SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
Download to read offline
AJPH LETTERS AND RESPONSES
THE FIRST EBOLA SURVIVOR TO
DELIVER A FULL-TERM BABY IN
THE UNITED STATES
In response to the AJPH’s February 2016
issue’s, “International Health Regulations,
Ebola, and Emerging Infectious Diseases in
Latin America and the Caribbean,” we sup-
port the call of importance to West Africa
Ebola Virus Disease’s (EVD) stigma percep-
tion as an international public health con-
cern.1
We report on an Ebola survivor who
successfully delivered a full-term baby at one
of our facilities, Greater El Monte Com-
munity Hospital (GEMCH), in Los Angeles,
California. This incident presented the dif-
ficulties of maintaining long-term follow-ups
including delivery, surgery, and other health
events on EVD survivors as a public health
challenge.
On November 2015, GEMCH treated
a pregnant EVD survivor identified as a
29-year old female physician from Lagos,
Nigeria. She contracted the disease while
treating the first EVD case in Nigeria in July
2014.2
The patient became pregnant in
Nigeria six months after her EVD recovery.
She requested to deliver her baby at GEMCH
by one of the hospital’s obstetrician team she
had been aware of in Nigeria. The mother
successfully gave birth to a nine pound and 1
ounce baby.
GEMCH worked collaboratively with the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
(CDC) and the Los Angeles County De-
partment of Public Health (LACDPH)
throughout the patient’s delivery procedure
(Figure 1). Upon delivery, CDC and
LACDPH examined the patient’s blood,
cord-blood, oral and vaginal swabs, breast
milk, first meconium, placenta specimen, and
amniotic fluid. All results returned negative
for EVD. This became the first documented
case in the United States where an EVD
survivor gave birth to a full-term EVD-free
baby.
The health care stigma of EVD has led us to
two critical issues for public health awareness.
First, hospitals in the Southern California
region were unwilling to accept the patient
because of her EVD history. The Centers
for Disease Control and Prevention and the
Los Angeles County Department of Public
Health initially requested to perform the
delivery at a tertiary hospital; however, no
hospital accepted. Second, GEMCH em-
ployees’ fear and reluctance to treat the
patient became an obstacle. Through the
partnership with the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention and Los Angeles
County Department of Public Health, staff
was educated about transmission and in-
fection control of EVD prior to delivery.
As health care providers, it is our re-
sponsibility to advocate for our patients rather
than to decline treatment because of health
stigma and discrimination.3
This case should
raise awareness that EVD survivors should be
equally accepted and treated at all health
facilities.
Wen-Ta Chiu, MD, DrPH
Stanley Toy Jr, MD
Jonathan Wu, MD, PhD
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Wen-Ta Chiu is with the College of Public Health, Taipei
Medical University, Taipei, Taiwan. Stanley Toy Jr is with
the Department of Emergency Medicine and Administration,
Greater El Monte Community Hospital, South El Monte,
CA. Jonathan Wu is with the Department of Family
Medicine, Administration, and Quality Control, AHMC
Healthcare Inc., Alhambra, CA.
Correspondence should be sent to Wen-Ta Chiu, CEO and
Chair Professor, AHMC Healthcare Inc., 500 E. Main Street,
Alhambra, CA 91801 (e-mail: wenta.chiu@ahmchealth.com).
Reprints can be ordered at http://www.ajph.org by clicking the
“Reprints” link.
This letter was accepted February 27, 2016.
doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2016.303170
CONTRIBUTORS
All authors contributed equally to this letter.
REFERENCES
1. Espinal M, Aldighieri S, St. John R, Becerra-Posada F,
Etienne C. International health regulations, Ebola, and
emerging infectious diseases in Latin America and the
Caribbean. Am J Public Health. 2016;106(2):279–282.
2. Igonoh A. Your blood tested positive for Ebola. I am
sorry. November 12, 2014. Available at: https://www.
gatesnotes.com/Health/Surviving-Ebola-Dr-Ada-
Igonoh. Accessed March 11, 2016.
3. Faherty LJ, Doubeni CA. Unintended consequences of
screening for Ebola. Am J Public Health. 2015;105(9):
1738–1739.
EDITOR’S NOTE
The authors of “International Health Reg-
ulations, Ebola, and Emerging Infectious
Diseases in Latin American and the Carib-
bean” were invited to provide a response,
and declined the invitation.
Letters to the editor referring to
a recent AJPH article are encouraged up
to 3 months after the article’s
appearance. By submitting a letter to the
editor, the author gives permission for
its publication in AJPH. Letters should
not duplicate material being published
or submitted elsewhere. The editors
reserve the right to edit and abridge
letters and to publish responses.
Text is limited to 400 words and 7
references. Submit online at www.
editorialmanager.com/ajph. Queries
should be addressed to the Editor-in-
Chief, Alfredo Morabia, MD, PhD, at
editorajph@qc.cuny.edu.
◢e4 Letters and Responses Chiu et al. AJPH June 2016, Vol 106, No. 6
Note. Printed with permission.
FIGURE 1—Letter from Thomas Frieden, Director of the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention
AJPH LETTERS AND RESPONSES
June 2016, Vol 106, No. 6 AJPH Chiu et al. Letters and Responses e5

