ten innovation opportunities, the
management of a venture capital firm would
spend the majority of its time discussing
how to exploit the potential of the one win-
ning idea. Here, we would only discuss how
to deal with the failure of the other nine.”
—Head of distribution innovation
for a multinational insurer
20 | Digital Insurance in Italy
LOSS PREVENTION
A DIGITAL OPPORTUNITY
New affordable technologies help
share information and monitor critical
data, increasing the possibility for consumers
to lower their risk exposure. This develop-
ment allows insurers to move from simple
risk assessment to dynamic knowledge of risk
and mitigation whenever possible.
Digital initiatives, then, can directly affect the
single most important cost item on an insur-
er’s P&L: losses, which in 2013 were about
15 billion for the Italian retail P&C market.
According to BCG analysis, the implementa-
tion of a digital strategy for loss prevention can
generate an improvement in operating mar-
gins of as much as 1 to 2 percent of premiums.
Digital initiatives can affect
the most important cost item
on an insurer’s P&L: losses.
The digital revolution and the rise of the In-
ternet of Things will allow something that has
not been possible before: real-time monitor-
ing and interaction, ad hoc gathering of cus-
tomer information, and data analytics for the
discovery of upcoming risks. (See Exhibit 9.)
On one hand, these capabilities allow insur-
ers to better anticipate risk. On the other
hand, they can lower risk by influencing cus-
tomer behavior through digital interaction
with the customer and through establishing a
direct link between behavior and the amount
of a customer’s premiums.
Reducing Motor Vehicle Risks
Today, Italy has one of the highest penetra-
tions of motor telematics, or black boxes, in
the world. Research conducted by BCG and
Ania highlighted that at the end of 2013,
there were 2 million black boxes installed in
cars, representing 6 percent of the auto mar-
ket. Black box installations are projected to
reach 10 to 15 percent of the car market by
2017. The precious behavioral data collected
through these devices can be stored and ana-
lyzed for loss-prevention purposes.
Additionally, this data can be made accessible
to customers through an online portal and
can be used as a basis for offering value-
added services, such as how to optimize fuel
consumption or driving-style suggestions.
Real-time monitoring can also trigger imme-
diate interaction in case of danger. For in-
stance, in the case of dangerous habits or un-
safe conditions, the system can contact the
driver by sending a text or an e-mail message
or by making an emergency call.
By integrating black boxes with onboard di-
agnostics (OBD), the possibilities expand.
The Boston Consulting Group | 21
Imagine if a car’s tire pressure created a dan-
gerous situation. OBD would communicate
that information to the black box, which
would alert the customer by displaying a
message and recommending that the driver
stop and check the tires.
Several insurers have started to leverage be-
havioral data coming from telematics. For ex-
ample, Aviva targets younger drivers who pay
higher premiums with an Android app that
monitors drivers’ first 200 miles to determine
individual premiums on the basis of driving
behavior. The app records data on accelera-
tion, braking, and cornering. Safe drivers are
offered discounts up to 20 percent.
Given the widespread use of mobile devices
in Italy—and particularly smartphones—de-
veloping an app that helps customers reduce
their motor-vehicle risks would, in turn, help
insurers prevent losses. In addition, an app
would help insurers gain access to a large
pool of users, even beyond those who in-
stalled a black box in their cars. And an app
could be an opportunity to increase the num-
ber of touchpoints with customers, thanks to
its regular use, and to improve customers’ sat-
isfaction with their insurance company,
thanks to services that make their overall
driving experience better.
For example, an Italian direct insurer recently
launched a hailstorm service that uses Twit-
ter and the company’s website to alert cus-
tomers about potential hailstorms throughout
the country.
The application could be integrated with a
black box and OBD to provide diagnostic in-
formation. For instance, the application could
provide periodic repair reminders and the ad-
dress of the closest branded repairer or links
to a how-to library for immediate repairs.
Bosch Group is already distributing an appli-
cation called fun2drive that is directly linked
to a car’s diagnostics using Bluetooth and
provides several features, such as vehicle-per-
AgricultureTransport
HomeHealth care
Car
Personal safety
Xega’s GPS implant
helps locate someone in distress
Marubeni’s sensor allows
remote monitoring of vital signs
HDFC ERGO insurance uses
RFID tags for livestock insurance
Trucks collect weather data
that is used to improve planning
4.3 m
illion
Google hits
3 m
illion
Google hits
10 m
illion
Google hits
2 m
illion
Google hits
1.3 m
illion
Google hits
4 m
illion
Google hits
Asahi Fire & Marine uses video
dongles for PAYD car insurance
RWE SmartHome has
a portfolio of 20 smart devices
Source: Google and BCG experience, 2013 data.
Note: RFID = radio frequency identification; PAYD = pay as you drive; GPS = global positioning system.
Exhibit 9 | Telematics and Digital Devices Open New Loss-Prevention Possibilities
22 | Digital Insurance in Italy
formance tracking, trip analysis, and engine
diagnostics.
Last but not least, an app could provide use-
ful safety features, such as nighttime driving
alerts and alarms in case a driver falls asleep.
The iOnRoad app warns drivers if there’s in-
sufficient distance between them and other
drivers or if they begin to cross into another
lane. The app also can locate a parked car
and offers SMS and a notification reader.
Although it isn’t costly to develop mobile
apps, insurers should consider providing a
branded interface to best-of-breed apps, such
as Waze or Google Maps.
Hence, the value that an insurance company
can bring to its clients goes beyond a specific
technological solution and consists of provid-
ing a broader integrated service, which at the
same time improves the experience of the
customers and reduces their risks.
Reducing Health Care and
Household Risks
Connectivity is spreading in the service of
health care, too. Humana and other health-
care insurers have incorporated the concept
of remote monitoring into interactive health-
care devices. These devices monitor Medicare
members who are living with congestive
heart failure, allowing for remote detection of
issues and remote advisory to the patient.
This enables quickly responding to emergen-
cies, easily sharing information, and following
up remotely. Office visits are reduced by
50 percent, resulting in reduced costs. In addi-
tion, early detection results in faster treat-
ment, ultimately reducing claim costs.
A large European insurer recently partnered
with a health program that offers individual
participants services and incentives for main-
taining an active lifestyle; data shows that
mortality rates are as much as 50 percent
lower for those who participate and their loy-
alty rates to the insurer are as much as three
times higher. A similar approach can be ob-
served in household insurance, where insur-
ers are starting to leverage the potential of
remote sensors to reduce risk.
Such examples point to the development of
“ecosystems” of companies built around a
specific area of customer need (such as main-
taining good health or ensuring a safe house-
hold)—ecosystems in which the insurer is one
of the players. These advanced business mod-
els, enabled by digital connectivity, may be
created and orchestrated by an insurance
company (as Ping An Insurance did in China)
or be led by a company that owns the cus-
tomer relationship (such was the role of the
Japanese e-retailer Rakuten). In the latter
case, the insurance provider plays only a “fac-
tory” role. Obviously, the share of value cap-
tured by an insurer is very different in these
two scenarios, providing an incentive to be a
first mover.
The Boston Consulting Group | 23
Our interviews with major insurers
highlighted that many struggle to deliver
on customer expectations mainly because of
internal roadblocks that are impeding digital
change rather than external constraints.
Companies should consider the following
factors and reflect on how they might affect
the approach to a digital transformation
before planning one.
Legacy IT
First and foremost, legacy IT systems repre-
sent a nightmare for insurers, as most compa-
nies have inherited complex, static, and frag-
mented systems. Gartner estimates that more
than two-thirds of global life and P&C insur-
ers still rely significantly on legacy systems—
some of which date back to the 1970s and
1980s—to manage their core processes.
Therefore, in order to craft an IT develop-
ment strategy, it is fundamental to under-
stand what the starting point is and how to
get the basics under control. For example, in-
surers should determine if the current IT
solutions are scalable across online and off-
line channels.
Furthermore, as a digital transformation hing-
es on sharing and integrating information,
companies should assess the effort required
to make their current data assets accessible
by all new systems.
A digital transformation
hinges on sharing and
integrating information.
To address these issues, experience suggests
that developing a temporary IT overlay that
is loosely integrated with a legacy environ-
ment (so-called two-speed IT) can be a way
to rapidly implement IT prototypes for new
product or channel functionalities without
undermining the systems’ integrity.
Legacy Processes
Beyond legacy IT, legacy processes can repre-
sent a serious hurdle. The extent to which
current processes will be replaced by digital
processes is a factor to be considered, thus
anticipating potential resistance in changing
consolidated habits. When planning a digital
transformation, therefore, companies should
THE MAIN CHALLENGE
INTERNAL LEGACIES
“The main obstacle to a digital
transformation is our legacies: first IT, but
also processes, products, and culture.”
—Head of sales at a large Italian insurer
24 | Digital Insurance in Italy
determine the incentives for employees to
switch to new processes and how this transi-
tion can be managed in an organic way
throughout the organization. It is important
that the new processes are implemented
without leaving the old processes still in place
in the organization.
Organization
Our interviews with insurance companies in
Italy highlighted that “digitization” means
different things to different people in a com-
pany: for the claims management depart-
ment, it might imply a new IT system to use;
for the sales force, a new channel to contact
the client; for the actuaries, a new source of
information; and so on. Therefore, it is not
surprising that it is often difficult to align the
various stakeholders and get them onboard
for this kind of project.
Insurers should determine the parts of the
organization that are involved, the goals of
the digital project, and how to sustain a
cross-functional effort toward change. In this
process, pinpointing responsibilities and
identifying a clear sponsor at the senior level
is vital.
In our experience, creating a center of com-
petence with a cross-functional team to de-
velop and test ideas in a safe environment
can be an effective solution at least for the
start-up phase. First, it enables sharing
knowledge and expertise across functions.
Second, it can represent a more agile organi-
zational unit compared with a traditional de-
partment. And third, it may irradiate success-
ful solutions to other businesses units.
Management Buy-In
One of the main issues related to digital
transformation cited by the interviewees is
the difficulty in achieving a strong buy-in
from senior management and from the board
of directors. In most cases, even if officers at
the level of vice president agree on the neces-
sity to implement a digital transformation,
plans and activities remain on paper, and lim-
ited efforts and resources are specifically allo-
cated to it. A recent success story from a ma-
jor European insurer shows that having the
CEO back a radical digital-transformation
project is fundamental, if not necessary. Pro-
ponents of a digital change should therefore
evaluate the level of consensus and commit-
ment from senior executives.
Insurers should determine
the goals of the digital
project and how to sustain a
cross-functional effort toward
change.
Budget Objections
Finally, digital transformation has to cope
with budget constraints and a lack of invest-
ment. A complete digital makeover usually
implies a long-term commitment, significant
expenses, and usually limited returns in the
very short term. Most of the interviewees cit-
ed the difficulty of having these investments
approved and the relatively small budget
they have access to.
To start a digital transformation, therefore,
it’s important to understand the size of the
available budget. In addition, our experience
indicates that applying short-term financial
parameters to evaluate innovation initiatives
can preempt several opportunities. The 2014
BCG Global Innovators Survey clearly high-
lights that breakthrough innovators tend to
treat radical innovation projects very differ-
“People use the buzzword “digital” all the
time, but they refer to very different things.”
—Chief marketing officer of
a global insurance group
“Any investment with a payback of more
than 12 months will not even be considered.”
—Head of claims management at
a large Italian insurer
The Boston Consulting Group | 25
ently from incremental projects, allowing the
former broader objectives and more time for
iterations. (See Exhibit 10.) More than 80 per-
cent of breakthrough innovators allow such
efforts to start without a projection of future
returns. Insurers should therefore try to avoid
strict enforcement of standard financial KPIs
and choose longer-term success indicators.
Also, it can be helpful to balance a portfolio
of initiatives that have different probabilities
of success and impact and different require-
ments for cash outlays.
How would you describe the processes and cultures governing disruptive or radical innovation projects?
8381
76
8284
81
78
75
8283
66
6164
68
72
59
65
697070
0
20
40
60
80
100
Differentiates
between high
and low
innovativeness
Room and
time for
experimentation
Allows for
iterations and
adjustments
–21
Respondents selecting “agree” or “strongly agree” (%)
Incentives
linked
to radical
innovations
Different
organization for
incremental and
radical projects
Project approval
does not depend
on projection of
future returns
Open
structure for
collaboration
–27 –24
Culture of
experimentation
Protects
radical projects
from strict
cost control
Top
management
committed to
radical projects
Governance Management Organization
Breakthrough Innovators (N = 114) Other companies (N = 228)
Source: 2014 BCG Global Innovators Survey (342 respondents).
Exhibit 10 | Breakthrough Innovators Treat Radical Innovation Very Differently from
Incremental Projects
26 | Digital Insurance in Italy
THE TIME TO ACT IS NOW
We can debate how radical the impact
of the Internet of Things will be or how
much cloud computing will change the way
business is done, but what is clear is that
digital transformation and all that it implies
has come to the insurance industry and will
be growing during the next several years.
What lies ahead is a once-in-a-lifetime oppor-
tunity for Italian insurance companies to
seize significant value while most of their
competitors are still trying to figure out what
to do. The time has come to reorient and
drive the organization in order to face the
structural hurdles that have so far impeded a
digital transformation. This time, change is all
about testing quickly and learning early.
C-level officers should decide whether they
want to start this transformation or not. If
there’s something that the digital economy
has proven so far, it is that a timely reaction
is the only way to survive in the market. The
conclusion can be only one: the time to act
is now.
The Boston Consulting Group | 27
About the Authors
Ugo Cotroneo is a partner and
managing director in the Milan
office of The Boston Consulting
Group. Emanuele Costa is a
principal in the firm’s Milan office.
Giovanni Ciarlariello is business
unit director of finance, technology,
and telecommunications for Google
Italy.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank
Laura Maida, Elisa Celestini,
Stefano Piacentini, Daniela Rigante,
and Gianluca Uberti at Google, as
well as our colleague Carlo Bravin.
For Further Contact
This report was sponsored by BCG’s
Insurance practice in Italy in col-
laboration with Google Italy. If you
would like to discuss the themes
and content of this report, please
contact one of the authors.
Italy
Ugo Cotroneo
Partner and Managing Director
BCG Milan
+39 02 65 59 91
cotroneo.ugo@bcg.com
Emanuele Costa
Principal
BCG Milan
+39 02 65 59 91
costa.emanuele@bcg.com
Giovanni Ciarlariello
Business Unit Director of Finance,
Technology, and Telecommunications
Google Italy
gci@google.com
note to the reader
© The Boston Consulting Group, Inc. 2015. All rights reserved.
For information or permission to reprint, please contact BCG at:
Phone: 	 +39 02 65 59 91
Fax: 	 +39 02 65 59 96 55
Mail: 	 The Boston Consulting Group, Inc.
	 Piazzetta Maurillo Bossi 2
	Milan 20121
	Italy
To find the latest BCG content and register to receive e-alerts on this topic or others, please visit bcgperspectives.com.
Follow bcg.perspectives on Facebook and Twitter.
3/15
Abu Dhabi
Amsterdam
Athens
Atlanta
Auckland
Bangkok
Barcelona
Beijing
Berlin
Bogotá
Boston
Brussels
Budapest
Buenos Aires
Calgary
Canberra
Casablanca
Chennai
Chicago
Cologne
Copenhagen
Dallas
Detroit
Dubai
Düsseldorf
Frankfurt
Geneva
Hamburg
Helsinki
Ho Chi Minh City
Hong Kong
Houston
Istanbul
Jakarta
Johannesburg
Kiev
Kuala Lumpur
Lisbon
London
Los Angeles
Luanda
Madrid
Melbourne
Mexico City
Miami
Milan
Minneapolis
Monterrey
Montréal
Moscow
Mumbai
Munich
Nagoya
New Delhi
New Jersey
New York
Oslo
Paris
Perth
Philadelphia
Prague
Rio de Janeiro
Rome
San Francisco
Santiago
São Paulo
Seattle
Seoul
Shanghai
Singapore
Stockholm
Stuttgart
Sydney
Taipei
Tel Aviv
Tokyo
Toronto
Vienna
Warsaw
Washington
Zurich
bcg.com | bcgperspectives.com

