SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 25
Opening up Research
                                                  Outputs and
                                                  Knowledge in
                                                   Agriculture:
                                                  Benefits and
                                                   Challenges


Regional Expert Consultation
on Opening Access to Agricultural Information in Africa
      Presented by Franz Martin
      Knowledge and Capacity for Development               www.ciard.net
                                                           information@ciard.net
Knowledge Sharing in Agricultural Innovation
Agricultural Research Outputs
Type of agric. research outputs
       (Kenya, Ghana, Zambia)
Publications over period 1999-2008
                                     Africa’s output of publications




 Source: Thomson-Reuters (April, 2010).
Network of collaboration
                 Cluster of countries with strongest partnerships (by papers)




Source: Thomson-Reuters (April, 2010).
Scientific Collaboration Map
           (2005-2009)
Content in Google from universities




Graph by FAO. Source data from www.webometrics.info (Webpages from universities. January, 2009)
Open Access Repositories




Source: Repository Maps - repository66.org
Powered by Google
Agric. Research Institutional Repositories
                                      Status in Ghana
  Numbeof f publica ions
                    tions
Number r o pub lic at




Graph by FAO. Source data from INSTI, Ghana. March, 2010
Accessibility of research outputs
   in some International Centres
         Centre A                                  Centre B                              Centre C




        Bibliographic                        Full Text Resources                         Search Engines
        References

Graph by FAO. Source data from Agricultural Information Worldwide. Vol. 3. No.1 (2010)
BENEFITS AND
 CHALLENGES
Region(s) where most respondents‘ work
             is carried out.

   Europe 4.6%                            Northern America 4.1%



                                                                           Caribbean
                                                                           6.9%


                     Asia and Pacific 23.7%



      Africa 32.6%

                               Latin America 53.5%


                                    Source: CIARD. Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
FACTORS ENCOURAGING
effective communication of research outputs

Most important:
- Institutional demands to report/communicate
- Opportunities for career enhancement
- Access to adequate IT infrastructure
- Acknowledgement of contributions
Less important:
- Direct monetary rewards
  (related to royalties and
  personal development)
                              Source: CIARD. Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
BENEFITS GAINED
          by communicating research

Most important:
- Reaching the target audience
- Increased access to: a) resources/funding for work and
                        b) colleagues for problem solving
- Increased recognition/visibility for the organization

    altruistic
Less important:
- Personal gain
  (financial or personal status)       © FAO

                                   Source: CIARD Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
BARRIERS
 preventing from communicating research

Most important:
- Lack of resources/time and funding
- Weak linkages between researchers and end users
- Lack of enabling institutional policies


Less important:
- Concerns about stealing and reuse of outputs
- Lack of skills/access to communication methods
- Poor IT infrastructure
                              Source: CIARD Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
ROUTES PREFERED
     for communication of research outputs


Stronger preference
Traditional routes
- Scholarly publishing, conferences and seminars (3/4)
- Training materials (1/2), practical demonstr. (1/3)

Weaker preference
Broadcast/Mass media
   - Newspapers (~8%), radio/TV (~15%), promo.mat.
                                                               © FAO
   (~29%)


   Modern methods (Internet enabled)
   -Social media (~18%), repository/web (~29%)
                                            Source: CIARD Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
SUPPORT MECHANISMS
for communicating research outputs effectively


 Strong demand for support and training
 - Web based social media
 - Participatory research methods &
   communications skills
   (e.g. audio/video)




                           © FAO

                            Source: CIARD Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
RESEARCH OUTPUTS PRODUCED


Traditional print-based formats still predominate...
but digital ones are now penetrating (20-35%)

Most outputs are communicated
through openly accessible, no-cost routes.




                             Source: CIARD Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
THE WAY FORWARD

Making research outputs openly available
often relies on individuals.

Individuals’ behaviours can be influenced
by institutional factors/barriers.

Relevant strategic policy frameworks are
required to change institutional/
individual behaviours.
THE WAY FORWARD




These findings can be considered by
senior managers to review their
organizational policies.
Coherence in Information
      for Agricultural Research for Development



A global movement that promotes and sustain
 the openness of agricultural knowledge to all.
The Movement
                   Founding Partners




More than 150 other organizations participating…   www.ciard.net
CIARD support for overcoming
the Challenges in Research Communication

         Our institution
         has no policy on                       We don’t have time to
         communicating                          adapt our results into the
         its outputs                            what extensionists want


We have no systems
                                      Other scientists will
and tools for Internet
                                      publish our results if we
dissemination
                                      share them


