Gulberg Society Trial Full Judgement (17.06.2016)

•@
G
o
C Special Designated Court for Riot Cases, at Ahmedabad
f!:
JUDGMENTf)
e in
e Sessions Case No.152 of 2002
e with
e Sessions Case No.167 of 2003
•
with
• Sessions Case No.279 of 2003
e with
Sessions Case No.190 of 2009
•
•
with
•
•e
S~s~i()ns Case No.191 of 2009
.. with ... ....
SessioIls Case No.193of 2009 .
withe
SeSsions Case No.194 of 2009G
} ..••. with
o ' .. :.::::::.". .:
Sessions Case No.195 of 2009Q~::
c:.;, </ withV
S~~si6nsCaseNo.279 of 2009~ .-:'-::-::>:-::
o
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

INDEX

PART · ... )·i> PARTICULARS PAGE NOS.
I Facts, details. With regard to documents, list of 5 to 65
witnesses and rel~varit exhibits
II (a) Arguments on behalf of Prosecution 66 to 411
(b) Arguments on behalf of Victims 411 to 432
,
III (a) Arguments on behalf of Defence 433 to 705
(b) Rejoinder arguments by Prosecution 705 to 726
(c) Rejoinder arguments by Defence 726 to 741
IV Reasons, findings, final order and judgment 742 to 1341

••
~
o
•
•
•••
•
•
fJ
••
•
•
•
• Sl!q!qxalueAala~
PH!!,";"
o
A
o
~
<..~.
V

A

V
@
••
•
•
•
••
••
•
•••
~
ojn~~81~;,qj~~!,*_b~J~p
.....',~~",!.,~j~~~:i1,'··•......•••......:i'·
I-~lIfd
••••
~
9

·
•••
••••••
•e
e
@
£) SCs/152/02.167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 1
~.-:~::;
Before the Special Designated Court
o
o
@
o
f)
C'i.'~"':~)
o

0.:..~;
~
e
~
e
o

with


with


with


with


with


with


with


with


.~
.,
jj
jj
ir
i'
I
I
Judgment
i~
at Ahmedabad
~
o Complainant state of Gujarat
@
A versusV
~ Accused
t)
A
Sessions Case No.152 of 2002~
()
1) KAlLAS LALCHAND DHOBI (IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY)
G 2) YOGENDRASINH @ LALO MOHANSINH SEKHAWAT
o 3) SURENDRASINH @ VAKIL DIGVIJAYSINH CHAUHAN
4) MANGAJI POKARJI MARWADIo
5) JAYESH RAMUBHAI PATNIN
o 6) KISHORBHAI MANGABHAI PATNI
e 7) SHAILESH KALUBHAI PATNI
G 8) KANAIYA @ BABLU CHAICHAU
9) KANTIBHAI POPATBHAI PATNI
G
10) SAKRABHAI SENDHABHAI PATNI
G 11) MANOJKUMAR PREMJIBHAI PARMAR
e 12) DEEPAKKUMAR SOMABHAI SOLANKI
13) VINODBHAI ARVINDBHAI SOLANKI
14) JAYESHKUMAR @ GABBAR MAGANLAL JINGER (MOCHI)• 15) AJAY SOMABHAI PANCHAL
16) DILIP @ KALU CHATURBHAI PARMAR
~._.;:-
..... '.i i ';"~
/ . ,- .. ;-".":It/': .,'.,.I .9 ,.~,r• .- "'.J" ,--_. -... ... '"
,,,•• y" '~"" ,.,~f'-' '.......: ,; ,.

l~ ,« :."':,,,~~; (t~~ :}--....::: 0
- J.t:i;4 ;.nmlC:i~~.~~~~p (",
1ft I: i '.' :", i;~~~x.1 ·~:··.f ;:....-t
p.i ..... f '" ':' ("'" ~j
~;~~~,2~?,:;~~~;~
.........o<:~::.::::~::>;.~_;~~ .

,<
~
I~':
.'
.:.:
r

••
••••
~• ;~~~ ::~
~
ff:l ;j;
()
o.'.)-' SCsIl52102,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 2 Judgment
('.;C}
:...;;'
17) RATILAL GANESHJI KUMBHAR (Abated)
() 18) SANJAYKUMAR SHANKARBHAI PATNI
(j 19) SHAILESH NATWARLAL PATNI
o 20) NARESH @ NARIYO BANSILAL~0'
A,
x::.:)
@
C 21) SANDEEP @ SONU RAMPRAKASH MEHRA
22) BABUBHAI MOHANBHAI PATNIG
e
••
23) BABUBHAI MANJIBHAI PATNI
24)

25)

26)

e 27)

l j~ 28)

29)
(:)'
30)
t'::'i
8
31)
C; 32)
r'''' 33)j.3
r:·"
34)
t~:: )
35)
(lJ 36)
() 37)
e'
o
SHANKARJI HAKAJI MALI
MANGILAL DHUPCHAND JAIN
PANNALAL @ PRABHU MOCHI
GOPALDAS MANDAS VAISHNAV
PRAHLADJI RAJUJI ASORI
MUKESH PUKHRAJ SANKHLA (MOCHI)
MADANLAL DHANRAJ RAVAL
MAHENDRA MULCHANDBHAI PARMAR
AMBESH KANTILAL JINGAR (MOCHI)
PRAHLAD OMPRAKASH SONGARA
KRISHNAKUMAR @ KRISHNA (SON
ASOK @ ASLO DHARSINH THAKOR
CHlRAG DILIP SHAH
PRAKASH @ KALI KHENGARJI
Sessions Case No.190 of 2009(.~
S.J
4-'01
%:1 38) MANISH PRABHULAL JAIN
39) MUKESH ATMARAM THAKORo
(c:.~
'-J
o
PRAJAPATI
PUNJABI (IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY)
(Abated)
PREMCHAND SISODIYA
(Abated)
PADHIYAR

A
Y 40) PARBATSINH TARSANSING @ DARSHANSINH DARPANSINH
@
If::':;, Sessions Case No.193 of 2009
~
C"."
41) JAYESH RAMJIBHAI PARMAR (IN JUDICIAL C_~~~~~~.
ou
Sessions Case No,194 of 2009~
42) RAJU @ MAMO KANIYO RAMAVTAR TIWARI@
43) NARAYAN SITARAM TANK @ NARAN CHENALWALO
G (IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY)
OF CHAMPABEN)
(Abated)
/";~' '... )C(::11- ] :"'~.
/(/ •••,1 ':'_"'~""'-"""-...:: t: ..."
/.~~/i.:o~>:J·:',;, ':;'~;...'.::;(~)
(IN ~:~:~;r~··,'c~~t~DX:~.:J~:~~C}.·'
@ N~~~! r(1)HIYQ:;,i,>; ~.l C:j
n ) {TJ L
," ".Ii- , ), .'
'~: 1 j ; -V"') '_...1.:
:'" ::~>~'" _, 1',--:",'; ";'F ).+ Ii
'1 1..' , "A.' '1 ~" .l" V -', !J
~~ .~.)' .'~._.....:: '~:~..r'~"~i"~"A<r::<~) /~
.,... ! ...",,;-, .--,--••_.~'C' ;.-'" /..'1'
':". "n.;1 ;-..•-", ,.} "-~., ...-::"~....... " '-"; C"': , i~ ........-""
~i~,,:-~~:.-l..: ..._'_~::;;.~
~-......--~
v

~'
, "'
~
~;~.
~:;
I>
SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 3 JudgmenL.
!
.~
"j] 44)
45)
46)
47)
~ 48)
49)
50)..~
51)

52)

~~ 53)

54)

55)

NAGIN HASMUKHBHAI PATNI

DASRATH @ GETTING JIVANBHAI PATNI (Abated) t-::

LAKHANSINH @ LAKHIYO BHURIYO LALUBHA
DHARMESH PRAHLADBHAI SHUKLA
JITENDRA @ JITU PRATAPJI THAKOR
MAHESH @ PAPPU PRATAPJI THAKOR
KAPILDEV NARAYAR @ MUNNABHAI MISHRA
MAHESH RAMJIBHAI NATH
SURESH KALI DAHYABHAI DHOBI
SUSHIL BRIJMOHAN SHARMA
BHARAT @ BHARAT TELLI SHITLAPRASAD
BHARAT LAXMANSINH GOD RAJPUT
,',
BALODIYA
'~
:rt
-:..
56)·:1~3
57)

~:~
58)

"'.' 59)

60)

61)

62)

63)

'~
PRADIP KHANABHAI PARMAR
KIRITKUMAR GOVINDJI ERDA
MEGHSING DHUPSING CHAUDHARI
ATUL INDRAVADAN VAIDH
BIPIN AMBALAL PATEL
CHUNILAL JETHALAL PRAJAPATI (Abated)

DILIP KANTILAL JINGAR

DINESH PRABHUDAS SHARMA (IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY)

'j]
64) SHIVCHARAN @ JITENDRA @ LALLO RAMJIRAI (IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY)
~ 65) RAJESH DAYARAM JINGAR
~ 66) BABU HASTIMAL MARWADI
::~
Appearances~~~
1) Shri R.C.Kodekar, learned Spl .P.P. for the
~} State.
:ii,
.~
2) Shri S.M.Vora, learned advocate for the original't:j
complainants/victims.
3) Shri Abhay Bhardwaj, Shri Rajendra Trivedi, Shri
T.R. Bajpai and Shri H.L.Jani, learned advocates
for the concerned accused.
/ ~;:~~~~-F~~',,,) (.' ,,:..~~
CORAM: Mr.P.B.Desai, Principal Judge, (2.~ty,jC:JAr..tl(:.'&'{~~
Ses~ions Court and,
Deslgnated Court for rlot
Society Mas sacre Case)
r::
CHUDASAMA l',
k
i-~:l·~·
b:
/ ' , '0 0'" ' - . " ' ,.;~
spelo~~~,:.·~·;.." ,~~~~~.(.~.~
cf.ay·,e,-s,;:·.·· (G,}li+}~JJ.r:.g ,()
fi:!'~( ';< ;:;;:~ ,~., i. c:H
{~' <,:':;}"~, .~,t~J
:' ._'" ", : ".' ," : r'. ''') r > if'
'~~~~~S~f

f-;.
..~~.
~
,~ I~
I,~:
SCS/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 4 Judgment
JUDGMENT
1. All the present proceedings relate to
and arise out of what has been recognized as one of
the most heinous incidents of a communal riot, where
.,
no less than 69 victims of a particular community
'~
were done to death by a mob of large number of.-;,~
~
persons, of whom the present accused are, in terms.-,.,.,
of the Prosecution case, involved therein and the
present proceedings are known and referred to as the
"Gulbarg Society Massacre Case". The horrific
incident in question took place on 28/02/2002. The
subsequent sessions are on account of the
subsequent arrest of accused and filing of
supplementary chargesheet which gave rise to
"~ separate proceedings. However, since all these cases
arose out of the same incident, vide order dated
23/07/2009 passed below Exh.97, the proceedings were
j}
ordered to stand consolidated and even a
'~
consolidated charge has been framed herein.
~:
2. It is required to be noted that there
$'
;~
were initially 66 accused facing trial, of whom
acclised Nos.17, 23, 27, 35, 45 and 61 have passed
away during the pendency of the present proceedings
and therefore, the trial has
such six of the accused.
continued to proceed against
such trial has ultimately
judgment.
stood abated against
The t r ip..J;,~,,:c::~h;~ t hus
/~'~"'" f~, I':' i::''':~
tot a .;(.-./6 O".a,eg'Q.~:e:q.)';~n d
.f ." '., " ~. ~""""1 "",,1 ""
led/' t'o . 'th<e~' ~:~p:2el~~~
. .. . ~, ....0{:...... ~ i. ~ ~'"~
".:;' ,,: ~ 'c::)~ , .'" ~.:; . ~ ':(1!i
, ".~ , ( .......~"

', ,<' <,.,:,;~':;; :r~;(, If+ ~J
;-.. ,,-;' '.. ' :.:. ' '.).' '<'''~' /"
"'<~01~I~.7 .

::
~:
•e
IE~
:."
e :~~
~o !:.
iC?, ,.
l~> SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 5 Judgment l.~
o
~.~
~~
()
(:)
£1~J'
o

~
~~:/
f~
£.~{.~...
G
•••
o•

o
u~
rCh,
~';i
~
f:)
~
~
e
o
@
e
~
~
~
":.'~
@~.
e
~
e..~
o
()
o
~
G
G
•
e
•
•
~--
3. For the sake of convenience, the present Ie
[:
judgment has been divided into four integral parts
as per the following details:
Part - I
Part - II
Part - III
Part - IV
Facts, details with regard to
documents, list of witnesses and
relevant exhibits.
Arguments on behalf of:
(a) Prosecution
(b) Victims
(a) Arguments on behalf of Defence
(b) Rejoinder arguments by
Prosecution
(c) Rejoinder arguments by Defence
Reasons, findings, final order and
judgment
*********
PART - I
:;
4. The accused are attributed to have
committed offences punishable under Secs.120(B),
143, 147, 148, 153(A) (1) (a), (b), 153(A) (2), 186, 188,
201, 217, 218, 295, 302, 307, 323, 324, 332, 337,
376 (2) (g), 396, 397,
read together with
Penal Code and under
Act, and of the 60
21, 41, 42, 43, 63
398, 435, 436, 447, 44.2,,,,,,~J.l2- 452,
.r"i>.' _."......,.,........,........_..;.~ ....

Secs. 34 and 149 ,~~~'t'j:i,~PfP~{l
Sec .135 (1)
accused,
and 64
//.:,.:/,,-/- ._'......'" ~,
of t~'~')'~6nwa-y~:91:l--'c~'1
accus~¥':.~;~3"~·~ii:;:.?'h4 ··~;.l·~,:)~~. ~ ..... '..... ,. ,- " 'j • "-"',~~:"
are hiQ~i'E:d tbciil al~t;:,:jl
i'<;~~,}::=-~~;;~!J
I'
t·:
I

•••••
-•• 1
o '::~.""'::'.
!~ :,'(:;)
:~
:-:
~
~;;" SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 6 Judgment
l'i.
~-:
o l:~.
I ~ '.
throughout the proceedings and are in jUdicial ,',@ I::
custody for more than 12 years. Some of the accused f:',
~ ...:
1':'
~,',,':';
0' I"
~ have been enlarged on bail pending trial and some of
tGf
~...~)~ the accused been as accused~ have arraigned
{) consequent to applications tendered by the victims
~w who have been permitted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
~
'&,J'
to play a proactive role in the present proceedings
o and in furtherance thereof, such victims preferred
e
•• applications under Sec. 319 of the Cr.P.C. for
arraignment of persons as accused herein, which has
resulted incidentally in the original complainant
who was a Police Officer holding the rank of
••
••
e
••
•
-';:
Inspector of Police (P. I. ) to be arraigned as an
[,
accused herein. It is required to be noted that the ",'t"
lee:
1-.'
•G
injured victims and surviving family members of f"·-:
persons who had lost their lives in the present
incident, have even moved the Hon' ble Apex Court
• from time to time which has resulted in a Special
Investigation Team (to be referred to herein after
•e

~.
as "the SIT" for short) being formed, with
directions given by the Hon'ble Supreme Court from
time to time. The Hon'ble Supreme Court even I~~
o
£:f appointed Amicus Curiae oversee the~ an to
o functioning of the Special Investigation Team and
t}
in fact the investigation of the SIT into the
e present offence as also seven other related
o incidents of communal carnages in Gujarat in the
o
year 2002 were being actively monito:r;,E;d::c:.·;ffT~:'::~e
e ;>"/ '> '; ) i ,'.' i """,:~
Hon' ble Supreme Court from time to ti}rt¥:·'~,:~DJ,:~11:h.·~i~:¥::~
•
J'.... ,'~ 'I' ;,< ',;..'..~~-- ~j:~ ~'~... !""'-".~ ...

the Hon' ble Supreme Court vide.{,,:.:q':t:_~er:~;}<;~f-~~"~_~<':'

• -I I , - . ";. ~: ~ .. ...., ~..... ..... -.~
14/11/2014, came to the conclusion t~at;ltJ;1erE)':"vv~s 'no~C:jJ
~~i~~;:~t/~:;..-

