SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 24
Google manipulates search results: A boost for small 
business?
As more and more businesses strive for a top ten Google 
ranking, it's becoming harder and harder to achieve. This 
is especially true for smaller businesses that simply 
don't have the budget for a big link popularity campaign. 
But hope may be just around the corner. If a top ten 
ranking for your primary keywords has been eluding 
you, then read on!
Google manipulates the results
Google is trialing an 'enhancement' to the way it 
displays its results. Instead of showing the top ten 
results for the exact words you enter, in the trial Google 
suggests three related results that you might want to 
check out. Where does it display these suggestions? It 
shunts (or replaces) results 6, 7 and 8 !!!
In this article, I refer to these results as 'intruders'.
To see some 'intruder' results in action, search for "piggy 
bank". Results 6, 7 and 8 are actually 'intruder' results; 
they're the top three results for the more specific, less 
popular search, "piggy bank lyrics". Google assumes that 
people searching for "piggy bank" will probably be 
interested in results of a search for "piggy bank lyrics".
On first impressions, it's tempting to think that this 
makes it harder to get into the top ten (because now it's 
really the top seven, and the last two results may be 
easily overlooked). But it may actually make it easier - 
especially for smaller businesses. Let me explain why...
The advantage for smaller businesses
It all comes down to who can rank in the top ten for the 
most popular searches - like "computers", "cars", 
"doctor", "pets", etc. For anyone in these industries, a 
top ten ranking for these keywords is the holy grail. 
Unfortunately, these sorts of searches are presently 
dominated by big corporations with hefty search 
budgets. Most smaller businesses don't even try to 
compete. Instead of focusing on these hotly contested 
keywords, small businesses tend to focus on much more 
specific keyword phrases - like "computers boston", 
"second hand cars ohio", "female doctor new england", 
"discount pets for children", etc.
But Google's trial may change that. Remember, it's 
replacing results 6, 7 and 8 of a popular, broad search 
with results 1, 2 and 3 of a less popular, more specific 
search. If the trial becomes a standard feature, a search 
for "computers" might well include three 'intruder' 
results from a search such as "computers boston". As 
discussed above, results 6, 7 and 8 are likely to belong to 
big companies, whereas results 1, 2 and 3 of the more 
specific search are more likely to belong to smaller 
businesses. Therefore, when the switch occurs, it's out 
with the big and in with the small!
In principle the enhancement appears to work in favor 
of small businesses:
1. Big business dominates popular / general search 
results2. Smaller businesses have a greater chance of 
dominating less popular / more specific search results3. 
General search results are replaced by specific search 
results4. Big businesses are shunted out of the top ten 
by smaller businesses
Now I hear what you're saying: "Why wouldn't the big 
companies simply start optimizing for the more specific 
searches?" Granted, this is a possibility; but for most big 
companies, it would be a monumental task. Big 
companies tend to service a large geographic region, and 
they typically offer numerous products and services. 
Even a hefty search budget would be stretched to the 
limit if it was required to bankroll optimization for every 
single product, every single service, and every single 
location. And this is what would be required to 
dominate all of the more specific results, thereby gaining 
back their number 6, 7 or 8 position. It's far more likely 
that they'll simply try harder for a
position in the top 5 of the popular/general search. This 
approach would be less complex and probably more 
rewarding.
The fine print
Of course, where Google is involved, nothing is ever that 
simple. I've oversimplified things above to make the trial 
a little easier to understand. In reality, the situation is a 
bit more complex because of the way Google chooses 
which search the three 'intruder' results come from. 
Take the "piggy bank" search for example. Google 
assumes that most users who search for "piggy bank" 
will also be interested in results from a search for "piggy 
bank lyrics". This assumption is based on the fact that 
thousands of other people are searching specifically for 
"piggy bank lyrics" - in fact, it's one of the most popular 
searches containing the original term "piggy bank". And 
that's why it gets the nod.
In other words, the intruder results come from popular 
searches (less popular than the original, but still 
popular). This means you'd already have to rank highly 
in a very popular search before you'd become an 
intruder. So, in reality, the above "computer" example is 
a little simplistic; the intruder results for "computer" are 
more likely to be from a search for something like 
"computers ibm". In reality, the top three results for 
"computer peripherals boston" are more likely to appear 
as intruders in a "computer peripherals" search.
Conclusion
The important thing to remember is that if this trial 
becomes a standard feature, it will be implemented on 
all searches. And the more specific the original search, 
the easier it would be to become an intruder in that 
search. In theory, it has great potential to help smaller 
businesses reach the next rung of the search engine 
ladder.
Other Examples
Here are some further examples if you're interested:
* Search for "add url"* Search for "on demand"
Happy shunting!
http://howtostartaninternetbusinesssite.info/form.php? 
id=646303

