SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Evidence from Swiss Public Hospitals
Stefan Meyer
Department of Health Economics, University of Basel
13 September 2013
Swiss Health Economic Workshop, Lucerne
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Outline
1 Background
2 Model and Data
3 Results
4 Conclusion
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Inefficiencies in Healthcare
Swiss healthcare expenditure has risen by 46% over the last
decade, reaching CHF 62.5 billion (10.9% of GDP) in 2010
(BFS, 2010).
A significant part of healthcare costs arise due to inefficient
allocation of resources and inefficient production of goods
and services (OECD, 2010).
A recent US study by the WHO (2010) estimates total costs
of inefficiencies to be in a range of $ 600 - 850 billion per year
(≈ 30% of total health spending).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Inefficiencies in Healthcare
Swiss healthcare expenditure has risen by 46% over the last
decade, reaching CHF 62.5 billion (10.9% of GDP) in 2010
(BFS, 2010).
A significant part of healthcare costs arise due to inefficient
allocation of resources and inefficient production of goods
and services (OECD, 2010).
A recent US study by the WHO (2010) estimates total costs
of inefficiencies to be in a range of $ 600 - 850 billion per year
(≈ 30% of total health spending).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Inefficiencies in Healthcare
Swiss healthcare expenditure has risen by 46% over the last
decade, reaching CHF 62.5 billion (10.9% of GDP) in 2010
(BFS, 2010).
A significant part of healthcare costs arise due to inefficient
allocation of resources and inefficient production of goods
and services (OECD, 2010).
A recent US study by the WHO (2010) estimates total costs
of inefficiencies to be in a range of $ 600 - 850 billion per year
(≈ 30% of total health spending).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Inefficiency and Payment Schemes
Well-known factors like income, technological progress, and
demography have contributed to the continuing upward
trend.
Still, as these forces are hardly controllable, policies aimed at
reducing inefficiencies have become essential.
Prospective reimbursement schemes can serve as controlling
instruments for lowering cost inefficiency.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Inefficiency and Payment Schemes
Well-known factors like income, technological progress, and
demography have contributed to the continuing upward
trend.
Still, as these forces are hardly controllable, policies aimed at
reducing inefficiencies have become essential.
Prospective reimbursement schemes can serve as controlling
instruments for lowering cost inefficiency.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Inefficiency and Payment Schemes
Well-known factors like income, technological progress, and
demography have contributed to the continuing upward
trend.
Still, as these forces are hardly controllable, policies aimed at
reducing inefficiencies have become essential.
Prospective reimbursement schemes can serve as controlling
instruments for lowering cost inefficiency.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Inpatient Sector in Switzerland I
A substantial part of healthcare resources is allocated to the
inpatient sector, amounting to CHF 21.7 billion (34.9%) in
2009 (OECD, 2012).
Small efficiency gains in this sector may lower total
healthcare costs considerably.
Saved resources can be reallocated to socially beneficial
areas of healthcare.
The average length of stay (ALOS) in Swiss hospitals
remains high  room for improving cost efficiency.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Inpatient Sector in Switzerland I
A substantial part of healthcare resources is allocated to the
inpatient sector, amounting to CHF 21.7 billion (34.9%) in
2009 (OECD, 2012).
Small efficiency gains in this sector may lower total
healthcare costs considerably.
Saved resources can be reallocated to socially beneficial
areas of healthcare.
The average length of stay (ALOS) in Swiss hospitals
remains high  room for improving cost efficiency.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Inpatient Sector in Switzerland I
A substantial part of healthcare resources is allocated to the
inpatient sector, amounting to CHF 21.7 billion (34.9%) in
2009 (OECD, 2012).
Small efficiency gains in this sector may lower total
healthcare costs considerably.
Saved resources can be reallocated to socially beneficial
areas of healthcare.
The average length of stay (ALOS) in Swiss hospitals
remains high  room for improving cost efficiency.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Inpatient Sector in Switzerland I
A substantial part of healthcare resources is allocated to the
inpatient sector, amounting to CHF 21.7 billion (34.9%) in
2009 (OECD, 2012).
Small efficiency gains in this sector may lower total
healthcare costs considerably.
Saved resources can be reallocated to socially beneficial
areas of healthcare.
The average length of stay (ALOS) in Swiss hospitals
remains high  room for improving cost efficiency.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Length of Stay in Selected OECD Countries (2009)
Source: OECD, 2009 (Greece: 2007 Data)
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Inpatient Sector in Switzerland II
Until 2011: Considerable differences in inpatient
reimbursement among hospitals and local healthcare areas
(cantons)
As of 2012: Implementation of cased-based payment
(SwissDRGs) in public and private hospitals all over
Switzerland
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
4 Payment Systems in Question I
Revenue per case (Ri ) under 4 payment schemes:
per diem: flat payment per patient day
Rdiem
i = pt · ti
APDRG: flat payment per case (according to a national DRG
catalogue)
RDRG
i = CW k · ¯P
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
4 Payment Systems in Question II
DCB: flat payment per case (according to the hospital
department involved)
RDCB
i = Bk
PLT (hybrid): flat payment per case + flat payment per
patient day (both depending on the hospital department
involved)
RPLT
i = Bk + pk
t · ti
PLT: Prozess-Leistungs-Tarifierung, DCB: Department case-based payments (Abteilungspauschalen). We treat the
patient pathway system (MIPP, Cantonal Hospital of Aarau) as DCB, since the two systems do not differ in the
way they offer financial incentives to the hospital.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Payment Schemes in Swiss Cantons (2009)
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Research Outline I
I aim to...
estimate cost (in)efficiency (CE) scores for Swiss public
hospitals by means of Stochastic Frontier Analysis (SFA),
show that flat payment schemes decrease inefficiency (c.p.).
analyse the consequences of heteroscedasticity (to be
discussed later on).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Research Outline I
I aim to...
estimate cost (in)efficiency (CE) scores for Swiss public
hospitals by means of Stochastic Frontier Analysis (SFA),
show that flat payment schemes decrease inefficiency (c.p.).
analyse the consequences of heteroscedasticity (to be
discussed later on).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Research Outline I
I aim to...
estimate cost (in)efficiency (CE) scores for Swiss public
hospitals by means of Stochastic Frontier Analysis (SFA),
show that flat payment schemes decrease inefficiency (c.p.).
analyse the consequences of heteroscedasticity (to be
discussed later on).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Research Outline II
I take advantage of the fact that...
until 2011, health insurers employed 4 different inpatient
payment schemes in 26 cantons.
the problem of unobserved heterogeneity across observation
areas is alleviated, as we only focus on one country.
the public sector (cantons) reimburses hospitals on the same
basis (object financing = global budget, deficit guarantee).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Research Outline II
I take advantage of the fact that...
until 2011, health insurers employed 4 different inpatient
payment schemes in 26 cantons.
the problem of unobserved heterogeneity across observation
areas is alleviated, as we only focus on one country.
the public sector (cantons) reimburses hospitals on the same
basis (object financing = global budget, deficit guarantee).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Research Outline II
I take advantage of the fact that...
until 2011, health insurers employed 4 different inpatient
payment schemes in 26 cantons.
the problem of unobserved heterogeneity across observation
areas is alleviated, as we only focus on one country.
the public sector (cantons) reimburses hospitals on the same
basis (object financing = global budget, deficit guarantee).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Econometric Model: Cobb Douglas Cost Frontier
ln TCit = α +
m
βm ln ym
it +
n
βn ln pn
it +
k
βksk
it + vit + uit
εit
TCit Total costs of hospital i at time t
ym
it Outputs
pn
it Factor prices
sk
it Hospital characteristics
vit Two-sided random noise component
uit Non-negative inefficiency component
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Econometric Model: Inefficiency Term
Battese and Coelli (1995) propose a model in which
inefficiency effects are assumed to be a function of
firm-specific variables and time:
uit = zitδ + wit, uit ∼ N+(zitδ, σ2
u)
zit
Vector of hospital-specific and regional variables (payment
scheme and other variables)
wit Random noise component (truncated normal distributed)
δ Vector of parameters to be estimated
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Distribution of the Inefficiency Term
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Data
BFS data on 122 public and publicly-financed hospitals in
Switzerland
Period: 2004 - 2009 (T = 6)
Information on hospital category, teaching, inputs, inpatient
and outpatient outputs, and costs
5 observations per hospital on average, total sample size of
606 (inclusion criterion: ≥ 2 obs., ≥750 inpatient days)
Data covers a total of 4.9 million cases (≈ 58% of all
hospital cases between 2004 and 2009)
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Despriptive Statistics I (N = 606)
Variable Description Mean SD
Cost frontier variables
TC Total costs (k CHF) 130 010.4 195 921.7
CASES Number of CMI-adjusted discharges 8 283.1 10 109.3
OUTP Revenue from outpatients (k CHF) 24 746.3 37 935.3
PL Price of labour (k CHF) 100.1 14.4
PK Price of capital (k CHF) 170.6 76.9
SERVICE Number of hospital services 36.2 18.0
INTERN Number of advanced training
categories*
20.5 27.9
*FMH Weiterbildungskategorien
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Despriptive Statistics II (N = 606)
Variable Description Mean SD
Inefficiency variables
APDRG APDRG-based payment system* 0.27
PLT Hybrid payment system* 0.54
DCB Department level case-based
system*
0.06
OCC Bed occupancy rate 0.88 0.10
BEDS Acute care beds per 1,000 residents 2.95 0.70
