SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 50
Download to read offline
AIR FORCE MEDICAL SERVICE
Total Exposure Health
Strategic Plan FY19-23
Prepared by:
Col Philip Goff and Richard Hartman, PhD
The information in this report is exempt from public disclosure in accordance with
Title 5 USC § 552(b) (5) (Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Exemption (b)(5)).
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified
STRATEGIC PLAN
FOR
TOTAL EXPOSURE HEALTH (TEH)
Sponsoring Organization: HAF SG3/5
Date Submitted: 22 Jan 2018
Approval Authority: Surgeon General
Validation Authority: Surgeon General
Document Point of Contact
Col Philip Goff,
AFMSA/SG3/5PB
Phone: 703-681-6912
DSN: 761-6912
NIPRNET:
philip.e.goff.mil@mail.mil
_______________________________
MARK A. EDIGER
Lieutenant General, USAF, MC, CFS
Surgeon General
Headquarters Air Force
OPR: Air Force Medical Support Agency/Operations and Research Directorate (AFMSA/SG3/5PB)
DSN: 761-6912
Commercial: (703) 681-6912
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified
Table of Contents
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.....................................................................................................................................1
2. INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................................................................2
2.1 BACKGROUND ..........................................................................................................................................2
2.2 TEHVISION..............................................................................................................................................3
2.3 CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES ................................................................................................4
3. STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS ...............................................................................................................................6
3.1 STUDIES AND ANALYSES....................................................................................................................6
3.2 RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT.......................................................................................................6
3.3 PARTNERSHIPS AND COLLABORATIONS ........................................................................................7
3.4 REGULATORY.........................................................................................................................................7
3.5 INFRASTRUCTURE ................................................................................................................................8
3.6 HEALTH AND HEALTHCARE...............................................................................................................8
3.7 TRAINING ................................................................................................................................................9
3.8 READINESS..............................................................................................................................................9
4. EXECUTION STRATEGY: STRATEGIC GOALS AND OBJECTIVES...........................................................10
GOAL 1: SYNTHESIZE, IDENTIFY, AND UNDERSTAND CURRENT AND EMERGING
TRENDS THROUGH STUDIES AND ANALYSES TO ADVANCE PREVENTION STRATEGIES.......10
4.2 GOAL 2: ADVANCE HEALTH AND HEALTHCARE THROUGH RESEARCH AND
DEVELOPMENT............................................................................................................................................11
4.3 GOAL 3: ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH REGULATORY STANDARDS.........................................12
4.4 GOAL 4: BUILD INFRASTRUCTURE TO SUPPORT ADVANCES IN HEALTHCARE...................13
4.5 GOAL 5: FOSTER A NETWORK OF INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL COLLABORATIVE
PARTNERS ....................................................................................................................................................13
4.6 GOAL 6: PROVIDE ENHANCED EXPOSURE HEALTH EDUCATION AND TRAINING..............15
4.7 GOAL 7: IMPROVE QUALITY OF CARE AND ENCOURAGE GOOD LIFESTYLE CHOICES ....16
4.8 GOAL 8: OPTIMIZE FORCE READINESS AND HUMAN PERFORMANCE BY REDUCING
HAZARDOUS EXPOSURES.........................................................................................................................17
4.9 GOAL 9: SHORT, MID, AND LONG TERM EXECUTION PLAN.......................................................17
5. STRATEGIC BUSINESS PLAN AND IMPLEMENTATION.............................................................................20
5.1 STRATEGIC BUSINESS PLAN DEVELOPMENT AND METHODOLOGY .....................................20
5.2 ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE AND STAFFING ..............................................................................20
6. STRATEGIC TECHNICAL PLAN AND IMPLEMENTATION.........................................................................21
6.1 TEH TECHNICAL SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT ....................................................................................21
7. ENABLERS FOR TEH SUCCESS.......................................................................................................................26
7.1 CULTURAL AND TECHNOLOGY ENABLERS..................................................................................26
8. MEDICAL PRIVACY AND ETHICS..................................................................................................................29
8.1 DATA COLLECTION INTEGRATION.................................................................................................29
8.2 SENSOR DEVELOPMENT ....................................................................................................................30
8.3 DATA INTEGRATION WITH HEALTH RECORDS............................................................................30
9. CONCLUSION.....................................................................................................................................................31
APPENDIX A: LIST OF ACRONYMS........................................................................................................................33
APPENDIX B: STRATEGIC PLAN ENDNOTE REFERENCES................................................................................36
APPENDIX C: GLOSSARY.........................................................................................................................................38
APPENDIX D: ADDITIONAL SELECTED PUBLICATIONS AND REFERENCE MATERIAL ............................41
APPENDIX E: TOTAL EXPOSURE HEALTH INFOGRAPHIC................................................................................46
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified
Table of Figures
Figure 1. Vision for TEH Portfolio................................................................................................................................. 3
Figure 2. Current State and Future State with TEH........................................................................................................ 4
Figure 3. TEH Variables................................................................................................................................................. 4
Figure 4. Focus Areas of the Future TEH....................................................................................................................... 6
Figure 5. TEH Strategic Goal ....................................................................................................................................... 10
Figure 6. Sample Regulatory Workflow for TEH Studies............................................................................................ 12
Figure 7. Capabilities Development Lifecycle ............................................................................................................. 20
Figure 8. Initial Proposed Organizational Structure for TEHO .................................................................................... 21
Figure 9. TEH End-to-End System Development ........................................................................................................ 22
Figure 10. Framework for Health Informatics.............................................................................................................. 25
Figure 11. Future State of Exposure Data Supporting Theater and Clinical Operations .............................................. 26
Figure 12. The Decreasing Cost of Next Generation Sequencing ................................................................................ 27
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 1
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Total Exposure Health (TEH) is the Air Force Medical Service (AFMS) solution to capture workplace,
environmental and lifestyle exposures to the individual using advances in science, technology &
informatics to prevent disease, preserve health and well-being and develop precision health solutions.
As a new way of delivering care, and responds to both congressional and several national military
readiness strategies such as, the 2013 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) and the 2017
National Security Strategy. To support the TEH capability, the AFMS commissioned the development of
this TEH Strategic Plan to define the responsibilities and processes necessary for the development and
implementation of TEH in a way that brings the most value to the AFMS. By supporting TEH, the
AFMS will lead an innovative approach to protecting its beneficiaries, promoting readiness, and
achieving truly personalized prevention health.
The TEH Strategic Plan will delineate how the focus areas, goals, and objectives for TEH align to the
overarching vision of AFMS: Healthiest Performing Population by 2025. The plan will outline current
and future operational drivers and challenges in healthcare delivery, how TEH addresses those
challenges, and identifies the required capabilities, potential supporting programs, and platforms
necessary for TEH execution. The eight (8) strategic focus areas (below) create a framework for the
Strategic Plan that is aligned with the AFMS strategic direction as determined by our environmental scan
and stakeholder analyses.
 Understand current and emerging trends through studies and analyses to advance primary
prevention
 Ensure compliance with regulatory standards
 Advance Medicine through Research & Development (R&D)
 Build Infrastructure to Support Advances in Healthcare
 Foster a network of collaborative partners
 Increase access to exposure science education and training
 Improve quality of care and encourage good lifestyle choices
 Increase Force Readiness and Human Performance
Through the Strategic Plan, TEH will leverage and advance exposure science, sensors and technologies,
health informatics, and clinical support systems as a cutting edge way to obtain a holistic understanding
of an individual’s health, root causes of disease and injury, and innovative but accessible methods for
primary prevention. The spectrum of resources will include:
 R&D to expand TEH capabilities into sensor, informatics, and database platforms
 Regulatory expertise for TEH deployment
 Infrastructure, resources, and activities management
 Military, public, academic, and private partnerships
 Care provider, workforce, and patient training
 Enhanced support, ancillary services and benefits
 Healthcare delivery towards primary prevention
 Organizational change and Military Readiness supported by validated data
 Individual Exposure Health Risk Profiles (IEHRP)
 Data integration into Individual Longitudinal Exposure Records (ILER)
The Strategic Plan’s near-term goal is to improve exposure characterization and to identify and
understand individual variability, susceptibility, and vulnerability to cumulative exposures. In the long-
term, TEH will translate these findings into clinically actionable recommendations to protect and
improve well-being of military members and their beneficiaries. The bottom line is that TEH is a future-
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 2
focused and progressive approach that represents a disruptive but necessary paradigm shift to help the
Air Force and the Military Health System (MHS) enhance human performance, support force health
protection, and ultimately transition from healthcare to precision health.
2. INTRODUCTION
2.1 BACKGROUND
The AFMS Strategic Vision seeks to ensure that the AFMS’s “supported population is the healthiest and
highest performing segment of the U.S. by 2025.” Achieving this vision will require a paradigm shift in
military medicine – from a primary focus on disease and injury treatment to a more holistic approach
that focuses on health and prevention. TEH is an approach to primary prevention and precision health
that seeks to evaluate the totality of an individual’s exposure history and integrate that with an
individual’s genetic makeup and clinical disposition, in order to understand the root causes of wellness,
injury and disease.
Total Exposure Health was initiated as a “Strategic Directive” through the Air Force Medical Service
FY17-21 MPPG:
“AF/SG/3/5 will define requirements and develop courses of action to integrate health promotion,
occupational health, environmental health, and "hobby health" evaluations to enhance overall delivery of
care in the Air Force Medical Home. Integration of all possible exposure pathways captured in data
analytics to ensure full spectrum of patient lifestyles is considered to create the healthiest segment of the
population by 2025.”
After demonstrating the feasibility of the TEH concept, TEH became an AFMS “Strategic Priority” in
the AFMS FY19-23 MPPG.
“AF/SG/3/5 will create a solution to capture workplace, environment, and lifestyle exposures and
connect to the individual (i.e., genome) in response to mandates in the 2013 National Defense
Authorization Act (NDAA) Section 313, PRD 05, 2017 National Security Strategy, 2015 National Health
Security Strategy, and DoDI 6055.05, using advances in science, technology and informatics to improve
health and well-being of the Air Force beneficiaries – Healthy performing populations by 2025.”
Since its inception, SG3P has been positioning the Air Force to lead the TEH initiative by identifying
collaborative partnerships within AFMS, the military components, Office of the Secretary of Defense,
federal agencies, and academia to integrate exposomics, advances in sensor technology, informatics, and
precision healthcare into TEH. Ultimately the goal of TEH is to prevent illness and disease by informing
Servicemembers and their beneficiaries to make and/or embrace preventive health choices in their
lifestyles, workplaces and homes.
The purpose of this Strategic Plan is to define the focus and goals of the initiative from FY19-23 as it
transitions to an operational Total Exposure Health Office (TEHO) and the methodologies that will be
used to ensure TEHO’s ability to provide support to both AFMS and the larger MHS community in
achieving the Healthy Performing Populations 2025 goal.
TEH to promote a healthy and high performing workforce
The Air Force is dedicated to being the “healthiest and highest performing segment of the US by 2025”.
The AFMS can only achieve Healthiest Population by true prevention and Total Exposure Health positions the AFMS to be
healthiest & highest performing population by 2025 with emphasis on “Personalized Healthcare”, going beyond healing the ill
and preventing early disease.
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 3
2.2 TEHVISION
TEH aims to integrate and provide exposure-related data to individuals, clinicians, and organizations to
improve health-related decision making that will strengthen prevention, human performance, resilience,
workforce, and readiness programs. As shown in Figure 1, TEH will partner across multiple program
areas and integrate occupational, lifestyle, and environmental exposure data from traditional and new
exposure assessment technologies (including sensors and –omics-based molecular biology) with clinical
and genomic data. Leveraging a Big Data infrastructure and advanced analytics, TEH will provide a new
and novel capability that will inform and encourage healthy lifestyle choices, enhance resilience and
human performance, and reduce illness and injury. These capabilities will inform preventive strategies by
reducing the health impacts of exposures, hence improving human performance and readiness of all
Airmen. Moreover, by educating individuals about their exposure profile, TEH will enable individuals
and families to make healthy lifestyle choices and become proactive about their own health.
THE VISION STATEMENT:
“Total Exposure Health (TEH) program will enrich the clinical/patient experience allowing beneficiaries
to take control of their own health.”
TEH MISSION STATEMENT:
“Total Exposure Health will achieve precision health through advances in medicine, sciences,
technology and informatics using interactive and transparent precision health information platforms to
improve health and well-being of all Air Force beneficiaries.”
Figure 1. Vision for TEH Portfolio
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 4
2.3 CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES
Organizational Change and New Collaborations. TEH aims to transform the current state of disparate
exposure monitoring, research studies, data collection, and healthcare records to holistic and integrated
systems that quantitate total exposure and inform health outcomes (Figure 2) into actionable insights and
initiatives.
1
* SEG – Similar Exposure Group
Current State - Prev Med Future State – Prev Med
Work exposure with limited
environmental and lifestyle exposures
Work, environment and lifestyle (home,
recreation, etc) exposures
Animal models of exposures are applied
to population and (SEG)* with safety
factors for Airmen protection and clinical
intervention
Individual exposure applied to each
Airman’s genome with tailored
interventions to include prevention,
protection, career, placement and clinical
Limited sensors (time, sensitivity,
analytes)
Individual and area sensors with full
analyte complement, real time/all-the-
time, sensitive to human based exposure
levels
Clinical intervention based on organ
function disruption/damage
Clinical intervention based on molecular
biology changes brought by exposure
Paper-based exposure summary
somewhere in the clinical record
Expert system (EHR) matching billions of
bits of information (DNA, sensor, etc)
relevant to exposure with clinical
recommendation
Prevention concerns applied post-
occupational/lifestyle choice
Prevention of key health outcomes part of
the care decision for career/life from
recruitment to separation/retirement
TEH
Figure 2. Current State and Future State with TEH
In its current state the MHS is experiencing multiple challenges which are affecting quality, access and
readiness while increasing costs. To boost military readiness, reduce cost, and improve quality and
access, the MHS enterprise is modernizing its institutional health system to combine prevention with
treatment which will reduce clinical errors, improve workflows and enhance clinical outcomes with
improved patient engagement. By integrating with various MHS change management and trusted care
paradigms, TEH can save lives, money and improve force readiness.
The challenges presented by developing TEH capabilities
vary from organizational coordination across a complex
set of stakeholders to funding and research prioritization.
With the advent of the Defense Health Agency (DHA),
TEH capability development must eventually work in a
joint environment resulting in the addition of multiple
stakeholders and less direct control. Synchronization and
optimization of R&D efforts, policy and programs begin
with the AFMS Panels which are extended to other
Services and the interagency space, as well as commercial
and academic partners. This process increases the
complexity and breadth of stakeholder management,
which will be addressed through the TEHO and a cross
functional team of subject matter experts (SMEs) to
negotiate programmatic boundaries and concerns.
TEH and its impact on human health will rely on collecting,
integrating, and analyzing a dataset of diverse variables like never before (Figure 3). Staying abreast of
developments within the rapidly evolving areas of exposomics, precision medicine, genomics, sensors,
health information technology (HIT) and Big Data analytics will require a broad spectrum of resources,
analytics, and technology, as well as a far reaching network of academic, industry, and federal agency
partnerships. Furthermore, competition for research funding warrants TEH capability development efforts
Figure 3. TEH Variables
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 5
be coordinated with a diverse set of stakeholders to ensure their needs are met and leveraged to provide
effective support to ongoing research activities.
Policies. After the military’s experiences with Agent Orange exposure during the Vietnam War and the
significant adverse health claims by Servicemembers deployed to the Persian Gulf War, the necessity to
monitor and document the health status of military forces was codified into Public Law 105-85 in 19971
whereupon the Department of Defense (DoD) was mandated to develop a deployment health surveillance
system to detect, prevent, or minimize health problems arising as a result of environmental exposures
during deployments and operations. This mandate has been followed by various policies2
to standardize
basic medical record keeping across the Services.
Expectations for deployment health surveillance and record keeping remain high as military personnel
continue to be deployed overseas in support of operational missions. More recently, the 2013 National
Defense Appropriations Act (NDAA) Section 313 mandated the Military to collect, document and act on
long-term environmental health risks in garrison.2
TEH will help to comply with current policy while informing future policy with more precise information
to better leverage our limited resources by leveraging recent advances in exposure science, sensor and data
technologies, health informatics, and clinical support systems to establish a more complete understanding
of an individual’s health and risks, root causes of disease and injury, and translating them into policy.
Opportunities. Opportunities exist based upon the disruptive growth and shift in exposure assessment
technologies for the Air Force (AF), DoD, and beyond. TEH will transition traditional clinical care into
personalized health as a better understanding of the relationships between exposures (i.e., internal vs.
external and harmful vs. beneficial) and health outcomes (positive and negative) is established. As a
result, the AFMS will be able to develop preventive and protective recommendations, based upon an
individual’s unique health profile and exposures, for improving health and well-being. For example,
through TEH, sensor technologies integrated with existing and emerging data platforms will be used to
detect environmental, occupational, and lifestyle exposures in real or near real-time to capture a
comprehensive longitudinal exposure record. Human genomic data from next generation sequencing and
exposure data will be integrated using bioinformatics to develop individual health risk profiles that will
support the development of a more advanced Clinical Decision Support System (CDSS) to complement
clinical and personal interventions.
A critical element of TEH involves the ability to centralize disparate and unstructured data from past
exposure data archives as well as current exposure data collection efforts to derive maximal value from
both historical and on-going work in this area. These existing resources will be used to assess the
relationships between an individual’s genetic predispositions, epigenetic factors, and exposure to
chemicals from lifestyle, occupation, and the environment. Thus, this initiative will support development
of diagnostic approaches, treatment methods, and intervention strategies that efficiently and appropriately
integrate all available data. In due course, there may also be substantial research value in this dataset (i.e.
the ability to discover new relationships that influence health and risk).
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 6
3. STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS
TEH has eight areas aligned with the AFMS strategic map. These areas of focus guide the strategic
goals and activities of the TEH Initiative (Figure 4).
Figure 4. Focus Areas of the Future TEH
3.1 STUDIES AND ANALYSES
To achieve TEH’s vision of acting as an integrator of multiple research, policy, and health efforts, TEH
will continue to initiate studies and demonstrations that help understand and characterize the roles and
activities the TEH Initiative should support. Due to the rapid pace of technological advancement (such as
genomics, medicine, sensors and informatics) and the changing legislative environment (such as new
presidential initiatives, healthcare policies, etc.), the TEHO will conduct environmental scans, literature
reviews, and market research to develop materials to better inform policy and the allocation of resources
to support and transform military healthcare.
3.2 RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT
The challenge for developing TEH capabilities is bringing together distinct systems and initiatives into
one portfolio: integrating exposure science, information technology, and existing healthcare programs to
TEH aims to streamline cross-cutting studies and analyses
Federal agencies, Services and academia are working on a myriad of Studies and Analysis (S&A) from prevention to cures,
using genomics, sensors, and Big Data. There is no overarching program of record to bring these disparate, resource-
intensive, activities together. TEH S&A environmental scans and market assessments will identify existing and current S&A
for proper resource allocation.
Imagine the Air Force, Navy, Army, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), and Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) working on studies for a perfluoroalkyls (e.g., PFOA and PFOS) sensor, a wide-spread contaminant
in the environment. The TEH S&A would identify any duplication of effort and recommend actions that may support all the
studies, a mix, or one to reduce duplication and reprogram funding towards other high priority studies.
Noise study to identify hearing loss risk
Currently the USAF School of Aerospace Medicine (USAFSAM) is working on a “noise” exposure TEH research
demonstration to demonstrate the ability to collect, store, and utilize unstructured “noise” exposure data to identify the unique
health risk associated with noise and manage Noise Induced Hearing Loss (NIHL). The demonstration will pull all the aspects
of TEH (sensing, seeing and action) with data to include: sensor, survey, DOEHRS, and genetics.
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 7
develop end-to-end systems. For the current and near-term, TEH has identified the key areas within
science and technology that research and development should be focused; including, but not limited to
science, engineering, medicine, and informatics. TEH aims to expand the standalone fields of study and
integrate them into a system that can transform exposure data into behavioral and clinical actions. Sensor
technologies integrated with existing and emerging data platforms will be leveraged to detect
environmental, occupational, and lifestyle exposures in near-/real-time to capture a comprehensive
exposure record that can identify risk factors and inform risk prevention.
Human genomic data generated from next generation sequencing and exposure data will be combined
through bioinformatics to develop individual exposure health risk profiles using informatics to support
the development of a more advanced CDSS to compliment clinical and personal interventions.
3.3 PARTNERSHIPS AND COLLABORATIONS
TEH is at the epicenter to focus synergistic initiatives within the Air Force, DoD, and at national levels to
advance health and healthcare with advances in science, technology, medicine, and informatics.
Establishing public-public and public-private partnerships will ensure appropriate coordination and
support, while minimizing duplicative efforts—a key priority for TEH. These partnerships will also help
to ensure data sharing, dissemination of results, and efficient use of resources, particularly in constrained
budgetary environments. It is paramount that partnerships and collaborations are created to form shared
resources and link together existing initiatives to move forward with the best value and minimize the
number of new efforts, which are increasingly difficult to fund in today’s constrained budgets.
R&D will be a major focus for TEH and the questions that TEH will tackle will be large, challenging
problems that are best addressed through collaborative efforts. For example, sharing of best practices and
lessons learned across the exposomics community will be critical to advancing the state of the science,
particularly as the tools and technologies central to TEH are still rapidly evolving. This approach will be
used to ensure that TEH is using cutting edge technologies, and focusing on unique research areas and
topics, without duplicating efforts, that will supplement existing initiatives and take TEH to the next
level of actionable healthcare decision support.
3.4 REGULATORY
There are numerous policy, legal and ethical considerations regarding the execution of TEH that must be
addressed while active studies are being conducted and before full implementation of TEH. Planning
and development of study documentation for research protocols is a lengthy, technical process and a
deep understanding of the requirements is essential to initiating studies without delays. It is important to
ensure that a lack of regulation does not become an obstacle to the implementation of R&D. Compliance
to regulatory guidelines must be considered at several levels across multiple agencies. Communications
with relevant agencies (e.g., OSHA, DHA and FDA) must start early and remain on-going so to ensure
existing compliance as well as anticipate future regulatory issues. Examples of issues that need to be
Accelerating AFMS Research by Leveraging Partners’ Existing Collaborations
SG3/5 is working with various federal, academic and private sector entities. One example is our work with the Pacific
Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), a leader in exposure sciences and genetics. Given PNNL’s unique position as a
national laboratory, AFMS has positioned assets to develop and integrate AFMS research using PNNL as an access
point to consortium of institutions from academia, the private sector, and other federal agencies.
Consequences of Exposure Data Collection
Imagine a Servicemember purchased an off-the-shelf wearable pollution monitor to monitor/control their Chronic Obstructive
Pulmonary Disease only to find out that their workplace was not safe. Will the Air Force allow personal devices into the
workplace? What are the ethical legal, policy implications? This is one of many complex issues associated with all aspects
of TEH that need to be addressed.
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 8
addressed include revisions and implementation of TEH in accordance with the Affordable Care Act
(ACA), compliance with military regulations for meaningful use of personalized data, the Genetic
Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA), and exposure data to improve both individual and
population health, as well as policy support to allow deployment of new technologies and tools such as
wearables and sensors to workplace environment.
With the advent and introduction of new technologies (sensors), clinical diagnostics (genetics) and
information technology (Big Data) within and outside the military workplace various ethical and privacy
issues will surface that will need deeper investigation. The findings, challenges and opportunities will
drive both policy and operations for early and future adoption. Therefore, it will be critical to ensure these
issues are identified and planned for with execution based on current rules, standards, and guidance.
The TEHO will take all these issues into consideration as they program and plan with a focus on realistic
