SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 41
Capital,
                                           Condos,
                                               and
                                    Mr. Greenspan's
                                        Conundrum


Notes on
the Current
and Future
Real Estate
Capital and
Transaction
Environment

Peter C. Burley, CRE
Vice President Market Research
Simpson Housing LLLP
for the
Colorado Chapter of the Appraisal
Institute
Real Estate has Been Great the Past Few Years

           Year-Year Returns Are Good

      Transaction Volume is at Record Highs

               Capital is Abundant

All DESPITE THREE YEARS of WEAK FUNDAMENTALS
Commercial Property Transactions At A Record
                                                                               $62 bil. in Q2
70                                                                             Up 50% YTD
                  Volume Closed Transactions ($ billions)                      from 2004
60


50


40


30


20


10


 0

         3   :1                                      4   :1           5   :1
      00                                     '2   00          '2   00
 '2
     Source: Real Capital Analytics
Commercial Transactions Jump Across the Board
45000
               Transaction Volume ($ bil.)

40000

35000           +64%                            +48%
30000

25000                                                       +10%
20000
                                     +88%
15000

10000

 5000

    0
           Apartments              Industrial      Office   Retail
        Source: Real Capital Analytics
Record New and Existing Home Sales
                                                                 New Record in Q2
                                                                 Including an 8.54 mil
                                                                 Unit Rate in June Alone
8000        Units (Qtr, SAAR)

7000

6000

5000

4000

3000
               New Homes
2000           Existing Homes

1000

   0
       Q3               Q2             Q1               Q4       Q2
     02              03              04               04       05
   20              20              20               20       20

       Source: NAR; Bureau of Census; Economy.com
Who is Buying




                Commercial
                Pension Funds
                REITs
                Foreign Investors
                Private Companies




                                    Residential
                                    Homeowners
                                    Private Investors
What's Driving the Activity ?
Uncertainty.

Low Yields Elsewhere.

Easy Access to Capital.
Stocks Have Been Rangebound

            S&P 500 (Index 1941-43=10)
  1260

  1240

  1220

  1200

  1180

  1160

  1140

  1120

  1100

  1080

  1060
        3       -04       -04      -04          04         04       -05       -05      -05
    ec-0      ar        ay       ug         ct-        ec-        ar        ay       ug
 0-D       2-M       4-M      5-A        -O          -D         -M        -M      2-A
3         1         2                  15          28         10        20

          Source: Standard & Poors; Economy.com
Commercial Real Estate Outperforms Other Markets

        DJIA




      S&P500




     NASDAQ




MS REIT Index




NCREIF Index*


                -4   -2      0       2      4      6       8       10        12       14       16
                                     % Return Through Mid-June 2005

          Source: Urban Land Institute
                                                       * Trailing 12-month through 3/31/2005
NOI Has Contributed Nothing to Commercial Property Returns
  12
        3 Year Average, %
                10.2
  10


   8

           3 Yr Return        5.8
   6
                                                          4.5
   4

                            Yield                     Cap Rates
   2
                                          NOI
   0
                                            -0.2

  -2

        Source: Torto Wheaton Research, Investment Database
Originators Have Ample Capital Available,
                     and Rates Are Extremely Competitive
     800
                               CMBS Trading Spreads above 10Yr Treasuries (bp)
     700

     600

     500

     400

     300

     200

     100

          0
                                              4        11       13            31              31              -70
                               -22                                                                  -35
 -100
                          ry                                                              -
                                     AA
                                          A       AA        A
                                                                     BB
                                                                          B           B            BB     B
              re   as u                                                            BB
            T
     -   Yr
10                   Source: Morgan Stanley; ULI
CMBS Issuance Continues to Rise
140000
           Issuance ($ mil.)

120000


100000


 80000


 60000


 40000


 20000


     0
         2000        2001        2002         2003   2004   2005 (ytd)

         Source: Commercial Mortgage Alert; ULI
REIT Growth Has Been Impressive

350
             REIT Industry Market Cap ($ bil.)          320.8
                                                 305
300


250


200


150    139

100


 50


  0
      2000                                       2004   2005(ytd)

      Source: NAREIT
- Are long-term yield levels
           still a "conundrum"?

