SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 14
Ebola Joke? You Probably
Won’t Get It—Interreality
Comparison of Ebola Threat
and Perceived Threat
Expressed in U.S. Media
Liad Lehavy, Conrad Foreman.
and Morgan Cullen
Why we did it?
◈ Ebola epidemic in Africa
◈ U.S. media neglect
◈ Sudden reporting-burst in news
◈ Why and how?
◈ News shapes the public’s perception
of the threat of Ebola?
Hypotheses
H1: American news articles about Ebola will be dramatized, sensationalized, use
episodic framing, and exaggerate the threat of Ebola to the U.S. population.
H2: The reported perceived threat of Ebola will be higher than the actual threat to
individuals in the U.S.
H3: The Ebola crisis in Africa did not receive sufficient coverage in U.S. news media
until a U.S. resident was infected with Ebola.
Methods
◈ Content analysis of 44 randomly selected articles
from 3 established newspapers: The Washington
Post, The New York Times, and The L.A. Times.
◈ Coded it for episodic framing, dramatization, and
geographical bias.
◈ Gallup data to measure public’s perceived threat of
Ebola.
Episodic Framing
Overall Avg.
◈ 0.86
Washington Post Avg.
◈ 0.67
New York Times Avg.
◈ 1
L.A. Times Avg.
◈ 0.93
Dramatization
Overall Avg.
◈ 1
Washington Post Avg.
◈ 1
New York Times Avg.
◈ 1.13
LA Times Avg.
◈ 0.86
So
What?
Actual threat of Ebola
Doucleff, M. (2014, October
23). What's My Risk Of
Catching Ebola? Retrieved
March 29, 2015.
Perceived threat of Ebola
◈ Gallup data to measure public’s perceived threat of
Ebola.
◈ 5% Americans Ebola is most important U.S. problem
◈ 17% Americans think Ebola is the “most urgent health
problem in the U.S.”
◈ 22% Americans worry about contracting the Ebola virus
McCarthy, J. (2014). Ebola Debuts on Americans' List of Top U.S. Problems. Gallup Poll. Retrieved March 29, 2015.
Dugan, A. (2014). One-Fifth of Americans Worry About Getting Ebola. Gallup Poll. Retrieved March 29, 2015.
Saad, L. (2014). Ebola Ranks Among Americans' Top Three Healthcare Concerns. Gallup Poll. Retrieved March 29, 2015.
But
why?
Geographical Bias
Overall Avg.
◈ 1.52
Washington Post Avg.
◈ 1.33
New York Times Avg.
◈ 1.46
LA Times Avg.
◈ 1.79
Summary of Findings
◈ Majority of articles showed episodic
framing (24/44)
◈ Majority of articles showed
dramatization (29/44)
◈ Majority of articles showed some
degree of geographical bias (37/44)
o Many scored 1
Implications

More Related Content

Similar to 261+Ebola+_1_

Final Paper_Megan Lax
Final Paper_Megan LaxFinal Paper_Megan Lax
Final Paper_Megan LaxMegan Lax
 
finalFEAR AND THE COMING PLAGUE
finalFEAR AND THE COMING PLAGUEfinalFEAR AND THE COMING PLAGUE
finalFEAR AND THE COMING PLAGUEMargaret du Bray
 
Ebola Six Reasons to Panic
Ebola Six Reasons to PanicEbola Six Reasons to Panic
Ebola Six Reasons to PanicHope Small
 
Homeopathic prevention and treatment of epidemics & pandemics
Homeopathic prevention and treatment of epidemics & pandemicsHomeopathic prevention and treatment of epidemics & pandemics
Homeopathic prevention and treatment of epidemics & pandemicsSharumSharif
 
Current Problems in the Media
Current Problems in the MediaCurrent Problems in the Media
Current Problems in the MediaMajid Heidari
 
1Table of Contents Title PageDedicationIn.docx
1Table of Contents  Title PageDedicationIn.docx1Table of Contents  Title PageDedicationIn.docx
1Table of Contents Title PageDedicationIn.docxaulasnilda
 
The Outbreak Of The Measles
The Outbreak Of The MeaslesThe Outbreak Of The Measles
The Outbreak Of The MeaslesJessica Lopez
 