More Related Content

What's hot

RX Homecare & Hospice newsletter
RX Homecare & Hospice newsletterRX Homecare & Hospice newsletter
RX Homecare & Hospice newsletterKristine Woolley
 
HSC_5320_HIV Poster_Berni_Krull_Vaughan
HSC_5320_HIV Poster_Berni_Krull_VaughanHSC_5320_HIV Poster_Berni_Krull_Vaughan
HSC_5320_HIV Poster_Berni_Krull_VaughanKristina Krull
 
The Prevalence and Coverage of Serious Health Risks in Popular Women's Magazines
The Prevalence and Coverage of Serious Health Risks in Popular Women's MagazinesThe Prevalence and Coverage of Serious Health Risks in Popular Women's Magazines
The Prevalence and Coverage of Serious Health Risks in Popular Women's MagazinesShanna Kurpe
 
Population disparities in health & health care
Population disparities in health & health carePopulation disparities in health & health care
Population disparities in health & health caregueste165460
 
Nutrition and Hydration in the Hospice Patient
Nutrition and Hydration in the Hospice PatientNutrition and Hydration in the Hospice Patient
Nutrition and Hydration in the Hospice PatientVITAS Healthcare
 
American with Ebola Now in Critical Condition
American with Ebola Now in Critical ConditionAmerican with Ebola Now in Critical Condition
American with Ebola Now in Critical Conditionfortunatequilt157
 
Chinese and Vietnamese Perceptions of Cervical Cancer and Medical Research 10...
Chinese and Vietnamese Perceptions of Cervical Cancer and Medical Research 10...Chinese and Vietnamese Perceptions of Cervical Cancer and Medical Research 10...
Chinese and Vietnamese Perceptions of Cervical Cancer and Medical Research 10...Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics
 
Antonia coello novello mb
Antonia coello novello mbAntonia coello novello mb
Antonia coello novello mbBilly Anderson
 

What's hot (17)

National Kidney Foundation
National Kidney FoundationNational Kidney Foundation
National Kidney Foundation
 
Food Allergy Trends and Epinephrine Autoinjector Presence in Summer Camps by ...
Food Allergy Trends and Epinephrine Autoinjector Presence in Summer Camps by ...Food Allergy Trends and Epinephrine Autoinjector Presence in Summer Camps by ...
Food Allergy Trends and Epinephrine Autoinjector Presence in Summer Camps by ...
 
RX Homecare & Hospice newsletter
RX Homecare & Hospice newsletterRX Homecare & Hospice newsletter
RX Homecare & Hospice newsletter
 
HSC_5320_HIV Poster_Berni_Krull_Vaughan
HSC_5320_HIV Poster_Berni_Krull_VaughanHSC_5320_HIV Poster_Berni_Krull_Vaughan
HSC_5320_HIV Poster_Berni_Krull_Vaughan
 
Ebola, ethical issues
Ebola, ethical issuesEbola, ethical issues
Ebola, ethical issues
 
Homeless solution
Homeless solutionHomeless solution
Homeless solution
 
The Prevalence and Coverage of Serious Health Risks in Popular Women's Magazines
The Prevalence and Coverage of Serious Health Risks in Popular Women's MagazinesThe Prevalence and Coverage of Serious Health Risks in Popular Women's Magazines
The Prevalence and Coverage of Serious Health Risks in Popular Women's Magazines
 
Thesisss.docx
Thesisss.docxThesisss.docx
Thesisss.docx
 
Population disparities in health & health care
Population disparities in health & health carePopulation disparities in health & health care
Population disparities in health & health care
 