                          There are no staff
                           with the skills in
                         digital technologies
                                                               www.ciard.net
Opening up Research
                                                  Outputs and
                                                  Knowledge in
                                                   Agriculture:
                                                  Benefits and
                                                   Challenges


Regional Expert Consultation
on Opening Access to Agricultural Information in Africa
      Presented by Franz Martin
      Knowledge and Capacity for Development               www.ciard.net
                                                           information@ciard.net

More Related Content

What's hot

Lebanon Plant Genetic Resources Knowledge Network, 11-12 June 2015 , LARI and...
Lebanon Plant Genetic Resources Knowledge Network, 11-12 June 2015 , LARI and...Lebanon Plant Genetic Resources Knowledge Network, 11-12 June 2015 , LARI and...
Lebanon Plant Genetic Resources Knowledge Network, 11-12 June 2015 , LARI and...FAO
 
Wb data assignment
Wb data assignmentWb data assignment
Wb data assignmentKami67
 
Reaching new global audiences - Nottingham's World Expo showcase: Emma Leech,...
Reaching new global audiences - Nottingham's World Expo showcase: Emma Leech,...Reaching new global audiences - Nottingham's World Expo showcase: Emma Leech,...
Reaching new global audiences - Nottingham's World Expo showcase: Emma Leech,...Chartered Institute of Public Relations
 
Integrated Global Early Warning and Response System
Integrated Global Early Warning and Response SystemIntegrated Global Early Warning and Response System
Integrated Global Early Warning and Response SystemInSTEDD
 
Afrigap history vision and objectives
Afrigap history vision and objectivesAfrigap history vision and objectives
Afrigap history vision and objectivesAfriGAP
 

What's hot (9)

Lebanon Plant Genetic Resources Knowledge Network, 11-12 June 2015 , LARI and...
Lebanon Plant Genetic Resources Knowledge Network, 11-12 June 2015 , LARI and...Lebanon Plant Genetic Resources Knowledge Network, 11-12 June 2015 , LARI and...
Lebanon Plant Genetic Resources Knowledge Network, 11-12 June 2015 , LARI and...
 
Wb data assignment
Wb data assignmentWb data assignment
Wb data assignment
 
Reaching new global audiences - Nottingham's World Expo showcase: Emma Leech,...
Reaching new global audiences - Nottingham's World Expo showcase: Emma Leech,...Reaching new global audiences - Nottingham's World Expo showcase: Emma Leech,...
Reaching new global audiences - Nottingham's World Expo showcase: Emma Leech,...
 
Institutional Frameworks Models, Trend, Challenges - Elida Reci
Institutional Frameworks Models, Trend, Challenges - Elida Reci Institutional Frameworks Models, Trend, Challenges - Elida Reci
Institutional Frameworks Models, Trend, Challenges - Elida Reci
 
ISA - a short overview - Dec 2013
ISA - a short overview - Dec 2013ISA - a short overview - Dec 2013
ISA - a short overview - Dec 2013
 
Integrated Global Early Warning and Response System
Integrated Global Early Warning and Response SystemIntegrated Global Early Warning and Response System
Integrated Global Early Warning and Response System
 
Data cite
Data citeData cite
Data cite
 
Health Systems 2020 Overview 2011
Health  Systems 2020 Overview 2011Health  Systems 2020 Overview 2011
Health Systems 2020 Overview 2011
 
Afrigap history vision and objectives
Afrigap history vision and objectivesAfrigap history vision and objectives
Afrigap history vision and objectives
 

Similar to 2012 06 CIARD (Regional Workshop)

2012 08 CIARD Opening Access (VI FORAGRO - Peru)
2012 08 CIARD Opening Access (VI FORAGRO - Peru)2012 08 CIARD Opening Access (VI FORAGRO - Peru)
2012 08 CIARD Opening Access (VI FORAGRO - Peru)CIARD
 
2011 11 ciard (opening up knowledge for all) ink4 dev -west africa
2011 11 ciard (opening up knowledge for all) ink4 dev -west africa2011 11 ciard (opening up knowledge for all) ink4 dev -west africa
2011 11 ciard (opening up knowledge for all) ink4 dev -west africaCIARD
 
2012 09 ciard using information to power innovation (macs mexico)
2012 09 ciard using information to power innovation (macs  mexico)2012 09 ciard using information to power innovation (macs  mexico)
2012 09 ciard using information to power innovation (macs mexico)CIARD
 
