SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
Download to read offline
BESTWEEK
                                                                                                                                                        U.S./Canada



                                                                                                                                                      Weekly Insurance Newsletter
 January 25, 2010 • Issue 4
BEST’S REGIONAL COMPOSITE INDEXES WEEK/WEEK: U.S. (AMBUS)                                         0.21         •       EUROPE (AMBEUR) M -6.56                      •        ASIA/PACIFIC (AMBAP) M -3.52
                                                                                             M



Banks Forming (and Folding) Captives
By Sean P. Carr
   Banks and other financial institutions are both consoli-                                                  are striving to be more efficient, said Nancy Gray, regional


                                                       CAPTIVES
dating their captive insurance                                                                               director of the Americas for Aon Insurance Managers.
companies and launching                                                                                         “In some cases, they may have ended up with three or
new captives in a range of                                                                                   four captives when they only want one or two,” Gray said.
domiciles, according to regulators and industry observers.                                                   “They’re asking, ‘Is our existing structure OK, or should we
   As the banking industry has engaged in a wave of merg-                                                    be consolidating?’”
ers and acquisitions — Bank of America/Merrill Lynch,                                                           While he oversees the largest captive domicile in the
PNC/National City, Wells Fargo/Wachovia, to name a few                                                       United States, Vermont Deputy Insurance Commissioner
— banks and related financial entities have been consoli-                                                    David Provost said his state has seen such consolidation.
dating their captives. In better economic times, financial                                                   While still gaining 39 new captives in 2009, Vermont saw
institutions often did not worry about winding down                                                          the dissolution of 36 others, one-third of which were due
potentially superfluous captives, but in this climate they                                                   I See BANKS, Page 5

A Closer Look                                      Game Changer
Insurers Are
Among Top
Campaign
Cash Donors
By Jesse A. Hamilton
   A new U.S. Supreme
Court decision clears the
way for unlimited corpo-
rate spending on political
ads, though it still restricts
direct donations to candi-
dates. But even as the new
law is added to the books,
the insurance industr y
is already well into a sig-
                                                     FILIBUSTER FUEL: U.S. Senator-elect Scott Brown speaks during his victory party in Boston
nificant spending bout for                           Tuesday. Brown, a Republican, won the special election for the senate seat vacated by the late
the 2010 election cycle.                             Sen. Edward Kennedy, a long-time advocate of health care reform. Brown’s stunning victory over
The election year has just                           Attorney General Martha Coakley ended the Democrats’ 60-40 filibuster-proof majority in the
begun, but the industry had                          Senate. Health Reform update, Page 4.
                                                                                                                                                                                                     AP/Elise Amendola
I See CAMPAIGN, Page 6
 Health                                           Reinsurance                                                 Personal Lines                                               8 Regulation Tracker
 2 Major health insurers                          4 General Re agrees to                                      10 State Farm
 agree to pay                                     pay $92.2 mil-                                              says it won’t be                                           12 Rating Actions
 for critical care                                lion, dissolve                                              renewing 1,600                                             14 Stocks
 for clinical trial                               Dublin unit to                                              policies on North
 participants in                                  settle finite re charges.                                   Carolina’s Barrier                                         16 Perspectives
 Florida.                                                                                                     Islands.
             Copyright © 2010 by A.M. Best Company, Inc.
             All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means; electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise.
INDUSTRYWIDE                      BESTWEEK

Hanover Exec Says Acquisition of Campania
A ‘Good Start’ as Group Eyes Health Industry
   The acquisition of Campania Group Inc. by Hanover               home health care, podiatrists, behavioral health specialists
Insurance Group Inc. is a good start but “not the end” for         and, to a lesser extent, elder care providers, said Robinson.
a company with its sights set on insurance for the health             Agents will be able to integrate the niche
care industry.                                                     products offered by Campania into other
   Andrew Robinson, executive leadership team member               Hanover coverages, like commercial automo-
responsible for Hanover’s health care business, told Best-         bile or marine, Robinson said. “They can wrap
Week that Hanover has been “seeking to enter the health            these around other professional coverages,” he
care market for some time” and found Campania’s lines of           said.“We tend to build complete accounts in this manner.”
businesses appealing.                                                 The agreement with Campania follows Hanover’s
   “Our view is not to enter into the meat of the med-mal          announcement that it secured a deal to take over renewal
market,” Robinson said. “We’re interested in the niche-y           rights for a majority segment of OneBeacon Insurance
stuff.” The company has also heard from its agents, who            Group’s small and middle-market commercial business.
are looking to certain high-growth segments of insurance           Hanover acquired as much as $400 million in renewals from
for the health care industry to “grow their books where            OneBeacon, bolstering scale in Hanover’s commercial lines
there may be some contraction in other parts.”                     and increasing its portfolio with almost 20 new programs.
   Hanover’s business is marketed and distributed by approxi-      Hanover said it has launched new programs, purchased three
mately 3,000 independent agencies, according to BestLink.          specialty providers and built industry and niche solutions for
   The niche solutions offered by Vienna, Va.-based Campa-         a dozen new markets over the past five years.
nia include insurance for durable medical equipment for                                                         —Chad Hemenway

