Moth Magic
by
Dr. Roger C. KENDRICK
C & R Wildlife, Hong Kong
founder
Asian Lepidoptera
Conservation Symposium
An Introduction to Moths
Introduction to Moths
• What is a moth?
• Diversity
• Survival Strategies
• Ecological Services
• Role in Wildlife
Conservation
• short break !!
• Recording Moths
• Field Identification
Skills . . .
What is a moth? main characters
Lepidoptera = Greek for scale-winged
27 characters defining Lepidoptera:
main ones on adult Lepidoptera are: -
• Hairs on wing modified as scales;
• Presence of haustellum (coiled proboscis – may be
degenerate or lost in some taxa);
• Presence of “vom Rath’s organ” in terminal segment of
labial palp;
• Fore tibia with movable “epiphysis” (antenna comb) on
inner surface;
• Median ocellus absent.
Moth Diversity
source:
Mutanen et al., 2010
Diversity - Major Families in Asia
• Tineidae
• Gracillariidae
• Yponomeutidae
• Oecophoridae
• Gelechiidae
• Tortricidae
• Pyralidae
• Crambidae
• Thyrididae
• Zygaenidae
• Sesiidae
• Sphingidae
• Saturniidae
• Geometridae
• Notodontidae
• Erebidae (inc. Arctiinae
& Lymantriinae)
• Nolidae
• Noctuidae
Diversity – Numbers of Species
Globally – c. 160,000 described, a further 150,000 to
200,000 estimated
China – circa 20,000 + ?
Borneo – c. 4,500 “macro” + further 4,000 “micro”
estimated
Taiwan – c. 4,000 recorded, adding tens new to science
most years
UK – 2,500 species, adding a few each year
HK – 2,400 recorded + 1,500 to 2,500 to find
Magic of Moth Diversity
• 150,000 to 200,000 species thought to be awaiting
description or discovery! (mostly in the tropics,
and even in HK – 590 of the 2,400 spp not id’d yet,
91 spp newly described by science since 1990)
• many ecological niches and almost all terrestrial
habitats occupied
• many species / higher taxa specially adapted to
particular ecological niche, thus good indicators of
habitat change, environmental impact or “quality”
Survival Strategies – Adult Moths
Mimicry
plants & lichens:
leaves, twigs, tree trunks,
(colour and shape/posture)
animals:
mammal faces; snakes;
unpalatable insects –
spiders, wasps, bees,
poisonous moths &
butterflies;
bird droppings
Survival Strategies – Adult Moths
Sound
detection of ultrasound to
avoid bats;
emitting sound to advertise
unpalatability (Arctiinae) or
pacify bees (Acherontia)
Colour
use of simple bold bright
patterns to advertise
unpalatability
flash colours to surprise
Survival Strategies – Moth Larvae
Mimicry
plants & lichens: leaves,
twigs, tree trunks, (colour
and shape/posture)
animals:
snakes; bird droppings
Survival Strategies – Moth Larvae
Concealment
crypsis; leaf rolling; leaf
mining; webs; stem borers;
root feeders; nocturnal
feeders
Colour
use of simple bold bright
patterns to advertise
unpalatability
Ecological Services
Pollination
Food resources
Nutrient Recycling
Pest control
Role of Moths in Wildlife
Conservation
high biodiversity, high relative abundance and
relative ease of identification make moths:
1. a good group for monitoring effects of ecological
processes and factors that affect these processes
2. indicate habitats and landscapes likely to be of
high conservation value
Role of Moths in Wildlife
Conservation
good for “hands on” demonstration of ecological
strategies and connecting with nature
Recording Moths
• Lights
• Traps
• Nets
• Baits
• Larvae
• Photography
• Weather
• Keeping Records
• Publishing
Lights
MV – mercury vapour
Actinic / UV – ultra-
violet
LED
Tungsten (incandescent)
Halogen
“Traps”
Sheet – needs to be manned at
all times. Good in the tropics Not
good for abundance samples.
Box – “Heath” and
“Skinner” traps. Catch
retention reasonable, but a long way
from perfect.
Bucket – “Robinson” trap
most efficient design, but still well
short of 100% catch retention. Large
traps not very portable, smaller
versions for use with actinic tubes
more portable.