Nutrition and Hydration in the Hospice Patient
Nutrition and Hydration in the Hospice PatientNutrition and Hydration in the Hospice Patient
Nutrition and Hydration in the Hospice Patient
 
American with Ebola Now in Critical Condition
American with Ebola Now in Critical ConditionAmerican with Ebola Now in Critical Condition
American with Ebola Now in Critical Condition
 
KEN_Momentum_Spring_15
KEN_Momentum_Spring_15KEN_Momentum_Spring_15
KEN_Momentum_Spring_15
 
Chinese and Vietnamese Perceptions of Cervical Cancer and Medical Research 10...
Chinese and Vietnamese Perceptions of Cervical Cancer and Medical Research 10...Chinese and Vietnamese Perceptions of Cervical Cancer and Medical Research 10...
Chinese and Vietnamese Perceptions of Cervical Cancer and Medical Research 10...
 
Dx y tx de hepatitis aguda en el
Dx y tx de hepatitis aguda en elDx y tx de hepatitis aguda en el
Dx y tx de hepatitis aguda en el
 
Antonia coello novello mb
Antonia coello novello mbAntonia coello novello mb
Antonia coello novello mb
 
2016 Ottawa County Department of Public Health Annual Report
2016 Ottawa County Department of Public Health Annual Report2016 Ottawa County Department of Public Health Annual Report
2016 Ottawa County Department of Public Health Annual Report
 
De sepidemiology
De sepidemiologyDe sepidemiology
De sepidemiology
 

Similar to 1st Ebola Survivor to Deliver a Full -Term Baby in US - AJPH

J Infect Dis.-2016-Cancedda-infdis-jiw345
J Infect Dis.-2016-Cancedda-infdis-jiw345J Infect Dis.-2016-Cancedda-infdis-jiw345
J Infect Dis.-2016-Cancedda-infdis-jiw345Gabriel Warren Schlough
 
Public Health Response to Ebola Statement of Dr. Frieden
Public Health Response to Ebola Statement of Dr. FriedenPublic Health Response to Ebola Statement of Dr. Frieden
Public Health Response to Ebola Statement of Dr. FriedenDawn Dawson
 
Presentation on managment of ebola virus by MWEBAZA VICTOR.pptx
Presentation on managment of ebola virus by MWEBAZA VICTOR.pptxPresentation on managment of ebola virus by MWEBAZA VICTOR.pptx
Presentation on managment of ebola virus by MWEBAZA VICTOR.pptxDr. MWEBAZA VICTOR
 
Newsletter Sept 2014
Newsletter Sept 2014Newsletter Sept 2014
Newsletter Sept 2014Jodi Szabo
 
TU Times 2015 ..publication..
TU Times 2015 ..publication..TU Times 2015 ..publication..
TU Times 2015 ..publication..Solo Otto Gaye
 
Drug Resistant Tuberculosis. A Survival Guide For Clinicians. Ntc.08
Drug Resistant Tuberculosis. A Survival Guide For Clinicians. Ntc.08Drug Resistant Tuberculosis. A Survival Guide For Clinicians. Ntc.08
Drug Resistant Tuberculosis. A Survival Guide For Clinicians. Ntc.08Raul Rojas
 
Heaptitis a respuesta
Heaptitis a respuestaHeaptitis a respuesta
Heaptitis a respuestaBeatles180681
 
Submission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docx
Submission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docxSubmission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docx
Submission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docxdavid4611
 
Submission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docx
Submission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docxSubmission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docx
Submission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docxdeanmtaylor1545
 
Evidence-Based Care of Your Immigrant & Refugee Patients
Evidence-Based Care of Your Immigrant & Refugee PatientsEvidence-Based Care of Your Immigrant & Refugee Patients
Evidence-Based Care of Your Immigrant & Refugee Patientsnatalielovesey
 
Economic And Social Consequences Of Diabetes
Economic And Social Consequences Of DiabetesEconomic And Social Consequences Of Diabetes
Economic And Social Consequences Of DiabetesChristina Berger
 
Published articles by Geraldine Carroll
Published articles by Geraldine CarrollPublished articles by Geraldine Carroll
Published articles by Geraldine CarrollGeraldine Carroll
 
Breast Cancer and Palliative Care Issues Essay Paper.docx
Breast Cancer and Palliative Care Issues Essay Paper.docxBreast Cancer and Palliative Care Issues Essay Paper.docx
Breast Cancer and Palliative Care Issues Essay Paper.docx4934bk
 
viewpoints_red_gray_v2
viewpoints_red_gray_v2viewpoints_red_gray_v2
viewpoints_red_gray_v2Patty Baraibar
 