,
•••
•••
•••••
6
• ;~'
~
"~~
•e ,PA
g"
SCs/152/02,167 • 279103, 190,191,193,194,195,279109 7 Judgment
o further need to monitor the investigation any
e further and the Hon'bleR"'>.~;J
direction to the trial@
in its entirety leadingo
tlJ is also required
o circumstances, the
£.:"
"<...~
to be belonging
AU
A
proceedings where the present incident has
~
admittedly come into scrutiny of the international
G
community at large. It is in the background of suchG
C facts and circumstances that the Prosecution case in
., a nutshell, is required to be narrated briefly as
••
o
•
herein after follows.
5 . It is the Prosecution case that a
horrific incident took place at the Godhra Railway
Station on 27/02/2002 when a train carrying
'Karsevaks' returning from Ayodhya, was allegedly
8 attacked by members of
~,".'
~
coaches of the train
e
Karsevaks travelling in
G
permitted to get out of such burning coaches ando
(] were ultimately set afire and burnt alive. It is the
o case of the Prosecution that in response to such
e incident, a number of Organizations/Institutions
o• gave a Bandh call and it is also the case of the
Prosecution that the charred and burnt bodies of
such Karsevaks were being brought t~<~~r
being handed over to their rel~-¥.i:~~'~'·:,;..,~<:3'~~~~
• process for
Incidentally,
to
Supreme Court has issued a
Court to conclude the trial
to the present judgment. It
be noted that in such
present proceedings can be said
to a very different class of
the minority community and
were set afire and the
such train coaches were not
their final rites,//.:q,il.}~28102l~~9),2.)
according to the U§;~~~'i~CUri~~,". t~)}
·"·~~I;_JJJ;J

~:'
i-·
(::
IS
"
t~
~
i . .
:.~
i
i:
tt
I .
, .
I
r".'
l
I

••••
••••••••
~:
~:
:;:
:~:••
•
@
~ i'
~7 SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 8 Judgment
o Bandh call was also given for 28/02/2002. It is the
o case of the Prosecution that in furtherance of theEft"'lL:.~
said Bandh call, various localities came under heavye
@ Police bandobast since there were perceived
R0,
e communally sensitive localities of Ahmedabad.
tf':"
'0'Y other hand, the Police Station within
u
~
jurisdiction the Gulbarg Society fell,
@
to be
On the
whose
was
Meghaninagar Police Station which was not perceived
e
to be a very communally sensitive locality. It is
the case of the Prosecution that in furtherance of
and in an effort to rigidly enforce the Bandh call,
mobs started gathering in the present locality where
e the present incident has taken place and incidents
c of stone throwing, arson, looting and setting afire
6
of vehicles belonging to the minority community as(j
also forcing down the shopkeepers to shut shops, hado
o commenced right since the morning of the fateful
o day. It is the case of the Prosecution that a number
~
of incidents took place surrounding Gulbarg Society
o (which would be narrated at length and in great
o
detail in the course of the present judgment) whichfj
rresulted in heightening of tension in the vicinitye r
c
o of Gulbarg Society and its surrounding
e neighbourhood. It is the Prosecution case that
G Gulbarg Society was occupied by members of the
G
minority community, of whom an elected Member of
o
Parliament (ex-MP) Shri Ehsan Jafri was 9~e:::~·(:}f~~-be
e ~~~~-::..,-:~... ~ :.... (~~.j /~~ .:.~:,:':'..
residents of the said Gulbarg societl?~~.~:t",··±s-<":.t?he.',,:,,
l/ ~,._>~j _<~t .~"( "'. l.,~' i ~ -...
case of the Prosecution that the ~~trj?;~~f.::s,·~~~,:;/t:(~~:i;'~·_'.
minority community were also residin~Uih''h.ou·se's and !':1" ~
l'i ,-, " , : ",.,.1 H
chawla which were inhabited by membJf~):if b61:h" th~):)
~2j!:"?J8Y

•••••
•••~:~;;.-<
~ SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 9 Judgment
© communities but on account of the atmosphere so
e created on the fateful day i.e. on 28/02/2002, the
o
A
~
members of the minority community residing in the
~
".'1 chawls and nearby houses, , took shelter in Gulbarg
~::..~
A
Society since it was perceived by them that Shri
r;l
® Ehsan Jafri on account of his political stature and
o status and on account of his being thought to be and
•
••
e
••
l~
accepted to be a leading member of the community,
.~
would be in a position to provide shelter and ,j
protection to such families. It is the case of the
Prosecution that after the incidents took place
outside Gulbarg Society, a mob comprising of
e initially 10 to 15 persons had gathered, and as time
c progressed, the mob swelled in numbers and(}
£':' surrounded the Society from all sides and started8
c,--""'" pelting stones at the residents of the Society. ItV
i"'"
:";;)' is the case of the Prosecution that such stone
G pelting by the mob resulted in a response from the
0:<
,)
residents of Gulbarg Society who admittedly in turn
()
pelted stones at the mob. It is the case of the
(f~
A
A:.j:, '
Prosecution that consequent thereto, the situation"'~~
A'(;:; spiralled out of control and the mob started making ~
F;" f'

-.;1 efforts to break open the gates as also the compound

f!::'"

~j
wall of the Gulbarg Society which resulted in a
o large number of residents of Gulbarg Society rushing
o to the Bunglow of Shri Ehsan Jafri with a view tof::""
take shelter. It is the case of the Prosecut~~n~~pat
@ ..~_ ..-."-,...•.,--,......-...,,,~
@ at about 11 0' clock, senior Police Offi~~:i~~;"j)j)s.T~;e~,.·
/ ' / " f :::/"",,,-~ 1': ";,,
~ the site of Gulbarg Society with a 'fi'e,~:<t'P":~~~F'$'}l,;~::~
" , " ' , ', .. " " , -', I, -r ,
() that due protection was offerred to {th.E= rrremb~~t v6:f_Y;:'-·
" , - .. ) 13
the minority community residing in, ?i1:pIor r:~~~in':l. ?~:fj,j
1- ~ ' _~. -r,., ":J /"" ij
" , ' - '- " ) . :
,~~:"':;:;;::;,:~":.:(~;l~"'~""" .",/ (- !~ r~ .)_~~~,fI.."!"
"~·~~~~;;;;:,~ii#'thr'"
V

6
•
•e
G SCs/l52/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 10
~
~
shelter in Gulbarg Society and the mob was
e
for a short while. However, no sooner
e
Police force go away to other arease
() localities of Ahmedabad which were also
e being impacted and affected by the Bandh call as
e also similar incidents of arson and rioting, that
e the mob gathered in large numbers and some amongst
•
e the present accused according to the Prosecution,
• who were armed with deadly weapons like swords,
knives, trishools as also inflammable material,
started inciting the mob to commit further and more
••A
~ gruesome atrocities on the members of the minority
e:"
V
community who had taken shelter within the residence
C":>
'0-1
of Shri Ehsan Jafri. It is the case of the
()

c} Prosecution that a series of incidents took place,

~)
beginning from about 11: 00 a .m. and went on tillC-)
A
l.:./ about 04;30 p.m., the details of which would be
:.:;,(~0
provided at length herein after, which ultimately
(s~

~J
resulted in the

C'!!
V
fire on the mob
()
grave and serious@
A the mob and also';~
C·)',' :/ persons of
c....c:) Prosecution
If''''',o enraged and
C~
~I
efforts of
®
the
that
(::) of the incident,
C?;. repeated firing of~
A," from their weapons~
deceased Shri Ehsan Jafri to open
with his licensed shotgun, causing
injuries to a number of members of
resulted in the death of one of the
mob. It is the case of the
this resulted in the mob being
incited beyond control and despite the
the Police officers posted at the scene
~ the enraged mob could not
~ the case of the Prosecution
~
•••
Judgment
dispersed
did such
and other
similarly
despite the Police resorting to
teargas shells and"a:I;:s~~:'~-tl>_,"d'~"'''' ..) !.....,I' ~....A' ~.,.. ...")...t
in an effort to cglrl~;,t'o/;:-""{h~'~1S';:
',".'. J ,,;."-,r-,.. .., (1 1
f: > • ',~ ,_, "....... ~,,~, , • '. ,

be contr¢'·r~~iq.2·an:~N:;~t·0'()
; / ~.~ ,~,-! / ';~~:~;.'};j ,......, t~' i;;
that thr~:r-f~,. co~~gK~sin~<i:';Jj
'( ,}, , c;;.}:,:2'~:-~~ '4>(f ~-!/I!'~
'~", ,l ' C'~ , /.J,:.t. ;
;;:~:~~~i'1:;Y
."4i
:~:
0
~~;,'.
~

:.
i
b
I
:~
":
F-~;
;~
<
.:.
'~~~
I
I.:.
r."
l"
f~
V

••••
••e ~
~
.-:"
@
~,;).~
® SCsI152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 11 Judgment
A
~Y
of, as perceived by the witnesses as also the Police
o
(?'?l Officers and as per the complaint, comprised of 5000
o
to 10000 persons who broke open gates of Gulbargo
@;;.:r, Society, demolished the rear wall of Gulbarg~~y
t®~ Society, entered into the Society and caused mayhem
e resulting in a carnage which resulted in turn in the
i?J.~.
death of a large number of innocent persons
~
e
~
including men, women and children and in such
fashion, no less than 69 persons belonging to the ~=!
minority community were done away in a most gruesome
fashion, properties in Gulbarg Society were set on
fire and a number of victims appeared to have been l<
C burnt alive by the mob. It is the case of the
~
U
A Prosecution that the Police force finally responded
'-~~j
~~"" by about 04: 30 p.m. in reaching the site of theU
f:~~
incident i. e. at Gulbarg Society and were finally't:~)
c) I.'b successful in dispersing the mob. It is the case of
j"
~:.;.:)
p;".
the Prosecution that the Police at that stage were
()
equipped with even enough vehicles whereby the
('
survivors of the massacre could be shifted to safetyc:"~.:r
;(:0 and thus the survivors were transported in Police
e
I:~~vehicles firstly to the Shahibaug Police Station ando[C)
v were thereafter taken away to safety and provided
o shelters in a refugee shelter immediately set up and
•
••
•
•
••
o
•
•
•
~
which was known as "Dariakhan Ghummat Shelter". It
is the case of the Prosecution that even when such
!f"'.•..,~....-~,.:.:.~~~~~~~
survivors were being escorted to saf~.~Y~.~·b~:¥:(~1~:tI:~~
Police, the mob regrouped and attemPt7tfl·:t;·9:~·:'.?f·~~;;e:fl'~·(~~~~
the Police from escorting such surviv#.r.~/.t-6:$~itti::,«?·
It is the case of the Prosecution t~~(i' the '~:~~,ice riJji1) . ,:....,~.,. . '. ".l.".,, -I ·1~.¥ ~ '__ I;'
had to yet again resort to firing tea~~.~.~~~,~~~~~::;;';:t>~/~l
:~..,-/.,:~~.~,:.~.;.<:: ~'Y.J(l
+';'.' /,.', r"" ...., 1 ~) ,"Q'~"-l;.~,. : I/!
,'j
; h~. i .. ::-~........ ,,#:-;1'"

•..., ,_ ~
........ - - ..h_·· .--'.'

..... _~o,;rJfIf'

•••e

~,'>
v
~
~
I!I>.~.g
e
~
~
o
e

o

••
••
o
••
G
6
A
V
iF"V
()
e'
U
-.,
'.(-'.::!
'.
()
C",''.:.)
€D
e:~"r:.
~
@
o
£1v
e
@
•
•
•
G
•
•
•
•
•
•

SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09
also live bullets upon
injuries being caused
12

the
and
number of persons of the mob
difficulty, the Police could
safety. It is the case of
mob which
death being
Judgment
resulted in
caused to
and finally with great
escort the survivors to
the Prosecution that
admittedly, a large number of residents of Gulbarg
Society were done to death and their bodies were
finally identified by their surviving near and dear
ones and a large number of persons inc'luding Shri
Ehsan Jafri, were and are till date missing and not
traceable and are, therefore, required to be
presumed dead in light of the statutory provisions
since
years.
such
they have been missing for more than seven
It is the case of the Prosecution that in
circumstances, P. I. Shri K. G. Erda who was in
charge of the Meghaninagar Police Station at that
point of time and thus was primarily responsible in
providing security and protection to members of the
minority community within
incidentally was found to be
of his duties, and was prima
negligent, which resulted in
the locality and who
negligent in discharge
facie found criminally
his being arraigned as
an accused herein, and thus incidentally is accused
No.57 herein, however, at that stage, lodged his
complaint with regard to the incident and an offence
came to be registered at I-C.R.No.67/2002 with the
Meghaninagar Police
Prosecution that the
offence was handed
Station. It is the 9~:~~S~~~~~he
investigation inv:6:<th;~~::P:~:~~~,r' ",., ~li'..j --,
over to said p:{/~~~B-~i:::~:~:.,q:EiC.c()~
/ . ' ~ .' I ."..:.. ~~.~"" "~- •
initially who carried out such
28/02/2002 to 08/03/2002, "'.__ ~~ .' _.,._,
<~;~~t~~irf/)'
I1:-'
I
I',
i':j:::
j;:
I""
t:
~:
-:::;..:

.
•••
••e
o
~ i
~3o/ SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 13 Judgment
f~:
e ~:
l":
investigation was handed over to various officers G:
~ I,':~;'f
I:'
from time to time viz. Shri P.N.Barot, Shri f::
© t:
A S.S.Chudasama, Shri H.P.Agrawat, Shri G.L.Singhal""':;;
I-~
o etc., who all in the course of their investigation,
Fe'
G arrested some of the accused, recorded statements of
P:"','~
~~)
the witnesses and the victims. It is the case of the
",,-,(0-"/,,"
Prosecution that the first chargesheet 'against 23 of
iR1C..~'I
the accused herein came to be filed before.ev:.li::I
Metropolitan Magistrate, Court No.ll on 03/06/2002
which culminated in Criminal Case No. 915/2002. The
proceedings in terms of the opinion of the learned
e Metropolitan Magistrate, involved commission of
e offences which were beyond the jurisdiction of the
~,'"~
Metropolitan Magistrate's Court and were triable
~
only by Sessions Court and therefore, vide ordere
@ dated 08/07/2002, the learned Metropolitan
~l'
8,' Magistrate committed the proceedings to the Court of
£0V Sessions being the City Civil & Sessions Court at
e Ahmedabad, which culminated in the first Session
f.~y
being Sessions Case No.152/2002. It is the case oft9:.,~
V
~ the Prosecution that subsequent thereto, number of
~
accused were arrested from time to time ando
Q chargesheets were filed against such accused on
fC:'!.
V 26/02/2003, 30/08/2002, 18/10/2004, 14/07/2008,
o 08/06/2004, 12/12/2008, 16/05/2009 and 27/08/2009.
f:),
~
It is the case of the Prosecution that the learned
@
Metropolitan Magistrate dealing wi~lk::~~':::::':c':§;~h
",r'."-' . ;..•.., ...... , .,"'~.•~G
chargesheets in Criminal Cases ~,9.'~/~~}~;i2li·~~~,~~·~~fJ
@ 172 012 0 02 , 1902/2 004, 190/2008 , 1142/2#~~~?9~Y,~'~'Ok?q~~
o 150/2009 and 262/2009 respectlvely,:,,-cp.me t;:o: the ... :.~:
••
,J
conclusion that it was only the sessJb,:~J! (loutt:::<khat,. ) ~:~)J
••
• ~~~12f~1~~fii

•• i1:
S
;~
G ;~
®
A. i
~JI SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 14 Judgment Il"_"
9~-::.-.,;
was vested with the jurisdiction to hear and decide
[~:©
the fate of the present proceedings and therefore, ~:
(} "
r~'
() vide committal orders dated 02/05/2003, 20/06/2003, r.
~ 30/05/2009 (05 committal orders) and 28/08/2009, the"-.5
o proceedings were committed to the Court of Sessions
() and culminated in Sessions Cases Nos.167/2003,
o 279/2003, 190/2009, 191/2009, 193/2009, 194/2009,
o 195/2009 and 279/2009 respectively.(i
••
•

6. It is the case of the Prosecution that

• the victims of the present proceedings and the

t';survivors who were aggrieved by the fact of the
A
~
State machinery as also the investigating agency not
I;.?
~
A making due and satisfactory efforts to bring the

U

If'," real perpetrators to book, made number of~)
applications through Advocates, NGOs and concernedo
o members of the society, which resulted in ultimately "
,
I;··
(.:,f
, the victims preferring a Special Writ Petition
o (Criminal) No.109/2003 before the Hon'ble Supreme
()
Court which covered eight separate incidents of
C,:~~v
riots/massacres, all of which took place in Gujarat€3~
@ State on 28/02/2002 and which resulted in the::.~
G Hon'ble Supreme Court initially staying the further
G proceedings in Sessions Cases arising out of all
A,
V such incidents. As has been stated herein before,
£'r-.
~
the Hon'ble Supreme Court also appointed the SIT to
o further investigate into the proceedings with regard&.
~
o
••
to the role of senior Police O~.~:t~~~3~,
politicians in the carnage. It is th~<·:q~s·~~·:..Rt:~-.,'blt£'i~
Prosecution that in the instant prd6~:~;d·i:h~'~:.·::~1'~:O~'·:·)';'
{i .!~'.: ;" :.'.' ... '~::... ~
•
••
•
CD there was further investigation by~: th~ "~i. SIT'W;hich ." :~'. i
t~ -, "..'' '~'~I:''/l
. :i
, ,
-'I. -'/
-.~>.f
-' ......