- Can the current nationwide housing market
           be categorized as a bubble?
Is This a Conundrum?
Spreads Have Narrowed; The Yield Curve Has Flattened

     5   %

   4.5

     4

   3.5
             2001

     3       2005
   2.5

     2          2002
   1.5            2004
                2003
     1
  90-Day Bill            1 Yr   2 Yr   5 Yr   10 Yr

         Source: Economy.com
Long Term Yields Aren't Moving Much Higher

 18
      %

 16

 14

 12

 10
                                     10-year Treasury
  8

  6

  4

  2
                                          Fed Funds
  0
 1976Q1   1981Q1   1986Q1   1991Q1     1996Q1   2001Q1

      Source: Economy.com
Mortgage Rates are About as Low as They Have Ever Been

    16   (%)

    14

    12

    10                    Average 30-Yr Conventional

     8

     6
             Avg 1-Yr Adj
     4

     2
    1984M1     1988M3     1992M5   1996M7   2000M9   2004M11

         Source: Economy.com
A Brief Look at Apartments and Condos
Apartment Share of Commercial Transactions
Has Grown from 22% in 2002 to About 30% in 2005

  From 2000-2005 over $130 billion in Apartment
      Transactions - About 6,100 properties

 Hottest Markets Have Been California, Florida,
Nevada, DC Metro - Represent 45% of Apartment
      Transactions, Up from 30% in 2002
Following the Money to Apartments

      Cap Rate (%) Q1:2005
10

9.5
                              CBD Office          Sub'n Office
 9

8.5
                                       Malls
 8
                                                               R&D
7.5
                                               Multifamily
 7

6.5
 1998:4    1999:4   2000:4   2001:4   2002:4     2003:4      2004:4   2005:1

      Source: RERC; ULI
Bigger is Better
Larger Properties in Larger Markets Trade at Lower Yields
  8
                            Average Cap Rate (%)
  7

  6

  5
       Third Tier Markets

                               Secondary Markets

                                                   Primary Markets


  4

  3

  2

  1

  0
                            $30 mil +                                $15-30 mil   $5 - 15 mil
      Source: Real Capital Analytics
Condo Conversions
  Have Exceeded New Apartment Deliveries For Two Quarters
35000
               Units

30000
                                                New Completions     Conversions


25000


20000


15000


10000


 5000


    0
        3:01       3:02    3:03   3:04   4:01      4:02    4:03   4:04   5:01     5:02
        Source: Reis Inc
Sales to Condo Converters As a Share of All Apartment Sales

           Share of All Apartment Sales (%)
     35


     30


     25


     20


     15


     10


      5
     2003:1    :2     :3     :4   2004:1   :2   :3   :4   2005:1   :2

          Source: Real Capital Analytics
Leading Condo Conversion Markets

    Miami

Las Vegas

San Diego

  Orlando

                                                          2004
   Tampa                                                  2005 (ytd)

DC Metro

  Phoenix

 Chicago

       LA

            0           2000        4000           6000    8000        10000   12000
                                           Units

                Source: Real Capital Analytics
Condo Conversions are Picking Up in Denver Too

2500      Units



2000




1500




1000




 500




   0
       2003       2        3   4   2004   2   3   4   2005   2

        Source: Reis Inc
Housing Market Activity in Denver
The Denver Market Looks Like Elsewhere
45
                 Existing Single Family Home Sales (Ths., SAAR)
40

35

30

25

20

15

10

 5

 0
           2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2
     Q4 Q
   94 1995 1995 1996 1996 1997 1997 1998 1998 1999 1999 2000 2000 2001 2001 2002 2002 2003 2003 2004 2004 2005
19

          Source: Economy.com
Prices Are Rising Faster in Denver

        Median Existing Home Price (Ths., SAAR)
260

240

220

200                     Denver
180
                                           US
160

140

120

100
 1995Q1 1996Q2 1997Q3 1998Q4 2000Q1 2001Q2 2002Q3 2003Q4 2005Q1


      Source: Economy.com
Affordability is A Bit Less in Denver

          Affordability (Index)
 170


 160


 150
                                                 US
 140


 130
                                  Denver
 120


 110

   5Q
      1        Q2     Q3     Q4     Q1     Q2     Q3     Q4     Q1
  9          96     97     98     00     01     02     03     05
19         19     19     19     20     20     20     20     20

