SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 17
Management experts have different 
views on the nature of management. Some 
are of the opinion that management is a 
science, some others hold the view that it is an 
art and yet others say it is a profession. 
Taking all these views into account, we can 
determine the nature of management.
A. MANAGEMENT IS A SCIENCE 
A strong group of management experts 
say that management has some unique 
features in common with science. Following 
are the special features of science which are 
compatible with the features of management.
Features of science are:- 
 Science is systematically arranged branch 
of knowledge: 
Science is a systematically arranged branch of 
knowledge. Its principles are evolved through 
experiments and observations and they are 
combined and preserved in different study 
materials. This holds good with management 
also. Management principles are also evolved 
through experiments and observations and 
they are also combined and preserved.
 Principles are formed from continuous 
research: 
Scientists develop scientific principles after 
numerous experiments carried out in different 
places and under different circumstances. This 
approach is true of management as well. 
Management has developed its principle after 
numerous experiments in different companies 
at different places.
 Principles are universally applicable: 
Scientific principles are universally applicable. 
For example, if molecules of hydrogen and 
oxygen are mixed, we get water anywhere in 
the world. However, management principles 
cannot be applied universally and in the same 
way. Since management is related to man, its 
principles are related to human behaviour, his 
culture, education and life style. Therefore 
universal applicability of science may not be 
compatible with management principles. For 
example, in a community of Buddhist monks, 
management principles may not work out.
 Scientific principles are formulated on the 
basis of observation and logic: 
Scientific principles are defined after logical 
observation. Moreover, observation of 
scientists will be hundred percent objective. 
But managers observe human beings and 
observation of managers may not be cent 
percent objective. Therefore this principle of 
science is also not compatible with 
management principles. 
When scientific principles and management 
principles are compared, we can reach the 
following conclusion.
Conclusion 
Of the four features of science, the first 
two features are latent in management 
principles also. But the last two principles 
are not seen in management. Therefore it is 
not possible to say that management is an 
exact science like physics or chemistry. As 
management is related to man, we can say, 
management is a social science.
B. MANAGEMENT IS AN ART 
A group of management experts are of 
the view that management is an art. 
Therefore let us examine the features of art 
and see whether they are compatible with the 
characteristics of management.
Features of art are:- 
 Theoretical knowledge is systematically 
arranged in art: 
The theoretical knowledge of art is 
systematically arranged in the books in order to 
enable the people to absorb the various aspects of 
art. For example, several books are a available 
which give about different aspects of music. In 
management also several books have been 
published giving knowledge about different 
aspects of management. Thus systematic 
arrangement of theoretical knowledge is an aspect 
common to both art and management.
 Art gives importance to individual 
differences: 
An artist becomes perfect in his work of art by 
combining the knowledge he has gained with his 
own inherent talents. For example, even though 
different dancers are trained by the same trainer, 
some of them excel by adding their natural 
talents. In management also all managers learn 
same theories and principles, but their efficiency 
depends on how well they use these principles 
under different situations by applying their own 
personal creativity and skill. So this feature of art 
is also present in management.
 An artist gains perfection through constant 
practice: 
Just as an artist gains perfection through 
constant practice, the managers become more 
perfect from their experience they have gained 
from the different circumstances. That means 
art and management have this characteristics in 
common. 
Conclusion 
As management has all the features of art in 
common, we can say that management is an 
art.
C. MANAGEMENT IS BOTH SCIENCE 
AND ART 
As management is systematically arranged 
body of knowledge, it is a science. As this 
collection of knowledge is practically applied, it 
is also an art.
Management is both science and art 
As art 
As science 
Management is a 
systematically arranged 
collection of knowledge. 
Management principles 
are gained through 
constant research. 
Art is a collection of 
theoretical knowledge. 
Individual differences 
are important in art. 
An artist gains 
perfection through 
constant practice.
Management Nature Debate

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Concept & Nature of Management
Concept & Nature of ManagementConcept & Nature of Management
Concept & Nature of ManagementKumar
 
Principle Management Chapter 9 Management Information Systems
Principle Management Chapter 9 Management Information SystemsPrinciple Management Chapter 9 Management Information Systems
Principle Management Chapter 9 Management Information SystemsDr. John V. Padua
 
Nature of Management
Nature of ManagementNature of Management
Nature of ManagementPie GS
 
Concept, nature & purpose of management
Concept, nature & purpose of managementConcept, nature & purpose of management
Concept, nature & purpose of managementRobin Gulati
 
Meaning,nature,scope,process of management & approaches of a system
Meaning,nature,scope,process of management & approaches of a systemMeaning,nature,scope,process of management & approaches of a system
Meaning,nature,scope,process of management & approaches of a systemsadhikakatiyar
 