....m.~
'.
~~
~~:'
~~
~~
:$i
~'
E~:
~.:
/
SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194.195,279/09 15 Judgment
i::
.,. resulted in a large number of arrests of accused
Y ~ taking place nearly six years after the incident l::
I>
i.e. in the year 2008-2009 and it is the case of the l~~
Prosecution that subsequently the Hon' ble Supreme
::
Court ordered the vacation of the stay on
proceedings and ordered the setting up of specially
designated Courts to take the present proceedings to
'.~
their logical conclusion. It is the case of the
Prosecution that initially Additional Sessions
Judge, Court No.13, City Civil & Sessions Court,
Ahmedabad i.e. Shri B.O.Joshi was appointed as the
specially designated Court to try the present
offence relating to Gulbarg Society massacre (it is
::::~~
made clear that the present incident would herein
after be referred to as either 'the Gulbarg Society
case' or 'the present incident' as and where the
context requires). It is the case of the Prosecution
that the designated Court proceeded to frame charges
.~
against 64 of the accused on 11/08/2009. The same
:~
designated Court in furtherance of orders passed
~,*. under Sec.319 of the Cr.P.C., whereby accused Nos.65
~~ and 66 were arraigned, proceeded to frame charge
~ against accused No.65 on 25/01/2010 and against
accused No. 66 on 10/02/2010. It is required to be
:.:*~
noted that the said designated Court Shri B.O.Joshi
ffi
thereafter proceeded to record the evidence of a
~~,~

':~~, large number of witnesses in the trial, but however,

was not in a position to complete the ... ~ . ''''''..
tr'i<:ff7?~i11":~<r"/"'" ", ! t! i~"
the said Presiding Officer was transM~L~,e,d"'::·'a:0i±b,~-;·"·.
the pendency of the proceedings.
position that Additional Sessions
/'/ .~., - .. 1·~· _ ......1.::"" .., .", ~ ..
'I' .... ; " ~. 1. ", l, .," ..... """'l I,. f
It jf.'s( ~;a!n.,.::>admi't,t6"d~() II;J ,: j r>,:'" >', ,,:::.(,~(..:., :~~~" 'j '-~. ~i
JU1t~~~:~ ~.ity'~~::C~.Vil r~)1
"
:.,.~'~F~~)i~~J >
''"''-':::'''---'---~.''-----~.,.~_:~
~___...,....""''''... ==~~.!!'tk~.:;:.~~;.:·;;;.r;;_-~==.>.I~l!:==>.I.

•••e
~ SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 16 Judgment
o j::
& Sessions Court No.8 Shri B.J.Dhandha came to be@ I:'
r.:
appointed as the specially designated Court to r:~,CJ
e conduct and conclude the present proceedings and
~:
@) amended charge was framed by the said Presiding
o Officer Shri B.J.Dhandha on 22/03/2011. It is
@
required to be noted that the initial charge framed
(}
was framed at Exh.109, additional charge came to be
•
••
c
framed vide Exhs.860, 934 and 1553 respectively.
7. All the charges referred to above, were
e individually read over and explained to each of the
G accused and it is required to be noted that the
o accused pleaded not guilty to the charges framed and
@;
claimed to be tried. Even in the course of recording~y
~~:'
V
of the further statements of the accused as
@ prescribed under Sec.313 of the Cr.P.C., the accused
A
~ maintained their innocence and claimed that they
e were falsely implicated in the present offence and
@
sought for a clean acquittal. It is required to be
©
A noted that consequent thereto, the then specially
V
designated Court No.8 Shri B.J.Dhandha proceeded tofJ
£.?,
hear the arguments in the present proceedings inV
eA
their entirety but was unable to deliver the
e judgment since he attained superannuation. The
o proceedings thereafter were placed for the
()
consideration of the Principal Sessions Judge Shri
o
K.K.Bhatt, but no progress could be achieved since_~r>f""~-:""''''"""~
G

•
the proceedings were stayed by the H~.J3:..~b'i~·~.·::B~;~~

," • .: • ~. "'->' ..._;~ {I "'....
Court. The proceedings were therea.t~~'~:'fJ~~~:::~.'.:·~,C(.r;'~
• the consideration of the present prtfD.?ip,al;:q'l1'~ge~:~~
the City Civil & Sessions Court, A~m~~)a9ad:±.F:~· ~~':~H.,' .,'~' )"iif
>', ' - ,. " . j 1/•
•
•
•
•
~~~'~..';'~:":~':.:.'~i.(::-~.',_~~:;J:S)~/..'< ,.,: .... 1-- '1,:; Y" ..>,;1j-..
':~~;.~::J~:__,:~}:~/......-....-~~

••
••••••••••
••
I
.,
••
@
e SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 17
~
undersigned, and the Hon'ble
e
G
•e
directed the present proceedings
disposed of within the time frame
e• 8 . It is in the background of such facts
and circumstances that the following points have
arisen for determination by this Court:
•• I~
1) Does the Prosecution· prove beyond
~
o reasonable doubt that the accused, anyone or
o more of them or all of them, had entered into a
Q
~
pre-planned conspiracy to form an unlawful
r·,
6 assembly and thereafter perpetrate the carnage
e
at Gulbarg Society on 28/02/2002 which resulted(3
in the deaths of 69 persons and resulted ino
Ci1 attempts to murder, cause grave and serious l:;
~'W' injuries to other residents of Gulbarg Society
o and also cause damage and destruction of
~~,
w
vehicles and
()
thereby, the
e
them, haveG
e under Sec.120B, 143, 147, 148, 149, 153 (a) (1) (,
(;} 153 (a) (b), 153 (a) (1) (b), 186, 188, 295, 302,
e 307, 323, 324, 332, 337, 395, 396, 397, 398, 427,
435, 436, 447, 449, 452 of the Indian Penal
Code?
_..~;.:~~··~~:·;~:·:·:;,::;::~:~·::s~·~~
2) Does the Prosecution pr9'1~ .~§jY9.ri~~>~,.
t</ ~'::",,,,>'•.,""', .....~.:. ~ (~i ""',,'
reasonable doubt that in furthel:l;;:~c.,~·/":.:,tb~,'·tg,e~,,~,0~
property at Gulbarg Society and
accused or anyone or more of
committed an offence punishable K~
r
carnage and killing of persons,
anyone or more of them, had
Judgment
Supreme Court has I"
!.
to be concluded and
,
to:.
.
stipulated. ~~~
tn'~)/";~~~us~.~·Hb~~;')l~"2yt" . ' , ) ,~,~~ 'fl
b~rA"i:l 'th:":B.<:"ad~.;:..i:!j}
~~,>;;::~··i:~~:-;/.;.J
;" .. , t~.· Ii' ." r '--" y..~
~::::;.;~~~<~~,r

-
•••••••
~~~
•e ~~.:.,1
:.:;
~ :::
®
f.'),
~-:..,;1 SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,27,9/09 18 Judgment
o f~~
CJ
~'-~bodies of the victims in such a fashion so as
to destroy any evidence that could be used
®

~ against them. and had thereby committed an
i..

~)'
R:~ offence punishable under Sec.120B read togethert:.-~~5
"
"0';(.
"" with Sec.201 of the Indian Penal Code?
10'.,
~':~
r ..~.."
3) Does the Prosecution prove beyondIf~
'-:7
reasonable doubt that the accused Nos.2, 46 and
€t ~~,

()

fill)

@ ::~:;::ai~~~~~~~:~~~~ffn:~:;::;:~a::ap::::::~
~
,',I-'
,(':
~.) r~'~
e
"C:;
r~.
'-.)'
(C':"
.. .~
() ,.,.
i,'
(} f..~
::E:~~~ii3J4~J~~:i~;,6i:~~:)~~0~i~it::n:::~()
o
('.)
~
e
::asonabi;':'~:6;~n~elif~~!~~:e~::cu:er:v:o .:~YO:~~ f.,:
~~
t·e being a part 0 the conspiracy and in
()
furtherance thereof, was criminally negligent
~
~
in preventing the co-accused from perpetrating
eJ
the offence and had further conducted the
•G investigation in such manner as would result in
destruction of material evidence a9~~~~~'.
/:< .J / .../'~"....~'" (f';), '-<'".
, h b l .. ·· '. ',~~ d '-.,~. ,.~
thereby committed offence pun 1 s a ie; .. u !'t,eL;f :" ,. (Y'-{;.
i·' ,·.......'·r,J_ (·s··.., ''-' '. '.I . I ""';."J"'-'-"., ,,'

Secs.201, 217, 218 of the. Indian pena1/f;~tl~·?··;>.1;'·":'~~·C::~;
.n" ) ,., . ( -0 i~:' 0 '" ... . " ,'" "A, (" .J': Z.:·.f! ";;. '.•~. ,.,;"".., .:. } "~f!j
5) Does the Prosecution PrOVF! ' '1 beyorrd;';~"! ! ":'A'', "r 'C. ~ .', [ ' /1~. I, ~.Jir,f ~ • _~', -,", ) ,I~ 'i
<.:.>://~:;.-",.~::.:::~,::':.:'~~~~()~/.
... ;, .,> !! ·r ~." r' 12..".-' I /J
•
"'0.>'_ (J, .~,. ) , ..... v -;,
~'~:~·~';.~~k~~·
•

;,;~
~
~
;:; j~]
(
'~ :.<.
~ SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 19 Judgment
f:'
'~
reasonable doubt that the accused or anyone or ~':.
~ ,."
'$:
<~
more of them, on account of they being armed li~
i:·.:
with lethal ,weapons, had committed offence
I;~
~ punishable under Sec.135 (1) of the Bombay
?i~'
Police Act?
6) Does the Prosecution prove beyond
reasonable doubt that the accused or anyone or...:.;.:.:-.;.:.:.:..;...,-:.;...;.... ~~
fE
more of tbett(';~ ::cfll?o.f .. theI11 had committed any ~~.):::-:. "-::":"
ft:
,.'
I::'"
":::""
'~
7) udgrlt;ent?
','
:.
points for9.
'~ determination as,Jo~iQws .,.
-:;:~ >. :'?::::)::-";;::; .<::: .t" .::;
'~
["_:
%I' ::';
)) }~f,;,;;,~;~?e .~ff~.ilhEi~L.
;".
~~~
',.:'
2) Partly in tl),e affirm§.tive.
f~
):~
~:/~r~ir~j~t!;:~~Y~~t i ve .
',..0; ~'.
:';:',
5)partTyiht:h~ affirmative.
~;
.i5.
6) In the negative.
"~;;
7) As per final order and judgment.
" ~.~)
10. Before ascribing my reasons for arriving
at the findings stated above on the pointsr~~~~~~'~
. . .#,.::.:,.--~<" C.. /-; '::':~"''''
determination framed, it 1S requ1red to b.~;~nQ,t:gd,:oA<.:,·:·::,..;'~~
,fl' . ,,' t .........,.. ...,>..J ."-'

that this has been a trial of almost unpre'ceden.t'e'd ):":- ...~ ~~~'~''! ' " '. -.,- ," , '" !..)'
proport ions, the oral evidence as [:~'~.l'i·:~l' ~~; ,,~' ~>~" (=1
~, • I
documentary evidence required to be cons~,d$r,~dl: f6~f:_-':~~"; !, ;~ :::~ij
<;·:>~220.:;j];/

'
*;.
",'
:~ SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 20 Judgment
-h'
deciding the fate of the present accused is also on
*' an unprecedented scale and since the trial of the,~
>'~~ present proceedings
*2 Presiding Officer,
the trial could be
.~
position of being
,'.
exceptional efforts
learned Advocates
was not conducted by the present
it is required to be noted that
concluded and judgment was in a
dictated only on account of the
of the learned Special P.P., the
for the defence as also the
cooperation of/ t::'il~' ¥ea:rhe¢> Advocate appearing on
~~;
,~:-~
:::::::::.....~~f:~;~~~~~~~~~t~c;~~~~i:~::::~ ::
.~~,
~
:~p~Ui::sd·~~::;~~~:~i~&~~; :iil;~t~~;:: h:P::~:~
~.
>~
~::::::l::tc~~:1::~!il:::e Jt~~:1;s1~re·p~:ri:::

,.
~
fi·
tl
:::::::~:f:~:~~tJ~!:~~;~~~~~;~;:~~~:~: :oon:::
~
Il
~;
t'
t~-~~
~: before the present court. It is also required to be
.~.,
noted that in light of the voluminous evidence
>,%"
required to be appreciated and referred to, the
present Court with agreement of all the parties
concerned, has directly dictated in the coqr.-t~·::?i~'~:7~~::;",,>
/<> ':. ~) ~..). ~~~: ',;;:; ,(:" ~"'1~
submissions made and arguments '"canvassed ~~:"',:;~:~:~:~«(9.I.·:,·:,:',~~~~~?~~~.
the parties, the parties have also/·./,:Rt9.~Tiq~o.:.;:.·<.....;":.;...~If ..--" ,f" ~'._-_., ; .., '/". 'rd;.J t,
compilations, tabulations and materiaJ!>:~s.. a~rkd~'>' .'J~) ':':: iJI.
~:. '.~~) .;':~ (..-:':: ~-' :.~ ~Ll, ~ •••,t.;:
judicial precedents considered relevay{~ >.c'-by ;;:fii~:~ + / ::<N
~;:~i;j:~:~;'{~;;;;';/....;<:~_~:> tj .'-', '-:::;.)'
......._.,..~~~

••
••••
•••
.,
f)
~"".'tj! SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 21 Judgment
:.

consideration of the Court and therefore, it ist9
(:) required to be noted that there are no formal
{} handwritten notes of submissions but only dictated
o portions of the submissions which are accepted by
()
all the parties to have been dictated in the open£.:')
t::~;i ["
Court and in the pres~!?:g~ of all parties concerned.
f:'
•
o
11. W9~:~d~:~:~~:~$:§~j:ya.t juncture
~~
thi s
@,
<.c:
.,. respective..),
@.
proceedings,
o
to stat~ t h&t ·:··.·:·::·.i:.ri··:··:•••::.::;g:;:•••••~.~.~.8;5.t ·.···:·....t·d·.::•••••:.:~•.FO~·~:..
agains tfiea,CcW~~d;:::t:h~·pF8$·:~¢ut:i,ohpp-~
tel
o
G
~
;)'
~

~

~ than
~
()
@
G
o
@
c
e
G
~
•G
e•
••
parties contesting the present
all of which has been placed for the
the charges
~.:
re1 i e d upon
33 8with~~~e~::'~.:~i:f0.r:::;:7:8~:::·f~i16w:Ln:~details :
~~.1Statqf'1 IPanch l
Exh.
No.
2591
~:il~;9::.~itn~::::
An~p·rti~:h,!~a~9~£h::shkhwarii
2 IPolice 263
-
Nathtisinh:Naharsfnh Chauhan
3 IPolice 266
-
Babuji Chhaguji Dabhi
4 IPolice 269
-
Rajendrasinh Kallusinh Rajput
5 IPolice 270
-
Indrasinh Himmatsinh Gohil
6 IPolice 271
-
Lalitkumar Ramanbhai Patni
7 IPolice 273Arvindsinh Shankersinh Vaghela
...8 Doctor
9 Panch
10 Panch
11 IPolice
Harshadkumar Kantilal Rathod ,,:~:;r.:z-1if::~~·~(.-' ." :. f ";. .-, ..,. . '
Jagdish Vanaj i Mali /:?::.>
' )• • • /.~'~'•• ~ ,.' ~I~ :: ~ ~•• ''',.:~ ~,,,,,'
Popatbhal Shantlbhal Thakorr:,.. / :~.;~!2,g~t,:,:
. , - .';".. ' ....
Rameshbhai Nagj ibhai Pandoti ,: J 31'it/:·
I
I.'
c:
F:
"':"'1,
''l~l:/f~:!_::'': ~~'
~~.'j .......;..:.;~>.
"')'-{'''Cj''..,., ' ,
~ C. ~ n,
..... ." .: __.. ,..<.;; , Hi~: ,. 6 ;,' .r n. .f, ~. 1
'lll~ "..... ' .,~. ./ '._.:...1 ; /
: . 'c, .,', - , . . / . ' , 1/
'<i~~iiJ;J'
i

••
••••
•••
~
~:~
~~~
~j
CD ~
{j
() SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 22 Judgment i:
@
o