More Related Content

What's hot

Internet of Things forecasts infographic
Internet of Things forecasts infographicInternet of Things forecasts infographic
Internet of Things forecasts infographic
Emerald Technology
 
Digital trends in 2017
Digital trends in 2017Digital trends in 2017
Digital trends in 2017
Constantin Magdalina
 
The 7 Biggest Technology Trends That Will Transform Telecoms In 2020
The 7 Biggest Technology Trends That Will Transform Telecoms In 2020The 7 Biggest Technology Trends That Will Transform Telecoms In 2020
The 7 Biggest Technology Trends That Will Transform Telecoms In 2020
Bernard Marr
 
6 Biggest Business Technology Trends in 2020
6 Biggest Business Technology Trends in 2020 6 Biggest Business Technology Trends in 2020
6 Biggest Business Technology Trends in 2020
Neil Haboush Judgement
 
Report 2 empathic things – intimate technology - from wearables to biohackin...
Report 2  empathic things – intimate technology - from wearables to biohackin...Report 2  empathic things – intimate technology - from wearables to biohackin...
Report 2 empathic things – intimate technology - from wearables to biohackin...
Rick Bouter
 
CIS14: NSTIC: Identity Enables a New Digital Relationship
CIS14: NSTIC: Identity Enables a New Digital RelationshipCIS14: NSTIC: Identity Enables a New Digital Relationship
CIS14: NSTIC: Identity Enables a New Digital Relationship
CloudIDSummit
 
The Digital Identity Network -- A Holistic Approach to Managing Risk in a Glo...
The Digital Identity Network -- A Holistic Approach to Managing Risk in a Glo...The Digital Identity Network -- A Holistic Approach to Managing Risk in a Glo...
The Digital Identity Network -- A Holistic Approach to Managing Risk in a Glo...
Elizabeth Dimit
 
SMACology
SMACologySMACology
SMACology
Kartik Jha
 
Technology tech trends 2022 and beyond
Technology tech trends 2022 and beyond Technology tech trends 2022 and beyond
Technology tech trends 2022 and beyond
Brian Pichman
 
Digital Banking: Reshaping the Business Model - Alba Céspedes
Digital Banking: Reshaping the Business Model - Alba CéspedesDigital Banking: Reshaping the Business Model - Alba Céspedes
Digital Banking: Reshaping the Business Model - Alba Céspedes
Alba Cespedes
 
Disruptive Technologies – A 2021 Update
Disruptive Technologies – A 2021 UpdateDisruptive Technologies – A 2021 Update
Disruptive Technologies – A 2021 Update
CTRM Center
 
FinTech 2015 Edinburgh
FinTech 2015 EdinburghFinTech 2015 Edinburgh
FinTech 2015 Edinburgh
Ray Bugg
 
Rethinking the Value Chain: New Realities in Collaborative Business
 Rethinking the Value Chain: New Realities in Collaborative Business Rethinking the Value Chain: New Realities in Collaborative Business
Rethinking the Value Chain: New Realities in Collaborative Business
Capgemini
 
Dutch Media Landscape 2018 by Publicis Spine
Dutch Media Landscape 2018 by Publicis SpineDutch Media Landscape 2018 by Publicis Spine
Dutch Media Landscape 2018 by Publicis Spine
starcomNL
 
Identity Relationship Management: Using Identity to Empower CIOs Everywhere
Identity Relationship Management: Using Identity to Empower CIOs EverywhereIdentity Relationship Management: Using Identity to Empower CIOs Everywhere
Identity Relationship Management: Using Identity to Empower CIOs Everywhere
Daniel Raskin
 
The Internet of Things: Are Organizations Ready For A Multi-Trillion Dollar P...
The Internet of Things: Are Organizations Ready For A Multi-Trillion Dollar P...The Internet of Things: Are Organizations Ready For A Multi-Trillion Dollar P...
The Internet of Things: Are Organizations Ready For A Multi-Trillion Dollar P...default default
 
Gp bullhound 2015
Gp bullhound 2015Gp bullhound 2015
Gp bullhound 2015
Merve Kara
 
E- Magazine issuu December 2016
E- Magazine issuu December 2016E- Magazine issuu December 2016
E- Magazine issuu December 2016
VARINDIA
 
TELECOM, MAS PODE ME CHAMAR DE PUBLISHER MESMO
TELECOM, MAS PODE ME CHAMAR DE PUBLISHER MESMOTELECOM, MAS PODE ME CHAMAR DE PUBLISHER MESMO
TELECOM, MAS PODE ME CHAMAR DE PUBLISHER MESMO
Meio & Mensagem
 

What's hot (19)

Internet of Things forecasts infographic
Internet of Things forecasts infographicInternet of Things forecasts infographic
Internet of Things forecasts infographic
 
Digital trends in 2017
Digital trends in 2017Digital trends in 2017
Digital trends in 2017
 
The 7 Biggest Technology Trends That Will Transform Telecoms In 2020
The 7 Biggest Technology Trends That Will Transform Telecoms In 2020The 7 Biggest Technology Trends That Will Transform Telecoms In 2020
The 7 Biggest Technology Trends That Will Transform Telecoms In 2020
 
6 Biggest Business Technology Trends in 2020
6 Biggest Business Technology Trends in 2020 6 Biggest Business Technology Trends in 2020
6 Biggest Business Technology Trends in 2020
 
Report 2 empathic things – intimate technology - from wearables to biohackin...
Report 2  empathic things – intimate technology - from wearables to biohackin...Report 2  empathic things – intimate technology - from wearables to biohackin...
Report 2 empathic things – intimate technology - from wearables to biohackin...
 
