APO 96225
             Mailing address of the
             25th Infantry Division
“And the young man once went off to war in a far off country…”
A young man once went off to war in a far country,
and when he had time, he wrote home and said,
“Dear Mom, sure rains a lot here.”

But his mother – reading between the lines as mothers
             always do – wrote back,
“We’re quite concerned. Tell us what it’s really like.”

And the young man responded,
“Wow! You ought to see the funny monkeys.”

To which the mother replied,
“Don’t hold back. How is it there?”

And the young man wrote,
“The sunsets here are spectacular!”
                                                          So the next time he wrote, the young man said,
In her next letter, the mother pleaded,                   “Today I killed a man. Yesterday, I helped drop napalm
“Son, we want you to tell us everything. Everything!”                   on woman and children.”

                                                          And the father wrote right back,
                                                          “Please don’t write back such depressing letters. You’re
                                                                       upsetting your mother.”

                                                          So, after a while,
                                                          the young man wrote,
                                                          “Dear Mom, sure rains here a lot.”
"Poetry should be great & unobtrusive, a
thing which enters into one's soul, and does
not startle it or amaze it with itself but with its
subject.”
                            -Keats
Good poetry
• although poem is not artfully or charmingly
  written, the underlying message is powerful

• does not startle or amaze with the poem itself
  – startles and amazes with its subject
  – startles and amazes with its message
Stanzas 1-6
               Expressing interest for information

• light tone
  – “And the young man responded,
   ‘Wow! You ought to see the funny monkeys’” (6-7).


• light subject matter
  – “Dear Mom, sure rains a lot here” (3).
  – “The sunsets here are spectacular!” (11).
     • only writes
Stanzas 1-6
• Structure
   – begins with a triplet, proceeds with couplets
   – short, exact communication
   – non-revealing of the soldier’s reality
      • the solider is hiding something
      • his communications are short, they are concealing the truth
• Emotion
   – “the mother pleaded” (12)
      • the soldier’s mother is desperate to know what her son is
          going through
   – “Son, we want you to tell us everything. Everything!” (13).
      • the mother expresses her earnest concern, care, and interest
      • ironic, because she does not truly want to know the horrors
          her son is going through
Stanza 7
                        Information given

  So the next time he wrote, the young man said,
  “Today I killed a man. Yesterday, I helped drop napalm
         on women and children.” (13-15).


• the reality of what the “young” (1) soldier is doing and
  experiencing is alarming, saddening, and terrifying
   – this is his truthful response to what is really
     happening
   – gruesome imagery of incendiary napalm bombs used
     against women and children
      • his mother, a woman, cannot handle this truth
Stanza 8
                Reaction to the information given

And the father wrote right back,
“Please don’t write such depressing letters. You’re
       upsetting your mother.” (16-18).

• the soldier’s honest response to his mother’s
  pleaded question is devastating and distressing
  to her
• the father contradicts the mother’s original
  request
• ironic that the mother cannot handle the truth
  she so urgently besought
Stanza 9
                          Resolution
      So, after a while,
      the young man wrote,
      “Dear mom, sure rains a lot here.” (19-21).

• the young man relates what he had originally
  communicated
  – non-upsetting, light information
  – information that his mother can handle
  – not the brutal, disturbing, shocking truth of his
    battle stories
• short, blunt lines
  – reverts back to hiding information, the real truth
Conclusion
• To hide the shocking and disturbing truth from concerned relatives back
  home is more acceptable than to relate the horrors of the atrocities
  committed in war.
    – not necessarily better, but easier
        • easier than upsetting those who cannot handle the truth

• The truth of what goes on and what is experienced on the battlefield is
  difficult for those who have not been in war to handle.

• It is difficult to acknowledge and accept what is going on during the “war
  in a far country” (1).
    – parallels the attitude of the American people at the time during the
      Vietnam War
    – can show concern and interest, but cannot accept the gruesome reality
Irony in APO 96225
• Situational Irony
  – the mother implores her son to tell her everything
    that he is experiencing but cannot even bring
    herself to write back to her son after he tells her
    what he has done, she is so upset by it
  – she did not expect her son to admit to the
    atrocities he had committed
Possible Alternative Meanings
• “rains a lot here” (3) or “rains here a lot” (21)
  – the soldier could possibly be referring to the rain
    of blood or bullets
• “see the funny monkeys” (7)
  – the soldier could be talking about the foreign
    people
• “sunsets here are spectacular” (11)
  – the solider could be relating skies of red and
    orange, or skies of blood, crossfire, and carnage