(0
e
P:"'-.- ~
r~·-l->
C"",
'-:)
0:.;j
,•
@
o

o

C
A
~
e
(}
G
FA
~
e
G
e

o
A.
~
~
e
G
e

.,
G
•
•
•

PW
NO.
IStatus Name of Witness Exh.
No.
12 IPolice Sajjansinh Jorubha Jhala 315
13 IPolice Dhanesinh Becharsinh Kumpawat 316
14 Panch IDipakbhai Somnath Panchal 1318
15 Panch IMohanji Piraji Vanzara 1319
16 Panch IIshwerlal Devilal Solanki 1327
17 Panch IVelaji Mafaji Thakor 1329
18 Panch IRamanbh§i ::i3Eikhabh,ai Prajapati 1330.....:::::::• .-.:.:::;::>.'.
19 panchls:6p~~U1:j'J; Vgg~~Kj*T,pakor 1332
20 Pol i ce .:.' ITDctik$.inh .M?hsinh.'Sqlank i 1334
21 Polj:te .IM9tieqg.I·:.::P::~hY~I§B~V9:gheTa 1335
22 PoliCe JShci.$lerlgpa:~ih1+.I'f~f~H§itlp·.·.Jadej a 1336
23 panch/ IT%:~io:c:hery.~:~p:B·(paYpl~~nh S.aluj:? 1340
24 parlch 1r1~he~hkumg'~'" :'E
Mgk,wa.na::: .
ameshcha~draI341
25 Panch IDh~rnleSl}~.tim~r.:Bhikh)aphai Bharwad 1343
26 Pandb 'lR~mi~l:a1 ::t~'dhi~bhai'! 9Smera. ..•.•.. / 1345
27
28 Y
Panch
Polic;e ip ~a.d~ps·inh Sh~t~·I1§ih.J:1Rathc5d 1349
rSerldhabhai Lalabhai Dhola:wala 1347.. .".:..: _ :. ,,~-'" . ..:.:.;..: :.:.'..-:.--: ::.. .
29 Police Db.c3.nsP1.3~¥Bha.~k:;+ l£%dBhsl:gwa t 1351
30 Police bh9ifn~bh:~J-:·.RajhtJibh~.iBOdat 1352
31 Panch Mahe~hbhaiRatnabhai Patel 1354
32 Panch Premaram Umedji Vanjara 1356
33 Panch 358Indrapalsinh Nawabsinh Rathod
34 Doctor 359Upendrabhai M. Jadhav
35 Doctor 363Jayendra R. Modi
36 Panch 380Prabhatbhai Sankabhai Desai
37
38
39
40
Police
Police
Police
Police
Kavaji Rupaji Asari
Dolatsinh Padamsinh Rathod
Chandubhai Vashrambhai Rami
Pasabhai Galabhai Solanki
t·"I:.:
I.,
I
ke
t":
E:
l:.~
~
.?
;.~:
:.~~~
:':
!::~
I.~.
1-,
~: . r' ~
!,~- ~ ).: <-... ~~-.;>-

•• Io
o
@ SCs /152/02, 167 & 279./03,
~
'-f'i"
'tj1
~~
@
fj
o

o

At,.;J
•••
e
•

••
•
e

e

@
A.,
*'
A
V
G
€p
V
A
Y
o
@
A
~
IF2c.
V
e

e

•
•
••
G
•••
•
•
~

l~
:~
~:
:~
(~~
PW
NO.
IStatus IName of Witness Exh.
No.
41 IPolice IRameshbhai Somabhai Solanki 391
42 IPanch IKamleshbhai Ambalal Thakker 393
43 IPanch IKantibhai Shankerbhai Patni 395
44 IPanch IRamprakash Gulabsinh Bhadoria 397
45 IPolice IRajeshbhai Kuberbhai Parmar 399
46 IPolice IMavjibhai Hakshibhai Bodar 400
47 IPo1 i ce IRanghh6dbhai<Ratnji,phai Malavia........ .<..-:.;..•. ,;",:->.«.; .
401
48 IPoli ce .ld~.9*~~'*n~',lMm+s±~h/Bbi3.ti 402
49 IDoctor tpc,,tt1t.bhai <'R,.Shah<' 403
50 IDoctor; .1 BP·a;il},i$.i~'·:$h'~hl:,...········ 408
51 IPanch>'1<:;it]l'§hbgi3:iJay.<3.rtt±.lCil '. Pate1 411
52 IP ?n~h l ~~~'r9t'~,~,,if@:r~~,ia1'.,.Tli$,k0 r. 413
53 IParich n~~9r~t s,$'~:~'~':~"~l p:ra3~pati·••••·. 414
54 IPanch IM~Aeddrasin.h'Babu.rg;mRathod. 416
55 IPol:Lc§ .••. la~~U~ha+:,~%t~·~phd,i,m,b.nam2t· 418
5 6 IDoctori iG§.;B'arl j a If'''t>::,::F'uka.n 419
57 IDoctOr IM~.t e s:p.B:~iE;q,:t e:.Ji:./:: 422
58 IDoctbr 7lRak.·~sh S . Bhavsar..,.,. . :..:.. 425
60
5 9
IPanch
IDoctor . ·
IGhan,§h~aitt Bh~Z;~riif.er· Tiwari
B$;t;~l '......IGdV&1A%9'f1~i<P
431
427
61 IPolice Kanjibh~i<Verjibhai Damor 433
62 IDoctor Jayeshkumar M.Joshi 434
63 IDoctor Kalpesh H.parikh 448
64 IDoctor Pravinbhai L. Desai 451
65 IPanch Santosh Ramachal Pathak 454
66 IPanch Hitendrasinh Manubha Jadeja 455
67
68
69
70 Doctor
Panch
Panch
Doctor
,/j:::-~~I§:';.~~>:/. '--' 459, ...
i; ",': J .'.. ' '·C'.,
j , ' , , '
,r '.,.;... ., ~4 6 4';'->-' ..,. 'C'y
; .... ) ,.:",~~;,:
i: ,'. '. 49}.:,;;,
Sanjaybhai Kantibhai Patni
Ramtirath Sahdevsinh Patel
Madansinh D. Jhala
Jayesh B. Rupal
190,191,193,194,195,279/09 23 Judgment
I' ,
~:.
t'··
t~
:::;
~
(:
I~"
!~
i'~
1;-:
~<
~~:<:
'..J
'-. (1 L~
I,. ~
I I 0, , ..... /
',. V=1
"r' j I
::~~;l~~_i;:~~~)
i

•••
••
I
~."u:'
~U SCS/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 24 Judgment
o -
Exh.PW IStatus IName of Witnessc NO. No.
-e 71 IPanch IDigpal hariharprasad Dubey 469
o -
72 IPanch IRambhai Ukabhai Patel 470e -
~ 73 IPanch ISuresh Lalchand Dhobi 471
o
~
-
47274 IPanch IPavankumar Hiralal Samodia
-au 47375 IPolice IPuransinh Ramsinh Tomar
C
•
-
47976 IPanch IKishanbhai Jorjibhai Purohit
-
•
48177 IPanch IDingshbfiaIM8hanDQai Vora
-
48678 IPanchIC~.~wp~~1~~.> m911~pl~l .• baf j i
-
79 1Panch...,..'lp~h"~~hJa¥§nt'ilai-Od""'" 487
•

-

48980 1PoliCe ILc3.X~an~Th·§j$ ig§th@i?hp.lsolankl
•

-

49081 1Pol iGe::J~a9~bh~·~...ftE{:tjj"ph&i)?and()r
:: .:;: :::::::.' . -
82 491P()liG~ M~buQ.h"a:(:::::.1S~~:~:~Dbhai'be~ai ..'G
~~ 83 ParlGh ~~pp~nd~~::::~·~n·£i1 a;lB~te i ~4
-tf?l.:l''l;;&
496Panch84 Himc3.rl,shu'<ir~y~nt i riafVYas
-(]
49785 Partch D¥¥Y~sh:.:E~~~i,i·i:p.l ;'$~.~~A -V
Panch .....cgJ~!BUs··inh'::K:~j~ti~·inh· dhg1.1han· 49886
@ -
87 500Panch <I Ch~mallphp+:pa;wj.£:9haipatniIf.--:".
(J -
50188 Panch 1Papkajpl1ai Mani.9hbhai Khatrio -
89 502PoliceTJ G~l1Pa.:ti8:P-ph:J:}hi51,Vit;~,n~±nh SOlankio -A
90 Police Hernuphdi "s6rAc3.Eh~iparmar~ 503
-(] 91 IPolice GautambhaI'.Amrutlal Shrimali 504
-o 92 IPolice Baldevbhai Jivabhai Chavda 505
-o 51193 IDoctor Dharitri B. Jadhav
-o 518Hemant D. Patel94 IDoctor
G
Rameshbhai Jayanti1al Doshi 152295 IPanch
G
~
~
~:'
I..
I::
'''.
f;;
1::
1:::
~ .:
r:·
k
ii!
i"'
r
~:
f~~~
-:;
~
Narendra sinh Ra j bahadurs i n9~5ff~'::::7 ·:;:~~c96 IPanch
•
•
•
•
o
•
•
•
•
...... ", .,.... '.. "....",,' -;'.
Chauhan //., . '.) /" '«",,"'" .. ;.', .,~
Jivanbhai Tribhovandas SOlankf{',>'~"{~'5;" r:<iC~.,:;·,(~~>97 Panch
Omkarbhai Shafuaj i Diya !r':;~:'/ '526<:> ':,,""'r. ';:'-:~'98 Panch
Ghanshyambhai Shankerlal Ran~"f0 -528(':,:': .? i''-~,)99 Panch
'~~~'~io~',.0:J!iY;

--
7
:2;'
.~
.'
'.•:.'
;
SCs/l52/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 25 Judgment
"
PW IStatus Name of Witness Exh. t~
NO.
.~ -
100
101
102
;~ 103
'i 104
-
Panch
Panch
Panch
Panch
Panch
105 Panch
106 Victim
107 Victim
108 1Doct op" IPJ1~riq;~kafjt;l?hai;t;~>Ta.r1,na·· 154 9:>:;;,~
10 9 1Doct-orlDJ;1a~mxll::::,':li:~:::,,;s:,$:iilj~Ya. 1554
110 1Doc;torl:ki§f'§TIi:S';J,:;;ff: ..sp igij15J I570
111lpanch. ';rTS[:'~'~~;jCi~,,+,,;,:.i~8Y,:~;~db:h~:~:Parmar 1575
112 1pl3.ricb.
:tS~
I¥i~~uti~ha~,;:;::"tij~~':~bhaa'Qiiresh~ 1577
1131 Panch IS1:lWes.1h pJBa~6hand ~~ypure . 1579
114 1Pc::1I1¢h . IK~~ra~h't'i;':::,§B,fKpab:pq~ Thak,qr' 158 0
115IPolicelsm$;i.dharJh;:;··Niii£~yakN@jir,..' 1582,'
116Ivicti-m,/ JS~eed~haJfl;:::::;l¥::pm~d~1+anP~than' 584
117;~
..~ 118
119
.~
'~
.~
$;~,
No .
Munawarali Mohammadismail Shaikh 1529
Narendra Becharbhai Kahar
Jignesh Rajubhai Shah
Salimuddin Mohammadmiya Saiyed
Aliyarkhan Afsarkhan Pathan
~~
531
1534
1536
1538
Halubhai Ramjibhai Patni 1539
Imt*yazkh,?'p $}:3.eedkhan Pathan 1542
,Rbppa;~ T;&h~'~p;~r$;mi.~hModi 154 8
':1 ., .... .'
AY).lbkb,PI1 Habibkhan J?Cl,thc:mVicthn ..... 588
Doctor .' 1G~l£~hW .v~.NF¥ Cif:'::. 593
Nc3.rendi~:gJ:nv~rit'~9i ·JoshiDoctor 595
120 Doctor
121 Doctor
122 Doctor
123 Doctor
Ku1 deep···J:·3o~hi
Rajesh D.Patel
Vikram K. Pardhi
Jayantbhai s. Kanoria
597
599
610
612
124 1Witness having Hafizrehman Islamuddin Ansari 629sufferred
damage ~~:~-::_ '''''::~'''''''~l';t
1251Witness having Zahirahmed Yousufbhai Ansari 0:. LCu"::·~::'~2.'.,sufferred , ,j" '". J.... , ,,,
12 6 1-;:-;-~~"':;-;e-d-da-h:-:g-i;-g+R-a-s-i-d-b-a-k-S-h--G-u-l-a-b-k-h-a-n--S-h-a-l-'-k-h---""";;'~+"V:;:"_':,o:..,~;;;."_'''... .•,,,''-1';;:;:<;~:.'~,.~:;j.,~':> r·'J":",'.,!,,
'--;;-~< ~,f~' ~~' '. [~
127 I:~~~:::ed d::::;gIAbdulbhai Gulfarozkhan Pathan (J' ~ ~: .. d. I:'
,j'j. ;. ". ;I
1281Victim Mohammadrafiq Abubakar Pathan . .. I"~ i(
," ,', ,. r '-,j :.f
~~;;i~~i~~2;~~Z(:://''''' 'C....·• ,C~'); .... ,
~~;'~~~~~~;;~~:F~

--
••••••
•e
@
e

C~
'(:)/
0;,
<,<",;;1
A
~;I
(9
A~;:"'
~,'l:.:.:;
(,5:."
,z)
~'lI;,c.j
©
@
o

~
~

~~

@
F,-,:-.~:;)
(1':';
c;;;
n~
x;..."
(J
()
(':-'J"
t:-".
'C';;')
C::.:')>,
~
E;,)
"J
1:'
W
()
e
A.
;¥
A
~
•
A
o
~
•
•

•
•

SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 26 Judgment
t-"
~::Name of Witness Exh.PW IStatus
NO. No. ~~
~'.
1291Victim Firozmohammad Gulzarmohammadl635
~::.
~:Pathan
Witness havinglKabirkhan Nasirkhan Pathan130 639sufferred
damage
-
Panch 640131 Jayeshbhai Vasantlal Shah
-
Panch132 Amarsinh Sundersinh Bhadoria
-
641
Panch Abdulaziz Abdul Khalid Shaikh 643133
-Witness having
645134 zu ltikar-M:~h.~mrnadkhan Pathansufferred
damage
-
646135 :~~~:;;edhavi~gs h$&~±f kh·~h.Na.si t"&h~nPat han
damage
136
damage!