More Related Content

Similar to Google manipulates search results: A boost for small business?

Can Google Really Deliver Country Specific Searching?
Can Google Really Deliver Country Specific Searching?Can Google Really Deliver Country Specific Searching?
Can Google Really Deliver Country Specific Searching?denisebusiness1
 
How to Become an Internet Research Specialist
How to Become an Internet Research SpecialistHow to Become an Internet Research Specialist
How to Become an Internet Research SpecialistChinedum Azuh
 
local-seo-guide_jessica-stradley
local-seo-guide_jessica-stradleylocal-seo-guide_jessica-stradley
local-seo-guide_jessica-stradleyJessica Stradley
 
Searching on google report
Searching on google reportSearching on google report
Searching on google reportssabrina94
 
Big book-of-digital-marketing
Big book-of-digital-marketingBig book-of-digital-marketing
Big book-of-digital-marketingTika Ayati
 
Using SEO to Build Your Business
Using SEO to Build Your BusinessUsing SEO to Build Your Business
Using SEO to Build Your BusinessSpryIdeas
 
Using SEO to Build Your Business
Using SEO to Build Your BusinessUsing SEO to Build Your Business
Using SEO to Build Your BusinessKatie Spence
 
How Google is forcing brands to reassess their entire business model
How Google is forcing brands to reassess their entire business modelHow Google is forcing brands to reassess their entire business model
How Google is forcing brands to reassess their entire business modelStickyeyes
 
Big book-of-digital-marketing
Big book-of-digital-marketingBig book-of-digital-marketing
Big book-of-digital-marketingQualityWebs
 
Cross Forum 2016: SEO Will Become "Search Experience Optimization"
Cross Forum 2016: SEO Will Become "Search Experience Optimization"Cross Forum 2016: SEO Will Become "Search Experience Optimization"
Cross Forum 2016: SEO Will Become "Search Experience Optimization"Keith Goode
 
Google Search Made Easy @ tnmg4u.com
Google Search Made Easy @ tnmg4u.comGoogle Search Made Easy @ tnmg4u.com
Google Search Made Easy @ tnmg4u.comDr. Angshuman Ghosh
 
Thegooglebestpracticesguide 121231052000-phpapp02
Thegooglebestpracticesguide 121231052000-phpapp02Thegooglebestpracticesguide 121231052000-phpapp02
Thegooglebestpracticesguide 121231052000-phpapp02Stephen Darori
 
How Do I Get A Job With...
How Do I Get A Job With...How Do I Get A Job With...
How Do I Get A Job With...Chuck Boyer
 
How Do I Get A Job With...
How Do I Get A Job With...How Do I Get A Job With...
How Do I Get A Job With...Chuck Boyer
 
Introduction to site search analytics by SearchBroker
Introduction to site search analytics by SearchBrokerIntroduction to site search analytics by SearchBroker
Introduction to site search analytics by SearchBrokerEmpathyBroker
 
ReThinking Search Strategy from netPRpro, Inc.
ReThinking Search Strategy from netPRpro, Inc.ReThinking Search Strategy from netPRpro, Inc.
ReThinking Search Strategy from netPRpro, Inc.net5000
 
Explosive Traffic Secrets
Explosive Traffic SecretsExplosive Traffic Secrets
Explosive Traffic Secretsgnc422
 
Google's ai future and what it means for seos
Google's ai future and what it means for seosGoogle's ai future and what it means for seos
Google's ai future and what it means for seosSuhanSunkad
 
Take the Cold Out of Cold Calling
Take the Cold Out of Cold CallingTake the Cold Out of Cold Calling
Take the Cold Out of Cold CallingStephen DuPlessis
 

Similar to Google manipulates search results: A boost for small business? (20)

Can Google Really Deliver Country Specific Searching?
Can Google Really Deliver Country Specific Searching?Can Google Really Deliver Country Specific Searching?
Can Google Really Deliver Country Specific Searching?
 