CIS14: NSTIC: Identity Enables a New Digital Relationship
CIS14: NSTIC: Identity Enables a New Digital RelationshipCIS14: NSTIC: Identity Enables a New Digital Relationship
CIS14: NSTIC: Identity Enables a New Digital Relationship
 
The Digital Identity Network -- A Holistic Approach to Managing Risk in a Glo...
The Digital Identity Network -- A Holistic Approach to Managing Risk in a Glo...The Digital Identity Network -- A Holistic Approach to Managing Risk in a Glo...
The Digital Identity Network -- A Holistic Approach to Managing Risk in a Glo...
 
SMACology
SMACologySMACology
SMACology
 
Technology tech trends 2022 and beyond
Technology tech trends 2022 and beyond Technology tech trends 2022 and beyond
Technology tech trends 2022 and beyond
 
Digital Banking: Reshaping the Business Model - Alba Céspedes
Digital Banking: Reshaping the Business Model - Alba CéspedesDigital Banking: Reshaping the Business Model - Alba Céspedes
Digital Banking: Reshaping the Business Model - Alba Céspedes
 
Disruptive Technologies – A 2021 Update
Disruptive Technologies – A 2021 UpdateDisruptive Technologies – A 2021 Update
Disruptive Technologies – A 2021 Update
 
FinTech 2015 Edinburgh
FinTech 2015 EdinburghFinTech 2015 Edinburgh
FinTech 2015 Edinburgh
 
Rethinking the Value Chain: New Realities in Collaborative Business
 Rethinking the Value Chain: New Realities in Collaborative Business Rethinking the Value Chain: New Realities in Collaborative Business
Rethinking the Value Chain: New Realities in Collaborative Business
 
Dutch Media Landscape 2018 by Publicis Spine
Dutch Media Landscape 2018 by Publicis SpineDutch Media Landscape 2018 by Publicis Spine
Dutch Media Landscape 2018 by Publicis Spine
 
Identity Relationship Management: Using Identity to Empower CIOs Everywhere
Identity Relationship Management: Using Identity to Empower CIOs EverywhereIdentity Relationship Management: Using Identity to Empower CIOs Everywhere
Identity Relationship Management: Using Identity to Empower CIOs Everywhere
 
The Internet of Things: Are Organizations Ready For A Multi-Trillion Dollar P...
The Internet of Things: Are Organizations Ready For A Multi-Trillion Dollar P...The Internet of Things: Are Organizations Ready For A Multi-Trillion Dollar P...
The Internet of Things: Are Organizations Ready For A Multi-Trillion Dollar P...
 
Gp bullhound 2015
Gp bullhound 2015Gp bullhound 2015
Gp bullhound 2015
 
E- Magazine issuu December 2016
E- Magazine issuu December 2016E- Magazine issuu December 2016
E- Magazine issuu December 2016
 
TELECOM, MAS PODE ME CHAMAR DE PUBLISHER MESMO
TELECOM, MAS PODE ME CHAMAR DE PUBLISHER MESMOTELECOM, MAS PODE ME CHAMAR DE PUBLISHER MESMO
TELECOM, MAS PODE ME CHAMAR DE PUBLISHER MESMO
 

Viewers also liked

день здоровья
день здоровьядень здоровья
день здоровья
jekah
 
Passem de la indignació a l'acció alliberadora
Passem de la indignació a l'acció alliberadoraPassem de la indignació a l'acció alliberadora
Passem de la indignació a l'acció alliberadora
Acció Catòlica Obrera
 
Singapore HACCP
Singapore HACCPSingapore HACCP
Singapore HACCP
HACCP Singapore
 
Russian import export (catalog) 2098
Russian import export (catalog) 2098Russian import export (catalog) 2098
Russian import export (catalog) 2098
lindaejhonson
 
Caso Nava
Caso NavaCaso Nava
Caso Nava
luiorellana
 
El maestro y el robot
El maestro y el robotEl maestro y el robot
El maestro y el robot
Alex Delgado
 
Planificacion
PlanificacionPlanificacion
Planificacion
Alex Delgado
 
New Technologies to Shape The Future of Transport - It’s About the Data - Dav...
New Technologies to Shape The Future of Transport - It’s About the Data - Dav...New Technologies to Shape The Future of Transport - It’s About the Data - Dav...
New Technologies to Shape The Future of Transport - It’s About the Data - Dav...
WRI Ross Center for Sustainable Cities
 
Customer experience management royal enfield
Customer experience management  royal enfieldCustomer experience management  royal enfield
Customer experience management royal enfield
Abrar Mazhar
 
Transforming Insurance Operations through Data and Analytics
Transforming Insurance Operations through Data and AnalyticsTransforming Insurance Operations through Data and Analytics
Transforming Insurance Operations through Data and Analytics
Datalytyx
 
How smart, connected products are transforming companies presentation (edit...
How smart, connected products are transforming companies   presentation (edit...How smart, connected products are transforming companies   presentation (edit...
How smart, connected products are transforming companies presentation (edit...
Fahmy Amrillah
 
Shaping the future of insurance with IBM Watson
Shaping the future of insurance with IBM WatsonShaping the future of insurance with IBM Watson
Shaping the future of insurance with IBM WatsonJohn Root
 
Analytics in P&C Insurance
Analytics in P&C InsuranceAnalytics in P&C Insurance
Analytics in P&C Insurance
Gregg Barrett
 

Viewers also liked (16)

день здоровья
день здоровьядень здоровья
день здоровья
 
De kettingbrug
De kettingbrugDe kettingbrug
De kettingbrug
 
Passem de la indignació a l'acció alliberadora
Passem de la indignació a l'acció alliberadoraPassem de la indignació a l'acció alliberadora
Passem de la indignació a l'acció alliberadora
 
Singapore HACCP
Singapore HACCPSingapore HACCP
Singapore HACCP
 
PRODUCT LIST. NT
PRODUCT LIST. NTPRODUCT LIST. NT
PRODUCT LIST. NT
 
Bitácora 14 02-2013
Bitácora 14 02-2013Bitácora 14 02-2013
Bitácora 14 02-2013
 
Russian import export (catalog) 2098
Russian import export (catalog) 2098Russian import export (catalog) 2098
Russian import export (catalog) 2098
 
Caso Nava
Caso NavaCaso Nava
Caso Nava
 
El maestro y el robot
El maestro y el robotEl maestro y el robot
El maestro y el robot
 
Planificacion
PlanificacionPlanificacion
Planificacion
 
New Technologies to Shape The Future of Transport - It’s About the Data - Dav...
New Technologies to Shape The Future of Transport - It’s About the Data - Dav...New Technologies to Shape The Future of Transport - It’s About the Data - Dav...
New Technologies to Shape The Future of Transport - It’s About the Data - Dav...
 
Customer experience management royal enfield
Customer experience management  royal enfieldCustomer experience management  royal enfield
Customer experience management royal enfield
 
Transforming Insurance Operations through Data and Analytics
Transforming Insurance Operations through Data and AnalyticsTransforming Insurance Operations through Data and Analytics
Transforming Insurance Operations through Data and Analytics
 
How smart, connected products are transforming companies presentation (edit...
How smart, connected products are transforming companies   presentation (edit...How smart, connected products are transforming companies   presentation (edit...
How smart, connected products are transforming companies presentation (edit...
 
Shaping the future of insurance with IBM Watson
Shaping the future of insurance with IBM WatsonShaping the future of insurance with IBM Watson
Shaping the future of insurance with IBM Watson
 
Analytics in P&C Insurance
Analytics in P&C InsuranceAnalytics in P&C Insurance
Analytics in P&C Insurance
 

Similar to BCG_Digital_Insurance_in_Italy_Mar_2015_-__1

File156453 (1)
File156453 (1)File156453 (1)
File156453 (1)Sumit Roy
 
89% of consumers switch to a competitor after a poor CX
89% of consumers switch to a competitor after a poor CX 89% of consumers switch to a competitor after a poor CX
89% of consumers switch to a competitor after a poor CX
Abhishek Sood
 
HeathWallace_Mobile_Whitepaper_2015
HeathWallace_Mobile_Whitepaper_2015HeathWallace_Mobile_Whitepaper_2015
HeathWallace_Mobile_Whitepaper_2015Rory Yates
 
Thesis final
Thesis finalThesis final
Thesis final
Angelica Greco
 
How Insurance CIOs Can Remake Themselves to Lead Digital Transformation
How Insurance CIOs Can Remake Themselves to Lead Digital TransformationHow Insurance CIOs Can Remake Themselves to Lead Digital Transformation
How Insurance CIOs Can Remake Themselves to Lead Digital Transformation
Cognizant
 
Strategic choices for banks in the digital age
Strategic choices for banks in the digital ageStrategic choices for banks in the digital age
Strategic choices for banks in the digital age
Ignasi Martín Morales
 
Global Business Trends to Follow in 2022 | CIOLOOK
Global Business Trends to Follow in 2022 | CIOLOOKGlobal Business Trends to Follow in 2022 | CIOLOOK
Global Business Trends to Follow in 2022 | CIOLOOK
CIO Look Magazine
 
Fintech 2.0 - Rebooting Financial Services - Blockchain Clearing
Fintech 2.0 - Rebooting Financial Services - Blockchain Clearing Fintech 2.0 - Rebooting Financial Services - Blockchain Clearing
Fintech 2.0 - Rebooting Financial Services - Blockchain Clearing
Ian Beckett
 
The FinTech 2.0 Paper: rebooting financial services
The FinTech 2.0 Paper: rebooting financial servicesThe FinTech 2.0 Paper: rebooting financial services
The FinTech 2.0 Paper: rebooting financial services
Edwin Soares
 
Digital Industrialization 2016 - Beyond Pilot projects
Digital Industrialization 2016 - Beyond Pilot projectsDigital Industrialization 2016 - Beyond Pilot projects
Digital Industrialization 2016 - Beyond Pilot projects
Solutions IT et Business
 
Digital industrialization 2016 - International version
Digital industrialization 2016 - International versionDigital industrialization 2016 - International version
Digital industrialization 2016 - International version
Lucile HYON-LE GOURRIEREC
 
Enabling digital customers
Enabling digital customersEnabling digital customers
Enabling digital customers
Manuel Vexler
 
UK Financial Services: Digital Trends Report 2020
UK Financial Services: Digital Trends Report 2020UK Financial Services: Digital Trends Report 2020
UK Financial Services: Digital Trends Report 2020
Let's Learn Digital
 