Wi the$X:: ::h:~~i~:;

suffer-red.. .137
A$f~mkh~!:!_;::~:~!~::~.~kbaq••.•,.satha.ndamage
13 8 I:~~~:::~dhavi~1 Atttin ~ha n/:·~'¢f:~§'r kh;~flPat h.aIi
damage
13 9 I~~~~~i;e}avingI ~!kh{~:::~:0~~~rkh,rdEat hah
~648
~
I
-
649
-
650
~:.
~
, t',
140 IWit~esSh~~ Ahdultf:aq······· ···p<a.tha.n..ijSh§mJulh~'q::::" 651sufferred .
damage .:;-" ....-.:.:.:.;.•.:;.. :,::;:; .••..;-.;...<:..::.-;.:-;:.
-
141 IWitness h.aVi';$:1A.khil ahm~ci 'AJ"'g'~~huss a iIi Ans a r i 652sufferred. .. ..... ..... .
damage.. .... ."_ . .
-
654142 Victim ""lA~'h!t:~f:t,,$)ikq:n.d~:6J3tl&±Sandhi
-143 Victim Altafki1a·ri Gtil~bkhaIi'Pathan 655 ~;.
.~
144 Doctor
145
146
Panch
Panch
I
664Himmatbhai F. Patel
-
670Salimkhan Achhankhan Pathan
-
672Jeparam Devaji Mali
-
-
674147 Panch Mayurkumar Govindbhai parmar
Witness having
677148 Fakirmohammad Ismailbhai Pathansufferred
damage ...,..,,::::::.::~~...
1491Witness having Asif Jehangirbhai Sandhi "ff,q-g",... P(i~~~sufferred /' t....?. /~ ,...~-. '". ...•,.''''''.........~~.,-.. .J' ,".'.

damage /. " '.. . " i , '~f
150lWitness having Bhurabhai Bandealibhai Shaikh /./;1 ~i~.~.:· '.·..'.':...".rs-~J~'C>..'r.:.,
sufferred J. '.' .' ':' / •• " ,., •..•, '$ J 0')f.
1511::::::s having Nadirkhan Bashirkhan Pathan lr(} "~8;0 (./:t:~( '~~" s=:l !.~sufferred t .IL:) ,....,"I.' I't· . , . .. / ··-V/· damage '. ,.'. - '. ' ',,- 1'
<;'»' ..''t,:,.i' :..~~~t rJf.i~}~
" . , _ , (~'J'"'-<"" /: .-::: ....~::'>.........,........ , !'} V ~~

-,," . :'~ i) (~, r'oh
'<~~~.~~~.~:~~~~

.
••
---
••••••
~.;"
....
[~
e :~:
:~
@
~OJ SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 27 Judgment
@
PW
Victim
Status IName of Witness{3
NO.
~."<l~3
152~
~,;
153 WitnessR!'. sufferred~:;~/
damage
.If-~~.>
154 1Witnesssufferred
damageo
Yousufbhai Badarbhai Pathan
having Azizkhan Yasinkhan Pathan
havinglHamidkhan Nasirkhan Pathan 683
Exh.
No.
i-:
~:
681
c:~
682 l:
o
E9
•••
•
••
Witness havingIHaroon Shakurbhai Ghanchisufferred
damage
~~E~::edhaVing.l~b~~T]d~~~f:::~~0q=~haI1 Sha i kh
156
15 9 IViqtim< .><1 Gu lti~:ni§.:r·§.uierriatii5ha i SaDdh i .
157
1551Witness havinglMohammadbhai Kheratibhai Kazisufferred
damage
158 I~~!~~:::~~avi1~dct§:Qh:=ii:; Gahib~§.i Mamin 687
690
685
684
686
~."y
160 1~~!~:if~d::~~~n~1A~d~~:p.h~:t.:.: Z~;T§rbPci±Mansuri 691
e
n~.,.
G
e
~..'
~
16 3 I:~i~:::eslh~~nri~1 A~:~:6J,ddirt::M&i·,~J'ldkharrPathan
damage' ...
....
F:i,~bz. Sat~.:l:r;bhaiShaikhWitne·s.s.....having
suffer:riici' .
dat11ag"
162
1611:Ji~::;ed~avingl~j a~kha'~!':'~'~~plka:daf Pathan
damage
I694
692
693
o 164 IPanc.l1.>~Jit~nti':2g::dfi%iri2hIBhai Makwana' I 6 95
tf.'."
'*'()
(]I 1661Victim ISh~rifk'h~h'::$::i;kahd~rkhan Pathan
165 I~~!~~:;edl;~VingIl~b2~~:~;: ..::A9.hai Shai kh
1697
I 696
o
()
o
@
167 IWitness haVingIMoha~adJ'anif';stdiqbhai Sandhisufferred
damage
Ramzanbhai Inayatrasul Silawat
Kishorkumar Sanjabhai Baleria
Witness having
sufferred
damage
169
1681Police
1698
700
701
o Police170
c
••
Witness having171 sufferred
damage
172 1Witness having
•
sufferred damage
173 Panch
174 Panch
itness havingr
175 sufferred damage
702
Ismailbhai Ibrahimbhai Pathan~.,,,,
~-:;~~~"T""-r-;::'::""~~...
Govaji Kanjibhai Chavda
ftl . 1<&0." ·r .... ~ ..
Samsuddin Ibrahimbhai Shaik1;.f<'~:?>:~'O~r'~~"~;:::}:;;:'
Jagdishbhai Sakharam Habale~<;>.!.<~~;>'7O:5~:":' -:(;~
~; ,.~~.: I '"
Amin Usmangani Shaikh fJ ·'::,
I ',' .. ' ' ' . I...
Mohammadumer Abdulhamld Pa~.·P0P.
'. ....!..
• ' . "'~'
~',:;~.: ".1 ~ (~.. .',:. )
706:: ,,! c::~ Ii
'." (--...I~.~. : I .-.,t) !It
7,94::' ~" f -'if!
, - ( " II- . ",,"" ":''19- ,. J!
«C~L~;~~//

••
•••••
•••••
"o

f)
c

•o
e
•
e
•o

o
e

()
@
()
A
~
()
o

(")
(}
~
t~
@
C
fl
~
Ej~
~
o
~
w
•
•
e
•
•
....

SCs/152/02,167 • 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 28
PW Name of Witness

NO.

Status
Witness having
176 Rafiqkhan Yasinkhan Pathansufferred
damage

1771Victim
Sairaben Salimbhai Sandhi
1781Doctor Dipak Champaklal Jagani
1791Victim Ezajali Fakirmohammad Shaikh
Witness havinglMariamben Noormohammad Sandhi180 sufferred
damage
181 IWitness havingIRi...Yazuddiri':styazudd.in Saiyedsufferred .....".,.,... ...."".'..
damage ....'..,...,." .' ....... '.. ....
182 :~~~:::edhaving N09P3~~anb~rtMehrnhdkhan Pathan
damage

183 Witness ""having

sufferr~d
damagE"'"

184 Iwitn13ss ..haV'ing

sufferred'dami.:ge·"'· .. ..,.,.'.,.",. . ;:-:, .
185lVlctim" E~$id~bai}H:'B~:$iqbhai Shaikh
1861Victim Mb£am±nadi/£iya:§ Usmanbhai Shaikh
u.."....."..•••.·••.•.U187 Iwitness.,sufferred....'haVingIY.."...•.....fl.,.••. s .• Val:ibha;i... ... Patel

da~~g~. :::::<:::::: ~:~ <= ..,;:<;~:: ::~" .

1881:~~~:::edl1a.ving ,R®~iqahmed::'6~fu(=mbhai Malek

damage

189 Witness haJin~JY()Usufb:hJi:·~aJ:~kbhai Patelsufferred .. . ....
damage
Witness havi-;J.g
190 sufferred . IK2J:b±-·¥~cj;nB,§.miap9- Ii Mans uri
damage

1911Victim Salltnbp?I': Ng~rmQhai1imad Sandhi

1921victim Mohammadali Shahjadali Saiyed
193 Witness having ISikander Noormohammad Sandhisufferred
damage

194 Witness having IHabibkhan Bhurekhan Pathan
sufferred
damage

1951Witness having
Gulabkhan Mankhan Pathansufferred
damage

196 IWitness having
!'lufferred damage
197 IWitness havingsufferred damage
198 IWitness having
sufferred
.damage

199 IWitness having
sufferred damage
~::~
;;?:
,,¥
~
Judgment
f:·
i>Exh.
~No. ~>
t:'
709 r:
[{
I"
i:711
713
720
721
722
I:
724
725
726
727
728
729
730
731
732
734
736
737 -:'
739
740
l-r~:-=:-~'~~
I

••e
g~.'~.'
o SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 29 Judgment
w~
PW Statusf}
NO.
~
Panch200
o 2011Victim
o Witness having
o::~ 202 sufferred~Y
damage
o Witness having
203 sufferred
e damage
Witness having@ 204 sufferred
damage
Q
Witness having
205
o sufferred
damage
l:·
t:'
Exh,IName of Witness ~~:No. r-'
,-:.
IRafiqkhan Gu1abkhan Pathan 745
({
748Rafiqbhai Usmanbhai Shi1avat
I'
750Ka1im Abdu1bhai Mansuri
Farid Abubakar pathan 751
752Wahidkhan Gafurkhan Pathan
;;.;
~~
753Ka~arruSh~i b:l;l:anoo:t.·..ManSuri 11
~;
o 75420 61 ~~~~~::edhav;,m]lt~±m~~g.~n<.B~~ht~Uddin .. Shai kh
f2)
755® 207 ~~~~~:i~dhav~~~.IMah0~MI~h§RN6¢r)sQ~Il Chand~1
r..':k.~""J
208 Witr~ss<B"."ingIAkh~rhu§sain i:Bdulbhai Mansuri 756
() ~~~~::Fed ."'...} .i....)
C~~.)
20 91 :~~~::~;ddi~:J;g IK~mrUddi:~:·::·:G1.lJ.;$bbhki··.· An s ar i 757
() 758210 Iwitnes.s....h..avi..ngIMub.•..ar.·.a.k N. kZitkhan Chande1suffeJOred' ........:. '. '.'

damage." ....... :.'.:.}.::."
()
()
211 I~~~~:::ecihaVii1Sli~~~:ad··..::'·,,·,··~~,h::·~bb jEr Abdu1 sat tar I75 9
f..r
.•>,
~::J
Witness hay;iri'g
212 Abbasbha.!::Ayubbh:ai kadir 760sufferr"ed()
damage
p;:."
:",Y~
2131Victim Tat adC:h:lk·.Hussai~........ Mu11a Tahirl763

$u.rbhj;···. ., .(;)
Witness having~ 214 MohsinA'~la:fup~than 766sufferred s:~
damageo Witness having
r:'.~ 215 Majid Nathhubhai Saiyed 767~.;7 sufferred
damage
r'~
'<0
2161victim Ismai1bhai Yasinkhan Pathan 772
e
217 Witness havinglNooriben Abdu1bhai Mansuri 773E:':"l:, sufferred
~ damage
e~
~ 774218 Panch Kanubhai Ka1abhai Bharwad
A,
Witness having
219 sufferred damage
~
@ Witness having
220 sufferredA
damage~
Witness having
221 sufferred
damage
•
•
e
•
•
..
Banobibi Hussainkhan Maniyar ",,<':'J7~:::";~:::'~~...f- ~/..,.. . ' t.' { ~_,.~:;".:.... ;"..~
Yunusbhai Fakirbhai Mansuri /,·,:;.>/.··'777····"·~::..ht5)~
,(.: '":'} -i/,' ,.::.,.~. ~'(;~
Mukhtarbhai Abdu1rahim Ansair·'1:.J i '/~ 778/<;~: "":~.,i,,.,., lC

- -
••
•••
e
A.~t
o
o
c.~;~j7
~
'7J
~
®
()
-".::~
' jE
p-,
:::.:.:~,l
@
()
o
{)
f:~
:,;.-...
1""....
l~.:9
(;~
l~
Cf
G
( '":j)
()
o
(:)
o
(')
~
()
tC)
V
(@
e
~
c
•
•
•
•
•
~
~
~
~~
~
SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 30 Judgment
PW Status
NO.
222 Victim
223 Victim
-
Sarfaraz Abdulkadir Munshi
Name of Witness
Alihussain Ibrahimbhai Shaikh
779
780
Exh.
No.
2241Doctor
-
Mukund M. Prabhakar 784
2251Doctor Sumanlal B. Shrimali 786
226 Doctor
227 Panch Sureshbhai Ambalal Parmar
Jaymish P. Gajjar
793
790
22 8 IDoct0 r IRa jI).ish<R:.;'patel 795
22 91 i~~~~::edhav~n~IRa0'0~~)a~::: ~lP§41Bh$i Sh~i kh 800
230 Ii~~~~::?l~Vingl~yepha.~~~,~:i[:iimM~~~rbbc1i,Gl1anchi 801
231 Ii~~~!::edha?i,MS~.:!~·~h~~,*n:,.~~·tkh@h Pathan 802
2321Docfbr ~~yan£i :(:~~)¥:~·:..rSati3.pare.? 1803
233 J OtheiW"H:n~ss ppadYumaI1·~i:til·£i
ch4dais ama ,". ..
bharmendrasinhl810
.,:::,:::":,;,:.:;.;.>
234 F.a.:t:::illrrl~." Ta.lsad-Oeuk." .Hus sa in
i~:~::ed~aVif91 illbh:i ":: ::':':;".:,:::":::-:": :::...::~.X
I813
2351:~~~:~~edcl~h::;:~A~~da}:)a.f.l.1:1.t111nnakhanPEithan..... :.: ,': ....:-:.:
814
23 61 Witnes~ havin.glsa.·.f,·da.~. hu~s~in ., Fazlehus sainsufferred.. .. r ..,..... .
damage '. 1I.PkJ,oeSwa+:iq ,.'..'.' .
1815
237lDoctorlParGl: JR"J :::::W~gp;~+k i 818
-
23 81 :~~~:::edhaving IMoblhaX9~s U:E.:aangwala
damage
827
-
2391Witness havingIKhati]'a Yousufbhai Khambhatisuffer-red
damage
828
-
240lWitness havinglAslam Kasambhai Mansurisufferred
damage
829
-
241 Witness havinglFiroz Dilawer Shaikhsufferred
damage
831
sufferred Salim Abdulbhai Mansuri ....,~:'::::+~~':~~>'"
Police Pratap j i Siraj i Waghela ~< ,'.:~ g:3··g~·::~,IS>...
" . . ,.:' "!-,,,..':;-' ./?~
Police ChlnUSlnh KeSrlSlnh Jhala /!:.":':('-:~;':;'.8,-.~:~:1,,:~'
,r, '•.' , ro' ',::::,"':< . .• J ••
Police Udesinh Pratapsinh Baraiy~LL'( ~a:4{)oJ .
242 1Witness having
damage
243
244
245
- - # ,/ ';. ~ i·~ { •.~ ~ ..:. )' ""
~. :
i::'~
f".'
I:,
[":",
(:~.
1-'i:-::
'~'
I,~
~
F
'''< "'
'~:)
" ,.-
';"",,::,;~
i~ ~..,. < (:<.: ):.' :1
f:
':~~~1~,0~i1 ~
~

I

•••••••
••o
A
tf.:}
C",
tj SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 31
o
Status
Other
wltness
Police
Police
Police
Police
Police
Police
253 Otherr, witness'0V
Name of Witness
Jayeshkumar A. Yadav
Laljibhai Kalaji Asari
Takaji Takhuji Chavda
Motisinh Habisinh Bariya
Vijaysinh Vikramsinh Rajput
Prataprai Chhaganlal Joshi
Kar;cansi~h,'J3~~';'~n~inh Vaghela
... M~h~rfun:~drd2ti~,CPl"19te Ansari
Police
Police
Noormohammad Valisha Tiwari
Varvaji Ishwerji Waghela
Tarunkumar Amrutlal Barot
Natwarji Jawanji Bhati
Anwermiya Y. Shaikh
IHimmatsinh B. Sisodiya j
i ..
I' ,IShevabhai K. Rathod "
l: '.'
Judgment
Exh.

No.

842
843
845
849
1853
1854
1867
1869
o
(J
o
(~
()
1:-.").
0:./
o
(}
(.:)
~
®
PW

NO.