Nets
Sweep net
Hand net
Malaise trap
Baits
“Sugar”
wine rope
fruit
faeces
synthetic
pheromones
others . . .
Photo: Fritz Geller-Grimm (via Wikipedia)Photo: D.E.Walter
(http://homebuggarden.blogspot.hk/2014/06/winters-coming.html)
Moth Larvae
Finding larvae
beating tray
sweep net
leaf rolls
leaf mines
galls (stems, twigs,
buds)
flowers & fruits
Rearing larvae
t.l.c. !
making notes & taking
photos . . .
Photography
digital camera
data storage
macro function
close focus
control of flash
best views to shoot
for i.d.
Weather
Light trapping: avoid high wind & heavy rain;
light rain / mist and warm conditions seem best;
in HK night time min between 17°C and 28°C
optimal; in UK between 8°C and ? (not warm
enough!)
larval searching: avoid heavy rain (everything
washed away!)
sugar/bait/pheromone: calm weather best
Keeping Records
what, (who made the
id)
sight record, voucher
specimen (where kept)
or photo
where seen/collected
when recorded
kept in notebook or on
computer database
Publishing
individual records of
note or a species life
history;
summary of a single
recording event
site or area lists
changes in species seen
or phenology (long term
data), distribution . . .
Field Identification of Moths
Wing pattern
Colour & Variations
Antennae
Resting Posture
Behaviour
Visible Field Characters
Adults
• Wing shape, pattern, posture
and coupling mechanism;
• On the head: form of antenna
and of labial palps;
• Presence of haustellum (coiled
proboscis – may be degenerate
or lost in some taxa);
• Pattern on head, thorax and
abdomen;
• Leg morphology & patterns.
Larvae
• Number of abdominal
prolegs;
• Pattern, spines, other
appendages.
Wing Patterns - areas
• Note the distinctive pattern features in relation to the wing areas
and edges as defined above.
• For clarity, all the possible lines (fascia and streaks) have not
been illustrated in the following pages – a particular marking
could occur anywhere on the wing; note its relative position to
the nearest edge and wing area.
medial
basal
terminal
costa
termen
tornus
dorsum
apex
base
Wing Patterns – vertical lines
lines crossing the wing:
Fasciae
1 – basal fascia
2 – sub-medial or ante-
medial fascia
3 – medial fascia
4 – post-medial fascia
5 – sub-terminal fasica
1
2 3 4 5
Wing Patterns - streaks
lines along the wing:
Streaks
1 – basal streak
2 – medial streak
3 – tornal streak
4 – apical streak
1
2 3
4
Wing Patterns - spots
spots on the wing
1 – orbicular stigma
2 – claviform stigma
3 – sub-reniform stigma
4 – discal spot, inside
the reniform stigma
1
3
2
4
Wing Patterns - veins
wing venation
(stems only)
1 – sub-costal vein (Sc)
2 – radial sector (Rs)
3 – cubital (Cu) /
medial vein (M)
4 – anal vein (A)
c – discal cell
1
4
2
3
c
Colour & Variation
Note the colour(s) of the wing patterns.
• Whilst this is not always diagnostic, it is usually a
good guide to a species’ identity.
• Sometimes colours on the body, legs, head or
ventral wing surface may be diagnostic.
• Be aware that colours & patterns in a species may:
differ between male and female; differ between
wet and dry seasons; have melanic forms; and/or
be faded and worn.
Antennae
Note the form and length of
the antenna,
• filiform (simple, threadlike)
• uni-, bi-, tri- or
quadripectinate (with one
ramus per segment, or 2 – 4
rami per segment)
• fasciculate
and if there is any distinct basal
modification, especially at the
scape (base)
Resting Posture
Note how the moth sits:
• how are the wings held;
• where are the antennae?
• how does it position its body and
legs?
Behaviour
What is the moth doing?
• record flowers visited;
• other nutritional sources used;
• thermoregulation behaviour;
• territorial behaviour.
• sexual behaviour;
Field i.d. – key references
• Barlow, H.S., 1982. An Introduction to the Moths of South East Asia.
Malayan Nature Society.
• Fauna Sinica Insecta (Science Press, Beijing), vols. 3, 5, 7, 11, 15, 16, 19,
27, 30, 31, 36, 38, 47.