Presentation1.pptxffk dkfjdskajfewfsdjklJKFND
Presentation1.pptxffk dkfjdskajfewfsdjklJKFNDPresentation1.pptxffk dkfjdskajfewfsdjklJKFND
Presentation1.pptxffk dkfjdskajfewfsdjklJKFND
mohannidya625
 
The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2
The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2
The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2
Ninety Consulting
 
Insurance IoT Digital Report
Insurance IoT Digital ReportInsurance IoT Digital Report
Insurance IoT Digital Report
Zsófia Kulcsár
 
Euromonitor digital consumer index extract - top 20 markets
Euromonitor digital consumer index extract - top 20 marketsEuromonitor digital consumer index extract - top 20 markets
Euromonitor digital consumer index extract - top 20 markets
Alexandre Pallota
 
Private Sector Digital Value at Stake
Private Sector Digital Value at StakePrivate Sector Digital Value at Stake
Private Sector Digital Value at StakeDarren Scott
 
Private Sector Digital Value at Stake
Private Sector Digital Value at StakePrivate Sector Digital Value at Stake
Private Sector Digital Value at StakeBridget Lindsay
 

Similar to BCG_Digital_Insurance_in_Italy_Mar_2015_-__1 (20)

File156453 (1)
File156453 (1)File156453 (1)
File156453 (1)
 
file156453
file156453file156453
file156453
 
89% of consumers switch to a competitor after a poor CX
89% of consumers switch to a competitor after a poor CX 89% of consumers switch to a competitor after a poor CX
89% of consumers switch to a competitor after a poor CX
 
HeathWallace_Mobile_Whitepaper_2015
HeathWallace_Mobile_Whitepaper_2015HeathWallace_Mobile_Whitepaper_2015
HeathWallace_Mobile_Whitepaper_2015
 
Thesis final
Thesis finalThesis final
Thesis final
 
How Insurance CIOs Can Remake Themselves to Lead Digital Transformation
How Insurance CIOs Can Remake Themselves to Lead Digital TransformationHow Insurance CIOs Can Remake Themselves to Lead Digital Transformation
How Insurance CIOs Can Remake Themselves to Lead Digital Transformation
 
Strategic choices for banks in the digital age
Strategic choices for banks in the digital ageStrategic choices for banks in the digital age
Strategic choices for banks in the digital age
 
Global Business Trends to Follow in 2022 | CIOLOOK
Global Business Trends to Follow in 2022 | CIOLOOKGlobal Business Trends to Follow in 2022 | CIOLOOK
Global Business Trends to Follow in 2022 | CIOLOOK
 
Fintech 2.0 - Rebooting Financial Services - Blockchain Clearing
Fintech 2.0 - Rebooting Financial Services - Blockchain Clearing Fintech 2.0 - Rebooting Financial Services - Blockchain Clearing
Fintech 2.0 - Rebooting Financial Services - Blockchain Clearing
 
The FinTech 2.0 Paper: rebooting financial services
The FinTech 2.0 Paper: rebooting financial servicesThe FinTech 2.0 Paper: rebooting financial services
The FinTech 2.0 Paper: rebooting financial services
 
Digital Industrialization 2016 - Beyond Pilot projects
Digital Industrialization 2016 - Beyond Pilot projectsDigital Industrialization 2016 - Beyond Pilot projects
Digital Industrialization 2016 - Beyond Pilot projects
 
Digital industrialization 2016 - International version
Digital industrialization 2016 - International versionDigital industrialization 2016 - International version
Digital industrialization 2016 - International version
 
Enabling digital customers
Enabling digital customersEnabling digital customers
Enabling digital customers
 
UK Financial Services: Digital Trends Report 2020
UK Financial Services: Digital Trends Report 2020UK Financial Services: Digital Trends Report 2020
UK Financial Services: Digital Trends Report 2020
 
Presentation1.pptxffk dkfjdskajfewfsdjklJKFND
Presentation1.pptxffk dkfjdskajfewfsdjklJKFNDPresentation1.pptxffk dkfjdskajfewfsdjklJKFND
Presentation1.pptxffk dkfjdskajfewfsdjklJKFND
 
The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2
The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2
The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2
 
Insurance IoT Digital Report
Insurance IoT Digital ReportInsurance IoT Digital Report
Insurance IoT Digital Report
 
Euromonitor digital consumer index extract - top 20 markets
Euromonitor digital consumer index extract - top 20 marketsEuromonitor digital consumer index extract - top 20 markets
Euromonitor digital consumer index extract - top 20 markets
 
Private Sector Digital Value at Stake
Private Sector Digital Value at StakePrivate Sector Digital Value at Stake
Private Sector Digital Value at Stake
 
Private Sector Digital Value at Stake
Private Sector Digital Value at StakePrivate Sector Digital Value at Stake
Private Sector Digital Value at Stake
 

