SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 29
De-risking Geothermal Development
Mindoro Geothermal Project
Dr. Antonie de Wilde
Chief Technical Officer
Emerging Power Inc.
Location Map of
Montelago
Geothermal Project
The Odds
• First and only Private Sector
developed green field in
Philippines
• No subsidies (Other than RE
2008 (No import tax, no VAT)
• No Feed-in-Tariff
• No previous drilling by PNOC
• First large-scale medium
enthalpy field (potential 40 MW)
• Field located in Protected Area
Development Partners
2013 -2017
2012
Review of earlier data (including CSMT) and
Medium – Enthalpy none volcanic experience
FEDS2010 -2012
Preliminary reports PNOC-EDC 1989 – 2001
CSMT survey.
Structural Geology, Gravity, Magnetics, Geo-chemical,
Conceptual Model and 3D Conceptual reservoir model
2013 -2016
MT, TEM, 1D and 3D Resistivity
Models, Well targeting, Drilling
supervision (including borehole
lithology, etc.)
POWER SERVICE AGREEMENT
Recovering Exploration Cost
• Get Power Purchase
Agreement to supply
electricity! (with a tariff
based on capital cost and
O&M cost)
• If no geothermal, EPI can
recover the exploration cost
by running a power plant.
• The impact of US$12 -14
million over a 15 year PPA is
reduction of 1.0% IRR.
What if after subsurface
surveys, (US$1.5 – 2.0 m) and
drilling 2 exploration wells
(US$ 12 m), there is no viable
geothermal resource?
Get A PSA= PPA for
20 MW HFO (Diesel)
+
40 MW Geothermal
IMPROVE SURFACE AND SUB-
SURFACE SURVEYS
Surface Surveys
TDEM-MT-Gravity-Magnetics
MT (Magneto Telluric)
COMMERCIAL DRILLING
EXPLORATION INSURANCE
Drilling and Exploration risk
• MARSH and RE
Munich offered
Commercial Risk
Insurance (Dec 2012
– 2013)
• Insurance premium =
10%
• Pay-out, only 80% of
insured premium
• Example: 2 wells,
insured for $12
million -> premium
US$ 1.2 million
• Pay-out= US$ 8.4
million
EXAMPLE CONCEPT OF COMMERCIAL DRILLING INSURANCE
Example:
Cost for 2 Prod. Wells + 1
RIW and Infrastructure
US$ 20 million
Underwritten by Insurance
Premium paid by Investor
Premium 8 – 10%
(example US$2 million)
Successful : delivers 2*5 MW
If unsuccessful repaid 80% of
insured costs
Pays 80% of insured cost if
not successful
80% of US$ 20 Million =
US$16 million
Risk Reduction
Equity Risk: US$20 million Equity Risk: US$6 million
premium $2 million +
20% loss $4 million
DEEP SMALL HOLE DRILLING
Drill 2 deep small holes
(at less than the cost of insurance premium)
PQ Phase (4 meters to 150-170 meters)
HQ Phase (150-170 meters to 500-700 m)
NQ Phase (700 meters to 1,500 meters)
Core drilling US$ 1.2 to 1.5
million for 2 holes of 1250
meter. < than insurance
premium
Risk Reduction using Small Deep Holes
• Cost of insurance premium US$1.2 – 1.5 million
• Cost of drilling small deep hole with coring rig < US$
1,5 million
• Drilling 2 holes makes assessment of reservoir possible
• If the wells flow, can use for production (.75 – 1.2 MW)
-> reduce cost for water pumping during production
well drilling
• From financing perspective using Australian code, the
reservoir moves from “measured reservoir” to
“productive reservoir”
• Lithology for production drilling known: faster
production drilling (reduce production drilling 4 -5 days
First deep small holes in Philippines
many have followed (12)
From: "Rimando, Philip M." <pmrimando@phinma.com.ph>
Date: March 11, 2015 at 12:13:54 PM GMT+8
To: Antonie De Wilde <adewilde@emergingpowerinc.com>
Cc: Meg Ledesma-Honrado <mlhonrado@basicenergy.ph>, "Buena, Sheryl L."
<slbuena@phinma.com.ph>
Subject: Thanks for the Meeting
……………………
You have also treaded on a realm that other geothermal
explorationists in the Philippines have not dared to go before – that is,
drilling slimholes to probe a geothermal resource. That’s a bold step if
I may say so and it goes against conventional wisdom in the Philippine
setting. It is also a pioneering venture that hopefully would open up
the mindset of other players in the local industry………
Philip M. Rimando
Trans-Asia Oil & Energy Dev’t Corp.
“MEASURED RESOURCE”
We are pleased by the success of our exploration drilling work in Naujan,” EPI
Chairman Antonio G. Zamora said in the statement.
“It shows we have the geothermal resources needed to produce close to our
target of 40 MW power,” he added.
Mr. Zamora said QED worked with geothermal consultants Iceland Geosurvey
(ISOR) and the Magister Geothermal Program of the Institute Teknologi
Bandung for the exploratory activity.
Antonie de Wilde, EPI chief technical officer, said based on “flow testing
obtained during the last days, we are very pleased to confirm that our earlier
assessment of a reservoir with the capacity to generate a minimum of 35 to 40
MW, is now confirmed with actual measured data.”
NAC = P446 + P474 =P920 = US$ 22 million
Dragon Capital = US$ 7 million
FMO= US$ 7 million
Gutierez= US$ 14 million
Total Equity = US$50
million
WELL-HEAD TURBINES
Large Turbines vs. Well head Turbines
Large Turbine
• 10 to 15% more efficient
• More risk as reservoir needs
to be drilled fully
• 3 – 5 years drilling and
construction, without cash
flow.
Well-head turbine
• 10 – 15% less efficient
• Can develop on well to well
or well pad to well pad
basis. (modular)
• Produce cash flow within 14
to 16 month.
• Requires significant less
equity than large field (Drill
one well and 1 re-injection)
Large vs. Well Head Turbines
• 15% efficiency loss is 15% of free steam/brine
• Increase in cash flow already covers a large
part of the inefficiency.
• Lesson learnt
• Volumetric Assessment or P90 for only one
well not possible in Philippines (or Indonesia)
– It is done in Netherlands, Govt. guarantee
program based on capacity of duplet. Due to
detailed mapping of Underground, where every
well (gas, oil, water) is mapped.
- Thank You!
Terima Kasih
adewilde@emergingpowerinc.com
Antonie de Wilde

