1. a
#INGO15 | 2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence | July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
ROOM NUMBER
July 28th, 2015 - 4:30-5:30
Currency Exchange Issues and
Rate Fluctuations -
Smart Management, Tips and Practices
203AB
2. #INGO15 | 2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence | July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
Session Panelists
•Leonard Williams - Moderator
•Rick Estridge
•Byard Bridge
3. #INGO15 | 2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence | July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
Background and Framing
Who Bears / How is
the risk / reward
allocated across the
Donor/Funder,
Implementer and
Subgrantee?
Often driven by
culture and capacity
of transaction
participants
Ability / Practicality of
Hedging
Should be addressed
very early on in the
award process and
documented in the
agreement / contract
Threshold
Issues Funding delivered to
field or HQ / Recovery
of IDC
Sophistication /
Maturity / Particulars of
local banking system
and currency
regulation
Funding provided by
Donor/Funder in
tranches
Capacity of local staff
Practical
Particulars
5. #INGO15 | 2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence | July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
Key Currency Risks in for Grants
• Translation Risks: Restatement of foreign currency
held assets and liabilities into base currency.
• Transaction Risks: The change in buying power you
will be able to achieve (actual exchange rate different
than budget assumptions.
6. #INGO15 | 2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence | July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
Key Currency Risks in for Grants
• Malawi Kwacha (MKW) was pegged to the USD at 165 MKW.
• Malawi dropped its currency peg to the US dollar in April 2012, causing the
Kwacha to devalue by about 50 percent.
• CRS had a MTZ program through FFP/USAID where food commodities
were sold to local buyer and Kwacha received.
• CRS/Malawi sold its monetization wheat at the beginning of the 1st quarter of
FY2012 for 436,467,656 MKW ($2.65 million)- enough to fund its entire
FY12 monetization budget and some FY2013 activities. CRS has a mixture
of locked USD obligations/expenses and others in LC.
• Currency laws require CRS/Malawi to retain the currency in MKW in a local
account – cash could not be exported.
7. #INGO15 | 2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence | July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
Case Study #1: The Tale of Malawi MTZ
USD Purchasing Power: $2.65 Million to $1.62 Million
8. #INGO15 | 2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence | July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
The Malawi Kwacha Challenge
• How to legally and responsibly manage and mitigate the impact on
purchasing power and beneficiaries when:
• Malawi law would not allow export of currency or converting into USD?
• Subrecipient Agreements for US-based subs were denominated in
USD?
• Economist projecting that the Kwacha may further devalue and inflation
of 20% impacting most LC expenses?
• Overview of action taken by CRS and lessons learned.
10. #INGO15 | 2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence | July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
Case #1
Headquarters
$1,000,000 to Nigeria
Local office receives
Naira (NGN)
11. #INGO15
2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence
July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
Analysis
• No rate comparison for the conversion
• Best rate?
• Captive client
• Additional Fees
12. #INGO15
2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence
July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
Case #2
• Organization to pay service provider in Brazil
• Expenses total 2,000,000 BRL
• Organization sends USD to local office
account
• Market rate fluctuates
• Bank converts USD to BRL at current rate
• Converted amount does not cover expenses
13. #INGO15
2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence
July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
Analysis
• Accounting transparency
• Must wait for rate to be reported by the
overseas entity
• True costs are not known up front
• Full amount of local currency may not be
received
• HQ send more funds potentially resulting in
more fees and further “approximation” risk.
(Multiple rates quoted)
14. #INGO15
2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence
July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
Case #3
Headquarters
Monthly
$500,000
India Local
Office
Locally converts
part to INR
Holds balance in
USD
15. #INGO15
2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence
July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
Analysis
• Volatility of markets
• Value lost on funds
• Country risk
• Credit risk
• Centralization of funding at HQ can
mitigate risks
17. #INGO15 | 2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence | July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
The Three Way - Issues
Donor provides funding directly to country office in £ for use in local
currency – TZS - by subgrantees and local staff. Will need to be
reported in USD. Project runs over three years with tranches released
based on attainment of certain objectives / deliverables / results.
Issues –
• Recovery of IDC
• Liquidation of subgrants
• Reporting of results to the donor
and other stakeholders
• Timing of receipts
18. #INGO15 | 2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence | July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
The Three Way - Analysis
Negotiate currency
conversion rate or terms
for dealing with losses /
gains upfront with donor
Consider deconstructing
transaction to use
natural hedging
Recovery of IDC
• Use offsets
• Fall back on pre- negotiated
rate
Liquidation of subgrants
• Push risk onto subgrantee
• Be prepared to revise
expectations regarding results
Reporting of results to
donors and other
stakeholders
• Use pre-negotiated rate
• Have explanation ready if
impact is material
Timing of receipts
• Press for tighter performance
• Consider hedging
19. a
#INGO15 | 2015 Annual Conference | Pathways To Excellence | July 28-30, 2015 | Washington, DC
Q&A
Editor's Notes
First, welcome to our session on managing currency exchange issues. I realize that its been a long, eventful first day, so let’s get started.
The thrust of this session is to frame the issues around currency exposures in an international development environment and suggest some effective practices and procedures for managing those exposures.
Regarding the format of this session, our panelists will illustrate issues from their own experience using real-life case. At end of each panelist’s presentation, we will have some time for Q&A and then some more time for Q&A at the end of the session.
Now regarding our panelists. My name is Leonard Williams and I served as CFO and EVP-Finance at Pact for five years and am now an Engagement Partner at Tatum. I will be serving as the moderator and making some contributions to the session.
Rick Estridge is a NGO finance and operations expert and consultant who was most recently Vice President, Overseas Finance at CRS. There he held a key leadership position within the agency assuming a strategic and hands-on role in the overall management of CRS’ overseas financial operations and internal control environment.
Finally, Byard Bridge is Senior Vice President - FX Sales at INTL FCStone Ltd where he provides foreign exchange and treasury services to humanitarian aid and development organizations and specializes in transferring funds in the more exotic and difficult currency markets worldwide which are not regularly serviced by the larger banks.
I will start things off with some general observations and then we will hear a case presented by Rick and then a set of situations by Byard and finally a case by me.