BCG_Digital_Insurance_in_Italy_Mar_2015_-__1

  • 1. Digital Insurance in Italy The Time to Act Is Now
  • 2. The Boston Consulting Group (BCG) is a global management consulting firm and the world’s leading advisor on business strategy. We partner with clients from the private, public, and not-for- profit sectors in all regions to identify their highest-value opportunities, address their most critical challenges, and transform their enterprises. Our customized approach combines deep in­sight into the dynamics of companies and markets with close collaboration at all levels of the client organization. This ensures that our clients achieve sustainable compet­itive advantage, build more capable organizations, and secure lasting results. Founded in 1963, BCG is a private company with 81 offices in 45 countries. For more information, please visit bcg.com.
  • 3. March 2015 | The Boston Consulting Group Digital Insurance in Italy The Time to Act Is Now Ugo Cotroneo emanuele costa Giovanni Ciarlariello in collaboration with
  • 4. 2 | Digital Insurance in Italy Contents 3 executive summary 5 Digitization Is a Disruptive Trend The Digital Economy Italy’s Digital Evolution 7 Follow Your Clients Online The Effect of Digital Channels The Potential Is Untapped Changing the Go-to-Market Approach 12 Mobile is the Emerging Digital Trend Providing a Satisfactory Mobile Experience Engaging Customers 16 A Transformation Journey Phase One: Preparing the Foundation Phase Two: Digitizing the Business Model Phase Three: Creating a Distinguishing Digital Spike Taking a Cultural Leap 20 Loss Prevention: A Digital Opportunity Reducing Motor Vehicle Risks Reducing Health Care and Household Risks 23 The Main Challenge: Internal Legacies Legacy IT Legacy Processes Organization Management Buy-In Budget Objections 26 The Time to Act Is Now 27 Note to the Reader
  • 5. The Boston Consulting Group | 3 Digitization is receiving widespread attention from business leaders. The global megatrend is causing customers to modify their purchasing habits and expectations when buying new products and services, including insurance. Italy is not excluded from this force that is changing the company- customer relationship. Customer behaviors highlight the relevance of digital touchpoints, and e-commerce is on the rise, fostered by the widespread use of mobile devices. The insurance industry’s awareness in Italy has rapidly increased in the past years, but only a few players have a clear path of digital transformation already ongoing. This report, a collaboration of The Boston Consulting Group and Google, outlines the opportunities and threats that lie ahead for Ital- ian insurers and makes the case that the time to act is now. First, we observe that at least 30 billion to 36 billion in premiums is affected by customers researching insurance online, making it a must for insurers to be present where customers are looking for informa- tion and advice, comparing products and prices, and forming their purchase decisions. Furthermore, we argue that insurers should build their digital presence considering the fast-growing importance of mobile connectivity; Google’s experience shows that searches using smartphones and tablets across multiple insurance lines have increased dramatically since 2008. This means that insurers should not only ensure a user-friendly display of information and a simple interface but also take advantage of mobile technology that enables “geo-fencing” and click-to-call functionality. Moreover, this report addresses the typical dilemma of how to start a digital transformation with a three-phase approach: laying the foun- dation with some no-regret initiatives, such as simplifying interaction Executive Summary
  • 6. 4 | Digital Insurance in Italy at digital touchpoints and gradually building up data assets; digitizing the business model by developing digital tools and applications that facilitate sales and service the customer; and finally, developing com- petitive differentiation with a uniquely recognized “digital spike.” In addition, we stress the key role that an innovation-oriented culture plays in the success of a digital transformation. Looking at specific digital opportunities in insurance, we see that im- proving loss-prevention effectiveness has huge, untapped potential. According to BCG, insurers that take this step could improve their op- erating margins by as much as 1 to 2 percent of premiums. Reducing motor vehicle risks is a good place to start, owing to the widespread use of telematics, or black boxes. Connectivity is also rapidly spread- ing in health care and household management, making them promis- ing areas for innovation, too. Finally, we conclude with a collection of the challenges that Italian in- surers believe are hampering their digital development, such as the complexity of their legacy IT systems and current processes. A lack of alignment among an organization’s various stakeholders and the in- ability to secure management buy-in and investment are also stalling digital efforts. To help managers address these challenges, we offer some practical suggestions stemming from our experience and that of successful innovators. The report draws on BCG’s experience and research in the digital insurance sector in Italy and abroad; analysis and insights from Google’s research and experts; and interviews—jointly conducted by BCG and Google—with several Italian insurance managers to provide a new, practical, Italy-specific perspective on the insurers’ digital opportunity.
  • 7. The Boston Consulting Group | 5 Digitization is everywhere. Today, there are 7.3 billion mobile-phone subscriptions,1 3 billion Internet users,2 and 2 billion social-media users.3 There are more digital connections in the world than there are people. Digital innovation happens at a rapid pace, and its influence spreads at an exponential rate. The Digital Economy The new digital economy is a product of digi- tization and is radically different from the tra- ditional one. If we consider the ways compa- nies interact with their customers, digitization has increased the number of touchpoints, im- proved the ability to target specific segments, and broadened and accelerated the reach of companies’ actions. Digitization is driving a fundamental shift in the relationships that companies have with their customers. Digitization is also a major disruptive force that has completely reshaped traditional business models that have been in place for decades; so-called digital disruptors have emerged in many industries. Digitization is not about doing the same things only faster or cheaper; rather, it is about enabling new business ideas and busi- ness models—from a sharing economy to global scalable platforms. There are many ex- amples of winning companies with “digital DNA.” Uber, the app-based transportation network and taxi company, has been quickly disrupting city transportation services and the traditional taxi business. Netflix, a con- tent distributor, has upended the media in- dustry, causing giants such as Blockbuster to yield to more agile and digital-savvy players. Every day there are new businesses being cre- ated that are generating revenues in new ways. Digital innovation is never ending. Digital gi- ants such as Google and Amazon continuous- ly innovate, reinventing their value proposi- tion to remain relevant to their customers and making their industries fluid and dynamic. Italy’s Digital Evolution As of October 2014, there were 41 million In- ternet users in Italy,4 more than 25 million ac- tive social-network users,5 and about 95 mil- lion active mobile-phone subscriptions.6 The country’s Internet penetration of 66 percent is lower than that of other advanced econo- mies in Western Europe. In Norway, for ex- ample, Internet penetration is 87 percent. However, Italy’s Internet usage has grown in the past two years by 6.8 percent, and 84 per- cent of the population use the Internet if we only consider people between the ages of 11 and 74. What is surprising about Italy is the wide- spread use of mobile phones, which had a DIGITIZATION IS A DISRUPTIVE TREND
  • 8. 6 | Digital Insurance in Italy market penetration of 82.2 percent in 2014. Smartphones are increasing their share among mobile devices and are projected to grow from 49.5 percent in 2014 to almost 72 percent in 2018.7 Rapid smartphone adoption is fueling the dramatic increase in online usage. Every day, more than 15 million Italians access the Inter- net from their smartphones, compared with 13 million people who log on from their per- sonal computers and 5 million who access it from their tablets.8 E-commerce is also growing. According to a study from Politecnico di Milano, revenue from e-commerce sales totaled about 13 bil- lion in 2014 after growing, on average, 18 per- cent per year since 2009.9 An even more ac- celerated growth pattern applies for purchasing transactions from mobile devices. Notes 1. GSMA Intelligence, https://gsmaintelligence.com/, January, 2015. 2. EMarketer, “Worldwide Internet and Mobile Users,” January, 2015. 3. We Are Social, “Digital Statshot 002,” http://www .slideshare.net/wearesocialsg/we-are-socials-digital -statshot-002. 4. Audiweb Database (powered by Nielsen), October 2014. 5. Audiweb Database (powered by Nielsen), October 2014. 6. AGCOM, Osservatorio trimestrale sulle Telecomunicazioni, September 2014. 7. EMarketer, “Smartphone Users and Penetration in Western Europe, by Country, 2013 through 2018.” 8. Audiweb Database (powered by Nielsen), October 2014. 9. Pagamenti elettronici e mobile payment & commerce: i valori del transato, Osservatori.net.
  • 9. The Boston Consulting Group | 7 Digital transformation has come to the insurance industry, bringing with it a huge business opportunity that will grow in the coming years. Given that most insurance players are still exploring the digital land- scape, the potential is mostly untapped. Interestingly, the 2014 BCG Global Innovators Survey—which collected the opinions of more than 1,500 senior executives world- wide—shows that insurance managers are well aware of the coming impact of digitiza- tion. In fact, this survey reveals that about 40 percent of insurance executives expect big data and mobile devices to have a significant impact on the industry over the next three to five years, placing insurance behind only the technology and telecommunications indus- tries in terms of the most affected sectors. Like executives in many other industries, however, a significantly lower percentage of insurance managers are actively targeting big data and mobile devices in their innovation programs, hence missing the opportunity. (See Exhibit 1.) The Effect of Digital Channels A recent BCG survey on global consumer sen- timent highlighted that in Italy, insurance consumers are turning to digital channels. Ac- cording to the research, about 50 to 55 per- cent of protection, health, and property and casualty (P&C) consumers require both rela- tionship channels (an agent, bank, or broker) and digital channels. In addition, approximately 15 percent of cus- tomers are ready to transition to digital-only interactions, bringing the overall reach of dig- ital channels to almost 70 percent of insur- ance customers in terms of their future buy- ing channels. The remaining customers, a little more than 30 percent, still prefer rela- tionship channels only, but that number is decreasing. (See Exhibit 2.) From 2008 through 2013, online searches related to insurance grew 128 percent. Italian consumers are not only leaning to- ward digital channels but also making a sig- nificant part of their purchasing decisions outside insurers’ domains. Consumers are increasingly using digital tools to search for product information, prices, and reviews. From 2008 through 2013, online searches related to insurance grew 128 percent, and more specifically, searches related to car in- surance grew 185 percent. These numbers give us a sense of the massive business opportunity for digital insurance in FOLLOW YOUR CLIENTS ONLINE
  • 10. 8 | Digital Insurance in Italy 0 10 20 30 40 50 10 20 30 40 50 60 Chemicals Consumer products Energy Financial services Industrial/manufacturing Pharma/biotech/health care Telecommunications Retail Insurance Technology (IT services) Technology (soware) Technology (hardware) Respondents actively targeting mobile products in their innovation program (%) Respondents expecting a significant impact from mobile products over the next three to five years (%) Autos/motor vehicles Tech industry AverageOther industry Behavior = belief Impact of mobile products1 Attitude toward digital channels Property and casualty1 High 10.5 16.7 6.1 Medium 12.0 16.2 5.2 Low 14.2 4.6 14.6 Income ∑ ∑ Protection1 37% 47% 16% Owners (%) Owners (%) 37% 51% 12% High 12.1 18.7 2.5 Medium 11.6 16.4 5.4 Low 13.7 15.4 4.3 Health1 High 8.3 20.9 4.1 Medium 9.9 18.5 4.9 Low 15.9 15.3 2.2 ∑ 34% 55% 11% Owners (%) Prefer relationship channelsHybridsPrefer digital channels Source: 2014 BCG Global Innovators Survey. 1 There is a similar pattern in other digital areas, such as big-data analytics. Source: 2012 BCG Global Consumer Sentiment Survey. Note: Interviewees were selected from 11 income brackets. Interviewees were asked this question: In general, how useful are or would the following interactions modes be to you when it comes to dealing with your insurance providers? 1 Any apparent discrepancies in totals are the result of rounding. Exhibit 1 | Many Insurance Executives Expect Digital Products to Have a High Impact, but Few Are Taking Action Exhibit 2 | Many Insurance Customers in Italy Are Already “Hybrids”
  • 11. The Boston Consulting Group | 9 Italy. Let’s take this a step further, however. A recent market study by Google shows, by in- surance category, the share of consumers that use the Web to gather information and com- pare prices. Using this research, we can better quantify the size of the opportunity. Considering that the overall 2013 retail P&C market (that is, excluding commercial insur- ance) in Italy was worth 28 billion to 30 bil- lion in premiums and that the percentage of insurance buyers who research online ranges from 29 percent (those interested in house- hold insurance) to 56 percent (those research- ing automotive insurance), we can estimate that the value of digital insurance premiums is approximately 12 billion to 14 billion (as- suming the middle of the range). (See Exhibit 3.) With regards to the life insurance business, we start from an overall market of roughly 80 billion in retail life-insurance premiums. Furthermore, our data suggests that about 50 percent of buyers of financial products research online for information before purchasing. Hence, even if we prudently assume that the percentage of life insurance buyers researching online is much lower than the broad average for financial products because of the inherent complexity of the product—say 20 to 30 percent of buyers— then we can estimate that the value of digital life-insurance premiums is 18 billion to 22 billion. This brings the total value of digital insurance premiums to 30 billion to 36 billion. This estimate is expected to increase as pro- spective customers change their purchasing behaviors. The BCG 2012 Insurance and New Media Consumer Survey shows that 43 per- cent of respondents met an agent in person for past transactions, but only 40 percent will do so for future transactions. In addition, the use of digital channels is on the rise: 58 per- cent of respondents will visit company web- sites, compared with 18 percent who did so for past transactions, and 45 percent will use a Web search engine, compared with 9 per- cent who did so in the past. Demographics will play a significant part in fueling the size of the opportunity in the fu- ture. Younger Italians are significantly more Property and casualty* Life* Retail premiums in the Italian market, 2013† €28 billion to €30 billion Purchasers who researchedonline before buyinginsurance Total premiums affected by online search €79 billion to €81 billion €12 billion to €14 billion‡ €18 billion to €22 billion 29–56% 20–30% €30 billion to €36 billion Sources: ANIA; Google Consumer Barometer. * Estimates. † Including European Union companies. ‡ Assuming middle of range. Exhibit 3 | The Size of the Insurance Market Influenced by the Web Is Already €30 Billion to €36 Billion