I   BANKS                                                             and boost their revenue streams.
From page 1                                                               “It’s all about control,” Provost said. Financial enti-
                                                                      ties want to save money and have access to reinsurance
to merger and acquisition activity, he said.                          options, he said.
   “Every time I read about a bank merger, I assume I’m                   A lot of banks formed mortgage insurance captives in
losing a captive,” Provost said.                                                            the late 1990s and early 2000s, Pro-
   In some cases, brand-new captives Captives State by State                                vost said. Surprisingly, he said, he is
are forming or changing states as          Snapshot                                         seeing that activity now, as well. After
a result of merger-related domicile                                    New in Net Change
                                                                                            massive shakeups in the housing mar-
reviews. Vermont gained 11 new cap- State                  Captives* 2009        in 2009    ket and among mortgage insurers, Pro-
tives from financial institutions in Vermont                     560        39            3 vost said,“They’re underwriting better
2009, including six that were not                                                           mortgages now than ever.”
                                          Hawaii                 162          4          -3
insurance companies. In Nevada,                                                                Gray said she is seeing banks form
regulators reported a surge in finan- South Carolina             161        13            4 captives to maximize their access to
cial-entity captives, including nine of Utah                     148        33           26 low-interest loans through the Fed-
their last 21 registrations.              Nevada                 130        11            6 eral Home Loan Banks. The 12 Fed-
   Banks create captives across a Arizona                         99          7          -7 eral Home Loan Banks are a system
broad range of lines, including direc- * Active captives as of Dec. 31, 2009.               of regional banks from which local
tors and officers liability, life, prop- Sources: State insurance departments.              lending institutions borrow funds to
erty/casualty and group benefits, said                                                      finance housing, economic develop-
Valerie Barton, executive director of the American Bankers ment and infrastructure projects. Provost said he knows
Insurance Association. For banks, establishing captives of a handful of non-bank financial companies that formed
makes a lot of sense, she said. They may already operate captives to take advantage of FHLB funding.
industry companies and are comfortable with the role of                   Captives may also provide banks and other institutions
captives.                                                             with speed-to-market benefits, said William P. White, manag-
   “It’s a very logical progression to take some of that risk ing principal, Prism Strategies LLC.
in-house,” Barton said. “Banks are used to taking risks, to               “Where there are problems, there are usually ways to
understanding risks.That’s what they do.”                             bridge that gap of uncertainty,” said White, the former cap-
   In the current economy, Barton said, financial institu- tive regulator for Delaware and Washington, D.C. “You can
tions — like all businesses — are also looking to diversify customize this, provided you’re willing to bear the risk.”

                                                                                  JanuaryXX, 2010 • BESTWEEK U.S./CANADA
                                                                                   Month 25,                                           5

More Related Content

Similar to Banks Forming (and Folding) Captives

Radical restructuring
Radical restructuringRadical restructuring
Radical restructuringDocJess
 
Federal Health Care Reform 2009: Affordable Health Care for All
Federal Health Care Reform 2009: Affordable Health Care for AllFederal Health Care Reform 2009: Affordable Health Care for All
Federal Health Care Reform 2009: Affordable Health Care for AllFHSU Learning Commons
 
Page 95 Journal of the International Academy for Case Stud.docx
Page 95 Journal of the International Academy for Case Stud.docxPage 95 Journal of the International Academy for Case Stud.docx
Page 95 Journal of the International Academy for Case Stud.docxbunyansaturnina
 
An End To Blank Cheques, May 2011
An End To Blank Cheques, May 2011An End To Blank Cheques, May 2011
An End To Blank Cheques, May 2011helen0101
 