246
247
248
249
250
251
252
920

921

926

~'::'
,":
.>
fi
::
:-.
'-",
i':=
~'
C)
"1( ,~yl
C",":.:;/
c·>
c:
f',-'-."
",.' :)C
()
f'~
:j
Q
o
c.u
o
€)
A
~
2541police If;ra:l1ia~~:~,,,~gpg~Iji.···Barot· 1876
25 51 panQhlI1a~4A;d ,'~hfu~d Ai5'dUfLazi zShaikh 1877
2561 Panch IRem~;h.!5u~~F",Bitd9pi$--bJinger 1883
2571Panc;h IH~roQhbhg:±;:<-L$~~khJrbfraiGhanchi 1885
25 81 o~hei
wltness
±~jpal s i Bm'::(f;i';:Bi s~ I897
25 91 o~her
wltness
Mc?haViirsidh',S. Shekhawat 1899
2 60 1~~~~~~s>JR~jeshbh:~::1':':;·V~:ghagaf 1902
26 lOther"
1 witn~!Ois I'". '
.'. P],lrsh9:;S:Sf:p'y?pq~,N., Patel I 90 6
262IWitneSSl1avin-i;iIMau.lana
~~~~::red'.' ..../» ",',, Yakub Akbar Vijapura
....,.... ',' . 1909
2 63IvictimlMoha~~d:Sc3.,limAbrriedbhai Shaikh 1910
2641Victim IFirozhhqi' ,BanQealiShaikh 1918
2651Witness havinglKarimabanusufferred
damage
Mohammadbhai Shaikh 1919
A
V
e
o
~
o
•

Victim
267
268
2691Police
270 IO~her
266
wltness
-
271 IO~her
wltness
272 IO~her
wltness

.
--
--
--
- -
•
•
•
~~
f$
o
e
o
•
c
••
•
•
•
•o
o
()
r-:",;.1
r·c-,
~""
roc,'l::-j
~"
t.)
C.··'>'
~
'R!:},~
(.)
{)
()
,~
It:Y
e
@
B."
o
~
e
e
e
•
G
••
•
•
•
•
•
SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 32 Judgment r:
I~~
~Name of Witness Exh.PW IStatus
~.NO. No. t~
~.
Doctor 944273 Mansukh M. Mawani ~:~
::-~
~Police274 Ramaji Gangaji Katara 946 .~
I~
.'
27 5 O~her Balwantsinh Rampraveshsinh 952wltness

276 IOther
954Pravinkumar N. Barotwltness
277 IO~her Sharadkumar B. Trivedi 962wltness

278 1Other
963Ratans ilJh::.J?~: c::;havdawltness ~
27 9lO~her t1ah~:saj ighqlon....•........:.
965wltness
280 IO~her
wltness
2811 O~her/
wltne.ss
282 Victi~ 978
Victim. 981283 A§~arrykh9-:Ri;·:;:~~:~tkft.anpathan
284/Victj"m 987M8hardmad~:i:ci±iif Nas it'uddin Shai kh::"':.;:,:':'
28 51 Polt.c~ Bh§ihj!ibha.l:J1L-vanqpai Sadawrati 1988

28 6IPOl:i.~~
J:~.gpl:Sh$.i0~j:::·~~mubha.> Ghudasama' 1991
e
287 IPoUc
i1~::~,1:~'~~0ri~'F6'/Surendras i nh I992
2881Police 7SfK"ishQysinh Motis~.nh Wag-hela 1994
2891Victim ·INadffiw::~.~§:~q.qU~hP·r~a.inSur-ohi 1995
290lWitness havingIMOha.·.imn :M~:hiligl uddin Ansari..... {::§::d~:r£f: 1023sufferred~. ...

damage ' : ::.-.- .

2911Witness havinglKamaruddin 1024Jalaluddin Saiyedsufferred

damage

2921Witness having IJamalbhai Fakirbhai Mansuri 1025sufferred
damage

2931 Witness having IAbdulbhai Allanoorbhai Mansuri
1029sufferred
damage
Witness having
294 sufferred damage Rajubhai Bandeali Rajasaheb Shaikh 11~~:~
Witness having
295 sufferred Sabidkhan Gulabkhan Pathan /.(~~~~~9~~~:_~~;::s~~
damage
,:;'';'',::':" j"~,:" .- ," ~.;:~
Witness having
296 sufferred Rafiqmohammad Nekmohammad sa,,i,Y·~:Sr"..Jl00~~~6':.,~·.;:"_/,ln

damage .~ ~ £.:, :,~ .,. r~·l;~~:~'" (~~~') :~~ ~

Witness having

sufferred
297 Ayubkhan Ishaqkhan pathan 1:.··~ .::, 10i4:~·.::~, 12Jldamage ~" '.:l.'lO.~l" ?........../~J.J
", ...
.I , # ..~
>;~;~~i,ti.i~~l

- -
- -
•••••
.,•
o
o
~ SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 33 Judgment
~
v
Exh.PW Status Name of Witness
C
No.NO.
@
Witness having
Shanazbanu Mohammadumerkhanl1038298 sufferred
e~
damage Pathan
o Witness having
Khatunbibi Abdulkadir299 1039sufferred
o damage
300lWitness havinglYousuf Taiyebbhai Khambhati
••
•
•
•
••
e 1040suffeI:-I:-ed
damage

3011Victim
Rasidabanu Dilawar Shaikh 1046
Witness having
1047302 RoshanbtbiJJ.$IDi3.nbhai Silawatsufferred ...:..:-:.:-........ . .

damage
1048303 ~~E:::edhaVingls~eE(£?~iB:~'::rsm~ilbhai Shaikh
3041 Victim 1049
305IPolic~.~~<II3h1.1lBMrta:¥§:§:~p~h<K~~?:ns~inhSisodiya 11052
iJ6d~jeh~n:::$igl§h~ 'S:haj. kh
e 30 61 Poii2i=IR9n1*ilgsiR9.:ml'a~kharipathak 11059
G 3071Panch
G
3081Pblice
G
30 91 O~her> ~.~~wltnesse
1.0 ~310~
G Police311
o Police312
~,
v 313 IO~her
wltness
G
•
e
•
o
••
G
•
314 Victim
315 Police
316 Police
317 Police
318 O~her
wltness
319 Police
320 Police
321 Police
322 Police
323 Panch
324 Police
•
•
•

. ,"....:'
1061IA¥~ta:&khap·~~::?$:~:ii.ih;jadkhanPathan
IKiranpur£~::~~G.E:t~gapuTi Goswami 1062
ILaktn~n K~:~:P:i3.:rdhi 1064~~"~'<"'" ,~,~~ ~~~,~~
~':.": IHI~~slhkli~,~.~;:··..'~:2/Agta~?t
: IJC3.gatsinh Ramsinh Parmar
lBabqbhk.t" Moharibhai Parmar
Ai3hish'Sureshchandra Khetan~::...~r.~~~~~ ,.. . .
Fagi:t:'itl6h~~~cr tNiius iraliSa i yed
AnantsihhKalyansinh Rathod
Ramkubhai Nagbhai Vala
Navalsinh Ramsinh Bariya
Dhiren Jayantilal Lariya
1069
1075
1077
1091
1098
1133
1134
1135
1137
~
t~
~

I ~
G
[::
i:."
i':'
i-::
L¥;
l~~
.~~
fi:
~
~
~ .
rr·-.
I',
Kumarrai Jagdishrai Chandna l13...9~:":C·"r:·.~._,
..... ,...~ ".• :, :' ! t'-'~ ~~. '...~~."
Jogdas Suryanarayanprasad Gedam ,. "'1140. ,..'.,:.':.:';:"::': .:",~
t'~' ." . ": ,- .., : " . ,""'"~''''''~''' ;., r ';~
Harisinh Chhatrasinh Gohil /: :~:t'4'J", ':'.IL'··,;.~~:'<:<~ I~.
Raiskhan Mohammadkhan Pathan (i.!1144 :,;::}~,'; "'('~:"r~~~,~
Nitinkumar Narandas Sheth .'. ' _,1147 :'::1«,' ,;;, /:::/}
'" '114:~r ;': '.' (0 'II
~~[~ ;,":':':::",~ !,'<;, ;~,:~li
."....~~ ':.',c :~~-~~/

••••••••
--
e
G
_~
,",.""1
"J'©
r~,J SCs/152/02,167 & 279103, 190,191,193,194,195,279109 34 Judgment
c
(:~
c)
@
r>..
.:;,:",i
0,
A
~::~"
e,.,:,~~
@
A
e
oil?-!>
~
m~
@
(3
o
()
()
c;
PW
NO.
..
IStatus Name of Witness Exh.
No.
3251 Police Bhikhusinh Khatusinh Rathod 1158
3261Police Shai1esh Anilkumar Vyas 1161
3271Police Sanjaykumar Ramjibhai Patni 1162
32811.0. Narottam D. Parmar 1164
32911.0. Harish R. Muliyana 1211
33011.0. Rahul Nanheshwar Sharma 1213
3311 I .0. 1Giri9hktifria'f<t~Sil1ghal'"':':':';'. ,".:.>:.:.:.;.: ".-.'.
1217
3 3 21 I . 0 ·lsGhqd~~s ~:n'~ ,:i:.·8.:Ghpq~sama 1226
3331 Doctor"" IMUk~shbha;';;g~'K~E?diya 1281
3341 Doctor ICl}ahd:g~:~:$·ffij;t;·:"::i<·j· @gs;;arni 1284
335 1I . o.~6a~~ri:ti~;p:Tivt~,;;;.suthqr 1289
336/ I ~O '. "<71Nffi~~a;t;~~~B::::·::':$:·.; ..:·~~jU·'····· 1377
337 1vicfidi Iz~ki Ina ~;'±;fu::::::'Aft::~an bafri..:....:;:.....: .. 1463
338 Other
witness,...."
DrOs hi:J.i letldra' Ramkishor Jha. . -' , " ' ,.. . . 1492
.-:.'1~'Y
C
()
'"
13 .Th~•.?) p;ros:;~'~:'~:t·~:~~ also' .r~lied upon
e",
~
~ :::u:::::~~~'~~~:~?,~:~~~~;:~~~p"f:::r:::~
~~::o~uminous~
6
£'h
El Al})jfr':ffCf!~~[~k . I~~~.
G
Forwarding letter regarding muddamall1761G
having been sent to F.S.L.e>.,
~
2 IThree acknowledgment receipts regardingl177
C
FSL having received the muddamal
@
178Opinion of FSL3
o
1794 Opinion of FSL4)
Forwarding letter regarding muddama!-: ~"'8~:~."-~~~5 ~. , '~.I·';"I- ·,."tG
having been sent to F S L .0/ '>1,)',:,,'" f".,~ ::::':>:'<:,;,• • • .Ii':.' '...~ , ~.~,I'".. •. .,..~ ,.".- . ~""", -'.. r ( ..; "-~~>"e
Acknowledgment receipts regarding /":':8St',],'81:':::;:: "'<~:','~>6
having received the muddamal
7 Opinion of FSL
I,". '.1 . • . ' , . - ' ~ ., ~l..
;::','.'i' ,;';,..<: ,:.:;~<",i..~.)~~
) '. , '. '.;:.) , ~ "'-1
~:'-,.' .l, 1$.2.,:, :"ni'.' , , ;.; , " '. .} ..., 'i
I';'" .C<,,? •.-' ! -...ifl
t. '. .;/... "7 •. ,,', / 'Ij
<·2::.~.:y[f;}) /
l·.
::'
[r:
I'I,
I
r
r~

I
~
"':
;.~i;
~
~r'

SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 35 Judgment
~
,~
j;:
"£"
f.g)
~,
.~
~
.",
~'
~
.~~
Exh.
No.
Sr. I Particulars
No.
muddamall1838 IForwarding letter regarding
having been sent to F.S.L.
9 IAcknowledgment receipts regarding FSLI184
having received the muddamal
10 IOpinion of FSL 1185
muddamall18611 IForwarding letter regarding
having been sent to F.S.L.
04 acknowl~99rrteHt;:r:~geipt;R regarding FSLI187
having I";~c~~yeq. t:h@ 'muq.q;am?T
12
Opiniph Q f ' 118813
panchnam~Of'qM.#f2:i·lg·'§R:yi~ty 126014
pa,nchl1~rDa 9;P GUltJ,g"rg.sgdigty . 126115
...~ ..... - ...... -
16 IBaIl.Chha,fna:t'egp:fd~:§:9..?7<:::6vefY of gun. 1262
17 1CofhptaYintiSf'.Mr.~·;.~;:·~::~·.~:~da /267
18 IReport ma.d.Et ~y MirC,I:f.C'iErdc3. to P.S.O. 1268
19 I04/p~p~rs Er9jduq~~:.,:?i.th prr!~port No.4 0 9 1275
20 IPM :R~pdft if clin~s·¥H;hkJi Kal~bhai 1276
ofl278body
. -:-:',':'.
21 I~:;~~~~en~:~~hl1¥B':H~, dead
27922 IInquest R§.h9h,ii;2rma::--AsminRa,~iqbhai
28023 IInquestBa,rfchp·~tn~· +·p.P:£ct~Atified
24 IInquest Panchnama:. Earidaben Shakilbhai /281
Mansuri
Kherunbibi 128225 IInquest Panchnama
Sikanderkhan Pathan
Nazmaben Kasambhail28326 IInquest Panchnama
Mansuri
27 IInquest Panchnama - Mumtaz Sikanderbhai Sandhi 1284
28 Inquest Panchnama - unidentified
1---+---------------------------+:;,...:;...:.::.""""':-'HoI-",.. ' .......
29 Inquest Panchnama - Nasim @ Zebu:Q: o28.? ",, . ,
Aslambhai Shaikh ,/, . .'~;
30 Inquest Panchnama - Asmatben AbdUlblj'i;,;,};/'
Mansurl L,.... I
I....-_....L. -:',..;,.. .;.,..;...'.L.'~.!'-.:....---'6_J
'"
~
r:I
2S..~·-:-~".::;7~::-:,;~
I'.~ - "'''''- "'.~~_,..' ---.J. ,l._ f','
.'....., ~::. ,~': '~
, . ' .) ,
....,~ ' (0') ;. f
' -~~:~~
'-,'" lit.). "4~'" ~jl
~ J ~·~i J~
'~.7tiii~fj

__
•••e
~C SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 36 Judgment
:6
Sr.
No.
Exh.
No.
Particulars
31 IInquest Panchnama Mehmuda Aslaml288
Kasambhai
32 Inquest Panchnama - Sharifaben Munirsha 1289
33 Inquest Panchnama Ahmedali 12 90
Faqirmohammad Saiyed
34 Inquest Panchnama Anwarkhan Ahmedkhan 12 91
pathan
35 Salimkhan 12 92
~~~~~~:rtha~P;=~~f-il~~'
36 Mohammadshafi 12 93
~~~~~~d~t~~~~~~~!W'-
37 294Inqu~~t'Ean@mri@fu~";, Gri±d~Ptiiied"
38 295In.qu§§t P ad-ghn9>m&.7-...u~iid~ritifled
39 Inq'-iE¥st pi&hchparti·g~···'''ffi.·;,¥pha~ad,. Imran Gulzar 1297
40 Inquest pahchpam~;:;.·i,:~dhamfnadyousufMehmudl298
Hussgin
41
42
ASlambhair9
I nqu~pt. Panchq.affi9,.:::::./ un.,~d.gnt i f ied 300
-':.:' :.-:;:..-;: '; :.: _. - , .
InqU~st :8·andhn§::tn~::;)::: ::'.~.:: I r fan
Mansuri:':. ·::,r::',:::'::: Yo':··:
43
44
Inq-liest? .Panchnama NilOfarl301
Inquest Panchri~~~;:·~,·::~]i-~·k~nAslam 302
Mohammad sh.a12:i.;EShaikh··:·:····:·,:····:·:·
45 Inquest P anchnama., ..: Shahir Asimbhai 1303
Mansuri
46 Inquest Panchnama - Jehrunisha Saiyedkhanl304
Ahmedkhan
47 Inquest Panchnama Mariambibi Gulzarl305
Mohammad Pathan
.<··~·~~'0,
48
49
50
51
52
Inquest Panchnama - unidentified 3Q.§._~,.
Inquest Panchnama - Irfan Mohammad Gulzar Mohammad Pathan/~;.j,;i-~::·;~:
I nques t Panchnama - unidentifi ed
Inquest Panchnama - unidentified i ,i :309:,--~~::::.,·:;~
",
Inquest Panchnama - unidentified '...... "310,.,,,:;,
,.:0 I;:
'0
&,~
e
v
:0
~~
(()
t:.
(~ tj
G
Q
,.,.',l0
'0
!~
IV
o
o
0:
10
o
(0
(e
(0
(0
r(E)
,A ~
(0".
(.
CO
(I
el
et
(,:t,-
~t; :~b;;:" ..C:::'.r~
e. . ..~":":.
i ·..., I
. )-"','1(~
ct
e.
~~~'}i;l1&~~et
It

•e
e
~
~
u SCs/152/02,167 • 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 38
~~:;"
G
~
~
"';~
o
®
e
G
()
CO'<
i?i
~
~~
t:::';l
~
o
()
f-";
VI
r""~-:)
0··.·"-J
(~_:'
(i
r-.'.
~ ...
(2)
@
C)
~

~

e:;,
~
@
@
o
e
..
•
•
••
•
e
••••
Exh.
No.
ParticularsSr.
No.
Bashirl370Shamshad Abubakar78 IPM report
Ahmed
37179 IPapers along with PM report
80 IPapers produced along with PM reportl 372
No.648
81 IPM report - Mohsin Mehbubbhai Allanoor 1373
Three papers pr0c:i."l?:s~9.with PM report 137482
PM reportNd<~49 $amimkalimbhai 1375.. ....:.:.:.:.:.:::. .::::, .:--,
83
Copy o;f':fo;t:'w~:r;ihDg) ±:~tt~J::" •.... 1376.' '.'" .
84
Copy/ 0 f~Oiward.in:9!r:::+:gtt:~r 1377.. .', :-:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:-:.;.;.:.:-:-:-:.:.; :-: ::
85
Copy of; . forWRra$R:g·.J::~tt·~W 1378. ..... .'.~"."~:'.~ ~"~'. ',',','
86
COBY9f fRiWar9i~:~(l.:~:~t~.r. I37987
Panc]:ln{amabf i:kc~:~i·:·~·::R::~:·:::;.:dflenC~ 138188
parichnam£6f::Clotm~;$:'}:;pecovetedby Police 139489
pahPhriama.df.pur§~;:i: q~:r:tridges 139690
~~~::~,~~llrrl~~~~~~t~J15L6tbes of tbel398
91
Report . r~9;:ard:ing):ii).o:p.-,,:.r::ec·eipt·· of PM Report 1404
No. 444 Eind477 /2
92
40593 IPM report)-M9~~~2fdf>atha.l)·
40694 IPapers aloqg JADt~t: ~lNr }f~p6rt
40795 IPM report - N~.sr·inbanuM<:>hammad Sharif
96 IReport regarding non-receipt of PM Reportl 409
97 IPM Report - Wasim @ Sonu Mehmood Mansuri 1410
98 IPanchnama of recovery of pieces of 12-1412
bore cartridge
100lPanchnama of damage
99 IPanchna~a of three pe~sons injured in private firing, police firing 415_.~"""
and pollce stone peltlng ,..,...•.<...;..,,~.
.--""....
/ ;11"17' i
:J/'~' .~ .•..'
101 ITotal three papers along with PM report:.~:.::,,:,~4:i9.:':...... ' ..' .
102 PM report - Mariambibi Gulzar MOhamma4<:·.1,/ 41
21
......-.. . .
103 Papers along with PM report No. 423 :·,:..::~... t.423~~<...::)
i~
E~
[~~
;:~
~~
Judgment
1/
~~~::
k
I:::
t:
"',
I.'
I::'
,
:"
II'·f~-.
L ~~'
I··
r;:
k7:
ff:
.r",.,
_.'::!';'.'+;-..
..... " ..'''~ ~-~r:r.;.'"
(,.; f......~~.,
:.~::..~~~--: ~.::~~.,c y~.....'~<-
,'::;'" ~~';):·'<C~i [.
."~' ~(-,n' I
c{"I>:; ':(:::..-.(~:'~ C
, ,- ,."
~ ~.}':fJ
'. " '~"" ..- .J "'I.l
;~:; .:;~>::~'.;~~:' ::::~:":,',:~J~;~~'..r.,1/"<i: :"!' ... ,....:?-~'.. ;..",)i'
"·;~,(,;.~2~;~;~~~;:~~~~