Similar to 1st Ebola Survivor to Deliver a Full -Term Baby in US - AJPH (20)

J Infect Dis.-2016-Cancedda-infdis-jiw345
J Infect Dis.-2016-Cancedda-infdis-jiw345J Infect Dis.-2016-Cancedda-infdis-jiw345
J Infect Dis.-2016-Cancedda-infdis-jiw345
 
HIV Nursing
HIV NursingHIV Nursing
HIV Nursing
 
Youth can help change the face of People Living With HIV charles wasike- efl
Youth can help change the face of People Living With HIV  charles wasike- eflYouth can help change the face of People Living With HIV  charles wasike- efl
Youth can help change the face of People Living With HIV charles wasike- efl
 
Public Health Response to Ebola Statement of Dr. Frieden
Public Health Response to Ebola Statement of Dr. FriedenPublic Health Response to Ebola Statement of Dr. Frieden
Public Health Response to Ebola Statement of Dr. Frieden
 
Presentation on managment of ebola virus by MWEBAZA VICTOR.pptx
Presentation on managment of ebola virus by MWEBAZA VICTOR.pptxPresentation on managment of ebola virus by MWEBAZA VICTOR.pptx
Presentation on managment of ebola virus by MWEBAZA VICTOR.pptx
 
Newsletter Sept 2014
Newsletter Sept 2014Newsletter Sept 2014
Newsletter Sept 2014
 
TU Times 2015 ..publication..
TU Times 2015 ..publication..TU Times 2015 ..publication..
TU Times 2015 ..publication..
 
Drug Resistant Tuberculosis. A Survival Guide For Clinicians. Ntc.08
Drug Resistant Tuberculosis. A Survival Guide For Clinicians. Ntc.08Drug Resistant Tuberculosis. A Survival Guide For Clinicians. Ntc.08
Drug Resistant Tuberculosis. A Survival Guide For Clinicians. Ntc.08
 
Finalposter_Elizabeth_Seroczynski
Finalposter_Elizabeth_SeroczynskiFinalposter_Elizabeth_Seroczynski
Finalposter_Elizabeth_Seroczynski
 
News4U
News4UNews4U
News4U
 
july2005
july2005july2005
july2005
 
Heaptitis a respuesta
Heaptitis a respuestaHeaptitis a respuesta
Heaptitis a respuesta
 
Submission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docx
Submission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docxSubmission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docx
Submission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docx
 
Submission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docx
Submission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docxSubmission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docx
Submission Ide 9e61a295-6866-4394-8151-63a36d3d2f9567 SI.docx
 
Evidence-Based Care of Your Immigrant & Refugee Patients
Evidence-Based Care of Your Immigrant & Refugee PatientsEvidence-Based Care of Your Immigrant & Refugee Patients
Evidence-Based Care of Your Immigrant & Refugee Patients
 
Economic And Social Consequences Of Diabetes
Economic And Social Consequences Of DiabetesEconomic And Social Consequences Of Diabetes
Economic And Social Consequences Of Diabetes
 
Published articles by Geraldine Carroll
Published articles by Geraldine CarrollPublished articles by Geraldine Carroll
Published articles by Geraldine Carroll
 
Breast Cancer and Palliative Care Issues Essay Paper.docx
Breast Cancer and Palliative Care Issues Essay Paper.docxBreast Cancer and Palliative Care Issues Essay Paper.docx
Breast Cancer and Palliative Care Issues Essay Paper.docx
 
viewpoints_red_gray_v2
viewpoints_red_gray_v2viewpoints_red_gray_v2
viewpoints_red_gray_v2
 
Ampul Spring 2016 Final
Ampul Spring 2016 FinalAmpul Spring 2016 Final
Ampul Spring 2016 Final
 