How to Become an Internet Research Specialist
How to Become an Internet Research SpecialistHow to Become an Internet Research Specialist
How to Become an Internet Research Specialist
 
Makinginternetwork
MakinginternetworkMakinginternetwork
Makinginternetwork
 
local-seo-guide_jessica-stradley
local-seo-guide_jessica-stradleylocal-seo-guide_jessica-stradley
local-seo-guide_jessica-stradley
 
Searching on google report
Searching on google reportSearching on google report
Searching on google report
 
Big book-of-digital-marketing
Big book-of-digital-marketingBig book-of-digital-marketing
Big book-of-digital-marketing
 
Using SEO to Build Your Business
Using SEO to Build Your BusinessUsing SEO to Build Your Business
Using SEO to Build Your Business
 
Using SEO to Build Your Business
Using SEO to Build Your BusinessUsing SEO to Build Your Business
Using SEO to Build Your Business
 
How Google is forcing brands to reassess their entire business model
How Google is forcing brands to reassess their entire business modelHow Google is forcing brands to reassess their entire business model
How Google is forcing brands to reassess their entire business model
 
Big book-of-digital-marketing
Big book-of-digital-marketingBig book-of-digital-marketing
Big book-of-digital-marketing
 
Cross Forum 2016: SEO Will Become "Search Experience Optimization"
Cross Forum 2016: SEO Will Become "Search Experience Optimization"Cross Forum 2016: SEO Will Become "Search Experience Optimization"
Cross Forum 2016: SEO Will Become "Search Experience Optimization"
 
Google Search Made Easy @ tnmg4u.com
Google Search Made Easy @ tnmg4u.comGoogle Search Made Easy @ tnmg4u.com
Google Search Made Easy @ tnmg4u.com
 
Thegooglebestpracticesguide 121231052000-phpapp02
Thegooglebestpracticesguide 121231052000-phpapp02Thegooglebestpracticesguide 121231052000-phpapp02
Thegooglebestpracticesguide 121231052000-phpapp02
 
How Do I Get A Job With...
How Do I Get A Job With...How Do I Get A Job With...
How Do I Get A Job With...
 
How Do I Get A Job With...
How Do I Get A Job With...How Do I Get A Job With...
How Do I Get A Job With...
 
Introduction to site search analytics by SearchBroker
Introduction to site search analytics by SearchBrokerIntroduction to site search analytics by SearchBroker
Introduction to site search analytics by SearchBroker
 
ReThinking Search Strategy from netPRpro, Inc.
ReThinking Search Strategy from netPRpro, Inc.ReThinking Search Strategy from netPRpro, Inc.
ReThinking Search Strategy from netPRpro, Inc.
 
Explosive Traffic Secrets
Explosive Traffic SecretsExplosive Traffic Secrets
Explosive Traffic Secrets
 
Google's ai future and what it means for seos
Google's ai future and what it means for seosGoogle's ai future and what it means for seos
Google's ai future and what it means for seos
 
Take the Cold Out of Cold Calling
Take the Cold Out of Cold CallingTake the Cold Out of Cold Calling
Take the Cold Out of Cold Calling
 

Google manipulates search results: A boost for small business?