-~
:~
.*

;~ .
.~
,gl
~
,~
.;,
'.
i~
,,:-:~
SCs/152/02,167 • 279103, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 39
Sr. Particulars
No.
~
~
is
~
':.0
~:
~~
~~
Judgment
Exh.
No.
424
105 ILetter directing PM note to be preparedlMark-A
1041PM report of Farha Mohammad Sharif
of the deceased
1061PM note - No1ifer Mohammad Sharif 426
1071Papers produced with PM report 427
1081Four papers relating to PM report 1428
No.453/02 .......:.:.:.::::;:.:.;.:-.. ,
109 IPM reportof.i~wa(r=kqan . AilmedJ<.han Pathan 1429
110 I~~:~~~:~~ :t~a~::~tlVt:~~~q'~rYOf clothes 1432
111 1PaBe r$. VJith ...gM::,,:.~:@p:6:B:t::::::::~9~:97 6
112 IP~ r§port df::unl~;lght±f),Jdd~adbody
113 IFourpi3-pe%§ w)tfl>..:::'~:M.:..:B'~I?:~'rtNo .447
114 IPMF~pbrtofMoh~Rij~.~:::.:Imran.:'.'
115 ll?apE::Fs: witB.> p1.vI re:p:q'rt'. No .416/02
435

436

449

450

452

116 IPMrE2Port$f.1Sr'1~,'~#:{~:i.-':.::}adpuji Vanzara. 1453
1171Panc::hnarna kecdv:g:i:@d vehiCles 1456
118 IPolice}.:. ·:: ...yaaqil-:::'::::::s::Ipqi:!est Panchnama 1457
postllumous':Fqrm .
of Police 14 60
1191~~~~~~a~:~1~~ti1~&j~iUlo~~ry
120lReport rega£dina.:HgD::-::receipt of papersl465 ,.
i~
relating to PM report No.451/02
1211PM report of Salimkhan Sikanderkhan 1466
1221PM report of Zehrunnisa 1468
123 1Panchnama regarding damage caused to government vehicles 1480
1241Panchnama of relics of human body 1482
125 Panchnama of relics of human body r::~~-'::~~ ·jfi:~:.~7::~:~r:::..,
126 Panchnama of unidentified dead body /::;..>~<·~Eff:·':':~:·, 5~
127 Panchnama of unidentified dead bOdl;,/~' ,t~f':~'~
128 Panchnama of relics of human body (,:< ,~,~,~ t;':~j)
:~~d~~<5h!

l~

••e
@
G SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 40
~":'1~~;:
~~
~
~
~
@
{}
(j
•
e

•
•e

e

e

o

tP::..
~
C
•
e

•
•
•o

•
e
.'

•
o
•..

•
•..
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

Sr.
No.
Exh.
No.
Particulars
1291Certificate issued by Meghaninagar PolicelMark-B
Station
130 IPanchnama regarding production of weapon 14 95
by accused No.35 Ashok @ Aslo
1311Panchnama regarding production of stickl499
by the brother of accused No.29
1321Injury certificate of Kantibhai Popatbhail512
1331X-ray photQ$'a'nd.'ofher.,. 21 papers ofl513
Kant ibha1",."'/""":':':":'
134 ICerti+ic§.t~reg9.rding ,.%:njuIY, ,to' Ajaybhai 1514
Som§.bha iPaDch~;;t,:,:)::,:::::"'::'::/i):: .' ... .
c erti :Eios.t " ' ,
13 6
No.281516
I~~~~~~~j ~~,It.~t~15~~t;lqf' accuseq
1371 517Two paperspfi cas'@;P'Cfp:ers ...
138Ipap~;s r7g~r~ing:,d:::pap~rs of PM reportl519
No /432102f?(pirgp)2;g;":':':::~,p,aceabJe
1391PM iepgxt'Sf Prakashbhai Ramanbhai Patni 1520
140l Jehangirl521ofpM ",. '/;E2PO.rt"·"':N6:::':,f~if62::":
No 0 rmohammad"': Sandhi. .. . :;.; -.
141 5241Panchn~ma bi':~t::9'Ej8'g;t'wtR~>
142 Accused No .18SaIlj~Yknfua:F ShClkrabhai Patni 1530
Maheshkumar LalchahdbhaiNayee~ injured
Vishalkumar Badri Nayee - injured
Panchnama of detention of Nareshkumar Bansilal,
accused No.42 and Shailesh Natwarlal Patni, accused
No.19
143 IPanchnama of the injured during Police firing 1532
147
145
146
144 Panchnama of detention of absconding 533
accused No. 23 babubhai Manj i Patni
Panchnama of physical conditioff;/..9:f:·.~~~~,<.~:~~:",
accused No. 31 Mahendra Mulchand Pa1J1la:~./·,.,"" >: '~",
panchnam~ ~f accuse~ No.3 9. MUke~h.£~:t~~'a't~m5'37;"':'"
who was lnJured durlng Pollce flr~,n,g i , . __
Panchnam~ of, physical condition of accused No. ~?"..:'~~~bhai: :$:4:D~.
Mohanbha~ Patn~ .;........ "', .'.,
Judgment
f-:
f":
~'::
I.'
'"
r",..:
(
I::.
!~~.
~:,.
~~:
i~.
l,"
,:~
"':
r:;,;~"::"~?::~:;~":".:-:"'~~~
.~,":~';
);~,.~ I,
II,
J}d
~: ',-,I;~;
~ ..• !
<~~',,:~"fj],~ijY

••••••
••e
A
'(:::.9
~ SCsIl52/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 41 Judgment
~~;;l
~
o~
e
u
~
•
•
•••
•
e
c

o

o

e?>.
(:1
£.JJ;
V
c;~
::'"..
t!'~
~J
f)
(}
{#
~
~
o

G
e
()
f$
C
e

•
e

•
•

Exh.
No.
ParticularsSr.
No.
5501481Four papers with PM report No.454
1491PM report of Mohammad Shafi Mohammadl551
Munawar
150lPapers produced with PM report No.467 1552
1511PM report of Yasmina Rafiq 1553
152 ITwo papers with PM report No.455/02 1555
1531PM report ofo.ead"bQpY of Firdosbanul556
Gu 1 z a r Mohamffi~d' P':i!:t:(:l)an/ ',
154 IPM repoitNbl45 6J:':e:Yiitidaber1 Shakilbhai 1557
ShaiJsh
Se qong, c;:dpy ,,9~':':,§Nt::::?fN§p:Q¥:'B No. 4 5,6 I558155
Papersp.foql8kd with 'PM 't~port. No'.456 1559156
PM(:r;~pbrt.9fKh~F::B':~l?:#~iSikandarkhan 1561
Pape;r:;9pr9§.uc¢d:~~~~.~.::¥~':t~port No. 457 1560157
158
Papers regarding :"p~p~:rs produced with PMI562
rep6ft No .45 8,., no:t)::.~,p:~,ceable
PM 'f~PQrt< .Nq. 45$·,:':::,C$'!j;';" Mahemuda" Aslambhai 1563
Manspr~
160
159
Paper:ptoctuged:::jIE:h:'::OpM "'fgport No. 459 1564161
1621PM reportfJg.459.Q.b".Sharitabep Munir Shah 1565
163 IPapers prodGtE:l@/;/Witi-B :?J:1peport No.4 60 1566
164 IPM report NO.46Q9f,l}§watben Abdulbhai 1567
1651Papers produced with PM report No.471 1568
166/PM report No.471 of Mohammad Hussainl569
Salimbhai Sandhi
571Papers produced with PM report No.443167
572PM report No.443 of Muskan Aslarn168
~~;::~~<;.(-'" :'~~~S'::'))
No.475 of Irfan Mohammad
of half charred dead bodieMC..'"(,.".:<::576',.;>;;;~ , .. • :"., ,'. r ",", • ,Y" ,
of identification of 15~ "4~ad 57,§)",·;.~
Papers produced with PM report No.475169
170 PM report
171 Panchnama
172 Panchnama
bodies
.~::!,(~:
.
I':
i'.
(
r;=:
1-"
ff
i','
i'f
f:
I:
s::
r"'~'~
GUX;i;·a:~:.':~7A·"~~j'·~~,··<~~(~~
. ~!'" ''
. ridI
,<i~~;i;;~{~;J

.
i
oe~~
~~~
:::
~, SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 42 Judgment
,~
Sr.
No.
Exh.
No.
Particulars
1731Papers produced with PM report No.488 1591
174 IPM report No.488 of Nazmaben Kasambhai 1592
1751Injury certificate of Manojkumarl594
Premjibhai
176 IInjury certificate of Parbatsinh Dharsinhl596
1771Letter from SIT regarding injuryl598
certificate of accused No.49 parbatsing;:.::~:::::::'.' '.' .
178 1Injury ce:r::ti:fi~at:te'qf :r;7:C:lZi9.1i 1600...;.: :.:- .
179 1~~t~~~n~::(~~t~~lfS~:::,r~dt:ipI}inthe namel601
... ,,=::::;:;::::::::;:~::.
180 1In jbry c~:pti:l:~:8i't'$'::::::::6:f:'$:h?Jkh 1602
181 IIrJjU~y: c~rti,Wf'iCCl,t4:'bf.ASl~rn"Anwarkhan 1603
185
184
1831
182
605
' Taiyeb Fakirl606
1PaP~~9: "':vyi ~~' P~ tk:p:~:~:t::N0 . 470:. 608
-
IInjury ~~xt~fid~t'~: of
Moh.kmmad '.. ;:. :: ~i '. - ;.;:'; ;~::" ::..:: "::;" ..... '", ...
Indpty c$Btif'ic~~:~':},'¢:.~:::Aslam,':,',
1X'-r~yqf .2¥$1aIrl:' l:0:w~'i~:han ':":, 1604,- . . , ' "..' ~. :.:.":.:.:. :.: ...;" .;.;./<: .; .'.
186/ pM repdrh~f ~~]::?1,:tI1P'~IJK<3sambhai 609
-••••• ,. C,·,-. ,"' ;. :.: .' ••••• :. :.; ". -." ••••:~:. •
187 IInjhfy6erei;ficate~f Karimbhai 611
-
190
1891
188 1Injury< ce>rti+'i;.F:§~:~·bf·:R~$h()rkumc;J.r 613
IInjury certificate··>6f accused No.421615~Naresh Bansilal
Injury certi:E{:g~t:~·.9.f~ M~ghjj,Kokaji .
1911Injury certificate of accused No.571616
Shai1eshkumar patni
195
193
192
194
1-
1Injury certificate of unknown person V<)
1Injury certificate of accused No. 2 3
Babubhai Manjibhai
1Injury certificate of accused No .131617
Vinodkumar Arvindbhai
1Injury certificate of Sanjay
Patni ';' ,.,.,
-+-------------------------------,.;...-.........,I----~
.. I t:'2 0
[;',~~,
~::
':$~ i-·
f-:
t~~:
r':,,'
*;
fJ
if
,
I~
,,'
'i1
:~
f?
,~
~?<
ilRJ..~
r
','
Wei
~~
~
;':~
$~
,>,
<~
:,,:_:~
A'~"""::'~:~'~"
,,1:-$', ; ; ( .;,:--~,
;f~~
/:'; ~~.,/ :;!::<:;::.. <: ....,::." .~:>
ChikUbb{~'i:.I~;~/:·'·:'~··(~~,?~
1(' 1,
','-' Jj
/ ":-) 1!
''''-' ~ I'
.,', ('..../ i~
"';~:~~~;~,;~::<;.~:':/.,~",. ,<,t:l,,' .:;..:'" ,C'. '"
:---.) vI'''' , ';... ..J ...-.;:....
·-'~~~I~~~~~~~·

~.~;
-:2;'
!~~
::~~
SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 43 Judgment
Sr.
No.
Exh.
No.
Particulars
196/Injury certificate of accused No.301621
Madanlal Dhanraj
Ratilal
Dipakkumar
Babubhai Mohanphai:,'···
200 Copy of ...,TTIjpry:(d:f2*:tifiqate of accusedl625
No. 2 2 . '.' .. ::::::,::,,:;:: :::>,.::::" '.'
.............-:-:...._....
202
201
~:;:~;ap~f6s~~~i~~~-,isZ:,,22.~:~ndragiri~G0:s w,q.rrti ..".,.:::::...::::'"
2031 Injur,y ce~$if:£~q~:~;::·:"{Fn%::,NaripalJl1ai 1628
2041}ff~aatit ot W:*:gi.i~adgulzar Mohammad I 637
Pathan "::<.: :.'" .
2051~::~~~~:~ r~1E1t~1~.iOff de¢~as~d Rameshl642
206lpancbna,magf :': identificat:Lon of total 171644
deadbbcli6$
207 IPapers ';;itllPM:'f~:port.J:J9.466 1658
2081~:hang~~~~~ftli/f~:'ljf~"6f Zarinabenl659
20 91Papers produc~dwith:·'PMreportNo.4 68 1660
210 IPM report No.468 of Mumtz Sikanderbhai Sandhi 1661
211 6621Papers with PM report No.469
212 1PM report No.468 of Nasim @ Zebunl663
Aslambhai
216
215
213
214
1Injury certificate of Pradipsinh :;6}68
Shetansinh Rathod ','-' ~ ,;
1Police yaadi ~~¥.{/:~"
1Police yaadi
Injury certificate of Baldevbhai
'~<;fY1I!S);{;"~~/l·
f~
t·::
r.'
~::-:
!~:
i~~
:~
:~
:~
:~ '(.
<,
~
,~ I~
;<l> 'S
~
•
~
<~<~
,.
l~~:
~>.
L
f'
~}
6 ~f~fP~~~ :,;r7~~~.~:::..
,.':-.:.;,
Jivabhai. "';~~v•.:..,,~:_,'::,~,::.··:::!-.::~;,>~
~t 2.·;·,<{.::})
';~' (':.: ,
.(. (1.:~~;J.
~: . (", J,j:~
"''' .:/>, ,--' -1, Ii':

••e
&..~'~:.
@
o

~~
~
'i>;;J
~

~

o
o
••
•
••
o

e
9
C
e:.~/~'
127>
'l~}
{..",
. ~!
~y
{J
o
()
o
~
A
~'
e
~
C?
e
~
o
G
G
•
•
e
••
•
••
•

SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 44 Judgment
Exh.

No.

Sr. Particulars
No.
217 IInjury certificate of Indrasinh Mansinh 1669

2181Panchnama of detention of accused No.27 &1671

26

2191Panchnama of detention of accused No. 241673

220

221

221
-A
222
223
224

225

226

227

228

229

230

231

232

233

Shankerji Hakaji mali
Panchnama of detention
Mukesh Pukhraj Sankhla
Prahlad RajujJ,As'Ori<
of
and
accused
accused
No.2 91675
No.28
Panchnamg/ 6f9qmag:~ -... 1708
~~i~d~iet~~!~~~~:~~~~~~~l,eQ' SaliOOohai 712
N$ranrao '~;~!i1;~~'''''W'' - .. . 0" •
~:J:;Y} 6~;'tiifi~~,[..~1£ ' Vishal Badrijil715
Police Yac:i.cU?lOr1,e.tkith Ekh. 715 1716
Bap~~s wisl). Pf'r r:~:B:?:::B:>.::N 0 .644 1717
PM~§pdrtWP.;~44:::'::()'if/:::D::~hiyClbenMahemudbhai 1718
.. ..... ,.
complaint of.<;ia,mi;l.ge..,.. ..: 1723. ..-.' '....-:...:... :.::: ..•:...;::.;.::.: ,.":. ,'-',
Panchnamaof identification of 06 deadl746
b 0 di e:·s.. .:..:..: : : :.:.:.: :.::::::: :.:.:.:'. .
~:~~~~:~aD~::!~~w;~th i accus ed No.3 01775
Injury certificate of Firoz 1785
Injury certificate 1787
Injury certificate of Altaf 1789
Injury certificate of Jetunbibi 1791
2341Panchnama of accused No.32
Kantilal having produced weapons
235 Injury certificate of Bablu
236 Police yaadi
237 PM report No.450 of Aslam
2381PM report No.452 of Shahjadali Faqir Mohammad
Ambesh 794
,:~~:;~S'~:~~~~?~~~,

!/" '·"l9'E)'''-'·'- . - ""~
.d:; ->'~" .-.~, ~' .,,':; ~,:.(."C;.:
'--J} ' , ' ' ;(::..'··L
"J < 8 05: '. t, (-- ;
I , ~,. ( "'y"; j ~
( .. ''''0, ! " ...' ii
. ! 80:6' + ~ ".,ili'- ,) , JI
~~:""~;:~?;~~'~/

[0°
!>
r:;
t-~
,"::
~
!
f;
f;
p.)
[2
f-:

••e
@
o SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 45 Judgment
o
o
o
~
~:3'
r}
(:)
P":;.
~.)
()
0
,',.-.-..-,:";
,/;.,j.:,i:.
~
A
~:-7
r).
V
._'.j( '"':':"
c:o;,
~.?
()
'".,"'>1
"-" ~C
C'
(:~':
(:)
"":_~"'~C
(
~.

,~)

o
o
(:)
@
A
~
f",
o
~
A
~
B
~
@
@
•
•
•
••
•
•
G
..

Exh.
No.
ParticularsSr .'
No.
2391PM report No.478 of Gulzar Mohammad I807
Noormohammad Pathan
240lpM report No.479 of Mohammad Yusuf 1808
2411PM report No.476 of Faisal Rafiqbhai 1809
2421Map of scene of offence 1812
2431Injury certificate of Naranbhai 1819
Chhanabhai ......;.:-:.:.:::..:- .
820244 1Injury ceftifi~a4:~::qf' I}.G:Erqa. ":'"':';'.'
82124510PD ca$epaw$+>,., ,., .
~ OPD.<cas e~ap§x::

822
823I njl;r;Yc~rtk:h£e.~t::~{·.'·pf:Pt$,p.J-ad Othpr a k ash247
248
~h~~f:~shit~~~£:~~,~:0::::;:;:Of.accused . No. 71824
249 1()P6da.sep~per: 1825
250lInjy:sy certificat:e:·o!'N.J.Bhati 1826
2511 ;~'MjiQoiltMj::~~1a~~~~;61~~~Y St::~~:1841
252 1StatE::!rn~n1:show.~n:9.,.::.q~t.g.:i.+p of bandobast on 184 6
28/'0 2/2..Q.o 2' ......:..::'".::: .:::..:; '.'.::·:··.x;: ":..':: '" '.
253IPhotOcppy./ gf:th.e, .. original attendancel847
~:~~~n~~a~=~~Z0:rt=':~("f:=Ebliceofficial of
2541Photocopy of th~br'igihaTattendance sheet ofl848
28/02/2002 of Police official of Meghaninagar
2551photocopy of original register of charge 1850
of Motisinh Abhesinh Bariya - dtd.
28/02/2002
2561photocopy of original register of
of Motisinh Abhesinh Bariya
28/02/2002
2571photocopy of original register of
of Motisinh Abhesinh Bariya
28/02/2002
2581Notification published by
Commis s ioner, dated 28/02/2002
~~

I:sp;:
E~
~I~::
I.:
,..
:.:.
::
~,~,
','
!
,.
~
l~
~

••
•••
c
•
e
SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 46 Judgment
~~~
@
~
v
e
o
@
@
~.'"t::;..'
@
'@
~
e