Hacia Salud Presentation At Ag Safe
Hacia Salud Presentation At Ag SafeHacia Salud Presentation At Ag Safe
Hacia Salud Presentation At Ag Safeemcclements
 
Primerica Credibility (1)
Primerica Credibility (1)Primerica Credibility (1)
Primerica Credibility (1)Patrick Johnson
 
MLM Rate Survey 2016 Exec_Summary
MLM Rate Survey 2016 Exec_SummaryMLM Rate Survey 2016 Exec_Summary
MLM Rate Survey 2016 Exec_SummaryPaul Greve
 
Online Conference Takes “Deep Dive” into Affordable Care Act
Online Conference Takes “Deep Dive” into Affordable Care ActOnline Conference Takes “Deep Dive” into Affordable Care Act
Online Conference Takes “Deep Dive” into Affordable Care ActPYA, P.C.
 
QUIHUIS V. STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
QUIHUIS V. STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
QUIHUIS V. STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
QUIHUIS V. STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY enchantingkingd96
 
Survival Of The Fittest
Survival Of The FittestSurvival Of The Fittest
Survival Of The FittestSOCAR3AP
 
Survival Of The Fittest
Survival Of The FittestSurvival Of The Fittest
Survival Of The Fittestsmidthun
 
200901 loma resource-industry_forecast
200901 loma resource-industry_forecast200901 loma resource-industry_forecast
200901 loma resource-industry_forecastSteven Callahan
 
Preferred Healthcare Funding "Revenue Cycle Strategist Article"
Preferred Healthcare Funding  "Revenue Cycle Strategist Article"Preferred Healthcare Funding  "Revenue Cycle Strategist Article"
Preferred Healthcare Funding "Revenue Cycle Strategist Article"Michael Bumann, FFEMT
 
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.docx
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.docxCenters for Medicare and Medicaid Services.docx
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.docx4934bk
 
N A I C~ Update Spring2009
N A I C~ Update Spring2009N A I C~ Update Spring2009
N A I C~ Update Spring2009Robert Llewelyn
 
Obamacare: Increases Health Insurance Premiums
Obamacare: Increases Health Insurance PremiumsObamacare: Increases Health Insurance Premiums
Obamacare: Increases Health Insurance PremiumsThe Heritage Foundation
 
Chapter 10 Health Reform in the United StatesC
Chapter 10 Health Reform in the United StatesCChapter 10 Health Reform in the United StatesC
Chapter 10 Health Reform in the United StatesCEstelaJeffery653
 
Health Reform Policy and Information Update
Health Reform Policy and Information UpdateHealth Reform Policy and Information Update
Health Reform Policy and Information UpdateTom Daly
 
Survival Of The Fittest1
Survival Of The Fittest1Survival Of The Fittest1
Survival Of The Fittest1shawn4law
 

Similar to Banks Forming (and Folding) Captives (20)

Radical restructuring
Radical restructuringRadical restructuring
Radical restructuring
 
Top of The Class
Top of The ClassTop of The Class
Top of The Class
 
Federal Health Care Reform 2009: Affordable Health Care for All
Federal Health Care Reform 2009: Affordable Health Care for AllFederal Health Care Reform 2009: Affordable Health Care for All
Federal Health Care Reform 2009: Affordable Health Care for All
 
Page 95 Journal of the International Academy for Case Stud.docx
Page 95 Journal of the International Academy for Case Stud.docxPage 95 Journal of the International Academy for Case Stud.docx
Page 95 Journal of the International Academy for Case Stud.docx
 
An End To Blank Cheques, May 2011
An End To Blank Cheques, May 2011An End To Blank Cheques, May 2011
An End To Blank Cheques, May 2011
 
Hacia Salud Presentation At Ag Safe
Hacia Salud Presentation At Ag SafeHacia Salud Presentation At Ag Safe
Hacia Salud Presentation At Ag Safe
 
Primerica Credibility (1)
Primerica Credibility (1)Primerica Credibility (1)
Primerica Credibility (1)
 
MLM Rate Survey 2016 Exec_Summary
MLM Rate Survey 2016 Exec_SummaryMLM Rate Survey 2016 Exec_Summary
MLM Rate Survey 2016 Exec_Summary
 
Online Conference Takes “Deep Dive” into Affordable Care Act
Online Conference Takes “Deep Dive” into Affordable Care ActOnline Conference Takes “Deep Dive” into Affordable Care Act
Online Conference Takes “Deep Dive” into Affordable Care Act
 