            Source: NAR; BOC; BEA; Economy.com
Concerns About Current Trends
Outlook for A Strong Economy
         and Low Mortgage Rates
Suggests A Solid Owner Market for Housing
             in the Near Term

                However,

       Buyer and Investor Leverage
        Pose Some Downside Risk
The Share of Adjustable Rate Mortgages is Increasing

         Percent of All Mortgage Borrowers with Adjustable Rates
    60
    55
    50
    45
    40
    35
    30
    25
    20
    15
    10
     5
    1995M1    1996M9    1998M5   2000M1    2001M9   2003M5   2005M1

         Source: FHFB; Economy.com
Homeowners Are Highly Leveraged

       Household Financial Obligations Ratio (% if Dis Income)
16.5

 16

15.5

 15

14.5

 14

13.5

 13
 1980Q1         1985Q1       1990Q1        1995Q1        2000Q1   2005Q1

       Source: Economy.com
Investor Purchases Are Increasing

10
                          % Mortgage Originations


 8




 6
                             Second Homes
     Investor Purchases




 4




 2




 0
              2001                                  2004    2005 (Thru April)

     Source: LoanPerformance; Economy.com
Look for Mr Greenspan to Stay the Course

                (%)
 6.5

       6

 5.5
                                                                        10-year Treasury
       5

 4.5
                                                                                 Fed Funds Rate
       4

 3.5

       3

 2.5
            2           Q   4           Q   2           Q   4           Q   2           Q   4           Q   2           Q   4           Q   2           Q   4
        Q
     05              05              06              06              07              07              08              08              09              09
20              20              20              20              20              20              20              20              20              20

                Source: FRB; Economy.com
Mortgage Rates Will Rise Toward Long Term Averages

        Conventional Mortgage Rates (%)
  7.5

    7
                         30yr Fixed
  6.5

    6

  5.5
                                    ARM
    5

  4.5

    4
   2005M6   2006M4     2007M2     2007M12   2008M10   2009M8

        Source: Freddie Mac; Economy.com
Prices Will Continue to Rise Faster in Denver

       Median Existing Home Price ($Ths)
 300


 280


 260


 240


 220


 200


 180

   5Q
     1     Q3     Q1     Q3     Q1     Q3     Q1     Q3     Q1     Q3
  0      05     06     06     07     07     08     08     09     09
20     20     20     20     20     20     20     20     20     20

        Source: NAR; Economy.com
Affordability will Decline

                Affordability (Index)
 130

 125

 120

 115

 110

 105

 100

     95

     90
        Q   1
                       5   Q3          6   Q1          6   Q3          7   Q1          7   Q3          8   Q1          8   Q3          9   Q1          9   Q3
     05             00              00              00              00              00              00              00              00              00
20              2               2               2               2               2               2               2               2               2
                     Source: Economy.com
Sales Will Ease (hopefully) Down
40
               Existing Sales, Units (Ths., SAAR) - Denver MSA
35


30


25


20


15


10


 5


 0
     2     3    4    1    2    3    4    1   2    3     4    1    2    3    4    1    2    3   4
  05Q 005Q 005Q 006Q 006Q 006Q 006Q 007Q 007Q 007Q 007Q 008Q 008Q 008Q 008Q 009Q 009Q 009Q 009Q
20 2      2    2    2    2    2    2    2   2    2     2    2    2    2    2    2    2    2
        Source: NAR; Economy.com
We’ll See

More Related Content

What's hot

Chap016 capital structure
Chap016 capital structure Chap016 capital structure
Chap016 capital structure Fatfat Shiying
 
southwest airline ar99
southwest airline ar99southwest airline ar99
southwest airline ar99finance40
 
Future Capital Holdings Ltd. Corporate Presentation 2010
Future Capital Holdings Ltd. Corporate Presentation 2010Future Capital Holdings Ltd. Corporate Presentation 2010
Future Capital Holdings Ltd. Corporate Presentation 2010AICL Communications
 