Management ppt
Management pptManagement ppt
Management pptYen Garcia
 

Viewers also liked (9)

Concept & Nature of Management
Concept & Nature of ManagementConcept & Nature of Management
Concept & Nature of Management
 
Principle Management Chapter 9 Management Information Systems
Principle Management Chapter 9 Management Information SystemsPrinciple Management Chapter 9 Management Information Systems
Principle Management Chapter 9 Management Information Systems
 
Nature of Management
Nature of ManagementNature of Management
Nature of Management
 
Nature of Management - Management Principles
Nature of Management - Management PrinciplesNature of Management - Management Principles
Nature of Management - Management Principles
 
Concept, nature & purpose of management
Concept, nature & purpose of managementConcept, nature & purpose of management
Concept, nature & purpose of management
 
Meaning,nature,scope,process of management & approaches of a system
Meaning,nature,scope,process of management & approaches of a systemMeaning,nature,scope,process of management & approaches of a system
Meaning,nature,scope,process of management & approaches of a system
 
Management ppt
Management pptManagement ppt
Management ppt
 
Basic concept of management
Basic concept of managementBasic concept of management
Basic concept of management
 
Chap 1 introduction to management
Chap 1 introduction to managementChap 1 introduction to management
Chap 1 introduction to management
 

Similar to Management Nature Debate

Unit I Introduction to Management & Organizations
Unit I Introduction to Management & OrganizationsUnit I Introduction to Management & Organizations
Unit I Introduction to Management & Organizationsdavid blessley
 
Introduction to management
Introduction to managementIntroduction to management
Introduction to managementKumar
 
Management as an art and science mr anil kumar gupta + eva
Management as an art and science mr anil kumar gupta + evaManagement as an art and science mr anil kumar gupta + eva
Management as an art and science mr anil kumar gupta + evakvdibrugarh
 
Management as science , art and profession and levels of Management
Management as science , art and profession and levels of Management Management as science , art and profession and levels of Management
Management as science , art and profession and levels of Management VNRacademy
 
Principles & Practice of Management - Nature - Arts, Science
Principles & Practice of Management - Nature - Arts, SciencePrinciples & Practice of Management - Nature - Arts, Science
Principles & Practice of Management - Nature - Arts, Scienceuma reur
 
Management art or science
Management art or scienceManagement art or science
Management art or sciencevikash Gupta
 
MANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES.pptx
MANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES.pptxMANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES.pptx
MANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES.pptxMercy194431
 
Management function notes by Malay Ghosh
Management  function notes by Malay Ghosh  Management  function notes by Malay Ghosh
Management function notes by Malay Ghosh Core consultants
 
1 Concept & Nature of Management.pdf
1 Concept & Nature of Management.pdf1 Concept & Nature of Management.pdf
1 Concept & Nature of Management.pdfteersinghania
 
Introduction to Management (BBA I)
Introduction to Management (BBA I)Introduction to Management (BBA I)
Introduction to Management (BBA I)Durgesh S
 
Management science
Management scienceManagement science
Management sciencejaya lakshmi
 
Management as an art, science and a profession
Management as an art, science and a professionManagement as an art, science and a profession
Management as an art, science and a professionMinalBhandari2
 
The concept of management is universal and very old
The concept of management is universal and very oldThe concept of management is universal and very old
The concept of management is universal and very oldFahad Nakade
 
Nature and significance of management
Nature and significance of managementNature and significance of management
Nature and significance of managementPreksha Mehta
 

Similar to Management Nature Debate (20)

Lmdaf lec 1 definition
Lmdaf lec 1 definitionLmdaf lec 1 definition
Lmdaf lec 1 definition
 
Concept of mgt by Deepa
Concept of mgt by DeepaConcept of mgt by Deepa
Concept of mgt by Deepa
 
Unit I Introduction to Management & Organizations
Unit I Introduction to Management & OrganizationsUnit I Introduction to Management & Organizations
Unit I Introduction to Management & Organizations
 
Introduction to management
Introduction to managementIntroduction to management
Introduction to management
 
Management as an art and science mr anil kumar gupta + eva
Management as an art and science mr anil kumar gupta + evaManagement as an art and science mr anil kumar gupta + eva
Management as an art and science mr anil kumar gupta + eva
 
Management as science , art and profession and levels of Management
Management as science , art and profession and levels of Management Management as science , art and profession and levels of Management
Management as science , art and profession and levels of Management
 
Principles & Practice of Management - Nature - Arts, Science
Principles & Practice of Management - Nature - Arts, SciencePrinciples & Practice of Management - Nature - Arts, Science
Principles & Practice of Management - Nature - Arts, Science
 
Management art or science
Management art or scienceManagement art or science
Management art or science
 
MANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES.pptx
MANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES.pptxMANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES.pptx
MANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES.pptx
 
Proiect engleza
Proiect englezaProiect engleza
Proiect engleza
 
Management function notes by Malay Ghosh
Management  function notes by Malay Ghosh  Management  function notes by Malay Ghosh
Management function notes by Malay Ghosh
 
1st sem mgt
1st sem mgt1st sem mgt
1st sem mgt
 
1 Concept & Nature of Management.pdf
1 Concept & Nature of Management.pdf1 Concept & Nature of Management.pdf
1 Concept & Nature of Management.pdf
 
Introduction to Management (BBA I)
Introduction to Management (BBA I)Introduction to Management (BBA I)
Introduction to Management (BBA I)
 
pom.doc
pom.docpom.doc
pom.doc
 
Management science
Management scienceManagement science
Management science
 
Management as an art, science and a profession
Management as an art, science and a professionManagement as an art, science and a profession
Management as an art, science and a profession
 
The concept of management is universal and very old
The concept of management is universal and very oldThe concept of management is universal and very old
The concept of management is universal and very old
 
Nature and significance of management
Nature and significance of managementNature and significance of management
Nature and significance of management
 
Mgmt Art Science
Mgmt Art ScienceMgmt Art Science
Mgmt Art Science
 

Management Nature Debate

  • 1.
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4. Management experts have different views on the nature of management. Some are of the opinion that management is a science, some others hold the view that it is an art and yet others say it is a profession. Taking all these views into account, we can determine the nature of management.
  • 5. A. MANAGEMENT IS A SCIENCE A strong group of management experts say that management has some unique features in common with science. Following are the special features of science which are compatible with the features of management.
  • 6. Features of science are:-  Science is systematically arranged branch of knowledge: Science is a systematically arranged branch of knowledge. Its principles are evolved through experiments and observations and they are combined and preserved in different study materials. This holds good with management also. Management principles are also evolved through experiments and observations and they are also combined and preserved.
  • 7.  Principles are formed from continuous research: Scientists develop scientific principles after numerous experiments carried out in different places and under different circumstances. This approach is true of management as well. Management has developed its principle after numerous experiments in different companies at different places.
  • 8.  Principles are universally applicable: Scientific principles are universally applicable. For example, if molecules of hydrogen and oxygen are mixed, we get water anywhere in the world. However, management principles cannot be applied universally and in the same way. Since management is related to man, its principles are related to human behaviour, his culture, education and life style. Therefore universal applicability of science may not be compatible with management principles. For example, in a community of Buddhist monks, management principles may not work out.
  • 9.  Scientific principles are formulated on the basis of observation and logic: Scientific principles are defined after logical observation. Moreover, observation of scientists will be hundred percent objective. But managers observe human beings and observation of managers may not be cent percent objective. Therefore this principle of science is also not compatible with management principles. When scientific principles and management principles are compared, we can reach the following conclusion.
  • 10. Conclusion Of the four features of science, the first two features are latent in management principles also. But the last two principles are not seen in management. Therefore it is not possible to say that management is an exact science like physics or chemistry. As management is related to man, we can say, management is a social science.
  • 11. B. MANAGEMENT IS AN ART A group of management experts are of the view that management is an art. Therefore let us examine the features of art and see whether they are compatible with the characteristics of management.
  • 12. Features of art are:-  Theoretical knowledge is systematically arranged in art: The theoretical knowledge of art is systematically arranged in the books in order to enable the people to absorb the various aspects of art. For example, several books are a available which give about different aspects of music. In management also several books have been published giving knowledge about different aspects of management. Thus systematic arrangement of theoretical knowledge is an aspect common to both art and management.
  • 13.  Art gives importance to individual differences: An artist becomes perfect in his work of art by combining the knowledge he has gained with his own inherent talents. For example, even though different dancers are trained by the same trainer, some of them excel by adding their natural talents. In management also all managers learn same theories and principles, but their efficiency depends on how well they use these principles under different situations by applying their own personal creativity and skill. So this feature of art is also present in management.
  • 14.  An artist gains perfection through constant practice: Just as an artist gains perfection through constant practice, the managers become more perfect from their experience they have gained from the different circumstances. That means art and management have this characteristics in common. Conclusion As management has all the features of art in common, we can say that management is an art.
  • 15. C. MANAGEMENT IS BOTH SCIENCE AND ART As management is systematically arranged body of knowledge, it is a science. As this collection of knowledge is practically applied, it is also an art.
  • 16. Management is both science and art As art As science Management is a systematically arranged collection of knowledge. Management principles are gained through constant research. Art is a collection of theoretical knowledge. Individual differences are important in art. An artist gains perfection through constant practice.