2011 06 CIARD Introduction - Beijing - English
2011 06 CIARD Introduction - Beijing - English2011 06 CIARD Introduction - Beijing - English
2011 06 CIARD Introduction - Beijing - EnglishFranz J R
 
2011 06 Ciard Introduction - English - Beijing
2011 06 Ciard Introduction - English - Beijing2011 06 Ciard Introduction - English - Beijing
2011 06 Ciard Introduction - English - BeijingCIARD
 
2011-05 CIARD General Presentation - English - Bangladesh
2011-05 CIARD General Presentation - English - Bangladesh 2011-05 CIARD General Presentation - English - Bangladesh
2011-05 CIARD General Presentation - English - Bangladesh CIARD
 
The African Open Science Platform: Policy, Infrastructure, Skills and Incenti...
The African Open Science Platform: Policy, Infrastructure, Skills and Incenti...The African Open Science Platform: Policy, Infrastructure, Skills and Incenti...
The African Open Science Platform: Policy, Infrastructure, Skills and Incenti...African Open Science Platform
 
C3.1. Framework for Information and Data Sharing
C3.1. Framework for Information and Data SharingC3.1. Framework for Information and Data Sharing
C3.1. Framework for Information and Data SharingGCARD Conferences
 
Council 142 inf-3 ciard
Council 142 inf-3 ciardCouncil 142 inf-3 ciard
Council 142 inf-3 ciardAARINENA
 
2012 10 ciard (GCARD2 Uruguay)
2012 10 ciard (GCARD2  Uruguay)2012 10 ciard (GCARD2  Uruguay)
2012 10 ciard (GCARD2 Uruguay)CIARD
 
2010-05 CIARD Detailed Presentation - English
2010-05 CIARD Detailed Presentation - English2010-05 CIARD Detailed Presentation - English
2010-05 CIARD Detailed Presentation - EnglishCIARD
 
2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE)
2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE) 2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE)
2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE) CIARD
 
CA knowledge and information management. The case of ACT. Hamisi Mzoba
CA knowledge and information management. The case of ACT. Hamisi MzobaCA knowledge and information management. The case of ACT. Hamisi Mzoba
CA knowledge and information management. The case of ACT. Hamisi MzobaJoanna Hicks
 
Open FAIR Data and Open Science: Developing Partnerships, Strategies, Policie...
Open FAIR Data and Open Science: Developing Partnerships, Strategies, Policie...Open FAIR Data and Open Science: Developing Partnerships, Strategies, Policie...
Open FAIR Data and Open Science: Developing Partnerships, Strategies, Policie...Academy of Science of South Africa (ASSAf)
 
EnablingFAIR - Open research data in the UK
EnablingFAIR - Open research data in the UKEnablingFAIR - Open research data in the UK
EnablingFAIR - Open research data in the UKSusanna-Assunta Sansone
 

Similar to 2012 06 CIARD (Regional Workshop) (20)

2012 08 CIARD Opening Access (VI FORAGRO - Peru)
2012 08 CIARD Opening Access (VI FORAGRO - Peru)2012 08 CIARD Opening Access (VI FORAGRO - Peru)
2012 08 CIARD Opening Access (VI FORAGRO - Peru)
 
2011 11 ciard (opening up knowledge for all) ink4 dev -west africa
2011 11 ciard (opening up knowledge for all) ink4 dev -west africa2011 11 ciard (opening up knowledge for all) ink4 dev -west africa
2011 11 ciard (opening up knowledge for all) ink4 dev -west africa
 
2012 09 ciard using information to power innovation (macs mexico)
2012 09 ciard using information to power innovation (macs  mexico)2012 09 ciard using information to power innovation (macs  mexico)
2012 09 ciard using information to power innovation (macs mexico)
 
2011 06 CIARD Introduction - Beijing - English
2011 06 CIARD Introduction - Beijing - English2011 06 CIARD Introduction - Beijing - English
2011 06 CIARD Introduction - Beijing - English
 
2011 06 Ciard Introduction - English - Beijing
2011 06 Ciard Introduction - English - Beijing2011 06 Ciard Introduction - English - Beijing
2011 06 Ciard Introduction - English - Beijing
 
2011-05 CIARD General Presentation - English - Bangladesh
2011-05 CIARD General Presentation - English - Bangladesh 2011-05 CIARD General Presentation - English - Bangladesh
2011-05 CIARD General Presentation - English - Bangladesh
 
CIARD Coherence in Information for Agricultural Research for Development
CIARD Coherence in Information for Agricultural Research for DevelopmentCIARD Coherence in Information for Agricultural Research for Development
CIARD Coherence in Information for Agricultural Research for Development
 
Agnic 2011 5
Agnic 2011 5Agnic 2011 5
Agnic 2011 5
 
The African Open Science Platform: Policy, Infrastructure, Skills and Incenti...
The African Open Science Platform: Policy, Infrastructure, Skills and Incenti...The African Open Science Platform: Policy, Infrastructure, Skills and Incenti...
The African Open Science Platform: Policy, Infrastructure, Skills and Incenti...
 