PHYS GPs  specialists per 1,000 residents 2.00 0.57
MCARE Managed Care contracts / total
number of MHI contracts
0.17 0.11
POP Population density (Residents / sq
km)
536.10 1 062.30
*Dummy variable
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Heteroscedasticity
SFA are likely to suffer from severe heteroscedasticity
(HEC), especially if the hospitals are of different size.
Coefficients are biased in SFA models if HEC is overlooked
(frontier is changed when dispersion increases; s. Caudill et
al., 1995).
Heteroscedastic uit: Large hospitals have more“under their
control”, efficiency gets more important with size  large
hospitals have much more in common than their small
counterparts
Heteroscedastic vit: Greater impact of random shocks on
small units (“Law of large numbers”)
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Heteroscedasticity
SFA are likely to suffer from severe heteroscedasticity
(HEC), especially if the hospitals are of different size.
Coefficients are biased in SFA models if HEC is overlooked
(frontier is changed when dispersion increases; s. Caudill et
al., 1995).
Heteroscedastic uit: Large hospitals have more“under their
control”, efficiency gets more important with size  large
hospitals have much more in common than their small
counterparts
Heteroscedastic vit: Greater impact of random shocks on
small units (“Law of large numbers”)
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Heteroscedasticity
SFA are likely to suffer from severe heteroscedasticity
(HEC), especially if the hospitals are of different size.
Coefficients are biased in SFA models if HEC is overlooked
(frontier is changed when dispersion increases; s. Caudill et
al., 1995).
Heteroscedastic uit: Large hospitals have more“under their
control”, efficiency gets more important with size  large
hospitals have much more in common than their small
counterparts
Heteroscedastic vit: Greater impact of random shocks on
small units (“Law of large numbers”)
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Specifying HEC
Three different specifications:
(1) No HEC
(2) HEC in uit
(3) HEC in both uit and vit
Assumption: σ2
uit = exp(CASESitη) and
σ2
vit = exp(CASESitφ), where η and φ are parameters to be
estimated.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
HEC: Findings
1 Both σ2
uit and σ2
vit are negatively correlated with hospital size
(p  0.01), indicating that variation of uit and vit is more
distinct among smaller institutions.
2 Coefficients (and standard errors) slightly change when HEC
is taken into acount.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
SFA Results
ln TC σ2
u/ σ2
v σ2
ui / σ2
v σ2
ui / σ2
vi
ln CASES 0.830*** (0.015) 0.882*** (0.013) 0.864*** (0.014)
ln OUTP 0.117*** (0.014) 0.098*** (0.010) 0.102*** (0.012)
ln PL 0.026 (0.072) 0.057 (0.037) 0.000 (0.039)
ln PK 0.271*** (0.027) 0.249*** (0.016) 0.258*** (0.020)
ln SERVICE 0.027* (0.014) 0.001* (0.000) 0.001* (0.000)
ln INTERN 0.029*** (0.007) 0.002*** (0.000) 0.002*** (0.000)
YEAR 0.014*** (0.004) 0.014*** (0.004) 0.007 (0.005)
APDRG =0.407** (0.171) =0.298*** (0.081) =0.289*** (0.072)
PLT =0.136 (0.084) =0.080* (0.043) =0.092** (0.040)
DCB =0.931 (0.810) =0.561** (0.237) =0.593* (0.338)
OCC =1.754** (0.869) =1.108*** (0.339) =1.239*** (0.359)
BEDS =0.414** (0.180) =0.246*** (0.067) =0.256*** (0.066)
PHYS 0.330** (0.156) 0.103** (0.050) 0.131*** (0.046)
MCARE =0.997 (0.775) =0.396* (0.239) =0.457** (0.229)
POP 0.000 (0.000) 0.000** (0.000) 0.000** (0.000)
YEAR 0.097 (0.067) 0.043** (0.020) 0.058*** (0.018)
Note: N = 606; Cluster robust standard errors are given in parentheses; *p  0.10, **p  0.05, ***p  0.01;
The sign of the efficiency variables are to be read as effects on inefficiency; Both constants not shown
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Main Findings I
Compared to per diem, all three systems are associated with
decreased inefficiency.
This finding is most pronounced among hospitals that apply
flat payment schemes (APDRG, DCB).
High bed density in acute care is associated with enhanced
CE (highly competitive markets  little market / bargaining
power)
Inefficient hospitals are likely found in population-dense
areas with a high penetration of GPs and specialists (
proxy measure of demand; s. Chirikos, 1998).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Main Findings I
Compared to per diem, all three systems are associated with
decreased inefficiency.
This finding is most pronounced among hospitals that apply
flat payment schemes (APDRG, DCB).
High bed density in acute care is associated with enhanced
CE (highly competitive markets  little market / bargaining
power)
Inefficient hospitals are likely found in population-dense
areas with a high penetration of GPs and specialists (
proxy measure of demand; s. Chirikos, 1998).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Main Findings I
Compared to per diem, all three systems are associated with
decreased inefficiency.
This finding is most pronounced among hospitals that apply
flat payment schemes (APDRG, DCB).
High bed density in acute care is associated with enhanced
CE (highly competitive markets  little market / bargaining
power)
Inefficient hospitals are likely found in population-dense
areas with a high penetration of GPs and specialists (
proxy measure of demand; s. Chirikos, 1998).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Main Findings II
As found in an earlier study by Rosko (2004), managed care
penetration is positively correlated with CE (Insurers may
place financial pressure on hospitals when prices are being
negotiated).
Mean cost inefficiency increased significantly from 7.8% in
2004 to 12.3% in 2009.
CE scores only changed marginally when the panel was
almost balanced (from 2006).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Main Findings II
As found in an earlier study by Rosko (2004), managed care
penetration is positively correlated with CE (Insurers may
place financial pressure on hospitals when prices are being
negotiated).
Mean cost inefficiency increased significantly from 7.8% in
2004 to 12.3% in 2009.
CE scores only changed marginally when the panel was
almost balanced (from 2006).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Mean Inefficiency Estimates by Payment Scheme
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Conclusion
Positive correlation of flat payment and CE in Swiss public
hospitals (controlling for hospital characteristics, the market
environment, and time trends).
Findings are in line with the basic economic theory on the
financial incentives of payment schemes (Ellis and McGuire,
1986).
Considerable differences in mean inefficiencies across
hospital categories (maximum gap of about 15% between per
diem and DLCB hospitals in 2009).
In SFA, heteroscedastic error terms (uit and vit) lead to
biased coefficients and standard errors.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Conclusion
Positive correlation of flat payment and CE in Swiss public
hospitals (controlling for hospital characteristics, the market
environment, and time trends).
Findings are in line with the basic economic theory on the
financial incentives of payment schemes (Ellis and McGuire,
1986).
Considerable differences in mean inefficiencies across
hospital categories (maximum gap of about 15% between per
diem and DLCB hospitals in 2009).
In SFA, heteroscedastic error terms (uit and vit) lead to
biased coefficients and standard errors.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Conclusion
Positive correlation of flat payment and CE in Swiss public
hospitals (controlling for hospital characteristics, the market
environment, and time trends).
Findings are in line with the basic economic theory on the
financial incentives of payment schemes (Ellis and McGuire,
1986).
Considerable differences in mean inefficiencies across
hospital categories (maximum gap of about 15% between per
diem and DLCB hospitals in 2009).
In SFA, heteroscedastic error terms (uit and vit) lead to
biased coefficients and standard errors.
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Limitations
I do not account for quality differences among hospitals
(evidence suggests that ignoring them may not be a serious
problem; s. Mutter et al., 2008).
Unobservable differences among cantons  biased
coefficients of the payment scheme variables.
Potential endogeneity in the outputs and the factor prices
as a major drawback in SFA (especially the price proxies may
reflect the hospitals’ choices about the average skill-mix and
the amount and mix of capital; s. Zuckermann et al., 1994).
Small sample of Swiss public hospitals  unclear whether
these findings can be applied to private hospitals as well (or
even other healthcare systems).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Limitations
I do not account for quality differences among hospitals
(evidence suggests that ignoring them may not be a serious
problem; s. Mutter et al., 2008).
Unobservable differences among cantons  biased
coefficients of the payment scheme variables.
Potential endogeneity in the outputs and the factor prices
as a major drawback in SFA (especially the price proxies may
reflect the hospitals’ choices about the average skill-mix and
the amount and mix of capital; s. Zuckermann et al., 1994).
Small sample of Swiss public hospitals  unclear whether
these findings can be applied to private hospitals as well (or
even other healthcare systems).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Limitations
I do not account for quality differences among hospitals
(evidence suggests that ignoring them may not be a serious
problem; s. Mutter et al., 2008).
Unobservable differences among cantons  biased
coefficients of the payment scheme variables.
Potential endogeneity in the outputs and the factor prices
as a major drawback in SFA (especially the price proxies may
reflect the hospitals’ choices about the average skill-mix and
the amount and mix of capital; s. Zuckermann et al., 1994).
Small sample of Swiss public hospitals  unclear whether
these findings can be applied to private hospitals as well (or
even other healthcare systems).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Limitations
I do not account for quality differences among hospitals
(evidence suggests that ignoring them may not be a serious
problem; s. Mutter et al., 2008).
Unobservable differences among cantons  biased
coefficients of the payment scheme variables.
Potential endogeneity in the outputs and the factor prices
as a major drawback in SFA (especially the price proxies may
reflect the hospitals’ choices about the average skill-mix and
the amount and mix of capital; s. Zuckermann et al., 1994).
Small sample of Swiss public hospitals  unclear whether
these findings can be applied to private hospitals as well (or
even other healthcare systems).
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
Background
Model and Data
Results
Conclusion
Thank you!
Many thanks for your attention!
Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency

More Related Content

What's hot

GLOBALIZATION OF HEALTH SYSTEMS ESSAY
GLOBALIZATION OF  HEALTH SYSTEMS ESSAYGLOBALIZATION OF  HEALTH SYSTEMS ESSAY
GLOBALIZATION OF HEALTH SYSTEMS ESSAYNkeonye Judith Izuka
 
Vasco Da Gama Dublin 2015 plenary 1 economic crisis introduction william behan
Vasco Da Gama Dublin 2015 plenary 1 economic crisis introduction william behanVasco Da Gama Dublin 2015 plenary 1 economic crisis introduction william behan
Vasco Da Gama Dublin 2015 plenary 1 economic crisis introduction william behanDrWilliamBehan
 
2 ijmpd feb-2018-3-abu dhabi healthcare system
2 ijmpd feb-2018-3-abu dhabi healthcare system2 ijmpd feb-2018-3-abu dhabi healthcare system
2 ijmpd feb-2018-3-abu dhabi healthcare systemAI Publications
 
Introductory perspectives - Kristina Garuoliene, Lithuania
Introductory perspectives - Kristina Garuoliene, LithuaniaIntroductory perspectives - Kristina Garuoliene, Lithuania
Introductory perspectives - Kristina Garuoliene, LithuaniaOECD Governance
 
Vasco Da Gama 2015 Dublin The Effect of the Economic Crisis on the Irish Heal...
Vasco Da Gama 2015 Dublin The Effect of the Economic Crisis on the Irish Heal...Vasco Da Gama 2015 Dublin The Effect of the Economic Crisis on the Irish Heal...
Vasco Da Gama 2015 Dublin The Effect of the Economic Crisis on the Irish Heal...DrWilliamBehan
 
Dr. Shuli Brammli Greenberg Presentation 2017-10-25
Dr. Shuli Brammli Greenberg Presentation 2017-10-25Dr. Shuli Brammli Greenberg Presentation 2017-10-25
Dr. Shuli Brammli Greenberg Presentation 2017-10-25Etan Diamond
 
The Next Frontier to Support Health Resource Tracking
The Next Frontier to Support Health Resource TrackingThe Next Frontier to Support Health Resource Tracking
The Next Frontier to Support Health Resource TrackingHFG Project
 

What's hot (7)

GLOBALIZATION OF HEALTH SYSTEMS ESSAY
GLOBALIZATION OF  HEALTH SYSTEMS ESSAYGLOBALIZATION OF  HEALTH SYSTEMS ESSAY
GLOBALIZATION OF HEALTH SYSTEMS ESSAY
 
Vasco Da Gama Dublin 2015 plenary 1 economic crisis introduction william behan
Vasco Da Gama Dublin 2015 plenary 1 economic crisis introduction william behanVasco Da Gama Dublin 2015 plenary 1 economic crisis introduction william behan
Vasco Da Gama Dublin 2015 plenary 1 economic crisis introduction william behan
 
2 ijmpd feb-2018-3-abu dhabi healthcare system
2 ijmpd feb-2018-3-abu dhabi healthcare system2 ijmpd feb-2018-3-abu dhabi healthcare system
2 ijmpd feb-2018-3-abu dhabi healthcare system
 
Introductory perspectives - Kristina Garuoliene, Lithuania
Introductory perspectives - Kristina Garuoliene, LithuaniaIntroductory perspectives - Kristina Garuoliene, Lithuania
Introductory perspectives - Kristina Garuoliene, Lithuania
 
Vasco Da Gama 2015 Dublin The Effect of the Economic Crisis on the Irish Heal...
Vasco Da Gama 2015 Dublin The Effect of the Economic Crisis on the Irish Heal...Vasco Da Gama 2015 Dublin The Effect of the Economic Crisis on the Irish Heal...
Vasco Da Gama 2015 Dublin The Effect of the Economic Crisis on the Irish Heal...
 