2013 M&A Silicon Valley Gathering (MASiV)
2013 M&A Silicon Valley Gathering (MASiV)2013 M&A Silicon Valley Gathering (MASiV)
2013 M&A Silicon Valley Gathering (MASiV)Tricia Salinero
 
oe E. Harlan Executive Vice President, Electro and Communications Business
oe E. Harlan Executive Vice President, Electro and Communications Businessoe E. Harlan Executive Vice President, Electro and Communications Business
oe E. Harlan Executive Vice President, Electro and Communications Businessfinance10
 
Perú ProinversióN
Perú ProinversióNPerú ProinversióN
Perú ProinversióNLuis
 
kohl's annual reports 2006
kohl's annual reports 2006kohl's annual reports 2006
kohl's annual reports 2006finance16
 
Merrill Lynch Banking & Financial Services Conference
Merrill Lynch Banking & Financial Services ConferenceMerrill Lynch Banking & Financial Services Conference
Merrill Lynch Banking & Financial Services Conferencefinance2
 
Patrick D. Campbell Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
 	Patrick D. Campbell Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer 	Patrick D. Campbell Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
Patrick D. Campbell Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officerfinance10
 
terex Merrill050808
terex Merrill050808terex Merrill050808
terex Merrill050808finance42
 
monsanto q1 2007 financial results
monsanto q1 2007 financial resultsmonsanto q1 2007 financial results
monsanto q1 2007 financial resultsearningsreport
 
Indianeconomyglobalisation 090728133702-phpapp01
Indianeconomyglobalisation 090728133702-phpapp01Indianeconomyglobalisation 090728133702-phpapp01
Indianeconomyglobalisation 090728133702-phpapp01Dipesh Rafaliya
 
terex BofA050808
terex BofA050808terex BofA050808
terex BofA050808finance42
 

What's hot (15)

Chap016 capital structure
Chap016 capital structure Chap016 capital structure
Chap016 capital structure
 
southwest airline ar99
southwest airline ar99southwest airline ar99
southwest airline ar99
 
Hl td
Hl tdHl td
Hl td
 
Future Capital Holdings Ltd. Corporate Presentation 2010
Future Capital Holdings Ltd. Corporate Presentation 2010Future Capital Holdings Ltd. Corporate Presentation 2010
Future Capital Holdings Ltd. Corporate Presentation 2010
 
2013 M&A Silicon Valley Gathering (MASiV)
2013 M&A Silicon Valley Gathering (MASiV)2013 M&A Silicon Valley Gathering (MASiV)
2013 M&A Silicon Valley Gathering (MASiV)
 
oe E. Harlan Executive Vice President, Electro and Communications Business
oe E. Harlan Executive Vice President, Electro and Communications Businessoe E. Harlan Executive Vice President, Electro and Communications Business
oe E. Harlan Executive Vice President, Electro and Communications Business
 
Perú ProinversióN
Perú ProinversióNPerú ProinversióN
Perú ProinversióN
 
kohl's annual reports 2006
kohl's annual reports 2006kohl's annual reports 2006
kohl's annual reports 2006
 
Merrill Lynch Banking & Financial Services Conference
Merrill Lynch Banking & Financial Services ConferenceMerrill Lynch Banking & Financial Services Conference
Merrill Lynch Banking & Financial Services Conference
 
Patrick D. Campbell Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
 	Patrick D. Campbell Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer 	Patrick D. Campbell Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
Patrick D. Campbell Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
 
terex Merrill050808
terex Merrill050808terex Merrill050808
terex Merrill050808
 
monsanto q1 2007 financial results
monsanto q1 2007 financial resultsmonsanto q1 2007 financial results
monsanto q1 2007 financial results
 
Indianeconomyglobalisation 090728133702-phpapp01
Indianeconomyglobalisation 090728133702-phpapp01Indianeconomyglobalisation 090728133702-phpapp01
Indianeconomyglobalisation 090728133702-phpapp01
 
CMI051007
CMI051007CMI051007
CMI051007
 
terex BofA050808
terex BofA050808terex BofA050808
terex BofA050808
 

Similar to Ai August 5 2005

5th Annual Appraisal Summit
5th Annual Appraisal Summit5th Annual Appraisal Summit
5th Annual Appraisal SummitNVAR .com
 