adoption within the current ethical, social and legal constraints while pushing for the adoption, use, and
integration of advances in science, medicine, and information technology to improve the health and
welfare of our forces.
3.5 INFRASTRUCTURE
The optimal infrastructure to support the TEH program should include but not be limited to resources such
as sensor platforms, database servers, high-performance computing, and the cloud. TEH-related programs
such as the Personal Exposure Monitor (PEM), Coriell Hearing Study3
, Digital Biobank, Bio-
environmental Threat Surveillance (BETS), Defense Occupational and Environmental Health Readiness
System (DOEHRS), and BLUE Longitudinal Exposure Record (BLER), are stood up through separate but
linked AFMS and DoD programs. Furthermore, besides Information Technology (IT) infrastructure, the
AFMS needs to define the needs to support all aspects of TEH, including laboratory and medical support.
The requirement here is to determine what distinct resources and infrastructure TEH will need to support
functional integration and fill gaps not provided by the related initiatives.
3.6 HEALTH AND HEALTHCARE
TEH will usher in a disruptive paradigm shift in healthcare. Whereas most providers care is oriented
toward “disease/illness care,” with TEH and other related initiatives, including the AFMS-led Digital
Biobank under their Precision Medicine Program, education for healthcare providers at all levels can
begin leaning more heavily toward prevention. The knowledge provided by TEH will foster an
understanding of how to interpret and integrate a wide variety of exposure-related data (including but not
limited to occupational, environmental, genomic, and health behavior data from new media) into clinical
practice and preventive medicine to optimize human performance and readiness. Ultimately, this will
allow individuals to take ownership of their health and to be more informed about their health-related
choices and behaviors.
The Collection, Storage, and Retrieval of Exposure Data Enables Personalized Healthcare Delivery
to Our Servicemembers and Veterans
A Servicemember is going to an appointment at her local clinic. He/she discusses their concerns related to
deployments and the impact it may have on her health and the health of her family. With her exposure record
available through the future TEH system, the provider can see all of her personal and group exposure histories with
interpretations to make the best possible education and health plan.
TEH Systems Will Reveal Unexpected Health Risks and Their Root Cause
A Servicemember authorizes genetic testing for a newborn family member and it reveals sensitivity to certain pesticides. The
end-point of TEH is to give providers a Clinical Decision Support System (CDSS) that will flag providers to such findings and
combine them with data from a variety of sources (sensors, medical records, lifestyle, occupational hazards, etc.) and
nonclinical data sources to include “smart base” data like Civil engineering pesticide application. When the clinician reviews
the CDSS information for this family it shows that in addition to the genetic sensitivity to pesticides, they are vegetarian and
live in a rural setting, thus potentially exposing them to higher pesticide levels. This information allows the provider to order
specific diagnostic tests and provide appropriate clinical interventions.
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 9
3.7 TRAINING
Additional training and education will also need to be developed for AFMS beneficiaries, including
Servicemembers, family members, as well as veterans and retirees who receive healthcare through the
AFMS and the MHS. The resulting health system will be a participant-engaged and data-driven endeavor
that synthesizes with advances in understanding human biology, behavior, genetics, occupation and
environment, along with data and computational science to produce new knowledge that reveals new
pathways for promoting health, enhancing human and operational performance, and preventing and
treating disease.
Once exposure records are accessible to healthcare providers and staffs, they will need training programs
to ensure they understand how to evaluate exposure data and utilize it to support their healthcare decisions.
Clinicians’ understanding of their patient’s symptoms will be less reliant on self-reporting and enhanced
by technology. Additionally, the limited and static snapshot of their patient’s health available during
examination will be less dependent on patients to conduct the burdensome task of self-logging often
undependable diaries of symptoms, exposures, and behaviors.
The TEH Initiative will not only affect clinicians, nurses, and other healthcare professionals. New training
and education will also need to be developed for the Air Force Bioenvironmental Engineering, Public
Health, and numerous other members of the exposure science, preventive medicine, and public health
functions of the AFMS so they can properly understand and leverage these advances in data collection,
computational biology, toxicology, toxicogenomics, and other rapidly evolving disciplines. By doing so,
the AFMS and by extension the DoD can assess, quantify, and understand exposures which in turn will
strengthen AFMS precision medicine, preventive medicine, population health, human performance, and
readiness initiatives.
3.8 READINESS
Before a Senate Appropriations Panel committee meeting on March 9, 2016, Air Force Surgeon General,
Lieutenant General Mark A. Ediger said, “The broad scope of care we provide is key to our readiness.” 4
If the broad scope of care the AFMS provides is the key to our readiness, then a TEH-informed health
system is an enabler of readiness on several levels. First, TEH will provide clinicians , nurses and other
healthcare professionals and staff with a much richer and knowledge-conveying set of data regarding
exposures as well as individual (e.g., genomics, metabolomics, pre-existing conditions, etc.)
susceptibilities to use in primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention efforts and the Air Force’s
Personalized Medicine Program (PMP), all of which increase readiness. Second, this expanded and
enriched data will drive an increased understanding of exposure-disease relationships and individual
susceptibilities that will optimize the deployment screening process to more accurately and tightly
identify those individuals with true deployment-limiting medical conditions—which increases readiness
Training and Education: How Understanding Genes Can Modify Behaviors
As we learn more about genetics, both patients and providers will realize we are more unique than previously thought. This
has already been shown in exposure to noise, with recent understanding that a collection of genes significantly affect
predisposition for hearing-loss and likely elucidate different levels of risk (risk profiles). Training and education will play a
crucial role in TEH, particularly when individuals and healthcare professionals will need to understand what personalized risk
profiles mean and how guidance will be best implemented in changing behaviors to prevent hearing loss through advanced
technology and lifestyle/workplace modifications.
TEH Together with Other AFMS Domains, Ultimately Improves Force Health and Readiness
In response to the Global Health Engagement, the exposure health data from TEH will enhance the AFMS
integrative/integrated medicine initiatives. Additionally by incorporating the exposure data from various geographic areas, we
can ensure our deploying forces have the most accurate medical intelligence with emphasis on their unique deployment
history and protective equipment.
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 10
and reduces the likelihood of putting individual’s in harm’s way. For example, with the development of
the ILER, TEH capabilities can improve military operation decision making by identifying personnel
who may be susceptible to certain exposures. Third, by empowering individuals with information about
their health, their exposures, and their unique individual susceptibilities, we will be arming them with
information to drive health behavior change and improve readiness.
4. EXECUTION STRATEGY: STRATEGIC GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
Setting clear goals is critical for TEH to maximize how it can benefit AFMS, existing research and health
programs, and the health of the community. Each of the following goals reflect a targeted approach to
delivering tangible results and deliverables in alignment with the TEH Focus Areas (Figure 5).
Figure 5. TEH Strategic Goals
GOAL 1: SYNTHESIZE, IDENTIFY, AND UNDERSTAND CURRENT AND EMERGING
TRENDS THROUGH STUDIES AND ANALYSES TO ADVANCE PREVENTION
STRATEGIES
There is currently an explosion of studies, research and technical development in the fields of
medicine, genomics, science, technology, informatics, and Big Data in the exposure sciences5
. To
systematically identify, and understand current and future TEH efforts, robust studies and analyses
are required to reduce duplication, partner with similarly minded groups, and focus on exposure
science initiatives that have military relevance. This process will require a comprehensive analysis
and cataloging of current and emerging technologies in the fields listed below.
 Genomics, Exposomics, “omics”
 Sensor and mobile applications
 Big Data (storage, transfer and use)
 Informatics
 Medicine
 Healthcare Policies
 Precision and personalized medicine
 Public Health and Environmental Monitoring
Goal 1 Example Activities and Milestones
Conduct a systematic literature analysis
Develop mechanisms to continuously learn about
emerging technologies that are not yet
published/publicized
Drive policy change and implementation into
healthcare delivery
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 11
Goal 2 Example Activities and Milestones
Develop evaluation criteria and selection processes
with TEH Stakeholders to determine which
technologies to support and implement on a cyclical
basis
Finalize and execute the Strategic Technical Plan
(Chapter 6)
Coordinate demonstrations of supported research
Support new and innovative studies on the
exposure sciences.
Partner with scientists to influence study design to
maximize efficiency during regulatory approval
processes
OBJECTIVE.1.1: SYSTEMATIC LITERATURE, WEB AND FUNDING ANALYSIS
The TEHO will become the centralized repository for everything exposure science related and will tie
specific research, technologies, initiatives, and programs to each AFMS panel to integrate into the
healthcare delivery system.
OBJECTIVE 1.2: CONTINUOUSLY LEARN
As the central repository for everything exposure science the TEHO will advance science and technology
while supporting the evolution and development of policies to support TEH implementation.
Through this process TEH will support the development of improved methodologies for sharing available
information, findings, and data in the exposure sciences and the expansion of studies and analyses, both
within DoD and through external stakeholders.
4.2 GOAL 2: ADVANCE HEALTH AND HEALTHCARE THROUGH RESEARCH AND
DEVELOPMENT
A defining characteristic of TEH is its use of
technology to ultimately drive personalized evidence-
based medicine that will enrich the patient/provider
relationship transferring ownership to the individual
to ultimately encourage health-promoting behaviors.
TEH also promotes the promise of Big Data, which is
sensing (collecting exposures with sensors), seeing
(using informatics to make sense of the data) and
acting (using expert systems so clinicians can make
better interventions).
Therefore one of TEH’s strategic goals is to advance
the state of research and development that is relevant
to furthering exposure detection and our ability to
make use of large volumes of disparate datasets that will eventually contain information about the
individual’s exposure, clinical disposition and genetics. This integration of disparate and unstructured
data will require a comprehensive analysis and cataloging of current and emerging technologies in the
fields listed below.
 Data collection tools and mechanisms (e.g., sensors, smartphone apps, Internet-of-Things (IoT)
 Technologies that facilitate the feasibility of transferring exposure and health data
 Solutions and infrastructure that are able to manage large volumes of disparate data
 Solutions that enable rapid and more efficient analytics of this data
 Expert health IT systems that facilitate the incorporation and use of data by healthcare providers
 Solutions that enable use of exposure data for individual as well as population health through
surveillance, warning, and countermeasure methods
TEHO aims to expand and optimize AFMS capabilities in technology; sensor development, data
analytics, and health IT systems. The deployment and integration of the future R&D portfolio of TEH
will allow AFMS to improve the health and well-being of its beneficiaries while reducing healthcare
associated costs, manpower, and staff burden.
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 12
4.3 GOAL 3: ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH REGULATORY STANDARDS
The healthcare industry and military medicine are in
constant flux driven by complex current and emerging
policy initiatives. The excess of existing policy
associated with the complexities of the TEH initiative
is daunting and requires a catalog to address not only
the exposure science issues but also those concerning
preventive medicine, genomics, technology, and
information technology to name a few. A holistic view
is needed to identify existing policies and also to
integrate TEH precepts as new and emerging policies
are developed to reap the benefits of the TEH approach
to improve the delivery of healthcare.
Figure 6. Sample Regulatory Workflow for TEH Studies
For example, the TEH goal of integrating wearable sensors, personal exposome data gathering,
genomics, and next generation electronic health records presents a unique and complex challenge with
respect to the spectrum of quality and regulatory requirements that govern this space. The cutting-edge
nature of TEH is more advanced than the policy and guidance materials that are currently in place.
Therefore, due to the absence of strong regulatory information, some additional delays in navigating the
protocol review and approval process are expected. Figure 6 illustrates several stages of development,
review, and approval authority signatories that TEH SMEs will obtain before TEH research with human
subjects can begin. Fortunately, some elements can be done simultaneously and some approvals may not
be required in the near-term.
OBJECTIVE 1: SYSTEMATIC POLICY AND REGULATORY REVIEW
TEH will require a comprehensive scan of existing policies and regulations around personalized sensors,
wearables, and the use of genetic data and will identify areas where TEH can be integrated into existing
DoD healthcare and public health policies and guidance.
OBJECTIVE 2: REVIEW OF REGULATORY PROCEDURES AND COMPLIANCE MANUALS
Since TEH will be using sensors and personalized wearables and individual genetic sequencing, these
issues need to comply with documents, lists, policies, programs, and statements relating to compliance
references used by FDA.
Goal 3 Example Activities and Milestones
Catalog all existing policy, guidance and
recommendations associated with the TEH initiative.
Identify and stay abreast of policies associated with
technologies that may not have designated
approval processes
Integrate TEH concepts into current and emerging
policy and guidance.
Be involved in the shaping of regulatory policies for
emerging technology
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 13
4.4 GOAL 4: BUILD INFRASTRUCTURE TO SUPPORT ADVANCES IN HEALTHCARE
Full implementation of TEH throughout the AFMS enterprise will require an infrastructure that supports
both the clinical and technology advancements to healthcare. This will need to be a carefully phased,
incremental approach for providing clinical support such as labs, pharmacy, etc.
Technology, applications, informatics networks, and participation by the vast population of Military and
their beneficiaries will need a significant initial investment and operating cost, though the expectation of
healthcare cost saving will justify the investment. Paramount to developing a TEH infrastructure will be
leveraging existing systems, working with currently
successful processes and innovative technology, and
collaborating closely with agencies under a similar
mission so to reduce costs and drive infrastructure
building forward in an efficient way.
The TEHO will also have established structures to
meet the objectives outlined for each of its goals.
These structures serve as building blocks for future
innovation and expansion. The organization of
TEHO (see Figure 8 in Section 5.2) depicts how these structures work together to support the current
AFMS healthcare infrastructure to be the healthiest and highest performing population by 2025.
The reach of Medical Support touches upon all future stakeholders of TEH including Benefits, Laboratory,
IM/IT, and Pharmacy. Furthermore, one of the main near-term objectives of TEH is to transform exposure
data into an individual health exposure risk profile that can be integrated into ILERs and ultimately be
interoperable with DoD electronic health record (EHR), MHS GENESIS. Together, TEHO aims to work
with Medical Support to develop guides and implementation policies relevant to information assurance and
Medical Records Management and execution of the Health Information Portability and Accountability Act
(HIPAA) as it relates to the operation of TEH technologies and services.
OBJECTIVE4.1: CONDUCT AN ENVIRONMENTAL SCAN OF EXISTING AFMS INFRASTRUCTURE
A comprehensive analysis of how to integrate existing IT systems and infrastructure to help TEH
identify current and future needs, and drive an AFMS wide modernization initiative that will support
TEH and other upcoming healthcare needs and challenges must be conducted.
OBJECTIVE4.2: PILOT TEST NEW PLATFORMS UNDER AFMS’S SECURE ENVIRONMENT
To ensure optimal integration of new tools and technologies for TEH initiative, pilot testing the most
critical technologies will be a necessary step to secure full integration of new systems into existing
infrastructure and also ensure interoperability and health information exchange among systems.
OBJECTIVE 4.3: IDENTIFY CURRENT AND FUTURE PHARMACY AND LABORATORY NEEDS
As TEH R&D matures there will be an expansion of various biomarkers and genetic testing required to
understand the individual’s health risks. Once the health risks are identified through environmental scans,
the Studies and Analysis and R&D focus areas, various pharmacological alternatives may exist or need
to be created that will eventually get on the AFMS formulary.
4.5 GOAL 5: FOSTER A NETWORK OF INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL COLLABORATIVE
PARTNERS
In order to efficiently maximize the capabilities and comprehensiveness of TEH supported risk
assessments and future CDSS in a resource constrained environment, a central goal of TEH is
maintaining relationships with multiple programs and initiatives that can provide rich sources of data.
TEH will accomplish this by fostering a network of partners within the AFMS, across the DoD, other
federal agencies (e.g., Department of Health and Human Services, National Institutes of Health (NIH),
NIOSH, and throughout industry and the private sector.
Goal 4 Example Activities and Milestones
Leverage understanding of emerging technology
and health trends gained from Goals 1 and 2 to
identify capability and capacity gaps
Engage with leadership within AFMS and MHS such
as Medical Support to ensure infrastructure
expansions can be integrated with preexisting and
future systems
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 14
 Within the Air Force: TEH will collaborate
with AF/SG5 derived R&D and studies and
analysis programs to support development of
individual sensor, communications and
analytics systems for individual exposure
monitoring, data integration and smart system
analytics for integration into MHS GENESIS.
TEH will also support staff’s ability to better
collect exposures, translate these data, and
implement protective and medical
interventions. As TEH evolves, TEH will remain engaged with AF entities outside of AFMS,
including Civil Engineering, Services, Human Resources and the Chief Information Officer (CIO),
to shape policy and implement TEH developed innovations to integrate with the “Smart Bases”
concept, for example.
 MHS & DoD: As TEH matures, TEH can apply its experience expanding capabilities within
AFMS to support development of a similar system across the larger Defense Health Agency while
collaborating with MHS and DoD efforts, such as the Center for Deployment Health Research &
Millennium Cohort Study and the Collaborative Health Initiative Research Program.
 Initiatives in the Public Sector: Due to resources needed to handle the size and complexity of data
involved in TEH analyses, TEH aims to bring together community resources wherever possible.
Federal organizations such as the NIH, NIOSH, CDC, and EPA, have all conducted research on
occupational and environmental exposures, biomonitoring, and exposure versus effect. Key
exposome initiatives in Europe and the United States could prove to be particularly valuable
partners for TEH.
 Academia and National Laboratories: Leveraging current relationships with various academic
institutions and National laboratories, such as, PNNL and expanding relationships will be key to
bringing the best in class solutions to the TEH initiative. With the rapid changes in science,
technology, medicine and informatics developing relationships outside the military complex will
be critical to advancing the product needs to support TEH.
 Private Sector & Industry: The issues related to delivering healthcare and ensuring employee
productivity and health are not restricted to the AF or the DOD, these issues burden our entire
healthcare system as well as employers. By fostering public/private relationships we can work
together to solve complex problems for the federal government. We will promote and foster
innovation by enabling the rapid development and transition of critical technologies and services
for use to resolve complex TEH issues and stimulate the transition of cutting-edge, innovative
lifesaving and outcome-improving technologies and services to the commercial/private sector.
OBJECTIVE 5.1: PARTNER WITH AFMS PANELS AND TO DEVELOP INTERNAL TEH SUPPORT
Establish a TEH advisory board that will be structured from AFMS Panel members and SME’s to help
drive TEH initiative, but also through their expertise and understanding of current operations and
developments to help identify needs and overcome challenges related to TEH efforts.
OBJECTIVE.5.2: EXPAND AND DEVELOP PUBLIC-PUBLIC COLLABORATIONS
Identify public stakeholders with focus on TEH and its concepts, including public sector agencies, non-
profit organizations, and promote and support communication, collaboration, and innovations in areas of
interest for AFMS and TEH through collaborative programs and funding initiatives.
OBJECTIVE.5.3: INSTITUTIONALIZE PUBLIC-PRIVATE COLLABORATIONS
Focus on the development and support of public-private partnerships (PPP) (over the more traditional
market-driven models), that will drive innovation and help promote the adoption and implementation of
TEH concepts and efforts from personal to institutional and public health levels. Through these
collaborations, private and public stakeholders can work together to identify and overcome risks and
Goal 5 Example Activities and Milestones
Identify the most impactful conferences and meetings
to hold oral presentations and workshops
Establish roles within the office to handle
MOUs, MTAs, teaming agreements, etc.
Once a group of partnerships are established, plan
and host annual TEH symposium
Publish review articles and book chapters on TEH
concepts and exposomics
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 15
challenges and share the benefits of this collaboration.
4.6 GOAL 6: PROVIDE ENHANCED EXPOSURE HEALTH EDUCATION AND TRAINING
In order to truly realize the beneficial impact of TEH, the individual, health providers and public health
professionals play a major role in changing the current paradigm of care into one that takes a holistic
approach to preventing disease and promoting health. Therefore, as technologies such as sensors,
exposomics, and individual exposure risk profiles
mature, TEH will work with Force Development to
identify training needs for clinical and non-clinical
career fields to develop and implement training
programs dedicated to transforming health and
science roles to include exposure science. Exposure
science will for example:
 Increase the public health professionals’
awareness and knowledge of the exposure
sciences through the use of sensors and Big
Data platforms to improve surveillance
 Train clinicians in interpreting new exposure and susceptibility data as it becomes more integrated
with clinical records, to increase exposure data’s role in clinical decision support.
 Expand scientific and engineering roles into the exposure science field.
The development of these training programs will involve an integrated approach from all the AFMS
panels as well as programmatic leads from the scientific, policy, and IT domains to develop the strategy,
prioritize the curriculum and resources needed to execute the training.
TEH will work with Force Development Panel SMEs and stakeholders and with public health
professionals to develop TEH within the Military Force through guidance, training, and providing a
knowledge base resource.
Education and training is not limited to clinical and non-clinical staff, it also requires training and
education for AFMS beneficiaries and the civilian workforce to help them better understand the
exposures not only in their workplace but through their individual choices and the environment they live
in. To identify these current and emerging needs, the TEHO will work with industry, academic, and
public sector SMEs to emphasize AFMS TEH.
OBJECTIVE 6.1: DEVELOP NEW EDUCATION RESOURCES FOR MEDICAL STAFF
Develop web portals populated with informational material about the scope and importance of TEH and
exposomics in promoting individual health and population/public health, and how these initiatives can
support personalized and precision medicine initiatives, reduce healthcare cost, and promote healthy
living.
OBJECTIVE 6.2: DEVELOP A COMMUNICATIONS PLAN
Communication plans will be developed to include medical staff, nonmedical staff and beneficiaries to
ensure understanding of TEH capabilities as they are available throughout the development. The
communications plan will include information on promoting individual and family health through
advancements in personalized medicine, healthy choices and enhanced understanding of personal and
family exposures.
Goal 6 Example Activities and Milestones
Make available review articles and book chapters
on TEH concepts and exposomics to the medical
staff (Communications Plan)
As TEH data matures, develop materials for user-
specific training modules to enable patients, care
providers, etc., to understand and use exposure data
to benefit health
Apply for Continuing Medical Education
accreditation to provide industry recognized training
to healthcare professionals
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 16
Goal 7 Example Activities and Milestones
Enhance Engagement with AF line leadership and
stakeholders
Integration of Individual Longitudinal Exposure
Records (ILERs) into EHRs allowing providers to
understand patients’ health even without clinical
presentation which is difficult to capture
Development of push-pull orbidirectionaluser-
friendly mobile applications that not only push
exposure data
4.7 GOAL 7: IMPROVE QUALITY OF CARE AND ENCOURAGE GOOD LIFESTYLE CHOICES
According to the 2014 MHS Review, there are
approximately 10M beneficiaries while there are
0.25M primary care physicians6, 7
. Given this ratio,
it is extremely challenging to achieve the patient-
provider relationship necessary for personalized
care.
TEH equips healthcare providers in 4 ways:
 Individual exposure records allow physicians
to more easily understand a patient’s
exposure and risk history that may contribute to their concerns.
 Integration of TEH data into expert systems (e.g. clinical decision support systems) helps care
providers make decisions more efficiently about screenings, diagnostics, and treatments to
prescribe.
 Identify and leverage health promotion activities, campaigns and practices that improve lifestyle
decisions and behaviors.
 Improve patient and family activation and engagement.
Realizing the pathway from monitoring exposures and translating them into a succinct patient/provider
clinical dashboard is in the distant future; we must recognize the potential of the future and work towards
it. By incrementally introducing the precepts into policy, technology and medical operations, the benefits
of TEH will gradually be realized by the entire medical enterprise.
Beyond creating an enriching clinical experience that will translate into positive behavioral changes,
TEH also aims to simultaneously enable Airman and beneficiaries to easily understand their exposures
and its effect on their health through an integrated approach with AFMS Health Promotions,
Occupational and Preventive Medicine. This could be accomplished through reports similar to those
provided in genomic services such as 23andMe or through mobile applications where individuals can
track their exposures in real time similar to the Fitbit’s or Apple Health’s mobile applications.
Collectively, TEH will bridge the divide between the care provider and the patient where the patient is
better equipped to take ownership of their healthcare with information and to participate in the
development of clinical plans that are individualized to encourage healthy lifestyle choices, safer
workplaces and a better understanding of the environment to enhance human performance and military
operations.
OBJECTIVE 7.1: DEVELOP NEW PATIENT FACING EDUCATION TOOLS AND RESOURCES
Provide beneficiaries and their families general information about exposures, how they affect their health,
how AFMS is prioritizing exposure science, and how patients can improve their overall health and
performance by adopting and promoting healthy lifestyle’s and health choices.
OBJECTIVE.7.2: DEVELOP INTERACTIVE TOOLS AND DASHBOARDS FOR PATIENTS TO FOLLOW THEIR
HEALTH
Patient facing tools and dashboard can be developed and integrated into the new MHS GENESIS for
beneficiaries to allow them to track their health, set up goals, and provide them with smart choices and
advise about protecting their health, adopting healthy choices, and recognizing and limiting harmful
exposures.
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 17
Goal 8 Example Activities and Milestones
Engage with Force Development leadership and
stakeholders
Integration of Individual Longitudinal Exposure
Records (ILERs) into EHRs allowing physicians to
understand patients’ health even without clinical
presentation which is difficult to capture
4.8 GOAL 8: OPTIMIZE FORCE READINESS AND HUMAN PERFORMANCE BY REDUCING
HAZARDOUS EXPOSURES
A TEH informed health system enhances and enables readiness. TEH will provide healthcare providers
with a knowledge-conveying set of data regarding exposures as well as individual (e.g., genomics,
metabolomics, pre-existing conditions, etc.)
susceptibilities to use in primary, secondary, and
tertiary prevention efforts and the Air Force’s
Personalized Medicine Program, all of which increase
readiness.
 This expanded data will drive an increased
understanding of exposure-disease
relationships and individual susceptibilities that will optimize the deployment screening process by
more accurately and specifically identifying those individuals with true deployment-limiting
medical conditions—which increases readiness and reduces the likelihood of putting individuals’
in harm’s way.
 Empowering individuals with information about their health, their exposures, and their unique
individual susceptibilities, will enable them with information to drive health promoting and health
improving behaviors which again increases readiness.
 TEH mitigates exposure to improve performance by providing the proper intervention geared to
the individual and their medial disposition, exposure and genetic propensity.
To reduce risks TEH will use exposure risk indices that will be part of the CDSS to develop protocols or
