SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Housing . . . Living Urban versus Suburban . . .
               September 2012

                  Terry Mitchell
                    July, 2011
Suburban Example . . .




                         About 240 Net Acres

                             600 Units


                          300 Park Acres
Downtown Sample

   1033 Units
   24.10 Acres




    Urban housing . . .
Consequences of Suburban – Sprawl



      • How do we want to grow?
Let’s Look at Austin
• Austin (metro) is expected to grow 580,000
  people over the next 10 years . . .
• Austin grew 67,000 in 2011.
• Many of our development regulations are
  focused on “low density”, “preservation of the
  environment” . . .
• “Density” is a bad word . . . (It should be your
  best friend . . . )
What will Austin look like in 10 years?



• 580,000 new residents . . . At 2.6 people per
  housing unit, means 223,077 new housing
  units will be needed . . .
Suburban Density of 3 Units/Acre



• At a suburban density of 3 units per acre, we
  will need 74,359 acres of land to house just
  our population growth over the next 10 years.
• . . . or 116 square miles. . . .
Townhome Density of 10 Units/Acre




• At a townhome density of 10 units per
  acre, we will need 22,308 acres of land to
  house just our population growth over the
  next 10 years.
• . . . Or 35 square miles. . . .
Downtown Density of 200 Units/Acre



      »At a downtown density of 200 units per
       acre, we will need 1,115 acres of land to
       house just our population growth over
       the next 10 years.
      ». . . Or 1.7 square miles. . . .
What Differing Densities Look Like
Density Helps Affordability
What does the differing forms of
    development mean for the City?
• If you take the roads – and utilities under the
  roads – that must be built to house these
  folks, over the next 10 years (for Austin), you
  will be building enough roads to get you to:
• At 3 units per acre, almost to Seattle, WA.
• At 10 units per acre, almost to Oxford, MS.
• At 200 units per acre, almost to San
  Marcos, Tx.
Sustainability
                                                     Comparison of Downtown High Rise And Suburban Development

          *This Chart compares the "environmental footprint" of a downtown high rise community with (i) a similarly priced luxury suburban community, (ii) a typical suburban single family   community,
                                                          and (iii) a lower density condominium project, all with a similar number of units.


                                                                                         Urban/Suburban                          Typical Suburban                           Similarly Priced
                                               Urban Condo Project                        Condo Project                         Single Family Project                     One Acre Lot Project

Number of Units                                          200                                    200                                       200                                       200


Acreage consumed for project                    Under 3/4 of an acre                 approximately 20 acres                   Between 57 and 70 acres                        220 to 230 acres
                                                                                 (approximately 10 units per acre          (between app. 3 and 3.5 units               (approximately one acre lots
                                                                                    with roads and drainage)              per acre with roads and drainage)              with roads and drainage)

Impervious Coverage
   Percentage of Total Project                         100%                                 55 to 60%                                    45%                                   15 to 45%
   Total Acres of IC                               3/4 of an acre                         11 to 12 acres                            26 to 32 acres                           29 to 87 acres


Length of Streets and Utility Lines                   334 feet                            app. 1900 feet                             1.5 to 2 miles                            4 to 5 miles
   Internal to the Project

Landscape Water Usage                                    Zero                             6,800,000 gal/year                     15,600,000 gal/year                       40,000,000 gal/year
                                            (Landscaping irrigated with          (Based on actual 10 unit per acre          (Typical standard lot irrigates       (Typical one acre lot irrigates at least
                                            rain water collection system               condo project, including              approximately 6,500 gallons                 10,000 s.f. resulting in
                                               and A/C condensation            initial establishment of landscaping.          or 78,000 gallons per year              200,000 per year of potable
                                                 collection system.)              2,833 gal/mo. Or 34,000 gal/yr.)          of potable water for irrigation.)      water used to irrigate landscaping.)

Electricity Usage                              $10 to $60 per month                 app. $50 to $200 or more               app. $100 to $300/mo. or more                 $250 to $450 per month
                                          (Energy efficient design; green           (Usage is less with smaller              (This usage will vary greatly                (Typical higher usage
                                          building, smaller size; using City     size homes and common walls.             depending on the size of the home       with larger size housing and separate
                                           chilled water system for A/C.)        Typically less than single family.)      and multiple A/C units per home.)         and multiple A/C units per home.)

Taxable Value Per Acre                           Over $80 million to                 Depends on location and                 Approximately $700,000 to              Approximately $1 million per acre
                                               $150 million per acre,             value of units. Range is from                 $1,225,000 per acre                (assuming an average home value
                                               depending on value of                app. $2,000,000 per acre to          (assuming an average home value          of approximately $1 million per home)
                                                       units.)                     (unit values from $200k/unit)        of approximately $200,000 per home)


Percentage of Taxes Used to Provide              about 10% to 20%                  Taxes may pay for services              Taxes do not pay for services             Taxes do not pay for services
City Services to Community               (Mayor's Will Wynn statement that           needed for Community                     needed for Community                      needed for Community
                                             downtown buildings need                as tax base is higher and
                                               only 20% of taxes to                maintenance obligations are
                                              provide City Services)                       much lower.