The State of Distress in Chicago Area Real Estate
The State of Distress in Chicago Area Real EstateThe State of Distress in Chicago Area Real Estate
The State of Distress in Chicago Area Real EstateRyan Slack
 
State of chicago area distres -matthew anderson
State of chicago area distres -matthew andersonState of chicago area distres -matthew anderson
State of chicago area distres -matthew andersonguest381588
 
Economic and Real Estate Market Update from National Association of REALTORS
Economic and Real Estate Market Update from National Association of REALTORSEconomic and Real Estate Market Update from National Association of REALTORS
Economic and Real Estate Market Update from National Association of REALTORSBrian Block
 
Real Estate and Economic Outlook, Presentation at CRE Finance Council Annual ...
Real Estate and Economic Outlook, Presentation at CRE Finance Council Annual ...Real Estate and Economic Outlook, Presentation at CRE Finance Council Annual ...
Real Estate and Economic Outlook, Presentation at CRE Finance Council Annual ...Nar Res
 
BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2011
BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2011BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2011
BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2011BoyarMiller
 
Commercial Real Estate and Economic Outlook
Commercial Real Estate and Economic OutlookCommercial Real Estate and Economic Outlook
Commercial Real Estate and Economic OutlookNar Res
 
Domenic mandato apartments_an_investors_dream_20110618
Domenic mandato apartments_an_investors_dream_20110618Domenic mandato apartments_an_investors_dream_20110618
Domenic mandato apartments_an_investors_dream_20110618Michael Lai
 
Colliers International: Retail Highlights Fall 2010
Colliers International: Retail Highlights Fall 2010Colliers International: Retail Highlights Fall 2010
Colliers International: Retail Highlights Fall 2010Coy Davidson
 
Economic update ltm (june 2012)
Economic update ltm (june 2012)Economic update ltm (june 2012)
Economic update ltm (june 2012)PhippsRealty
 
WSMM_Media_January.pdf
WSMM_Media_January.pdfWSMM_Media_January.pdf
WSMM_Media_January.pdfSamShiah1
 
March 2011 Office Notes
March 2011 Office NotesMarch 2011 Office Notes
March 2011 Office Noteselsantos
 
Pdf version for flash drive torto_utah -august 14v1
Pdf version for flash drive  torto_utah -august 14v1Pdf version for flash drive  torto_utah -august 14v1
Pdf version for flash drive torto_utah -august 14v1raymondtorto
 
Why you should Invest in Chile?
Why you should Invest in Chile?Why you should Invest in Chile?
Why you should Invest in Chile?Sebastian Landgren
 
2015 02-05--corelogic-rpdata-housing-economic-chartpack
2015 02-05--corelogic-rpdata-housing-economic-chartpack2015 02-05--corelogic-rpdata-housing-economic-chartpack
2015 02-05--corelogic-rpdata-housing-economic-chartpackLJ Gilland Real Estate Pty Ltd
 

Similar to Ai August 5 2005 (20)

5th Annual Appraisal Summit
5th Annual Appraisal Summit5th Annual Appraisal Summit
5th Annual Appraisal Summit
 
The State of Distress in Chicago Area Real Estate
The State of Distress in Chicago Area Real EstateThe State of Distress in Chicago Area Real Estate
The State of Distress in Chicago Area Real Estate
 
State of chicago area distres -matthew anderson
State of chicago area distres -matthew andersonState of chicago area distres -matthew anderson
State of chicago area distres -matthew anderson
 
Economic and Real Estate Market Update from National Association of REALTORS
Economic and Real Estate Market Update from National Association of REALTORSEconomic and Real Estate Market Update from National Association of REALTORS
Economic and Real Estate Market Update from National Association of REALTORS
 
Market Outlook with Lawrence Yun
Market Outlook with Lawrence YunMarket Outlook with Lawrence Yun
Market Outlook with Lawrence Yun
 
Real Estate and Economic Outlook, Presentation at CRE Finance Council Annual ...
Real Estate and Economic Outlook, Presentation at CRE Finance Council Annual ...Real Estate and Economic Outlook, Presentation at CRE Finance Council Annual ...
Real Estate and Economic Outlook, Presentation at CRE Finance Council Annual ...
 
BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2011
BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2011BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2011
BoyarMiller Breakfast Forum: The Current State of the Capital Markets 2011
 
Commercial Real Estate and Economic Outlook
Commercial Real Estate and Economic OutlookCommercial Real Estate and Economic Outlook
Commercial Real Estate and Economic Outlook
 
Domenic mandato apartments_an_investors_dream_20110618
Domenic mandato apartments_an_investors_dream_20110618Domenic mandato apartments_an_investors_dream_20110618
Domenic mandato apartments_an_investors_dream_20110618
 
Q2 2021 Austin Office Report
Q2 2021 Austin Office ReportQ2 2021 Austin Office Report
Q2 2021 Austin Office Report
 
Colliers International: Retail Highlights Fall 2010
Colliers International: Retail Highlights Fall 2010Colliers International: Retail Highlights Fall 2010
Colliers International: Retail Highlights Fall 2010
 
Economic update ltm (june 2012)
Economic update ltm (june 2012)Economic update ltm (june 2012)
Economic update ltm (june 2012)
 
WSMM_Media_January.pdf
WSMM_Media_January.pdfWSMM_Media_January.pdf
WSMM_Media_January.pdf
 
Dr. Lawrence Yun Economic Forecast Presentation
Dr. Lawrence Yun Economic Forecast PresentationDr. Lawrence Yun Economic Forecast Presentation
Dr. Lawrence Yun Economic Forecast Presentation
 
March 2011 Office Notes
March 2011 Office NotesMarch 2011 Office Notes
March 2011 Office Notes
 
Pdf version for flash drive torto_utah -august 14v1
Pdf version for flash drive  torto_utah -august 14v1Pdf version for flash drive  torto_utah -august 14v1
Pdf version for flash drive torto_utah -august 14v1
 
Why you should Invest in Chile?
Why you should Invest in Chile?Why you should Invest in Chile?
Why you should Invest in Chile?
 
2015 02-05--corelogic-rpdata-housing-economic-chartpack
2015 02-05--corelogic-rpdata-housing-economic-chartpack2015 02-05--corelogic-rpdata-housing-economic-chartpack
2015 02-05--corelogic-rpdata-housing-economic-chartpack
 
Anchor capital senate group 6th november 2015 - final
Anchor capital   senate group 6th november 2015 - finalAnchor capital   senate group 6th november 2015 - final
Anchor capital senate group 6th november 2015 - final
 
Marriot Income Specialists
Marriot Income SpecialistsMarriot Income Specialists
Marriot Income Specialists
 