courses of action (COA) to enhance prevention and protect military members from chronic and adverse
exposures. Collectively TEH creates the ability to reduce the potential outcome of the exposure through
various means such as removing the hazard, changing the operational process, instituting engineering
controls, and implementing personal protective countermeasures such as gear or vaccinations/prophylaxis.
Longer term solutions will focus more on biological mechanisms. As those mechanisms are better
understood, a myriad of potential mitigation strategies could appear that may be more focused on giving
cells better defense mechanisms or making an organ more resilient. The end state is enhanced human
performance and a ready force.
TEH aims to ensure the medical readiness of individual Servicemembers through understanding of
exposures at the individual level, which will drive prevention behaviors and increase human performance
and mission effectiveness. In order to impact the care of AFMS beneficiaries, ILERs and exposure-based
health risk profiles can be integrated into clinical encounters and medical surveillance programs.
Therefore, TEH will work closely with the Medical Readiness Panel members to understand the issues and
impact TEH systems will have on training & medical operations at the individual level (e.g., sensors,
personal apps, questionnaires).
4.9 GOAL 9: SHORT, MID, AND LONG TERM EXECUTION PLAN
Establishing a TEH capability can be a complex process that will require incremental development and
establishment of new technologies and research tools, the engagement of multiple stakeholders, and
changes in policies and procedures and healthcare practices. To be able to establish performance metrics
a n d monitor the progress of the TEH capability, well defined goals need to be followed throughout the
development of this capability. These goals are divided into short-term, mid-term, and long-term goals.
Near-Term Tasks (6-12 months)
 Finalize the TEH Strategic Plan
 Develop the TEH Concept of Operations (CONOPS)
 Develop Capabilities Based Assessment (CBA) & informational briefs
 Strategic Business plan
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 18
 Strategic Technical Plan from SG5 Research Development Document (RDD)
 Develop the appropriate doctrine, organization, training, materiel, leadership and education,
personnel and facilities (DOTMLPF) for each focus area.
 Conduct TEH demonstration project with an emphasis on noise
 Understand the landscape of existing initiatives within AFMS, the Surgeon General Office, and its
stakeholders
 Conduct an environmental scan to understand how TEH affects the AFMS and all stakeholders
 Bring together a consortium of stakeholders with shared goals to develop relationships and
combine resources, align deliverables, reduce redundancies, and identify gaps and solutions
 Expand relationships with intra and interagency partners to include the Department of Homeland
Security and agencies with the Department of Health and Human Services.
 Develop memorandums of agreements or memorandums of understanding with inter and intra
government agencies and potentially DoD allies, non-governmental organizations, etc.
 Identify existing DoD-approved computer infrastructures projects with Authority to Operate for
HIPPA-compliant personal identifiable information (PII)/protected health information (PHI)
aggregation and analysis
 Identify all potential infrastructures that can be used to support TEH Information Technology (IT)
and tech initiatives (sensors, Big Data, analytics, etc.) for data collection, storage, and analysis
 Create a plan to integrated TEH IT and technology initiatives (sensors, Big Data, analytics, etc.)
as a path toward an Initial Authority to Operate (IOA) and/or Authority to Operate (ATO)
 Identify and develop synergistic partnerships with other public sector, private sector, and academic
efforts.
Mid-term Tasks (1-3 years)
 Establish the TEH Program with sufficient structure to support the following:
o Develop the Initial Capabilities Document
o Leadership Function
• Establish performance metrics and monitor the progress of the TEH capability
• Develop Informational briefs, presentations and day-to-day documentation to support the
TEH
• Develop the TEH Business Plan from the TEH Strategic Plan
o Policy and Program Support
• Monitor changes in policies and procedures and healthcare practices.
• Develop the Initial Capabilities Document and the final CBA
• Develop the appropriate doctrine, organization, training, materiel, leadership and
education, personnel and facilities (DOTMLPF) for each focus area
o Research and Development
• Develop and engage with multiple public, industry and academic stakeholders
• Develop the TEH technical plan for the Research Development Document
• Leverage existing technologies and begin to shape exposure monitoring systems that
connect with data analytics and clinical research (e.g., genomics) to provide meaningful
health solutions (e.g. clinical decision support)
o Program for training and education
• Identity training requirements for specialty fields/clinical and non-clinical
• Strategically and tactically continue to identify programmatic needs to support training,
education, and manpower needs as TEH transforms medical services
• Work with various AFMS research and development partners to develop technology
needs assessment to support staff to better collect exposure information, translate and
take appropriate protective and medical interventions.
 Identify program gaps, resource needs, and institutionalize TEH within the AFMS and OSD
o Strategically and tactically continue to identify programmatic needs to support training,
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 19
education, and manpower needs as TEH transforms medical services
o Work with various AFMS research and development partners to develop technology
needs assessment to support staff to better collect exposure information, translate and
take appropriate protective and medical interventions.
o Build on the AFMS experience to build out beyond AFMS to the other services and
DHA.
o Identify program gaps, resource needs, and institutionalize TEH within the AFMS and OSD
• Develop both Air Force and AFMS service TEH policies that expand beyond the AFMS
to include other Air Force partners like the Civil Engineer, Human Resources and CIO.
• Work with various intra Air Force agencies to create the policies outside of healthcare to
institute TEH in to the Air Force landscape
• Integrate with Individual Longitudinal Exposure Record (ILER) and MHS GENESIS
• Develop the plan to support, augment and integrate TEH into the ILER
• Develop the plan to support, augment and integrate TEH into Genesis
 Identify training requirements for specialty fields/clinical and non-clinical
o Work with each AFMS Associate Chief to identify training needs
o Develop a training plan with specific training needs and programmatic plan to institute into
the AFMS Force Development Panel plan
 Leverage existing technologies and begin to shape exposure monitoring systems that connect
with data analytics and clinical research (e.g., genomics) to provide meaningful health solutions
(e.g. clinical decision support)
 Develop both Air Force and AFMS service TEH policies that expand beyond the AFMS to
include other Air Force partners like the Civil Engineer, Human Resources and CIO.
 Expand relationships with inter and interagency partners to include the Department of Homeland
Security and agencies with the Department of Health and Human Services.
 Investigate feasibility of Federal, Interagency and other public sector partners and/or
Public/Private partnerships as an innovative approach to ensure the AFMS does not bear the
total cost or resources to find common ground to collectively bring TEH to the forefront and
support the advancement of healthcare
o Develop the plan to create partnerships and identify ways to leverage resources to find
common ground to advance healthcare
 Integrate TEH with ILER and MHS GENESIS
 Establish sensor portfolio to generate a comprehensive, real-time/near-time, continuous
exposure monitoring of the individual.
Long-term Tasks (3-7 years)
 Fully integrate TEH into future DOD policy/JCS doctrine, programs (e.g. ILER)
 Integrate exposure data into MHS GENESIS and ILER
 Promote protective health behaviors based on TEH research findings
Given that TEH is a bold and novel holistic integration of technology and health across many areas
(occupational, military threats, environmental, etc.) that are rapidly advancing, the expansion of TEH
capabilities will be an iterative process where once one phase is complete and lessons learned are
captured, future phases will be reviewed and reevaluated based on experience and emerging trends that
may impact TEH. This will ensure the TEH remains relevant and provides the most beneficial support to
the AFMS.
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 20
5. STRATEGIC BUSINESS PLAN AND IMPLEMENTATION
5.1 STRATEGIC BUSINESS PLAN DEVELOPMENT AND METHODOLOGY
This TEH Strategic Plan identifies the technical requirements and activities necessary for the
development and implementation of TEH capabilities. It delineates the goals, objectives, focus areas, and
strategic technical investments for TEH aligned to the overarching vision of AFMS. In order to make
T E H capabilities a reality, a comprehensive Strategic Business Plan will be developed to document the
foundational business practices to facilitate success. The Strategic Business Plan identifies how current
and future TEH capabilities and projects will be planned, prioritized and executed. The plan will set forth
how success, through the achievement of goals and objectives, will be measured and communicated.
Additionally, the plan will identify how funding will be
budgeted, executed, and monitored. Development of the
Strategic Business Plan is an iterative process. Just as this
Strategic Plan will be reviewed and refined, the Strategic
Business Plan will be updated and modified to reflect
necessary changes based on the development and
implementation of TEH capabilities. The Strategic Business
Plan will outline a fundamental and cyclical methodology
to Plan, Prioritize, Budget, Execute, and Measure TEH
initiatives and capability development (Figure 7).
Plan: The Strategic Business Plan will delineate key processes
and practices, organizational structures, and resources to be implemented in order to initiate and sustain
the TEH capability, identify capability gaps and make the TEH capability a reality. This section includes
the identification and management of focus areas, technical initiatives, and R&D projects to achieve
TEH goals and objectives. The planning section will identify how risks (financial, operational, business,
regulatory, et.al.) will be identified, managed and strategically communicated with internal and external
stakeholders.
Prioritize: The Strategic Business Plan will identify how key technical initiatives and R&D projects will
be prioritized and selected. The Strategic Business Plan will delineate the methodology to be implemented
to identify, prioritize, and select future TEH efforts.
Budget: The process by which budgets will be determined, allocated, and monitored for individual
initiatives or R&D projects will be documented. Additionally funding for the TEH capability will be
planned, programmed and budgeted through the Program Objective Memorandum (POM) process and
other AFMS procedures.
Execute: The Strategic Business Plan will identify how the selected and budgeted initiatives and projects
will be executed and monitored. Each initiative and project should develop customized schedules, budgets,
and risk registers to manage the overall success.
Measure: This section of the plan will outline techniques to measure both incremental success of
individual initiatives and projects as well as total cumulative success of the TEH capability. Outcomes
from the measuring techniques outlined in this section of the Strategic Business Plan will inform future
planning efforts.
5.2 ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE AND STAFFING
Organization structure and staffing will be addressed and completed in FY18 after specific CONOPS and
other analysis such as the Business Plan and Capability Based Assessment. The initial structure for TEHO
that was proposed for the FY 19-23 POM can be found in the COA and Supporting Documents section of
this Plan. A TEHO initial proposed organization structure can be found in Figure 8. Final decisions will be
made as part of the final CONOPS and associated analyses.
Figure 7. Capabilities Development Lifecycle
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 21
Figure 8. Initial Proposed Organizational Structure for TEHO
6. STRATEGIC TECHNICAL PLAN AND IMPLEMENTATION
6.1 TEH TECHNICAL SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT
The challenge for developing TEH capabilities is bringing together distinct systems and initiatives into
one portfolio: integrating exposure science, information technology, and existing healthcare programs to
develop end-to-end systems (Figure 9). TEH capabilities will maximize the value of these advances by
translating data collection, analysis, management, and visualization into clinically and personally
actionable results.
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 22
Figure 9. TEH End-to-End System Development
6.1.1 EXPOSURE MONITORING AND DATA COLLECTION
In order to create a comprehensive TEH analytics platform, the Air Force will need to integrate traditional
and non-traditional exposure assessment technologies to develop a robust exposure assessment capability.
The capability will consider the current state of the science and the future technologies being developed
(e.g., area monitoring, personal air sampling, survey instruments and questionnaires, etc.) with an
increased emphasis on internal measurements of exposure and effect that come from traditional
biomonitoring and new biotechnologies, including all of the -omics.
Given the current state of the science, a robust combination of these exposure assessment tools is
necessary to ensure data from the far field (smart home devices, GPS-related ambient environmental
inputs), near field (individual sensors/dosimeters; patient generated data; Internet of Things [IoT]),
medical records, and biological sources (urine, serum, sputum, saliva, stool, etc.). Micro-level or near-
field sensors need to be mobile, user-friendly, accurate, low power, and economical. The popularity of
this technological niche has created a vibrant market with an increasing number of useful devices
becoming available. Taking advantage of the impressive and ubiquitous blue-tooth and Wi-Fi enabled
technologies and sensors developed over the past few years, TEH intends to assess the value and utility
of these data to reveal overall trends and improve current successes in personalized medicine efforts.
Additionally, this shift from active self-reporting to passive surveillance of health and exposure data
enhances reporting adherence and accuracy of information, which can greatly optimize costs in the MHS.
6.1.2 GENOMICS AND ASSOCIATED -OMICS
Genomics is the foundation of our understanding of genetic predispositions to disease and disorder, but
genomic sequencing is only the tip of the iceberg in understanding complex functional interactions
between human health and the environment. It is estimated that genetics only account for 10-30% of
illness and disease8
, leaving the vast majority of human health effects related to environment (workplace,
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 23
lifestyle, and personal) exposures. The identification and phenotypic expression of genes are critical to
predicting risk/susceptibility from exposure(s). In order to achieve a level of understanding to inform
TEH initiatives, research and development in ‘-omic’ fields such as exposomics, metabolomics,
lipidomics, transcriptomics and proteomics will need to be integrated through technologies for mining
and analyzing large amounts of data (i.e., Big Data) to discover statistical associations between
exposure, genetic biomarkers, and susceptibility factors. Multidisciplinary fields of study such as
exposomics, the microbiome, and environmental epigenetics are focused on understanding these
complex relationships that align with TEH goals.
6.1.2.1 Exposomics
Exposures from our environment, microbiome, lifestyle, and workplace affect our physiology and health
through epigenetics and the application of internal and external exposure assessment methods are crucial to
understanding these interactions for health optimization and promotion. In addition to the above, research
in fields of study such as transcriptomics and proteomics will be utilized by TEH to understand internal
exposures, while external exposure assessment relies on measuring environmental exposures that stress
and degrade human health. Paramount to exposomics is the ability to accurately measure exposures and
exposure effect through "omics" research and technologies.
6.1.2.2 Microbiome
The human gastrointestinal tract harbors diverse and abundant microbiota that are essential for human
health. The human body is a highly complex ecosystem that has formed a permanent symbiotic
relationship with our enteric cells9
. In recent years, there have been major gains in our understanding of the
role of microbiome in host physiology. Alteration of the gut microbiome composition and function has
been associated with the pathology of many diseases to include obesity and type 2 diabetes10
, as well as
more complex diseases like inflammatory bowel disease, and autoimmune diseases such as rheumatoid
arthritis. With diet being a significant exposure to the human body as well as the microbiome, it is
imperative that we take advantage of recent advancements in the field of gut microbiome to help in further
understanding the etiology of various biological disorders as part of the TEH solution set .
6.1.2.3 Epigenetics
Exposures from our environment directly affect how gene expression is activated, repressed, and
regulated. This is part of the larger filed known as epigenetics and TEH must understand how epigenetic
changes in response to our exposures are involved in a wide range of what we currently believe as
genetic diseases. Links between environmental exposures and epigenetics is not straight-forward and
will involve integrating research and analyses from collaborating programs such as the National Institute
of Environmental Health Sciences (NIEHS) and NIOSH to fully understand how environmental factors
can cause epigenetic changes that lead to health problems or disease. One prime example is the National
Institute of Health Roadmap Epigenomics Mapping Consortium, which is tasked with creating and
cataloging reference epigenomes for use by the larger scientific community to use for comparative
research.
6.1.3 CLINICAL EXPOSURE RECORDS
The MHS has had a long standing directive to support the integration of exposure data into EHRs for
Servicemembers. This was initially to relieve the burden on veterans who had to prove their hazard
exposures encountered during deployment in order to claim compensation benefits.
However, the success of exposure data integration into the clinical record so far has been limited due to
the reliance on self-reporting as well as the uncertainty that medical conditions were caused by hazards
(or undetected hazards). Therefore, TEH aims to increase the accuracy of exposure records by enhancing
exposure data collection so that it is collected in quantifiable units that can later be used in mechanistic
studies.
Through TEH we can improve the exposure data collection process with more advanced and mobile
sensors that will allow passive data collection, minimizing data gaps resulting from patient
noncompliance with data entry and can detect exposures in terms of concentration in context with time
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 24
and geographical location. Secondly, exposure data needs will be incorporated into military EHRs in a
user-friendly, and eventually automated way. While reinventing EHRs is not feasible or productive, TEH
will determine requirements and limitations for integrating individual exposure data into MHS
GENESIS in order to establish technical requirements such as data format for new analytical platforms.
The DoD has many systems and data warehouses and TEH will focus on integrating systems of record
that already are being consolidated/interoperable and integrating with additional EHR systems over time.
Systems to be considered include, but are not limited to:
 Health Services Data Warehouse (HSDW)
 Medical Data Repository (MDR)
 MHS Data Mart (M2)
 Defense Medical Surveillance System (DMSS)
 Defense Occupational and Environmental Health Readiness System – Industrial Hygiene
(DOEHRS-IH), including DOEHRS-Environmental Health and DOEHRS-Incident Reporting
Module
 Defense Occupational and Environmental Health Readiness System – Hearing Conservation
(DOERHS-HC)
 MHS GENESIS, the DoD’s new EHR system (when available; currently being tested in the
Pacific Northwest)
 Veterans Health Administration Corporate Data Warehouse (CDW)
 Veterans Health Administration Health Data Repository (HDR)
 Veterans Health Administration eHealth Management Platform, the Veterans Affairs (VA) new
EHR system (when available)
 Purchased care network
 Non-MHS healthcare providers
6.1.4 DATA MANAGEMENT: COLLECTION, STORAGE, AND TRANSFER
TEH will require a workflow that will include organizing, storing, integrating, and retrieving medical
and exposure data using effective and efficient informatics solutions. These solutions will be able to
standardize clinical and exposure data in a meaningful way, and enable healthcare professionals to
analyze disparate data to discover associations between exposures and diseases/conditions. The
development of electronic health records/electronic medical records (EHR/EMR) solutions, personal
trackers and sensors, and the advancement of –omics technologies have made health informatics a
necessary discipline among TEH initiatives.
This conceptual TEH Health Informatics network will assist the TEH initiative to manage Big Data from
multiple sources, organize, and analyze it in a meaningful way, and provide public health professionals the
capability to recommend better treatment to improve healthcare outcomes but more importantly identify
risk factors and health behaviors which if are mitigated may prevent the onset of a disease.
6.1.5 DATA ANALYTICS
Given the use of multiple and diverse sensor types and data sources, TEH will seek technical solutions to
uniformly standardize data and ensure interoperability between legacy and future systems.
To be able to improve the level of healthcare provided to patients and impact healthcare outcomes, all
different systems and solutions that generate data must be capable of differentiating between an
abundance of data, select only meaningful types of data, and integrate this data under a common
ecosystem for further processing and analysis (Figure 10).
Ideally TEH data can be ingested and processed using the same data analytical engines as those that are
currently used or will be used to analyze health and genomic data and integrated into MHS GENESIS.
These systems should be modular, with the ability to swap in more advanced components into the
technology stack when available and create limitless options in terms of sensors and data collection tools
and techniques.
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 25
Figure 10. Framework for Health Informatics
6.1.6 INDIVIDUAL EXPOSURE HEALTH RISK PROFILES (IEHRPS)
Optimizing human performance is contingent on the ability to accurately identify, monitor/measure and
document risk factors at the individual level. A logical extension to exposure monitoring, data collection
and integration is deriving actionable information for either the individual and/or the clinician. This is
achieved through the Individual Exposure Health Risk Profile (IEHRP), which is derived from the
individual’s exposure, medical disposition, genetics and various variables.
IEHRP development is a research initiative in the AFMS to leverage existing and ongoing exposomic,
genomic, and epigenetic research studies to gather comprehensive data for understanding the risk at which
an individual will develop a particular disease based on their individual exposome and genetic and clinical
predispositions. IEHRP models will ultimately ingest data from AFMS/SG5 derived R&D programs and
stakeholder developments. The ultimate goal is to have TEH systems that ingest exposomic and genomic
data with monitored exposures and current medical disposition at the individual level and calculate
personal risk profiles that can be used to inform and guide the individual to understand their risk profile
and make healthy choices to reduce disease and illness and further use the aggregate information for
population health and for policy and resource decision making.
The problem facing the AFMS is how to quantify and statistically validate the combined impact of:
(1) occupational, lifestyle, and environmental exposures in deployed, local, and home environments
(2) clinical disposition and (3) genetic pre-dispositions and susceptibilities to exposure-related illness
and injury, which contributes to health risk and drive preventive or protective COA Steps to reach these
goals in the near term are:
 Develop statistically validated algorithms that determine health risk profiles and drive
preventive COA strategies for individuals
 Establish an implementation plan to apply individual clinical, genetic and exposure data to
IEHRP models that result in risk profiles to inform individuals for preventive behaviors and
improved health outcomes.
 Design and support execution of research studies that address DoD and AF healthcare disease
priorities.
When fully developed, the IEHRP will provide a new capability that will inform and encourage healthy
lifestyle choices, enhance resilience and human performance, and reduce illness and injury. These
capabilities will inform preventive strategies by reducing the health impacts of exposures, hence
improving human performance, readiness, and the resiliency of all military members and their
beneficiaries. Moreover, by educating individuals about their exposure profile, the IEHRP will enable
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 26
individuals and families to make healthy lifestyle choices and become proactive about their own health
(Figure 11).
Figure 11. Future State of Exposure Data Supporting Theater and Clinical Operations
6.1.7 EXPERT SYSTEMS – CLINICAL DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEMS
Analyzed exposure data needs to be visualized and made easily accessible to care givers by integrating
exposure records with clinical decision support systems. These systems are capable of taking data curated
from medical and scientific literature, federal guidance and policies, traditional health data from EHRs and
eventually, exposure record data, and generating recommendations for clinical courses of action such as
screenings, diagnostic tests, prescriptions, and prevention plans in some instances.
TEH will need to understand the current expert systems being used in MHS and ensure interoperability
with these systems. This will require evaluating the technology behind any current systems, understanding
its impact of exposure data integration on patient data security, and determining how TEH data will be
integrated. For example, InterQual has currently been adopted by MHS as a way to make medical
admissions and authorizations more efficient11
. In this instance, TEH may collaborate with vendor specific
engineers to configure InterQual’s algorithms to take into account a patient’s exposure record.
7. ENABLERS FOR TEH SUCCESS
7.1 CULTURAL AND TECHNOLOGY ENABLERS
TEH will represent a major shift in approach with respect to healthcare and prevention. An examination
of the current landscape, both within AFMS and externally, reveals a favorable environment that will
support the successful development of a fully realized TEH capability. Rapidly evolving cultural factors
make the launch of a TEH capability favorable at this time. The ubiquity of mobile phones, increased
public adoption of “wearable” sensors and mobile health applications, as well as advancements in Big
Data analytics can be leveraged by TEH capabilities. Further, cultural and policy shifts in military,
federal, and private sectors to preventive and precision medicine establish both the foundation and the
need for development of TEH capabilities.
7.1.1 COMMERCIAL POPULARITY OF HEALTH WEARABLES
Individual “wearable” sensors permit both the generation of Big Data for analysis as well as personalized
data for tailored care. Sensor systems need to be mobile, low power, and economical in order to
maximize the continuity of data from an individual. Building from advancements in the global
popularity of mobile phone technology, commercial products of this nature are rapidly emerging, and
more now than ever, individuals are voluntarily interested in wearing health monitors to passively obtain
data for themselves. The global market for health wearables is estimated to be $30B by 2018 12
. Tech
giants like Google have recently developed a wearable that captures light exposure and noise levels in
Air Force Medical Service
Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23
Unclassified 27
addition to basic biometrics (heart rate, temperature, etc.)13
. Another Google product being tested is a
contact lens that monitors blood glucose levels14
.
Likewise, The AFMS is investing in the development of wearable sensors. One example is the PEM,
which is a wearable wireless monitoring device that measures long-term exposure to agents of interest
on and off duty. Data from the PEM would be automatically integrated with other exposure data (e.g.
DOEHRS) and genomics data if available. The sensor would be one that is small and out of the way for
the user while maintaining its functionality in a variety of field environments.
These wearable and “pocket” sensors permit both generation of “Real World Evidence” (RWE) for
analyses and individual data for tailored care. New sensor development will provide new and better
contextual information, rapidly identify unknown threats, and draw associations with low-level exposure
biomarkers from human genomics, proteomics, metabolomics, etc. With a more complete picture of the
impacts of exposures on health outcomes, the AFMS can tailor interventions to promote health and
reduce adverse outcomes.
7.1.2 ADVANCES IN GENOMICS, BIG DATA AND OTHER SUPPORTING TECHNOLOGIES
Also critical to the success of TEH are advances in technologies including high-throughput molecular
characterization, genomic sequencing, and Big Data analytics. The cost of sequencing has plummeted
over the past decade (Figure 1215
), to less than $1000 per genome, giving access to more laboratories to
rapidly identify genetic variants or elements that are associated with disease, immunity, response to
treatment, etc., thereby making individual genomic analysis a reality. Advances in Big Data such as high-
performance computing and cloud-based infrastructure permit the aggregation of millions of individual
disparate exposure data points from “wearables”, etc., and the analysis of that data into information that
can be used for public health and medicine.
Figure 12. The Decreasing Cost of Next Generation Sequencing
7.1.3 AFMS MEDICAL MODERNIZATION
There has been renewed interest in recent years to modernize and transform the AFMS into an exemplary
healthcare system. This mindset has led to an increased willingness across the AFMS to move beyond
traditional medicine, to embrace innovation, and to invest in preventive interventions. TEH supports the
AFMS to move beyond just the treatment of illness and injury and to include preservation of health and
optimization of performance, namely a move from healthcare to health. Driven by these emerging values
and changes in attitude, the AFMS is well positioned to embrace novel and innovative approaches like
TEH, which have the potential to significantly advance prevention and better health.
The new Chief of Innovation for the Military Health System has indicated that change is needed in how
future healthcare is delivered. “From an innovation perspective, the MHS needs to accelerate progress in
health and readiness. Innovation is about identifying tools, practices and opportunities to partner to
better serve our beneficiaries and meet our operational mission.” said Steffensen. He has stated that he
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan
Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan

More Related Content

Similar to Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan

Advancing thenationshealth3
Advancing thenationshealth3Advancing thenationshealth3
Advancing thenationshealth3vijayangopalsamy
 
Synthesis of Data Collected From Health Facilities through Supportive Supervi...
Synthesis of Data Collected From Health Facilities through Supportive Supervi...Synthesis of Data Collected From Health Facilities through Supportive Supervi...
Synthesis of Data Collected From Health Facilities through Supportive Supervi...HFG Project
 
Abstract for EMBA
Abstract for EMBAAbstract for EMBA
Abstract for EMBAsyed ali
 
Seminar presentation by Natnael Dechasa Gemeda on the world's current status ...
Seminar presentation by Natnael Dechasa Gemeda on the world's current status ...Seminar presentation by Natnael Dechasa Gemeda on the world's current status ...
Seminar presentation by Natnael Dechasa Gemeda on the world's current status ...Dire Dawa University
 
Natnael Dechasa Gemeda college wide seminar presentation at Dire Dawa Univer...
Natnael Dechasa Gemeda college wide seminar presentation  at Dire Dawa Univer...Natnael Dechasa Gemeda college wide seminar presentation  at Dire Dawa Univer...
Natnael Dechasa Gemeda college wide seminar presentation at Dire Dawa Univer...Dire Dawa University
 
Pandemic influenza preparedness: sharing of influenza viruses and access to v...
Pandemic influenza preparedness: sharing of influenza viruses and access to v...Pandemic influenza preparedness: sharing of influenza viruses and access to v...
Pandemic influenza preparedness: sharing of influenza viruses and access to v...haytham khalifa
 
Investment Case to Fast-Track and Sustain the HIV Response in the Dominican R...
Investment Case to Fast-Track and Sustain the HIV Response in the Dominican R...Investment Case to Fast-Track and Sustain the HIV Response in the Dominican R...
Investment Case to Fast-Track and Sustain the HIV Response in the Dominican R...HFG Project
 
Bleaking_8_Gonnella_Privacy and Security of Patient Healthcare Information Us...
Bleaking_8_Gonnella_Privacy and Security of Patient Healthcare Information Us...Bleaking_8_Gonnella_Privacy and Security of Patient Healthcare Information Us...
Bleaking_8_Gonnella_Privacy and Security of Patient Healthcare Information Us...Paul Bleaking
 
Health insurance-2012 acharya-report
Health insurance-2012 acharya-reportHealth insurance-2012 acharya-report
Health insurance-2012 acharya-reportDr Lendy Spires
 
HFG Project TB Strategic Purchasing Activity: Malawi Assessment Technical Report
HFG Project TB Strategic Purchasing Activity: Malawi Assessment Technical ReportHFG Project TB Strategic Purchasing Activity: Malawi Assessment Technical Report
HFG Project TB Strategic Purchasing Activity: Malawi Assessment Technical ReportHFG Project
 
The global eye health action plan 2014–2019
The global eye health action plan 2014–2019The global eye health action plan 2014–2019
The global eye health action plan 2014–2019Trinity Care Foundation
 
Threat and Hazard Identificationand Risk Assessment (THIRA)
Threat and Hazard Identificationand Risk Assessment (THIRA) Threat and Hazard Identificationand Risk Assessment (THIRA)
Threat and Hazard Identificationand Risk Assessment (THIRA) TakishaPeck109
 
Targeting the Poor for Universal Health Coverage Program Inclusion: Exploring...
Targeting the Poor for Universal Health Coverage Program Inclusion: Exploring...Targeting the Poor for Universal Health Coverage Program Inclusion: Exploring...
Targeting the Poor for Universal Health Coverage Program Inclusion: Exploring...HFG Project
 
Asnc scct snmmi guideline for cardiac spect-ct and pet-ct
Asnc scct snmmi guideline for cardiac spect-ct and pet-ctAsnc scct snmmi guideline for cardiac spect-ct and pet-ct
Asnc scct snmmi guideline for cardiac spect-ct and pet-ctDrPETcanton
 
Australia Lung Cancer Drugs Market Report
Australia Lung Cancer Drugs Market Report Australia Lung Cancer Drugs Market Report
Australia Lung Cancer Drugs Market Report Insights10
 
AMSARA Annual Report 2016
AMSARA Annual Report 2016AMSARA Annual Report 2016
AMSARA Annual Report 2016JA Larson
 
Health & Wellbeing May 2010
Health & Wellbeing May 2010Health & Wellbeing May 2010
Health & Wellbeing May 2010Timothy Holden
 
Euphoria eu-project-proposal
Euphoria eu-project-proposalEuphoria eu-project-proposal
Euphoria eu-project-proposalNick Glezakos
 

Similar to Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan (20)

Essential osh revised 2706 final
Essential osh revised 2706 final Essential osh revised 2706 final
Essential osh revised 2706 final
 
Advancing thenationshealth3
Advancing thenationshealth3Advancing thenationshealth3
Advancing thenationshealth3
 
Synthesis of Data Collected From Health Facilities through Supportive Supervi...
Synthesis of Data Collected From Health Facilities through Supportive Supervi...Synthesis of Data Collected From Health Facilities through Supportive Supervi...
Synthesis of Data Collected From Health Facilities through Supportive Supervi...
 
Abstract for EMBA
Abstract for EMBAAbstract for EMBA
Abstract for EMBA
 
Seminar presentation by Natnael Dechasa Gemeda on the world's current status ...
Seminar presentation by Natnael Dechasa Gemeda on the world's current status ...Seminar presentation by Natnael Dechasa Gemeda on the world's current status ...
Seminar presentation by Natnael Dechasa Gemeda on the world's current status ...
 
Natnael Dechasa Gemeda college wide seminar presentation at Dire Dawa Univer...
Natnael Dechasa Gemeda college wide seminar presentation  at Dire Dawa Univer...Natnael Dechasa Gemeda college wide seminar presentation  at Dire Dawa Univer...
Natnael Dechasa Gemeda college wide seminar presentation at Dire Dawa Univer...
 
Pandemic influenza preparedness: sharing of influenza viruses and access to v...
Pandemic influenza preparedness: sharing of influenza viruses and access to v...Pandemic influenza preparedness: sharing of influenza viruses and access to v...
Pandemic influenza preparedness: sharing of influenza viruses and access to v...
 
Investment Case to Fast-Track and Sustain the HIV Response in the Dominican R...
Investment Case to Fast-Track and Sustain the HIV Response in the Dominican R...Investment Case to Fast-Track and Sustain the HIV Response in the Dominican R...
Investment Case to Fast-Track and Sustain the HIV Response in the Dominican R...
 
Bleaking_8_Gonnella_Privacy and Security of Patient Healthcare Information Us...
Bleaking_8_Gonnella_Privacy and Security of Patient Healthcare Information Us...Bleaking_8_Gonnella_Privacy and Security of Patient Healthcare Information Us...
Bleaking_8_Gonnella_Privacy and Security of Patient Healthcare Information Us...
 
Health insurance-2012 acharya-report
Health insurance-2012 acharya-reportHealth insurance-2012 acharya-report
Health insurance-2012 acharya-report
 
HFG Project TB Strategic Purchasing Activity: Malawi Assessment Technical Report
HFG Project TB Strategic Purchasing Activity: Malawi Assessment Technical ReportHFG Project TB Strategic Purchasing Activity: Malawi Assessment Technical Report
HFG Project TB Strategic Purchasing Activity: Malawi Assessment Technical Report
 
The global eye health action plan 2014–2019
The global eye health action plan 2014–2019The global eye health action plan 2014–2019
The global eye health action plan 2014–2019
 
Threat and Hazard Identificationand Risk Assessment (THIRA)
Threat and Hazard Identificationand Risk Assessment (THIRA) Threat and Hazard Identificationand Risk Assessment (THIRA)
Threat and Hazard Identificationand Risk Assessment (THIRA)
 
Targeting the Poor for Universal Health Coverage Program Inclusion: Exploring...
Targeting the Poor for Universal Health Coverage Program Inclusion: Exploring...Targeting the Poor for Universal Health Coverage Program Inclusion: Exploring...
Targeting the Poor for Universal Health Coverage Program Inclusion: Exploring...
 
Asnc scct snmmi guideline for cardiac spect-ct and pet-ct
Asnc scct snmmi guideline for cardiac spect-ct and pet-ctAsnc scct snmmi guideline for cardiac spect-ct and pet-ct
Asnc scct snmmi guideline for cardiac spect-ct and pet-ct
 
Australia Lung Cancer Drugs Market Report
Australia Lung Cancer Drugs Market Report Australia Lung Cancer Drugs Market Report
Australia Lung Cancer Drugs Market Report
 
AMSARA Annual Report 2016
AMSARA Annual Report 2016AMSARA Annual Report 2016
AMSARA Annual Report 2016
 
Master's Thesis
Master's ThesisMaster's Thesis
Master's Thesis
 
Health & Wellbeing May 2010
Health & Wellbeing May 2010Health & Wellbeing May 2010
Health & Wellbeing May 2010
 
Euphoria eu-project-proposal
Euphoria eu-project-proposalEuphoria eu-project-proposal
Euphoria eu-project-proposal
 

More from Richard Hartman, Ph.D.