  • 12. 10 | Digital Insurance in Italy proficient in using digital resources and pre- fer those channels over the traditional ones. The Potential Is Untapped BCG and Google conducted interviews with major industry players and found that there is a shared sense of urgency for digital trans- formation. Most players recognize the impact of digital channels. Nonetheless, there is widespread concern given that the industry is unprepared to cope because of its structural shortcomings. Since 2007, traditional insurers have been gradually losing online brand share to direct players and aggregators—companies that have built a significant position online in re- cent years. Traditional insurers’ brand share of overall online insurance searches declined from 39 percent in 2007 to 34 percent in 2014, well below their fair share when we consider premium revenues. (See Exhibit 4.) By contrast, direct insurers and then aggrega- tors filled this gap. Aggregators alone repre- sented almost a fifth (17 percent) of online brand share in 2014. When we compare online brand share with real brand share for each player (excluding aggregators), the vast majority of traditional insurers is underrepresented online. (See Exhibit 5.) If we consider emerging buying behaviors, the gap between online and real brand share should be worrisome for established insurers in the medium term and calls for a review of their go-to-market strategy. That said, some early recovery signs in 2014 might indicate a greater focus by traditional insurers on advertising and an online presence. Changing the Go-to-Market Approach Changing the way an insurer interacts with its clients is critical to harvesting the potential of digital insurance. With rising acquisition costs and surging churn rates, customer retention is an impera- tive for Italian insurers. For example, churn rates for third-party-liability automotive in- surance in Italy increased from less than 10 percent to approximately 20 percent in the past five years. To be successful, industry players should de- vote the effort necessary to truly understand the “moments of truth” in the customer jour- Trend inversion in 2014 potentially signals efforts by traditional insurers to increase advertising and improve Web presence 39 40 37 33 29 30 31 34 59 59 61 65 60 53 49 49 10 16 20 17 80 100 40 20 0 60 1 Traditional insurers Direct players Insurers’ brand share of online search (%) 11 Aggregators 20142013201220112010200920082007 2 Source: Google proprietary data. Note: Any apparent discrepancies in totals are the result of rounding. Exhibit 4 | Online Brand Share Is Dominated by Direct Players and Aggregators
  • 13. The Boston Consulting Group | 11 ney and explore how digital channels can help improve the customer experience at those touchpoints. BCG experience shows that when improving the digital experience for customers, it is criti- cal to segment them on the basis of behaviors and needs, since the reasons for an insurance purchase may vary significantly across clus- ters of consumers. Digital features multiply the number of possibilities to personalize the selling proposition—if the insurer is able to identify the segment in which a customer be- longs early on in the sales process. Digital channels have multiplied the number of touchpoints and taken away the early stages of the sales process—when customers look for information, compare companies, and form a buying decision—from physical channels. Thus, having a direct insurance subsidiary alongside traditional operations is not suffi- cient anymore. But, indeed, we see an oppor- tunity to better leverage the specific experi- ence and skills that such subsidiaries have typically developed. Some insurers have invested in digital mar- keting not only to target consumers more di- rectly and effectively but also to gain an addi- tional opportunity to interact and engage with their clients. For example, SunLife, a di- rect-distribution brand of AXA, structured its online presence to increase trust and brand recognition through extensive customer re- views and clearer corporate communications. Other insurers have taken advantage of mul- tiple digital channels. For instance, in 2012, Allianz Germany further expanded its multi- channel approach and established social networks as an additional platform for sales agents. These and other success stories show that dig- ital channels enable a wide range of opportu- nities for insurers to shape the customer ex- perience across the entire front end of a company. 9 8 6 3 3 2 14 10 5 4 3 1211 0 5 10 15 #3 #4 #5 #7#6 #11 #12 Others1 #10#8 #9#1 Brands associated with insurance online queries, 2014 (%) #2 Traditional insurersDirect players Online share versus market share Online market position Source: Google proprietary data. Note: Online brand share, excluding aggregators. 1 Mostly traditional insurance companies. Exhibit 5 | Most Traditional Insurers Are Underrepresented in Online Share “Digital channels provide a huge opportuni- ty to listen to our clients. We are not doing it seriously, and churn rates prove it.” —Head of marketing at a large insurance group
  • 14. 12 | Digital Insurance in Italy Mobile Is the EMERGING DIGITAL TREND Mobile devices are a major consumer trend in Italy. In 2014, the number of mobile-device users was 50.7 million, of which 24.1 million were equipped with smartphones. On a daily basis, these smart- phone users made 16.6 million connections and spent an average of 1 hour and 37 min- utes online, exceeding the number of connec- tions and the amount of time spent online by users of traditional desktops.1 By 2018, the number of smartphone users will climb to 37 million. The importance of mobile devices will in- crease over time, as younger consumers are naturally more inclined to use these devices. The 2013 BCG Global Consumer Sentiment Survey highlights that 76 percent of Italian respondents between the ages of 18 and 24 use a smartphone, compared with 31 percent over the age of 65; similarly, 30 percent of re- spondents between the ages of 18 and 24 use a smartphone as a shopping platform, com- pared with 5 percent over the age of 65. A step change is expected as those under the age of 18, who consider using mobile devices “standard practice,” gain purchasing power. The presence of mobile devices has become so ubiquitous that, according to Google, 78 percent of all smartphone users are online daily with their device, compared with 60 percent of laptop users and 49 percent of tablet users. Mobile shopping is rapidly gaining share in Italy. Research by comScore indicates that the penetration rate of mobile commerce com- pared with total e-commerce in Italy is the second highest in Europe and the fastest growing. (See Exhibit 6.) Mobile shoppers are usually frequent purchasers; approximately 60 percent buy something through a mobile device at least once a month.2 By 2018, the number of smartphone users will climb to 37 million. The use of location services on smartphones is growing exponentially: 92 percent of smart- phone users access their phone to find infor- mation on local stores, and 28 percent access local information every day. More important, those who research local information are more likely to engage in specific actions: com- Score’s research indicates that 48 percent contacted stores directly, 60 percent visited them, and 30 percent purchased something.3 Nonetheless, it would be an error to envision mobile devices purely as substitutes for tradi- tional laptop connections. According to a study by Google and TNS, 51 percent of consumers use at least two types of devices to connect to
  • 15. The Boston Consulting Group | 13 the Internet, and 13 percent of consumers con- nect using up to three types of devices. This phenomenon, referred to as “multi- screening,” is another important trend and proves that digital interaction should not be thought of as a linear process. Rather, con- necting with consumers happens on a num- ber of devices and platforms that are activat- ed from various places. In 2015, the potential number of personal connected devices will increase from three—a laptop, tablet, and smartphone—to six, as consumers add Web TV, smart watches, and connected cars to their mix, giving com- panies multiple new touchpoints. Providing a Satisfactory Mobile Experience The use of new devices is booming among in- surance customers. Google’s experience shows that searches using smartphones across multiple insurance lines increased dra- matically since 2008. (See Exhibit 7.) However, as of September 2014, only two out of five major insurance groups in Italy had a native mobile site, or m-site. In addition, these m-sites mainly focused on providing fast quotes and agency locations; they didn’t offer a complete range of services. The re- maining three insurance groups presented a smaller version of their desktop website to mobile users, deteriorating the customer ex- perience. This is even more surprising if we consider that statistics from Google show that 67 percent of consumers who access the In- ternet through a smartphone or tablet are more likely to take action—buy a product, complete a form, or download an app—on a website that is optimized for mobile devices.4 Engaging Customers A large number of insurers outside Italy have redesigned their entire approach for mobile devices, adopting simplicity and ease of use to improve the customer experience. For exam- ple, Oscar, a U.S.-based health-insurance com- pany, designed a straightforward instant- quote system for mobile devices that lets customers easily adjust predefined parame- ters to receive instant pricing information. More broadly, mobile devices should be part of a multichannel business model, in order to 23 21 18 12 10 34 70 36 40 30 0 20 40 60 80 Growth across European countries averaged 42.5% France Mobile e-commerce in Europe (%) SpainGermanyItalyUK Year-over-year growth Penetration (m-commerce compared with total e-commerce) Italy is Europe’s second-highest market when m-commerce is compared with total e-commerce and is the fastest growing Source: ComScore, “The Role of Mobile in Online Shopping and Buying,” May 21, 2014. Exhibit 6 | Mobile E-commerce in Italy Is Widespread and Fast Growing
  • 16. 14 | Digital Insurance in Italy drive customers to physical locations. Creat- ing a smooth customer process requires an understanding of consumer habits and effec- tive cooperation with the distribution net- work. Some real-world examples from other industries may provide food for thought. Nissan used mobile technology to increase the number of digital leads for dealerships. In July 2013, the automotive company launched a Nissan Note group for the Waze app that helps drivers locate the closest dealership for test-driving the car. In November 2013, Nis- san launched a “geo-fencing” campaign: cus- tomers who entered a defined geographic area received dynamic advertising banners that included click-to-call buttons to book a test-drive and directed potential customers to nearby dealerships. As a result of both ef- forts, 20 percent of Nissan’s digital leads came from mobile devices in 2013, and 35 percent of its global Web traffic now comes from mobile devices in the U.S. Carrefour Bank’s experience demonstrates how mobile devices can be instrumental to both providing value-added services and seg- menting customers. The French company dif- ferentiated its mobile presence with two in- terfaces. The first was a mobile site with a loan calculator (to determine monthly pay- ments depending on the amount borrowed), Web callback, and simple inquiry forms de- signed to attract new customers. The second was an app designed to enhance interaction with existing customers by pushing personal- ized offers and scheduling retargeting cam- paigns. The impact was a twofold increase in conversions on mobile devices, compared with conversions on desktops. The overall goal was to have mobile devices account for 25 percent of Web sales in 2015. Mobile devices can also enable new and inno- vative business models, and some insurers have created mobile applications to sell “on the go” insurance products. Tokio Marine 50 100 0 +158% 2014201320122011201020092008 Mobile search queries (indexed) Car insurance 100 0 50 +158% 2014201320122011201020092008 Health insurance 100 0 50 +156% 2014201320122011201020092008 Life insurance 0 100 50 +145% 2010 201320112009 2012 20142008 Home insurance Source: Google internal data. Exhibit 7 | The Use of Mobile Devices in Insurance Searches Is Booming
  • 17. The Boston Consulting Group | 15 Management has introduced short-term in- surance policies that can be purchased for short periods of time, such as a day or a few weeks. These policies are designed to protect customers when they engage in infrequent activities. The mobile app uses a global posi- tioning system (GPS) to determine customers’ locations and proactively prompts them with relevant one-time insurance products, such as travel insurance when customers are at an airport or accident insurance when they are at a ski resort. Customers can complete the purchase of the policy instantaneously on their mobile devices. Notes 1. Audiweb Database (powered by Nielsen), October 2014. 2. EMarketer, “The Role of Mobile in Online Shopping and Buying,” May 2014. 3. Google, “Our Mobile Planet: Understanding the Mobile Consumer,” May 2013. 4. Google, Sterling Research, and SmithGeiger, “What Users Want Most From Mobile Sites Today.”