• Haruta, T. (ed.) 1992-2000. Moths of Nepal (in 6 parts, published as
supplement volumes of the journal Tinea)
• Holloway, J.D., 1983-2011. The Moths of Borneo (in 18 parts)
[available on-line, except parts 2, 13 & 17]
• Leverton, R., 2001. Enjoying Moths. T. & A.D.Poyser Natural History,
London
• Robinson, G.S., Tuck, K.R. & Shaffer, M., 1994. The Smaller Moths of
South-East Asia. The Natural History Museum, London
• various authors. The Moths of Thailand. 6 volumes published to date.,
Bangkok.
Recording HK’s Moths
• Photographic records – please deposit at iNaturalist’s Hong
Kong Moths Recording Project, whence they’ll get added to
the HK Moth Recorder Database.
• Identifications – via websites : HKMR on iNat, Moths of
Borneo, Moths of Japan ; & HK Wildlife Net forum / F/B
• Can’t find an i.d.? – consider further research options, visit
KFBG’s HK moth collection (by appointment), or . . .
• Books on HK moths :
• Kendrick (2002) – Ph.D. thesis (many nomenclatural updates and a few
misidentifications)
• HKLS photo “guides” (two volumes so far: 2014, 2015)
• HKES volumes on insects – “Insecta Hongkongica” & “A Photographic Guide to
HK Insects” (though with unnecessary errors)
Why are moths magic ?
because . . . .
Survival strategy:
colours; shapes;
behaviour
Biodiversity: high species
richness
Involvement: community
and individual
Value: conservation,
ecosystem and
cultural
Acknowledgments:
Attendees
Thank you
Asian Lepidoptera
Conservation Symposia
ALCS3 - Bharathiar University, Coimbatore, India, 2010
ALCS4 - Nankai University, Tianjin, China, 2012
ALCS – NSS Workshop, Singapore, 2014
Hong Kong Bird Watching Society
(Hong Kong)
Moth Magic - Questions ?

Moth Magic- An Introduction to Moths [2015 HKBWS]

  • 1.
    Moth Magic by Dr. RogerC. KENDRICK C & R Wildlife, Hong Kong founder Asian Lepidoptera Conservation Symposium An Introduction to Moths
  • 2.
    Introduction to Moths •What is a moth? • Diversity • Survival Strategies • Ecological Services • Role in Wildlife Conservation • short break !! • Recording Moths • Field Identification Skills . . .
  • 3.
    What is amoth? main characters Lepidoptera = Greek for scale-winged 27 characters defining Lepidoptera: main ones on adult Lepidoptera are: - • Hairs on wing modified as scales; • Presence of haustellum (coiled proboscis – may be degenerate or lost in some taxa); • Presence of “vom Rath’s organ” in terminal segment of labial palp; • Fore tibia with movable “epiphysis” (antenna comb) on inner surface; • Median ocellus absent.
  • 4.
  • 5.
    Diversity - MajorFamilies in Asia • Tineidae • Gracillariidae • Yponomeutidae • Oecophoridae • Gelechiidae • Tortricidae • Pyralidae • Crambidae • Thyrididae • Zygaenidae • Sesiidae • Sphingidae • Saturniidae • Geometridae • Notodontidae • Erebidae (inc. Arctiinae & Lymantriinae) • Nolidae • Noctuidae
  • 6.
    Diversity – Numbersof Species Globally – c. 160,000 described, a further 150,000 to 200,000 estimated China – circa 20,000 + ? Borneo – c. 4,500 “macro” + further 4,000 “micro” estimated Taiwan – c. 4,000 recorded, adding tens new to science most years UK – 2,500 species, adding a few each year HK – 2,400 recorded + 1,500 to 2,500 to find
  • 7.
    Magic of MothDiversity • 150,000 to 200,000 species thought to be awaiting description or discovery! (mostly in the tropics, and even in HK – 590 of the 2,400 spp not id’d yet, 91 spp newly described by science since 1990) • many ecological niches and almost all terrestrial habitats occupied • many species / higher taxa specially adapted to particular ecological niche, thus good indicators of habitat change, environmental impact or “quality”
  • 8.