The Personalized Health Risk Profile: A New Tool for Safety and Occupational ...
The Personalized Health Risk Profile: A New Tool for Safety and Occupational ...The Personalized Health Risk Profile: A New Tool for Safety and Occupational ...
The Personalized Health Risk Profile: A New Tool for Safety and Occupational ...Richard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
Combining Clinical and Social Determinants to Improve Military/Veteran Qualit...
Combining Clinical and Social Determinants to Improve Military/Veteran Qualit...Combining Clinical and Social Determinants to Improve Military/Veteran Qualit...
Combining Clinical and Social Determinants to Improve Military/Veteran Qualit...Richard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
CLINICAL AND SOCIAL DETERMINANTS TO IMPROVE DOD/VETERAN WELL BEING: THE SERVI...
CLINICAL AND SOCIAL DETERMINANTS TO IMPROVE DOD/VETERAN WELL BEING: THE SERVI...CLINICAL AND SOCIAL DETERMINANTS TO IMPROVE DOD/VETERAN WELL BEING: THE SERVI...
CLINICAL AND SOCIAL DETERMINANTS TO IMPROVE DOD/VETERAN WELL BEING: THE SERVI...Richard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
HartmanPhD LLC Capability Statement 2020
HartmanPhD LLC Capability Statement 2020HartmanPhD LLC Capability Statement 2020
HartmanPhD LLC Capability Statement 2020Richard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
Revolutionizing Precision Medicine w/Big Data The Individual Exposure Health ...
Revolutionizing Precision Medicine w/Big Data The Individual Exposure Health ...Revolutionizing Precision Medicine w/Big Data The Individual Exposure Health ...
Revolutionizing Precision Medicine w/Big Data The Individual Exposure Health ...Richard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
VHA Office of Rural Health (ORH) Strategic Plan 2010-2014
VHA Office of Rural Health (ORH) Strategic Plan 2010-2014VHA Office of Rural Health (ORH) Strategic Plan 2010-2014
VHA Office of Rural Health (ORH) Strategic Plan 2010-2014Richard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
Total Exposure Health - A New Approach to the Exposure Sciences
Total Exposure Health - A New Approach to the Exposure SciencesTotal Exposure Health - A New Approach to the Exposure Sciences
Total Exposure Health - A New Approach to the Exposure SciencesRichard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
Enhancing Health Risk Assessment:The Individual Exposure Health Risk Profile ...
Enhancing Health Risk Assessment:The Individual Exposure Health Risk Profile ...Enhancing Health Risk Assessment:The Individual Exposure Health Risk Profile ...
Enhancing Health Risk Assessment:The Individual Exposure Health Risk Profile ...Richard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
REVOLUTIONIZING MILITARY HEALTH AND MEDICINE THROUGH TOTAL EXPOSURE HEALTH
REVOLUTIONIZING MILITARY HEALTH AND MEDICINE THROUGH TOTAL EXPOSURE HEALTHREVOLUTIONIZING MILITARY HEALTH AND MEDICINE THROUGH TOTAL EXPOSURE HEALTH
REVOLUTIONIZING MILITARY HEALTH AND MEDICINE THROUGH TOTAL EXPOSURE HEALTHRichard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
Revolutionizing Precision Health with Big Data - The Individual Exposure Heal...
Revolutionizing Precision Health with Big Data - The Individual Exposure Heal...Revolutionizing Precision Health with Big Data - The Individual Exposure Heal...
Revolutionizing Precision Health with Big Data - The Individual Exposure Heal...Richard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
Total Exposure Health - A Bold Approach to Transform the Delivery of Healthca...
Total Exposure Health - A Bold Approach to Transform the Delivery of Healthca...Total Exposure Health - A Bold Approach to Transform the Delivery of Healthca...
Total Exposure Health - A Bold Approach to Transform the Delivery of Healthca...Richard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
Gop social media_analysis_21_dec_2011_final
Gop social media_analysis_21_dec_2011_finalGop social media_analysis_21_dec_2011_final
Gop social media_analysis_21_dec_2011_finalRichard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
Aihce2016 s-teh-presentation-25-may-2016
Aihce2016 s-teh-presentation-25-may-2016Aihce2016 s-teh-presentation-25-may-2016
Aihce2016 s-teh-presentation-25-may-2016Richard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
How the Financial Services and Pharmaceutical industries are innovating and e...
How the Financial Services and Pharmaceutical industries are innovating and e...How the Financial Services and Pharmaceutical industries are innovating and e...
How the Financial Services and Pharmaceutical industries are innovating and e...Richard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
U.S. Military Improves Medical Care, Tactical Advantage with Wireless Point-o...
U.S. Military Improves Medical Care, Tactical Advantage with Wireless Point-o...U.S. Military Improves Medical Care, Tactical Advantage with Wireless Point-o...
U.S. Military Improves Medical Care, Tactical Advantage with Wireless Point-o...Richard Hartman, Ph.D.
 
Sample Senate Testimony - Air Force Environmental Programs
Sample Senate Testimony - Air Force Environmental ProgramsSample Senate Testimony - Air Force Environmental Programs
Sample Senate Testimony - Air Force Environmental ProgramsRichard Hartman, Ph.D.
 

More from Richard Hartman, Ph.D. (20)

The Personalized Health Risk Profile: A New Tool for Safety and Occupational ...
The Personalized Health Risk Profile: A New Tool for Safety and Occupational ...The Personalized Health Risk Profile: A New Tool for Safety and Occupational ...
The Personalized Health Risk Profile: A New Tool for Safety and Occupational ...
 
Combining Clinical and Social Determinants to Improve Military/Veteran Qualit...
Combining Clinical and Social Determinants to Improve Military/Veteran Qualit...Combining Clinical and Social Determinants to Improve Military/Veteran Qualit...
Combining Clinical and Social Determinants to Improve Military/Veteran Qualit...
 
CLINICAL AND SOCIAL DETERMINANTS TO IMPROVE DOD/VETERAN WELL BEING: THE SERVI...
CLINICAL AND SOCIAL DETERMINANTS TO IMPROVE DOD/VETERAN WELL BEING: THE SERVI...CLINICAL AND SOCIAL DETERMINANTS TO IMPROVE DOD/VETERAN WELL BEING: THE SERVI...
CLINICAL AND SOCIAL DETERMINANTS TO IMPROVE DOD/VETERAN WELL BEING: THE SERVI...
 
HartmanPhD LLC Capability Statement 2020
HartmanPhD LLC Capability Statement 2020HartmanPhD LLC Capability Statement 2020
HartmanPhD LLC Capability Statement 2020
 
Revolutionizing Precision Medicine w/Big Data The Individual Exposure Health ...
Revolutionizing Precision Medicine w/Big Data The Individual Exposure Health ...Revolutionizing Precision Medicine w/Big Data The Individual Exposure Health ...
Revolutionizing Precision Medicine w/Big Data The Individual Exposure Health ...
 
Total Exposure Health
Total Exposure HealthTotal Exposure Health
Total Exposure Health
 
VHA Office of Rural Health (ORH) Strategic Plan 2010-2014
VHA Office of Rural Health (ORH) Strategic Plan 2010-2014VHA Office of Rural Health (ORH) Strategic Plan 2010-2014
VHA Office of Rural Health (ORH) Strategic Plan 2010-2014
 
Total Exposure Health - A New Approach to the Exposure Sciences
Total Exposure Health - A New Approach to the Exposure SciencesTotal Exposure Health - A New Approach to the Exposure Sciences
Total Exposure Health - A New Approach to the Exposure Sciences
 
Enhancing Health Risk Assessment:The Individual Exposure Health Risk Profile ...
Enhancing Health Risk Assessment:The Individual Exposure Health Risk Profile ...Enhancing Health Risk Assessment:The Individual Exposure Health Risk Profile ...
Enhancing Health Risk Assessment:The Individual Exposure Health Risk Profile ...
 
REVOLUTIONIZING MILITARY HEALTH AND MEDICINE THROUGH TOTAL EXPOSURE HEALTH
REVOLUTIONIZING MILITARY HEALTH AND MEDICINE THROUGH TOTAL EXPOSURE HEALTHREVOLUTIONIZING MILITARY HEALTH AND MEDICINE THROUGH TOTAL EXPOSURE HEALTH
REVOLUTIONIZING MILITARY HEALTH AND MEDICINE THROUGH TOTAL EXPOSURE HEALTH
 
Revolutionizing Precision Health with Big Data - The Individual Exposure Heal...
Revolutionizing Precision Health with Big Data - The Individual Exposure Heal...Revolutionizing Precision Health with Big Data - The Individual Exposure Heal...
Revolutionizing Precision Health with Big Data - The Individual Exposure Heal...
 
Total Exposure Health - A Bold Approach to Transform the Delivery of Healthca...
Total Exposure Health - A Bold Approach to Transform the Delivery of Healthca...Total Exposure Health - A Bold Approach to Transform the Delivery of Healthca...
Total Exposure Health - A Bold Approach to Transform the Delivery of Healthca...
 
Gop social media_analysis_21_dec_2011_final
Gop social media_analysis_21_dec_2011_finalGop social media_analysis_21_dec_2011_final
Gop social media_analysis_21_dec_2011_final
 
Aihce2016 s-teh-presentation-25-may-2016
Aihce2016 s-teh-presentation-25-may-2016Aihce2016 s-teh-presentation-25-may-2016
Aihce2016 s-teh-presentation-25-may-2016
 
How the Financial Services and Pharmaceutical industries are innovating and e...
How the Financial Services and Pharmaceutical industries are innovating and e...How the Financial Services and Pharmaceutical industries are innovating and e...
How the Financial Services and Pharmaceutical industries are innovating and e...
 
U.S. Military Improves Medical Care, Tactical Advantage with Wireless Point-o...
U.S. Military Improves Medical Care, Tactical Advantage with Wireless Point-o...U.S. Military Improves Medical Care, Tactical Advantage with Wireless Point-o...
U.S. Military Improves Medical Care, Tactical Advantage with Wireless Point-o...
 
Sample Senate Testimony - Air Force Environmental Programs
Sample Senate Testimony - Air Force Environmental ProgramsSample Senate Testimony - Air Force Environmental Programs
Sample Senate Testimony - Air Force Environmental Programs
 
Vha baseline analysis
Vha baseline analysisVha baseline analysis
Vha baseline analysis
 
ALI Social Media Workshop Part 1
ALI Social Media Workshop Part 1 ALI Social Media Workshop Part 1
ALI Social Media Workshop Part 1
 
ALI Social Media Workshop Part 2
ALI Social Media Workshop Part 2 ALI Social Media Workshop Part 2
ALI Social Media Workshop Part 2
 

Recently uploaded

Chandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD available
Chandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD availableChandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD available
Chandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD availableDipal Arora
 
Call Girls Bhubaneswar Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Bhubaneswar Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...Call Girls Bhubaneswar Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Bhubaneswar Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...Dipal Arora
 
Call Girls Bareilly Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Bareilly Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Bareilly Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Bareilly Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls JaipurCall Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipurparulsinha
 
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Call Girls Siliguri Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Siliguri Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Siliguri Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Siliguri Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort ServicePremium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Servicevidya singh
 
VIP Service Call Girls Sindhi Colony 📳 7877925207 For 18+ VIP Call Girl At Th...
VIP Service Call Girls Sindhi Colony 📳 7877925207 For 18+ VIP Call Girl At Th...VIP Service Call Girls Sindhi Colony 📳 7877925207 For 18+ VIP Call Girl At Th...
VIP Service Call Girls Sindhi Colony 📳 7877925207 For 18+ VIP Call Girl At Th...jageshsingh5554
 
VIP Russian Call Girls in Varanasi Samaira 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP Russian Call Girls in Varanasi Samaira 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...VIP Russian Call Girls in Varanasi Samaira 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP Russian Call Girls in Varanasi Samaira 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...Neha Kaur
 
Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...
Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...
Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...hotbabesbook
 
Best Rate (Guwahati ) Call Girls Guwahati ⟟ 8617370543 ⟟ High Class Call Girl...
Best Rate (Guwahati ) Call Girls Guwahati ⟟ 8617370543 ⟟ High Class Call Girl...Best Rate (Guwahati ) Call Girls Guwahati ⟟ 8617370543 ⟟ High Class Call Girl...
Best Rate (Guwahati ) Call Girls Guwahati ⟟ 8617370543 ⟟ High Class Call Girl...Dipal Arora
 
Low Rate Call Girls Kochi Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Kochi
Low Rate Call Girls Kochi Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service KochiLow Rate Call Girls Kochi Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Kochi
Low Rate Call Girls Kochi Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service KochiSuhani Kapoor
 
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...indiancallgirl4rent
 
High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanvi☎️ 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanvi☎️  8250192130 Independent Escort Se...High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanvi☎️  8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanvi☎️ 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...narwatsonia7
 
(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...
(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...
(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...Taniya Sharma
 
Vip Call Girls Anna Salai Chennai 👉 8250192130 ❣️💯 Top Class Girls Available
Vip Call Girls Anna Salai Chennai 👉 8250192130 ❣️💯 Top Class Girls AvailableVip Call Girls Anna Salai Chennai 👉 8250192130 ❣️💯 Top Class Girls Available
Vip Call Girls Anna Salai Chennai 👉 8250192130 ❣️💯 Top Class Girls AvailableNehru place Escorts
 
VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...
VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...
VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...narwatsonia7
 
Call Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...Taniya Sharma
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Chandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD available
Chandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD availableChandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD available
Chandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD available
 
Call Girls Bhubaneswar Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Bhubaneswar Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...Call Girls Bhubaneswar Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Bhubaneswar Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
 
Call Girls Bareilly Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Bareilly Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Bareilly Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Bareilly Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls JaipurCall Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
 
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Siliguri Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Siliguri Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Siliguri Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Siliguri Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort ServicePremium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
 
VIP Service Call Girls Sindhi Colony 📳 7877925207 For 18+ VIP Call Girl At Th...
VIP Service Call Girls Sindhi Colony 📳 7877925207 For 18+ VIP Call Girl At Th...VIP Service Call Girls Sindhi Colony 📳 7877925207 For 18+ VIP Call Girl At Th...
VIP Service Call Girls Sindhi Colony 📳 7877925207 For 18+ VIP Call Girl At Th...
 
VIP Russian Call Girls in Varanasi Samaira 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP Russian Call Girls in Varanasi Samaira 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...VIP Russian Call Girls in Varanasi Samaira 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP Russian Call Girls in Varanasi Samaira 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
 
Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...
Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...
Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...
 
Best Rate (Guwahati ) Call Girls Guwahati ⟟ 8617370543 ⟟ High Class Call Girl...
Best Rate (Guwahati ) Call Girls Guwahati ⟟ 8617370543 ⟟ High Class Call Girl...Best Rate (Guwahati ) Call Girls Guwahati ⟟ 8617370543 ⟟ High Class Call Girl...
Best Rate (Guwahati ) Call Girls Guwahati ⟟ 8617370543 ⟟ High Class Call Girl...
 
Low Rate Call Girls Kochi Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Kochi
Low Rate Call Girls Kochi Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service KochiLow Rate Call Girls Kochi Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Kochi
Low Rate Call Girls Kochi Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Kochi
 
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 09521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON D...
 
High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanvi☎️ 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanvi☎️  8250192130 Independent Escort Se...High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanvi☎️  8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanvi☎️ 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
 
(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...
(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...
(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...
 
Vip Call Girls Anna Salai Chennai 👉 8250192130 ❣️💯 Top Class Girls Available
Vip Call Girls Anna Salai Chennai 👉 8250192130 ❣️💯 Top Class Girls AvailableVip Call Girls Anna Salai Chennai 👉 8250192130 ❣️💯 Top Class Girls Available
Vip Call Girls Anna Salai Chennai 👉 8250192130 ❣️💯 Top Class Girls Available
 
VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...
VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...
VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...
 
Call Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Dehradun Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
 

Air Force Medical Service - Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan

  • 1. AIR FORCE MEDICAL SERVICE Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Prepared by: Col Philip Goff and Richard Hartman, PhD The information in this report is exempt from public disclosure in accordance with Title 5 USC § 552(b) (5) (Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Exemption (b)(5)).
  • 2. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified STRATEGIC PLAN FOR TOTAL EXPOSURE HEALTH (TEH) Sponsoring Organization: HAF SG3/5 Date Submitted: 22 Jan 2018 Approval Authority: Surgeon General Validation Authority: Surgeon General Document Point of Contact Col Philip Goff, AFMSA/SG3/5PB Phone: 703-681-6912 DSN: 761-6912 NIPRNET: philip.e.goff.mil@mail.mil _______________________________ MARK A. EDIGER Lieutenant General, USAF, MC, CFS Surgeon General Headquarters Air Force OPR: Air Force Medical Support Agency/Operations and Research Directorate (AFMSA/SG3/5PB) DSN: 761-6912 Commercial: (703) 681-6912
  • 3. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified Table of Contents 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.....................................................................................................................................1 2. INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................................................................2 2.1 BACKGROUND ..........................................................................................................................................2 2.2 TEHVISION..............................................................................................................................................3 2.3 CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES ................................................................................................4 3. STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS ...............................................................................................................................6 3.1 STUDIES AND ANALYSES....................................................................................................................6 3.2 RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT.......................................................................................................6 3.3 PARTNERSHIPS AND COLLABORATIONS ........................................................................................7 3.4 REGULATORY.........................................................................................................................................7 3.5 INFRASTRUCTURE ................................................................................................................................8 3.6 HEALTH AND HEALTHCARE...............................................................................................................8 3.7 TRAINING ................................................................................................................................................9 3.8 READINESS..............................................................................................................................................9 4. EXECUTION STRATEGY: STRATEGIC GOALS AND OBJECTIVES...........................................................10 GOAL 1: SYNTHESIZE, IDENTIFY, AND UNDERSTAND CURRENT AND EMERGING TRENDS THROUGH STUDIES AND ANALYSES TO ADVANCE PREVENTION STRATEGIES.......10 4.2 GOAL 2: ADVANCE HEALTH AND HEALTHCARE THROUGH RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT............................................................................................................................................11 4.3 GOAL 3: ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH REGULATORY STANDARDS.........................................12 4.4 GOAL 4: BUILD INFRASTRUCTURE TO SUPPORT ADVANCES IN HEALTHCARE...................13 4.5 GOAL 5: FOSTER A NETWORK OF INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL COLLABORATIVE PARTNERS ....................................................................................................................................................13 4.6 GOAL 6: PROVIDE ENHANCED EXPOSURE HEALTH EDUCATION AND TRAINING..............15 4.7 GOAL 7: IMPROVE QUALITY OF CARE AND ENCOURAGE GOOD LIFESTYLE CHOICES ....16 4.8 GOAL 8: OPTIMIZE FORCE READINESS AND HUMAN PERFORMANCE BY REDUCING HAZARDOUS EXPOSURES.........................................................................................................................17 4.9 GOAL 9: SHORT, MID, AND LONG TERM EXECUTION PLAN.......................................................17 5. STRATEGIC BUSINESS PLAN AND IMPLEMENTATION.............................................................................20 5.1 STRATEGIC BUSINESS PLAN DEVELOPMENT AND METHODOLOGY .....................................20 5.2 ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE AND STAFFING ..............................................................................20 6. STRATEGIC TECHNICAL PLAN AND IMPLEMENTATION.........................................................................21 6.1 TEH TECHNICAL SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT ....................................................................................21 7. ENABLERS FOR TEH SUCCESS.......................................................................................................................26 7.1 CULTURAL AND TECHNOLOGY ENABLERS..................................................................................26 8. MEDICAL PRIVACY AND ETHICS..................................................................................................................29 8.1 DATA COLLECTION INTEGRATION.................................................................................................29 8.2 SENSOR DEVELOPMENT ....................................................................................................................30 8.3 DATA INTEGRATION WITH HEALTH RECORDS............................................................................30 9. CONCLUSION.....................................................................................................................................................31 APPENDIX A: LIST OF ACRONYMS........................................................................................................................33 APPENDIX B: STRATEGIC PLAN ENDNOTE REFERENCES................................................................................36 APPENDIX C: GLOSSARY.........................................................................................................................................38 APPENDIX D: ADDITIONAL SELECTED PUBLICATIONS AND REFERENCE MATERIAL ............................41 APPENDIX E: TOTAL EXPOSURE HEALTH INFOGRAPHIC................................................................................46
  • 4. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified Table of Figures Figure 1. Vision for TEH Portfolio................................................................................................................................. 3 Figure 2. Current State and Future State with TEH........................................................................................................ 4 Figure 3. TEH Variables................................................................................................................................................. 4 Figure 4. Focus Areas of the Future TEH....................................................................................................................... 6 Figure 5. TEH Strategic Goal ....................................................................................................................................... 10 Figure 6. Sample Regulatory Workflow for TEH Studies............................................................................................ 12 Figure 7. Capabilities Development Lifecycle ............................................................................................................. 20 Figure 8. Initial Proposed Organizational Structure for TEHO .................................................................................... 21 Figure 9. TEH End-to-End System Development ........................................................................................................ 22 Figure 10. Framework for Health Informatics.............................................................................................................. 25 Figure 11. Future State of Exposure Data Supporting Theater and Clinical Operations .............................................. 26 Figure 12. The Decreasing Cost of Next Generation Sequencing ................................................................................ 27
  • 5. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 1 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Total Exposure Health (TEH) is the Air Force Medical Service (AFMS) solution to capture workplace, environmental and lifestyle exposures to the individual using advances in science, technology & informatics to prevent disease, preserve health and well-being and develop precision health solutions. As a new way of delivering care, and responds to both congressional and several national military readiness strategies such as, the 2013 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) and the 2017 National Security Strategy. To support the TEH capability, the AFMS commissioned the development of this TEH Strategic Plan to define the responsibilities and processes necessary for the development and implementation of TEH in a way that brings the most value to the AFMS. By supporting TEH, the AFMS will lead an innovative approach to protecting its beneficiaries, promoting readiness, and achieving truly personalized prevention health. The TEH Strategic Plan will delineate how the focus areas, goals, and objectives for TEH align to the overarching vision of AFMS: Healthiest Performing Population by 2025. The plan will outline current and future operational drivers and challenges in healthcare delivery, how TEH addresses those challenges, and identifies the required capabilities, potential supporting programs, and platforms necessary for TEH execution. The eight (8) strategic focus areas (below) create a framework for the Strategic Plan that is aligned with the AFMS strategic direction as determined by our environmental scan and stakeholder analyses.  Understand current and emerging trends through studies and analyses to advance primary prevention  Ensure compliance with regulatory standards  Advance Medicine through Research & Development (R&D)  Build Infrastructure to Support Advances in Healthcare  Foster a network of collaborative partners  Increase access to exposure science education and training  Improve quality of care and encourage good lifestyle choices  Increase Force Readiness and Human Performance Through the Strategic Plan, TEH will leverage and advance exposure science, sensors and technologies, health informatics, and clinical support systems as a cutting edge way to obtain a holistic understanding of an individual’s health, root causes of disease and injury, and innovative but accessible methods for primary prevention. The spectrum of resources will include:  R&D to expand TEH capabilities into sensor, informatics, and database platforms  Regulatory expertise for TEH deployment  Infrastructure, resources, and activities management  Military, public, academic, and private partnerships  Care provider, workforce, and patient training  Enhanced support, ancillary services and benefits  Healthcare delivery towards primary prevention  Organizational change and Military Readiness supported by validated data  Individual Exposure Health Risk Profiles (IEHRP)  Data integration into Individual Longitudinal Exposure Records (ILER) The Strategic Plan’s near-term goal is to improve exposure characterization and to identify and understand individual variability, susceptibility, and vulnerability to cumulative exposures. In the long- term, TEH will translate these findings into clinically actionable recommendations to protect and improve well-being of military members and their beneficiaries. The bottom line is that TEH is a future-
  • 6. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 2 focused and progressive approach that represents a disruptive but necessary paradigm shift to help the Air Force and the Military Health System (MHS) enhance human performance, support force health protection, and ultimately transition from healthcare to precision health. 2. INTRODUCTION 2.1 BACKGROUND The AFMS Strategic Vision seeks to ensure that the AFMS’s “supported population is the healthiest and highest performing segment of the U.S. by 2025.” Achieving this vision will require a paradigm shift in military medicine – from a primary focus on disease and injury treatment to a more holistic approach that focuses on health and prevention. TEH is an approach to primary prevention and precision health that seeks to evaluate the totality of an individual’s exposure history and integrate that with an individual’s genetic makeup and clinical disposition, in order to understand the root causes of wellness, injury and disease. Total Exposure Health was initiated as a “Strategic Directive” through the Air Force Medical Service FY17-21 MPPG: “AF/SG/3/5 will define requirements and develop courses of action to integrate health promotion, occupational health, environmental health, and "hobby health" evaluations to enhance overall delivery of care in the Air Force Medical Home. Integration of all possible exposure pathways captured in data analytics to ensure full spectrum of patient lifestyles is considered to create the healthiest segment of the population by 2025.” After demonstrating the feasibility of the TEH concept, TEH became an AFMS “Strategic Priority” in the AFMS FY19-23 MPPG. “AF/SG/3/5 will create a solution to capture workplace, environment, and lifestyle exposures and connect to the individual (i.e., genome) in response to mandates in the 2013 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) Section 313, PRD 05, 2017 National Security Strategy, 2015 National Health Security Strategy, and DoDI 6055.05, using advances in science, technology and informatics to improve health and well-being of the Air Force beneficiaries – Healthy performing populations by 2025.” Since its inception, SG3P has been positioning the Air Force to lead the TEH initiative by identifying collaborative partnerships within AFMS, the military components, Office of the Secretary of Defense, federal agencies, and academia to integrate exposomics, advances in sensor technology, informatics, and precision healthcare into TEH. Ultimately the goal of TEH is to prevent illness and disease by informing Servicemembers and their beneficiaries to make and/or embrace preventive health choices in their lifestyles, workplaces and homes. The purpose of this Strategic Plan is to define the focus and goals of the initiative from FY19-23 as it transitions to an operational Total Exposure Health Office (TEHO) and the methodologies that will be used to ensure TEHO’s ability to provide support to both AFMS and the larger MHS community in achieving the Healthy Performing Populations 2025 goal. TEH to promote a healthy and high performing workforce The Air Force is dedicated to being the “healthiest and highest performing segment of the US by 2025”. The AFMS can only achieve Healthiest Population by true prevention and Total Exposure Health positions the AFMS to be healthiest & highest performing population by 2025 with emphasis on “Personalized Healthcare”, going beyond healing the ill and preventing early disease.
  • 7. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 3 2.2 TEHVISION TEH aims to integrate and provide exposure-related data to individuals, clinicians, and organizations to improve health-related decision making that will strengthen prevention, human performance, resilience, workforce, and readiness programs. As shown in Figure 1, TEH will partner across multiple program areas and integrate occupational, lifestyle, and environmental exposure data from traditional and new exposure assessment technologies (including sensors and –omics-based molecular biology) with clinical and genomic data. Leveraging a Big Data infrastructure and advanced analytics, TEH will provide a new and novel capability that will inform and encourage healthy lifestyle choices, enhance resilience and human performance, and reduce illness and injury. These capabilities will inform preventive strategies by reducing the health impacts of exposures, hence improving human performance and readiness of all Airmen. Moreover, by educating individuals about their exposure profile, TEH will enable individuals and families to make healthy lifestyle choices and become proactive about their own health. THE VISION STATEMENT: “Total Exposure Health (TEH) program will enrich the clinical/patient experience allowing beneficiaries to take control of their own health.” TEH MISSION STATEMENT: “Total Exposure Health will achieve precision health through advances in medicine, sciences, technology and informatics using interactive and transparent precision health information platforms to improve health and well-being of all Air Force beneficiaries.” Figure 1. Vision for TEH Portfolio
  • 8. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 4 2.3 CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES Organizational Change and New Collaborations. TEH aims to transform the current state of disparate exposure monitoring, research studies, data collection, and healthcare records to holistic and integrated systems that quantitate total exposure and inform health outcomes (Figure 2) into actionable insights and initiatives. 1 * SEG – Similar Exposure Group Current State - Prev Med Future State – Prev Med Work exposure with limited environmental and lifestyle exposures Work, environment and lifestyle (home, recreation, etc) exposures Animal models of exposures are applied to population and (SEG)* with safety factors for Airmen protection and clinical intervention Individual exposure applied to each Airman’s genome with tailored interventions to include prevention, protection, career, placement and clinical Limited sensors (time, sensitivity, analytes) Individual and area sensors with full analyte complement, real time/all-the- time, sensitive to human based exposure levels Clinical intervention based on organ function disruption/damage Clinical intervention based on molecular biology changes brought by exposure Paper-based exposure summary somewhere in the clinical record Expert system (EHR) matching billions of bits of information (DNA, sensor, etc) relevant to exposure with clinical recommendation Prevention concerns applied post- occupational/lifestyle choice Prevention of key health outcomes part of the care decision for career/life from recruitment to separation/retirement TEH Figure 2. Current State and Future State with TEH In its current state the MHS is experiencing multiple challenges which are affecting quality, access and readiness while increasing costs. To boost military readiness, reduce cost, and improve quality and access, the MHS enterprise is modernizing its institutional health system to combine prevention with treatment which will reduce clinical errors, improve workflows and enhance clinical outcomes with improved patient engagement. By integrating with various MHS change management and trusted care paradigms, TEH can save lives, money and improve force readiness. The challenges presented by developing TEH capabilities vary from organizational coordination across a complex set of stakeholders to funding and research prioritization. With the advent of the Defense Health Agency (DHA), TEH capability development must eventually work in a joint environment resulting in the addition of multiple stakeholders and less direct control. Synchronization and optimization of R&D efforts, policy and programs begin with the AFMS Panels which are extended to other Services and the interagency space, as well as commercial and academic partners. This process increases the complexity and breadth of stakeholder management, which will be addressed through the TEHO and a cross functional team of subject matter experts (SMEs) to negotiate programmatic boundaries and concerns. TEH and its impact on human health will rely on collecting, integrating, and analyzing a dataset of diverse variables like never before (Figure 3). Staying abreast of developments within the rapidly evolving areas of exposomics, precision medicine, genomics, sensors, health information technology (HIT) and Big Data analytics will require a broad spectrum of resources, analytics, and technology, as well as a far reaching network of academic, industry, and federal agency partnerships. Furthermore, competition for research funding warrants TEH capability development efforts Figure 3. TEH Variables
  • 9. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 5 be coordinated with a diverse set of stakeholders to ensure their needs are met and leveraged to provide effective support to ongoing research activities. Policies. After the military’s experiences with Agent Orange exposure during the Vietnam War and the significant adverse health claims by Servicemembers deployed to the Persian Gulf War, the necessity to monitor and document the health status of military forces was codified into Public Law 105-85 in 19971 whereupon the Department of Defense (DoD) was mandated to develop a deployment health surveillance system to detect, prevent, or minimize health problems arising as a result of environmental exposures during deployments and operations. This mandate has been followed by various policies2 to standardize basic medical record keeping across the Services. Expectations for deployment health surveillance and record keeping remain high as military personnel continue to be deployed overseas in support of operational missions. More recently, the 2013 National Defense Appropriations Act (NDAA) Section 313 mandated the Military to collect, document and act on long-term environmental health risks in garrison.2 TEH will help to comply with current policy while informing future policy with more precise information to better leverage our limited resources by leveraging recent advances in exposure science, sensor and data technologies, health informatics, and clinical support systems to establish a more complete understanding of an individual’s health and risks, root causes of disease and injury, and translating them into policy. Opportunities. Opportunities exist based upon the disruptive growth and shift in exposure assessment technologies for the Air Force (AF), DoD, and beyond. TEH will transition traditional clinical care into personalized health as a better understanding of the relationships between exposures (i.e., internal vs. external and harmful vs. beneficial) and health outcomes (positive and negative) is established. As a result, the AFMS will be able to develop preventive and protective recommendations, based upon an individual’s unique health profile and exposures, for improving health and well-being. For example, through TEH, sensor technologies integrated with existing and emerging data platforms will be used to detect environmental, occupational, and lifestyle exposures in real or near real-time to capture a comprehensive longitudinal exposure record. Human genomic data from next generation sequencing and exposure data will be integrated using bioinformatics to develop individual health risk profiles that will support the development of a more advanced Clinical Decision Support System (CDSS) to complement clinical and personal interventions. A critical element of TEH involves the ability to centralize disparate and unstructured data from past exposure data archives as well as current exposure data collection efforts to derive maximal value from both historical and on-going work in this area. These existing resources will be used to assess the relationships between an individual’s genetic predispositions, epigenetic factors, and exposure to chemicals from lifestyle, occupation, and the environment. Thus, this initiative will support development of diagnostic approaches, treatment methods, and intervention strategies that efficiently and appropriately integrate all available data. In due course, there may also be substantial research value in this dataset (i.e. the ability to discover new relationships that influence health and risk).
  • 10. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 6 3. STRATEGIC FOCUS AREAS TEH has eight areas aligned with the AFMS strategic map. These areas of focus guide the strategic goals and activities of the TEH Initiative (Figure 4). Figure 4. Focus Areas of the Future TEH 3.1 STUDIES AND ANALYSES To achieve TEH’s vision of acting as an integrator of multiple research, policy, and health efforts, TEH will continue to initiate studies and demonstrations that help understand and characterize the roles and activities the TEH Initiative should support. Due to the rapid pace of technological advancement (such as genomics, medicine, sensors and informatics) and the changing legislative environment (such as new presidential initiatives, healthcare policies, etc.), the TEHO will conduct environmental scans, literature reviews, and market research to develop materials to better inform policy and the allocation of resources to support and transform military healthcare. 3.2 RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT The challenge for developing TEH capabilities is bringing together distinct systems and initiatives into one portfolio: integrating exposure science, information technology, and existing healthcare programs to TEH aims to streamline cross-cutting studies and analyses Federal agencies, Services and academia are working on a myriad of Studies and Analysis (S&A) from prevention to cures, using genomics, sensors, and Big Data. There is no overarching program of record to bring these disparate, resource- intensive, activities together. TEH S&A environmental scans and market assessments will identify existing and current S&A for proper resource allocation. Imagine the Air Force, Navy, Army, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), and Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) working on studies for a perfluoroalkyls (e.g., PFOA and PFOS) sensor, a wide-spread contaminant in the environment. The TEH S&A would identify any duplication of effort and recommend actions that may support all the studies, a mix, or one to reduce duplication and reprogram funding towards other high priority studies. Noise study to identify hearing loss risk Currently the USAF School of Aerospace Medicine (USAFSAM) is working on a “noise” exposure TEH research demonstration to demonstrate the ability to collect, store, and utilize unstructured “noise” exposure data to identify the unique health risk associated with noise and manage Noise Induced Hearing Loss (NIHL). The demonstration will pull all the aspects of TEH (sensing, seeing and action) with data to include: sensor, survey, DOEHRS, and genetics.
  • 11. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 7 develop end-to-end systems. For the current and near-term, TEH has identified the key areas within science and technology that research and development should be focused; including, but not limited to science, engineering, medicine, and informatics. TEH aims to expand the standalone fields of study and integrate them into a system that can transform exposure data into behavioral and clinical actions. Sensor technologies integrated with existing and emerging data platforms will be leveraged to detect environmental, occupational, and lifestyle exposures in near-/real-time to capture a comprehensive exposure record that can identify risk factors and inform risk prevention. Human genomic data generated from next generation sequencing and exposure data will be combined through bioinformatics to develop individual exposure health risk profiles using informatics to support the development of a more advanced CDSS to compliment clinical and personal interventions. 3.3 PARTNERSHIPS AND COLLABORATIONS TEH is at the epicenter to focus synergistic initiatives within the Air Force, DoD, and at national levels to advance health and healthcare with advances in science, technology, medicine, and informatics. Establishing public-public and public-private partnerships will ensure appropriate coordination and support, while minimizing duplicative efforts—a key priority for TEH. These partnerships will also help to ensure data sharing, dissemination of results, and efficient use of resources, particularly in constrained budgetary environments. It is paramount that partnerships and collaborations are created to form shared resources and link together existing initiatives to move forward with the best value and minimize the number of new efforts, which are increasingly difficult to fund in today’s constrained budgets. R&D will be a major focus for TEH and the questions that TEH will tackle will be large, challenging problems that are best addressed through collaborative efforts. For example, sharing of best practices and lessons learned across the exposomics community will be critical to advancing the state of the science, particularly as the tools and technologies central to TEH are still rapidly evolving. This approach will be used to ensure that TEH is using cutting edge technologies, and focusing on unique research areas and topics, without duplicating efforts, that will supplement existing initiatives and take TEH to the next level of actionable healthcare decision support. 3.4 REGULATORY There are numerous policy, legal and ethical considerations regarding the execution of TEH that must be addressed while active studies are being conducted and before full implementation of TEH. Planning and development of study documentation for research protocols is a lengthy, technical process and a deep understanding of the requirements is essential to initiating studies without delays. It is important to ensure that a lack of regulation does not become an obstacle to the implementation of R&D. Compliance to regulatory guidelines must be considered at several levels across multiple agencies. Communications with relevant agencies (e.g., OSHA, DHA and FDA) must start early and remain on-going so to ensure existing compliance as well as anticipate future regulatory issues. Examples of issues that need to be Accelerating AFMS Research by Leveraging Partners’ Existing Collaborations SG3/5 is working with various federal, academic and private sector entities. One example is our work with the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), a leader in exposure sciences and genetics. Given PNNL’s unique position as a national laboratory, AFMS has positioned assets to develop and integrate AFMS research using PNNL as an access point to consortium of institutions from academia, the private sector, and other federal agencies. Consequences of Exposure Data Collection Imagine a Servicemember purchased an off-the-shelf wearable pollution monitor to monitor/control their Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease only to find out that their workplace was not safe. Will the Air Force allow personal devices into the workplace? What are the ethical legal, policy implications? This is one of many complex issues associated with all aspects of TEH that need to be addressed.