Ai August 5 2005

  • 1. Capital, Condos, and Mr. Greenspan's Conundrum Notes on the Current and Future Real Estate Capital and Transaction Environment Peter C. Burley, CRE Vice President Market Research Simpson Housing LLLP for the Colorado Chapter of the Appraisal Institute
  • 2. Real Estate has Been Great the Past Few Years Year-Year Returns Are Good Transaction Volume is at Record Highs Capital is Abundant All DESPITE THREE YEARS of WEAK FUNDAMENTALS
  • 3. Commercial Property Transactions At A Record $62 bil. in Q2 70 Up 50% YTD Volume Closed Transactions ($ billions) from 2004 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 3 :1 4 :1 5 :1 00 '2 00 '2 00 '2 Source: Real Capital Analytics
  • 4. Commercial Transactions Jump Across the Board 45000 Transaction Volume ($ bil.) 40000 35000 +64% +48% 30000 25000 +10% 20000 +88% 15000 10000 5000 0 Apartments Industrial Office Retail Source: Real Capital Analytics
  • 5. Record New and Existing Home Sales New Record in Q2 Including an 8.54 mil Unit Rate in June Alone 8000 Units (Qtr, SAAR) 7000 6000 5000 4000 3000 New Homes 2000 Existing Homes 1000 0 Q3 Q2 Q1 Q4 Q2 02 03 04 04 05 20 20 20 20 20 Source: NAR; Bureau of Census; Economy.com
  • 6. Who is Buying Commercial Pension Funds REITs Foreign Investors Private Companies Residential Homeowners Private Investors
  • 7. What's Driving the Activity ?
  • 9. Stocks Have Been Rangebound S&P 500 (Index 1941-43=10) 1260 1240 1220 1200 1180 1160 1140 1120 1100 1080 1060 3 -04 -04 -04 04 04 -05 -05 -05 ec-0 ar ay ug ct- ec- ar ay ug 0-D 2-M 4-M 5-A -O -D -M -M 2-A 3 1 2 15 28 10 20 Source: Standard & Poors; Economy.com
  • 10. Commercial Real Estate Outperforms Other Markets DJIA S&P500 NASDAQ MS REIT Index NCREIF Index* -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 % Return Through Mid-June 2005 Source: Urban Land Institute * Trailing 12-month through 3/31/2005
  • 11. NOI Has Contributed Nothing to Commercial Property Returns 12 3 Year Average, % 10.2 10 8 3 Yr Return 5.8 6 4.5 4 Yield Cap Rates 2 NOI 0 -0.2 -2 Source: Torto Wheaton Research, Investment Database
  • 12. Originators Have Ample Capital Available, and Rates Are Extremely Competitive 800 CMBS Trading Spreads above 10Yr Treasuries (bp) 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 4 11 13 31 31 -70 -22 -35 -100 ry - AA A AA A BB B B BB B re as u BB T - Yr 10 Source: Morgan Stanley; ULI
  • 13. CMBS Issuance Continues to Rise 140000 Issuance ($ mil.) 120000 100000 80000 60000 40000 20000 0 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 (ytd) Source: Commercial Mortgage Alert; ULI
  • 14. REIT Growth Has Been Impressive 350 REIT Industry Market Cap ($ bil.) 320.8 305 300 250 200 150 139 100 50 0 2000 2004 2005(ytd) Source: NAREIT
  • 15. - Are long-term yield levels still a "conundrum"? - Can the current nationwide housing market be categorized as a bubble?
  • 16. Is This a Conundrum? Spreads Have Narrowed; The Yield Curve Has Flattened 5 % 4.5 4 3.5 2001 3 2005 2.5 2 2002 1.5 2004 2003 1 90-Day Bill 1 Yr 2 Yr 5 Yr 10 Yr Source: Economy.com
  • 17. Long Term Yields Aren't Moving Much Higher 18 % 16 14 12 10 10-year Treasury 8 6 4 2 Fed Funds 0 1976Q1 1981Q1 1986Q1 1991Q1 1996Q1 2001Q1 Source: Economy.com
  • 18. Mortgage Rates are About as Low as They Have Ever Been 16 (%) 14 12 10 Average 30-Yr Conventional 8 6 Avg 1-Yr Adj 4 2 1984M1 1988M3 1992M5 1996M7 2000M9 2004M11 Source: Economy.com
  • 19. A Brief Look at Apartments and Condos
  • 20. Apartment Share of Commercial Transactions Has Grown from 22% in 2002 to About 30% in 2005 From 2000-2005 over $130 billion in Apartment Transactions - About 6,100 properties Hottest Markets Have Been California, Florida, Nevada, DC Metro - Represent 45% of Apartment Transactions, Up from 30% in 2002
  • 21. Following the Money to Apartments Cap Rate (%) Q1:2005 10 9.5 CBD Office Sub'n Office 9 8.5 Malls 8 R&D 7.5 Multifamily 7 6.5 1998:4 1999:4 2000:4 2001:4 2002:4 2003:4 2004:4 2005:1 Source: RERC; ULI