    Survival Strategies –Adult Moths Mimicry plants & lichens: leaves, twigs, tree trunks, (colour and shape/posture) animals: mammal faces; snakes; unpalatable insects – spiders, wasps, bees, poisonous moths & butterflies; bird droppings
  • 9.
    Survival Strategies –Adult Moths Sound detection of ultrasound to avoid bats; emitting sound to advertise unpalatability (Arctiinae) or pacify bees (Acherontia) Colour use of simple bold bright patterns to advertise unpalatability flash colours to surprise
  • 10.
    Survival Strategies –Moth Larvae Mimicry plants & lichens: leaves, twigs, tree trunks, (colour and shape/posture) animals: snakes; bird droppings
  • 11.
    Survival Strategies –Moth Larvae Concealment crypsis; leaf rolling; leaf mining; webs; stem borers; root feeders; nocturnal feeders Colour use of simple bold bright patterns to advertise unpalatability
  • 12.
  • 13.
    Role of Mothsin Wildlife Conservation high biodiversity, high relative abundance and relative ease of identification make moths: 1. a good group for monitoring effects of ecological processes and factors that affect these processes 2. indicate habitats and landscapes likely to be of high conservation value
  • 14.
    Role of Mothsin Wildlife Conservation good for “hands on” demonstration of ecological strategies and connecting with nature
  • 15.
    Recording Moths • Lights •Traps • Nets • Baits • Larvae • Photography • Weather • Keeping Records • Publishing
  • 16.
    Lights MV – mercuryvapour Actinic / UV – ultra- violet LED Tungsten (incandescent) Halogen
  • 17.
    “Traps” Sheet – needsto be manned at all times. Good in the tropics Not good for abundance samples. Box – “Heath” and “Skinner” traps. Catch retention reasonable, but a long way from perfect. Bucket – “Robinson” trap most efficient design, but still well short of 100% catch retention. Large traps not very portable, smaller versions for use with actinic tubes more portable.
  • 18.
  • 19.
    Baits “Sugar” wine rope fruit faeces synthetic pheromones others .. . Photo: Fritz Geller-Grimm (via Wikipedia)Photo: D.E.Walter (http://homebuggarden.blogspot.hk/2014/06/winters-coming.html)
  • 20.
    Moth Larvae Finding larvae beatingtray sweep net leaf rolls leaf mines galls (stems, twigs, buds) flowers & fruits Rearing larvae t.l.c. ! making notes & taking photos . . .
  • 21.
    Photography digital camera data storage macrofunction close focus control of flash best views to shoot for i.d.
  • 22.
    Weather Light trapping: avoidhigh wind & heavy rain; light rain / mist and warm conditions seem best; in HK night time min between 17°C and 28°C optimal; in UK between 8°C and ? (not warm enough!) larval searching: avoid heavy rain (everything washed away!) sugar/bait/pheromone: calm weather best
  • 23.
    Keeping Records what, (whomade the id) sight record, voucher specimen (where kept) or photo where seen/collected when recorded kept in notebook or on computer database
  • 24.
    Publishing individual records of noteor a species life history; summary of a single recording event site or area lists changes in species seen or phenology (long term data), distribution . . .
  • 25.
    Field Identification ofMoths Wing pattern Colour & Variations Antennae Resting Posture Behaviour
  • 26.
    Visible Field Characters Adults •Wing shape, pattern, posture and coupling mechanism; • On the head: form of antenna and of labial palps; • Presence of haustellum (coiled proboscis – may be degenerate or lost in some taxa); • Pattern on head, thorax and abdomen; • Leg morphology & patterns. Larvae • Number of abdominal prolegs; • Pattern, spines, other appendages.
  • 27.
    Wing Patterns -areas • Note the distinctive pattern features in relation to the wing areas and edges as defined above. • For clarity, all the possible lines (fascia and streaks) have not been illustrated in the following pages – a particular marking could occur anywhere on the wing; note its relative position to the nearest edge and wing area. medial basal terminal costa termen tornus dorsum apex base
  • 28.
    Wing Patterns –vertical lines lines crossing the wing: Fasciae 1 – basal fascia 2 – sub-medial or ante- medial fascia 3 – medial fascia 4 – post-medial fascia 5 – sub-terminal fasica 1 2 3 4 5
  • 29.