More Related Content

Similar to Antonie de Wilde- De-Risking Geothermal Development

The Severn Estuary - A sustainable low carbon energy resource - Peter Kydd
The Severn Estuary - A sustainable low carbon energy resource - Peter KyddThe Severn Estuary - A sustainable low carbon energy resource - Peter Kydd
The Severn Estuary - A sustainable low carbon energy resource - Peter KyddSustainable Severn
 
Energold Corporate Presentation April 2019
Energold Corporate Presentation April 2019Energold Corporate Presentation April 2019
Energold Corporate Presentation April 2019Adnet Communications
 
Energold Corporate Presentation - September 2015
Energold Corporate Presentation - September 2015Energold Corporate Presentation - September 2015
Energold Corporate Presentation - September 2015Adnet Communications
 
170123_REE_sesión trabajo OWF_R01.pptx
170123_REE_sesión trabajo OWF_R01.pptx170123_REE_sesión trabajo OWF_R01.pptx
170123_REE_sesión trabajo OWF_R01.pptxtonigonzalez29
 
Research, Innovation and Improving Productivity - Douglas Morrison, CEMI – th...
Research, Innovation and Improving Productivity - Douglas Morrison, CEMI – th...Research, Innovation and Improving Productivity - Douglas Morrison, CEMI – th...
Research, Innovation and Improving Productivity - Douglas Morrison, CEMI – th...Mining Network marcus evans
 
Energold Investor Presentation
Energold Investor PresentationEnergold Investor Presentation
Energold Investor PresentationMining On Top
 
Advanced Fossil Energy Technologies: Presentation by the US Dept of Energy Of...
Advanced Fossil Energy Technologies: Presentation by the US Dept of Energy Of...Advanced Fossil Energy Technologies: Presentation by the US Dept of Energy Of...
Advanced Fossil Energy Technologies: Presentation by the US Dept of Energy Of...atlanticcouncil
 
Decarbonising Australia’s Electricity Supply: The role for Small Modular Reac...
Decarbonising Australia’s Electricity Supply: The role for Small Modular Reac...Decarbonising Australia’s Electricity Supply: The role for Small Modular Reac...
Decarbonising Australia’s Electricity Supply: The role for Small Modular Reac...Ben Heard
 
Djibouti geothermal project study
Djibouti geothermal project studyDjibouti geothermal project study
Djibouti geothermal project studyParti Djibouti
 

Similar to Antonie de Wilde- De-Risking Geothermal Development (20)

Egd nov2013
Egd nov2013Egd nov2013
Egd nov2013
 
Egd presentation
Egd presentationEgd presentation
Egd presentation
 
Energold presentation-sept2016
Energold presentation-sept2016Energold presentation-sept2016
Energold presentation-sept2016
 
