Pirate 3 tells Pirates 1 and 2 frightening stories of ships that have gone missing in a certain area, believed by some to be due to attacks by a legendary sea monster called the Kraken. Pirate 3 provides the others with a old map in exchange for payment. However, when Pirates 1 and 2 later get robbed, they chase down the thief, who is revealed to work for the navy, and Pirate 1 brutally murders him with his sword.