    Wing Patterns -streaks lines along the wing: Streaks 1 – basal streak 2 – medial streak 3 – tornal streak 4 – apical streak 1 2 3 4
  • 30.
    Wing Patterns -spots spots on the wing 1 – orbicular stigma 2 – claviform stigma 3 – sub-reniform stigma 4 – discal spot, inside the reniform stigma 1 3 2 4
  • 31.
    Wing Patterns -veins wing venation (stems only) 1 – sub-costal vein (Sc) 2 – radial sector (Rs) 3 – cubital (Cu) / medial vein (M) 4 – anal vein (A) c – discal cell 1 4 2 3 c
  • 32.
    Colour & Variation Notethe colour(s) of the wing patterns. • Whilst this is not always diagnostic, it is usually a good guide to a species’ identity. • Sometimes colours on the body, legs, head or ventral wing surface may be diagnostic. • Be aware that colours & patterns in a species may: differ between male and female; differ between wet and dry seasons; have melanic forms; and/or be faded and worn.
  • 33.
    Antennae Note the formand length of the antenna, • filiform (simple, threadlike) • uni-, bi-, tri- or quadripectinate (with one ramus per segment, or 2 – 4 rami per segment) • fasciculate and if there is any distinct basal modification, especially at the scape (base)
  • 34.
    Resting Posture Note howthe moth sits: • how are the wings held; • where are the antennae? • how does it position its body and legs?
  • 35.
    Behaviour What is themoth doing? • record flowers visited; • other nutritional sources used; • thermoregulation behaviour; • territorial behaviour. • sexual behaviour;
  • 36.
    Field i.d. –key references • Barlow, H.S., 1982. An Introduction to the Moths of South East Asia. Malayan Nature Society. • Fauna Sinica Insecta (Science Press, Beijing), vols. 3, 5, 7, 11, 15, 16, 19, 27, 30, 31, 36, 38, 47. • Haruta, T. (ed.) 1992-2000. Moths of Nepal (in 6 parts, published as supplement volumes of the journal Tinea) • Holloway, J.D., 1983-2011. The Moths of Borneo (in 18 parts) [available on-line, except parts 2, 13 & 17] • Leverton, R., 2001. Enjoying Moths. T. & A.D.Poyser Natural History, London • Robinson, G.S., Tuck, K.R. & Shaffer, M., 1994. The Smaller Moths of South-East Asia. The Natural History Museum, London • various authors. The Moths of Thailand. 6 volumes published to date., Bangkok.
  • 37.
    Recording HK’s Moths •Photographic records – please deposit at iNaturalist’s Hong Kong Moths Recording Project, whence they’ll get added to the HK Moth Recorder Database. • Identifications – via websites : HKMR on iNat, Moths of Borneo, Moths of Japan ; & HK Wildlife Net forum / F/B • Can’t find an i.d.? – consider further research options, visit KFBG’s HK moth collection (by appointment), or . . . • Books on HK moths : • Kendrick (2002) – Ph.D. thesis (many nomenclatural updates and a few misidentifications) • HKLS photo “guides” (two volumes so far: 2014, 2015) • HKES volumes on insects – “Insecta Hongkongica” & “A Photographic Guide to HK Insects” (though with unnecessary errors)
  • 38.
    Why are mothsmagic ? because . . . . Survival strategy: colours; shapes; behaviour Biodiversity: high species richness Involvement: community and individual Value: conservation, ecosystem and cultural
  • 39.
    Acknowledgments: Attendees Thank you Asian Lepidoptera ConservationSymposia ALCS3 - Bharathiar University, Coimbatore, India, 2010 ALCS4 - Nankai University, Tianjin, China, 2012 ALCS – NSS Workshop, Singapore, 2014 Hong Kong Bird Watching Society (Hong Kong)
  • 40.
    Moth Magic -Questions ?

Editor's Notes

  • #18 Sheet – labour intensive as needs to be manned at all times. Good in the tropics if large beetles and bugs are anticipated as this method minimises damage to specimens. Not good for abundance samples. Can be difficult to set up. Box – “Heath” and “Skinner” traps both useful as can be packed flat for work in the field. Catch retention reasonable, but a long way from perfect. Bucket – “Robinson” trap most efficient design, but still well short of 100% catch retention. Large traps not very portable, smaller versions for use with actinic tubes more portable.