QUIHUIS V. STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
QUIHUIS V. STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
QUIHUIS V. STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
QUIHUIS V. STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
 
Survival Of The Fittest
Survival Of The FittestSurvival Of The Fittest
Survival Of The Fittest
 
Survival Of The Fittest
Survival Of The FittestSurvival Of The Fittest
Survival Of The Fittest
 
200901 loma resource-industry_forecast
200901 loma resource-industry_forecast200901 loma resource-industry_forecast
200901 loma resource-industry_forecast
 
Preferred Healthcare Funding "Revenue Cycle Strategist Article"
Preferred Healthcare Funding  "Revenue Cycle Strategist Article"Preferred Healthcare Funding  "Revenue Cycle Strategist Article"
Preferred Healthcare Funding "Revenue Cycle Strategist Article"
 
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.docx
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.docxCenters for Medicare and Medicaid Services.docx
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.docx
 
N A I C~ Update Spring2009
N A I C~ Update Spring2009N A I C~ Update Spring2009
N A I C~ Update Spring2009
 
Obamacare: Increases Health Insurance Premiums
Obamacare: Increases Health Insurance PremiumsObamacare: Increases Health Insurance Premiums
Obamacare: Increases Health Insurance Premiums
 
Chapter 10 Health Reform in the United StatesC
Chapter 10 Health Reform in the United StatesCChapter 10 Health Reform in the United StatesC
Chapter 10 Health Reform in the United StatesC
 
Health Reform Policy and Information Update
Health Reform Policy and Information UpdateHealth Reform Policy and Information Update
Health Reform Policy and Information Update
 
Survival Of The Fittest1
Survival Of The Fittest1Survival Of The Fittest1
Survival Of The Fittest1
 