1st Ebola Survivor to Deliver a Full -Term Baby in US - AJPH

  • 1. AJPH LETTERS AND RESPONSES THE FIRST EBOLA SURVIVOR TO DELIVER A FULL-TERM BABY IN THE UNITED STATES In response to the AJPH’s February 2016 issue’s, “International Health Regulations, Ebola, and Emerging Infectious Diseases in Latin America and the Caribbean,” we sup- port the call of importance to West Africa Ebola Virus Disease’s (EVD) stigma percep- tion as an international public health con- cern.1 We report on an Ebola survivor who successfully delivered a full-term baby at one of our facilities, Greater El Monte Com- munity Hospital (GEMCH), in Los Angeles, California. This incident presented the dif- ficulties of maintaining long-term follow-ups including delivery, surgery, and other health events on EVD survivors as a public health challenge. On November 2015, GEMCH treated a pregnant EVD survivor identified as a 29-year old female physician from Lagos, Nigeria. She contracted the disease while treating the first EVD case in Nigeria in July 2014.2 The patient became pregnant in Nigeria six months after her EVD recovery. She requested to deliver her baby at GEMCH by one of the hospital’s obstetrician team she had been aware of in Nigeria. The mother successfully gave birth to a nine pound and 1 ounce baby. GEMCH worked collaboratively with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the Los Angeles County De- partment of Public Health (LACDPH) throughout the patient’s delivery procedure (Figure 1). Upon delivery, CDC and LACDPH examined the patient’s blood, cord-blood, oral and vaginal swabs, breast milk, first meconium, placenta specimen, and amniotic fluid. All results returned negative for EVD. This became the first documented case in the United States where an EVD survivor gave birth to a full-term EVD-free baby. The health care stigma of EVD has led us to two critical issues for public health awareness. First, hospitals in the Southern California region were unwilling to accept the patient because of her EVD history. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Los Angeles County Department of Public Health initially requested to perform the delivery at a tertiary hospital; however, no hospital accepted. Second, GEMCH em- ployees’ fear and reluctance to treat the patient became an obstacle. Through the partnership with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and Los Angeles County Department of Public Health, staff was educated about transmission and in- fection control of EVD prior to delivery. As health care providers, it is our re- sponsibility to advocate for our patients rather than to decline treatment because of health stigma and discrimination.3 This case should raise awareness that EVD survivors should be equally accepted and treated at all health facilities. Wen-Ta Chiu, MD, DrPH Stanley Toy Jr, MD Jonathan Wu, MD, PhD ABOUT THE AUTHORS Wen-Ta Chiu is with the College of Public Health, Taipei Medical University, Taipei, Taiwan. Stanley Toy Jr is with the Department of Emergency Medicine and Administration, Greater El Monte Community Hospital, South El Monte, CA. Jonathan Wu is with the Department of Family Medicine, Administration, and Quality Control, AHMC Healthcare Inc., Alhambra, CA. Correspondence should be sent to Wen-Ta Chiu, CEO and Chair Professor, AHMC Healthcare Inc., 500 E. Main Street, Alhambra, CA 91801 (e-mail: wenta.chiu@ahmchealth.com). Reprints can be ordered at http://www.ajph.org by clicking the “Reprints” link. This letter was accepted February 27, 2016. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2016.303170 CONTRIBUTORS All authors contributed equally to this letter. REFERENCES 1. Espinal M, Aldighieri S, St. John R, Becerra-Posada F, Etienne C. International health regulations, Ebola, and emerging infectious diseases in Latin America and the Caribbean. Am J Public Health. 2016;106(2):279–282. 2. Igonoh A. Your blood tested positive for Ebola. I am sorry. November 12, 2014. Available at: https://www. gatesnotes.com/Health/Surviving-Ebola-Dr-Ada- Igonoh. Accessed March 11, 2016. 3. Faherty LJ, Doubeni CA. Unintended consequences of screening for Ebola. Am J Public Health. 2015;105(9): 1738–1739. EDITOR’S NOTE The authors of “International Health Reg- ulations, Ebola, and Emerging Infectious Diseases in Latin American and the Carib- bean” were invited to provide a response, and declined the invitation. Letters to the editor referring to a recent AJPH article are encouraged up to 3 months after the article’s appearance. By submitting a letter to the editor, the author gives permission for its publication in AJPH. Letters should not duplicate material being published or submitted elsewhere. The editors reserve the right to edit and abridge letters and to publish responses. Text is limited to 400 words and 7 references. Submit online at www. editorialmanager.com/ajph. Queries should be addressed to the Editor-in- Chief, Alfredo Morabia, MD, PhD, at editorajph@qc.cuny.edu. ◢e4 Letters and Responses Chiu et al. AJPH June 2016, Vol 106, No. 6
  • 2. Note. Printed with permission. FIGURE 1—Letter from Thomas Frieden, Director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention AJPH LETTERS AND RESPONSES June 2016, Vol 106, No. 6 AJPH Chiu et al. Letters and Responses e5