  • 1. Google manipulates search results: A boost for small business?
  • 2. As more and more businesses strive for a top ten Google ranking, it's becoming harder and harder to achieve. This is especially true for smaller businesses that simply don't have the budget for a big link popularity campaign. But hope may be just around the corner. If a top ten ranking for your primary keywords has been eluding you, then read on!
  • 4. Google is trialing an 'enhancement' to the way it displays its results. Instead of showing the top ten results for the exact words you enter, in the trial Google suggests three related results that you might want to check out. Where does it display these suggestions? It shunts (or replaces) results 6, 7 and 8 !!!
  • 5. In this article, I refer to these results as 'intruders'.
  • 6. To see some 'intruder' results in action, search for "piggy bank". Results 6, 7 and 8 are actually 'intruder' results; they're the top three results for the more specific, less popular search, "piggy bank lyrics". Google assumes that people searching for "piggy bank" will probably be interested in results of a search for "piggy bank lyrics".
  • 7. On first impressions, it's tempting to think that this makes it harder to get into the top ten (because now it's really the top seven, and the last two results may be easily overlooked). But it may actually make it easier - especially for smaller businesses. Let me explain why...
  • 8. The advantage for smaller businesses
  • 9. It all comes down to who can rank in the top ten for the most popular searches - like "computers", "cars", "doctor", "pets", etc. For anyone in these industries, a top ten ranking for these keywords is the holy grail. Unfortunately, these sorts of searches are presently dominated by big corporations with hefty search budgets. Most smaller businesses don't even try to compete. Instead of focusing on these hotly contested keywords, small businesses tend to focus on much more specific keyword phrases - like "computers boston", "second hand cars ohio", "female doctor new england", "discount pets for children", etc.
  • 10. But Google's trial may change that. Remember, it's replacing results 6, 7 and 8 of a popular, broad search with results 1, 2 and 3 of a less popular, more specific search. If the trial becomes a standard feature, a search for "computers" might well include three 'intruder' results from a search such as "computers boston". As discussed above, results 6, 7 and 8 are likely to belong to big companies, whereas results 1, 2 and 3 of the more specific search are more likely to belong to smaller businesses. Therefore, when the switch occurs, it's out with the big and in with the small!
  • 11. In principle the enhancement appears to work in favor of small businesses:
  • 12. 1. Big business dominates popular / general search results2. Smaller businesses have a greater chance of dominating less popular / more specific search results3. General search results are replaced by specific search results4. Big businesses are shunted out of the top ten by smaller businesses
  • 13. Now I hear what you're saying: "Why wouldn't the big companies simply start optimizing for the more specific searches?" Granted, this is a possibility; but for most big companies, it would be a monumental task. Big companies tend to service a large geographic region, and they typically offer numerous products and services. Even a hefty search budget would be stretched to the limit if it was required to bankroll optimization for every single product, every single service, and every single location. And this is what would be required to dominate all of the more specific results, thereby gaining back their number 6, 7 or 8 position. It's far more likely that they'll simply try harder for a
  • 14. position in the top 5 of the popular/general search. This approach would be less complex and probably more rewarding.
  • 16. Of course, where Google is involved, nothing is ever that simple. I've oversimplified things above to make the trial a little easier to understand. In reality, the situation is a bit more complex because of the way Google chooses which search the three 'intruder' results come from. Take the "piggy bank" search for example. Google assumes that most users who search for "piggy bank" will also be interested in results from a search for "piggy bank lyrics". This assumption is based on the fact that thousands of other people are searching specifically for "piggy bank lyrics" - in fact, it's one of the most popular searches containing the original term "piggy bank". And that's why it gets the nod.
  • 17. In other words, the intruder results come from popular searches (less popular than the original, but still popular). This means you'd already have to rank highly in a very popular search before you'd become an intruder. So, in reality, the above "computer" example is a little simplistic; the intruder results for "computer" are more likely to be from a search for something like "computers ibm". In reality, the top three results for "computer peripherals boston" are more likely to appear as intruders in a "computer peripherals" search.
  • 19. The important thing to remember is that if this trial becomes a standard feature, it will be implemented on all searches. And the more specific the original search, the easier it would be to become an intruder in that search. In theory, it has great potential to help smaller businesses reach the next rung of the search engine ladder.
  • 21. Here are some further examples if you're interested:
  • 22. * Search for "add url"* Search for "on demand"