Banks Forming (and Folding) Captives

  • 1. BESTWEEK U.S./Canada Weekly Insurance Newsletter January 25, 2010 • Issue 4 BEST’S REGIONAL COMPOSITE INDEXES WEEK/WEEK: U.S. (AMBUS) 0.21 • EUROPE (AMBEUR) M -6.56 • ASIA/PACIFIC (AMBAP) M -3.52 M Banks Forming (and Folding) Captives By Sean P. Carr Banks and other financial institutions are both consoli- are striving to be more efficient, said Nancy Gray, regional CAPTIVES dating their captive insurance director of the Americas for Aon Insurance Managers. companies and launching “In some cases, they may have ended up with three or new captives in a range of four captives when they only want one or two,” Gray said. domiciles, according to regulators and industry observers. “They’re asking, ‘Is our existing structure OK, or should we As the banking industry has engaged in a wave of merg- be consolidating?’” ers and acquisitions — Bank of America/Merrill Lynch, While he oversees the largest captive domicile in the PNC/National City, Wells Fargo/Wachovia, to name a few United States, Vermont Deputy Insurance Commissioner — banks and related financial entities have been consoli- David Provost said his state has seen such consolidation. dating their captives. In better economic times, financial While still gaining 39 new captives in 2009, Vermont saw institutions often did not worry about winding down the dissolution of 36 others, one-third of which were due potentially superfluous captives, but in this climate they I See BANKS, Page 5 A Closer Look Game Changer Insurers Are Among Top Campaign Cash Donors By Jesse A. Hamilton A new U.S. Supreme Court decision clears the way for unlimited corpo- rate spending on political ads, though it still restricts direct donations to candi- dates. But even as the new law is added to the books, the insurance industr y is already well into a sig- FILIBUSTER FUEL: U.S. Senator-elect Scott Brown speaks during his victory party in Boston nificant spending bout for Tuesday. Brown, a Republican, won the special election for the senate seat vacated by the late the 2010 election cycle. Sen. Edward Kennedy, a long-time advocate of health care reform. Brown’s stunning victory over The election year has just Attorney General Martha Coakley ended the Democrats’ 60-40 filibuster-proof majority in the begun, but the industry had Senate. Health Reform update, Page 4. AP/Elise Amendola I See CAMPAIGN, Page 6 Health Reinsurance Personal Lines 8 Regulation Tracker 2 Major health insurers 4 General Re agrees to 10 State Farm agree to pay pay $92.2 mil- says it won’t be 12 Rating Actions for critical care lion, dissolve renewing 1,600 14 Stocks for clinical trial Dublin unit to policies on North participants in settle finite re charges. Carolina’s Barrier 16 Perspectives Florida. Islands. Copyright © 2010 by A.M. Best Company, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means; electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise.
  • 2. INDUSTRYWIDE BESTWEEK Hanover Exec Says Acquisition of Campania A ‘Good Start’ as Group Eyes Health Industry The acquisition of Campania Group Inc. by Hanover home health care, podiatrists, behavioral health specialists Insurance Group Inc. is a good start but “not the end” for and, to a lesser extent, elder care providers, said Robinson. a company with its sights set on insurance for the health Agents will be able to integrate the niche care industry. products offered by Campania into other Andrew Robinson, executive leadership team member Hanover coverages, like commercial automo- responsible for Hanover’s health care business, told Best- bile or marine, Robinson said. “They can wrap Week that Hanover has been “seeking to enter the health these around other professional coverages,” he care market for some time” and found Campania’s lines of said.“We tend to build complete accounts in this manner.” businesses appealing. The agreement with Campania follows Hanover’s “Our view is not to enter into the meat of the med-mal announcement that it secured a deal to take over renewal market,” Robinson said. “We’re interested in the niche-y rights for a majority segment of OneBeacon Insurance stuff.” The company has also heard from its agents, who Group’s small and middle-market commercial business. are looking to certain high-growth segments of insurance Hanover acquired as much as $400 million in renewals from for the health care industry to “grow their books where OneBeacon, bolstering scale in Hanover’s commercial lines there may be some contraction in other parts.” and increasing its portfolio with almost 20 new programs. Hanover’s business is marketed and distributed by approxi- Hanover said it has launched new programs, purchased three mately 3,000 independent agencies, according to BestLink. specialty providers and built industry and niche solutions for The niche solutions offered by Vienna, Va.-based Campa- a dozen new markets over the past five years. nia include insurance for durable medical equipment for —Chad Hemenway I BANKS and boost their revenue streams. From page 1 “It’s all about control,” Provost said. Financial enti- ties want to save money and have access to reinsurance to merger and acquisition activity, he said. options, he said. “Every time I read about a bank merger, I assume I’m A lot of banks formed mortgage insurance captives in losing a captive,” Provost said. the late 1990s and early 2000s, Pro- In some cases, brand-new captives Captives State by State vost said. Surprisingly, he said, he is are forming or changing states as Snapshot seeing that activity now, as well. After a result of merger-related domicile New in Net Change massive shakeups in the housing mar- reviews. Vermont gained 11 new cap- State Captives* 2009 in 2009 ket and among mortgage insurers, Pro- tives from financial institutions in Vermont 560 39 3 vost said,“They’re underwriting better 2009, including six that were not mortgages now than ever.” Hawaii 162 4 -3 insurance companies. In Nevada, Gray said she is seeing banks form regulators reported a surge in finan- South Carolina 161 13 4 captives to maximize their access to cial-entity captives, including nine of Utah 148 33 26 low-interest loans through the Fed- their last 21 registrations. Nevada 130 11 6 eral Home Loan Banks. The 12 Fed- Banks create captives across a Arizona 99 7 -7 eral Home Loan Banks are a system broad range of lines, including direc- * Active captives as of Dec. 31, 2009. of regional banks from which local tors and officers liability, life, prop- Sources: State insurance departments. lending institutions borrow funds to erty/casualty and group benefits, said finance housing, economic develop- Valerie Barton, executive director of the American Bankers ment and infrastructure projects. Provost said he knows Insurance Association. For banks, establishing captives of a handful of non-bank financial companies that formed makes a lot of sense, she said. They may already operate captives to take advantage of FHLB funding. industry companies and are comfortable with the role of Captives may also provide banks and other institutions captives. with speed-to-market benefits, said William P. White, manag- “It’s a very logical progression to take some of that risk ing principal, Prism Strategies LLC. in-house,” Barton said. “Banks are used to taking risks, to “Where there are problems, there are usually ways to understanding risks.That’s what they do.” bridge that gap of uncertainty,” said White, the former cap- In the current economy, Barton said, financial institu- tive regulator for Delaware and Washington, D.C. “You can tions — like all businesses — are also looking to diversify customize this, provided you’re willing to bear the risk.” JanuaryXX, 2010 • BESTWEEK U.S./CANADA Month 25, 5