  • 18. 16 | Digital Insurance in Italy A TRANSFORMATION JOURNEY Digital transformation is a process of increasing complexity. Regardless of the long-term target business model, we recom- mend adopting a phased approach to the digital transformation journey. The phases we propose include initiatives that take into account the starting point of Italian insurers and address the major issues insurers face with a pragmatic ap- proach. All in all, these initiatives represent stepping stones for change. (See Exhibit 8.) Phase One: Preparing the Foundation Most insurance companies have high ambi- tions for a digital transformation. But when companies begin the process, they struggle to identify a starting point and a coherent course of action. To help insurance compa- nies lay the foundation for their transforma- tion effort, we suggest undertaking the fol- lowing five initiatives. “Hygiene” conditions to tap into digitization • Simple and coherent digital interfaces • Investment in data assets • Aligned organization and partners Digitization embedded in the business model • Digitization enhances sales process, risk management, and operations • Redesign of products and channels Digital spike is recognized in the market • Areas of digital excellence, as a marketing lever and competitive differentiator • Customers delighted through digitization A step-wise journey with a time horizon of at least two to three years Distinguishing digital spike Business model digitization Foundation Phase 1 Phase 2 Phase 3 Source: BCG analysis. Exhibit 8 | How to Craft a Digital Transformation
  • 19. The Boston Consulting Group | 17 Simplify interaction at digital touchpoints. According to a BCG survey that asked consumers to rate their digital interactions with various industries, respondents rated their digital experiences with the insurance industry among the worst. The daunting website registration process to get an online quote was one reason for customers’ dissatisfaction. At a minimum, then, an insurer should set up a simple, effective website that has an intui- tive registration process and that is easy to navigate. The website should provide clear product information and optimize the digi- tal-conversion funnel. The proper use of fonts and images can significantly improve custom- er satisfaction, as can an appropriate amount of information and interaction. Insurers can improve cus- tomer interaction simply by creating a mobile presence. Provide a coherent digital presence across channels. Today, having a digital presence means providing customers with access to services anywhere and anytime. Customers want to be able to choose any channel, or a combination of channels, to interact with com- panies. It is critical for insurers to provide this choice at every step of the value chain. In addition, insurers should have the same look and feel across all channels and devices and coherently manage distributors’ presence on social media. Furthermore, companies should ensure that information captured anywhere online is also available through physical channels. Create a mobile presence. Insurers can improve customer interaction and the num- ber of touchpoints simply by creating a mobile presence. This is important given that one of every three inquiries comes from mobile devices and that 82 percent of the population uses mobile phones. Insurers should build websites with dedicated mobile landing pages. In addition, compa- nies’ mobile apps should provide customer- centric—rather than product-centric—func- tionality and offer support for every step of the customer life cycle, rather than focusing only on claims management. Both mobile websites and mobile apps should implement functionality that enables direct interactions with clients. For example, click-to-call buttons can redirect support requests or leads to the closest agent available, thus increasing con- version rates. Similarly, GPS services can be used to offer customers one-time insurance products on the basis of their location or to target specific customer segments by alerting them that they are close to an agency loca- tion. Most of these activities can be launched without running into IT legacy issues or seri- ous budget constraints. Build up data assets. Insurers often lack information about their customers because of infrequent contact with them; about half of an insurer’s clients are contacted once a year or less. In addition, this interaction often happens with an agent or intermediary. Insurers should start addressing their chronic information gap and build up the firm’s data assets by collecting all the available informa- tion on existing clients and creating a single data repository. Information can be collected online by encouraging customers to use pri- vate areas on a website, which are now com- pulsory under Italian regulations. By having customers log in, insurers can capture person- al information as well as navigation patterns and preferences—all of which insurers can then analyze and monitor. To gather the in- formation needed, insurers have to drive sig- nificant traffic to these areas by providing ad- ditional services—such as a client portal, personalized information services, and cus- tomized 24-7 chat support—that are attrac- tive to customers. “For us, digital transformation primarily means to provide a multiaccess service mod- el to customers, especially presale, creating an awareness of the need for protection and an interest in our products.” —Manager of an Italian bancassurance operator
  • 20. 18 | Digital Insurance in Italy Information can also be collected offline through the agent’s network. Most customer information still resides in local databases owned by agents. Insurers should work to inte- grate and centralize that information through a cooperative program with their agents. For example, the adoption of cloud solutions for document management in the agencies would allow, at the same time, for improved function- alities, digitization, and integration of data. Customer data is a strategic asset. Customer data is such a strategic asset that some innovators are gathering information on customer behaviors and preferences using ways that are normally employed by other consumer-focused industries. For example, some insurers are creating agreements with external partners, such as retailers, to share information about common clients, their be- haviors, purchasing patterns, lifestyles, and so on, whenever allowed by regulation. More- over, the rise of the Internet of Things—the connection of uniquely identifiable devices (such as wearables, telematics boxes, and house sensors) over the Internet—will give insurers the opportunity to have real-time in- formation on customers, their behaviors, and their risks. Bring distribution partners onboard. For most of the insurance managers we inter- viewed, being able to involve their agents in the digital transformation is key. Insurers should define a clear mutual-value proposi- tion for their distribution network to ensure cooperation. For example, a financial institu- tion recently launched a co-investment Web campaign for its insurance agents. Those that participated would benefit from advertising sponsored by the corporate marketing department and targeting users who connect- ed to the Internet from the agent’s local area. Providing digital tools that empower agents can also help get them onboard. Digital tools not only support a paperless, one-stop sales process but also have a substantial impact on operational efficiency, with upsides for both the company and the sales force. By implementing these initiatives, insurers can create momentum for their digital transformation. Phase Two: Digitizing the Business Model After laying the foundation for a digital trans- formation, insurers should focus on digital initiatives to enhance the core business. Digital tools and applications need to be leveraged to facilitate sales processes, free up agents’ time for sales, and enable real-time KPI monitoring. If a company wants to pursue online sales, it should develop a strong online channel with clear customer segmentation and a strong value proposition. This requires designing simple products and services specifically for the channel. If a company wants to keep its agent network as the main sales channel, a digital strategy should be designed to integrate online and off- line channels so traffic can be directed from one to the other. For example, the strategy should allow leads generated on the Web and other digital platforms to be directed to agents, and the strategy should let agents efficiently and effectively direct their clients to digital channels for customer care and renewal. New tools to service and engage customers proactively should also be created. The basis for these tools should be an analytics engine, which can use customer data and insights for better monitoring and analysis of customer issues and feedback. Phase Three: Creating a Distinguishing Digital Spike Finally, insurers should enhance their digital presence by identifying a unique value propo- sition—be it superior customer care, com- plete process digitization, or an enhanced multichannel approach—that differentiates them from the competition. Allianz in Italy, for example, was the first in- surer to offer and broadly advertise “fast quote” functionality, through which potential
  • 21. The Boston Consulting Group | 19 clients can quickly compare an Allianz offer for automotive insurance by sending only their birth date and car plate using short mes- sage service (SMS). Insurers can also extend their digital strategy and efforts beyond the core business. They can enhance the user experience by engaging users in product design; ensure a seamless multichannel experience by implementing an end-to-end customer-relationship-manage- ment system; or digitize back-office processes to reduce cost and improve efficiency. Taking a Cultural Leap Many major insurers are still deeply rooted in their traditional cultural and organizational values, and this prevents real change. It is one of the main reasons why, in past years, some companies have launched and delivered some easy quick wins but have not pursued a deep digital transformation. A culture ready for a digital transformation is, first of all, a culture based on sharing infor- mation, encouraging experimentation, and reacting promptly. In particular, becoming a digital company requires a new paradigm for innovation that must pervade the entire orga- nization. The old understanding of technolog- ical disruption with systematic, long-cycle R&D efforts based on heavy investments and a lengthy time frame does not work any lon- ger. A digital organization requires rapid-fire, free-wheeling experimentation with minimal investment requirements and a very short time frame. Becoming a digital company requires a new paradigm. The oversight process must also be different. Many insurers are still focused on a few iso- lated innovation projects, usually controlled by a centralized committee-driven structure. The solution is not to create highly detailed business cases, which usually prove to be also highly unrealistic, but to manage digital ini- tiatives as a portfolio. Insurers should find the right mix by balancing the level of disrup- tion, the likelihood of success, and the re- sources required by each initiative in the portfolio. In this respect, failure should be integrated as a source of learning: by testing several, even conflicting ideas, insurers should try to fail often, well, and soon. An in- novative culture, which is profoundly differ- ent from that of traditional large corpora- tions, is the distinguishing asset of winning digital players such as Google and Amazon. Finally, the role of employees should be re- considered. To support change, all employees need to be empowered with the freedom to generate bottom-up ideas. Time and resources must be allocated to try and test these ideas at an early stage. In addition, mechanisms must be put in place to choose among the ini- tiatives that work and then scale them. A recent BCG global survey shows that more than 70 percent of the most innovative com- panies have a specific organizational entity for managing radical innovation. Italian in- surers should consider establishing such fo- cused innovation units—as some large global peers have already done—with the mandate to scout out, nurture, and accelerate innova- tion efforts. The mission of “digital labs” may vary depending on the strategy and maturity of each player, but a dedicated structure can play a key role in orchestrating a company’s digital-innovation portfolio and lead to an overall cultural change. “Out of ten innovation opportunities, the management of a venture capital firm would spend the majority of its time discussing how to exploit the potential of the one win- ning idea. Here, we would only discuss how to deal with the failure of the other nine.” —Head of distribution innovation for a multinational insurer
  • 22. 20 | Digital Insurance in Italy LOSS PREVENTION A DIGITAL OPPORTUNITY New affordable technologies help share information and monitor critical data, increasing the possibility for consumers to lower their risk exposure. This develop- ment allows insurers to move from simple risk assessment to dynamic knowledge of risk and mitigation whenever possible. Digital initiatives, then, can directly affect the single most important cost item on an insur- er’s P&L: losses, which in 2013 were about 15 billion for the Italian retail P&C market. According to BCG analysis, the implementa- tion of a digital strategy for loss prevention can generate an improvement in operating mar- gins of as much as 1 to 2 percent of premiums. Digital initiatives can affect the most important cost item on an insurer’s P&L: losses. The digital revolution and the rise of the In- ternet of Things will allow something that has not been possible before: real-time monitor- ing and interaction, ad hoc gathering of cus- tomer information, and data analytics for the discovery of upcoming risks. (See Exhibit 9.) On one hand, these capabilities allow insur- ers to better anticipate risk. On the other hand, they can lower risk by influencing cus- tomer behavior through digital interaction with the customer and through establishing a direct link between behavior and the amount of a customer’s premiums. Reducing Motor Vehicle Risks Today, Italy has one of the highest penetra- tions of motor telematics, or black boxes, in the world. Research conducted by BCG and Ania highlighted that at the end of 2013, there were 2 million black boxes installed in cars, representing 6 percent of the auto mar- ket. Black box installations are projected to reach 10 to 15 percent of the car market by 2017. The precious behavioral data collected through these devices can be stored and ana- lyzed for loss-prevention purposes. Additionally, this data can be made accessible to customers through an online portal and can be used as a basis for offering value- added services, such as how to optimize fuel consumption or driving-style suggestions. Real-time monitoring can also trigger imme- diate interaction in case of danger. For in- stance, in the case of dangerous habits or un- safe conditions, the system can contact the driver by sending a text or an e-mail message or by making an emergency call. By integrating black boxes with onboard di- agnostics (OBD), the possibilities expand.