Apo 96225

  • 1.
    APO 96225 Mailing address of the 25th Infantry Division “And the young man once went off to war in a far off country…”
  • 2.
    A young manonce went off to war in a far country, and when he had time, he wrote home and said, “Dear Mom, sure rains a lot here.” But his mother – reading between the lines as mothers always do – wrote back, “We’re quite concerned. Tell us what it’s really like.” And the young man responded, “Wow! You ought to see the funny monkeys.” To which the mother replied, “Don’t hold back. How is it there?” And the young man wrote, “The sunsets here are spectacular!” So the next time he wrote, the young man said, In her next letter, the mother pleaded, “Today I killed a man. Yesterday, I helped drop napalm “Son, we want you to tell us everything. Everything!” on woman and children.” And the father wrote right back, “Please don’t write back such depressing letters. You’re upsetting your mother.” So, after a while, the young man wrote, “Dear Mom, sure rains here a lot.”
  • 3.
    "Poetry should begreat & unobtrusive, a thing which enters into one's soul, and does not startle it or amaze it with itself but with its subject.” -Keats
  • 4.
    Good poetry • althoughpoem is not artfully or charmingly written, the underlying message is powerful • does not startle or amaze with the poem itself – startles and amazes with its subject – startles and amazes with its message
  • 5.
    Stanzas 1-6 Expressing interest for information • light tone – “And the young man responded, ‘Wow! You ought to see the funny monkeys’” (6-7). • light subject matter – “Dear Mom, sure rains a lot here” (3). – “The sunsets here are spectacular!” (11). • only writes
  • 6.
    Stanzas 1-6 • Structure – begins with a triplet, proceeds with couplets – short, exact communication – non-revealing of the soldier’s reality • the solider is hiding something • his communications are short, they are concealing the truth • Emotion – “the mother pleaded” (12) • the soldier’s mother is desperate to know what her son is going through – “Son, we want you to tell us everything. Everything!” (13). • the mother expresses her earnest concern, care, and interest • ironic, because she does not truly want to know the horrors her son is going through
  • 7.
    Stanza 7 Information given So the next time he wrote, the young man said, “Today I killed a man. Yesterday, I helped drop napalm on women and children.” (13-15). • the reality of what the “young” (1) soldier is doing and experiencing is alarming, saddening, and terrifying – this is his truthful response to what is really happening – gruesome imagery of incendiary napalm bombs used against women and children • his mother, a woman, cannot handle this truth
  • 8.
    Stanza 8 Reaction to the information given And the father wrote right back, “Please don’t write such depressing letters. You’re upsetting your mother.” (16-18). • the soldier’s honest response to his mother’s pleaded question is devastating and distressing to her • the father contradicts the mother’s original request • ironic that the mother cannot handle the truth she so urgently besought
  • 9.
    Stanza 9 Resolution So, after a while, the young man wrote, “Dear mom, sure rains a lot here.” (19-21). • the young man relates what he had originally communicated – non-upsetting, light information – information that his mother can handle – not the brutal, disturbing, shocking truth of his battle stories • short, blunt lines – reverts back to hiding information, the real truth
  • 10.
    Conclusion • To hidethe shocking and disturbing truth from concerned relatives back home is more acceptable than to relate the horrors of the atrocities committed in war. – not necessarily better, but easier • easier than upsetting those who cannot handle the truth • The truth of what goes on and what is experienced on the battlefield is difficult for those who have not been in war to handle. • It is difficult to acknowledge and accept what is going on during the “war in a far country” (1). – parallels the attitude of the American people at the time during the Vietnam War – can show concern and interest, but cannot accept the gruesome reality
  • 11.
    Irony in APO96225 • Situational Irony – the mother implores her son to tell her everything that he is experiencing but cannot even bring herself to write back to her son after he tells her what he has done, she is so upset by it – she did not expect her son to admit to the atrocities he had committed
  • 12.
    Possible Alternative Meanings •“rains a lot here” (3) or “rains here a lot” (21) – the soldier could possibly be referring to the rain of blood or bullets • “see the funny monkeys” (7) – the soldier could be talking about the foreign people • “sunsets here are spectacular” (11) – the solider could be relating skies of red and orange, or skies of blood, crossfire, and carnage