Dr. Shuli Brammli Greenberg Presentation 2017-10-25
Dr. Shuli Brammli Greenberg Presentation 2017-10-25Dr. Shuli Brammli Greenberg Presentation 2017-10-25
Dr. Shuli Brammli Greenberg Presentation 2017-10-25
 
The Next Frontier to Support Health Resource Tracking
The Next Frontier to Support Health Resource TrackingThe Next Frontier to Support Health Resource Tracking
The Next Frontier to Support Health Resource Tracking
 

Similar to Plenary_Talk_1_Meyer

Spending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
Spending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak RepublicSpending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
Spending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak RepublicOECD Governance
 
The drivers of public health spending: integrating policies and institutions
The drivers of public health spending: integrating policies and institutionsThe drivers of public health spending: integrating policies and institutions
The drivers of public health spending: integrating policies and institutionsOECD Governance
 
Stephen Aldridge -Public sector efficiency in the UK
Stephen Aldridge -Public sector efficiency in the UKStephen Aldridge -Public sector efficiency in the UK
Stephen Aldridge -Public sector efficiency in the UKOECD CFE
 
Sabin SIF country ownership case studies IX.15
Sabin SIF country ownership case studies IX.15Sabin SIF country ownership case studies IX.15
Sabin SIF country ownership case studies IX.15Mike McQuestion
 
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_1_Colombier
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_1_ColombierParallel_Session_1_Talk_1_Colombier
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_1_ColombierCSS-Institute
 
10 04 28_whitepaper_hospital_costs_final
10 04 28_whitepaper_hospital_costs_final10 04 28_whitepaper_hospital_costs_final
10 04 28_whitepaper_hospital_costs_finalDuong Huyen
 
Activity-Based Funding (ABF).pdf
Activity-Based Funding (ABF).pdfActivity-Based Funding (ABF).pdf
Activity-Based Funding (ABF).pdfKhalid Alshrari
 
Session 2 a discussion of mary o'mahony paper in session 2a 25 august
Session 2 a discussion of mary o'mahony paper in session 2a 25 augustSession 2 a discussion of mary o'mahony paper in session 2a 25 august
Session 2 a discussion of mary o'mahony paper in session 2a 25 augustIARIW 2014
 
Mc daid primhe conference 2011
Mc daid primhe conference 2011Mc daid primhe conference 2011
Mc daid primhe conference 2011henkpar
 
Presentacion Del Secretario De Estado En Londr
Presentacion Del Secretario De Estado En LondrPresentacion Del Secretario De Estado En Londr
Presentacion Del Secretario De Estado En Londrricard santamaria
 
Budget for Outcomes - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
Budget for Outcomes - Stefan Kiss, Slovak RepublicBudget for Outcomes - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
Budget for Outcomes - Stefan Kiss, Slovak RepublicOECD Governance
 
Healthcare Costs And Performance In The OECD
Healthcare Costs And Performance In The OECDHealthcare Costs And Performance In The OECD
Healthcare Costs And Performance In The OECDguest112d32
 
Healthcare Costs And Performance in the OECD
Healthcare Costs And Performance in the OECDHealthcare Costs And Performance in the OECD
Healthcare Costs And Performance in the OECDAlex Rascanu
 
Presentation on the results to date of the Federal Partnership for Patients (...
Presentation on the results to date of the Federal Partnership for Patients (...Presentation on the results to date of the Federal Partnership for Patients (...
Presentation on the results to date of the Federal Partnership for Patients (...Noel Eldridge
 
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_5_Tondelli
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_5_TondelliParallel_Session_1_Talk_5_Tondelli
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_5_TondelliCSS-Institute
 

Similar to Plenary_Talk_1_Meyer (20)

Spending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
Spending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak RepublicSpending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
Spending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
 
The drivers of public health spending: integrating policies and institutions
The drivers of public health spending: integrating policies and institutionsThe drivers of public health spending: integrating policies and institutions
The drivers of public health spending: integrating policies and institutions
 
QIPP Costings Report
QIPP Costings ReportQIPP Costings Report
QIPP Costings Report
 
Stephen Aldridge -Public sector efficiency in the UK
Stephen Aldridge -Public sector efficiency in the UKStephen Aldridge -Public sector efficiency in the UK
Stephen Aldridge -Public sector efficiency in the UK
 
Sabin SIF country ownership case studies IX.15
Sabin SIF country ownership case studies IX.15Sabin SIF country ownership case studies IX.15
Sabin SIF country ownership case studies IX.15
 
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_1_Colombier
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_1_ColombierParallel_Session_1_Talk_1_Colombier
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_1_Colombier
 
Domain-specific risk and public policy
Domain-specific risk and public policyDomain-specific risk and public policy
Domain-specific risk and public policy
 
0204 JP Thierry - Basic Health Economics
0204 JP Thierry - Basic Health Economics0204 JP Thierry - Basic Health Economics
0204 JP Thierry - Basic Health Economics
 
Hawkins house meeting
Hawkins house meetingHawkins house meeting
Hawkins house meeting
 
10 04 28_whitepaper_hospital_costs_final
10 04 28_whitepaper_hospital_costs_final10 04 28_whitepaper_hospital_costs_final
10 04 28_whitepaper_hospital_costs_final
 
Portugal economic-survey-main-findings
Portugal economic-survey-main-findingsPortugal economic-survey-main-findings
Portugal economic-survey-main-findings
 
Activity-Based Funding (ABF).pdf
Activity-Based Funding (ABF).pdfActivity-Based Funding (ABF).pdf
Activity-Based Funding (ABF).pdf
 
Session 2 a discussion of mary o'mahony paper in session 2a 25 august
Session 2 a discussion of mary o'mahony paper in session 2a 25 augustSession 2 a discussion of mary o'mahony paper in session 2a 25 august
Session 2 a discussion of mary o'mahony paper in session 2a 25 august
 
Mc daid primhe conference 2011
Mc daid primhe conference 2011Mc daid primhe conference 2011
Mc daid primhe conference 2011
 
Presentacion Del Secretario De Estado En Londr
Presentacion Del Secretario De Estado En LondrPresentacion Del Secretario De Estado En Londr
Presentacion Del Secretario De Estado En Londr
 
Budget for Outcomes - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
Budget for Outcomes - Stefan Kiss, Slovak RepublicBudget for Outcomes - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
Budget for Outcomes - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
 
Healthcare Costs And Performance In The OECD
Healthcare Costs And Performance In The OECDHealthcare Costs And Performance In The OECD
Healthcare Costs And Performance In The OECD
 
Healthcare Costs And Performance in the OECD
Healthcare Costs And Performance in the OECDHealthcare Costs And Performance in the OECD
Healthcare Costs And Performance in the OECD
 
Presentation on the results to date of the Federal Partnership for Patients (...
Presentation on the results to date of the Federal Partnership for Patients (...Presentation on the results to date of the Federal Partnership for Patients (...
Presentation on the results to date of the Federal Partnership for Patients (...
 