  • 23. The Boston Consulting Group | 21 Imagine if a car’s tire pressure created a dan- gerous situation. OBD would communicate that information to the black box, which would alert the customer by displaying a message and recommending that the driver stop and check the tires. Several insurers have started to leverage be- havioral data coming from telematics. For ex- ample, Aviva targets younger drivers who pay higher premiums with an Android app that monitors drivers’ first 200 miles to determine individual premiums on the basis of driving behavior. The app records data on accelera- tion, braking, and cornering. Safe drivers are offered discounts up to 20 percent. Given the widespread use of mobile devices in Italy—and particularly smartphones—de- veloping an app that helps customers reduce their motor-vehicle risks would, in turn, help insurers prevent losses. In addition, an app would help insurers gain access to a large pool of users, even beyond those who in- stalled a black box in their cars. And an app could be an opportunity to increase the num- ber of touchpoints with customers, thanks to its regular use, and to improve customers’ sat- isfaction with their insurance company, thanks to services that make their overall driving experience better. For example, an Italian direct insurer recently launched a hailstorm service that uses Twit- ter and the company’s website to alert cus- tomers about potential hailstorms throughout the country. The application could be integrated with a black box and OBD to provide diagnostic in- formation. For instance, the application could provide periodic repair reminders and the ad- dress of the closest branded repairer or links to a how-to library for immediate repairs. Bosch Group is already distributing an appli- cation called fun2drive that is directly linked to a car’s diagnostics using Bluetooth and provides several features, such as vehicle-per- AgricultureTransport HomeHealth care Car Personal safety Xega’s GPS implant helps locate someone in distress Marubeni’s sensor allows remote monitoring of vital signs HDFC ERGO insurance uses RFID tags for livestock insurance Trucks collect weather data that is used to improve planning 4.3 m illion Google hits 3 m illion Google hits 10 m illion Google hits 2 m illion Google hits 1.3 m illion Google hits 4 m illion Google hits Asahi Fire & Marine uses video dongles for PAYD car insurance RWE SmartHome has a portfolio of 20 smart devices Source: Google and BCG experience, 2013 data. Note: RFID = radio frequency identification; PAYD = pay as you drive; GPS = global positioning system. Exhibit 9 | Telematics and Digital Devices Open New Loss-Prevention Possibilities
  • 24. 22 | Digital Insurance in Italy formance tracking, trip analysis, and engine diagnostics. Last but not least, an app could provide use- ful safety features, such as nighttime driving alerts and alarms in case a driver falls asleep. The iOnRoad app warns drivers if there’s in- sufficient distance between them and other drivers or if they begin to cross into another lane. The app also can locate a parked car and offers SMS and a notification reader. Although it isn’t costly to develop mobile apps, insurers should consider providing a branded interface to best-of-breed apps, such as Waze or Google Maps. Hence, the value that an insurance company can bring to its clients goes beyond a specific technological solution and consists of provid- ing a broader integrated service, which at the same time improves the experience of the customers and reduces their risks. Reducing Health Care and Household Risks Connectivity is spreading in the service of health care, too. Humana and other health- care insurers have incorporated the concept of remote monitoring into interactive health- care devices. These devices monitor Medicare members who are living with congestive heart failure, allowing for remote detection of issues and remote advisory to the patient. This enables quickly responding to emergen- cies, easily sharing information, and following up remotely. Office visits are reduced by 50 percent, resulting in reduced costs. In addi- tion, early detection results in faster treat- ment, ultimately reducing claim costs. A large European insurer recently partnered with a health program that offers individual participants services and incentives for main- taining an active lifestyle; data shows that mortality rates are as much as 50 percent lower for those who participate and their loy- alty rates to the insurer are as much as three times higher. A similar approach can be ob- served in household insurance, where insur- ers are starting to leverage the potential of remote sensors to reduce risk. Such examples point to the development of “ecosystems” of companies built around a specific area of customer need (such as main- taining good health or ensuring a safe house- hold)—ecosystems in which the insurer is one of the players. These advanced business mod- els, enabled by digital connectivity, may be created and orchestrated by an insurance company (as Ping An Insurance did in China) or be led by a company that owns the cus- tomer relationship (such was the role of the Japanese e-retailer Rakuten). In the latter case, the insurance provider plays only a “fac- tory” role. Obviously, the share of value cap- tured by an insurer is very different in these two scenarios, providing an incentive to be a first mover.
  • 25. The Boston Consulting Group | 23 Our interviews with major insurers highlighted that many struggle to deliver on customer expectations mainly because of internal roadblocks that are impeding digital change rather than external constraints. Companies should consider the following factors and reflect on how they might affect the approach to a digital transformation before planning one. Legacy IT First and foremost, legacy IT systems repre- sent a nightmare for insurers, as most compa- nies have inherited complex, static, and frag- mented systems. Gartner estimates that more than two-thirds of global life and P&C insur- ers still rely significantly on legacy systems— some of which date back to the 1970s and 1980s—to manage their core processes. Therefore, in order to craft an IT develop- ment strategy, it is fundamental to under- stand what the starting point is and how to get the basics under control. For example, in- surers should determine if the current IT solutions are scalable across online and off- line channels. Furthermore, as a digital transformation hing- es on sharing and integrating information, companies should assess the effort required to make their current data assets accessible by all new systems. A digital transformation hinges on sharing and integrating information. To address these issues, experience suggests that developing a temporary IT overlay that is loosely integrated with a legacy environ- ment (so-called two-speed IT) can be a way to rapidly implement IT prototypes for new product or channel functionalities without undermining the systems’ integrity. Legacy Processes Beyond legacy IT, legacy processes can repre- sent a serious hurdle. The extent to which current processes will be replaced by digital processes is a factor to be considered, thus anticipating potential resistance in changing consolidated habits. When planning a digital transformation, therefore, companies should THE MAIN CHALLENGE INTERNAL LEGACIES “The main obstacle to a digital transformation is our legacies: first IT, but also processes, products, and culture.” —Head of sales at a large Italian insurer
  • 26. 24 | Digital Insurance in Italy determine the incentives for employees to switch to new processes and how this transi- tion can be managed in an organic way throughout the organization. It is important that the new processes are implemented without leaving the old processes still in place in the organization. Organization Our interviews with insurance companies in Italy highlighted that “digitization” means different things to different people in a com- pany: for the claims management depart- ment, it might imply a new IT system to use; for the sales force, a new channel to contact the client; for the actuaries, a new source of information; and so on. Therefore, it is not surprising that it is often difficult to align the various stakeholders and get them onboard for this kind of project. Insurers should determine the parts of the organization that are involved, the goals of the digital project, and how to sustain a cross-functional effort toward change. In this process, pinpointing responsibilities and identifying a clear sponsor at the senior level is vital. In our experience, creating a center of com- petence with a cross-functional team to de- velop and test ideas in a safe environment can be an effective solution at least for the start-up phase. First, it enables sharing knowledge and expertise across functions. Second, it can represent a more agile organi- zational unit compared with a traditional de- partment. And third, it may irradiate success- ful solutions to other businesses units. Management Buy-In One of the main issues related to digital transformation cited by the interviewees is the difficulty in achieving a strong buy-in from senior management and from the board of directors. In most cases, even if officers at the level of vice president agree on the neces- sity to implement a digital transformation, plans and activities remain on paper, and lim- ited efforts and resources are specifically allo- cated to it. A recent success story from a ma- jor European insurer shows that having the CEO back a radical digital-transformation project is fundamental, if not necessary. Pro- ponents of a digital change should therefore evaluate the level of consensus and commit- ment from senior executives. Insurers should determine the goals of the digital project and how to sustain a cross-functional effort toward change. Budget Objections Finally, digital transformation has to cope with budget constraints and a lack of invest- ment. A complete digital makeover usually implies a long-term commitment, significant expenses, and usually limited returns in the very short term. Most of the interviewees cit- ed the difficulty of having these investments approved and the relatively small budget they have access to. To start a digital transformation, therefore, it’s important to understand the size of the available budget. In addition, our experience indicates that applying short-term financial parameters to evaluate innovation initiatives can preempt several opportunities. The 2014 BCG Global Innovators Survey clearly high- lights that breakthrough innovators tend to treat radical innovation projects very differ- “People use the buzzword “digital” all the time, but they refer to very different things.” —Chief marketing officer of a global insurance group “Any investment with a payback of more than 12 months will not even be considered.” —Head of claims management at a large Italian insurer
  • 27. The Boston Consulting Group | 25 ently from incremental projects, allowing the former broader objectives and more time for iterations. (See Exhibit 10.) More than 80 per- cent of breakthrough innovators allow such efforts to start without a projection of future returns. Insurers should therefore try to avoid strict enforcement of standard financial KPIs and choose longer-term success indicators. Also, it can be helpful to balance a portfolio of initiatives that have different probabilities of success and impact and different require- ments for cash outlays. How would you describe the processes and cultures governing disruptive or radical innovation projects? 8381 76 8284 81 78 75 8283 66 6164 68 72 59 65 697070 0 20 40 60 80 100 Differentiates between high and low innovativeness Room and time for experimentation Allows for iterations and adjustments –21 Respondents selecting “agree” or “strongly agree” (%) Incentives linked to radical innovations Different organization for incremental and radical projects Project approval does not depend on projection of future returns Open structure for collaboration –27 –24 Culture of experimentation Protects radical projects from strict cost control Top management committed to radical projects Governance Management Organization Breakthrough Innovators (N = 114) Other companies (N = 228) Source: 2014 BCG Global Innovators Survey (342 respondents). Exhibit 10 | Breakthrough Innovators Treat Radical Innovation Very Differently from Incremental Projects
  • 28. 26 | Digital Insurance in Italy THE TIME TO ACT IS NOW We can debate how radical the impact of the Internet of Things will be or how much cloud computing will change the way business is done, but what is clear is that digital transformation and all that it implies has come to the insurance industry and will be growing during the next several years. What lies ahead is a once-in-a-lifetime oppor- tunity for Italian insurance companies to seize significant value while most of their competitors are still trying to figure out what to do. The time has come to reorient and drive the organization in order to face the structural hurdles that have so far impeded a digital transformation. This time, change is all about testing quickly and learning early. C-level officers should decide whether they want to start this transformation or not. If there’s something that the digital economy has proven so far, it is that a timely reaction is the only way to survive in the market. The conclusion can be only one: the time to act is now.
  • 29. The Boston Consulting Group | 27 About the Authors Ugo Cotroneo is a partner and managing director in the Milan office of The Boston Consulting Group. Emanuele Costa is a principal in the firm’s Milan office. Giovanni Ciarlariello is business unit director of finance, technology, and telecommunications for Google Italy. Acknowledgments The authors would like to thank Laura Maida, Elisa Celestini, Stefano Piacentini, Daniela Rigante, and Gianluca Uberti at Google, as well as our colleague Carlo Bravin. For Further Contact This report was sponsored by BCG’s Insurance practice in Italy in col- laboration with Google Italy. If you would like to discuss the themes and content of this report, please contact one of the authors. Italy Ugo Cotroneo Partner and Managing Director BCG Milan +39 02 65 59 91 cotroneo.ugo@bcg.com Emanuele Costa Principal BCG Milan +39 02 65 59 91 costa.emanuele@bcg.com Giovanni Ciarlariello Business Unit Director of Finance, Technology, and Telecommunications Google Italy gci@google.com note to the reader
  • 30. © The Boston Consulting Group, Inc. 2015. All rights reserved. For information or permission to reprint, please contact BCG at: Phone: +39 02 65 59 91 Fax: +39 02 65 59 96 55 Mail: The Boston Consulting Group, Inc. Piazzetta Maurillo Bossi 2 Milan 20121 Italy To find the latest BCG content and register to receive e-alerts on this topic or others, please visit bcgperspectives.com. Follow bcg.perspectives on Facebook and Twitter. 3/15
  • 31. Abu Dhabi Amsterdam Athens Atlanta Auckland Bangkok Barcelona Beijing Berlin Bogotá Boston Brussels Budapest Buenos Aires Calgary Canberra Casablanca Chennai Chicago Cologne Copenhagen Dallas Detroit Dubai Düsseldorf Frankfurt Geneva Hamburg Helsinki Ho Chi Minh City Hong Kong Houston Istanbul Jakarta Johannesburg Kiev Kuala Lumpur Lisbon London Los Angeles Luanda Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Miami Milan Minneapolis Monterrey Montréal Moscow Mumbai Munich Nagoya New Delhi New Jersey New York Oslo Paris Perth Philadelphia Prague Rio de Janeiro Rome San Francisco Santiago São Paulo Seattle Seoul Shanghai Singapore Stockholm Stuttgart Sydney Taipei Tel Aviv Tokyo Toronto Vienna Warsaw Washington Zurich bcg.com | bcgperspectives.com