C3.1. Framework for Information and Data Sharing
C3.1. Framework for Information and Data SharingC3.1. Framework for Information and Data Sharing
C3.1. Framework for Information and Data Sharing
 
Council 142 inf-3 ciard
Council 142 inf-3 ciardCouncil 142 inf-3 ciard
Council 142 inf-3 ciard
 
2012 10 ciard (GCARD2 Uruguay)
2012 10 ciard (GCARD2  Uruguay)2012 10 ciard (GCARD2  Uruguay)
2012 10 ciard (GCARD2 Uruguay)
 
Lessons Learnt from the GCP Experience - Jean-Marcel Ribaut
Lessons Learnt from the GCP Experience - Jean-Marcel RibautLessons Learnt from the GCP Experience - Jean-Marcel Ribaut
Lessons Learnt from the GCP Experience - Jean-Marcel Ribaut
 
013 sumumba
013   sumumba013   sumumba
013 sumumba
 
2010-05 CIARD Detailed Presentation - English
2010-05 CIARD Detailed Presentation - English2010-05 CIARD Detailed Presentation - English
2010-05 CIARD Detailed Presentation - English
 
2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE)
2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE) 2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE)
2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE)
 
011 rudgard
011   rudgard011   rudgard
011 rudgard
 
CA knowledge and information management. The case of ACT. Hamisi Mzoba
CA knowledge and information management. The case of ACT. Hamisi MzobaCA knowledge and information management. The case of ACT. Hamisi Mzoba
CA knowledge and information management. The case of ACT. Hamisi Mzoba
 
Open FAIR Data and Open Science: Developing Partnerships, Strategies, Policie...
Open FAIR Data and Open Science: Developing Partnerships, Strategies, Policie...Open FAIR Data and Open Science: Developing Partnerships, Strategies, Policie...
Open FAIR Data and Open Science: Developing Partnerships, Strategies, Policie...
 
EnablingFAIR - Open research data in the UK
EnablingFAIR - Open research data in the UKEnablingFAIR - Open research data in the UK
EnablingFAIR - Open research data in the UK
 

2012 06 CIARD (Regional Workshop)