  • 12. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 8 addressed include revisions and implementation of TEH in accordance with the Affordable Care Act (ACA), compliance with military regulations for meaningful use of personalized data, the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA), and exposure data to improve both individual and population health, as well as policy support to allow deployment of new technologies and tools such as wearables and sensors to workplace environment. With the advent and introduction of new technologies (sensors), clinical diagnostics (genetics) and information technology (Big Data) within and outside the military workplace various ethical and privacy issues will surface that will need deeper investigation. The findings, challenges and opportunities will drive both policy and operations for early and future adoption. Therefore, it will be critical to ensure these issues are identified and planned for with execution based on current rules, standards, and guidance. The TEHO will take all these issues into consideration as they program and plan with a focus on realistic adoption within the current ethical, social and legal constraints while pushing for the adoption, use, and integration of advances in science, medicine, and information technology to improve the health and welfare of our forces. 3.5 INFRASTRUCTURE The optimal infrastructure to support the TEH program should include but not be limited to resources such as sensor platforms, database servers, high-performance computing, and the cloud. TEH-related programs such as the Personal Exposure Monitor (PEM), Coriell Hearing Study3 , Digital Biobank, Bio- environmental Threat Surveillance (BETS), Defense Occupational and Environmental Health Readiness System (DOEHRS), and BLUE Longitudinal Exposure Record (BLER), are stood up through separate but linked AFMS and DoD programs. Furthermore, besides Information Technology (IT) infrastructure, the AFMS needs to define the needs to support all aspects of TEH, including laboratory and medical support. The requirement here is to determine what distinct resources and infrastructure TEH will need to support functional integration and fill gaps not provided by the related initiatives. 3.6 HEALTH AND HEALTHCARE TEH will usher in a disruptive paradigm shift in healthcare. Whereas most providers care is oriented toward “disease/illness care,” with TEH and other related initiatives, including the AFMS-led Digital Biobank under their Precision Medicine Program, education for healthcare providers at all levels can begin leaning more heavily toward prevention. The knowledge provided by TEH will foster an understanding of how to interpret and integrate a wide variety of exposure-related data (including but not limited to occupational, environmental, genomic, and health behavior data from new media) into clinical practice and preventive medicine to optimize human performance and readiness. Ultimately, this will allow individuals to take ownership of their health and to be more informed about their health-related choices and behaviors. The Collection, Storage, and Retrieval of Exposure Data Enables Personalized Healthcare Delivery to Our Servicemembers and Veterans A Servicemember is going to an appointment at her local clinic. He/she discusses their concerns related to deployments and the impact it may have on her health and the health of her family. With her exposure record available through the future TEH system, the provider can see all of her personal and group exposure histories with interpretations to make the best possible education and health plan. TEH Systems Will Reveal Unexpected Health Risks and Their Root Cause A Servicemember authorizes genetic testing for a newborn family member and it reveals sensitivity to certain pesticides. The end-point of TEH is to give providers a Clinical Decision Support System (CDSS) that will flag providers to such findings and combine them with data from a variety of sources (sensors, medical records, lifestyle, occupational hazards, etc.) and nonclinical data sources to include “smart base” data like Civil engineering pesticide application. When the clinician reviews the CDSS information for this family it shows that in addition to the genetic sensitivity to pesticides, they are vegetarian and live in a rural setting, thus potentially exposing them to higher pesticide levels. This information allows the provider to order specific diagnostic tests and provide appropriate clinical interventions.
  • 13. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 9 3.7 TRAINING Additional training and education will also need to be developed for AFMS beneficiaries, including Servicemembers, family members, as well as veterans and retirees who receive healthcare through the AFMS and the MHS. The resulting health system will be a participant-engaged and data-driven endeavor that synthesizes with advances in understanding human biology, behavior, genetics, occupation and environment, along with data and computational science to produce new knowledge that reveals new pathways for promoting health, enhancing human and operational performance, and preventing and treating disease. Once exposure records are accessible to healthcare providers and staffs, they will need training programs to ensure they understand how to evaluate exposure data and utilize it to support their healthcare decisions. Clinicians’ understanding of their patient’s symptoms will be less reliant on self-reporting and enhanced by technology. Additionally, the limited and static snapshot of their patient’s health available during examination will be less dependent on patients to conduct the burdensome task of self-logging often undependable diaries of symptoms, exposures, and behaviors. The TEH Initiative will not only affect clinicians, nurses, and other healthcare professionals. New training and education will also need to be developed for the Air Force Bioenvironmental Engineering, Public Health, and numerous other members of the exposure science, preventive medicine, and public health functions of the AFMS so they can properly understand and leverage these advances in data collection, computational biology, toxicology, toxicogenomics, and other rapidly evolving disciplines. By doing so, the AFMS and by extension the DoD can assess, quantify, and understand exposures which in turn will strengthen AFMS precision medicine, preventive medicine, population health, human performance, and readiness initiatives. 3.8 READINESS Before a Senate Appropriations Panel committee meeting on March 9, 2016, Air Force Surgeon General, Lieutenant General Mark A. Ediger said, “The broad scope of care we provide is key to our readiness.” 4 If the broad scope of care the AFMS provides is the key to our readiness, then a TEH-informed health system is an enabler of readiness on several levels. First, TEH will provide clinicians , nurses and other healthcare professionals and staff with a much richer and knowledge-conveying set of data regarding exposures as well as individual (e.g., genomics, metabolomics, pre-existing conditions, etc.) susceptibilities to use in primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention efforts and the Air Force’s Personalized Medicine Program (PMP), all of which increase readiness. Second, this expanded and enriched data will drive an increased understanding of exposure-disease relationships and individual susceptibilities that will optimize the deployment screening process to more accurately and tightly identify those individuals with true deployment-limiting medical conditions—which increases readiness Training and Education: How Understanding Genes Can Modify Behaviors As we learn more about genetics, both patients and providers will realize we are more unique than previously thought. This has already been shown in exposure to noise, with recent understanding that a collection of genes significantly affect predisposition for hearing-loss and likely elucidate different levels of risk (risk profiles). Training and education will play a crucial role in TEH, particularly when individuals and healthcare professionals will need to understand what personalized risk profiles mean and how guidance will be best implemented in changing behaviors to prevent hearing loss through advanced technology and lifestyle/workplace modifications. TEH Together with Other AFMS Domains, Ultimately Improves Force Health and Readiness In response to the Global Health Engagement, the exposure health data from TEH will enhance the AFMS integrative/integrated medicine initiatives. Additionally by incorporating the exposure data from various geographic areas, we can ensure our deploying forces have the most accurate medical intelligence with emphasis on their unique deployment history and protective equipment.
  • 14. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 10 and reduces the likelihood of putting individual’s in harm’s way. For example, with the development of the ILER, TEH capabilities can improve military operation decision making by identifying personnel who may be susceptible to certain exposures. Third, by empowering individuals with information about their health, their exposures, and their unique individual susceptibilities, we will be arming them with information to drive health behavior change and improve readiness. 4. EXECUTION STRATEGY: STRATEGIC GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Setting clear goals is critical for TEH to maximize how it can benefit AFMS, existing research and health programs, and the health of the community. Each of the following goals reflect a targeted approach to delivering tangible results and deliverables in alignment with the TEH Focus Areas (Figure 5). Figure 5. TEH Strategic Goals GOAL 1: SYNTHESIZE, IDENTIFY, AND UNDERSTAND CURRENT AND EMERGING TRENDS THROUGH STUDIES AND ANALYSES TO ADVANCE PREVENTION STRATEGIES There is currently an explosion of studies, research and technical development in the fields of medicine, genomics, science, technology, informatics, and Big Data in the exposure sciences5 . To systematically identify, and understand current and future TEH efforts, robust studies and analyses are required to reduce duplication, partner with similarly minded groups, and focus on exposure science initiatives that have military relevance. This process will require a comprehensive analysis and cataloging of current and emerging technologies in the fields listed below.  Genomics, Exposomics, “omics”  Sensor and mobile applications  Big Data (storage, transfer and use)  Informatics  Medicine  Healthcare Policies  Precision and personalized medicine  Public Health and Environmental Monitoring Goal 1 Example Activities and Milestones Conduct a systematic literature analysis Develop mechanisms to continuously learn about emerging technologies that are not yet published/publicized Drive policy change and implementation into healthcare delivery
  • 15. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 11 Goal 2 Example Activities and Milestones Develop evaluation criteria and selection processes with TEH Stakeholders to determine which technologies to support and implement on a cyclical basis Finalize and execute the Strategic Technical Plan (Chapter 6) Coordinate demonstrations of supported research Support new and innovative studies on the exposure sciences. Partner with scientists to influence study design to maximize efficiency during regulatory approval processes OBJECTIVE.1.1: SYSTEMATIC LITERATURE, WEB AND FUNDING ANALYSIS The TEHO will become the centralized repository for everything exposure science related and will tie specific research, technologies, initiatives, and programs to each AFMS panel to integrate into the healthcare delivery system. OBJECTIVE 1.2: CONTINUOUSLY LEARN As the central repository for everything exposure science the TEHO will advance science and technology while supporting the evolution and development of policies to support TEH implementation. Through this process TEH will support the development of improved methodologies for sharing available information, findings, and data in the exposure sciences and the expansion of studies and analyses, both within DoD and through external stakeholders. 4.2 GOAL 2: ADVANCE HEALTH AND HEALTHCARE THROUGH RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT A defining characteristic of TEH is its use of technology to ultimately drive personalized evidence- based medicine that will enrich the patient/provider relationship transferring ownership to the individual to ultimately encourage health-promoting behaviors. TEH also promotes the promise of Big Data, which is sensing (collecting exposures with sensors), seeing (using informatics to make sense of the data) and acting (using expert systems so clinicians can make better interventions). Therefore one of TEH’s strategic goals is to advance the state of research and development that is relevant to furthering exposure detection and our ability to make use of large volumes of disparate datasets that will eventually contain information about the individual’s exposure, clinical disposition and genetics. This integration of disparate and unstructured data will require a comprehensive analysis and cataloging of current and emerging technologies in the fields listed below.  Data collection tools and mechanisms (e.g., sensors, smartphone apps, Internet-of-Things (IoT)  Technologies that facilitate the feasibility of transferring exposure and health data  Solutions and infrastructure that are able to manage large volumes of disparate data  Solutions that enable rapid and more efficient analytics of this data  Expert health IT systems that facilitate the incorporation and use of data by healthcare providers  Solutions that enable use of exposure data for individual as well as population health through surveillance, warning, and countermeasure methods TEHO aims to expand and optimize AFMS capabilities in technology; sensor development, data analytics, and health IT systems. The deployment and integration of the future R&D portfolio of TEH will allow AFMS to improve the health and well-being of its beneficiaries while reducing healthcare associated costs, manpower, and staff burden.
  • 16. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 12 4.3 GOAL 3: ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH REGULATORY STANDARDS The healthcare industry and military medicine are in constant flux driven by complex current and emerging policy initiatives. The excess of existing policy associated with the complexities of the TEH initiative is daunting and requires a catalog to address not only the exposure science issues but also those concerning preventive medicine, genomics, technology, and information technology to name a few. A holistic view is needed to identify existing policies and also to integrate TEH precepts as new and emerging policies are developed to reap the benefits of the TEH approach to improve the delivery of healthcare. Figure 6. Sample Regulatory Workflow for TEH Studies For example, the TEH goal of integrating wearable sensors, personal exposome data gathering, genomics, and next generation electronic health records presents a unique and complex challenge with respect to the spectrum of quality and regulatory requirements that govern this space. The cutting-edge nature of TEH is more advanced than the policy and guidance materials that are currently in place. Therefore, due to the absence of strong regulatory information, some additional delays in navigating the protocol review and approval process are expected. Figure 6 illustrates several stages of development, review, and approval authority signatories that TEH SMEs will obtain before TEH research with human subjects can begin. Fortunately, some elements can be done simultaneously and some approvals may not be required in the near-term. OBJECTIVE 1: SYSTEMATIC POLICY AND REGULATORY REVIEW TEH will require a comprehensive scan of existing policies and regulations around personalized sensors, wearables, and the use of genetic data and will identify areas where TEH can be integrated into existing DoD healthcare and public health policies and guidance. OBJECTIVE 2: REVIEW OF REGULATORY PROCEDURES AND COMPLIANCE MANUALS Since TEH will be using sensors and personalized wearables and individual genetic sequencing, these issues need to comply with documents, lists, policies, programs, and statements relating to compliance references used by FDA. Goal 3 Example Activities and Milestones Catalog all existing policy, guidance and recommendations associated with the TEH initiative. Identify and stay abreast of policies associated with technologies that may not have designated approval processes Integrate TEH concepts into current and emerging policy and guidance. Be involved in the shaping of regulatory policies for emerging technology
  • 17. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 13 4.4 GOAL 4: BUILD INFRASTRUCTURE TO SUPPORT ADVANCES IN HEALTHCARE Full implementation of TEH throughout the AFMS enterprise will require an infrastructure that supports both the clinical and technology advancements to healthcare. This will need to be a carefully phased, incremental approach for providing clinical support such as labs, pharmacy, etc. Technology, applications, informatics networks, and participation by the vast population of Military and their beneficiaries will need a significant initial investment and operating cost, though the expectation of healthcare cost saving will justify the investment. Paramount to developing a TEH infrastructure will be leveraging existing systems, working with currently successful processes and innovative technology, and collaborating closely with agencies under a similar mission so to reduce costs and drive infrastructure building forward in an efficient way. The TEHO will also have established structures to meet the objectives outlined for each of its goals. These structures serve as building blocks for future innovation and expansion. The organization of TEHO (see Figure 8 in Section 5.2) depicts how these structures work together to support the current AFMS healthcare infrastructure to be the healthiest and highest performing population by 2025. The reach of Medical Support touches upon all future stakeholders of TEH including Benefits, Laboratory, IM/IT, and Pharmacy. Furthermore, one of the main near-term objectives of TEH is to transform exposure data into an individual health exposure risk profile that can be integrated into ILERs and ultimately be interoperable with DoD electronic health record (EHR), MHS GENESIS. Together, TEHO aims to work with Medical Support to develop guides and implementation policies relevant to information assurance and Medical Records Management and execution of the Health Information Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) as it relates to the operation of TEH technologies and services. OBJECTIVE4.1: CONDUCT AN ENVIRONMENTAL SCAN OF EXISTING AFMS INFRASTRUCTURE A comprehensive analysis of how to integrate existing IT systems and infrastructure to help TEH identify current and future needs, and drive an AFMS wide modernization initiative that will support TEH and other upcoming healthcare needs and challenges must be conducted. OBJECTIVE4.2: PILOT TEST NEW PLATFORMS UNDER AFMS’S SECURE ENVIRONMENT To ensure optimal integration of new tools and technologies for TEH initiative, pilot testing the most critical technologies will be a necessary step to secure full integration of new systems into existing infrastructure and also ensure interoperability and health information exchange among systems. OBJECTIVE 4.3: IDENTIFY CURRENT AND FUTURE PHARMACY AND LABORATORY NEEDS As TEH R&D matures there will be an expansion of various biomarkers and genetic testing required to understand the individual’s health risks. Once the health risks are identified through environmental scans, the Studies and Analysis and R&D focus areas, various pharmacological alternatives may exist or need to be created that will eventually get on the AFMS formulary. 4.5 GOAL 5: FOSTER A NETWORK OF INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL COLLABORATIVE PARTNERS In order to efficiently maximize the capabilities and comprehensiveness of TEH supported risk assessments and future CDSS in a resource constrained environment, a central goal of TEH is maintaining relationships with multiple programs and initiatives that can provide rich sources of data. TEH will accomplish this by fostering a network of partners within the AFMS, across the DoD, other federal agencies (e.g., Department of Health and Human Services, National Institutes of Health (NIH), NIOSH, and throughout industry and the private sector. Goal 4 Example Activities and Milestones Leverage understanding of emerging technology and health trends gained from Goals 1 and 2 to identify capability and capacity gaps Engage with leadership within AFMS and MHS such as Medical Support to ensure infrastructure expansions can be integrated with preexisting and future systems
  • 18. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 14  Within the Air Force: TEH will collaborate with AF/SG5 derived R&D and studies and analysis programs to support development of individual sensor, communications and analytics systems for individual exposure monitoring, data integration and smart system analytics for integration into MHS GENESIS. TEH will also support staff’s ability to better collect exposures, translate these data, and implement protective and medical interventions. As TEH evolves, TEH will remain engaged with AF entities outside of AFMS, including Civil Engineering, Services, Human Resources and the Chief Information Officer (CIO), to shape policy and implement TEH developed innovations to integrate with the “Smart Bases” concept, for example.  MHS & DoD: As TEH matures, TEH can apply its experience expanding capabilities within AFMS to support development of a similar system across the larger Defense Health Agency while collaborating with MHS and DoD efforts, such as the Center for Deployment Health Research & Millennium Cohort Study and the Collaborative Health Initiative Research Program.  Initiatives in the Public Sector: Due to resources needed to handle the size and complexity of data involved in TEH analyses, TEH aims to bring together community resources wherever possible. Federal organizations such as the NIH, NIOSH, CDC, and EPA, have all conducted research on occupational and environmental exposures, biomonitoring, and exposure versus effect. Key exposome initiatives in Europe and the United States could prove to be particularly valuable partners for TEH.  Academia and National Laboratories: Leveraging current relationships with various academic institutions and National laboratories, such as, PNNL and expanding relationships will be key to bringing the best in class solutions to the TEH initiative. With the rapid changes in science, technology, medicine and informatics developing relationships outside the military complex will be critical to advancing the product needs to support TEH.  Private Sector & Industry: The issues related to delivering healthcare and ensuring employee productivity and health are not restricted to the AF or the DOD, these issues burden our entire healthcare system as well as employers. By fostering public/private relationships we can work together to solve complex problems for the federal government. We will promote and foster innovation by enabling the rapid development and transition of critical technologies and services for use to resolve complex TEH issues and stimulate the transition of cutting-edge, innovative lifesaving and outcome-improving technologies and services to the commercial/private sector. OBJECTIVE 5.1: PARTNER WITH AFMS PANELS AND TO DEVELOP INTERNAL TEH SUPPORT Establish a TEH advisory board that will be structured from AFMS Panel members and SME’s to help drive TEH initiative, but also through their expertise and understanding of current operations and developments to help identify needs and overcome challenges related to TEH efforts. OBJECTIVE.5.2: EXPAND AND DEVELOP PUBLIC-PUBLIC COLLABORATIONS Identify public stakeholders with focus on TEH and its concepts, including public sector agencies, non- profit organizations, and promote and support communication, collaboration, and innovations in areas of interest for AFMS and TEH through collaborative programs and funding initiatives. OBJECTIVE.5.3: INSTITUTIONALIZE PUBLIC-PRIVATE COLLABORATIONS Focus on the development and support of public-private partnerships (PPP) (over the more traditional market-driven models), that will drive innovation and help promote the adoption and implementation of TEH concepts and efforts from personal to institutional and public health levels. Through these collaborations, private and public stakeholders can work together to identify and overcome risks and Goal 5 Example Activities and Milestones Identify the most impactful conferences and meetings to hold oral presentations and workshops Establish roles within the office to handle MOUs, MTAs, teaming agreements, etc. Once a group of partnerships are established, plan and host annual TEH symposium Publish review articles and book chapters on TEH concepts and exposomics
  • 19. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 15 challenges and share the benefits of this collaboration. 4.6 GOAL 6: PROVIDE ENHANCED EXPOSURE HEALTH EDUCATION AND TRAINING In order to truly realize the beneficial impact of TEH, the individual, health providers and public health professionals play a major role in changing the current paradigm of care into one that takes a holistic approach to preventing disease and promoting health. Therefore, as technologies such as sensors, exposomics, and individual exposure risk profiles mature, TEH will work with Force Development to identify training needs for clinical and non-clinical career fields to develop and implement training programs dedicated to transforming health and science roles to include exposure science. Exposure science will for example:  Increase the public health professionals’ awareness and knowledge of the exposure sciences through the use of sensors and Big Data platforms to improve surveillance  Train clinicians in interpreting new exposure and susceptibility data as it becomes more integrated with clinical records, to increase exposure data’s role in clinical decision support.  Expand scientific and engineering roles into the exposure science field. The development of these training programs will involve an integrated approach from all the AFMS panels as well as programmatic leads from the scientific, policy, and IT domains to develop the strategy, prioritize the curriculum and resources needed to execute the training. TEH will work with Force Development Panel SMEs and stakeholders and with public health professionals to develop TEH within the Military Force through guidance, training, and providing a knowledge base resource. Education and training is not limited to clinical and non-clinical staff, it also requires training and education for AFMS beneficiaries and the civilian workforce to help them better understand the exposures not only in their workplace but through their individual choices and the environment they live in. To identify these current and emerging needs, the TEHO will work with industry, academic, and public sector SMEs to emphasize AFMS TEH. OBJECTIVE 6.1: DEVELOP NEW EDUCATION RESOURCES FOR MEDICAL STAFF Develop web portals populated with informational material about the scope and importance of TEH and exposomics in promoting individual health and population/public health, and how these initiatives can support personalized and precision medicine initiatives, reduce healthcare cost, and promote healthy living. OBJECTIVE 6.2: DEVELOP A COMMUNICATIONS PLAN Communication plans will be developed to include medical staff, nonmedical staff and beneficiaries to ensure understanding of TEH capabilities as they are available throughout the development. The communications plan will include information on promoting individual and family health through advancements in personalized medicine, healthy choices and enhanced understanding of personal and family exposures. Goal 6 Example Activities and Milestones Make available review articles and book chapters on TEH concepts and exposomics to the medical staff (Communications Plan) As TEH data matures, develop materials for user- specific training modules to enable patients, care providers, etc., to understand and use exposure data to benefit health Apply for Continuing Medical Education accreditation to provide industry recognized training to healthcare professionals
  • 20. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 16 Goal 7 Example Activities and Milestones Enhance Engagement with AF line leadership and stakeholders Integration of Individual Longitudinal Exposure Records (ILERs) into EHRs allowing providers to understand patients’ health even without clinical presentation which is difficult to capture Development of push-pull orbidirectionaluser- friendly mobile applications that not only push exposure data 4.7 GOAL 7: IMPROVE QUALITY OF CARE AND ENCOURAGE GOOD LIFESTYLE CHOICES According to the 2014 MHS Review, there are approximately 10M beneficiaries while there are 0.25M primary care physicians6, 7 . Given this ratio, it is extremely challenging to achieve the patient- provider relationship necessary for personalized care. TEH equips healthcare providers in 4 ways:  Individual exposure records allow physicians to more easily understand a patient’s exposure and risk history that may contribute to their concerns.  Integration of TEH data into expert systems (e.g. clinical decision support systems) helps care providers make decisions more efficiently about screenings, diagnostics, and treatments to prescribe.  Identify and leverage health promotion activities, campaigns and practices that improve lifestyle decisions and behaviors.  Improve patient and family activation and engagement. Realizing the pathway from monitoring exposures and translating them into a succinct patient/provider clinical dashboard is in the distant future; we must recognize the potential of the future and work towards it. By incrementally introducing the precepts into policy, technology and medical operations, the benefits of TEH will gradually be realized by the entire medical enterprise. Beyond creating an enriching clinical experience that will translate into positive behavioral changes, TEH also aims to simultaneously enable Airman and beneficiaries to easily understand their exposures and its effect on their health through an integrated approach with AFMS Health Promotions, Occupational and Preventive Medicine. This could be accomplished through reports similar to those provided in genomic services such as 23andMe or through mobile applications where individuals can track their exposures in real time similar to the Fitbit’s or Apple Health’s mobile applications. Collectively, TEH will bridge the divide between the care provider and the patient where the patient is better equipped to take ownership of their healthcare with information and to participate in the development of clinical plans that are individualized to encourage healthy lifestyle choices, safer workplaces and a better understanding of the environment to enhance human performance and military operations. OBJECTIVE 7.1: DEVELOP NEW PATIENT FACING EDUCATION TOOLS AND RESOURCES Provide beneficiaries and their families general information about exposures, how they affect their health, how AFMS is prioritizing exposure science, and how patients can improve their overall health and performance by adopting and promoting healthy lifestyle’s and health choices. OBJECTIVE.7.2: DEVELOP INTERACTIVE TOOLS AND DASHBOARDS FOR PATIENTS TO FOLLOW THEIR HEALTH Patient facing tools and dashboard can be developed and integrated into the new MHS GENESIS for beneficiaries to allow them to track their health, set up goals, and provide them with smart choices and advise about protecting their health, adopting healthy choices, and recognizing and limiting harmful exposures.