  • 22. Bigger is Better Larger Properties in Larger Markets Trade at Lower Yields 8 Average Cap Rate (%) 7 6 5 Third Tier Markets Secondary Markets Primary Markets 4 3 2 1 0 $30 mil + $15-30 mil $5 - 15 mil Source: Real Capital Analytics
  • 23. Condo Conversions Have Exceeded New Apartment Deliveries For Two Quarters 35000 Units 30000 New Completions Conversions 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0 3:01 3:02 3:03 3:04 4:01 4:02 4:03 4:04 5:01 5:02 Source: Reis Inc
  • 24. Sales to Condo Converters As a Share of All Apartment Sales Share of All Apartment Sales (%) 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 2003:1 :2 :3 :4 2004:1 :2 :3 :4 2005:1 :2 Source: Real Capital Analytics
  • 25. Leading Condo Conversion Markets Miami Las Vegas San Diego Orlando 2004 Tampa 2005 (ytd) DC Metro Phoenix Chicago LA 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 Units Source: Real Capital Analytics
  • 26. Condo Conversions are Picking Up in Denver Too 2500 Units 2000 1500 1000 500 0 2003 2 3 4 2004 2 3 4 2005 2 Source: Reis Inc
  • 28. The Denver Market Looks Like Elsewhere 45 Existing Single Family Home Sales (Ths., SAAR) 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q2 Q4 Q 94 1995 1995 1996 1996 1997 1997 1998 1998 1999 1999 2000 2000 2001 2001 2002 2002 2003 2003 2004 2004 2005 19 Source: Economy.com
  • 29. Prices Are Rising Faster in Denver Median Existing Home Price (Ths., SAAR) 260 240 220 200 Denver 180 US 160 140 120 100 1995Q1 1996Q2 1997Q3 1998Q4 2000Q1 2001Q2 2002Q3 2003Q4 2005Q1 Source: Economy.com
  • 30. Affordability is A Bit Less in Denver Affordability (Index) 170 160 150 US 140 130 Denver 120 110 5Q 1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 9 96 97 98 00 01 02 03 05 19 19 19 19 20 20 20 20 20 Source: NAR; BOC; BEA; Economy.com
  • 32. Outlook for A Strong Economy and Low Mortgage Rates Suggests A Solid Owner Market for Housing in the Near Term However, Buyer and Investor Leverage Pose Some Downside Risk
  • 33. The Share of Adjustable Rate Mortgages is Increasing Percent of All Mortgage Borrowers with Adjustable Rates 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 1995M1 1996M9 1998M5 2000M1 2001M9 2003M5 2005M1 Source: FHFB; Economy.com
  • 34. Homeowners Are Highly Leveraged Household Financial Obligations Ratio (% if Dis Income) 16.5 16 15.5 15 14.5 14 13.5 13 1980Q1 1985Q1 1990Q1 1995Q1 2000Q1 2005Q1 Source: Economy.com
  • 35. Investor Purchases Are Increasing 10 % Mortgage Originations 8 6 Second Homes Investor Purchases 4 2 0 2001 2004 2005 (Thru April) Source: LoanPerformance; Economy.com
  • 36. Look for Mr Greenspan to Stay the Course (%) 6.5 6 5.5 10-year Treasury 5 4.5 Fed Funds Rate 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 Q 4 Q 2 Q 4 Q 2 Q 4 Q 2 Q 4 Q 2 Q 4 Q 05 05 06 06 07 07 08 08 09 09 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 Source: FRB; Economy.com
  • 37. Mortgage Rates Will Rise Toward Long Term Averages Conventional Mortgage Rates (%) 7.5 7 30yr Fixed 6.5 6 5.5 ARM 5 4.5 4 2005M6 2006M4 2007M2 2007M12 2008M10 2009M8 Source: Freddie Mac; Economy.com
  • 38. Prices Will Continue to Rise Faster in Denver Median Existing Home Price ($Ths) 300 280 260 240 220 200 180 5Q 1 Q3 Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3 0 05 06 06 07 07 08 08 09 09 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 Source: NAR; Economy.com
  • 39. Affordability will Decline Affordability (Index) 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 Q 1 5 Q3 6 Q1 6 Q3 7 Q1 7 Q3 8 Q1 8 Q3 9 Q1 9 Q3 05 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 20 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 Source: Economy.com
  • 40. Sales Will Ease (hopefully) Down 40 Existing Sales, Units (Ths., SAAR) - Denver MSA 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 05Q 005Q 005Q 006Q 006Q 006Q 006Q 007Q 007Q 007Q 007Q 008Q 008Q 008Q 008Q 009Q 009Q 009Q 009Q 20 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 Source: NAR; Economy.com