July2016
July2016July2016
July2016
 
The Severn Estuary - A sustainable low carbon energy resource - Peter Kydd
The Severn Estuary - A sustainable low carbon energy resource - Peter KyddThe Severn Estuary - A sustainable low carbon energy resource - Peter Kydd
The Severn Estuary - A sustainable low carbon energy resource - Peter Kydd
 
Energold Corporate Presentation April 2019
Energold Corporate Presentation April 2019Energold Corporate Presentation April 2019
Energold Corporate Presentation April 2019
 
Energold Presentation - July 2014
Energold Presentation - July 2014Energold Presentation - July 2014
Energold Presentation - July 2014
 
Energold Corporate Presentation - September 2015
Energold Corporate Presentation - September 2015Energold Corporate Presentation - September 2015
Energold Corporate Presentation - September 2015
 
Egd may2015
Egd may2015Egd may2015
Egd may2015
 
170123_REE_sesión trabajo OWF_R01.pptx
170123_REE_sesión trabajo OWF_R01.pptx170123_REE_sesión trabajo OWF_R01.pptx
170123_REE_sesión trabajo OWF_R01.pptx
 
Research, Innovation and Improving Productivity - Douglas Morrison, CEMI – th...
Research, Innovation and Improving Productivity - Douglas Morrison, CEMI – th...Research, Innovation and Improving Productivity - Douglas Morrison, CEMI – th...
Research, Innovation and Improving Productivity - Douglas Morrison, CEMI – th...
 
Energold Presentation - May 2016
Energold Presentation - May 2016Energold Presentation - May 2016
Energold Presentation - May 2016
 
Egd dec2015
Egd dec2015Egd dec2015
Egd dec2015
 
Energold Investor Presentation
Energold Investor PresentationEnergold Investor Presentation
Energold Investor Presentation
 
EGD April 2017
EGD April 2017EGD April 2017
EGD April 2017
 
2017 10-18-cp egd
2017 10-18-cp egd2017 10-18-cp egd
2017 10-18-cp egd
 
Advanced Fossil Energy Technologies: Presentation by the US Dept of Energy Of...
Advanced Fossil Energy Technologies: Presentation by the US Dept of Energy Of...Advanced Fossil Energy Technologies: Presentation by the US Dept of Energy Of...
Advanced Fossil Energy Technologies: Presentation by the US Dept of Energy Of...
 
Decarbonising Australia’s Electricity Supply: The role for Small Modular Reac...
Decarbonising Australia’s Electricity Supply: The role for Small Modular Reac...Decarbonising Australia’s Electricity Supply: The role for Small Modular Reac...
Decarbonising Australia’s Electricity Supply: The role for Small Modular Reac...
 
Djibouti geothermal project study
Djibouti geothermal project studyDjibouti geothermal project study
Djibouti geothermal project study
 