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_5_Tondelli
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_5_TondelliParallel_Session_1_Talk_5_Tondelli
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_5_Tondelli
 

More from CSS-Institute

Parallel_Session_2_Talk_5_Huber
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_5_HuberParallel_Session_2_Talk_5_Huber
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_5_HuberCSS-Institute
 
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_3_Wieser
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_3_WieserParallel_Session_2_Talk_3_Wieser
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_3_WieserCSS-Institute
 
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_2_Ingenhaag
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_2_IngenhaagParallel_Session_2_Talk_2_Ingenhaag
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_2_IngenhaagCSS-Institute
 
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_1_Schleiniger
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_1_SchleinigerParallel_Session_2_Talk_1_Schleiniger
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_1_SchleinigerCSS-Institute
 
Plenary_Talk_1_Zweifel
Plenary_Talk_1_ZweifelPlenary_Talk_1_Zweifel
Plenary_Talk_1_ZweifelCSS-Institute
 
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_6_Strobl
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_6_StroblParallel_Session_2_Talk_6_Strobl
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_6_StroblCSS-Institute
 
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_2_Widmer
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_2_WidmerParallel_Session_1_Talk_2_Widmer
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_2_WidmerCSS-Institute
 
0_1_Program_SHEW_2013
0_1_Program_SHEW_20130_1_Program_SHEW_2013
0_1_Program_SHEW_2013CSS-Institute
 
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_4_Spika
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_4_SpikaParallel_Session_2_Talk_4_Spika
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_4_SpikaCSS-Institute
 
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_4_vonWyl
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_4_vonWylParallel_Session_1_Talk_4_vonWyl
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_4_vonWylCSS-Institute
 
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_3_Beck
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_3_BeckParallel_Session_1_Talk_3_Beck
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_3_BeckCSS-Institute
 

More from CSS-Institute (11)

Parallel_Session_2_Talk_5_Huber
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_5_HuberParallel_Session_2_Talk_5_Huber
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_5_Huber
 
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_3_Wieser
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_3_WieserParallel_Session_2_Talk_3_Wieser
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_3_Wieser
 
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_2_Ingenhaag
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_2_IngenhaagParallel_Session_2_Talk_2_Ingenhaag
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_2_Ingenhaag
 
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_1_Schleiniger
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_1_SchleinigerParallel_Session_2_Talk_1_Schleiniger
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_1_Schleiniger
 
Plenary_Talk_1_Zweifel
Plenary_Talk_1_ZweifelPlenary_Talk_1_Zweifel
Plenary_Talk_1_Zweifel
 
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_6_Strobl
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_6_StroblParallel_Session_2_Talk_6_Strobl
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_6_Strobl
 
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_2_Widmer
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_2_WidmerParallel_Session_1_Talk_2_Widmer
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_2_Widmer
 
0_1_Program_SHEW_2013
0_1_Program_SHEW_20130_1_Program_SHEW_2013
0_1_Program_SHEW_2013
 
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_4_Spika
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_4_SpikaParallel_Session_2_Talk_4_Spika
Parallel_Session_2_Talk_4_Spika
 
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_4_vonWyl
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_4_vonWylParallel_Session_1_Talk_4_vonWyl
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_4_vonWyl
 
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_3_Beck
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_3_BeckParallel_Session_1_Talk_3_Beck
Parallel_Session_1_Talk_3_Beck
 

Recently uploaded

how to sell pi coins on Binance exchange
how to sell pi coins on Binance exchangehow to sell pi coins on Binance exchange
how to sell pi coins on Binance exchangeDOT TECH
 
how can I sell my mined pi coins profitabily.
how can I sell my mined pi coins profitabily.how can I sell my mined pi coins profitabily.
how can I sell my mined pi coins profitabily.DOT TECH
 
Digital Finance Summit 2024 Partners Brochure
Digital Finance Summit 2024 Partners BrochureDigital Finance Summit 2024 Partners Brochure
Digital Finance Summit 2024 Partners BrochureFinTech Belgium
 
Jio Financial service Multibagger 2024 from India stock Market
Jio Financial service  Multibagger 2024 from India stock MarketJio Financial service  Multibagger 2024 from India stock Market
Jio Financial service Multibagger 2024 from India stock Marketfuturecapsadvisor
 
what is a pi whale and how to access one.
what is a pi whale and how to access one.what is a pi whale and how to access one.
what is a pi whale and how to access one.DOT TECH
 
一比一原版BCU毕业证伯明翰城市大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版BCU毕业证伯明翰城市大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版BCU毕业证伯明翰城市大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版BCU毕业证伯明翰城市大学毕业证成绩单如何办理ydubwyt
 
is it possible to sell pi network coin in 2024.
is it possible to sell pi network coin in 2024.is it possible to sell pi network coin in 2024.
is it possible to sell pi network coin in 2024.DOT TECH
 
when officially can i withdraw my pi Network coins.
when officially can i withdraw my pi Network coins.when officially can i withdraw my pi Network coins.
when officially can i withdraw my pi Network coins.DOT TECH
 
how can I sell my locked pi coins safety.
how can I sell my locked pi coins safety.how can I sell my locked pi coins safety.
how can I sell my locked pi coins safety.DOT TECH
 
how can I transfer pi coins to someone in a different country.
how can I transfer pi coins to someone in a different country.how can I transfer pi coins to someone in a different country.
how can I transfer pi coins to someone in a different country.DOT TECH
 
what is the future of Pi Network currency.
what is the future of Pi Network currency.what is the future of Pi Network currency.
what is the future of Pi Network currency.DOT TECH
 
how can i make money selling pi coins in 2024
how can i make money selling pi coins in 2024how can i make money selling pi coins in 2024
how can i make money selling pi coins in 2024DOT TECH
 
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Optimizing Returns with Minimal Risk
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Optimizing Returns with Minimal RiskFalcon Invoice Discounting: Optimizing Returns with Minimal Risk
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Optimizing Returns with Minimal RiskFalcon Invoice Discounting
 
Juspay Case study(Doubling Revenue Juspay's Success).pptx
Juspay Case study(Doubling Revenue Juspay's Success).pptxJuspay Case study(Doubling Revenue Juspay's Success).pptx
Juspay Case study(Doubling Revenue Juspay's Success).pptxaryan963438
 
how can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYC
how can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYChow can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYC
how can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYCDOT TECH
 
Can a Pi network coin ever be sold out: I am ready to sell mine.
Can a Pi network coin ever be sold out: I am ready to sell mine.Can a Pi network coin ever be sold out: I am ready to sell mine.
Can a Pi network coin ever be sold out: I am ready to sell mine.DOT TECH
 
一比一原版Adelaide毕业证阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版Adelaide毕业证阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版Adelaide毕业证阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版Adelaide毕业证阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单如何办理zsewypy
 
how can i use my minded pi coins I need some funds.
how can i use my minded pi coins I need some funds.how can i use my minded pi coins I need some funds.
how can i use my minded pi coins I need some funds.DOT TECH
 

Recently uploaded (20)

how to sell pi coins on Binance exchange
how to sell pi coins on Binance exchangehow to sell pi coins on Binance exchange
how to sell pi coins on Binance exchange
 
how can I sell my mined pi coins profitabily.
how can I sell my mined pi coins profitabily.how can I sell my mined pi coins profitabily.
how can I sell my mined pi coins profitabily.
 