  • 1. Opening up Research Outputs and Knowledge in Agriculture: Benefits and Challenges Regional Expert Consultation on Opening Access to Agricultural Information in Africa Presented by Franz Martin Knowledge and Capacity for Development www.ciard.net information@ciard.net
  • 2. Knowledge Sharing in Agricultural Innovation
  • 4. Type of agric. research outputs (Kenya, Ghana, Zambia)
  • 5. Publications over period 1999-2008 Africa’s output of publications Source: Thomson-Reuters (April, 2010).
  • 6. Network of collaboration Cluster of countries with strongest partnerships (by papers) Source: Thomson-Reuters (April, 2010).
  • 8. Content in Google from universities Graph by FAO. Source data from www.webometrics.info (Webpages from universities. January, 2009)
  • 9. Open Access Repositories Source: Repository Maps - repository66.org Powered by Google
  • 10. Agric. Research Institutional Repositories Status in Ghana Numbeof f publica ions tions Number r o pub lic at Graph by FAO. Source data from INSTI, Ghana. March, 2010
  • 11. Accessibility of research outputs in some International Centres Centre A Centre B Centre C Bibliographic Full Text Resources Search Engines References Graph by FAO. Source data from Agricultural Information Worldwide. Vol. 3. No.1 (2010)
  • 13. Region(s) where most respondents‘ work is carried out. Europe 4.6% Northern America 4.1% Caribbean 6.9% Asia and Pacific 23.7% Africa 32.6% Latin America 53.5% Source: CIARD. Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
  • 14. FACTORS ENCOURAGING effective communication of research outputs Most important: - Institutional demands to report/communicate - Opportunities for career enhancement - Access to adequate IT infrastructure - Acknowledgement of contributions Less important: - Direct monetary rewards (related to royalties and personal development) Source: CIARD. Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
  • 15. BENEFITS GAINED by communicating research Most important: - Reaching the target audience - Increased access to: a) resources/funding for work and b) colleagues for problem solving - Increased recognition/visibility for the organization altruistic Less important: - Personal gain (financial or personal status) © FAO Source: CIARD Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
  • 16. BARRIERS preventing from communicating research Most important: - Lack of resources/time and funding - Weak linkages between researchers and end users - Lack of enabling institutional policies Less important: - Concerns about stealing and reuse of outputs - Lack of skills/access to communication methods - Poor IT infrastructure Source: CIARD Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
  • 17. ROUTES PREFERED for communication of research outputs Stronger preference Traditional routes - Scholarly publishing, conferences and seminars (3/4) - Training materials (1/2), practical demonstr. (1/3) Weaker preference Broadcast/Mass media - Newspapers (~8%), radio/TV (~15%), promo.mat. © FAO (~29%) Modern methods (Internet enabled) -Social media (~18%), repository/web (~29%) Source: CIARD Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
  • 18. SUPPORT MECHANISMS for communicating research outputs effectively Strong demand for support and training - Web based social media - Participatory research methods & communications skills (e.g. audio/video) © FAO Source: CIARD Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
  • 19. RESEARCH OUTPUTS PRODUCED Traditional print-based formats still predominate... but digital ones are now penetrating (20-35%) Most outputs are communicated through openly accessible, no-cost routes. Source: CIARD Global Survey for Researchers. 2011
  • 20. THE WAY FORWARD Making research outputs openly available often relies on individuals. Individuals’ behaviours can be influenced by institutional factors/barriers. Relevant strategic policy frameworks are required to change institutional/ individual behaviours.
  • 21. THE WAY FORWARD These findings can be considered by senior managers to review their organizational policies.
  • 22. Coherence in Information for Agricultural Research for Development A global movement that promotes and sustain the openness of agricultural knowledge to all.
  • 23. The Movement Founding Partners More than 150 other organizations participating… www.ciard.net
  • 24. CIARD support for overcoming the Challenges in Research Communication Our institution has no policy on We don’t have time to communicating adapt our results into the its outputs what extensionists want We have no systems Other scientists will and tools for Internet publish our results if we dissemination share them There are no staff with the skills in digital technologies www.ciard.net
  • 25. Opening up Research Outputs and Knowledge in Agriculture: Benefits and Challenges Regional Expert Consultation on Opening Access to Agricultural Information in Africa Presented by Franz Martin Knowledge and Capacity for Development www.ciard.net information@ciard.net

Editor's Notes

  1. When you say ‘outputs’ do you mean the technology, the know-how of ag innovation, i.e. knowledge on ag innov? Suggest “ Rapid agricultural innovation is knowledge-intensive and depends on access to information and knowledge” “ Most public domain agricultural information and knowledge not yet widely accessible” seems to fit better in the challenges slide 4
  2. Introducing the issue of lack of access to the outputs of African agricultural research
  3. Noting in a positive context that output of traditional scientific publications from African scientists has been rising over the last decade in all parts of the continent. Note: This covers all subjects not just agriculture.
  4. Graphical representation of how African scientists are collaborating together – as reflected by co-authoring of scientific papers together. Shows language barriers (Anglo:Franco) and regional barriers to collaboration Note: This covers all subjects not just agriculture.
  5. Graphic representation of the amount of web-based information/content across continents/regions. Note: This covers all subjects not just agriculture.
  6. Under the Ghana Agricultural Information Network System (GAINS), five national organizations are making their full text research outputs accessible in digital format, and have had varying degrees of success so far.
  7. This slide shows how three agricultural research centres are struggling with making their research outputs truly accessible in three generic areas, starting with % accessibility of Bibliographic References, moving to % accessibility of Full Text, and lastly % accessibility through international search engines/indexes. It can be noted that these issues affect international centres just as much as they affect national ones. Note: The various segments of the diagram represent different indicators of accessibility within each of the three general categories – the details have been left out to simplify the diagrams.
  8. Institutional/organizational behaviour can be changed by the development of relevant strategic and policy frameworks. In many cases individual behaviour will not be changed unless there are policy requirements which influence the individual.
  9. CIARD aims to influence and provide support at both the level of the organization and of the individual. The movement is a collective commitment to promote and sustain the openness of agricultural knowledge for all.   CIARD aims to provide guidance and support to, and through this to change the behaviour of, both individuals and institutions. Through institutional change will come also enhanced individual change and, in the case of the CIARD initiative, increased and pervasive openness of research outputs. There is already much ‘good practices’ in institutions/organizations around the world, but a great deal more needs to be catalysed.