                                                                                                                                                                                              10/16/2009

More Related Content

Similar to 2012.10.20 short density sustainability

15 Powerful Facts on Water and Energy Use
15 Powerful Facts on Water and Energy Use15 Powerful Facts on Water and Energy Use
15 Powerful Facts on Water and Energy Use
Lily Perkins-High
 
The economics of ecosystems and biodiversity for business - Joshua Bishop, WWF
The economics of ecosystems and biodiversity for business - Joshua Bishop, WWFThe economics of ecosystems and biodiversity for business - Joshua Bishop, WWF
The economics of ecosystems and biodiversity for business - Joshua Bishop, WWFWWF Heart of Borneo Global Initiative
 
Green City... Clean Water
Green City... Clean WaterGreen City... Clean Water
1 Introduction, Composites
1 Introduction, Composites1 Introduction, Composites
1 Introduction, Composites
CompositeBuilding
 
Eco3 Bts Env
Eco3 Bts EnvEco3 Bts Env
Eco3 Bts Envsdas61
 
Just Bio Fiber Introduction
Just Bio Fiber IntroductionJust Bio Fiber Introduction
Just Bio Fiber Introduction
Dave Ladouceur
 
Economic Benefits and Returns to Rural Feeder Roads
Economic Benefits and Returns to Rural Feeder RoadsEconomic Benefits and Returns to Rural Feeder Roads
Economic Benefits and Returns to Rural Feeder Roadsessp2
 
Energy 4 4_sanctuary_p_o_c
Energy 4 4_sanctuary_p_o_cEnergy 4 4_sanctuary_p_o_c
Energy 4 4_sanctuary_p_o_c
ecologicalfox
 
Women Of Green
Women Of GreenWomen Of Green
Women Of Green
CUNY Sustainable Cities
 
Minneapolis Energy Options
Minneapolis Energy OptionsMinneapolis Energy Options
Minneapolis Energy Options
John Farrell
 
Chapter 6 Urban Land Rent - Urban Economics 6th Edition
Chapter 6 Urban Land Rent - Urban Economics 6th EditionChapter 6 Urban Land Rent - Urban Economics 6th Edition
Chapter 6 Urban Land Rent - Urban Economics 6th Edition
Paramita E.
 

Similar to 2012.10.20 short density sustainability (12)

15 Powerful Facts on Water and Energy Use
15 Powerful Facts on Water and Energy Use15 Powerful Facts on Water and Energy Use
15 Powerful Facts on Water and Energy Use
 
The economics of ecosystems and biodiversity for business - Joshua Bishop, WWF
The economics of ecosystems and biodiversity for business - Joshua Bishop, WWFThe economics of ecosystems and biodiversity for business - Joshua Bishop, WWF
The economics of ecosystems and biodiversity for business - Joshua Bishop, WWF
 
Green City... Clean Water
Green City... Clean WaterGreen City... Clean Water
Green City... Clean Water
 
1 Introduction, Composites
1 Introduction, Composites1 Introduction, Composites
1 Introduction, Composites
 
Cyflwyniad gan Gareth Wyn Jones yn ystod cyfarfod y Comisiwn Cymru ar y Newid...
Cyflwyniad gan Gareth Wyn Jones yn ystod cyfarfod y Comisiwn Cymru ar y Newid...Cyflwyniad gan Gareth Wyn Jones yn ystod cyfarfod y Comisiwn Cymru ar y Newid...
Cyflwyniad gan Gareth Wyn Jones yn ystod cyfarfod y Comisiwn Cymru ar y Newid...
 
Eco3 Bts Env
Eco3 Bts EnvEco3 Bts Env
Eco3 Bts Env
 
Just Bio Fiber Introduction
Just Bio Fiber IntroductionJust Bio Fiber Introduction
Just Bio Fiber Introduction
 
Economic Benefits and Returns to Rural Feeder Roads
Economic Benefits and Returns to Rural Feeder RoadsEconomic Benefits and Returns to Rural Feeder Roads
Economic Benefits and Returns to Rural Feeder Roads
 
Energy 4 4_sanctuary_p_o_c
Energy 4 4_sanctuary_p_o_cEnergy 4 4_sanctuary_p_o_c
Energy 4 4_sanctuary_p_o_c
 
Women Of Green
Women Of GreenWomen Of Green
Women Of Green
 
Minneapolis Energy Options
Minneapolis Energy OptionsMinneapolis Energy Options
Minneapolis Energy Options
 