CGI Newsletter 26 October 2014
CGI Newsletter 26 October 2014CGI Newsletter 26 October 2014
CGI Newsletter 26 October 2014Dr. Chris Stout
 
America’s role in the world
America’s role in the world America’s role in the world
America’s role in the world professorgoff
 
U.S Actions Towards EBOLA
U.S Actions Towards EBOLAU.S Actions Towards EBOLA
U.S Actions Towards EBOLANeslihan Yakut
 
Published articles by Geraldine Carroll
Published articles by Geraldine CarrollPublished articles by Geraldine Carroll
Published articles by Geraldine CarrollGeraldine Carroll
 
Maxwell Final Paper_POLS 413
Maxwell Final Paper_POLS 413Maxwell Final Paper_POLS 413
Maxwell Final Paper_POLS 413Savannah Maxwell
 
COVID.City.Tuskegee.Bootstraps.TALK.5.17.2022.Alexander.final.1.pptx
COVID.City.Tuskegee.Bootstraps.TALK.5.17.2022.Alexander.final.1.pptxCOVID.City.Tuskegee.Bootstraps.TALK.5.17.2022.Alexander.final.1.pptx
COVID.City.Tuskegee.Bootstraps.TALK.5.17.2022.Alexander.final.1.pptxWeldonFultz1
 

Similar to 261+Ebola+_1_ (20)

Final Paper_Megan Lax
Final Paper_Megan LaxFinal Paper_Megan Lax
Final Paper_Megan Lax
 
Covering Ebola
Covering EbolaCovering Ebola
Covering Ebola
 
finalFEAR AND THE COMING PLAGUE
finalFEAR AND THE COMING PLAGUEfinalFEAR AND THE COMING PLAGUE
finalFEAR AND THE COMING PLAGUE
 
Ebola Six Reasons to Panic
Ebola Six Reasons to PanicEbola Six Reasons to Panic
Ebola Six Reasons to Panic
 
Ebola Study 2015 APHA Poster
Ebola  Study 2015 APHA PosterEbola  Study 2015 APHA Poster
Ebola Study 2015 APHA Poster
 
Ebola EDIT1
Ebola EDIT1Ebola EDIT1
Ebola EDIT1
 
Homeopathic prevention and treatment of epidemics & pandemics
Homeopathic prevention and treatment of epidemics & pandemicsHomeopathic prevention and treatment of epidemics & pandemics
Homeopathic prevention and treatment of epidemics & pandemics
 
Current Problems in the Media
Current Problems in the MediaCurrent Problems in the Media
Current Problems in the Media
 
Maríadelos angeles betancur3
Maríadelos angeles betancur3Maríadelos angeles betancur3
Maríadelos angeles betancur3
 
Erroranalysisinl2writing
Erroranalysisinl2writingErroranalysisinl2writing
Erroranalysisinl2writing
 
1Table of Contents Title PageDedicationIn.docx
1Table of Contents  Title PageDedicationIn.docx1Table of Contents  Title PageDedicationIn.docx
1Table of Contents Title PageDedicationIn.docx
 
The Outbreak Of The Measles
The Outbreak Of The MeaslesThe Outbreak Of The Measles
The Outbreak Of The Measles
 
CGI Newsletter 26 October 2014
CGI Newsletter 26 October 2014CGI Newsletter 26 October 2014
CGI Newsletter 26 October 2014
 
America’s role in the world
America’s role in the world America’s role in the world
America’s role in the world
 
U.S Actions Towards EBOLA
U.S Actions Towards EBOLAU.S Actions Towards EBOLA
U.S Actions Towards EBOLA
 
Published articles by Geraldine Carroll
Published articles by Geraldine CarrollPublished articles by Geraldine Carroll
Published articles by Geraldine Carroll
 
Human geo final project
Human geo final project Human geo final project
Human geo final project
 
Human geo final project
Human geo final project Human geo final project
Human geo final project
 
Maxwell Final Paper_POLS 413
Maxwell Final Paper_POLS 413Maxwell Final Paper_POLS 413
Maxwell Final Paper_POLS 413
 