Digital Finance Summit 2024 Partners Brochure
Digital Finance Summit 2024 Partners BrochureDigital Finance Summit 2024 Partners Brochure
Digital Finance Summit 2024 Partners Brochure
 
Jio Financial service Multibagger 2024 from India stock Market
Jio Financial service  Multibagger 2024 from India stock MarketJio Financial service  Multibagger 2024 from India stock Market
Jio Financial service Multibagger 2024 from India stock Market
 
what is a pi whale and how to access one.
what is a pi whale and how to access one.what is a pi whale and how to access one.
what is a pi whale and how to access one.
 
Commercial Bank Economic Capsule - May 2024
Commercial Bank Economic Capsule - May 2024Commercial Bank Economic Capsule - May 2024
Commercial Bank Economic Capsule - May 2024
 
一比一原版BCU毕业证伯明翰城市大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版BCU毕业证伯明翰城市大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版BCU毕业证伯明翰城市大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版BCU毕业证伯明翰城市大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
 
is it possible to sell pi network coin in 2024.
is it possible to sell pi network coin in 2024.is it possible to sell pi network coin in 2024.
is it possible to sell pi network coin in 2024.
 
when officially can i withdraw my pi Network coins.
when officially can i withdraw my pi Network coins.when officially can i withdraw my pi Network coins.
when officially can i withdraw my pi Network coins.
 
how can I sell my locked pi coins safety.
how can I sell my locked pi coins safety.how can I sell my locked pi coins safety.
how can I sell my locked pi coins safety.
 
how can I transfer pi coins to someone in a different country.
how can I transfer pi coins to someone in a different country.how can I transfer pi coins to someone in a different country.
how can I transfer pi coins to someone in a different country.
 
what is the future of Pi Network currency.
what is the future of Pi Network currency.what is the future of Pi Network currency.
what is the future of Pi Network currency.
 
how can i make money selling pi coins in 2024
how can i make money selling pi coins in 2024how can i make money selling pi coins in 2024
how can i make money selling pi coins in 2024
 
Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No. 232, May 2024
Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No. 232, May 2024Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No. 232, May 2024
Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No. 232, May 2024
 
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Optimizing Returns with Minimal Risk
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Optimizing Returns with Minimal RiskFalcon Invoice Discounting: Optimizing Returns with Minimal Risk
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Optimizing Returns with Minimal Risk
 
Juspay Case study(Doubling Revenue Juspay's Success).pptx
Juspay Case study(Doubling Revenue Juspay's Success).pptxJuspay Case study(Doubling Revenue Juspay's Success).pptx
Juspay Case study(Doubling Revenue Juspay's Success).pptx
 
how can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYC
how can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYChow can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYC
how can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYC
 
Can a Pi network coin ever be sold out: I am ready to sell mine.
Can a Pi network coin ever be sold out: I am ready to sell mine.Can a Pi network coin ever be sold out: I am ready to sell mine.
Can a Pi network coin ever be sold out: I am ready to sell mine.
 
一比一原版Adelaide毕业证阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版Adelaide毕业证阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版Adelaide毕业证阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版Adelaide毕业证阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
 
how can i use my minded pi coins I need some funds.
how can i use my minded pi coins I need some funds.how can i use my minded pi coins I need some funds.
how can i use my minded pi coins I need some funds.
 