  • 21. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 17 Goal 8 Example Activities and Milestones Engage with Force Development leadership and stakeholders Integration of Individual Longitudinal Exposure Records (ILERs) into EHRs allowing physicians to understand patients’ health even without clinical presentation which is difficult to capture 4.8 GOAL 8: OPTIMIZE FORCE READINESS AND HUMAN PERFORMANCE BY REDUCING HAZARDOUS EXPOSURES A TEH informed health system enhances and enables readiness. TEH will provide healthcare providers with a knowledge-conveying set of data regarding exposures as well as individual (e.g., genomics, metabolomics, pre-existing conditions, etc.) susceptibilities to use in primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention efforts and the Air Force’s Personalized Medicine Program, all of which increase readiness.  This expanded data will drive an increased understanding of exposure-disease relationships and individual susceptibilities that will optimize the deployment screening process by more accurately and specifically identifying those individuals with true deployment-limiting medical conditions—which increases readiness and reduces the likelihood of putting individuals’ in harm’s way.  Empowering individuals with information about their health, their exposures, and their unique individual susceptibilities, will enable them with information to drive health promoting and health improving behaviors which again increases readiness.  TEH mitigates exposure to improve performance by providing the proper intervention geared to the individual and their medial disposition, exposure and genetic propensity. To reduce risks TEH will use exposure risk indices that will be part of the CDSS to develop protocols or courses of action (COA) to enhance prevention and protect military members from chronic and adverse exposures. Collectively TEH creates the ability to reduce the potential outcome of the exposure through various means such as removing the hazard, changing the operational process, instituting engineering controls, and implementing personal protective countermeasures such as gear or vaccinations/prophylaxis. Longer term solutions will focus more on biological mechanisms. As those mechanisms are better understood, a myriad of potential mitigation strategies could appear that may be more focused on giving cells better defense mechanisms or making an organ more resilient. The end state is enhanced human performance and a ready force. TEH aims to ensure the medical readiness of individual Servicemembers through understanding of exposures at the individual level, which will drive prevention behaviors and increase human performance and mission effectiveness. In order to impact the care of AFMS beneficiaries, ILERs and exposure-based health risk profiles can be integrated into clinical encounters and medical surveillance programs. Therefore, TEH will work closely with the Medical Readiness Panel members to understand the issues and impact TEH systems will have on training & medical operations at the individual level (e.g., sensors, personal apps, questionnaires). 4.9 GOAL 9: SHORT, MID, AND LONG TERM EXECUTION PLAN Establishing a TEH capability can be a complex process that will require incremental development and establishment of new technologies and research tools, the engagement of multiple stakeholders, and changes in policies and procedures and healthcare practices. To be able to establish performance metrics a n d monitor the progress of the TEH capability, well defined goals need to be followed throughout the development of this capability. These goals are divided into short-term, mid-term, and long-term goals. Near-Term Tasks (6-12 months)  Finalize the TEH Strategic Plan  Develop the TEH Concept of Operations (CONOPS)  Develop Capabilities Based Assessment (CBA) & informational briefs  Strategic Business plan
  • 22. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 18  Strategic Technical Plan from SG5 Research Development Document (RDD)  Develop the appropriate doctrine, organization, training, materiel, leadership and education, personnel and facilities (DOTMLPF) for each focus area.  Conduct TEH demonstration project with an emphasis on noise  Understand the landscape of existing initiatives within AFMS, the Surgeon General Office, and its stakeholders  Conduct an environmental scan to understand how TEH affects the AFMS and all stakeholders  Bring together a consortium of stakeholders with shared goals to develop relationships and combine resources, align deliverables, reduce redundancies, and identify gaps and solutions  Expand relationships with intra and interagency partners to include the Department of Homeland Security and agencies with the Department of Health and Human Services.  Develop memorandums of agreements or memorandums of understanding with inter and intra government agencies and potentially DoD allies, non-governmental organizations, etc.  Identify existing DoD-approved computer infrastructures projects with Authority to Operate for HIPPA-compliant personal identifiable information (PII)/protected health information (PHI) aggregation and analysis  Identify all potential infrastructures that can be used to support TEH Information Technology (IT) and tech initiatives (sensors, Big Data, analytics, etc.) for data collection, storage, and analysis  Create a plan to integrated TEH IT and technology initiatives (sensors, Big Data, analytics, etc.) as a path toward an Initial Authority to Operate (IOA) and/or Authority to Operate (ATO)  Identify and develop synergistic partnerships with other public sector, private sector, and academic efforts. Mid-term Tasks (1-3 years)  Establish the TEH Program with sufficient structure to support the following: o Develop the Initial Capabilities Document o Leadership Function • Establish performance metrics and monitor the progress of the TEH capability • Develop Informational briefs, presentations and day-to-day documentation to support the TEH • Develop the TEH Business Plan from the TEH Strategic Plan o Policy and Program Support • Monitor changes in policies and procedures and healthcare practices. • Develop the Initial Capabilities Document and the final CBA • Develop the appropriate doctrine, organization, training, materiel, leadership and education, personnel and facilities (DOTMLPF) for each focus area o Research and Development • Develop and engage with multiple public, industry and academic stakeholders • Develop the TEH technical plan for the Research Development Document • Leverage existing technologies and begin to shape exposure monitoring systems that connect with data analytics and clinical research (e.g., genomics) to provide meaningful health solutions (e.g. clinical decision support) o Program for training and education • Identity training requirements for specialty fields/clinical and non-clinical • Strategically and tactically continue to identify programmatic needs to support training, education, and manpower needs as TEH transforms medical services • Work with various AFMS research and development partners to develop technology needs assessment to support staff to better collect exposure information, translate and take appropriate protective and medical interventions.  Identify program gaps, resource needs, and institutionalize TEH within the AFMS and OSD o Strategically and tactically continue to identify programmatic needs to support training,
  • 23. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 19 education, and manpower needs as TEH transforms medical services o Work with various AFMS research and development partners to develop technology needs assessment to support staff to better collect exposure information, translate and take appropriate protective and medical interventions. o Build on the AFMS experience to build out beyond AFMS to the other services and DHA. o Identify program gaps, resource needs, and institutionalize TEH within the AFMS and OSD • Develop both Air Force and AFMS service TEH policies that expand beyond the AFMS to include other Air Force partners like the Civil Engineer, Human Resources and CIO. • Work with various intra Air Force agencies to create the policies outside of healthcare to institute TEH in to the Air Force landscape • Integrate with Individual Longitudinal Exposure Record (ILER) and MHS GENESIS • Develop the plan to support, augment and integrate TEH into the ILER • Develop the plan to support, augment and integrate TEH into Genesis  Identify training requirements for specialty fields/clinical and non-clinical o Work with each AFMS Associate Chief to identify training needs o Develop a training plan with specific training needs and programmatic plan to institute into the AFMS Force Development Panel plan  Leverage existing technologies and begin to shape exposure monitoring systems that connect with data analytics and clinical research (e.g., genomics) to provide meaningful health solutions (e.g. clinical decision support)  Develop both Air Force and AFMS service TEH policies that expand beyond the AFMS to include other Air Force partners like the Civil Engineer, Human Resources and CIO.  Expand relationships with inter and interagency partners to include the Department of Homeland Security and agencies with the Department of Health and Human Services.  Investigate feasibility of Federal, Interagency and other public sector partners and/or Public/Private partnerships as an innovative approach to ensure the AFMS does not bear the total cost or resources to find common ground to collectively bring TEH to the forefront and support the advancement of healthcare o Develop the plan to create partnerships and identify ways to leverage resources to find common ground to advance healthcare  Integrate TEH with ILER and MHS GENESIS  Establish sensor portfolio to generate a comprehensive, real-time/near-time, continuous exposure monitoring of the individual. Long-term Tasks (3-7 years)  Fully integrate TEH into future DOD policy/JCS doctrine, programs (e.g. ILER)  Integrate exposure data into MHS GENESIS and ILER  Promote protective health behaviors based on TEH research findings Given that TEH is a bold and novel holistic integration of technology and health across many areas (occupational, military threats, environmental, etc.) that are rapidly advancing, the expansion of TEH capabilities will be an iterative process where once one phase is complete and lessons learned are captured, future phases will be reviewed and reevaluated based on experience and emerging trends that may impact TEH. This will ensure the TEH remains relevant and provides the most beneficial support to the AFMS.
  • 24. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 20 5. STRATEGIC BUSINESS PLAN AND IMPLEMENTATION 5.1 STRATEGIC BUSINESS PLAN DEVELOPMENT AND METHODOLOGY This TEH Strategic Plan identifies the technical requirements and activities necessary for the development and implementation of TEH capabilities. It delineates the goals, objectives, focus areas, and strategic technical investments for TEH aligned to the overarching vision of AFMS. In order to make T E H capabilities a reality, a comprehensive Strategic Business Plan will be developed to document the foundational business practices to facilitate success. The Strategic Business Plan identifies how current and future TEH capabilities and projects will be planned, prioritized and executed. The plan will set forth how success, through the achievement of goals and objectives, will be measured and communicated. Additionally, the plan will identify how funding will be budgeted, executed, and monitored. Development of the Strategic Business Plan is an iterative process. Just as this Strategic Plan will be reviewed and refined, the Strategic Business Plan will be updated and modified to reflect necessary changes based on the development and implementation of TEH capabilities. The Strategic Business Plan will outline a fundamental and cyclical methodology to Plan, Prioritize, Budget, Execute, and Measure TEH initiatives and capability development (Figure 7). Plan: The Strategic Business Plan will delineate key processes and practices, organizational structures, and resources to be implemented in order to initiate and sustain the TEH capability, identify capability gaps and make the TEH capability a reality. This section includes the identification and management of focus areas, technical initiatives, and R&D projects to achieve TEH goals and objectives. The planning section will identify how risks (financial, operational, business, regulatory, et.al.) will be identified, managed and strategically communicated with internal and external stakeholders. Prioritize: The Strategic Business Plan will identify how key technical initiatives and R&D projects will be prioritized and selected. The Strategic Business Plan will delineate the methodology to be implemented to identify, prioritize, and select future TEH efforts. Budget: The process by which budgets will be determined, allocated, and monitored for individual initiatives or R&D projects will be documented. Additionally funding for the TEH capability will be planned, programmed and budgeted through the Program Objective Memorandum (POM) process and other AFMS procedures. Execute: The Strategic Business Plan will identify how the selected and budgeted initiatives and projects will be executed and monitored. Each initiative and project should develop customized schedules, budgets, and risk registers to manage the overall success. Measure: This section of the plan will outline techniques to measure both incremental success of individual initiatives and projects as well as total cumulative success of the TEH capability. Outcomes from the measuring techniques outlined in this section of the Strategic Business Plan will inform future planning efforts. 5.2 ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE AND STAFFING Organization structure and staffing will be addressed and completed in FY18 after specific CONOPS and other analysis such as the Business Plan and Capability Based Assessment. The initial structure for TEHO that was proposed for the FY 19-23 POM can be found in the COA and Supporting Documents section of this Plan. A TEHO initial proposed organization structure can be found in Figure 8. Final decisions will be made as part of the final CONOPS and associated analyses. Figure 7. Capabilities Development Lifecycle
  • 25. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 21 Figure 8. Initial Proposed Organizational Structure for TEHO 6. STRATEGIC TECHNICAL PLAN AND IMPLEMENTATION 6.1 TEH TECHNICAL SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT The challenge for developing TEH capabilities is bringing together distinct systems and initiatives into one portfolio: integrating exposure science, information technology, and existing healthcare programs to develop end-to-end systems (Figure 9). TEH capabilities will maximize the value of these advances by translating data collection, analysis, management, and visualization into clinically and personally actionable results.
  • 26. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 22 Figure 9. TEH End-to-End System Development 6.1.1 EXPOSURE MONITORING AND DATA COLLECTION In order to create a comprehensive TEH analytics platform, the Air Force will need to integrate traditional and non-traditional exposure assessment technologies to develop a robust exposure assessment capability. The capability will consider the current state of the science and the future technologies being developed (e.g., area monitoring, personal air sampling, survey instruments and questionnaires, etc.) with an increased emphasis on internal measurements of exposure and effect that come from traditional biomonitoring and new biotechnologies, including all of the -omics. Given the current state of the science, a robust combination of these exposure assessment tools is necessary to ensure data from the far field (smart home devices, GPS-related ambient environmental inputs), near field (individual sensors/dosimeters; patient generated data; Internet of Things [IoT]), medical records, and biological sources (urine, serum, sputum, saliva, stool, etc.). Micro-level or near- field sensors need to be mobile, user-friendly, accurate, low power, and economical. The popularity of this technological niche has created a vibrant market with an increasing number of useful devices becoming available. Taking advantage of the impressive and ubiquitous blue-tooth and Wi-Fi enabled technologies and sensors developed over the past few years, TEH intends to assess the value and utility of these data to reveal overall trends and improve current successes in personalized medicine efforts. Additionally, this shift from active self-reporting to passive surveillance of health and exposure data enhances reporting adherence and accuracy of information, which can greatly optimize costs in the MHS. 6.1.2 GENOMICS AND ASSOCIATED -OMICS Genomics is the foundation of our understanding of genetic predispositions to disease and disorder, but genomic sequencing is only the tip of the iceberg in understanding complex functional interactions between human health and the environment. It is estimated that genetics only account for 10-30% of illness and disease8 , leaving the vast majority of human health effects related to environment (workplace,
  • 27. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 23 lifestyle, and personal) exposures. The identification and phenotypic expression of genes are critical to predicting risk/susceptibility from exposure(s). In order to achieve a level of understanding to inform TEH initiatives, research and development in ‘-omic’ fields such as exposomics, metabolomics, lipidomics, transcriptomics and proteomics will need to be integrated through technologies for mining and analyzing large amounts of data (i.e., Big Data) to discover statistical associations between exposure, genetic biomarkers, and susceptibility factors. Multidisciplinary fields of study such as exposomics, the microbiome, and environmental epigenetics are focused on understanding these complex relationships that align with TEH goals. 6.1.2.1 Exposomics Exposures from our environment, microbiome, lifestyle, and workplace affect our physiology and health through epigenetics and the application of internal and external exposure assessment methods are crucial to understanding these interactions for health optimization and promotion. In addition to the above, research in fields of study such as transcriptomics and proteomics will be utilized by TEH to understand internal exposures, while external exposure assessment relies on measuring environmental exposures that stress and degrade human health. Paramount to exposomics is the ability to accurately measure exposures and exposure effect through "omics" research and technologies. 6.1.2.2 Microbiome The human gastrointestinal tract harbors diverse and abundant microbiota that are essential for human health. The human body is a highly complex ecosystem that has formed a permanent symbiotic relationship with our enteric cells9 . In recent years, there have been major gains in our understanding of the role of microbiome in host physiology. Alteration of the gut microbiome composition and function has been associated with the pathology of many diseases to include obesity and type 2 diabetes10 , as well as more complex diseases like inflammatory bowel disease, and autoimmune diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis. With diet being a significant exposure to the human body as well as the microbiome, it is imperative that we take advantage of recent advancements in the field of gut microbiome to help in further understanding the etiology of various biological disorders as part of the TEH solution set . 6.1.2.3 Epigenetics Exposures from our environment directly affect how gene expression is activated, repressed, and regulated. This is part of the larger filed known as epigenetics and TEH must understand how epigenetic changes in response to our exposures are involved in a wide range of what we currently believe as genetic diseases. Links between environmental exposures and epigenetics is not straight-forward and will involve integrating research and analyses from collaborating programs such as the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (NIEHS) and NIOSH to fully understand how environmental factors can cause epigenetic changes that lead to health problems or disease. One prime example is the National Institute of Health Roadmap Epigenomics Mapping Consortium, which is tasked with creating and cataloging reference epigenomes for use by the larger scientific community to use for comparative research. 6.1.3 CLINICAL EXPOSURE RECORDS The MHS has had a long standing directive to support the integration of exposure data into EHRs for Servicemembers. This was initially to relieve the burden on veterans who had to prove their hazard exposures encountered during deployment in order to claim compensation benefits. However, the success of exposure data integration into the clinical record so far has been limited due to the reliance on self-reporting as well as the uncertainty that medical conditions were caused by hazards (or undetected hazards). Therefore, TEH aims to increase the accuracy of exposure records by enhancing exposure data collection so that it is collected in quantifiable units that can later be used in mechanistic studies. Through TEH we can improve the exposure data collection process with more advanced and mobile sensors that will allow passive data collection, minimizing data gaps resulting from patient noncompliance with data entry and can detect exposures in terms of concentration in context with time
  • 28. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 24 and geographical location. Secondly, exposure data needs will be incorporated into military EHRs in a user-friendly, and eventually automated way. While reinventing EHRs is not feasible or productive, TEH will determine requirements and limitations for integrating individual exposure data into MHS GENESIS in order to establish technical requirements such as data format for new analytical platforms. The DoD has many systems and data warehouses and TEH will focus on integrating systems of record that already are being consolidated/interoperable and integrating with additional EHR systems over time. Systems to be considered include, but are not limited to:  Health Services Data Warehouse (HSDW)  Medical Data Repository (MDR)  MHS Data Mart (M2)  Defense Medical Surveillance System (DMSS)  Defense Occupational and Environmental Health Readiness System – Industrial Hygiene (DOEHRS-IH), including DOEHRS-Environmental Health and DOEHRS-Incident Reporting Module  Defense Occupational and Environmental Health Readiness System – Hearing Conservation (DOERHS-HC)  MHS GENESIS, the DoD’s new EHR system (when available; currently being tested in the Pacific Northwest)  Veterans Health Administration Corporate Data Warehouse (CDW)  Veterans Health Administration Health Data Repository (HDR)  Veterans Health Administration eHealth Management Platform, the Veterans Affairs (VA) new EHR system (when available)  Purchased care network  Non-MHS healthcare providers 6.1.4 DATA MANAGEMENT: COLLECTION, STORAGE, AND TRANSFER TEH will require a workflow that will include organizing, storing, integrating, and retrieving medical and exposure data using effective and efficient informatics solutions. These solutions will be able to standardize clinical and exposure data in a meaningful way, and enable healthcare professionals to analyze disparate data to discover associations between exposures and diseases/conditions. The development of electronic health records/electronic medical records (EHR/EMR) solutions, personal trackers and sensors, and the advancement of –omics technologies have made health informatics a necessary discipline among TEH initiatives. This conceptual TEH Health Informatics network will assist the TEH initiative to manage Big Data from multiple sources, organize, and analyze it in a meaningful way, and provide public health professionals the capability to recommend better treatment to improve healthcare outcomes but more importantly identify risk factors and health behaviors which if are mitigated may prevent the onset of a disease. 6.1.5 DATA ANALYTICS Given the use of multiple and diverse sensor types and data sources, TEH will seek technical solutions to uniformly standardize data and ensure interoperability between legacy and future systems. To be able to improve the level of healthcare provided to patients and impact healthcare outcomes, all different systems and solutions that generate data must be capable of differentiating between an abundance of data, select only meaningful types of data, and integrate this data under a common ecosystem for further processing and analysis (Figure 10). Ideally TEH data can be ingested and processed using the same data analytical engines as those that are currently used or will be used to analyze health and genomic data and integrated into MHS GENESIS. These systems should be modular, with the ability to swap in more advanced components into the technology stack when available and create limitless options in terms of sensors and data collection tools and techniques.
  • 29. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 25 Figure 10. Framework for Health Informatics 6.1.6 INDIVIDUAL EXPOSURE HEALTH RISK PROFILES (IEHRPS) Optimizing human performance is contingent on the ability to accurately identify, monitor/measure and document risk factors at the individual level. A logical extension to exposure monitoring, data collection and integration is deriving actionable information for either the individual and/or the clinician. This is achieved through the Individual Exposure Health Risk Profile (IEHRP), which is derived from the individual’s exposure, medical disposition, genetics and various variables. IEHRP development is a research initiative in the AFMS to leverage existing and ongoing exposomic, genomic, and epigenetic research studies to gather comprehensive data for understanding the risk at which an individual will develop a particular disease based on their individual exposome and genetic and clinical predispositions. IEHRP models will ultimately ingest data from AFMS/SG5 derived R&D programs and stakeholder developments. The ultimate goal is to have TEH systems that ingest exposomic and genomic data with monitored exposures and current medical disposition at the individual level and calculate personal risk profiles that can be used to inform and guide the individual to understand their risk profile and make healthy choices to reduce disease and illness and further use the aggregate information for population health and for policy and resource decision making. The problem facing the AFMS is how to quantify and statistically validate the combined impact of: (1) occupational, lifestyle, and environmental exposures in deployed, local, and home environments (2) clinical disposition and (3) genetic pre-dispositions and susceptibilities to exposure-related illness and injury, which contributes to health risk and drive preventive or protective COA Steps to reach these goals in the near term are:  Develop statistically validated algorithms that determine health risk profiles and drive preventive COA strategies for individuals  Establish an implementation plan to apply individual clinical, genetic and exposure data to IEHRP models that result in risk profiles to inform individuals for preventive behaviors and improved health outcomes.  Design and support execution of research studies that address DoD and AF healthcare disease priorities. When fully developed, the IEHRP will provide a new capability that will inform and encourage healthy lifestyle choices, enhance resilience and human performance, and reduce illness and injury. These capabilities will inform preventive strategies by reducing the health impacts of exposures, hence improving human performance, readiness, and the resiliency of all military members and their beneficiaries. Moreover, by educating individuals about their exposure profile, the IEHRP will enable
  • 30. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 26 individuals and families to make healthy lifestyle choices and become proactive about their own health (Figure 11). Figure 11. Future State of Exposure Data Supporting Theater and Clinical Operations 6.1.7 EXPERT SYSTEMS – CLINICAL DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEMS Analyzed exposure data needs to be visualized and made easily accessible to care givers by integrating exposure records with clinical decision support systems. These systems are capable of taking data curated from medical and scientific literature, federal guidance and policies, traditional health data from EHRs and eventually, exposure record data, and generating recommendations for clinical courses of action such as screenings, diagnostic tests, prescriptions, and prevention plans in some instances. TEH will need to understand the current expert systems being used in MHS and ensure interoperability with these systems. This will require evaluating the technology behind any current systems, understanding its impact of exposure data integration on patient data security, and determining how TEH data will be integrated. For example, InterQual has currently been adopted by MHS as a way to make medical admissions and authorizations more efficient11 . In this instance, TEH may collaborate with vendor specific engineers to configure InterQual’s algorithms to take into account a patient’s exposure record. 7. ENABLERS FOR TEH SUCCESS 7.1 CULTURAL AND TECHNOLOGY ENABLERS TEH will represent a major shift in approach with respect to healthcare and prevention. An examination of the current landscape, both within AFMS and externally, reveals a favorable environment that will support the successful development of a fully realized TEH capability. Rapidly evolving cultural factors make the launch of a TEH capability favorable at this time. The ubiquity of mobile phones, increased public adoption of “wearable” sensors and mobile health applications, as well as advancements in Big Data analytics can be leveraged by TEH capabilities. Further, cultural and policy shifts in military, federal, and private sectors to preventive and precision medicine establish both the foundation and the need for development of TEH capabilities. 7.1.1 COMMERCIAL POPULARITY OF HEALTH WEARABLES Individual “wearable” sensors permit both the generation of Big Data for analysis as well as personalized data for tailored care. Sensor systems need to be mobile, low power, and economical in order to maximize the continuity of data from an individual. Building from advancements in the global popularity of mobile phone technology, commercial products of this nature are rapidly emerging, and more now than ever, individuals are voluntarily interested in wearing health monitors to passively obtain data for themselves. The global market for health wearables is estimated to be $30B by 2018 12 . Tech giants like Google have recently developed a wearable that captures light exposure and noise levels in
  • 31. Air Force Medical Service Total Exposure Health Strategic Plan FY19-23 Unclassified 27 addition to basic biometrics (heart rate, temperature, etc.)13 . Another Google product being tested is a contact lens that monitors blood glucose levels14 . Likewise, The AFMS is investing in the development of wearable sensors. One example is the PEM, which is a wearable wireless monitoring device that measures long-term exposure to agents of interest on and off duty. Data from the PEM would be automatically integrated with other exposure data (e.g. DOEHRS) and genomics data if available. The sensor would be one that is small and out of the way for the user while maintaining its functionality in a variety of field environments. These wearable and “pocket” sensors permit both generation of “Real World Evidence” (RWE) for analyses and individual data for tailored care. New sensor development will provide new and better contextual information, rapidly identify unknown threats, and draw associations with low-level exposure biomarkers from human genomics, proteomics, metabolomics, etc. With a more complete picture of the impacts of exposures on health outcomes, the AFMS can tailor interventions to promote health and reduce adverse outcomes. 7.1.2 ADVANCES IN GENOMICS, BIG DATA AND OTHER SUPPORTING TECHNOLOGIES Also critical to the success of TEH are advances in technologies including high-throughput molecular characterization, genomic sequencing, and Big Data analytics. The cost of sequencing has plummeted over the past decade (Figure 1215 ), to less than $1000 per genome, giving access to more laboratories to rapidly identify genetic variants or elements that are associated with disease, immunity, response to treatment, etc., thereby making individual genomic analysis a reality. Advances in Big Data such as high- performance computing and cloud-based infrastructure permit the aggregation of millions of individual disparate exposure data points from “wearables”, etc., and the analysis of that data into information that can be used for public health and medicine. Figure 12. The Decreasing Cost of Next Generation Sequencing 7.1.3 AFMS MEDICAL MODERNIZATION There has been renewed interest in recent years to modernize and transform the AFMS into an exemplary healthcare system. This mindset has led to an increased willingness across the AFMS to move beyond traditional medicine, to embrace innovation, and to invest in preventive interventions. TEH supports the AFMS to move beyond just the treatment of illness and injury and to include preservation of health and optimization of performance, namely a move from healthcare to health. Driven by these emerging values and changes in attitude, the AFMS is well positioned to embrace novel and innovative approaches like TEH, which have the potential to significantly advance prevention and better health. The new Chief of Innovation for the Military Health System has indicated that change is needed in how future healthcare is delivered. “From an innovation perspective, the MHS needs to accelerate progress in health and readiness. Innovation is about identifying tools, practices and opportunities to partner to better serve our beneficiaries and meet our operational mission.” said Steffensen. He has stated that he