COVID.City.Tuskegee.Bootstraps.TALK.5.17.2022.Alexander.final.1.pptx
COVID.City.Tuskegee.Bootstraps.TALK.5.17.2022.Alexander.final.1.pptxCOVID.City.Tuskegee.Bootstraps.TALK.5.17.2022.Alexander.final.1.pptx
COVID.City.Tuskegee.Bootstraps.TALK.5.17.2022.Alexander.final.1.pptx
 

261+Ebola+_1_

  • 1. Ebola Joke? You Probably Won’t Get It—Interreality Comparison of Ebola Threat and Perceived Threat Expressed in U.S. Media Liad Lehavy, Conrad Foreman. and Morgan Cullen
  • 2. Why we did it? ◈ Ebola epidemic in Africa ◈ U.S. media neglect ◈ Sudden reporting-burst in news ◈ Why and how? ◈ News shapes the public’s perception of the threat of Ebola?
  • 3.
  • 4. Hypotheses H1: American news articles about Ebola will be dramatized, sensationalized, use episodic framing, and exaggerate the threat of Ebola to the U.S. population. H2: The reported perceived threat of Ebola will be higher than the actual threat to individuals in the U.S. H3: The Ebola crisis in Africa did not receive sufficient coverage in U.S. news media until a U.S. resident was infected with Ebola.
  • 5. Methods ◈ Content analysis of 44 randomly selected articles from 3 established newspapers: The Washington Post, The New York Times, and The L.A. Times. ◈ Coded it for episodic framing, dramatization, and geographical bias. ◈ Gallup data to measure public’s perceived threat of Ebola.
  • 6. Episodic Framing Overall Avg. ◈ 0.86 Washington Post Avg. ◈ 0.67 New York Times Avg. ◈ 1 L.A. Times Avg. ◈ 0.93
  • 7. Dramatization Overall Avg. ◈ 1 Washington Post Avg. ◈ 1 New York Times Avg. ◈ 1.13 LA Times Avg. ◈ 0.86
  • 9. Actual threat of Ebola Doucleff, M. (2014, October 23). What's My Risk Of Catching Ebola? Retrieved March 29, 2015.
  • 10. Perceived threat of Ebola ◈ Gallup data to measure public’s perceived threat of Ebola. ◈ 5% Americans Ebola is most important U.S. problem ◈ 17% Americans think Ebola is the “most urgent health problem in the U.S.” ◈ 22% Americans worry about contracting the Ebola virus McCarthy, J. (2014). Ebola Debuts on Americans' List of Top U.S. Problems. Gallup Poll. Retrieved March 29, 2015. Dugan, A. (2014). One-Fifth of Americans Worry About Getting Ebola. Gallup Poll. Retrieved March 29, 2015. Saad, L. (2014). Ebola Ranks Among Americans' Top Three Healthcare Concerns. Gallup Poll. Retrieved March 29, 2015.
  • 12. Geographical Bias Overall Avg. ◈ 1.52 Washington Post Avg. ◈ 1.33 New York Times Avg. ◈ 1.46 LA Times Avg. ◈ 1.79
  • 13. Summary of Findings ◈ Majority of articles showed episodic framing (24/44) ◈ Majority of articles showed dramatization (29/44) ◈ Majority of articles showed some degree of geographical bias (37/44) o Many scored 1

Editor's Notes

  1. CONRAD / introduce clip
  2. Liad
  3. MORGAN
  4. CONRAD--explain the scale 0-2 and what that means for EPF —24 out of 44 articles found to have some -H1
  5. explain the scale 0-2 and what that means for DRA —29 out of 44 found to have some dramatization -H1
  6. MORGAN
  7. MORGAN
  8. MORGAN--How this supports H2
  9. LIAD — big disparity between actual and perceived threat — why? -- feeds into geographical bias
  10. Liad -H3 —High scores indicate greater bias toward American side of the story —37 out of 44 articles found to have some —20 out of 44 coded as 2 or 3
  11. LIAD All our data showed some support for our 3 hypotheses
  12. CONRAD — EPF, DRA, and GEO in news overall, not just in this case — the nature of a commercial, profit-driven news system — how unaware Americans are of international current events — role of politicians in the news about ebola — cable news and other TV