o
g,
~~}
£"
~:;:
o
C)
('.
,<j
()
(')
f"
I;i;,;,f
G
(.")Cl
v
()
~
e
c
v
~
@
G
e
B.'
v
•
•
•
•
e
Sr.
No.
259
Panchnama
Panchnama
Panchnama
Panchnama
260
261
262
263
Exh.
No.
Particulars
870Complaint regarding damage to vehicles
878of damage
879of damage
880of damage
881of damage
882
2651Panchnama of damage 1884
264 Panchnama of damage
.':':':::':' .
2 66Ipanchnamao{fi~m~'g:~ 1886
267 Panc hriamp ... dfd.~ma(j'§::
==---....-;.,......".,..;....,.....-,..;....,.----+--~
2 68 panChpamCl. of
1890
270 Ip~ncH~ama>6f¢l~r;rri!Mt:~ :.:i( 1891." '". .~.:.....:.:. .... .. .. .
271 PeEm.iss i oD.. .::.f 0 i.:::·'.i·::::·:···~~:pb s e cut i on a g a inst I8 98
accused NC). 56 to ''63' ...' ; ::.:.
272 permissiop>f:r-om{,th~i'Stat~Governmentforl900
prosee1.Jt i~Q a,ga ~:'P..§:~¥::·'.!.·~.Scu s~d};ro . 24t0 37
273 P~rrh:tssioriiftom the'State Government forl901
prbs~cbtion agp;i:.r.:rS;t( aqclsed No ..1 to 20
274 Permission tor pro~ecution against 903
accused NO. {l)" .." ..:,•.:......... .
904
accused No.38 and 39
276 IPermission for prosecution against 905
accused No.22 and 23
2771Permission for prosecution against 1907
accused No.42 to 55
2781Permission for prosecution against 1908
accused No.40
275 Pe rmi s s i on.ftir·.:: •••:p:tb~~cu t i on against
••-",'~_"lIt1':
~.,'-"-;:"~~"';' ," '.
~panchnama of scene of offence / •. 82,8 ',. ,
7! .::. " ~:.>" ~.~
:Q·39. I·~.280lPhotocopy of Fire Call No.113 ..,/ v
/'":(' ~."''''~' ,I' (,' :::, '..:.~, ".". s~~'""' ~ ~. (;......;'
f' ,... ,; . '", '. . - ,,) :~l - <Q- .i;.....
281lDetails on page No.147 of I"
[0
Occurri~'.~'cf~ ,-941 t 1~~, .y~:. J~
Register
I
~:, i~~:~ ';. ~'~~6!'
I
<
.', ) ;I'" ......'I'Ie.". '... '. ,~".. : I
'} p i "- , (1, I
'1'11' "~'" ., ~ _t! ,.' 1 ci~~; cI~tf Ij'
, i }.:~,:;'."~ .'. ,< 1.,' '/'~'i" 0 ./",,_. '/ ' ."',,/...... ,.... LI
~,' , . "." 'OJ I~
;:.....:...~/l" ;') ~J~' ~~
~;,:..'. '.~" ' ~ ~
~.:(o~~~~_,~ _~J
l=':
f~f~
f>I,:.
I::
':.
i"
[,
r
•.'S'~~.
:.':.::.'.,...~~~....
" ". -'''',
:.~;;:';'<:,::~:,
=.. ',

•••••••••••••
I
•e
e
@
~ SCsfl52/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 47
@
Sr. ParticularsA
W'
No.
e 2821Evening Entry dated 28/02/2002 in
e original vehicle Register
o 2831Medical certificate of Kheda Hospital
2841Panchnama of damage
•
•••
•
e
2851Panchnama of damage
2861Permission of State Government
prosecution against accused No.53.....'..:.:...:-:.... ,;,.,:"",:,:-;.
287IPanchnamapeg~;diJ1'g(phY$:ic:::al . condition
accusedNc;>.;l4.J~~hHlh·:~Gabbar and
•
let another Ninpa.A-fvindbh§,{
• 288 1:~~~~~:m~o.1~~~~I'~~':~~h9i condition
o 289
~
~
~
C",'t;:>i 290
G
~
~
i.:.'Gi
Room,
2991MeSSage
No.235,
..
Judgment: j.-
Exh.
I::'
No.
t;
l::thel942
i:
[~
l~~
I":
1945
1947
1948
forl953
':~:
;;.'
tofl955
one
.~~:
I~~
ofl956 f{
panGhpamat~gp;.rcripg·.r~covery of swordl957
;~~:~1:1c~~ieJarl!rZ"% Jayesh @ Gabbar
Panchnama ort5hYs:i:cal. condition ofl958
accused No.6,·. Kisb.Qt/Mangabhai Patni, and
~:~~~~~.~A~pal;c~::t:·.:::~l~;r~:;~s~h~::~~~:~
Patniand·k:Lranbhai Hirabhai Nadiya........:.....

e 291IPanch~arnao:f·"d~{~:I1tionof accused No.101959
@ Shakrabhai Sehdhabhai Patni··. . '.:.:.:.;..•.:.; ' .
e
•e
292 IPanchnama. ·.·bf/·/:-:::a¢¢V$ed. •....:::.. No .11 Mano j 1960
Premj ibhaiPartnak .•. hard..rigbeert detained
e
r~:
9662931Copy of order fo:rCUFre~ I:'
2941Message of Ahmedabad City Police Controll967
Room, page No.215, entry No.659
2951Message of Ahmedabad City Police Controll968
2961Report made to S.C.P. 970
2971Message of
Room, page
2981Message of
page
Ahmedabad City Police
No.227, entry No.479
Ahmedabad City Police
No.233, entry No.446
Cont ro,k: ~~'~'~;::):'.;~;~~
. jI~/~ ~ ~..~ ~.... ~ IJ l'-'~ ::~~
i /:?::>~:::','~>~~'-,,::.~~::;~
Cortt r,o,1:~74·;..e.< f .~(~.~.
t· '::.)" ':!;:;~~~i ~:.. ")- ,'" f ·l~
of Ahmedabad City Police Control Roont "pagEl"- 97~'. . l ;)11
entry N o . 4 4 0 - · " , · ~ 1::"';,1/
" /sl'h_,~:. 't~ ~}
!
" ' / > . , - ...
,. . .c.. , ' •• :-~-:, ~"J; r
·-·':"'T';,..~·~L~f:1;;;7
t

•••••••
I
[-;;.:
.;:
•
•• ~~r.~
~~;
G
@ SCs/152/02,167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 48 Judgment
k
@
Exh.
No.
ParticularsSr.
No.
300lMessage of Ahmedabad City Police Controll976
3011Complaint made by Aslam in Gujarati at 1982
Meghaninagar Police Station
3021Complaint made by Aslam in Hindi atl983
Meghaninagar Police Station
3031Panchnama of damage 1989
304.IPanchnama o:f dama:~.~ ...· 1990
305Ipanchnama9~~~rnaq;$ 1993
306 ComPtairtt, ()f'~~he'iYM.~:khan, 1060
307 ~~7~~i~;;~ e~~"g,~~Im@ges No.1 and 115 1063
308
d:~a;pn1J'~~c!k~~IiAton~!riasd~ate for
309
~~~~~~ti~~,~J :~1~!l( for .. oonducting
310 Pahchnama /)gf .ide.p·t:;i::f~sa.tibn ,.parade
311 Panch ,slip) of ~Gdakfu~lkrticle'No.1 of
sessif,qps Gase.No..~.+'97/2Q03....: ..:: .: .. ~: . ;.: .;.:•..•-: .:.;:-: ". _'i~:' .... ,'. . .
312 IPanchnama of ,sword having been traced out
by accused. N;o~.21.....sandip'@ "SOH'll
313ICertifiedp1164Mt¢·py:.···:P:£:::rit~ssagedated 27 &11076
28/2/2002 ofWi.r~le:§·~: Message Register
1082
..... - - ..
314 IPanchnama of dead body
3151Panchnama of recovery of burst cartridgesl1083
from the scene of offence
316 IPanchnama of recovery of knife froml1084
accused No.1
317 Panchnama of recovery of burst cartridges 1085
rill:' . ': ..",,:~
318 Panchnama of recovery of cylindrical,~~'~r~,;}(~~ij:~<~
con-:ainer (kerbo) from accused
Vakll ",1,- ... ' .,,, .. C
~ / l.- '.': .- ,"r' L
319 Affidavit of Sayeedkhan Ahmedkhan
, ~.. :
320 Letter of Hutch Company
r-:'
e !:.~
e i·,:
r"
c.;
..••
"
•e
e
e '.
e
~
~
::-
IfJ;,.
~
a~
@
~.
1:.:)
{'"
,',""
";J
o~
("<.;,
c~"
~.~;?
c-:·.:)
()
o
o
@
Q ~2
&
r~
~
~
o
e
G
e ~,~~..,.,:~
• Surend~~~~::;'>.:.;.:..·~:···~~:~'~~::.~)l.:$~
'. •- '~i
~...,:_'~ ~,; ...::"J -' 1 'l. ~.",.. "!:l
patharijJ:1'd94'i~ft:;?V~(~,~,}/..,~ ..
.:: :Oi, ! ~::, i~ i.
'j). Ht38 ;~"~",). )_.l.'J; l,
"., "<:' ~'" , ",-:.~;':".! ·I.··~f/l
,~ • .I~ ,./ ....~ .J/
-:(S~~j1~[;grl

••e
t} SCsi 152102, 167 & 279/03, 190,191,193,194,195,279/09 49 Judgment
~.
w
Sr. I Particulars
No.
321 Control Room Slip No.307
322 Control Room Slip No.1121
Exh.
No.
1145
1146
•
3231Panchnama of CD of voice of accused 1148
324 Certified photocopy of Slip No.732 of the/1150
message on page No.213 of Exh.507
325 Certified photocopy of Slip No.879 of thel115l
message on page N?~~~9 of Exh.507
326 Certified pho£oGPPy'<·o,:f.·. ···Slip No .1095 of 11152
the messa.gE?dppa·g~?!)$tq}45+of Exh. 507
372 Cert~fiedph9toe6By'bfSlip ..•..' No.. 1115 of 11153
7 the message 0rti#l:e9.;§:::W@f?57 of EXh. 507
~~~~~~e~qG~~~~~~~i~f~;$~x~: of the11154
328
5~;7
32 9 Pan2lihamabfiJovw.::;·~·~~t Vehicle Jeep 1159
330 Yaadi of ..<•. P ..! .i,~6?>:take statements of 1166
witness
custodyl1167
331 I~~k~~:~e~b~tnhaJtl~::~l~knr;;~:~i~~ victims
332 IAcknQVJledgment.,... ::.r~.y.gJp.t.,:r::egarding custOd) 1168
of dead bodyh'Eiv::trtg:'" beert givento victims
333IAcknowledgmE?ntrec.e,.ipt' regarding custod01169
of dead b()dY9~Jtt;psr'p:~ei:givento victims
Acknowledgment receipt're~kr(:Iih<j g~~tody of dead body having been 11170
given to victims .,.,.,.•.,< ,.
334
3351Acknowledgment receipt regarding custodyl117l
of dead body having been given to victims
3361Acknowledgment receipt regarding custody 11172
340 Acknowledgment receipt regarding custody of dead ~q,¢y' lI76 "..:'.
3371Acknowledgment receipt regarding custody 11173
3381Acknowledgment receipt regarding
of dead body having been given to victim,.'.:.,//'.
I r".> ".' :. . l" ..,' :",
3 3 91 Acknowledgment r~ceipt re~arding c~st?dY ?~Z.5
of dead body havlng been glven to Vlct+r:n,S"~
having been given to victims ." . "
..,'
~c'
o t~·:··
e r:i":
A
~ f::
fC
:
~
li.::Ji
©
C?
Q,:)1
(':~
t:.:,:.:?
@ :5
.;.~
r,};
~~@
(c,
@
C)
Ci
C~
(.
(:
1"
".
Ci c·:
k:!::o ,~.:
0"':,
:;;:.-i
o
o
()
@
t!'>,
o
~
&J,
,*"
o
n
U
G
•
••
•••
•
o
•
custody:~f7~~·~i:.~J;~~~
__.r.~·'-·,~,,~~'~
l~J' .~'". .... (-~, ".~~
:;..:::;:,....,:.~.';...()"~..
'~C:.
J.JJii
'(it f """'1'.1;'" ': {. ;.~. r, /1
", .,.~. '-"}",. ,..,-,'",: r ~ ;.1
...;,,<,. ::.I.q., ,.....( ....>//L"-:" ,>,.." " p.:V"'..-'..'.' .-~,'" ~ "~'
.... .; i,': 1"')' :) ~i.
...,,~;;=::';~L;~~
.

Gulberg Society Trial Full Judgement (17.06.2016)

Gulberg Society Trial Full Judgement (17.06.2016)

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

What's hot

What's hot (12)

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (20)

Similar to Gulberg Society Trial Full Judgement (17.06.2016)

Similar to Gulberg Society Trial Full Judgement (17.06.2016) (20)

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

Gulberg Society Trial Full Judgement (17.06.2016)