Chapter 6 Urban Land Rent - Urban Economics 6th Edition
Chapter 6 Urban Land Rent - Urban Economics 6th EditionChapter 6 Urban Land Rent - Urban Economics 6th Edition
Chapter 6 Urban Land Rent - Urban Economics 6th Edition
 

2012.10.20 short density sustainability

  • 1. Housing . . . Living Urban versus Suburban . . . September 2012 Terry Mitchell July, 2011
  • 2. Suburban Example . . . About 240 Net Acres 600 Units 300 Park Acres
  • 3. Downtown Sample 1033 Units 24.10 Acres Urban housing . . .
  • 4. Consequences of Suburban – Sprawl • How do we want to grow?
  • 5. Let’s Look at Austin • Austin (metro) is expected to grow 580,000 people over the next 10 years . . . • Austin grew 67,000 in 2011. • Many of our development regulations are focused on “low density”, “preservation of the environment” . . . • “Density” is a bad word . . . (It should be your best friend . . . )
  • 6. What will Austin look like in 10 years? • 580,000 new residents . . . At 2.6 people per housing unit, means 223,077 new housing units will be needed . . .
  • 7. Suburban Density of 3 Units/Acre • At a suburban density of 3 units per acre, we will need 74,359 acres of land to house just our population growth over the next 10 years. • . . . or 116 square miles. . . .
  • 8. Townhome Density of 10 Units/Acre • At a townhome density of 10 units per acre, we will need 22,308 acres of land to house just our population growth over the next 10 years. • . . . Or 35 square miles. . . .
  • 9. Downtown Density of 200 Units/Acre »At a downtown density of 200 units per acre, we will need 1,115 acres of land to house just our population growth over the next 10 years. ». . . Or 1.7 square miles. . . .
  • 12. What does the differing forms of development mean for the City? • If you take the roads – and utilities under the roads – that must be built to house these folks, over the next 10 years (for Austin), you will be building enough roads to get you to: • At 3 units per acre, almost to Seattle, WA. • At 10 units per acre, almost to Oxford, MS. • At 200 units per acre, almost to San Marcos, Tx.
  • 13.
  • 14. Sustainability Comparison of Downtown High Rise And Suburban Development *This Chart compares the "environmental footprint" of a downtown high rise community with (i) a similarly priced luxury suburban community, (ii) a typical suburban single family community, and (iii) a lower density condominium project, all with a similar number of units. Urban/Suburban Typical Suburban Similarly Priced Urban Condo Project Condo Project Single Family Project One Acre Lot Project Number of Units 200 200 200 200 Acreage consumed for project Under 3/4 of an acre approximately 20 acres Between 57 and 70 acres 220 to 230 acres (approximately 10 units per acre (between app. 3 and 3.5 units (approximately one acre lots with roads and drainage) per acre with roads and drainage) with roads and drainage) Impervious Coverage Percentage of Total Project 100% 55 to 60% 45% 15 to 45% Total Acres of IC 3/4 of an acre 11 to 12 acres 26 to 32 acres 29 to 87 acres Length of Streets and Utility Lines 334 feet app. 1900 feet 1.5 to 2 miles 4 to 5 miles Internal to the Project Landscape Water Usage Zero 6,800,000 gal/year 15,600,000 gal/year 40,000,000 gal/year (Landscaping irrigated with (Based on actual 10 unit per acre (Typical standard lot irrigates (Typical one acre lot irrigates at least rain water collection system condo project, including approximately 6,500 gallons 10,000 s.f. resulting in and A/C condensation initial establishment of landscaping. or 78,000 gallons per year 200,000 per year of potable collection system.) 2,833 gal/mo. Or 34,000 gal/yr.) of potable water for irrigation.) water used to irrigate landscaping.) Electricity Usage $10 to $60 per month app. $50 to $200 or more app. $100 to $300/mo. or more $250 to $450 per month (Energy efficient design; green (Usage is less with smaller (This usage will vary greatly (Typical higher usage building, smaller size; using City size homes and common walls. depending on the size of the home with larger size housing and separate chilled water system for A/C.) Typically less than single family.) and multiple A/C units per home.) and multiple A/C units per home.) Taxable Value Per Acre Over $80 million to Depends on location and Approximately $700,000 to Approximately $1 million per acre $150 million per acre, value of units. Range is from $1,225,000 per acre (assuming an average home value depending on value of app. $2,000,000 per acre to (assuming an average home value of approximately $1 million per home) units.) (unit values from $200k/unit) of approximately $200,000 per home) Percentage of Taxes Used to Provide about 10% to 20% Taxes may pay for services Taxes do not pay for services Taxes do not pay for services City Services to Community (Mayor's Will Wynn statement that needed for Community needed for Community needed for Community downtown buildings need as tax base is higher and only 20% of taxes to maintenance obligations are provide City Services) much lower. 10/16/2009