Plenary_Talk_1_Meyer

  • 1. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency Evidence from Swiss Public Hospitals Stefan Meyer Department of Health Economics, University of Basel 13 September 2013 Swiss Health Economic Workshop, Lucerne Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 2. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Outline 1 Background 2 Model and Data 3 Results 4 Conclusion Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 3. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Inefficiencies in Healthcare Swiss healthcare expenditure has risen by 46% over the last decade, reaching CHF 62.5 billion (10.9% of GDP) in 2010 (BFS, 2010). A significant part of healthcare costs arise due to inefficient allocation of resources and inefficient production of goods and services (OECD, 2010). A recent US study by the WHO (2010) estimates total costs of inefficiencies to be in a range of $ 600 - 850 billion per year (≈ 30% of total health spending). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 4. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Inefficiencies in Healthcare Swiss healthcare expenditure has risen by 46% over the last decade, reaching CHF 62.5 billion (10.9% of GDP) in 2010 (BFS, 2010). A significant part of healthcare costs arise due to inefficient allocation of resources and inefficient production of goods and services (OECD, 2010). A recent US study by the WHO (2010) estimates total costs of inefficiencies to be in a range of $ 600 - 850 billion per year (≈ 30% of total health spending). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 5. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Inefficiencies in Healthcare Swiss healthcare expenditure has risen by 46% over the last decade, reaching CHF 62.5 billion (10.9% of GDP) in 2010 (BFS, 2010). A significant part of healthcare costs arise due to inefficient allocation of resources and inefficient production of goods and services (OECD, 2010). A recent US study by the WHO (2010) estimates total costs of inefficiencies to be in a range of $ 600 - 850 billion per year (≈ 30% of total health spending). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 6. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Inefficiency and Payment Schemes Well-known factors like income, technological progress, and demography have contributed to the continuing upward trend. Still, as these forces are hardly controllable, policies aimed at reducing inefficiencies have become essential. Prospective reimbursement schemes can serve as controlling instruments for lowering cost inefficiency. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 7. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Inefficiency and Payment Schemes Well-known factors like income, technological progress, and demography have contributed to the continuing upward trend. Still, as these forces are hardly controllable, policies aimed at reducing inefficiencies have become essential. Prospective reimbursement schemes can serve as controlling instruments for lowering cost inefficiency. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 8. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Inefficiency and Payment Schemes Well-known factors like income, technological progress, and demography have contributed to the continuing upward trend. Still, as these forces are hardly controllable, policies aimed at reducing inefficiencies have become essential. Prospective reimbursement schemes can serve as controlling instruments for lowering cost inefficiency. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 9. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Inpatient Sector in Switzerland I A substantial part of healthcare resources is allocated to the inpatient sector, amounting to CHF 21.7 billion (34.9%) in 2009 (OECD, 2012). Small efficiency gains in this sector may lower total healthcare costs considerably. Saved resources can be reallocated to socially beneficial areas of healthcare. The average length of stay (ALOS) in Swiss hospitals remains high room for improving cost efficiency. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 10. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Inpatient Sector in Switzerland I A substantial part of healthcare resources is allocated to the inpatient sector, amounting to CHF 21.7 billion (34.9%) in 2009 (OECD, 2012). Small efficiency gains in this sector may lower total healthcare costs considerably. Saved resources can be reallocated to socially beneficial areas of healthcare. The average length of stay (ALOS) in Swiss hospitals remains high room for improving cost efficiency. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 11. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Inpatient Sector in Switzerland I A substantial part of healthcare resources is allocated to the inpatient sector, amounting to CHF 21.7 billion (34.9%) in 2009 (OECD, 2012). Small efficiency gains in this sector may lower total healthcare costs considerably. Saved resources can be reallocated to socially beneficial areas of healthcare. The average length of stay (ALOS) in Swiss hospitals remains high room for improving cost efficiency. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 12. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Inpatient Sector in Switzerland I A substantial part of healthcare resources is allocated to the inpatient sector, amounting to CHF 21.7 billion (34.9%) in 2009 (OECD, 2012). Small efficiency gains in this sector may lower total healthcare costs considerably. Saved resources can be reallocated to socially beneficial areas of healthcare. The average length of stay (ALOS) in Swiss hospitals remains high room for improving cost efficiency. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 13. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Length of Stay in Selected OECD Countries (2009) Source: OECD, 2009 (Greece: 2007 Data) Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 14. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Inpatient Sector in Switzerland II Until 2011: Considerable differences in inpatient reimbursement among hospitals and local healthcare areas (cantons) As of 2012: Implementation of cased-based payment (SwissDRGs) in public and private hospitals all over Switzerland Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 15. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion 4 Payment Systems in Question I Revenue per case (Ri ) under 4 payment schemes: per diem: flat payment per patient day Rdiem i = pt · ti APDRG: flat payment per case (according to a national DRG catalogue) RDRG i = CW k · ¯P Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 16. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion 4 Payment Systems in Question II DCB: flat payment per case (according to the hospital department involved) RDCB i = Bk PLT (hybrid): flat payment per case + flat payment per patient day (both depending on the hospital department involved) RPLT i = Bk + pk t · ti PLT: Prozess-Leistungs-Tarifierung, DCB: Department case-based payments (Abteilungspauschalen). We treat the patient pathway system (MIPP, Cantonal Hospital of Aarau) as DCB, since the two systems do not differ in the way they offer financial incentives to the hospital. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 17. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Payment Schemes in Swiss Cantons (2009) Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 18. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Research Outline I I aim to... estimate cost (in)efficiency (CE) scores for Swiss public hospitals by means of Stochastic Frontier Analysis (SFA), show that flat payment schemes decrease inefficiency (c.p.). analyse the consequences of heteroscedasticity (to be discussed later on). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 19. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Research Outline I I aim to... estimate cost (in)efficiency (CE) scores for Swiss public hospitals by means of Stochastic Frontier Analysis (SFA), show that flat payment schemes decrease inefficiency (c.p.). analyse the consequences of heteroscedasticity (to be discussed later on). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 20. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Research Outline I I aim to... estimate cost (in)efficiency (CE) scores for Swiss public hospitals by means of Stochastic Frontier Analysis (SFA), show that flat payment schemes decrease inefficiency (c.p.). analyse the consequences of heteroscedasticity (to be discussed later on). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 21. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Research Outline II I take advantage of the fact that... until 2011, health insurers employed 4 different inpatient payment schemes in 26 cantons. the problem of unobserved heterogeneity across observation areas is alleviated, as we only focus on one country. the public sector (cantons) reimburses hospitals on the same basis (object financing = global budget, deficit guarantee). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 22. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Research Outline II I take advantage of the fact that... until 2011, health insurers employed 4 different inpatient payment schemes in 26 cantons. the problem of unobserved heterogeneity across observation areas is alleviated, as we only focus on one country. the public sector (cantons) reimburses hospitals on the same basis (object financing = global budget, deficit guarantee). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 23. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Research Outline II I take advantage of the fact that... until 2011, health insurers employed 4 different inpatient payment schemes in 26 cantons. the problem of unobserved heterogeneity across observation areas is alleviated, as we only focus on one country. the public sector (cantons) reimburses hospitals on the same basis (object financing = global budget, deficit guarantee). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 24. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Econometric Model: Cobb Douglas Cost Frontier ln TCit = α + m βm ln ym it + n βn ln pn it + k βksk it + vit + uit εit TCit Total costs of hospital i at time t ym it Outputs pn it Factor prices sk it Hospital characteristics vit Two-sided random noise component uit Non-negative inefficiency component Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 25. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Econometric Model: Inefficiency Term Battese and Coelli (1995) propose a model in which inefficiency effects are assumed to be a function of firm-specific variables and time: uit = zitδ + wit, uit ∼ N+(zitδ, σ2 u) zit Vector of hospital-specific and regional variables (payment scheme and other variables) wit Random noise component (truncated normal distributed) δ Vector of parameters to be estimated Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 26. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Distribution of the Inefficiency Term Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 27. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Data BFS data on 122 public and publicly-financed hospitals in Switzerland Period: 2004 - 2009 (T = 6) Information on hospital category, teaching, inputs, inpatient and outpatient outputs, and costs 5 observations per hospital on average, total sample size of 606 (inclusion criterion: ≥ 2 obs., ≥750 inpatient days) Data covers a total of 4.9 million cases (≈ 58% of all hospital cases between 2004 and 2009) Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 28. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Despriptive Statistics I (N = 606) Variable Description Mean SD Cost frontier variables TC Total costs (k CHF) 130 010.4 195 921.7 CASES Number of CMI-adjusted discharges 8 283.1 10 109.3 OUTP Revenue from outpatients (k CHF) 24 746.3 37 935.3 PL Price of labour (k CHF) 100.1 14.4 PK Price of capital (k CHF) 170.6 76.9 SERVICE Number of hospital services 36.2 18.0 INTERN Number of advanced training categories* 20.5 27.9 *FMH Weiterbildungskategorien Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 29. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Despriptive Statistics II (N = 606) Variable Description Mean SD Inefficiency variables APDRG APDRG-based payment system* 0.27 PLT Hybrid payment system* 0.54 DCB Department level case-based system* 0.06 OCC Bed occupancy rate 0.88 0.10 BEDS Acute care beds per 1,000 residents 2.95 0.70 PHYS GPs specialists per 1,000 residents 2.00 0.57 MCARE Managed Care contracts / total number of MHI contracts 0.17 0.11 POP Population density (Residents / sq km) 536.10 1 062.30 *Dummy variable Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 30. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Heteroscedasticity SFA are likely to suffer from severe heteroscedasticity (HEC), especially if the hospitals are of different size. Coefficients are biased in SFA models if HEC is overlooked (frontier is changed when dispersion increases; s. Caudill et al., 1995). Heteroscedastic uit: Large hospitals have more“under their control”, efficiency gets more important with size large hospitals have much more in common than their small counterparts Heteroscedastic vit: Greater impact of random shocks on small units (“Law of large numbers”) Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 31. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Heteroscedasticity SFA are likely to suffer from severe heteroscedasticity (HEC), especially if the hospitals are of different size. Coefficients are biased in SFA models if HEC is overlooked (frontier is changed when dispersion increases; s. Caudill et al., 1995). Heteroscedastic uit: Large hospitals have more“under their control”, efficiency gets more important with size large hospitals have much more in common than their small counterparts Heteroscedastic vit: Greater impact of random shocks on small units (“Law of large numbers”) Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 32. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Heteroscedasticity SFA are likely to suffer from severe heteroscedasticity (HEC), especially if the hospitals are of different size. Coefficients are biased in SFA models if HEC is overlooked (frontier is changed when dispersion increases; s. Caudill et al., 1995). Heteroscedastic uit: Large hospitals have more“under their control”, efficiency gets more important with size large hospitals have much more in common than their small counterparts Heteroscedastic vit: Greater impact of random shocks on small units (“Law of large numbers”) Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 33. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Specifying HEC Three different specifications: (1) No HEC (2) HEC in uit (3) HEC in both uit and vit Assumption: σ2 uit = exp(CASESitη) and σ2 vit = exp(CASESitφ), where η and φ are parameters to be estimated. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 34. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion HEC: Findings 1 Both σ2 uit and σ2 vit are negatively correlated with hospital size (p 0.01), indicating that variation of uit and vit is more distinct among smaller institutions. 2 Coefficients (and standard errors) slightly change when HEC is taken into acount. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 35. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion SFA Results ln TC σ2 u/ σ2 v σ2 ui / σ2 v σ2 ui / σ2 vi ln CASES 0.830*** (0.015) 0.882*** (0.013) 0.864*** (0.014) ln OUTP 0.117*** (0.014) 0.098*** (0.010) 0.102*** (0.012) ln PL 0.026 (0.072) 0.057 (0.037) 0.000 (0.039) ln PK 0.271*** (0.027) 0.249*** (0.016) 0.258*** (0.020) ln SERVICE 0.027* (0.014) 0.001* (0.000) 0.001* (0.000) ln INTERN 0.029*** (0.007) 0.002*** (0.000) 0.002*** (0.000) YEAR 0.014*** (0.004) 0.014*** (0.004) 0.007 (0.005) APDRG =0.407** (0.171) =0.298*** (0.081) =0.289*** (0.072) PLT =0.136 (0.084) =0.080* (0.043) =0.092** (0.040) DCB =0.931 (0.810) =0.561** (0.237) =0.593* (0.338) OCC =1.754** (0.869) =1.108*** (0.339) =1.239*** (0.359) BEDS =0.414** (0.180) =0.246*** (0.067) =0.256*** (0.066) PHYS 0.330** (0.156) 0.103** (0.050) 0.131*** (0.046) MCARE =0.997 (0.775) =0.396* (0.239) =0.457** (0.229) POP 0.000 (0.000) 0.000** (0.000) 0.000** (0.000) YEAR 0.097 (0.067) 0.043** (0.020) 0.058*** (0.018) Note: N = 606; Cluster robust standard errors are given in parentheses; *p 0.10, **p 0.05, ***p 0.01; The sign of the efficiency variables are to be read as effects on inefficiency; Both constants not shown Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 36. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Main Findings I Compared to per diem, all three systems are associated with decreased inefficiency. This finding is most pronounced among hospitals that apply flat payment schemes (APDRG, DCB). High bed density in acute care is associated with enhanced CE (highly competitive markets little market / bargaining power) Inefficient hospitals are likely found in population-dense areas with a high penetration of GPs and specialists ( proxy measure of demand; s. Chirikos, 1998). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 37. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Main Findings I Compared to per diem, all three systems are associated with decreased inefficiency. This finding is most pronounced among hospitals that apply flat payment schemes (APDRG, DCB). High bed density in acute care is associated with enhanced CE (highly competitive markets little market / bargaining power) Inefficient hospitals are likely found in population-dense areas with a high penetration of GPs and specialists ( proxy measure of demand; s. Chirikos, 1998). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 38. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Main Findings I Compared to per diem, all three systems are associated with decreased inefficiency. This finding is most pronounced among hospitals that apply flat payment schemes (APDRG, DCB). High bed density in acute care is associated with enhanced CE (highly competitive markets little market / bargaining power) Inefficient hospitals are likely found in population-dense areas with a high penetration of GPs and specialists ( proxy measure of demand; s. Chirikos, 1998). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 39. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Main Findings II As found in an earlier study by Rosko (2004), managed care penetration is positively correlated with CE (Insurers may place financial pressure on hospitals when prices are being negotiated). Mean cost inefficiency increased significantly from 7.8% in 2004 to 12.3% in 2009. CE scores only changed marginally when the panel was almost balanced (from 2006). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 40. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Main Findings II As found in an earlier study by Rosko (2004), managed care penetration is positively correlated with CE (Insurers may place financial pressure on hospitals when prices are being negotiated). Mean cost inefficiency increased significantly from 7.8% in 2004 to 12.3% in 2009. CE scores only changed marginally when the panel was almost balanced (from 2006). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 41. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Mean Inefficiency Estimates by Payment Scheme Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 42. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Conclusion Positive correlation of flat payment and CE in Swiss public hospitals (controlling for hospital characteristics, the market environment, and time trends). Findings are in line with the basic economic theory on the financial incentives of payment schemes (Ellis and McGuire, 1986). Considerable differences in mean inefficiencies across hospital categories (maximum gap of about 15% between per diem and DLCB hospitals in 2009). In SFA, heteroscedastic error terms (uit and vit) lead to biased coefficients and standard errors. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 43. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Conclusion Positive correlation of flat payment and CE in Swiss public hospitals (controlling for hospital characteristics, the market environment, and time trends). Findings are in line with the basic economic theory on the financial incentives of payment schemes (Ellis and McGuire, 1986). Considerable differences in mean inefficiencies across hospital categories (maximum gap of about 15% between per diem and DLCB hospitals in 2009). In SFA, heteroscedastic error terms (uit and vit) lead to biased coefficients and standard errors. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 44. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Conclusion Positive correlation of flat payment and CE in Swiss public hospitals (controlling for hospital characteristics, the market environment, and time trends). Findings are in line with the basic economic theory on the financial incentives of payment schemes (Ellis and McGuire, 1986). Considerable differences in mean inefficiencies across hospital categories (maximum gap of about 15% between per diem and DLCB hospitals in 2009). In SFA, heteroscedastic error terms (uit and vit) lead to biased coefficients and standard errors. Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 45. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Limitations I do not account for quality differences among hospitals (evidence suggests that ignoring them may not be a serious problem; s. Mutter et al., 2008). Unobservable differences among cantons biased coefficients of the payment scheme variables. Potential endogeneity in the outputs and the factor prices as a major drawback in SFA (especially the price proxies may reflect the hospitals’ choices about the average skill-mix and the amount and mix of capital; s. Zuckermann et al., 1994). Small sample of Swiss public hospitals unclear whether these findings can be applied to private hospitals as well (or even other healthcare systems). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 46. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Limitations I do not account for quality differences among hospitals (evidence suggests that ignoring them may not be a serious problem; s. Mutter et al., 2008). Unobservable differences among cantons biased coefficients of the payment scheme variables. Potential endogeneity in the outputs and the factor prices as a major drawback in SFA (especially the price proxies may reflect the hospitals’ choices about the average skill-mix and the amount and mix of capital; s. Zuckermann et al., 1994). Small sample of Swiss public hospitals unclear whether these findings can be applied to private hospitals as well (or even other healthcare systems). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 47. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Limitations I do not account for quality differences among hospitals (evidence suggests that ignoring them may not be a serious problem; s. Mutter et al., 2008). Unobservable differences among cantons biased coefficients of the payment scheme variables. Potential endogeneity in the outputs and the factor prices as a major drawback in SFA (especially the price proxies may reflect the hospitals’ choices about the average skill-mix and the amount and mix of capital; s. Zuckermann et al., 1994). Small sample of Swiss public hospitals unclear whether these findings can be applied to private hospitals as well (or even other healthcare systems). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 48. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Limitations I do not account for quality differences among hospitals (evidence suggests that ignoring them may not be a serious problem; s. Mutter et al., 2008). Unobservable differences among cantons biased coefficients of the payment scheme variables. Potential endogeneity in the outputs and the factor prices as a major drawback in SFA (especially the price proxies may reflect the hospitals’ choices about the average skill-mix and the amount and mix of capital; s. Zuckermann et al., 1994). Small sample of Swiss public hospitals unclear whether these findings can be applied to private hospitals as well (or even other healthcare systems). Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency
  • 49. Background Model and Data Results Conclusion Thank you! Many thanks for your attention! Stefan Meyer Inpatient Payment Schemes and Cost Efficiency