Presentation
PresentationPresentation
Presentation
 

Antonie de Wilde- De-Risking Geothermal Development

  • 1. De-risking Geothermal Development Mindoro Geothermal Project Dr. Antonie de Wilde Chief Technical Officer Emerging Power Inc.
  • 3. The Odds • First and only Private Sector developed green field in Philippines • No subsidies (Other than RE 2008 (No import tax, no VAT) • No Feed-in-Tariff • No previous drilling by PNOC • First large-scale medium enthalpy field (potential 40 MW) • Field located in Protected Area
  • 4. Development Partners 2013 -2017 2012 Review of earlier data (including CSMT) and Medium – Enthalpy none volcanic experience FEDS2010 -2012 Preliminary reports PNOC-EDC 1989 – 2001 CSMT survey. Structural Geology, Gravity, Magnetics, Geo-chemical, Conceptual Model and 3D Conceptual reservoir model 2013 -2016 MT, TEM, 1D and 3D Resistivity Models, Well targeting, Drilling supervision (including borehole lithology, etc.)
  • 6. Recovering Exploration Cost • Get Power Purchase Agreement to supply electricity! (with a tariff based on capital cost and O&M cost) • If no geothermal, EPI can recover the exploration cost by running a power plant. • The impact of US$12 -14 million over a 15 year PPA is reduction of 1.0% IRR. What if after subsurface surveys, (US$1.5 – 2.0 m) and drilling 2 exploration wells (US$ 12 m), there is no viable geothermal resource? Get A PSA= PPA for 20 MW HFO (Diesel) + 40 MW Geothermal
  • 7. IMPROVE SURFACE AND SUB- SURFACE SURVEYS
  • 10. Drilling and Exploration risk • MARSH and RE Munich offered Commercial Risk Insurance (Dec 2012 – 2013) • Insurance premium = 10% • Pay-out, only 80% of insured premium • Example: 2 wells, insured for $12 million -> premium US$ 1.2 million • Pay-out= US$ 8.4 million
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16. EXAMPLE CONCEPT OF COMMERCIAL DRILLING INSURANCE Example: Cost for 2 Prod. Wells + 1 RIW and Infrastructure US$ 20 million Underwritten by Insurance Premium paid by Investor Premium 8 – 10% (example US$2 million) Successful : delivers 2*5 MW If unsuccessful repaid 80% of insured costs Pays 80% of insured cost if not successful 80% of US$ 20 Million = US$16 million Risk Reduction Equity Risk: US$20 million Equity Risk: US$6 million premium $2 million + 20% loss $4 million
  • 17. DEEP SMALL HOLE DRILLING
  • 18. Drill 2 deep small holes (at less than the cost of insurance premium)
  • 19. PQ Phase (4 meters to 150-170 meters) HQ Phase (150-170 meters to 500-700 m) NQ Phase (700 meters to 1,500 meters) Core drilling US$ 1.2 to 1.5 million for 2 holes of 1250 meter. < than insurance premium
  • 20. Risk Reduction using Small Deep Holes • Cost of insurance premium US$1.2 – 1.5 million • Cost of drilling small deep hole with coring rig < US$ 1,5 million • Drilling 2 holes makes assessment of reservoir possible • If the wells flow, can use for production (.75 – 1.2 MW) -> reduce cost for water pumping during production well drilling • From financing perspective using Australian code, the reservoir moves from “measured reservoir” to “productive reservoir” • Lithology for production drilling known: faster production drilling (reduce production drilling 4 -5 days
  • 21. First deep small holes in Philippines many have followed (12) From: "Rimando, Philip M." <pmrimando@phinma.com.ph> Date: March 11, 2015 at 12:13:54 PM GMT+8 To: Antonie De Wilde <adewilde@emergingpowerinc.com> Cc: Meg Ledesma-Honrado <mlhonrado@basicenergy.ph>, "Buena, Sheryl L." <slbuena@phinma.com.ph> Subject: Thanks for the Meeting …………………… You have also treaded on a realm that other geothermal explorationists in the Philippines have not dared to go before – that is, drilling slimholes to probe a geothermal resource. That’s a bold step if I may say so and it goes against conventional wisdom in the Philippine setting. It is also a pioneering venture that hopefully would open up the mindset of other players in the local industry……… Philip M. Rimando Trans-Asia Oil & Energy Dev’t Corp.
  • 23.
  • 24. We are pleased by the success of our exploration drilling work in Naujan,” EPI Chairman Antonio G. Zamora said in the statement. “It shows we have the geothermal resources needed to produce close to our target of 40 MW power,” he added. Mr. Zamora said QED worked with geothermal consultants Iceland Geosurvey (ISOR) and the Magister Geothermal Program of the Institute Teknologi Bandung for the exploratory activity. Antonie de Wilde, EPI chief technical officer, said based on “flow testing obtained during the last days, we are very pleased to confirm that our earlier assessment of a reservoir with the capacity to generate a minimum of 35 to 40 MW, is now confirmed with actual measured data.”
  • 25. NAC = P446 + P474 =P920 = US$ 22 million Dragon Capital = US$ 7 million FMO= US$ 7 million Gutierez= US$ 14 million Total Equity = US$50 million
  • 27. Large Turbines vs. Well head Turbines Large Turbine • 10 to 15% more efficient • More risk as reservoir needs to be drilled fully • 3 – 5 years drilling and construction, without cash flow. Well-head turbine • 10 – 15% less efficient • Can develop on well to well or well pad to well pad basis. (modular) • Produce cash flow within 14 to 16 month. • Requires significant less equity than large field (Drill one well and 1 re-injection)
  • 28. Large vs. Well Head Turbines • 15% efficiency loss is 15% of free steam/brine • Increase in cash flow already covers a large part of the inefficiency. • Lesson learnt • Volumetric Assessment or P90 for only one well not possible in Philippines (or Indonesia) – It is done in Netherlands, Govt. guarantee program based on capacity of duplet. Due to detailed mapping of Underground, where every well (gas, oil, water) is mapped.
  • 29. - Thank You! Terima Kasih adewilde@emergingpowerinc.com Antonie de Wilde

Editor's Notes

  1. Although PNOC-IDC had done some preliminary investigations, there was no reliable data set that could be used for well targeting. Also in Philippines and Indonesia there is no experience with actual developing a 20 to 40 MW low enthalpy resource. Thus EPI turned to firms in Europe, with experience with low enthalpy. IF technology in the Netherlands, which had advised over 8 projects in the Netherlands, drilling more than 3,500 meter for a brine temperature of 90° C was contracted to review all the existing data and present a development plan. This was done in collaboration with the Magister Program in Geothermal Technology of the Institute Teknologi Bandung, Indonesia’s